Chapter 3

The Great Argument

28 min

The physical basis of all psychic belief is that the soul is a complete duplicate of the body, resembling it in the smallest particular, although constructed in some far more tenuous material. In ordinary conditions these two bodies are intermingled so that the identity of the finer one is entirely obscured. At death, however, and under certain conditions in the course of life, the two divide and can be seen separately. Death differs from the conditions of separation before death in that there is a complete break between the two bodies, and life is carried on entirely by the lighter of the two, while the heavier, like a cocoon from which the living occupant has escaped, degenerates and disappears, the world burying the cocoon with much solemnity by taking little pains to ascertain what has become of its nobler contents. It is a vain thing to urge that science has not admitted this contention, and that the statement is pure dogmatism. The science which has not examined the facts has, it is true, not admitted the contention, but its opinion is manifestly worthless, or at the best of less weight than that of the humblest student of psychic phenomena. The real science which has examined the facts is the only valid authority, and it is practically unanimous. I have made personal appeals to at least one great leader of science to examine the facts, however superficially, without any success, while Sir William Crookes appealed to Sir George Stokes, the Secretary of the Royal Society, one of the most bitter opponents of the movement, to come down to his laboratory and see the psychic force at work, but he took no notice. What weight has science of that sort? It can only be compared to that theological prejudice which caused the Ecclesiastics in the days of Galileo to refuse to look through the telescope which he held out to them.

The physical basis of all psychic belief is that the soul is an exact duplicate of the body. It resembles the body in every smallest detail, though it is made of a much finer material. Normally, the two bodies are intermingled, so the identity of the finer body is completely hidden. At death, however, and under certain conditions during life, they separate and can be seen individually. Death differs from separation during life because the two bodies break apart completely. Life continues entirely in the lighter body, while the heavier one decays and disappears. It is like a cocoon from which the living occupant has escaped. The world buries the cocoon with great solemnity, but takes little trouble to discover what has become of its nobler contents. It is pointless to argue that science has not accepted this claim and that the statement is pure dogmatism. Science that has not examined the facts has indeed not accepted the claim. But its opinion is clearly worthless, or at best carries less weight than that of the humblest student of psychic phenomena. The real science that has examined the facts is the only valid authority, and it is practically unanimous. I have personally appealed to at least one great leader of science to examine the facts, however superficially, without success. Sir William Crookes also appealed to Sir George Stokes, the Secretary of the Royal Society, to visit his laboratory. Stokes was one of the movement's most bitter opponents. Crookes invited him to see psychic force at work, but he took no notice. What weight does that sort of science have? It can only be compared to the theological prejudice of the ecclesiastics in Galileo's day. They refused to look through the telescope he offered them.

It is possible to write down the names of fifty professors in great seats of learning who have examined and endorsed these facts, and the list would include many of the greatest intellects which the world has produced in our time—Flammarion and Lombroso, Charles Richet and Russel Wallace, Willie Reichel, Myers, Zollner, James, Lodge, and Crookes. Therefore the facts HAVE been endorsed by the only science that has the right to express an opinion. I have never, in my thirty years of experience, known one single scientific man who went thoroughly into this matter and did not end by accepting the Spiritual solution. Such may exist, but I repeat that I have never heard of him. Let us, then, with confidence examine this matter of the "spiritual body," to use the term made classical by Saint Paul. There are many signs in his writings that Paul was deeply versed in psychic matters, and one of these is his exact definition of the natural and spiritual bodies in the service which is the final farewell to life of every Christian. Paul picked his words, and if he had meant that man consisted of a natural body and a spirit he would have said so. When he said "a spiritual body" he meant a body which contained the spirit and yet was distinct from the ordinary natural body. That is exactly what psychic science has now shown to be true.

It is possible to name fifty professors at major universities who have examined and endorsed these facts. The list would include many of the greatest minds the world has produced in our time: Flammarion and Lombroso, Charles Richet and Russel Wallace, Willie Reichel, Myers, Zollner, James, Lodge, and Crookes. Therefore, the facts HAVE been endorsed by the only science with the right to express an opinion. In thirty years of experience, I have never known a single scientist who thoroughly investigated this matter without eventually accepting the Spiritual explanation. Such a person may exist, but I repeat that I have never heard of him. Let us, then, confidently examine the "spiritual body," to use the term made famous by Saint Paul. Many signs in his writings show that Paul knew a great deal about psychic matters. One is his precise definition of the natural and spiritual bodies in the service that bids every Christian a final farewell to life. Paul chose his words carefully. If he had meant that a person consisted of a natural body and a spirit, he would have said so. When he said "a spiritual body" he meant a body that contained the spirit but was distinct from the ordinary natural body. That is exactly what psychic science has now shown to be true.

When a man has taken hashish or certain other drugs, he not infrequently has the experience that he is standing or floating beside his own body, which he can see stretched senseless upon the couch. So also under anaesthetics, particularly under laughing gas, many people are conscious of a detachment from their bodies, and of experiences at a distance. I have myself seen very clearly my wife and children inside a cab while I was senseless in the dentist's chair. Again, when a man is fainting or dying, and his system in an unstable condition, it is asserted in very many definite instances that he can, and does, manifest himself to others at a distance. These phantasms of the living, which have been so carefully explored and docketed by Messrs. Myers and Gurney, ran into hundreds of cases. Some people claim that by an effort of will they can, after going to sleep, propel their own doubles in the direction which they desire, and visit those whom they wish to see. Thus there is a great volume of evidence—how great no man can say who has not spent diligent years in exploring it—which vouches for the existence of this finer body containing the precious jewels of the mind and spirit, and leaving only gross confused animal functions in its heavier companion.

When a man takes hashish or certain other drugs, he often feels that he is standing or floating beside his own body. He can see his body lying unconscious on the couch. Similarly, under anesthetics, especially laughing gas, many people feel detached from their bodies and have experiences at a distance. I have myself seen my wife and children very clearly inside a cab while I was unconscious in the dentist's chair. Again, when a man is fainting or dying and his body is in an unstable condition, many specific cases suggest that he can appear to others at a distance, and does so. Myers and Gurney carefully investigated and recorded hundreds of cases of these apparitions of living people. Some people claim that, by an effort of will after falling asleep, they can send their own doubles wherever they choose and visit those they wish to see. Thus, there is a great deal of evidence for the existence of this finer body. No one who has not spent years carefully examining the evidence can say how much there is. It suggests that this finer body contains the precious jewels of the mind and spirit, leaving only crude, confused animal functions in its heavier companion.

Mr. Funk, who is a critical student of psychic phenomena, and also the joint compiler of the standard American dictionary, narrates a story in point which could be matched from other sources. He tells of an American doctor of his acquaintance, and he vouches personally for the truth of the incident. This doctor, in the course of a cataleptic seizure in Florida, was aware that he had left his body, which he saw lying beside him. He had none the less preserved his figure and his identity. The thought of some friend at a distance came into his mind, and after an appreciable interval he found himself in that friend's room, half way across the continent. He saw his friend, and was conscious that his friend saw him. He afterwards returned to his own room, stood beside his own senseless body, argued within himself whether he should re-occupy it or not, and finally, duty overcoming inclination, he merged his two frames together and continued his life. A letter from him to his friend explaining matters crossed a letter from the friend, in which he told how he also had been aware of his presence. The incident is narrated in detail in Mr. Funk's "Psychic Riddle."

