Chapter 5
Is It the Second Dawn?
There are many incidents in the New Testament which might be taken as starting points in tracing a close analogy between the phenomenal events which are associated with the early days of Christianity, and those which have perplexed the world in connection with modern Spiritualism. Most of us are prepared to admit that the lasting claims of Christianity upon the human race are due to its own intrinsic teachings, which are quite independent of those wonders which can only have had a use in startling the solid complacence of an unspiritual race, and so directing their attention violently to this new system of thought. Exactly the same may be said of the new revelation. The exhibitions of a force which is beyond human experience and human guidance is but a method of calling attention. To repeat a simile which has been used elsewhere, it is the humble telephone bell which heralds the all-important message. In the case of Christ, the Sermon on the Mount was more than many miracles. In the case of this new development, the messages from beyond are more than any phenomena. A vulgar mind might make Christ's story seem vulgar, if it insisted upon loaves of bread and the bodies of fish. So, also, a vulgar mind may make psychic religion vulgar by insisting upon moving furniture or tambourines in the air. In each case they are crude signs of power, and the essence of the matter lies upon higher planes.
Many incidents in the New Testament could serve as starting points for tracing a close parallel. This parallel is between the extraordinary events associated with early Christianity and those connected with modern Spiritualism that have perplexed the world. Most of us are ready to admit that Christianity has a lasting claim on humanity because of its own teachings. Those teachings stand quite apart from the wonders. The wonders could only have served to shock a complacent, unspiritual human race into paying attention to this new way of thinking. Exactly the same may be said of the new revelation. Displays of a force beyond human experience and control are only a way of attracting attention. To repeat a comparison used elsewhere, they are the humble telephone bell that announces the all-important message. In Christ's case, the Sermon on the Mount mattered more than many miracles. In this new development, the messages from beyond matter more than any phenomena. A vulgar mind might make Christ's story seem vulgar by focusing on loaves of bread and the bodies of fish. In the same way, a vulgar mind may make psychic religion seem vulgar by focusing on moving furniture or tambourines in the air. In each case, these are crude signs of power. The essence of the matter lies on higher planes.
It is stated in the second chapter of the Acts of the Apostles, that they, the Christian leaders, were all "with one accord" in one place. "With one accord" expresses admirably those sympathetic conditions which have always been found, in psychic circles, to be conducive of the best results, and which are so persistently ignored by a certain class of investigators. Then there came "a mighty rushing wind," and afterwards "there appeared cloven tongues like unto fire and it sat upon each of them." Here is a very definite and clear account of a remarkable sequence of phenomena. Now, let us compare with this the results which were obtained by Professor Crookes in his investigation in 1873, after he had taken every possible precaution against fraud which his experience, as an accurate observer and experimenter, could suggest. He says in his published notes: "I have seen luminous points of light darting about, sitting on the heads of different persons" and then again:
The second chapter of the Acts of the Apostles says that the Christian leaders were all "with one accord" in one place. "With one accord" admirably describes the sympathetic conditions that psychic circles have always found conducive to the best results. Yet a certain class of investigators persistently ignores these conditions. Then came "a mighty rushing wind," and afterward "there appeared cloven tongues like unto fire and it sat upon each of them." This is a very definite and clear account of a remarkable sequence of phenomena. Now let us compare this account with Professor Crookes's results from his investigation in 1873. He had taken every possible precaution against fraud that his experience as a careful observer and experimenter could suggest. He says in his published notes: "I have seen luminous points of light darting about, sitting on the heads of different persons" and then again:
"These movements, and, indeed, I may say the same of every class of phenomena, are generally preceded by a peculiar cold air, sometimes amounting to a decided wind. I have had sheets of paper blown about by it. . . ." Now, is it not singular, not merely that the phenomena should be of the same order, but that they should come in exactly the same sequence, the wind first and the lights afterwards? In our ignorance of etheric physics, an ignorance which is now slowly clearing, one can only say that there is some indication here of a general law which links those two episodes together in spite of the nineteen centuries which divide them. A little later, it is stated that "the place was shaken where they were assembled together." Many modern observers of psychic phenomena have testified to vibration of the walls of an apartment, as if a heavy lorry were passing. It is, evidently, to such experiences that Paul alludes when he says: "Our gospel came unto you not in word only, but also in power." The preacher of the New Revelation can most truly say the same words. In connection with the signs of the pentecost, I can most truly say that I have myself experienced them all, the cold sudden wind, the lambent misty flames, all under the mediumship of Mr. Phoenix, an amateur psychic of Glasgow. The fifteen sitters were of one accord upon that occasion, and, by a coincidence, it was in an upper room, at the very top of the house.
"These movements are generally preceded by a strange cold current of air. The same is true, I may say, of every class of phenomena. Sometimes the current is strong enough to be a definite wind. I have had sheets of paper blown about by it. . . ." Now, isn't it remarkable that the phenomena should be of the same kind? And isn't it remarkable that they should occur in exactly the same order, with the wind first and the lights afterward? Our ignorance of etheric physics is now slowly clearing. For now, we can only say that there is some indication of a general law linking these two episodes. This is so despite the nineteen centuries between them. A little later, we are told that "the place was shaken where they were assembled together." Many modern observers of psychic phenomena have reported the walls of a room vibrating, as if a heavy truck were passing. Clearly, Paul refers to such experiences when he says: "Our gospel came unto you not in word only, but also in power." The preacher of the New Revelation can say the same words with complete truth. As for the signs of Pentecost, I can truthfully say that I have experienced them all myself. I felt the sudden cold wind and saw the softly glowing, misty flames. All of this happened under the mediumship of Mr. Phoenix, an amateur psychic from Glasgow. The fifteen sitters were all of one mind on that occasion. By coincidence, they were in an upper room, at the very top of the house.
