Chapter 4

The Coming World

21 min

We come first to the messages which tell us of the life beyond the grave, sent by those who are actually living it. I have already insisted upon the fact that they have three weighty claims to our belief. The one is, that they are accompanied by "signs," in the Biblical sense, in the shape of "miracles" or phenomena. The second is, that in many cases they are accompanied by assertions about this life of ours which prove to be correct, and which are beyond the possible knowledge of the medium after every deduction has been made for telepathy or for unconscious memory. The third is, that they have a remarkable, though not a complete, similarity from whatever source they come.

We turn first to messages about life beyond the grave, sent by those who are actually living it. I have already stressed that there are three strong reasons to believe these messages. First, they come with "signs" in the Biblical sense, in the form of "miracles" or phenomena. Second, many contain statements about our life that prove correct. The medium could not possibly know these things, even after allowing for telepathy or unconscious memory. Third, the messages are remarkably, though not completely, similar, whatever their source.

It may be noted that the differences of opinion become most marked when they deal with their own future, which may well be a matter of speculation to them as to us. Thus, upon the question of reincarnation there is a distinct cleavage, and though I am myself of opinion that the general evidence is against this oriental doctrine, it is none the less an undeniable fact that it has been maintained by some messages which appear in other ways to be authentic, and, therefore, it is necessary to keep one's mind open on the subject.

The differences of opinion are most pronounced when they discuss their own future. Their future may be as much a matter of speculation for them as it is for us. For example, there is a clear division over reincarnation. I believe the evidence overall is against this Eastern doctrine. Nevertheless, some messages that appear authentic in other ways have undeniably supported it. We must therefore keep an open mind on the subject.

Before entering upon the substance of the messages I should wish to emphasize the second of these two points, so as to reinforce the reader's confidence in the authenticity of these assertions. To this end I will give a detailed example, with names almost exact. The medium was Mr. Phoenix, of Glasgow, with whom I have myself had some remarkable experiences. The sitter was Mr. Ernest Oaten, the President of the Northern Spiritual Union, a man of the utmost veracity and precision of statement. The dialogue, which came by the direct voice, a trumpet acting as megaphone, ran like this:—

Before discussing the messages themselves, I want to emphasize the second of these two points. This should strengthen the reader's confidence in the authenticity of these claims. To do this, I will give a detailed example, using names that are almost exact. The medium was Mr. Phoenix, of Glasgow, with whom I have had some remarkable experiences myself. The sitter was Mr. Ernest Oaten, the President of the Northern Spiritual Union. He was a man of the utmost honesty and precision in what he said. The dialogue came through a direct voice, with a trumpet acting as a megaphone. It went like this:

The Voice: Good evening, Mr. Oaten.

The Voice: Good evening, Mr. Oaten.

Mr. O.: Good evening. Who are you?

Mr. O.: Good evening. Who are you?

The Voice: My name is Mill. You know my father.

The Voice: My name is Mill. You know my father.

Mr. O.: No, I don't remember anyone of the name.

Mr. O.: No, I don't remember anyone by that name.

The Voice: Yes, you were speaking to him the other day.

The Voice: Yes, you were talking to him the other day.

Mr. O.: To be sure. I remember now. I only met him casually.

Mr. O.: Of course. I remember now. I only met him casually.

The Voice: I want you to give him a message from me.

The Voice: I want you to give him a message from me.

Mr. O.: What is it?

Mr. O.: What is it?

The Voice: Tell him that he was not mistaken at midnight on Tuesday last.

The Voice: Tell him he was not mistaken last Tuesday at midnight.

Mr. O.: Very good. I will say so. Have you passed long?

Mr. O.: All right. I'll say so. Have you been dead long?

The Voice: Some time. But our time is different from yours.

The Voice: Some time. But our time is different from yours.

Mr. O.: What were you?

Mr. O.: What were you?

The Voice: A Surgeon.

The Voice: A Surgeon.

Mr. O.: How did you pass?

Mr. O.: How did you die?

The Voice: Blown up in a battleship during the war.

The Voice: Blown up on a battleship during the war.

Mr. O.: Anything more?

Mr. O.: Anything more?

The answer was the Gipsy song from "Il Trovatore," very accurately whistled, and then a quick-step. After the latter, the voice said: "That is a test for father."

The answer was the Romani song from "Il Trovatore," whistled very accurately, followed by a quickstep. After the quickstep, the voice said: "That is a test for father."

This reproduction of conversation is not quite verbatim, but gives the condensed essence. Mr. Oaten at once visited Mr. Mill, who was not a Spiritualist, and found that every detail was correct. Young Mill had lost his life as narrated. Mr. Mill, senior, explained that while sitting in his study at midnight on the date named he had heard the Gipsy song from "Il Trovatore," which had been a favourite of his boy's, and being unable to trace the origin of the music, had finally thought that it was a freak of his imagination. The test connected with the quick-step had reference to a tune which the young man used to play upon the piccolo, but which was so rapid that he never could get it right, for which he was chaffed by the family.