Mr. Funk is a critical student of psychic phenomena and a joint compiler of the standard American dictionary. He tells a relevant story that could be matched by accounts from other sources. It concerns an American doctor he knew, and he personally vouches for its truth. During a cataleptic seizure in Florida, the doctor became aware that he had left his body. He saw it lying beside him, yet he still had his form and identity. He thought of a friend who lived far away. After a noticeable interval, he found himself in that friend's room, halfway across the continent. He saw his friend and knew that his friend saw him. He then returned to his own room and stood beside his unconscious body. He debated whether to reenter it. In the end, duty overcame inclination, and he merged his two forms and continued his life. He wrote to his friend to explain what had happened. His letter crossed one from the friend, who also described being aware of the doctor's presence. The incident is described in detail in Mr. Funk's "Psychic Riddle."

I do not understand how any man can examine the many instances coming from various angles of approach without recognising that there really is a second body of this sort, which incidentally goes far to account for all stories, sacred or profane, of ghosts, apparitions and visions. Now, what is this second body, and how does it fit into modern religious revelation?

I do not understand how anyone can examine the many examples from different angles without recognizing that a second body like this really exists. This second body also goes a long way toward explaining all stories of ghosts, apparitions, and visions, whether sacred or secular. Now, what is this second body, and how does it fit into modern religious revelation?

What it is, is a difficult question, and yet when science and imagination unite, as Tyndall said they should unite, to throw a searchlight into the unknown, they may produce a beam sufficient to outline vaguely what will become clearer with the future advance of our race. Science has demonstrated that while ether pervades everything the ether which is actually in a body is different from the ether outside it. "Bound" ether is the name given to this, which Fresnel and others have shown to be denser. Now, if this fact be applied to the human body, the result would be that, if all that is visible of that body were removed, there would still remain a complete and absolute mould of the body, formed in bound ether which would be different from the ether around it. This argument is more solid than mere speculation, and it shows that even the soul may come to be defined in terms of matter and is not altogether "such stuff as dreams are made of."

What it is remains a difficult question. Yet Tyndall said that science and imagination should work together to shine a searchlight into the unknown. Together, they may produce a beam strong enough to outline vaguely what will become clearer as our race advances. Science has shown that ether pervades everything, but the ether inside a body differs from the ether outside it. This is called "bound" ether, and Fresnel and others have shown that it is denser. Now, consider how this applies to the human body. If everything visible were removed from the body, a complete and exact mould of it would remain. The mould would be formed of bound ether, which would differ from the ether around it. This argument is more solid than mere speculation. It shows that even the soul may one day be defined in terms of matter. The soul is not entirely "such stuff as dreams are made of."

It has been shown that there is some good evidence for the existence of this second body apart from psychic religion, but to those who have examined that religion it is the centre of the whole system, sufficiently real to be recognised by clairvoyants, to be heard by clairaudients, and even to make an exact impression upon a photographic plate. Of the latter phenomenon, of which I have had some very particular opportunities of judging, I have no more doubt than I have of the ordinary photography of commerce. It had already been shown by the astronomers that the sensitized plate is a more delicate recording instrument than the human retina, and that it can show stars upon a long exposure which the eye has never seen. It would appear that the spirit world is really so near to us that a very little extra help under correct conditions of mediumship will make all the difference. Thus the plate, instead of the eye, may bring the loved face within the range of vision, while the trumpet, acting as a megaphone, may bring back the familiar voice where the spirit whisper with no mechanical aid was still inaudible. So loud may the latter phenomenon be that in one case, of which I have the record, the dead man's dog was so excited at hearing once more his master's voice that he broke his chain, and deeply scarred the outside of the seance room door in his efforts to force an entrance.

There is some good evidence for the existence of this second body outside psychic religion. But for those who have examined that religion, the second body is at the centre of the whole system. It is real enough to be seen by clairvoyants, heard by clairaudients, and even captured precisely on a photographic plate. I have had some very good opportunities to judge this last phenomenon. I have no more doubt about it than I do about ordinary commercial photography. Astronomers had already shown that the sensitized plate is a more sensitive recording instrument than the human retina. With a long exposure, it can reveal stars the eye has never seen. It seems that the spirit world is really so close to us that a little extra help can make all the difference, under the right conditions of mediumship. Thus, a photographic plate may bring a loved face into view where the eye cannot see it. A trumpet, acting as a megaphone, may bring back a familiar voice when a spirit's unaided whisper is still inaudible. The voice can be very loud. In one case I have a record of, a dead man's dog heard his master's voice once more. The dog was so excited that he broke his chain. He deeply scarred the outside of the séance room door as he tried to force his way in.

Now, having said so much of the spirit body, and having indicated that its presence is not vouched for by only one line of evidence or school of thought, let us turn to what happens at the time of death, according to the observation of clairvoyants on this side and the posthumous accounts of the dead upon the other. It is exactly what we should expect to happen, granted the double identity. In a painless and natural process the lighter disengages itself from the heavier, and slowly draws itself off until it stands with the same mind, the same emotions, and an exactly similar body, beside the couch of death, aware of those around and yet unable to make them aware of it, save where that finer spiritual eyesight called clairvoyance exists. How, we may well ask, can it see without the natural organs? How did the hashish victim see his own unconscious body? How did the Florida doctor see his friend? There is a power of perception in the spiritual body which does give the power. We can say no more. To the clairvoyant the new spirit seems like a filmy outline. To the ordinary man it is invisible. To another spirit it would, no doubt, seem as normal and substantial as we appear to each other. There is some evidence that it refines with time, and is therefore nearer to the material at the moment of death or closely after it, than after a lapse of months or years. Hence, it is that apparitions of the dead are most clear and most common about the time of death, and hence also, no doubt, the fact that the cataleptic physician already quoted was seen and recognised by his friend. The meshes of his ether, if the phrase be permitted, were still heavy with the matter from which they had only just been disentangled.

Having said this much about the spirit body, I have shown that more than one line of evidence or school of thought supports its existence. Let us now turn to what happens at death. We have the observations of clairvoyants on this side and the accounts of the dead on the other. If we accept the double identity, the process is exactly what we would expect. The lighter body separates painlessly and naturally from the heavier one. It slowly withdraws until it stands beside the deathbed, with the same mind, the same emotions, and an identical body. It is aware of those around it, but cannot make them aware of it. Only those with the finer spiritual eyesight called clairvoyance can see it. We may well ask how it can see without natural organs. How did the hashish victim see his own unconscious body? How did the Florida doctor see his friend? The spiritual body has a power of perception that allows it to see. We can say no more. To a clairvoyant, the new spirit looks like a thin, misty outline. To an ordinary person, it is invisible. To another spirit, it would no doubt seem as normal and solid as we appear to each other. There is some evidence that the spirit body becomes more refined over time. It is therefore closer to material substance at or shortly after death than it is months or years later. This explains why apparitions of the dead are clearest and most common around the time of death. It also no doubt explains why the friend of the cataleptic physician mentioned earlier saw and recognized him. If I may use the phrase, the meshes of his ether were still heavy with the matter from which they had only just come free.