In a previous section of this essay, I have remarked that no philosophical explanation of these phenomena, known as spiritual, could be conceived which did not show that all, however different in their working, came from the same central source. St. Paul seems to state this in so many words when he says: "But all these worketh that one and the selfsame spirit, dividing to every man severally as he will." Could our modern speculation, forced upon us by the facts, be more tersely stated? He has just enumerated the various gifts, and we find them very close to those of which we have experience. There is first "the word of wisdom," "the word of knowledge" and "faith." All these taken in connection with the Spirit would seem to mean the higher communications from the other side. Then comes healing, which is still practised in certain conditions by a highly virile medium, who has the power of discharging strength, losing just as much as the weakling gains, as instanced by Christ when He said: "Who has touched me? Much virtue" (or power) "has gone out of me." Then we come upon the working of miracles, which we should call the production of phenomena, and which would cover many different types, such as apports, where objects are brought from a distance, levitation of objects or of the human frame into the air, the production of lights and other wonders. Then comes prophecy, which is a real and yet a fitful and often delusive form of mediumship—never so delusive as among the early Christians, who seem all to have mistaken the approaching fall of Jerusalem and the destruction of the Temple, which they could dimly see, as being the end of the world. This mistake is repeated so often and so clearly that it is really not honest to ignore or deny it. Then we come to the power of "discerning the spirits," which corresponds to our clairvoyance, and finally that curious and usually useless gift of tongues, which is also a modern phenomenon. I can remember that some time ago I read the book, "I Heard a Voice," by an eminent barrister, in which he describes how his young daughter began to write Greek fluently with all the complex accents in their correct places. Just after I read it I received a letter from a no less famous physician, who asked my opinion about one of his children who had written a considerable amount of script in mediaeval French. These two recent cases are beyond all doubt, but I have not had convincing evidence of the case where some unintelligible signs drawn by an unlettered man were pronounced by an expert to be in the Ogham or early Celtic character. As the Ogham script is really a combination of straight lines, the latter case may be taken with considerable reserve.
In an earlier section of this essay, I argued that all spiritual phenomena must come from the same central source. No philosophical explanation could suggest otherwise, however differently the phenomena work. St. Paul seems to say exactly this: "But all these worketh that one and the selfsame spirit, dividing to every man severally as he will." Could our modern speculation, forced on us by the facts, be stated more concisely? He has just listed the various gifts, and we find them very close to those we have experienced. First come "the word of wisdom," "the word of knowledge" and "faith." Taken together in connection with the Spirit, these seem to mean the higher communications from the other side. Then comes healing, which is still practised under certain conditions by a highly vigorous medium. The medium has the power to give out strength, losing just as much as the weak person gains. Christ gave an example when he said: "Who has touched me? Much virtue" (or power) "has gone out of me." Next comes the working of miracles, which we would call the production of phenomena. This would cover many types, such as apports, where objects are brought from a distance. It would also include the levitation of objects or people into the air, the production of lights, and other wonders. Then comes prophecy, a real but inconsistent and often misleading form of mediumship. It was never more misleading than among the early Christians. They seem all to have mistaken the approaching fall of Jerusalem and destruction of the Temple for the end of the world. They could see those events dimly. This mistake is repeated so often and so clearly that it is not honest to ignore or deny it. Next comes the power of "discerning the spirits," which corresponds to our clairvoyance. Finally, there is the curious and usually useless gift of tongues, which is also a modern phenomenon. I remember reading "I Heard a Voice," a book by an eminent barrister. He describes how his young daughter began to write Greek fluently, with all the complex accents in their correct places. Just after I read it, I received a letter from an equally famous physician. He asked my opinion about one of his children, who had written a considerable amount in mediaeval French. These two recent cases are beyond all doubt. But I have not had convincing evidence of another case. An unlettered man drew some unintelligible signs, which an expert declared to be in the Ogham or early Celtic character. Since the Ogham script is really a combination of straight lines, this last case may be viewed with considerable reserve.
Thus the phenomena associated with the rise of Christianity and those which have appeared during the present spiritual ferment are very analogous. In examining the gifts of the disciples, as mentioned by Matthew and Mark, the only additional point is the raising of the dead. If any of them besides their great leader did in truth rise to this height of power, where life was actually extinct, then he, undoubtedly, far transcended anything which is recorded of modern mediumship. It is clear, however, that such a power must have been very rare, since it would otherwise have been used to revive the bodies of their own martyrs, which does not seem to have been attempted. For Christ the power is clearly admitted, and there are little touches in the description of how it was exercised by Him which are extremely convincing to a psychic student. In the account of how He raised Lazarus from the grave after he had been four days dead—far the most wonderful of all Christ's miracles—it is recorded that as He went down to the graveside He was "groaning." Why was He groaning? No Biblical student seems to have given a satisfactory reason. But anyone who has heard a medium groaning before any great manifestation of power will read into this passage just that touch of practical knowledge, which will convince him of its truth. The miracle, I may add, is none the less wonderful or beyond our human powers, because it was wrought by an extension of natural law, differing only in degree with that which we can ourselves test and even do.
