Appendix D

Mrs. B.'s Clairvoyance

2 min

At the time of this volume going to press the results obtained by clients of this medium have been forty-two successes out of fifty attempts, checked and docketted by the author. This series forms a most conclusive proof of spirit clairvoyance. An attempt has been made by Mr. E. F. Benson, who examined some of the letters, to explain the results upon the grounds of telepathy. He admits that "The tastes, appearance and character of the deceased are often given, and many names are introduced by the medium, some not traceable, but most of them identical with relations or friends." Such an admission would alone banish thought-reading as an explanation, for there is no evidence in existence to show that this power ever reaches such perfection that one who possesses it could draw the image of a dead man from your brain, fit a correct name to him, and then associate him with all sorts of definite and detailed actions in which he was engaged. Such an explanation is not an explanation but a pretence. But even if one were to allow such a theory to pass, there are numerous incidents in these accounts which could not be explained in such a fashion, where unknown details have been given which were afterwards verified, and even where mistakes in thought upon the part of the sitter were corrected by the medium under spirit guidance. Personally I believe that the medium's own account of how she gets her remarkable results is the absolute truth, and I can imagine no other fashion in which they can be explained. She has, of course, her bad days, and the conditions are always worst when there is an inquisitorial rather than a religious atmosphere in the interview. This intermittent character of the results is, according to my experience, characteristic of spirit clairvoyance as compared with thought-reading, which can, in its more perfect form, become almost automatic within certain marked limits. I may add that the constant practice of some psychical researchers to take no notice at all of the medium's own account of how he or she attains results, but to substitute some complicated and unproved explanation of their own, is as insulting as it is unreasonable. It has been alleged as a slur upon Mrs. B's results and character that she has been twice prosecuted by the police. This is, in fact, not a slur upon the medium but rather upon the law, which is in so barbarous a condition that the true seer fares no better than the impostor, and that no definite psychic principles are recognised. A medium may under such circumstances be a martyr rather than a criminal, and a conviction ceases to be a stain upon the character.

As this volume goes to press, clients of this medium have had forty-two successes in fifty attempts. The author has checked and recorded them. This series provides the most conclusive proof of spirit clairvoyance. Mr. E. F. Benson, who examined some of the letters, has tried to explain the results through telepathy. He admits that "The tastes, appearance and character of the deceased are often given, and many names are introduced by the medium, some not traceable, but most of them identical with relations or friends." That admission alone would rule out thought-reading as an explanation. No existing evidence shows that this power ever reaches such perfection. A person with it could not draw an image of a dead man from your mind, give him the correct name, and associate him with all sorts of specific, detailed actions he had performed. Such an explanation is not an explanation but a pretense. But even if one accepted this theory, many incidents in these accounts could not be explained that way. The medium gave unknown details that were later verified. She even corrected mistakes in the sitter's thoughts under spirit guidance. Personally, I believe the medium's own account of how she gets her remarkable results is the absolute truth. I can imagine no other way to explain them. She has, of course, her bad days. Conditions are always worst when the interview has a questioning rather than a religious atmosphere. In my experience, such inconsistent results are characteristic of spirit clairvoyance. Thought-reading, by contrast, can become almost automatic in its more perfect form, within certain clear limits. I may add that some psychical researchers regularly ignore a medium's own account of how he or she gets results. Instead, they substitute some complicated and unproven explanation of their own. This practice is as insulting as it is unreasonable. It has been claimed that Mrs. B's two prosecutions by the police reflect badly on her results and character. In fact, they reflect badly not on the medium but on the law. The law is in such a barbarous state that a genuine seer fares no better than an impostor. It recognizes no definite psychic principles. Under such circumstances, a medium may be a martyr rather than a criminal. A conviction therefore ceases to be a stain on a medium's character.

The end