Having disengaged itself from grosser matter, what happens to this spirit body, the precious bark which bears our all in all upon this voyage into unknown seas? Very many accounts have come back to us, verbal and written, detailing the experiences of those who have passed on. The verbal are by trance mediums, whose utterances appear to be controlled by outside intelligences. The written from automatic writers whose script is produced in the same way. At these words the critic naturally and reasonably shies, with a "What nonsense! How can you control the statement of this medium who is consciously or unconsciously pretending to inspiration?" This is a healthy scepticism, and should animate every experimenter who tests a new medium. The proofs must lie in the communication itself. If they are not present, then, as always, we must accept natural rather than unknown explanations. But they are continually present, and in such obvious forms that no one can deny them. There is a certain professional medium to whom I have sent many, mothers who were in need of consolation. I always ask the applicants to report the result to me, and I have their letters of surprise and gratitude before me as I write. "Thank you for this beautiful and interesting experience. She did not make a single mistake about their names, and everything she said was correct." In this case there was a rift between husband and wife before death, but the medium was able, unaided, to explain and clear up the whole matter, mentioning the correct circumstances, and names of everyone concerned, and showing the reasons for the non-arrival of certain letters, which had been the cause of the misunderstanding. The next case was also one of husband and wife, but it is the husband who is the survivor. He says: "It was a most successful sitting. Among other things, I addressed a remark in Danish to my wife (who is a Danish girl), and the answer came back in English without the least hesitation." The next case was again of a man who had lost a very dear male friend. "I have had the most wonderful results with Mrs. —— to-day. I cannot tell you the joy it has been to me. Many grateful thanks for your help." The next one says: "Mrs. —— was simply wonderful. If only more people knew, what agony they would be spared." In this case the wife got in touch with the husband, and the medium mentioned correctly five dead relatives who were in his company. The next is a case of mother and son. "I saw Mrs. —— to-day, and obtained very wonderful results. She told me nearly everything quite correctly—a very few mistakes." The next is similar. "We were quite successful. My boy even reminded me of something that only he and I knew." Says another: "My boy reminded me of the day when he sowed turnip seed upon the lawn. Only he could have known of this." These are fair samples of the letters, of which I hold a large number. They are from people who present themselves from among the millions living in London, or the provinces, and about whose affairs the medium had no possible normal way of knowing. Of all the very numerous cases which I have sent to this medium I have only had a few which have been complete failures. On quoting my results to Sir Oliver Lodge, he remarked that his own experience with another medium had been almost identical. It is no exaggeration to say that our British telephone systems would probably give a larger proportion of useless calls. How is any critic to get beyond these facts save by ignoring or misrepresenting them? Healthy, scepticism is the basis of all accurate observation, but there comes a time when incredulity means either culpable ignorance or else imbecility, and this time has been long past in the matter of spirit intercourse.

Once it has freed itself from coarser matter, what happens to the spirit body? It is the precious vessel that carries our all in all on this voyage into unknown seas. Many accounts have come back to us, spoken and written, describing the experiences of those who have passed on. The spoken accounts come through trance mediums, whose words appear to be controlled by outside intelligences. The written accounts come from automatic writers, whose writing is produced in the same way. At this point, the critic naturally and reasonably recoils: "What nonsense! How can you verify what this medium says, when the medium is consciously or unconsciously pretending to be inspired?" This is healthy skepticism, and every experimenter testing a new medium should have it. The proof must lie in the communication itself. If it is not there, then, as always, we must accept natural explanations rather than unknown ones. But proof is continually present, and in such obvious forms that no one can deny it. There is a professional medium to whom I have sent many mothers in need of comfort. I always ask them to report the results to me. As I write, I have their letters of surprise and gratitude before me. "Thank you for this beautiful and interesting experience. She did not make a single mistake about their names, and everything she said was correct." In this case, a husband and wife had become estranged before death. But the medium was able to explain and clear up the whole matter without help. She gave the correct circumstances and the names of everyone involved. She also explained why certain letters had not arrived, causing the misunderstanding. The next case also involved a husband and wife, but the husband was the survivor. He says: "It was a most successful sitting. Among other things, I spoke to my wife in Danish (she is a Danish girl). The answer came back in English without the slightest hesitation." The next case involved a man who had lost a very dear male friend. "I had the most wonderful results with Mrs. —— today. I cannot tell you the joy it has brought me. Many grateful thanks for your help." The next person says: "Mrs. —— was simply wonderful. If only more people knew, they would be spared so much agony." In this case, the wife got in touch with her husband. The medium correctly named five dead relatives who were with him. The next case involves a mother and son. "I saw Mrs. —— today and got very wonderful results. She told me nearly everything quite correctly, with very few mistakes." The next is similar. "We were quite successful. My boy even reminded me of something that only he and I knew." Another says: "My boy reminded me of the day when he sowed turnip seed on the lawn. Only he could have known about this." These are representative samples of the many letters I have. They come from people who present themselves from among the millions living in London or elsewhere in the country. The medium could not possibly have known about their affairs by any normal means. Of all the many cases I have sent to this medium, only a few have been complete failures. When I told Sir Oliver Lodge my results, he said his experience with another medium had been almost identical. It is no exaggeration to say that our British telephone systems would probably produce a higher proportion of useless calls. How can any critic get around these facts except by ignoring or misrepresenting them? Healthy skepticism is the basis of all accurate observation. But there comes a time when disbelief means either culpable ignorance or imbecility. That time has long passed when it comes to communication with spirits.

In my own case, this medium mentioned correctly the first name of a lady who had died in our house, gave several very characteristic messages from her, described the only two dogs which we have ever kept, and ended by saying that a young officer was holding up a gold coin by which I would recognise him. I had lost my brother-in-law, an army doctor, in the war, and I had given him a spade guinea for his first fee, which he always wore on his chain. There were not more than two or three close relatives who knew about this incident, so that the test was a particularly good one. She made no incorrect statements, though some were vague. After I had revealed the identity of this medium several pressmen attempted to have test seances with her—a test seance being, in most cases, a seance which begins by breaking every psychic condition and making success most improbable. One of these gentlemen, Mr. Ulyss Rogers, had very fair results. Another sent from "Truth" had complete failure. It must be understood that these powers do not work from the medium, but through the medium, and that the forces in the beyond have not the least sympathy with a smart young pressman in search of clever copy, while they have a very different feeling to a bereaved mother who prays with all her broken heart that some assurance may be given her that the child of her love is not gone from her for ever. When this fact is mastered, and it is understood that "Stand and deliver" methods only excite gentle derision on the other side, we shall find some more intelligent manner of putting things of the spirit to the proof.

