Part 2
Preface
I have mentioned in the former part of The Age of Reason that it had long been my intention to publish my thoughts upon Religion; but that I had originally reserved it to a later period in life, intending it to be the last work I should undertake. The circumstances, however, which existed in France in the latter end of the year 1793, determined me to delay it no longer. The just and humane principles of the Revolution which Philosophy had first diffused, had been departed from. The Idea, always dangerous to Society as it is derogatory to the Almighty,—that priests could forgive sins,—though it seemed to exist no longer, had blunted the feelings of humanity, and callously prepared men for the commission of all crimes. The intolerant spirit of church persecution had transferred itself into politics; the tribunals, stiled Revolutionary, supplied the place of an Inquisition; and the Guillotine of the Stake. I saw many of my most intimate friends destroyed; others daily carried to prison; and I had reason to believe, and had also intimations given me, that the same danger was approaching myself.
I mentioned in the earlier part of The Age of Reason that I had long intended to publish my thoughts on Religion. But I had originally planned to wait until later in life and make it my last work. However, circumstances in France at the end of 1793 convinced me to delay no longer. The just and humane principles of the Revolution, first spread by Philosophy, had been abandoned. The idea that priests could forgive sins was always dangerous to society and an insult to the Almighty. Though that idea seemed to have disappeared, it had dulled human compassion and made men callous enough to commit any crime. The intolerant spirit of church persecution had moved into politics. The tribunals called Revolutionary had taken the place of the Inquisition, and the Guillotine had replaced the Stake. I saw many of my closest friends destroyed and others taken to prison every day. I had reason to believe, and had also been warned, that the same danger was approaching me.
Under these disadvantages, I began the former part of the Age of Reason; I had, besides, neither Bible nor Testament [It must be borne in mind that throughout this work Paine generally means by “Bible” only the Old Testament, and speaks of the New as the “Testament.”—Editor.] to refer to, though I was writing against both; nor could I procure any; notwithstanding which I have produced a work that no Bible Believer, though writing at his ease and with a Library of Church Books about him, can refute. Towards the latter end of December of that year, a motion was made and carried, to exclude foreigners from the Convention. There were but two, Anacharsis Cloots and myself; and I saw I was particularly pointed at by Bourdon de l’Oise, in his speech on that motion.
Under these disadvantages, I began the first part of The Age of Reason. I had neither a Bible nor a Testament to consult, though I was writing against both. [Throughout this work, Paine generally means only the Old Testament by “Bible.” He calls the New Testament the “Testament.” (Editor)] Nor could I obtain either one. Despite this, I produced a work that no Bible believer can refute, even while writing at ease with a library of church books around him. Near the end of December that year, a motion to exclude foreigners from the Convention was proposed and passed. There were only two foreigners, Anacharsis Cloots and myself. In his speech on the motion, I saw that Bourdon de l’Oise was singling me out.
Conceiving, after this, that I had but a few days of liberty, I sat down and brought the work to a close as speedily as possible; and I had not finished it more than six hours, in the state it has since appeared, [This is an allusion to the essay which Paine wrote at an earlier part of 1793. See Introduction.—Editor.] before a guard came there, about three in the morning, with an order signed by the two Committees of Public Safety and Surety General, for putting me in arrestation as a foreigner, and conveying me to the prison of the Luxembourg. I contrived, in my way there, to call on Joel Barlow, and I put the Manuscript of the work into his hands, as more safe than in my possession in prison; and not knowing what might be the fate in France either of the writer or the work, I addressed it to the protection of the citizens of the United States.
After this, I believed I had only a few days of freedom left. So I sat down and finished the work as quickly as possible. I had finished it in the form in which it has since appeared less than six hours before a guard came. [This refers to the essay Paine wrote earlier in 1793. See Introduction. Editor.] The guard arrived around three in the morning. He had an order signed by the two Committees of Public Safety and Surety General. It called for my arrest as a foreigner and my transfer to the Luxembourg prison. On my way there, I managed to call on Joel Barlow. I gave him the manuscript of the work, believing it would be safer with him than with me in prison. I did not know what might happen in France to either the writer or the work. So I placed the work under the protection of the citizens of the United States.