The phenomena associated with the rise of Christianity are very similar to those appearing during the present spiritual ferment. Matthew and Mark describe the disciples’ gifts, and the only additional power they mention is raising the dead. If any disciple besides their great leader truly gained this power, when life was actually extinct, he far surpassed anything recorded in modern mediumship. However, such a power must have been very rare. Otherwise, the disciples would have used it to revive the bodies of their own martyrs. They do not seem to have tried. Christ clearly had this power, and the descriptions of how he used it contain details that are extremely convincing to a student of psychic phenomena. Christ raised Lazarus from the grave after he had been dead for four days. This was by far the most wonderful of all Christ’s miracles. The account says that Christ was "groaning" as he went down to the graveside. Why was he groaning? No Biblical scholar seems to have given a satisfactory reason. But anyone who has heard a medium groaning before a great display of power will recognize a touch of practical knowledge in this passage. It will convince him that the account is true. I may add that the miracle is no less wonderful or beyond human powers because it was performed through an extension of natural law. This extension differs only in degree from what we can test and even do ourselves.
Although our modern manifestations have never attained the power mentioned in the Biblical records, they present some features which are not related in the New Testament. Clairaudience, that is the hearing of a spirit voice, is common to both, but the direct voice, that is the hearing of a voice which all can discern with their material ears, is a well-authenticated phenomenon now which is more rarely mentioned of old. So, too, Spirit-photography, where the camera records what the human eye cannot see, is necessarily a new testimony. Nothing is evidence to those who do not examine evidence, but I can attest most solemnly that I personally know of several cases where the image upon the plate after death has not only been unmistakable, but also has differed entirely from any pre-existing photograph.
Although modern manifestations have never reached the power described in the Biblical records, they have some features not mentioned in the New Testament. Clairaudience, the hearing of a spirit voice, occurs in both. But the direct voice, a voice everyone can hear with their physical ears, is now a well-established phenomenon. It is mentioned less often in earlier times. Spirit-photography is also necessarily new evidence, since the camera records what the human eye cannot see. Nothing is evidence to those who do not examine it. But I can solemnly affirm that I personally know of several cases where an image on a photographic plate after death was unmistakable. In each case, it was also entirely different from any existing photograph.
As to the methods by which the early Christians communicated with the spirits, or with the "Saints" as they called their dead brethren, we have, so far as I know, no record, though the words of John: "Brothers, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God," show very clearly that spirit communion was a familiar idea, and also that they were plagued, as we are, by the intrusion of unwelcome spiritual elements in their intercourse. Some have conjectured that the "Angel of the Church," who is alluded to in terms which suggest that he was a human being, was really a medium sanctified to the use of that particular congregation. As we have early indications of bishops, deacons and other officials, it is difficult to say what else the "angel" could have been. This, however, must remain a pure speculation.
As far as I know, we have no record of how early Christians communicated with spirits, or with the "Saints", as they called their dead brothers and sisters. But John's words make clear that communicating with spirits was a familiar idea: "Brothers, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are of God." They also show that early Christians, like us, were troubled by unwelcome spiritual elements intruding on their communications. Some have suggested that the "Angel of the Church" was a medium dedicated to serving that particular congregation. The angel is mentioned in terms that suggest he was a human being. We have early evidence of bishops, deacons, and other officials, so it is difficult to say what else the "angel" could have been. This suggestion, however, must remain pure speculation.
Another speculation which is, perhaps, rather more fruitful is upon what principle did Christ select his twelve chief followers. Out of all the multitudes he chose twelve men. Why these particular ones? It was not for their intelligence or learning, for Peter and John, who were among the most prominent, are expressly described as "unlearned and ignorant men." It was not for their virtue, for one of them proved to be a great villain, and all of them deserted their Master in His need. It was not for their belief, for there were great numbers of believers. And yet it is clear that they were chosen on some principle of selection since they were called in ones and in twos. In at least two cases they were pairs of brothers, as though some family gift or peculiarity, might underlie the choice.
Another question may be more fruitful: how did Christ choose his twelve chief followers? Out of all the crowds, he chose twelve men. Why these particular men? It was not for their intelligence or education. Peter and John were among the most prominent, yet they are expressly described as "uneducated and ignorant men." It was not for their virtue. One of them proved to be a great villain, and all of them deserted their Master in his time of need. It was not for their belief, because there were many believers. Yet clearly some principle guided his choice, since he called them one or two at a time. In at least two cases, they were pairs of brothers. This suggests that some family gift or trait may have influenced his choice.
Is it not at least possible that this gift was psychic power, and that Christ, as the greatest exponent who has ever appeared upon earth of that power, desired to surround Himself with others who possessed it to a lesser degree? This He would do for two reasons. The first is that a psychic circle is a great source of strength to one who is himself psychic, as is shown continually in our own experience, where, with a sympathetic and helpful surrounding, an atmosphere is created where all the powers are drawn out. How sensitive Christ was to such an atmosphere is shown by the remark of the Evangelist, that when He visited His own native town, where the townspeople could not take Him seriously, He was unable to do any wonders. The second reason may have been that He desired them to act as His deputies, either during his lifetime or after His death, and that for this reason some natural psychic powers were necessary.
Is it not at least possible that this gift was psychic power? Christ was the greatest exponent of that power ever to appear on earth. Could he have wanted to surround himself with others who possessed it to a lesser degree? He would have done this for two reasons. First, a psychic circle is a great source of strength to someone who is himself psychic. Our own experience continually shows this. Supportive and sympathetic people create an atmosphere that draws out all of a psychic person’s powers. The Evangelist’s account shows how sensitive Christ was to such an atmosphere. When Christ visited his hometown, the townspeople could not take him seriously. There he was unable to perform any wonders. The second reason may have been that he wanted them to act as his deputies, either during his lifetime or after his death. For this reason, they needed some natural psychic powers.