In my own case, this medium correctly gave the first name of a woman who had died in our house. She gave several very characteristic messages from her and described the only two dogs we have ever kept. She ended by saying that a young officer was holding up a gold coin by which I would recognize him. I had lost my brother-in-law, an army doctor, in the war. I had given him a spade guinea as his first fee, and he always wore it on his chain. No more than two or three close relatives knew about this incident, so it was a particularly good test. The medium made no incorrect statements, though some were vague. After I revealed the medium’s identity, several reporters tried to hold test séances with her. In most cases, a test séance begins by breaking every psychic condition and making success most improbable. One of these men, Mr. Ulyss Rogers, had quite good results. Another, sent from "Truth", had no success at all. It must be understood that these powers do not come from the medium, but work through her. The forces in the beyond have no sympathy at all for a clever young reporter looking for a good story. They feel very differently toward a grieving mother who prays with all her broken heart for reassurance. She wants to know that the child she loves is not gone from her forever. Once we grasp this fact, we can find a more intelligent way to test spiritual matters. We must also understand that "Stand and deliver" methods only provoke gentle amusement on the other side.

See Appendix D.

I have dwelt upon these results, which could be matched by other mediums, to show that we have solid and certain reasons to say that the verbal reports are not from the mediums themselves. Readers of Arthur Hill's "Psychical Investigations" will find many even more convincing cases. So in the written communications, I have in a previous paper pointed to the "Gate of Remembrance" case, but there is a great mass of material which proves that, in spite of mistakes and failures, there really is a channel of communication, fitful and evasive sometimes, but entirely beyond coincidence or fraud. These, then, are the usual means by which we receive psychic messages, though table tilting, ouija boards, glasses upon a smooth surface, or anything which can be moved by the vital animal-magnetic force already discussed will equally serve the purpose. Often information is conveyed orally or by writing which could not have been known to anyone concerned. Mr. Wilkinson has given details of the case where his dead son drew attention to the fact that a curio (a coin bent by a bullet) had been overlooked among his effects. Sir William Barrett has narrated how a young officer sent a message leaving a pearl tie-pin to a friend. No one knew that such a pin existed, but it was found among his things. The death of Sir Hugh Lane was given at a private seance in Dublin before the details of the Lusitania disaster had been published. On that morning we ourselves, in a small seance, got the message "It is terrible, terrible, and will greatly affect the war," at a time when we were convinced that no great loss of life could have occurred. Such examples are very numerous, and are only quoted here to show how impossible it is to invoke telepathy as the origin of such messages. There is only one explanation which covers the facts. They are what they say they are, messages from those who have passed on, from the spiritual body which was seen to rise from the deathbed, which has been so often photographed, which pervades all religion in every age, and which has been able, under proper circumstances, to materialise back into a temporary solidity so that it could walk and talk like a mortal, whether in Jerusalem two thousand years ago, or in the laboratory of Mr. Crookes, in Mornington Road, London.

I have discussed these results, which other mediums could match, to show that we have solid and certain reasons for saying that the verbal reports do not come from the mediums themselves. Readers of Arthur Hill's "Psychical Investigations" will find many even more convincing cases. As for written communications, I have pointed to the "Gate of Remembrance" case in a previous paper. But a great deal of material shows that, despite mistakes and failures, a channel of communication really exists. It is sometimes irregular and elusive, but it is entirely beyond coincidence or fraud. These are the usual means by which we receive psychic messages. But table tilting, ouija boards, glasses on a smooth surface, or anything moved by the vital animal-magnetic force already discussed will serve equally well. Often, information is conveyed orally or in writing that no one involved could have known. Mr. Wilkinson has described a case in which his dead son drew attention to a curio overlooked among his belongings. It was a coin bent by a bullet. Sir William Barrett has described how a young officer sent a message leaving a pearl tie-pin to a friend. No one knew such a pin existed, but it was found among his belongings. Sir Hugh Lane's death was reported at a private seance in Dublin before details of the Lusitania disaster had been published. That morning, we ourselves received the message "It is terrible, terrible, and will greatly affect the war" at a small seance. At the time, we were convinced that no great loss of life could have occurred. Such examples are very numerous. They are quoted here only to show how impossible it is to explain such messages as telepathy. There is only one explanation that covers the facts. They are what they say they are: messages from those who have passed on. They come from the spiritual body that was seen rising from the deathbed and has so often been photographed. This spiritual body is found throughout religion in every age. Under the right circumstances, it has been able to materialize in solid form temporarily, so that it could walk and talk like a mortal. It has done so whether in Jerusalem two thousand years ago or in Mr. Crookes's laboratory on Mornington Road, London.

Details of both these latter cases can be found in "Voices from the Void" by Mrs. Travers Smith. The book contains some carefully considered evidence.

Let us for a moment examine the facts in this Crookes' episode. A small book exists which describes them, though it is not as accessible as it should be. In these wonderful experiments, which extended over several years, Miss Florrie Cook, who was a young lady of from 16 to 18 years of age, was repeatedly confined in Prof. Crookes' study, the door being locked on the inside. Here she lay unconscious upon a couch. The spectators assembled in the laboratory, which was separated by a curtained opening from the study. After a short interval, through this opening there emerged a lady who was in all ways different from Miss Cook. She gave her earth name as Katie King, and she proclaimed herself to be a materialised spirit, whose mission it was to carry the knowledge of immortality to mortals.

Let us take a moment to examine the facts of this Crookes episode. A short book describes them, though it is not as easy to find as it should be. These wonderful experiments took place over several years. Miss Florrie Cook, a young woman between 16 and 18 years old, was repeatedly shut inside Prof. Crookes' study. The door was locked from the inside, and she lay unconscious on a couch. The spectators gathered in the laboratory, which was separated from the study by a curtained opening. After a short time, a woman emerged through the opening. She was different from Miss Cook in every way. She gave her earthly name as Katie King and declared that she was a materialized spirit. Her mission, she said, was to bring mortals the knowledge of immortality.

She was of great beauty of face, figure, and manner. She was four and a half inches taller than Miss Cook, fair, whereas the latter was dark, and as different from her as one woman could be from another. Her pulse rate was markedly slower. She became for the time entirely one of the company, walking about, addressing each person present, and taking delight in the children. She made no objection to photography or any other test. Forty-eight photographs of different degrees of excellence were made of her. She was seen at the same time as the medium on several occasions. Finally she departed, saying that her mission was over and that she had other work to do. When she vanished materialism should have vanished also, if mankind had taken adequate notice of the facts.

She was very beautiful in face, figure, and manner. She was four and a half inches taller than Miss Cook. She was fair, while Miss Cook was dark, and they were as different as two women could be. Her pulse was noticeably slower. For a time, she became completely one of the group. She walked around, spoke to everyone present, and delighted in the children. She did not object to being photographed or to any other test. Forty-eight photographs of her were taken, some better than others. On several occasions, she was seen at the same time as the medium. Finally, she left, saying that her mission was over and she had other work to do. When she vanished, materialism should have vanished too, if people had paid enough attention to the facts.