This account of the conversation is not quite word for word, but it gives the main points in condensed form. Mr. Oaten immediately visited Mr. Mill, who was not a Spiritualist, and found that every detail was correct. Young Mill had died as described. Mr. Mill, senior, explained that he had been sitting in his study at midnight on the date named. He had heard the Gypsy song from "Il Trovatore," which had been a favorite of his son’s. Unable to find where the music came from, he finally decided that he had imagined it. The test involving the quick-step referred to a tune the young man used to play on the piccolo. It was so fast that he could never get it right, and his family teased him about it.

I tell this story at length to make the reader realise that when young Mill, and others like him, give such proofs of accuracy, which we can test for ourselves, we are bound to take their assertions very seriously when they deal with the life they are actually leading, though in their very nature we can only check their accounts by comparison with others.

I tell this story in detail to make a point. Young Mill and others like him give proofs of accuracy that we can test for ourselves. So we must take their claims about the lives they are actually leading very seriously. By their nature, though, we can only check their accounts against those of others.

Now let me epitomise what these assertions are. They say that they are exceedingly happy, and that they do not wish to return. They are among the friends whom they had loved and lost, who meet them when they die and continue their careers together. They are very busy on all forms of congenial work. The world in which they find themselves is very much like that which they have quitted, but everything keyed to a higher octave. As in a higher octave the rhythm is the same, and the relation of notes to each other the same, but the total effect different, so it is here. Every earthly thing has its equivalent. Scoffers have guffawed over alcohol and tobacco, but if all things are reproduced it would be a flaw if these were not reproduced also. That they should be abused, as they are here, would, indeed, be evil tidings, but nothing of the sort has been said, and in the much discussed passage in "Raymond," their production was alluded to as though it were an unusual, and in a way a humorous, instance of the resources of the beyond. I wonder how many of the preachers, who have taken advantage of this passage in order to attack the whole new revelation, have remembered that the only other message which ever associated alcohol with the life beyond is that of Christ Himself, when He said: "I will not drink henceforth of this fruit of the vine until that day when I drink it new with you in my Father's kingdom."

Now let me summarize these claims. They say they are extremely happy and do not wish to return. They are among the friends they loved and lost. These friends meet them when they die and continue their lives with them. They are very busy with all kinds of work they enjoy. The world they find themselves in is much like the one they left, but everything is pitched an octave higher. In a higher octave, the rhythm and the relationships between notes are the same, but the overall effect is different. So it is here. Everything on earth has its equivalent there. Scoffers have laughed at the idea of alcohol and tobacco in the next world. But if everything is reproduced, it would be a flaw if these were not reproduced too. If they were abused, as they are here, that would indeed be bad news. But nothing of the sort has been said. A much discussed passage in "Raymond" mentions their production. It treats this as an unusual and, in a way, amusing example of the resources of the world beyond. Many preachers have used this passage to attack the whole new revelation. I wonder how many have remembered the only other message that ever linked alcohol with life beyond death. It came from Christ himself, when he said: "I will not drink henceforth of this fruit of the vine until that day when I drink it new with you in my Father's kingdom."

This matter is a detail, however, and it is always dangerous to discuss details in a subject which is so enormous, so dimly seen. As the wisest woman I have known remarked to me: "Things may well be surprising over there, for if we had been told the facts of this life before we entered it, we should never have believed it." In its larger issues this happy life to come consists in the development of those gifts which we possess. There is action for the man of action, intellectual work for the thinker, artistic, literary, dramatic and religious for those whose God-given powers lie that way. What we have both in brain and character we carry over with us. No man is too old to learn, for what he learns he keeps. There is no physical side to love and no child-birth, though there is close union between those married people who really love each other, and, generally, there is deep sympathetic friendship and comradeship between the sexes. Every man or woman finds a soul mate sooner or later. The child grows up to the normal, so that the mother who lost a babe of two years old, and dies herself twenty years later finds a grown-up daughter of twenty-two awaiting her coming. Age, which is produced chiefly by the mechanical presence of lime in our arteries, disappears, and the individual reverts to the full normal growth and appearance of completed man—or womanhood. Let no woman mourn her lost beauty, and no man his lost strength or weakening brain. It all awaits them once more upon the other side. Nor is any deformity or bodily weakness there, for all is normal and at its best.

This matter is a detail, however, and it is always dangerous to discuss details in a subject so vast and so dimly understood. As the wisest woman I have known said to me: "Things may well be surprising over there. If we had been told the facts of this life before we entered it, we would never have believed them." In its broadest sense, the happy life to come consists of developing the gifts we possess. There is action for the man of action and intellectual work for the thinker. There is artistic, literary, dramatic and religious work for those whose God-given powers lie in those directions. We carry our intellect and character with us. No one is too old to learn, because whatever we learn, we keep. There is no physical side to love and no childbirth. Still, married people who truly love each other have a close union. In general, there is deep, sympathetic friendship and companionship between the sexes. Every man or woman finds a soul mate sooner or later. A child grows to normal adulthood. So a mother who lost a two-year-old baby and dies twenty years later finds a grown daughter of twenty-two waiting for her. Age is caused chiefly by the physical presence of calcium in our arteries. It disappears, and each person returns to the full growth and appearance of a mature man or woman. Let no woman mourn her lost beauty, and no man his lost strength or weakening mind. It all awaits them once more on the other side. There is no deformity or bodily weakness there either, for all is normal and at its best.