It is justice that I say, that the guard who executed this order, and the interpreter to the Committee of General Surety, who accompanied them to examine my papers, treated me not only with civility, but with respect. The keeper of the ‘Luxembourg, Benoit, a man of good heart, shewed to me every friendship in his power, as did also all his family, while he continued in that station. He was removed from it, put into arrestation, and carried before the tribunal upon a malignant accusation, but acquitted.
In fairness, I must say that the guard who carried out this order treated me with courtesy and respect. So did the interpreter for the Committee of General Surety, who accompanied them to examine my papers. Benoit, the keeper of the Luxembourg, was a kindhearted man. He and his family showed me every kindness they could while he remained in that position. He was removed, arrested, and brought before the tribunal on a malicious accusation, but he was acquitted.
After I had been in Luxembourg about three weeks, the Americans then in Paris went in a body to the Convention to reclaim me as their countryman and friend; but were answered by the President, Vadier, who was also President of the Committee of Surety General, and had signed the order for my arrestation, that I was born in England. [These excited Americans do not seem to have understood or reported the most important item in Vadeer’s reply, namely that their application was “unofficial,” i.e. not made through or sanctioned by Gouverneur Morris, American Minister. For the detailed history of all this see vol. iii.—Editor.] I heard no more, after this, from any person out of the walls of the prison, till the fall of Robespierre, on the 9th of Thermidor—July 27, 1794.
After I had been in Luxembourg for about three weeks, the Americans in Paris went together to the Convention. They went to demand my release as their countryman and friend. But the President, Vadier, replied that I was born in England. He was also President of the Committee of Surety General and had signed the order for my arrest. [These excited Americans do not seem to have understood or reported the most important part of Vadeer’s reply. He said their request was “unofficial.” That is, it had not been made through or approved by Gouverneur Morris, the American Minister. For the detailed history of all this, see vol. iii. Editor.] After this, I heard nothing more from anyone outside the prison walls until the fall of Robespierre on 9 Thermidor (July 27, 1794).
About two months before this event, I was seized with a fever that in its progress had every symptom of becoming mortal, and from the effects of which I am not recovered. It was then that I remembered with renewed satisfaction, and congratulated myself most sincerely, on having written the former part of The Age of Reason. I had then but little expectation of surviving, and those about me had less. I know therefore by experience the conscientious trial of my own principles.
About two months before this event, I came down with a fever. As it progressed, every symptom suggested it would be fatal, and I have not yet recovered from its effects. At that time, I remembered with renewed satisfaction that I had written the earlier part of The Age of Reason. I sincerely congratulated myself on having done so. I had little hope of surviving, and those around me had even less. I therefore know from experience what it is to test my own principles against my conscience.
I was then with three chamber comrades: Joseph Vanheule of Bruges, Charles Bastfni, and Michael Robyns of Louvain. The unceasing and anxious attention of these three friends to me, by night and day, I remember with gratitude and mention with pleasure. It happened that a physician (Dr. Graham) and a surgeon, (Mr. Bond,) part of the suite of General O’Hara, [The officer who at Yorktown, Virginia, carried out the sword of Cornwallis for surrender, and satirically offered it to Rochambeau instead of Washington. Paine loaned him 300 pounds when he (O’Hara) left the prison, the money he had concealed in the lock of his cell-door.—Editor.] were then in the Luxembourg: I ask not myself whether it be convenient to them, as men under the English Government, that I express to them my thanks; but I should reproach myself if I did not; and also to the physician of the Luxembourg, Dr. Markoski.