Now, what can the fair-minded inquirer say to such a story as that—one of many, but for the moment we are concentrating upon it? Was Mr. Crookes a blasphemous liar? But there were very many witnesses, as many sometimes as eight at a single sitting. And there are the photographs which include Miss Cook and show that the two women were quite different. Was he honestly mistaken? But that is inconceivable. Read the original narrative and see if you can find any solution save that it is true. If a man can read that sober, cautious statement and not be convinced, then assuredly his brain, is out of gear. Finally, ask yourself whether any religious manifestation in the world has had anything like the absolute proof which lies in this one. Cannot the orthodox see that instead of combating such a story, or talking nonsense about devils, they should hail that which is indeed the final answer to that materialism which is their really dangerous enemy. Even as I write, my eye falls upon a letter on my desk from an officer who had lost all faith in immortality and become an absolute materialist. "I came to dread my return home, for I cannot stand hypocrisy, and I knew well my attitude would cause some members of my family deep grief. Your book has now brought me untold comfort, and I can face the future cheerfully." Are these fruits from the Devil's tree, you timid orthodox critic?

Now, what can a fair-minded inquirer say about such a story? It is one of many, but for now we are focusing on this one. Was Mr. Crookes a blasphemous liar? But there were very many witnesses, sometimes as many as eight at a single sitting. And there are photographs that include Miss Cook and show that the two women were quite different. Was he honestly mistaken? But that is inconceivable. Read the original account and see whether you can find any explanation except that it is true. If someone can read that sober, cautious statement and not be convinced, then surely their brain is not working properly. Finally, ask yourself whether any religious manifestation in the world has had anything like the absolute proof supporting this one. Can the orthodox not see that they should welcome it? Instead, they oppose such a story or talk nonsense about devils. Yet this story is the final answer to materialism, their truly dangerous enemy. Even as I write, my eye falls on a letter on my desk from an officer. He had lost all faith in immortality and become a complete materialist. "I came to dread returning home, because I cannot stand hypocrisy. I knew my attitude would cause some members of my family deep grief. Your book has now brought me untold comfort, and I can face the future cheerfully." Are these fruits from the Devil's tree, you timid orthodox critic?

Having then got in touch with our dead, we proceed, naturally, to ask them how it is with them, and under what conditions they exist. It is a very vital question, since what has befallen them yesterday will surely befall us to-morrow. But the answer is tidings of great joy. Of the new vital message to humanity nothing is more important than that. It rolls away all those horrible man-bred fears and fancies, founded upon morbid imaginations and the wild phrases of the oriental. We come upon what is sane, what is moderate, what is reasonable, what is consistent with gradual evolution and with the benevolence of God. Were there ever any conscious blasphemers upon earth who have insulted the Deity so deeply as those extremists, be they Calvinist, Roman Catholic, Anglican, or Jew, who pictured with their distorted minds an implacable torturer as the Ruler of the Universe!

Once we have made contact with our dead, we naturally ask how they are and what conditions they live in. It is a vital question, because what happened to them yesterday will surely happen to us tomorrow. But the answer brings great joy. Nothing in the new vital message to humanity is more important than that. It sweeps away all those horrible fears and fantasies created by people. They are based on morbid imaginations and the wild language of Eastern peoples. Instead, we find what is sane, moderate, and reasonable. It is consistent with gradual evolution and the goodness of God. Have any people on earth ever knowingly blasphemed and insulted God more deeply than those extremists? Whether Calvinist, Roman Catholic, Anglican, or Jewish, their distorted minds imagined the Ruler of the Universe as a merciless torturer!

The truth of what is told us as to the life beyond can in its very nature never be absolutely established. It is far nearer to complete proof, however, than any religious revelation which has ever preceded it. We have the fact that these accounts are mixed up with others concerning our present life which are often absolutely true. If a spirit can tell the truth about our sphere, it is difficult to suppose that he is entirely false about his own. Then, again, there is a very great similarity about such accounts, though their origin may be from people very far apart. Thus though "non-veridical," to use the modern jargon, they do conform to all our canons of evidence. A series of books which have attracted far less attention than they deserve have drawn the coming life in very close detail. These books are not found on railway bookstalls or in popular libraries, but the successive editions through which they pass show that there is a deeper public which gets what it wants in spite of artificial obstacles.

By its very nature, the truth of what we are told about life after death can never be absolutely established. Still, it is much closer to complete proof than any earlier religious revelation. These accounts are mixed with others about our present life, and those are often absolutely true. If a spirit can tell the truth about our world, it is hard to suppose he is entirely wrong about his own. Also, such accounts are very similar, even when they come from people far apart. Thus, although they are "non-veridical", to use the modern jargon, they conform to all our standards of evidence. A series of books has described the life to come in great detail. These books have attracted far less attention than they deserve. They are not found at railway bookstalls or in popular libraries. But their successive editions show that a more discerning public gets what it wants despite artificial obstacles.

Looking over the list of my reading I find, besides nearly a dozen very interesting and detailed manuscript accounts, such published narratives as "Claude's Book," purporting to come from a young British aviator; "Thy Son Liveth," from an American soldier, "Private Dowding"; "Raymond," from a British soldier; "Do Thoughts Perish?" which contains accounts from several British soldiers and others; "I Heard a Voice," where a well-known K.C., through the mediumship of his two young daughters, has a very full revelation of the life beyond; "After Death," with the alleged experiences of the famous Miss Julia Ames; "The Seven Purposes," from an American pressman, and many others. They differ much in literary skill and are not all equally impressive, but the point which must strike any impartial mind is the general agreement of these various accounts as to the conditions of spirit life. An examination would show that some of them must have been in the press at the same time, so that they could not have each inspired the other. "Claude's Book" and "Thy Son Liveth" appeared at nearly the same time on different sides of the Atlantic, but they agree very closely. "Raymond" and "Do Thoughts Perish?" must also have been in the press together, but the scheme of things is exactly the same. Surely the agreement of witnesses must here, as in all cases, be accounted as a test of truth. They differ mainly, as it seems to me, when they deal with their own future including speculations as to reincarnation, etc., which may well be as foggy to them as it is to us, or systems of philosophy where again individual opinion is apparent.