Before leaving this section of the subject, I should say a few more words upon the evidence as it affects the etheric body. This body is a perfect thing. This is a matter of consequence in these days when so many of our heroes have been mutilated in the wars. One cannot mutilate the etheric body, and it remains always intact. The first words uttered by a returning spirit in the recent experience of Dr. Abraham Wallace were "I have got my left arm again." The same applies to all birth marks, deformities, blindness, and other imperfections. None of them are permanent, and all will vanish in that happier life that awaits us. Such is the teaching from the beyond—that a perfect body waits for each.

Before leaving this part of the subject, I should say a little more about the evidence concerning the etheric body. This body is perfect. That matters today, when so many of our heroes have been mutilated in the wars. The etheric body cannot be mutilated and always remains intact. In a recent experience of Dr. Abraham Wallace, a returning spirit’s first words were "I have got my left arm again." The same applies to all birthmarks, deformities, blindness, and other imperfections. None of them are permanent. All will vanish in the happier life that awaits us. This is the teaching from beyond: a perfect body awaits each of us.

"But," says the critic, "what then of the clairvoyant descriptions, or the visions where the aged father is seen, clad in the old-fashioned garments of another age, or the grandmother with crinoline and chignon? Are these the habiliments of heaven?" Such visions are not spirits, but they are pictures which are built up before us or shot by spirits into our brains or those of the seer for the purposes of recognition. Hence the grey hair and hence the ancient garb. When a real spirit is indeed seen it comes in another form to this, where the flowing robe, such as has always been traditionally ascribed to the angels, is a vital thing which, by its very colour and texture, proclaims the spiritual condition of the wearer, and is probably a condensation of that aura which surrounds us upon earth.

"But," says the critic, "what about clairvoyant descriptions or visions of an elderly father dressed in old-fashioned clothes? Or a grandmother wearing a crinoline and a chignon? Are these the clothes of heaven?" Such visions are not spirits. They are pictures created before us or projected by spirits into our brains or the seer’s brain. Their purpose is to help us recognize the person. That is why we see the gray hair and old-fashioned clothes. When a real spirit is seen, it appears in a different form. It wears a flowing robe, like those traditionally attributed to angels. The robe is a vital thing. Its very color and texture reveal the wearer’s spiritual condition. It is probably a condensed form of the aura that surrounds us on earth.

It is a world of sympathy. Only those who have this tie foregather. The sullen husband, the flighty wife, is no longer there to plague the innocent spouse. All is sweet and peaceful. It is the long rest cure after the nerve strain of life, and before new experiences in the future. The circumstances are homely and familiar. Happy circles live in pleasant homesteads with every amenity of beauty and of music. Beautiful gardens, lovely flowers, green woods, pleasant lakes, domestic pets—all of these things are fully described in the messages of the pioneer travellers who have at last got news back to those who loiter in the old dingy home. There are no poor and no rich. The craftsman may still pursue his craft, but he does it for the joy of his work. Each serves the community as best he can, while from above come higher ministers of grace, the "Angels" of holy writ, to direct and help. Above all, shedding down His atmosphere upon all, broods that great Christ spirit, the very soul of reason, of justice, and of sympathetic understanding, who has the earth sphere, with all its circles, under His very special care. It is a place of joy and laughter. There are games and sports of all sorts, though none which cause pain to lower life. Food and drink in the grosser sense do not exist, but there seem to be pleasures of taste, and this distinction causes some confusion in the messages upon the point.

It is a world of sympathy. Only those who share this bond gather together. The gloomy husband or flighty wife is no longer there to torment the innocent spouse. Everything is sweet and peaceful. It is a long rest cure after the nervous strain of life and before new experiences in the future. The surroundings are homelike and familiar. Happy groups live in pleasant homes with every comfort that beauty and music can offer. There are beautiful gardens, lovely flowers, green woods, pleasant lakes, and domestic pets. All these things are fully described in messages from the pioneer travelers. At last, they have sent news back to those who linger in the old, gloomy home. There are no poor people and no rich people. A craftsman may still practice his craft, but he does it for the joy of the work. Each person serves the community as best he can. Meanwhile, higher messengers of grace come from above to guide and help. These are the "Angels" of holy scripture. Above all, the great Christ spirit watches over everyone, spreading his presence among them. He is the very soul of reason, justice, and sympathetic understanding. He has the earth sphere, with all its circles, under his special care. It is a place of joy and laughter. There are games and sports of all sorts, though none that cause pain to lower forms of life. Food and drink in the physical sense do not exist, but there seem to be pleasures of taste. This distinction causes some confusion in the messages on the subject.

But above all, brain, energy, character, driving power, if exerted for good, makes a man a leader there as here, while unselfishness, patience and spirituality there, as here, qualify the soul for the higher places, which have often been won by those very tribulations down here which seem so purposeless and so cruel, and are in truth our chances of spiritual quickening and promotion, without which life would have been barren and without profit.

But above all, intelligence, energy, character, and drive, when used for good, make a man a leader there, just as they do here. Unselfishness, patience, and spirituality also qualify the soul for higher places there, just as they do here. Those places have often been won through the very hardships here on earth that seem so pointless and cruel. In truth, those hardships give us chances to grow and advance spiritually. Without them, life would have been empty and without benefit.