The close connection which appears to exist between the Apostles and the miracles, has been worked out in an interesting fashion by Dr. Abraham Wallace, in his little pamphlet "Jesus of Nazareth." Certainly, no miracle or wonder working, save that of exorcism, is recorded in any of the Evangelists until after the time when Christ began to assemble His circle. Of this circle the three who would appear to have been the most psychic were Peter and the two fellow-fishermen, sons of Zebedee, John and James. These were the three who were summoned when an ideal atmosphere was needed. It will be remembered that when the daughter of Jairus was raised from the dead it was in the presence, and possibly, with the co-operation, of these three assistants. Again, in the case of the Transfiguration, it is impossible to read the account of that wonderful manifestation without being reminded at every turn of one's own spiritual experiences. Here, again, the points are admirably made in "Jesus of Nazareth," and it would be well if that little book, with its scholarly tone, its breadth of treatment and its psychic knowledge, was in the hands of every Biblical student. Dr. Wallace points out that the place, the summit of a hill, was the ideal one for such a manifestation, in its pure air and freedom from interruption; that the drowsy state of the Apostles is paralleled by the members of any circle who are contributing psychic power; that the transfiguring of the face and the shining raiment are known phenomena; above all, that the erection of three altars is meaningless, but that the alternate reading, the erection of three booths or cabinets, one for the medium and one for each materialised form, would absolutely fulfil the most perfect conditions for getting results. This explanation of Wallace's is a remarkable example of a modern brain, with modern knowledge, throwing a clear searchlight across all the centuries and illuminating an incident which has always been obscure.
Dr. Abraham Wallace explores the apparent close connection between the Apostles and miracles in his short pamphlet "Jesus of Nazareth." Certainly, the Gospels record no miracle or wonder, except exorcism, until after Christ began to gather his circle. The three members who seem to have been the most psychic were Peter and two fellow fishermen, John and James, the sons of Zebedee. These three were called upon when an ideal atmosphere was needed. When Jairus’s daughter was raised from the dead, these three assistants were present and may have helped. The Transfiguration is another example. One cannot read the account of that wonderful manifestation without being reminded at every turn of one’s own spiritual experiences. Once again, "Jesus of Nazareth" makes these points admirably. It would be good if every Biblical student had this short book, with its scholarly tone, broad treatment, and psychic knowledge. Dr. Wallace points out that the hilltop was ideal for such a manifestation because of its pure air and freedom from interruption. The Apostles’ drowsiness is also found among members of any circle who are contributing psychic power. The change in Christ’s face and his shining clothes are known phenomena. Above all, the building of three altars makes no sense. But an alternative reading describes the building of three booths or cabinets, one for the medium and one for each materialised form. That would perfectly fulfil the best conditions for getting results. Wallace’s explanation is a remarkable example of a modern mind using modern knowledge to shine a clear searchlight across the centuries. It illuminates an incident that has always been obscure.
Published for sixpence by the Light Publishing Co., 6, Queen Square, London, W.C. The same company sells Dr. Ellis Powell's convincing little book on the same subject.
When we translate Bible language into the terms of modern psychic religion the correspondence becomes evident. It does not take much alteration. Thus for "Lo, a miracle!" we say "This is a manifestation." "The angel of the Lord" becomes "a high spirit." Where we talked of "a voice from heaven," we say "the direct voice." "His eyes were opened and he saw a vision" means "he became clairvoyant." It is only the occultist who can possibly understand the Scriptures as being a real exact record of events.
When we translate the language of the Bible into the terms of modern psychic religion, the similarities become clear. It takes little change. For example, instead of "Look, a miracle!" we say "This is a manifestation." "The angel of the Lord" becomes "a high spirit." Instead of "a voice from heaven," we say "the direct voice." "His eyes were opened and he saw a vision" means "he became clairvoyant." Only an occultist can understand the Scriptures as a true and exact record of events.
There are many other small points which seem to bring the story of Christ and of the Apostles into very close touch with modern psychic research, and greatly support the close accuracy of some of the New Testament narrative. One which appeals to me greatly is the action of Christ when He was asked a question which called for a sudden decision, namely the fate of the woman who had been taken in sin. What did He do? The very last thing that one would have expected or invented. He stooped down before answering and wrote with his finger in the sand. This he did a second time upon a second catch-question being addressed to Him. Can any theologian give a reason for such an action? I hazard the opinion that among the many forms of mediumship which were possessed in the highest form by Christ, was the power of automatic writing, by which He summoned those great forces which were under His control to supply Him with the answer. Granting, as I freely do, that Christ was preternatural, in the sense that He was above and beyond ordinary humanity in His attributes, one may still inquire how far these powers were contained always within His human body, or how far He referred back to spiritual reserves beyond it. When He spoke merely from His human body He was certainly open to error, like the rest of us, for it is recorded how He questioned the woman of Samaria about her husband, to which she replied that she had no husband. In the case of the woman taken in sin, one can only explain His action by the supposition that He opened a channel instantly for the knowledge and wisdom which was preter-human, and which at once gave a decision in favor of large-minded charity.