I was then sharing a room with three companions: Joseph Vanheule of Bruges, Charles Bastfni, and Michael Robyns of Louvain. These three friends cared for me constantly and anxiously, day and night. I remember their care with gratitude and mention it with pleasure. A physician, Dr. Graham, and a surgeon, Mr. Bond, were also then in the Luxembourg. They were members of General O’Hara’s party. [O’Hara was the officer who carried Cornwallis’s sword for surrender at Yorktown, Virginia. He mockingly offered it to Rochambeau instead of Washington. When O’Hara left the prison, Paine lent him 300 pounds, which Paine had hidden in his cell door’s lock. Editor.] I do not ask myself whether, as men under the English Government, they would find it convenient for me to thank them. But I would reproach myself if I did not thank them and Dr. Markoski, the Luxembourg’s physician.
I have some reason to believe, because I cannot discover any other, that this illness preserved me in existence. Among the papers of Robespierre that were examined and reported upon to the Convention by a Committee of Deputies, is a note in the hand writing of Robespierre, in the following words:
I have some reason to believe that this illness kept me alive, because I can find no other explanation. A Committee of Deputies examined Robespierre's papers and reported on them to the Convention. Among the papers was a note in Robespierre's handwriting, which read:
“Demander que Thomas Paine soit decrete d’accusation, pour l’interet de l’Amerique autant que de la France.”
“Demand that Thomas Paine be indicted, in the interest of America as well as France.”
[Demand that Thomas Paine be decreed of accusation, for the interest of America, as well as of France.] From what cause it was that the intention was not put in execution, I know not, and cannot inform myself; and therefore I ascribe it to impossibility, on account of that illness.
[Demand that Thomas Paine be formally accused, in the interest of America as well as France.] I do not know why the intention was not carried out, and I cannot find out. I therefore assume that the illness made it impossible.
The Convention, to repair as much as lay in their power the injustice I had sustained, invited me publickly and unanimously to return into the Convention, and which I accepted, to shew I could bear an injury without permitting it to injure my principles or my disposition. It is not because right principles have been violated, that they are to be abandoned.
The Convention publicly and unanimously invited me to return, to make up for the injustice I had suffered as much as it could. I accepted to show that I could bear an injury without letting it harm my principles or my disposition. We should not abandon sound principles simply because they have been violated.
I have seen, since I have been at liberty, several publications written, some in America, and some in England, as answers to the former part of “The Age of Reason.” If the authors of these can amuse themselves by so doing, I shall not interrupt them, They may write against the work, and against me, as much as they please; they do me more service than they intend, and I can have no objection that they write on. They will find, however, by this Second Part, without its being written as an answer to them, that they must return to their work, and spin their cobweb over again. The first is brushed away by accident.
Since gaining my freedom, I have seen several publications responding to the first part of “The Age of Reason.” Some were written in America and others in England. If the authors enjoy doing this, I will not interrupt them. They may write against the work and against me as much as they please. They do me more good than they intend, and I have no objection to their continuing. This Second Part is not written as an answer to them. Even so, they will find that they must go back to work and spin their cobweb again. The first one has been brushed away by accident.
They will now find that I have furnished myself with a Bible and Testament; and I can say also that I have found them to be much worse books than I had conceived. If I have erred in any thing, in the former part of the Age of Reason, it has been by speaking better of some parts than they deserved.
They will now find that I have obtained a Bible and a Testament. I can also say that I found them much worse than I had imagined. If I made any mistakes in the first part of The Age of Reason, I spoke better of some parts than they deserved.
I observe, that all my opponents resort, more or less, to what they call Scripture Evidence and Bible authority, to help them out. They are so little masters of the subject, as to confound a dispute about authenticity with a dispute about doctrines; I will, however, put them right, that if they should be disposed to write any more, they may know how to begin.
I notice that all my opponents rely, to some extent, on what they call scriptural evidence and biblical authority. They understand the subject so poorly that they confuse a dispute about authenticity with a dispute about doctrines. But I will set them straight. Then, if they choose to write more, they will know how to begin.
THOMAS PAINE. October, 1795.
THOMAS PAINE. October 1795.