The revelation abolishes the idea of a grotesque hell and of a fantastic heaven, while it substitutes the conception of a gradual rise in the scale of existence without any monstrous change which would turn us in an instant from man to angel or devil. The system, though different from previous ideas, does not, as it seems to me, run counter in any radical fashion to the old beliefs. In ancient maps it was usual for the cartographer to mark blank spaces for the unexplored regions, with some such legend as "here are anthropophagi," or "here are mandrakes," scrawled across them. So in our theology there have been ill-defined areas which have admittedly been left unfilled, for what sane man has ever believed in such a heaven as is depicted in our hymn books, a land of musical idleness and barren monotonous adoration! Thus in furnishing a clearer conception this new system has nothing to supplant. It paints upon a blank sheet.

The revelation does away with the idea of a grotesque hell and a fantastic heaven. Instead, it offers the idea of a gradual rise through levels of existence. There is no monstrous change that turns us instantly from human beings into angels or devils. Though this system differs from earlier ideas, it does not, it seems to me, radically contradict the old beliefs. On ancient maps, mapmakers usually left unexplored regions blank. They scrawled notes across them such as "here are cannibals" or "here are mandrakes." Our theology, too, has had vague areas that everyone admits have been left empty. After all, what sane person has ever believed in the heaven depicted in our hymn books? It is a land of musical idleness and empty, monotonous worship! So, by offering a clearer idea, this new system replaces nothing. It paints on a blank sheet.

One may well ask, however, granting that there is evidence for such a life and such a world as has been described, what about those who have not merited such a destination? What do the messages from beyond say about these? And here one cannot be too definite, for there is no use exchanging one dogma for another. One can but give the general purport of such information as has been vouchsafed to us. It is natural that those with whom we come in contact are those whom we may truly call the blessed, for if the thing be approached in a reverent and religious spirit it is those whom we should naturally attract. That there are many less fortunate than themselves is evident from their own constant allusions to that regenerating and elevating missionary work which is among their own functions. They descend apparently and help others to gain that degree of spirituality which fits them for this upper sphere, as a higher student might descend to a lower class in order to bring forward a backward pupil. Such a conception gives point to Christ's remark that there was more joy in heaven over saving one sinner than over ninety-nine just, for if He had spoken of an earthly sinner he would surely have had to become just in this life and so ceased to be a sinner before he had reached Paradise. It would apply very exactly, however, to a sinner rescued from a lower sphere and brought to a higher one.

But one might ask: even if there is evidence for the life and world described, what about those who have not earned such a destination? What do the messages from beyond say about them? We cannot be too definite here, for there is no point in exchanging one dogma for another. We can only give the general meaning of the information that has been given to us. Naturally, those we come into contact with are people we can truly call the blessed. If we approach the matter in a reverent and religious spirit, we should naturally attract such people. Their own frequent references to their missionary work make it clear that many others are less fortunate. This work of renewal and spiritual growth is among their duties. Apparently, they descend and help others gain the spirituality needed for this upper sphere. They do this as an advanced student might go down to a lower class to help a struggling pupil. This idea gives meaning to Christ's remark that there was more joy in heaven over saving one sinner than over ninety-nine just people. If he had spoken of an earthly sinner, that person would surely have had to become just in this life. The person would therefore have stopped being a sinner before reaching Paradise. Christ's remark would apply very well, however, to a sinner rescued from a lower sphere and brought to a higher one.

When we view sin in the light of modern science, with the tenderness of the modern conscience and with a sense of justice and proportion, it ceases to be that monstrous cloud which darkened the whole vision of the mediaeval theologian. Man has been more harsh with himself than an all-merciful God will ever be. It is true that with all deductions there remains a great residuum which means want of individual effort, conscious weakness of will, and culpable failure of character when the sinner, like Horace, sees and applauds the higher while he follows the lower. But when, on the other hand, one has made allowances—and can our human allowance be as generous as God's?—for the sins which are the inevitable product of early environment, for the sins which are due to hereditary and inborn taint, and to the sins which are due to clear physical causes, then the total of active sin is greatly reduced. Could one, for example, imagine that Providence, all-wise and all-merciful, as every creed proclaims, could punish the unfortunate wretch who hatches criminal thoughts behind the slanting brows of a criminal head? A doctor has but to glance at the cranium to predicate the crime. In its worst forms all crime, from Nero to Jack the Ripper, is the product of absolute lunacy, and those gross national sins to which allusion has been made seem to point to collective national insanity. Surely, then, there is hope that no very terrible inferno is needed to further punish those who have been so afflicted upon earth. Some of our dead have remarked that nothing has surprised them so much as to find who have been chosen for honour, and certainly, without in any way condoning sin, one could well imagine that the man whose organic makeup predisposed him with irresistible force in that direction should, in justice, receive condolence and sympathy. Possibly such a sinner, if he had not sinned so deeply as he might have done, stands higher than the man who was born good, and remained so, but was no better at the end of his life. The one has made some progress and the other has not. But the commonest failing, the one which fills the spiritual hospitals of the other world, and is a temporary bar to the normal happiness of the after-life, is the sin of Tomlinson in Kipling's poem, the commonest of all sins in respectable British circles, the sin of conventionality, of want of conscious effort and development, of a sluggish spirituality, fatted over by a complacent mind and by the comforts of life. It is the man who is satisfied, the man who refers his salvation to some church or higher power without steady travail of his own soul, who is in deadly danger. All churches are good, Christian or non-Christian, so long as they promote the actual spirit life of the individual, but all are noxious the instant that they allow him to think that by any form of ceremony, or by any fashion of creed, he obtains the least advantage over his neighbour, or can in any way dispense with that personal effort which is the only road to the higher places.