Many other small details seem to connect the story of Christ and the Apostles closely with modern psychic research. They also strongly support the accuracy of some New Testament accounts. One detail particularly strikes me. Christ was asked a question that required a quick decision about the fate of a woman caught in sin. What did he do? The very last thing one would have expected or invented. Before answering, he bent down and wrote in the sand with his finger. He did this again when a second trick question was put to him. Can any theologian explain why he did this? I suggest that Christ possessed many forms of mediumship in their highest form, including the power of automatic writing. Through it, he summoned the great forces under his control to provide him with the answer. I freely admit that Christ was preternatural, in the sense that his qualities put him above and beyond ordinary humanity. Even so, we may ask how far these powers were always contained within his human body. We may also ask how far he drew on spiritual reserves beyond it. When he spoke from his human body alone, he was certainly open to error, like the rest of us. For it is recorded that he questioned the woman of Samaria about her husband. She replied that she had no husband. In the case of the woman caught in sin, I can explain his action only by one assumption. He instantly opened a channel to knowledge and wisdom beyond human powers. This at once gave a decision in favor of generous charity.
It is interesting to observe the effect which these phenomena, or the report of them, produced upon the orthodox Jews of those days. The greater part obviously discredited them, otherwise they could not have failed to become followers, or at the least to have regarded such a wonder-worker with respect and admiration. One can well imagine how they shook their bearded heads, declared that such occurrences were outside their own experience, and possibly pointed to the local conjuror who earned a few not over-clean denarii by imitating the phenomena. There were others, however, who could not possibly deny, because they either saw or met with witnesses who had seen. These declared roundly that the whole thing was of the devil, drawing from Christ one of those pithy, common-sense arguments in which He excelled. The same two classes of opponents, the scoffers and the diabolists, face us to-day. Verily the old world goes round and so do the events upon its surface.
It is interesting to see how these phenomena, or reports of them, affected the orthodox Jews of those days. Most clearly did not believe them. Otherwise, they would surely have become followers, or at least regarded such a wonder-worker with respect and admiration. One can imagine them shaking their bearded heads and saying that such things were outside their own experience. Perhaps they pointed to the local conjurer, who earned a few not entirely clean denarii by imitating the phenomena. Others, however, could not possibly deny the phenomena. They had either seen them or met witnesses who had. These people declared outright that the whole thing was the work of the devil. This prompted Christ to offer one of the concise, common-sense arguments at which he excelled. The same two classes of opponents, the scoffers and those who blame the devil, face us today. Truly, the old world goes round, and so do the events on its surface.
There is one line of thought which may be indicated in the hope that it will find development from the minds and pens of those who have studied most deeply the possibilities of psychic power. It is at least possible, though I admit that under modern conditions it has not been clearly proved, that a medium of great power can charge another with his own force, just as a magnet when rubbed upon a piece of inert steel can turn it also into a magnet. One of the best attested powers of D. D. Home was that he could take burning coals from the fire with impunity and carry them in his hand. He could then—and this comes nearer to the point at issue—place them on the head of anyone who was fearless without their being burned. Spectators have described how the silver filigree of the hair of Mr. Carter Hall used to be gathered over the glowing ember, and Mrs. Hall has mentioned how she combed out the ashes afterwards. Now, in this case, Home was clearly, able to convey, a power to another person, just as Christ, when He was levitated over the lake, was able to convey the same power to Peter, so long as Peter's faith held firm. The question then arises if Home concentrated all his force upon transferring such a power how long would that power last? The experiment was never tried, but it would have borne very, directly upon this argument. For, granting that the power can be transferred, then it is very clear how the Christ circle was able to send forth seventy disciples who were endowed with miraculous functions. It is clear also why, new disciples had to return to Jerusalem to be "baptised of the spirit," to use their phrase, before setting forth upon their wanderings. And when in turn they, desired to send forth representatives would not they lay hands upon them, make passes over them and endeavour to magnetise them in the same way—if that word may express the process? Have we here the meaning of the laying on of hands by the bishop at ordination, a ceremony to which vast importance is still attached, but which may well be the survival of something really vital, the bestowal of the thaumaturgic power? When, at last, through lapse of time or neglect of fresh cultivation, the power ran out, the empty formula may have been carried on, without either the blesser or the blessed understanding what it was that the hands of the bishop, and the force which streamed from them, were meant to bestow. The very words "laying on of hands" would seem to suggest something different from a mere benediction.
There is one idea I would like to suggest. I hope those who have studied the possibilities of psychic power most deeply will develop it further in their writing. It is at least possible that a powerful medium can transfer his own force to another person. I admit that this has not been clearly proved under modern conditions. But a magnet rubbed against an ordinary piece of steel can turn it into a magnet too. One of D. D. Home’s best documented powers was his ability to take burning coals from a fire. He could carry them in his hand without being harmed. He could also place them on the head of anyone who was fearless without burning that person. This comes closer to the point at issue. Spectators have described how Mr. Carter Hall’s fine silver hair was gathered over the glowing coal. Mrs. Hall said that she combed the ashes out afterwards. In this case, Home was clearly able to transfer a power to another person. In the same way, Christ, when he was levitated over the lake, could transfer that power to Peter, as long as Peter’s faith held firm. Suppose Home had concentrated all his force on transferring such a power. How long would it have lasted? The experiment was never tried, but it would have been directly relevant to this argument. For if the power can be transferred, it is very clear how Christ’s circle could send out seventy disciples endowed with miraculous powers. It is also clear why new disciples had to return to Jerusalem to be "baptised of the spirit," as they called it, before setting out on their travels. And when those disciples wanted to send out representatives in turn, would they not lay hands on them? Would they not make passes over them and try to magnetise them in the same way, if that word describes the process? Could this be the meaning of the bishop’s laying on of hands at ordination? Great importance is still attached to this ceremony. It may well be the survival of something truly vital, the bestowal of the thaumaturgic power. In time, the power may have run out, either through the passage of time or because no one renewed its cultivation. The empty ceremony may then have continued, with neither the bishop nor the person he blessed understanding what it was meant to bestow. They may not have understood what the bishop’s hands and the force streaming from them were meant to give. The very words "laying on of hands" seem to suggest something different from a mere blessing.
