Appendix C

Spirit Photography

4 min

On this subject I should recommend the reader to consult Coates' "Photographing the Invisible," which states, in a thoughtful and moderate way, the evidence for this most remarkable phase, and illustrates it with many examples. It is pointed out that here, as always, fraud must be carefully guarded against, having been admitted in the case of the French spirit photographer, Buguet.

On this subject, I recommend Coates' "Photographing the Invisible." It presents the evidence for this remarkable phenomenon thoughtfully and moderately, with many examples. Coates points out that, here as always, we must guard carefully against fraud. Fraud was admitted in the case of Buguet, the French spirit photographer.

There are, however, a large number of cases where the photograph, under rigid test conditions in which fraud has been absolutely barred, has reproduced the features of the dead. Here there are limitations and restrictions which call for careful study and observation. These faces of the dead are in some cases as contoured and as recognisable as they were in life, and correspond with no pre-existing picture or photograph. One such case absolutely critic-proof is enough, one would think, to establish survival, and these valid cases are to be counted not in ones, but in hundreds. On the other hand, many of the likenesses, obtained under the same test conditions, are obviously simulacra or pictures built up by some psychic force, not necessarily by the individual spirits themselves, to represent the dead. In some undoubtedly genuine cases it is an exact, or almost exact, reproduction of an existing picture, as if the conscious intelligent force, whatever it might be, had consulted it as to the former appearance of the deceased, and had then built it up in exact accordance with the original. In such cases the spirit face may show as a flat surface instead of a contour. Rigid examination has shown that the existing model was usually outside the ken of the photographer.

However, there are many cases in which photographs have reproduced the features of the dead under strict test conditions. Under these conditions, fraud has been absolutely ruled out. There are limitations and restrictions here that require careful study and observation. In some cases, these faces of the dead have contours and are as recognizable as they were in life. They do not match any existing picture or photograph. One such case that is beyond criticism would, one might think, be enough to establish survival after death. And these valid cases number not just one or two, but hundreds. On the other hand, many likenesses obtained under the same test conditions are clearly imitations. They are pictures created by some psychic force to represent the dead, not necessarily by the individual spirits themselves. In some undoubtedly genuine cases, the likeness is an exact or almost exact reproduction of an existing picture. It is as if the conscious, intelligent force, whatever it might be, had consulted the picture to see how the deceased looked. It had then recreated the likeness exactly as it appeared in the original. In such cases, the spirit face may appear flat rather than contoured. Thorough examination has shown that the photographer usually knew nothing about the existing picture used as a model.

Two of the bravest champions whom Spiritualism has ever produced, the late W. T. Stead and the late Archdeacon Colley—names which will bulk large in days to come—attached great importance to spirit photography as a final and incontestable proof of survival. In his recent work, "Proofs of the Truth of Spiritualism" (Kegan Paul), the eminent botanist, Professor Henslow, has given one case which would really appear to be above criticism. He narrates how the inquirer subjected a sealed packet of plates to the Crewe circle without exposure, endeavoring to get a psychograph. Upon being asked on which plate he desired it, he said "the fifth." Upon this plate being developed, there was found on it a copy of a passage from the Codex Alexandrinus of the New Testament in the British Museum. Reproductions, both of the original and of the copy, will be found in Professor Henslow's book.

Two of Spiritualism's bravest champions were the late W. T. Stead and the late Archdeacon Colley. Their names will loom large in the years to come. Both placed great importance on spirit photography as final and incontestable proof of survival after death. In his recent book, "Proofs of the Truth of Spiritualism" (Kegan Paul), the eminent botanist Professor Henslow describes one case that seems beyond criticism. An investigator brought a sealed packet of unexposed photographic plates to the Crewe circle, hoping to obtain a psychograph. Asked which plate he wanted it on, he said "the fifth." When the fifth plate was developed, it showed a copy of a passage from the Codex Alexandrinus of the New Testament in the British Museum. Professor Henslow's book includes reproductions of both the original and the copy.