When we view sin in the light of modern science, a more compassionate conscience, and a sense of justice and proportion, it no longer seems like the monstrous cloud that darkened the medieval theologian's entire view. People have judged themselves more harshly than an all-merciful God ever will. Even after all allowances, it is true that much sin remains. It comes from a lack of personal effort, a conscious weakness of will, and a blameworthy failure of character. The sinner, like Horace, sees and praises the higher path while following the lower one. But we must also make allowances for sins that are the inevitable product of early surroundings, inherited and inborn defects, or clear physical causes. And can our human allowances be as generous as God's? Once we have made them, the total of active sin is greatly reduced. Every creed proclaims Providence to be all-wise and all-merciful. Could one imagine that Providence would punish the unfortunate person who forms criminal thoughts behind the sloping brow of a criminal head? A doctor need only glance at the skull to predict the crime. In its worst forms, all crime, from Nero to Jack the Ripper, is the product of complete insanity. And the terrible national sins mentioned earlier seem to point to collective national insanity. Surely, then, there is hope that no very terrible hell is needed to further punish those who have suffered so much on earth. Some of our dead have remarked that nothing surprised them more than discovering who had been chosen for honor. Without excusing sin in any way, one can certainly imagine that a person whose physical makeup led him irresistibly toward it should, in fairness, receive pity and sympathy. Perhaps such a sinner, if he has not sinned as deeply as he might have, stands higher than a person born good who remained good but was no better at the end of his life. The sinner has made some progress, and the other person has not. But the most common failing is the sin of Tomlinson in Kipling's poem. It fills the spiritual hospitals of the other world and temporarily prevents people from enjoying the normal happiness of the afterlife. It is the most common sin in respectable British circles: the sin of conformity, of failing to make a conscious effort and develop, and of spiritual laziness made worse by a self-satisfied mind and the comforts of life. A person who is satisfied with himself is in deadly danger. So is the person who leaves his salvation to a church or higher power without steady effort from his own soul. All churches, Christian or non-Christian, are good as long as they encourage the individual's actual spiritual life. But all become harmful the moment they allow him to think that any ceremony or creed gives him the slightest advantage over his neighbor. They are also harmful if they allow him to think he can avoid the personal effort that is the only path to higher places.

This is, of course, as applicable to believers in Spiritualism as to any other belief. If it does not show in practice then it is vain. One can get through this life very comfortably following without question in some procession with a venerable leader. But one does not die in a procession. One dies alone. And it is then that one has alone to accept the level gained by the work of life.

This applies, of course, as much to believers in Spiritualism as to those with any other belief. If a belief does not show itself in practice, it is worthless. One can live very comfortably by following a respected leader without question. But one does not die in a procession. One dies alone. And then one must accept alone the level reached through the work of one’s life.

And what is the punishment of the undeveloped soul? It is that it should be placed where it WILL develop, and sorrow would seem always to be the forcing ground of souls. That surely is our own experience in life where the insufferably complacent and unsympathetic person softens and mellows into beauty of character and charity of thought, when tried long enough and high enough in the fires of life. The Bible has talked about the "Outer darkness where there is weeping and gnashing of teeth." The influence of the Bible has sometimes been an evil one through our own habit of reading a book of Oriental poetry and treating it as literally as if it were Occidental prose. When an Eastern describes a herd of a thousand camels he talks of camels which are more numerous than the hairs of your head or the stars in the sky. In this spirit of allowance for Eastern expression, one must approach those lurid and terrible descriptions which have darkened the lives of so many imaginative children and sent so many earnest adults into asylums. From all that we learn there are indeed places of outer darkness, but dim as these uncomfortable waiting-rooms may be, they all admit to heaven in the end. That is the final destination of the human race, and it would indeed be a reproach to the Almighty if it were not so. We cannot dogmatise upon this subject of the penal spheres, and yet we have very clear teaching that they are there and that the no-man's-land which separates us from the normal heaven, that third heaven to which St. Paul seems to have been wafted in one short strange experience of his lifetime, is a place which corresponds with the Astral plane of the mystics and with the "outer darkness" of the Bible. Here linger those earth-bound spirits whose worldly interests have clogged them and weighed them down, until every spiritual impulse had vanished; the man whose life has been centred on money, on worldly ambition, or on sensual indulgence. The one-idea'd man will surely be there, if his one idea was not a spiritual one. Nor is it necessary that he should be an evil man, if dear old brother John of Glastonbury, who loved the great Abbey so that he could never detach himself from it, is to be classed among earth-bound spirits. In the most material and pronounced classes of these are the ghosts who impinge very closely upon matter and have been seen so often by those who have no strong psychic sense. It is probable, from what we know of the material laws which govern such matters, that a ghost could never manifest itself if it were alone, that the substance for the manifestation is drawn from the spectator, and that the coldness, raising of hair, and other symptoms of which he complains are caused largely by the sudden drain upon his own vitality. This, however, is to wander into speculation, and far from that correlation of psychic knowledge with religion, which has been the aim of these chapters.