Enough has been said, perhaps, to show the reader that it is possible to put forward a view of Christ's life which would be in strict accord with the most modern psychic knowledge, and which, far from supplanting Christianity, would show the surprising accuracy of some of the details handed down to us, and would support the novel conclusion that those very miracles, which have been the stumbling block to so many truthful, earnest minds, may finally offer some very cogent arguments for the truth of the whole narrative. Is this then a line of thought which merits the wholesale condemnations and anathemas hurled at it by those who profess to speak in the name of religion? At the same time, though we bring support to the New Testament, it would, indeed, be a misconception if these, or any such remarks, were quoted as sustaining its literal accuracy—an idea from which so much harm has come in the past. It would, indeed, be a good, though an unattainable thing, that a really honest and open-minded attempt should be made to weed out from that record the obvious forgeries and interpolations which disfigure it, and lessen the value of those parts which are really above suspicion.
Perhaps enough has been said to show that we can view Christ's life in strict agreement with the latest psychic knowledge. Far from replacing Christianity, this view would reveal the surprising accuracy of some details handed down to us. It would also support a new conclusion about the miracles. These miracles have been a stumbling block for many honest, earnest people. Yet they may ultimately provide very convincing arguments for the truth of the whole account. Does this line of thought deserve the sweeping condemnations and curses hurled at it by those who claim to speak for religion? At the same time, although we support the New Testament, it would be wrong to quote these remarks, or any like them, as evidence that it is literally accurate. That belief has caused much harm in the past. It would be good, though impossible, for someone to make a truly honest and open-minded attempt to remove the obvious forgeries and later additions from the record. These spoil it and reduce the value of those parts that are truly beyond suspicion.
Is it necessary, for example, to be told, as an inspired fact from Christ's own lips, that Zacharias, the son of Barachias, was struck dead within the precincts of the Temple in the time of Christ, when, by a curious chance, Josephus has independently narrated the incident as having occurred during the siege of Jerusalem, thirty-seven years later? This makes it very clear that this particular Gospel, in its present form, was written after that event, and that the writer fitted into it at least one other incident which had struck his imagination. Unfortunately, a revision by general agreement would be the greatest of all miracles, for two of the very first texts to go would be those which refer to the "Church," an institution and an idea utterly unfamiliar in the days of Christ. Since the object of the insertion of these texts is perfectly clear, there can be no doubt that they are forgeries, but as the whole system of the Papacy rests upon one of them, they are likely to survive for a long time to come. The text alluded to is made further impossible because it is based upon the supposition that Christ and His fishermen conversed together in Latin or Greek, even to the extent of making puns in that language. Surely the want of moral courage and intellectual honesty among Christians will seem as strange to our descendants as it appears marvellous to us that the great thinkers of old could have believed, or at least have pretended to believe, in the fighting sexual deities of Mount Olympus.
Must we, for example, accept a claim as inspired fact from Christ's own lips? He says that Zacharias, the son of Barachias, was struck dead within the Temple grounds in Christ's time. Yet, by a curious chance, Josephus independently reported the incident as occurring during the siege of Jerusalem, thirty-seven years later. This makes it very clear that this Gospel, in its present form, was written after that event. It also shows that the writer added at least one other incident that had captured his imagination. Unfortunately, a revision by general agreement would be the greatest miracle of all. Two of the first passages to go would be those referring to the "Church". Both the institution and the idea were completely unfamiliar in Christ's day. The purpose of inserting these passages is perfectly clear, so there can be no doubt that they are forgeries. But the whole system of the Papacy rests on one of them, so they are likely to survive for a long time. The passage in question is even more impossible because it assumes that Christ and his fishermen spoke together in Latin or Greek. It even assumes they made puns in that language. Surely our descendants will find Christians' lack of moral courage and intellectual honesty just as strange as we find it astonishing that the great thinkers of old could have believed, or at least pretended to believe, in the fighting sexual deities of Mount Olympus.
The references are to Matthew, xxiii 35, and Josephus, Wars of the Jews, Book IV, Chapter 5.
Revision is, indeed, needed, and as I have already pleaded, a change of emphasis is also needed, in order to get the grand Christian conception back into the current of reason and progress. The orthodox who, whether from humble faith or some other cause, do not look deeply into such matters, can hardly conceive the stumbling-blocks which are littered about before the feet of their more critical brethren. What is easy, for faith is impossible for reflection. Such expressions as "Saved by the blood of the Lamb" or "Baptised by His precious blood" fill their souls with a gentle and sweet emotion, while upon a more thoughtful mind they have a very different effect.
Revision is indeed needed. As I have already argued, a change of emphasis is also needed. Both are needed to bring the grand Christian vision back in line with reason and progress. Orthodox believers may not look deeply into such matters, whether from humble faith or some other cause. They can hardly imagine the obstacles that confront their more critical fellow believers. What is easy for faith is impossible for reflection. Expressions such as "Saved by the blood of the Lamb" or "Baptised by His precious blood" fill their souls with a gentle, sweet emotion. Yet these expressions have a very different effect on a more thoughtful mind.