Looking over my reading list, I find nearly a dozen very interesting and detailed manuscript accounts. I also find published narratives such as "Claude's Book," supposedly from a young British aviator. There is "Thy Son Liveth," from an American soldier, "Private Dowding," and "Raymond," from a British soldier. "Do Thoughts Perish?" contains accounts from several British soldiers and others. In "I Heard a Voice," a well-known K.C. receives a very full revelation of life beyond through his two young daughters as mediums. "After Death" gives the alleged experiences of the famous Miss Julia Ames. There is also "The Seven Purposes," from an American journalist, and many others. They vary greatly in literary skill, and they are not all equally impressive. But any impartial mind must be struck by their general agreement about the conditions of spirit life. A closer look would show that some must have been in print at the same time. They could not, therefore, all have inspired one another. "Claude's Book" and "Thy Son Liveth" appeared at nearly the same time on opposite sides of the Atlantic. Yet they agree very closely. "Raymond" and "Do Thoughts Perish?" must also have been in print together, but their picture of how things are is exactly the same. Surely the agreement of witnesses must be counted as a test of truth here, as in all cases. It seems to me that they differ mainly when they discuss their own future, including speculations about reincarnation and similar matters. These may well be as unclear to them as they are to us. They also differ on systems of philosophy, where individual opinion is again apparent.

Of all these accounts the one which is most deserving of study is "Raymond." This is so because it has been compiled from several famous mediums working independently of each other, and has been checked and chronicled by a man who is not only one of the foremost scientists of the world, and probably the leading intellectual force in Europe, but one who has also had a unique experience of the precautions necessary for the observation of psychic phenomena. The bright and sweet nature of the young soldier upon the other side, and his eagerness to tell of his experience is also a factor which will appeal to those who are already satisfied as to the truth of the communications. For all these reasons it is a most important document—indeed it would be no exaggeration to say that it is one of the most important in recent literature. It is, as I believe, an authentic account of the life in the beyond, and it is often more interesting from its sidelights and reservations than for its actual assertions, though the latter bear the stamp of absolute frankness and sincerity. The compilation is in some ways faulty. Sir Oliver has not always the art of writing so as to be understanded of the people, and his deeper and more weighty thoughts get in the way of the clear utterances of his son. Then again, in his anxiety to be absolutely accurate, Sir Oliver has reproduced the fact that sometimes Raymond is speaking direct, and sometimes the control is reporting what Raymond is saying, so that the same paragraph may turn several times from the first person to the third in a manner which must be utterly unintelligible to those who are not versed in the subject. Sir Oliver will, I am sure, not be offended if I say that, having satisfied his conscience by the present edition, he should now leave it for reference, and put forth a new one which should contain nothing but the words of Raymond and his spirit friends. Such a book, published at a low price, would, I think, have an amazing effect, and get all this new teaching to the spot that God has marked for it—the minds and hearts of the people.

Of all these accounts, "Raymond" is the one most deserving of study. It was compiled from accounts by several famous mediums who worked independently of one another. It was checked and recorded by a man who is one of the world's foremost scientists. He is probably also the leading intellectual force in Europe. He has unique experience of the precautions needed to observe psychic phenomena. The young soldier on the other side has a bright, sweet nature and is eager to share his experience. This will also appeal to those who are already satisfied that the communications are true. For all these reasons, the book is a most important document. Indeed, it would be no exaggeration to call it one of the most important works of recent literature. I believe it is an authentic account of life beyond death. Its hints and qualifications are often more interesting than its direct claims, though those claims bear the stamp of complete frankness and sincerity. The compilation is flawed in some ways. Sir Oliver does not always know how to write so that ordinary people can understand him. His deeper, weightier thoughts get in the way of his son's clear statements. Also, in his desire to be completely accurate, Sir Oliver has recorded changes in who is speaking. Sometimes Raymond speaks directly, and sometimes the control reports what Raymond is saying. As a result, a single paragraph may switch several times between the first and third person. This must be utterly confusing to anyone unfamiliar with the subject. I am sure Sir Oliver will not be offended by my suggestion. Having satisfied his conscience with the present edition, he should now keep it for reference. He should publish a new edition containing only the words of Raymond and his spirit friends. I think such a book, published at a low price, would have an amazing effect. It would bring all this new teaching to the place God has marked for it, the minds and hearts of the people.

So much has been said here about mediumship that perhaps it would be well to consider this curious condition a little more closely. The question of mediumship, what it is and how it acts, is one of the most mysterious in the whole range of science. It is a common objection to say if our dead are there why should we only hear of them through people by no means remarkable for moral or mental gifts, who are often paid for their ministration. It is a plausible argument, and yet when we receive a telegram from a brother in Australia we do not say: "It is strange that Tom should not communicate with me direct, but that the presence of that half-educated fellow in the telegraph office should be necessary." The medium is in truth a mere passive machine, clerk and telegraph in one. Nothing comes FROM him. Every message is THROUGH him. Why he or she should have the power more than anyone else is a very interesting problem. This power may best be defined as the capacity for allowing the bodily powers, physical or mental, to be used by an outside influence. In its higher forms there is temporary extinction of personality and the substitution of some other controlling spirit. At such times the medium may entirely lose consciousness, or he may retain it and be aware of some external experience which has been enjoyed by his own entity while his bodily house has been filled by the temporary tenant. Or the medium may retain consciousness, and with eyes and ears attuned to a higher key than the normal man can attain, he may see and hear what is beyond our senses. Or in writing mediumship, a motor centre of the brain regulating the nerves and muscles of the arm may be controlled while all else seems to be normal. Or it may take the more material form of the exudation of a strange white evanescent dough-like substance called the ectoplasm, which has been frequently photographed by scientific enquirers in different stages of its evolution, and which seems to possess an inherent quality of shaping itself into parts or the whole of a body, beginning in a putty-like mould and ending in a resemblance to perfect human members. Or the ectoplasm, which seems to be an emanation of the medium to the extent that whatever it may weigh is so much subtracted from his substance, may be used as projections or rods which can convey objects or lift weights. A friend, in whose judgment and veracity I have absolute confidence, was present at one of Dr. Crawford's experiments with Kathleen Goligher, who is, it may be remarked, an unpaid medium. My friend touched the column of force, and found it could be felt by the hand though invisible to the eye. It is clear that we are in touch with some entirely new form both of matter and of energy. We know little of the properties of this extraordinary substance save that in its materialising form it seems extremely sensitive to the action of light. A figure built up in it and detached from the medium dissolves in light quicker than a snow image under a tropical sun, so that two successive flash-light photographs would show the one a perfect figure, and the next an amorphous mass. When still attached to the medium the ectoplasm flies back with great force on exposure to light, and, in spite of the laughter of the scoffers, there is none the less good evidence that several mediums have been badly injured by the recoil after a light has suddenly been struck by some amateur detective. Professor Geley has, in his recent experiments, described the ectoplasm as appearing outside the black dress of his medium as if a hoar frost had descended upon her, then coalescing into a continuous sheet of white substance, and oozing down until it formed a sort of apron in front of her. This process he has illustrated by a very complete series of photographs.