I have myself been to Crewe and have had results which would be amazing were it not that familiarity blunts the mind to miracles. Three marked plates brought by myself, and handled, developed and fixed by no hand but mine, gave psychic extras. In each case I saw the extra in the negative when it was still wet in the dark room. I reproduce in Plate I a specimen of the results, which is enough in itself to prove the whole case of survival to any reasonable mind. The three sitters are Mr. Oaten, Mr. Walker, and myself, I being obscured by the psychic cloud. In this cloud appears a message of welcome to me from the late Archdeacon Colley. A specimen of the Archdeacon's own handwriting is reproduced in Plate II for the purpose of comparison. Behind, there is an attempt at materialisation obscured by the cloud. The mark on the side of the plate is my identification mark. I trust that I make it clear that no hand but mine ever touched this plate, nor did I ever lose sight of it for a second save when it was in the carrier, which was conveyed straight back to the dark room and there opened. What has any critic to say to that?

I have been to Crewe myself and had results that would be amazing if familiarity did not dull the mind to miracles. Three marked plates I brought myself produced psychic extras. No hand but mine handled, developed, or fixed them. In each case, I saw the extra on the negative while it was still wet in the darkroom. I reproduce an example of the results in Plate I. That example alone is enough to prove the whole case for survival after death to any reasonable person. The three sitters are Mr. Oaten, Mr. Walker, and myself. I am hidden by the psychic cloud. In this cloud is a message of welcome to me from the late Archdeacon Colley. For comparison, an example of the Archdeacon's own handwriting is reproduced in Plate II. Behind the cloud is an attempt at materialisation, hidden by the cloud. The mark on the side of the plate is my identification mark. I trust I have made it clear that no hand but mine ever touched this plate. Nor did I lose sight of it for a second, except when it was in the carrier. The carrier was taken straight back to the darkroom and opened there. What does any critic have to say to that?

By the kindness of those fearless pioneers of the movement, Mr. and Mrs. Hewat Mackenzie, I am allowed to publish another example of spirit photography. The circumstances were very remarkable. The visit of the parents to Crewe was unproductive and their plate a blank save for their own presentment. Returning disappointed, to London they managed, through the mediumship of Mrs. Leonard, to get into touch with their boy, and asked him why they had failed. He replied that the conditions had been bad, but that he had actually succeeded some days later in getting on to the plate of Lady Glenconnor, who had been to Crewe upon a similar errand. The parents communicated with this lady, who replied saying that she had found the image of a stranger upon her plate. On receiving a print they at once recognised their son, and could even see that, as a proof of identity, he had reproduced the bullet wound on his left temple. No. 3 is their gallant son as he appeared in the flesh, No. 4 is his reappearance after death. The opinion of a miniature painter who had done a picture of the young soldier is worth recording as evidence of identity. The artist says: "After painting the miniature of your son Will, I feel I know every turn of his face, and am quite convinced of the likeness of the psychic photograph. All the modelling of the brow, nose and eyes is marked by illness—especially is the mouth slightly contracted—but this does not interfere with the real form. The way the hair grows on the brow and temple is noticeably like the photograph taken before he was wounded."

Thanks to the kindness of Mr. and Mrs. Hewat Mackenzie, fearless pioneers of the movement, I can publish another example of spirit photography. The circumstances were very remarkable. The parents’ visit to Crewe produced no result. Their photographic plate was blank except for their own image. They returned to London disappointed and managed to contact their boy through Mrs. Leonard’s mediumship. They asked him why they had failed. He replied that the conditions had been bad. But some days later, he had managed to appear on Lady Glenconnor’s plate. She had gone to Crewe for a similar purpose. The parents contacted Lady Glenconnor, who replied that she had found a stranger’s image on her plate. When they received a print, they immediately recognized their son. They could even see that he had reproduced the bullet wound on his left temple as proof of his identity. No. 3 shows their gallant son as he appeared in life. No. 4 shows his reappearance after death. A miniature painter who had painted the young soldier gave an opinion worth recording as evidence of his identity. The artist says: "After painting the miniature of your son Will, I feel I know every detail of his face. I am quite convinced that the psychic photograph is a likeness of him. The contours of his brow, nose, and eyes all show signs of illness. His mouth is especially affected and is slightly contracted. But this does not change its real shape. The way his hair grows on his brow and temple is noticeably like the photograph taken before he was wounded."