Apart from the apparent injustice of vicarious atonement, the student is well aware that the whole of this sanguinary metaphor is drawn really from the Pagan rites of Mithra, where the neophyte was actually placed under a bull at the ceremony of the TAUROBOLIUM, and was drenched, through a grating, with the blood of the slaughtered animal. Such reminiscences of the more brutal side of Paganism are not helpful to the thoughtful and sensitive modern mind. But what is always fresh and always useful and always beautiful, is the memory of the sweet Spirit who wandered on the hillsides of Galilee; who gathered the children around him; who met his friends in innocent good-fellowship; who shrank from forms and ceremonies, craving always for the inner meaning; who forgave the sinner; who championed the poor, and who in every decision threw his weight upon the side of charity and breadth of view. When to this character you add those wondrous psychic powers already analysed, you do, indeed, find a supreme character in the world's history who obviously stands nearer to the Highest than any other. When one compares the general effect of His teaching with that of the more rigid churches, one marvels how in their dogmatism, their insistence upon forms, their exclusiveness, their pomp and their intolerance, they could have got so far away from the example of their Master, so that as one looks upon Him and them, one feels that there is absolute deep antagonism and that one cannot speak of the Church and Christ, but only of the Church or Christ.
Apart from the apparent injustice of vicarious atonement, students know where this whole bloody metaphor really comes from. It comes from the Pagan rites of Mithra. In the ceremony of the TAUROBOLIUM, a new initiate was placed under a bull. The animal was slaughtered, and its blood drenched the initiate through a grating. Such reminders of the more brutal side of Paganism are not helpful to thoughtful and sensitive modern minds. But the memory of the gentle Spirit who wandered the hillsides of Galilee is always fresh, useful, and beautiful. He gathered children around him and met his friends in innocent fellowship. He avoided forms and ceremonies, always seeking the inner meaning. He forgave sinners and championed the poor. In every decision, he stood for charity and open-mindedness. Add to this character the wonderful psychic powers already examined, and you find a supreme figure in world history. He obviously stands nearer to the Highest than anyone else. Compare the overall effect of his teaching with that of the more rigid churches. One marvels at how far they have strayed from their Master's example. They are dogmatic and insist on forms. They are exclusive, pompous, and intolerant. Looking at him and at them, one feels a deep and absolute antagonism. One cannot speak of the Church and Christ, but only of the Church or Christ.
And yet every Church produces beautiful souls, though it may be debated whether "produces" or "contains" is the truthful word. We have but to fall back upon our own personal experience if we have lived long and mixed much with our fellow-men. I have myself lived during the seven most impressionable years of my life among Jesuits, the most maligned of all ecclesiastical orders, and I have found them honourable and good men, in all ways estimable outside the narrowness which limits the world to Mother Church. They were athletes, scholars, and gentlemen, nor can I ever remember any examples of that casuistry with which they are reproached. Some of my best friends have been among the parochial clergy of the Church of England, men of sweet and saintly character, whose pecuniary straits were often a scandal and a reproach to the half-hearted folk who accepted their spiritual guidance. I have known, also, splendid men among the Nonconformist clergy, who have often been the champions of liberty, though their views upon that subject have sometimes seemed to contract when one ventured upon their own domain of thought. Each creed has brought out men who were an honour to the human race, and Manning or Shrewsbury, Gordon or Dolling, Booth or Stopford Brooke, are all equally admirable, however diverse the roots from which they grow. Among the great mass of the people, too, there are very many thousands of beautiful souls who have been brought up on the old-fashioned lines, and who never heard of spiritual communion or any other of those matters which have been discussed in these essays, and yet have reached a condition of pure spirituality such as all of us may envy. Who does not know the maiden aunt, the widowed mother, the mellowed elderly man, who live upon the hilltops of unselfishness, shedding kindly thoughts and deeds around them, but with their simple faith deeply, rooted in anything or everything which has come to them in a hereditary fashion with the sanction of some particular authority? I had an aunt who was such an one, and can see her now, worn with austerity and charity, a small, humble figure, creeping to church at all hours from a house which was to her but a waiting-room between services, while she looked at me with sad, wondering, grey eyes. Such people have often reached by instinct, and in spite of dogma, heights, to which no system of philosophy can ever raise us.
And yet every Church produces beautiful souls, though one might debate whether "produces" or "contains" is the right word. If we have lived long and known many people, we need only look to our own experience. I spent the seven most impressionable years of my life among Jesuits, the most maligned of all religious orders. I found them honorable and good men, admirable in every way except for their narrow belief that the world revolved around Mother Church. They were athletes, scholars, and gentlemen. I cannot remember any examples of the deceptive reasoning they are accused of. Some of my best friends have been parish clergy in the Church of England. They were gentle, saintly men. Their financial hardships were often a scandal and a reproach to the half-hearted people who accepted their spiritual guidance. I have also known splendid men among the Nonconformist clergy. They have often been champions of liberty, though their views sometimes seemed to narrow when one ventured into their own realm of thought. Every creed has produced men who were an honor to the human race. Manning or Shrewsbury, Gordon or Dolling, Booth or Stopford Brooke are all equally admirable, however different the roots from which they grew. Among ordinary people, too, there are many thousands of beautiful souls raised in the old-fashioned way. They have never heard of spiritual communion or any of the other matters discussed in these essays. Yet they have reached a state of pure spirituality that all of us might envy. Who does not know the unmarried aunt, the widowed mother, or the kindly old man who lives on the heights of unselfishness? They spread kind thoughts and deeds around them. Yet their simple faith is deeply rooted in whatever beliefs they have inherited and accepted on the authority of a particular institution. I had an aunt who was one of them. I can see her now, a small, humble figure, worn down by self-denial and charity. She would make her way to church at all hours from a house that was merely a waiting room between services. She looked at me with sad, wondering gray eyes. Such people have often reached heights by instinct and in spite of dogma. No system of philosophy can ever raise us to those heights.