So much has been said here about mediumship that perhaps we should look more closely at this curious condition. What mediumship is and how it works are among the greatest mysteries in all of science. People often raise an objection: if our dead are there, why do we hear from them only through certain people? These people are by no means remarkable for their moral or mental gifts, and they are often paid for their services. This is a plausible argument. Yet when we receive a telegram from a brother in Australia, we do not say: "It is strange that Tom cannot contact me directly, and that the presence of that half-educated fellow in the telegraph office should be necessary." In truth, the medium is merely a passive machine, a clerk and telegraph in one. Nothing comes FROM the medium. Every message comes THROUGH the medium. Why one person should have this power more than anyone else is a very interesting question. The power may best be defined as the ability to let an outside influence use one's physical or mental powers. In its higher forms, the medium's personality is temporarily replaced by another controlling spirit. At such times, the medium may lose consciousness entirely. Or the medium may remain conscious and be aware of an experience outside the body. His own being has enjoyed this experience while his bodily home has been occupied by a temporary tenant. The medium may also remain conscious, with eyes and ears tuned beyond the range of an ordinary person. He may then see and hear things beyond our senses. In writing mediumship, a motor center of the brain controlling the nerves and muscles of the arm may be controlled, while everything else seems normal. Mediumship may also take a more material form. A strange, white, fleeting, dough-like substance called ectoplasm may seep out of the medium. Scientific investigators have often photographed it at different stages of its development. It seems to have an innate ability to form parts of a body or a whole body. It begins as a putty-like mold and ends up resembling perfect human limbs and organs. Ectoplasm also seems to come from the medium in such a way that its weight is taken from his body. It may be used to form projections or rods that can move objects or lift weights. A friend of mine was present at one of Dr. Crawford's experiments with Kathleen Goligher. I have absolute confidence in my friend's judgment and truthfulness. It is worth noting that Kathleen Goligher is an unpaid medium. My friend touched the column of force and found that it could be felt by hand, though it was invisible. Clearly, we are dealing with an entirely new form of both matter and energy. We know little about the properties of this extraordinary substance, except that its materializing form seems extremely sensitive to light. A figure made from it and detached from the medium dissolves in light faster than a snow figure under a tropical sun. So two flash photographs taken in succession would show a perfect figure in the first and a shapeless mass in the second. When the ectoplasm is still attached to the medium, it flies back with great force when exposed to light. Scoffers may laugh, but there is still good evidence that several mediums have been badly injured by this recoil. In each case, an amateur detective had suddenly turned on a light. In his recent experiments, Professor Geley has described ectoplasm appearing on the outside of his medium's black dress. It looked as if frost had settled on her. Then it came together into a continuous sheet of white substance and oozed down, forming a kind of apron in front of her. He has illustrated this process with a very complete series of photographs.

For Geley's experiments, see Appendix A.

These are a few of the properties of mediumship. There are also the beautiful phenomena of the production of lights, and the rarer, but for evidential purposes even more valuable, manifestations of spirit photography. The fact that the photograph does not correspond in many cases with any which existed in life, must surely silence the scoffer, though there is a class of bigoted sceptic who would still be sneering if an Archangel alighted in Trafalgar Square. Mr. Hope and Mrs. Buxton, of Crewe, have brought this phase of mediumship to great perfection, though others have powers in that direction. Indeed, in some cases it is difficult to say who the medium may have been, for in one collective family group which was taken in the ordinary way, and was sent me by a master in a well known public school, the young son who died has appeared in the plate seated between his two little brothers.

These are a few of the properties of mediumship. There are also the beautiful phenomena of lights appearing, and the rarer manifestations of spirit photography. These are even more valuable as evidence. In many cases, the photograph does not match any photograph that existed during the person’s life. That fact should surely silence the scoffer. But some bigoted skeptics would still sneer if an Archangel landed in Trafalgar Square. Mr. Hope and Mrs. Buxton, of Crewe, have perfected this form of mediumship, though others also have such powers. Indeed, in some cases it is hard to say who the medium was. For example, a teacher at a well-known public school sent me a family group photograph taken in the ordinary way. In the photographic plate, his young son who had died appeared seated between his two little brothers.

As to the personality of mediums, they have seemed to me to be very average specimens of the community, neither markedly better nor markedly worse. I know many, and I have never met anything in the least like "Sludge," a poem which Browning might be excused for writing in some crisis of domestic disagreement, but which it was inexcusable to republish since it is admitted to be a concoction, and the exposure described to have been imaginary. The critic often uses the term medium as if it necessarily meant a professional, whereas every investigator has found some of his best results among amateurs. In the two finest seances I ever attended, the psychic, in each case a man of moderate means, was resolutely determined never directly or indirectly to profit by his gift, though it entailed very exhausting physical conditions. I have not heard of a clergyman of any denomination who has attained such a pitch of altruism—nor is it reasonable to expect it. As to professional mediums, Mr. Vout Peters, one of the most famous, is a diligent collector of old books and an authority upon the Elizabethan drama; while Mr. Dickinson, another very remarkable discerner of spirits, who named twenty-four correctly during two meetings held on the same day, is employed in loading canal barges. This man is one gifted clairvoyants in England, though Tom Tyrrell the weaver, Aaron Wilkinson, and others are very marvellous. Tyrrell, who is a man of the Anthony of Padua type, a walking saint, beloved of animals and children, is a figure who might have stepped out of some legend of the church. Thomas, the powerful physical medium, is a working coal miner. Most mediums take their responsibilities very seriously and view their work in a religious light. There is no denying that they are exposed to very particular temptations, for the gift is, as I have explained elsewhere, an intermittent one, and to admit its temporary absence, and so discourage one's clients, needs greater moral principle than all men possess. Another temptation to which several great mediums have succumbed is that of drink. This comes about in a very natural way, for overworking the power leaves them in a state of physical prostration, and the stimulus of alcohol affords a welcome relief, and may tend at last to become a custom and finally a curse. Alcoholism always weakens the moral sense, so that these degenerate mediums yield themselves more readily to fraud, with the result that several who had deservedly won honoured names and met all hostile criticism have, in their later years, been detected in the most contemptible tricks. It is a thousand pities that it should be so, but if the Court of Arches were to give up its secrets, it would be found that tippling and moral degeneration were by no means confined to psychics. At the same time, a psychic is so peculiarly sensitive that I think he or she would always be well advised to be a life long abstainer—as many actually are.