And what is the punishment for an undeveloped soul? It is placed where it will develop, and sorrow always seems to be the soil where souls grow. Surely our own experience confirms this. A person who is unbearably complacent and unfeeling can develop a beautiful character and generous thoughts. This happens when the fires of life test that person long enough and intensely enough. The Bible speaks of the "Outer darkness where there is weeping and gnashing of teeth." The Bible's influence has sometimes been harmful because of how we read it. We treat a book of Eastern poetry as literally as if it were Western prose. When an Eastern writer describes a herd of a thousand camels, he says they outnumber the hairs on your head or the stars in the sky. We must make the same allowance for Eastern expression when reading those vivid, terrible descriptions. They have darkened the lives of so many imaginative children and sent so many earnest adults into asylums. From all we learn, there really are places of outer darkness. But however dim these uncomfortable waiting rooms may be, they all lead to heaven in the end. Heaven is the final destination of the human race, and it would be a reproach to the Almighty if it were not. We cannot speak with certainty about these realms of punishment. Yet we have very clear teaching that they exist. We are also taught about a no-man's-land that separates us from the normal heaven. That heaven is the third heaven to which St. Paul seems to have been carried in one brief, strange experience during his life. The no-man's-land corresponds to the Astral plane of the mystics and the "outer darkness" of the Bible. Earth-bound spirits linger there. Their worldly interests have burdened and weighed them down until every spiritual impulse has vanished. These include people whose lives have centered on money, worldly ambition, or sensual pleasure. Anyone devoted to a single idea will surely be there if that idea was not spiritual. Nor does such a person have to be evil. Consider dear old brother John of Glastonbury, if he is to be counted among the earth-bound spirits. He loved the great Abbey so much that he could never detach himself from it. The most material and pronounced kinds of earth-bound spirits are the ghosts that come very close to the material world. They have often been seen by people with no strong psychic sense. From what we know of the material laws governing such matters, a ghost probably could never appear on its own. The substance for its appearance is drawn from the person who sees it. The coldness, the hair standing on end, and the other symptoms that person reports are largely caused by the sudden drain on their own vitality. This, however, takes us into speculation. It carries us far from the aim of these chapters, which has been to connect psychic knowledge with religion.

By one of those strange coincidences, which seem to me sometimes to be more than coincidences, I had reached this point in my explanation of the difficult question of the intermediate state, and was myself desiring further enlightenment, when an old book reached me through the post, sent by someone whom I have never met, and in it is the following passage, written by an automatic writer, and in existence since 1880. It makes the matter plain, endorsing what has been said and adding new points.

By a strange coincidence, one of those that sometimes seem to me more than coincidences, an old book arrived in the mail. I had reached this point in my explanation of the difficult question of the intermediate state and wanted more insight myself. The book was sent by someone I have never met. It contains the following passage, written by an automatic writer and in existence since 1880. The passage makes the matter clear, supporting what has been said and adding new points.

"Some cannot advance further than the borderland—such as never thought of spirit life and have lived entirely for the earth, its cares and pleasures—even clever men and women, who have lived simply intellectual lives without spirituality. There are many who have misused their opportunities, and are now longing for the time misspent and wishing to recall the earth-life. They will learn that on this side the time can be redeemed, though at much cost. The borderland has many among the restless money-getters of earth, who still haunt the places where they had their hopes and joys. These are often the longest to remain . . . many are not unhappy. They feel the relief to be sufficient to be without their earth bodies. All pass through the borderland, but some hardly perceive it. It is so immediate, and there is no resting there for them. They pass on at once to the refreshment place of which we tell you." The anonymous author, after recording this spirit message, mentions the interesting fact that there is a Christian inscription in the Catacombs which runs: NICEFORUS ANIMA DULCIS IN REFRIGERIO, "Nicephorus, a sweet soul in the refreshment place." One more scrap of evidence that the early Christian scheme of things was very like that of the modern psychic.

"Some cannot go beyond the borderland. These include people who never thought about spirit life and lived entirely for earthly cares and pleasures. They also include clever men and women who lived purely intellectual lives without spirituality. Many have misused their opportunities. They now long for the time they wasted and wish they could return to earthly life. They will learn that time can be redeemed on this side, though at great cost. Many restless people who pursued money on earth are in the borderland. They still haunt the places where they had their hopes and joys. These people often stay the longest . . . many are not unhappy. They find enough relief in being free of their earthly bodies. All pass through the borderland, but some hardly notice it. Their passage is so swift that they do not rest there. They pass at once to the refreshment place we tell you about." After recording this spirit message, the anonymous author mentions an interesting Christian inscription in the Catacombs. It reads: NICEFORUS ANIMA DULCIS IN REFRIGERIO, "Nicephorus, a sweet soul in the refreshment place." This is one more scrap of evidence that the early Christian view of things was very like that of the modern psychic.