But making full allowance for the high products of every creed, which may be only, a proof of the innate goodness of civilised humanity, it is still beyond all doubt that Christianity has broken down, and that this breakdown has been brought home to everyone by the terrible catastrophe which has befallen the world. Can the most optimistic apologist contend that this is a satisfactory, outcome from a religion which has had the unopposed run of Europe for so many centuries? Which has come out of it worst, the Lutheran Prussian, the Catholic Bavarian, or the peoples who have been nurtured by the Greek Church? If we, of the West, have done better, is it not rather an older and higher civilisation and freer political institutions that have held us back from all the cruelties, excesses and immoralities which have taken the world back to the dark ages? It will not do to say that they have occurred in spite of Christianity, and that Christianity is, therefore, not to blame. It is true that Christ's teaching is not to blame, for it is often spoiled in the transmission. But Christianity has taken over control of the morals of Europe, and should have the compelling force which would ensure that those morals would not go to pieces upon the first strain. It is on this point that Christianity must be judged, and the judgment can only be that it has failed. It has not been an active controlling force upon the minds of men. And why? It can only be because there is something essential which is wanting. Men do not take it seriously. Men do not believe in it. Lip service is the only service in innumerable cases, and even lip service grows fainter.
Even allowing for the finest achievements of every faith, Christianity has undoubtedly failed. Those achievements may only prove the innate goodness of civilized humanity. The terrible catastrophe that has struck the world has brought Christianity's failure home to everyone. Could even the most optimistic defender claim this is a satisfactory outcome for Christianity? It has had a free hand in Europe, unopposed, for so many centuries. Who has come out of it worst: the Lutheran Prussian, the Catholic Bavarian, or the peoples raised by the Greek Church? If we in the West have done better, is it not because of our older and higher civilization and freer political institutions? Have these not held us back from all the cruelties, excesses, and immoralities that have taken the world back to the dark ages? It is not enough to say these things happened despite Christianity, and that Christianity is therefore not to blame. Christ's teaching is indeed not to blame, because it is often spoiled as it is passed on. But Christianity has taken control of Europe's morals. It should have enough force to ensure that those morals do not fall apart under the first strain. This is the test by which Christianity must be judged, and the only possible judgment is that it has failed. It has not been an active force governing men's minds. And why? It can only be because something essential is missing. Men do not take Christianity seriously. They do not believe in it. In countless cases, they offer it nothing but lip service, and even that is growing fainter.
Men, as distinct from women, have, both in the higher and lower classes of life, ceased, in the greater number of cases, to show a living interest in religion. The churches lose their grip upon the people—and lose it rapidly. Small inner circles, convocations, committees, assemblies, meet and debate and pass resolutions of an ever narrower character. But the people go their way and religion is dead, save in so far as intellectual culture and good taste can take its place. But when religion is dead, materialism becomes active, and what active materialism may produce has been seen in Germany.
Unlike women, most men in both the upper and lower classes no longer take a real interest in religion. The churches are rapidly losing their hold on the people. Small inner circles, church councils, committees, and assemblies meet, debate, and pass increasingly narrow resolutions. But the people go their own way, and religion is dead, except where intellectual culture and good taste can replace it. But when religion is dead, materialism becomes active. What active materialism may produce has been seen in Germany.
Is it not time, then, for the religious bodies to discourage their own bigots and sectarians, and to seriously consider, if only for self-preservation, how they can get into line once more with that general level of human thought which is now so far in front of them? I say that they can do more than get level—they can lead. But to do so they must, on the one hand, have the firm courage to cut away from their own bodies all that dead tissue which is but a disfigurement and an encumbrance. They must face difficulties of reason, and adapt themselves to the demands of the human intelligence which rejects, and is right in rejecting, much which they offer. Finally, they must gather fresh strength by drawing in all the new truth and all the new power which are afforded by this new wave of inspiration which has been sent into the world by God, and which the human race, deluded and bemused by the would-be clever, has received with such perverse and obstinate incredulity. When they have done all this, they will find not only that they are leading the world with an obvious right to the leadership, but, in addition, that they have come round once more to the very teaching of that Master whom they have so long misrepresented.
Isn't it time, then, for religious organizations to discourage the bigots and sectarians among them? Shouldn't they seriously consider how to catch up with the general level of human thought? They should do this if only to protect themselves, since human thought is now so far ahead of them. I say they can do more than catch up. They can lead. But to do that, they must have the courage to cut away all the dead tissue from their own bodies. It only disfigures them and weighs them down. They must face challenges to reason and adapt to the demands of human intelligence. Human intelligence rejects much of what they offer, and rightly so. Finally, they must gain fresh strength by drawing in all the new truth and power offered by a new wave of inspiration. God has sent this inspiration into the world. But the human race, misled and confused by those who claim to be clever, has received it with perverse and stubborn disbelief. Once religious organizations have done all this, they will find that they are leading the world and clearly deserve to lead. They will also find that they have returned to the very teaching of the Master they have misrepresented for so long.