As for the personalities of mediums, they have seemed to me quite average, neither notably better nor notably worse than other people. I know many mediums, and I have never met anyone remotely like “Sludge.” Browning might be excused for writing that poem during some domestic quarrel. But republishing it was inexcusable, since it is admitted to be a fabrication and its account of an exposure imaginary. Critics often use the word medium as if it necessarily meant a professional. Yet every investigator has found some of their best results among amateurs. In the two finest séances I ever attended, each psychic was a man of moderate means. Both were determined never to profit from their gift, directly or indirectly, although using it left them physically exhausted. I have not heard of a clergyman of any denomination reaching such a level of selflessness, nor is it reasonable to expect it. Among professional mediums, Mr. Vout Peters, one of the most famous, is an avid collector of old books and an authority on Elizabethan drama. Mr. Dickinson, another remarkably gifted discerner of spirits, correctly named twenty-four spirits during two meetings held on the same day. He works loading canal barges. He is one of England’s gifted clairvoyants, though Tom Tyrrell the weaver, Aaron Wilkinson, and others are quite extraordinary. Tyrrell is a man of the Anthony of Padua type, a walking saint beloved by animals and children. He is a figure who might have stepped out of a church legend. Thomas, the powerful physical medium, is a working coal miner. Most mediums take their responsibilities very seriously and regard their work as religious. There is no denying that mediums face some very particular temptations. As I have explained elsewhere, the gift comes and goes. Admitting that it is temporarily absent, and thus discouraging clients, requires more moral principle than everyone possesses. Another temptation to which several great mediums have succumbed is drink. This happens quite naturally. Overworking their power leaves them physically exhausted, and the stimulus of alcohol offers welcome relief. Drinking may eventually become a habit and finally a curse. Alcoholism always weakens the moral sense, so these degenerate mediums become more prone to fraud. As a result, several who had deservedly earned honored names and withstood all hostile criticism were caught using the most contemptible tricks in later life. It is a great pity, but if the Court of Arches revealed its secrets, we would find that habitual drinking and moral decline were by no means confined to psychics. At the same time, psychics are especially sensitive, and I think they would always be wise to abstain from alcohol for life, as many actually do.

As to the method by which they attain their results they have, when in the trance state, no recollection. In the case of normal clairvoyants and clairaudients, the information comes in different ways. Sometimes it is no more than a strong mental impression which gives a name or an address. Sometimes they say that they see it written up before them. Sometimes the spirit figures seem to call it to them. "They yell it at me," said one.

When they are in a trance, they have no memory of how they achieve their results. For normal clairvoyants and clairaudients, information comes in different ways. Sometimes it is just a strong mental impression that gives them a name or an address. Sometimes they say they see the name or address written in front of them. Sometimes spirit figures seem to call it out to them. "They yell it at me," said one.

We need more first-hand accounts of these matters before we can formulate laws.

We need more firsthand accounts of these matters before we can establish laws.

It has been stated in a previous book by the author, but it will bear repetition, that the use of the seance should, in his opinion, be carefully regulated as well as reverently conducted. Having once satisfied himself of the absolute existence of the unseen world, and of its proximity to our own, the inquirer has got the great gift which psychical investigation can give him, and thenceforth he can regulate his life upon the lines which the teaching from beyond has shown to be the best. There is much force in the criticism that too constant intercourse with the affairs of another world may distract our attention and weaken our powers in dealing with our obvious duties in this one. A seance, with the object of satisfying curiosity or of rousing interest, cannot be an elevating influence, and the mere sensation-monger can make this holy and wonderful thing as base as the over-indulgence in a stimulant. On the other hand, where the seance is used for the purpose of satisfying ourselves as to the condition of those whom we have lost, or of giving comfort to others who crave for a word from beyond, then it is, indeed, a blessed gift from God to be used with moderation and with thankfulness. Our loved ones have their own pleasant tasks in their new surroundings, and though they assure us that they love to clasp the hands which we stretch out to them, we should still have some hesitation in intruding to an unreasonable extent upon the routine of their lives.

I have said in a previous book that séances should be carefully regulated and conducted with reverence. I believe the point is worth repeating. Once an investigator is convinced that the unseen world exists and is close to our own, they have received the great gift that psychic investigation can offer. From then on, they can live according to what teachings from beyond have shown to be best. There is much force in the criticism that too much contact with the affairs of another world may distract us from our duties in this one. It may also weaken our ability to carry them out. A séance held to satisfy curiosity or stir interest cannot uplift us. Someone seeking mere thrills can make this holy and wonderful thing as degrading as excessive use of a stimulant. On the other hand, we may use a séance to learn about the condition of those we have lost. We may also use it to comfort others who long for a word from beyond. In those cases, it is indeed a blessed gift from God, to be used with moderation and gratitude. Our loved ones have their own pleasant tasks in their new surroundings. They assure us that they love to clasp the hands we stretch out to them. Even so, we should hesitate to intrude too much on the routine of their lives.

A word should be said as to that fear of fiends and evil spirits which appears to have so much weight with some of the critics of this subject. When one looks more closely at this emotion it seems somewhat selfish and cowardly. These creatures are in truth our own backward brothers, bound for the same ultimate destination as ourselves, but retarded by causes for which our earth conditions may have been partly responsible. Our pity and sympathy should go out to them, and if they do indeed manifest at a seance, the proper Christian attitude is, as it seems to me, that we should reason with them and pray for them in order to help them upon their difficult way. Those who have treated them in this way have found a very marked difference in the subsequent communications. In Admiral Usborne Moore's "Glimpses of the Next State" there will be found some records of an American circle which devoted itself entirely to missionary work of this sort. There is some reason to believe that there are forms of imperfect development which can be helped more by earthly than by purely spiritual influences, for the reason, perhaps, that they are closer to the material.

A word should be said about the fear of fiends and evil spirits, which seems to weigh heavily with some critics of this subject. On closer examination, this fear seems somewhat selfish and cowardly. These creatures are really our own brothers who have fallen behind. They are headed for the same ultimate destination as we are, but have been held back by causes for which conditions on earth may have been partly responsible. We should feel pity and sympathy for them. If they do appear at a seance, it seems to me that the proper Christian response is to reason with them and pray for them, to help them on their difficult journey. Those who have treated them this way have found a very marked difference in later communications. Admiral Usborne Moore's "Glimpses of the Next State" contains accounts of an American circle devoted entirely to missionary work of this kind. There is some reason to believe that beings whose development is imperfect can be helped more by earthly influences than by purely spiritual ones. Perhaps this is because they are closer to the material world.

In a recent case I was called in to endeavour to check a very noisy entity which frequented an old house in which there were strong reasons to believe that crime had been committed, and also that the criminal was earth-bound. Names were given by the unhappy spirit which proved to be correct, and a cupboard was described, which was duly found, though it had never before been suspected. On getting into touch with the spirit I endeavoured to reason with it and to explain how selfish it was to cause misery to others in order to satisfy any feelings of revenge which it might have carried over from earth life. We then prayed for its welfare, exhorted it to rise higher, and received a very solemn assurance, tilted out at the table, that it would mend its ways. I have very gratifying reports that it has done so, and that all is now quiet in the old house.

In a recent case, I was called in to try to stop a very noisy entity that haunted an old house. There were strong reasons to believe that a crime had been committed there and that the criminal was bound to the earth. The unhappy spirit gave names that proved to be correct. It also described a cupboard that was found, though no one had suspected it was there. When I made contact with the spirit, I tried to reason with it. I explained how selfish it was to make others miserable to satisfy any feelings of revenge it had carried over from earthly life. We then prayed for its welfare and urged it to rise higher. Through the tilting of the table, it gave us a very solemn assurance that it would mend its ways. I have received very gratifying reports that it has done so and that all is now quiet in the old house.

Let us now consider the life in the Beyond as it is shown to us by the new revelation.

Let us now consider life in the Beyond as the new revelation shows it to us.