So much for the borderland, the intermediate condition. The present Christian dogma has no name for it, unless it be that nebulous limbo which is occasionally mentioned, and is usually defined as the place where the souls of the just who died before Christ were detained. The idea of crossing a space before reaching a permanent state on the other side is common to many religions, and took the allegorical form of a river with a ferry-boat among the Romans and Greeks. Continually, one comes on points which make one realise that far back in the world's history there has been a true revelation, which has been blurred and twisted in time. Thus in Dr. Muir's summary of the RIG. VEDA, he says, epitomising the beliefs of the first Aryan conquerors of India: "Before, however, the unborn part" (that is, the etheric body) "can complete its course to the third heaven it has to traverse a vast gulf of darkness, leaving behind on earth all that is evil, and proceeding by the paths the fathers trod, the spirit soars to the realms of eternal light, recovers there his body in a glorified form, and obtains from God a delectable abode and enters upon a more perfect life, which is crowned with the fulfilment of all desires, is passed in the presence of the Gods and employed in the fulfilment of their pleasure." If we substitute "angels" for "Gods" we must admit that the new revelation from modern spirit sources has much in common with the belief of our Aryan fathers.

That is the borderland, the intermediate state. Current Christian doctrine has no name for it, unless it is the vague concept of limbo. Limbo is occasionally mentioned and is usually defined as the place where the souls of the just who died before Christ were held. Many religions share the idea of crossing a space before reaching a permanent state on the other side. Among the Romans and Greeks, this took the allegorical form of a river and a ferryboat. Again and again, one finds evidence that a true revelation occurred far back in human history. Over time, it has been blurred and distorted. For example, in his summary of the RIG. VEDA, Dr. Muir sums up the beliefs of the first Aryan conquerors of India: "Before the unborn part" (that is, the etheric body) "can complete its journey to the third heaven, it must cross a vast gulf of darkness. Leaving behind on earth all that is evil and following the paths the fathers took, the spirit rises to the realms of eternal light. There, the spirit recovers its body in a glorified form and receives a delightful home from God. It enters a more perfect life, crowned by the fulfillment of all desires. This life is spent in the presence of the Gods and in doing what pleases them." If we substitute "angels" for "Gods", we must admit that the new revelation from modern spirit sources has much in common with the belief of our Aryan fathers.

Such, in very condensed form, is the world which is revealed to us by these wonderful messages from the beyond. Is it an unreasonable vision? Is it in any way opposed to just principles? Is it not rather so reasonable that having got the clue we could now see that, given any life at all, this is exactly the line upon which we should expect to move? Nature and evolution are averse from sudden disconnected developments. If a human being has technical, literary, musical, or other tendencies, they are an essential part of his character, and to survive without them would be to lose his identity and to become an entirely different man. They must therefore survive death if personality is to be maintained. But it is no use their surviving unless they can find means of expression, and means of expression seem to require certain material agents, and also a discriminating audience. So also the sense of modesty among civilised races has become part of our very selves, and implies some covering of our forms if personality is to continue. Our desires and sympathies would prompt us to live with those we love, which implies something in the nature of a house, while the human need for mental rest and privacy would predicate the existence of separate rooms. Thus, merely starting from the basis of the continuity of personality one might, even without the revelation from the beyond, have built up some such system by the use of pure reason and deduction.

Such, in a very condensed form, is the world revealed to us by these wonderful messages from beyond. Is this vision unreasonable? Does it in any way conflict with just principles? Is it not so reasonable that, once given the clue, we can see that this is exactly what we should expect, if there is any life after death? Nature and evolution do not favor sudden, disconnected developments. If people have technical, literary, musical, or other interests, these are essential parts of their character. To survive without them would be to lose their identity and become entirely different people. These interests must therefore survive death if personality is to continue. But there is no use in their surviving unless they can find expression. And expression seems to require certain material means and an audience capable of appreciating it. Likewise, the sense of modesty among civilized peoples has become part of our very selves. If personality is to continue, modesty implies some covering for our bodies. Our desires and sympathies would prompt us to live with those we love. This implies something like a house. The human need for mental rest and privacy would also imply separate rooms. Thus, starting only with the continuity of personality, we might have built up a similar system through reason and deduction alone. We could have done this even without the revelation from beyond.

So far as the existence of this land of happiness goes, it would seem to have been more fully proved than any other religious conception within our knowledge.

The existence of this land of happiness seems to be more fully proven than any other religious belief we know of.

It may very reasonably be asked, how far this precise description of life beyond the grave is my own conception, and how far it has been accepted by the greater minds who have studied this subject? I would answer, that it is my own conclusion as gathered from a very large amount of existing testimony, and that in its main lines it has for many years been accepted by those great numbers of silent active workers all over the world, who look upon this matter from a strictly religious point of view. I think that the evidence amply justifies us in this belief. On the other hand, those who have approached this subject with cold and cautious scientific brains, endowed, in many cases, with the strongest prejudices against dogmatic creeds and with very natural fears about the possible re-growth of theological quarrels, have in most cases stopped short of a complete acceptance, declaring that there can be no positive proof upon such matters, and that we may deceive ourselves either by a reflection of our own thoughts or by receiving the impressions of the medium. Professor Zollner, for example, says:

It is reasonable to ask how much of this precise description of life beyond the grave is my own idea. How much of it has been accepted by the greatest minds who have studied the subject? My answer is that it is my own conclusion, drawn from a great deal of existing testimony. Its main points have also been accepted for many years by large numbers of quiet, active workers around the world. They approach the subject from a strictly religious point of view. I think the evidence fully justifies this belief. On the other hand, others have approached the subject with cool, cautious scientific minds. Many of them have strong prejudices against dogmatic creeds. They also have very natural fears that theological quarrels might arise again. Most of them have stopped short of accepting this description completely. They say there can be no definite proof about such matters. They also say we may deceive ourselves, either by seeing a reflection of our own thoughts or by receiving the medium’s impressions. Professor Zollner, for example, says:

"Science can make no use of the substance of intellectual revelations, but must be guided by observed facts and by the conclusions logically and mathematically uniting them"—a passage which is quoted with approval by Professor Reichel, and would seem to be endorsed by the silence concerning the religious side of the question which is observed by most of our great scientific supporters. It is a point of view which can well be understood, and yet, closely examined, it would appear to be a species of enlarged materialism. To admit, as these observers do, that spirits do return, that they give every proof of being the actual friends whom we have lost, and yet to turn a deaf ear to the messages which they send would seem to be pushing caution to the verge of unreason. To get so far, and yet not to go further, is impossible as a permanent position. If, for example, in Raymond's case we find so many allusions to the small details of his home upon earth, which prove to be surprisingly correct, is it reasonable to put a blue pencil through all he says of the home which he actually inhabits? Long before I had convinced my mind of the truth of things which appeared so grotesque and incredible, I had a long account sent by table tilting about the conditions of life beyond. The details seemed to me impossible and I set them aside, and yet they harmonise, as I now discover, with other revelations. So, too, with the automatic script of Mr. Hubert Wales, which has been described in my previous book. He had tossed it aside into a drawer as being unworthy of serious consideration, and yet it also proved to be in harmony. In neither of these cases was telepathy or the prepossession of the medium a possible explanation. On the whole, I am inclined to think that these doubtful or dissentient scientific men, having their own weighty studies to attend to, have confined their reading and thought to the more objective side of the question, and are not aware of the vast amount of concurrent evidence which appears to give us an exact picture of the life beyond. They despise documents which cannot be proved, and they do not, in my opinion, sufficiently realise that a general agreement of testimony, and the already established character of a witness, are themselves arguments for truth. Some complicate the question by predicating the existence of a fourth dimension in that world, but the term is an absurdity, as are all terms which find no corresponding impression in the human brain. We have mysteries enough to solve without gratuitously introducing fresh ones. When solid passes through solid, it is, surely, simpler to assume that it is done by a dematerialisation, and subsequent reassembly—a process which can, at least, be imagined by the human mind—than to invoke an explanation which itself needs to be explained.

“Science cannot use the substance of intellectual revelations. It must be guided by observed facts and the conclusions that connect them logically and mathematically.” Professor Reichel quotes this passage with approval. Most of our leading scientific supporters also seem to endorse it by remaining silent about the religious side of the question. Their point of view is understandable, but on closer examination it seems to be a form of expanded materialism. These observers admit that spirits do return and give every proof that they are the friends we have lost. Yet they turn a deaf ear to the messages those spirits send. That seems to push caution to the edge of unreason. It is impossible to go so far, yet no further, as a permanent position. In Raymond’s case, for example, we find many references to small details of his home on earth. These prove to be surprisingly accurate. Is it reasonable, then, to strike out everything he says about the home where he now lives? Long before I had convinced myself of the truth of things that seemed so grotesque and incredible, an account was sent to me through table tilting. It gave a long description of the conditions of life beyond. The details seemed impossible to me, and I set them aside. Yet I now discover that they agree with other revelations. The same is true of Mr. Hubert Wales’s automatic script, which I described in my previous book. He had tossed it into a drawer, thinking it unworthy of serious consideration. Yet it too proved to agree with the other revelations. In neither case could telepathy or the medium’s preconceptions explain the result. On the whole, I am inclined to think that these skeptical or dissenting scientists have limited their reading and thought to the more objective side of the question. They have their own important studies to attend to. I think they are unaware of the vast amount of consistent evidence that appears to give us an exact picture of life beyond. They dismiss documents that cannot be proved. In my opinion, they do not sufficiently recognize that general agreement among accounts is itself an argument for truth. So is the already established character of a witness. Some complicate the question by assuming that a fourth dimension exists in that world. But the term is absurd, as are all terms that have no corresponding impression in the human mind. We have enough mysteries to solve without needlessly introducing new ones. When one solid passes through another, it is surely simpler to assume that it dematerializes and then reassembles. The human mind can at least imagine that process. It is simpler than calling on an explanation that itself needs to be explained.

In the next and final chapter I will ask the reader to accompany me in an examination of the New Testament by the light of this psychic knowledge, and to judge how far it makes clear and reasonable much which was obscure and confused.

In the next and final chapter, I will invite the reader to examine the New Testament in light of this psychic knowledge. I will ask the reader to judge how far this knowledge makes clear and reasonable much that was obscure and confusing.