Part 2, Chapter 1

The Old Testament

1h 38m

It has often been said that any thing may be proved from the Bible; but before any thing can be admitted as proved by Bible, the Bible itself must be proved to be true; for if the Bible be not true, or the truth of it be doubtful, it ceases to have authority, and cannot be admitted as proof of any thing.

People often say that anything can be proved from the Bible. But before the Bible can be accepted as proof of anything, it must itself be proved true. If the Bible is not true, or if its truth is doubtful, it has no authority. It cannot be accepted as proof of anything.

It has been the practice of all Christian commentators on the Bible, and of all Christian priests and preachers, to impose the Bible on the world as a mass of truth, and as the word of God; they have disputed and wrangled, and have anathematized each other about the supposeable meaning of particular parts and passages therein; one has said and insisted that such a passage meant such a thing, another that it meant directly the contrary, and a third, that it meant neither one nor the other, but something different from both; and this they have called understanding the Bible.

All Christian Bible commentators, priests, and preachers have imposed the Bible on the world as pure truth and God’s word. They have argued and quarreled over the possible meanings of particular parts and passages. They have even condemned one another over them. One has insisted that a passage meant one thing. Another has insisted that it meant the exact opposite. A third has claimed that it meant neither, but something different from both. And they have called this understanding the Bible.

It has happened, that all the answers that I have seen to the former part of ‘The Age of Reason’ have been written by priests: and these pious men, like their predecessors, contend and wrangle, and understand the Bible; each understands it differently, but each understands it best; and they have agreed in nothing but in telling their readers that Thomas Paine understands it not.

All the responses I have seen to the first part of ‘The Age of Reason’ were written by priests. Like their predecessors, these pious men argue and quarrel, and understand the Bible. Each understands it differently, but each understands it best. They agree on only one thing: they tell their readers that Thomas Paine does not understand it.

Now instead of wasting their time, and heating themselves in fractious disputations about doctrinal points drawn from the Bible, these men ought to know, and if they do not it is civility to inform them, that the first thing to be understood is, whether there is sufficient authority for believing the Bible to be the word of God, or whether there is not?

Instead of wasting time and getting worked up in quarrels over doctrines drawn from the Bible, these men should understand the first question. If they do not, it is only polite to inform them. The first question is whether there is enough authority to believe that the Bible is the word of God.

There are matters in that book, said to be done by the express command of God, that are as shocking to humanity, and to every idea we have of moral justice, as any thing done by Robespierre, by Carrier, by Joseph le Bon, in France, by the English government in the East Indies, or by any other assassin in modern times. When we read in the books ascribed to Moses, Joshua, etc., that they (the Israelites) came by stealth upon whole nations of people, who, as the history itself shews, had given them no offence; that they put all those nations to the sword; that they spared neither age nor infancy; that they utterly destroyed men, women and children; that they left not a soul to breathe; expressions that are repeated over and over again in those books, and that too with exulting ferocity; are we sure these things are facts? are we sure that the Creator of man commissioned those things to be done? Are we sure that the books that tell us so were written by his authority?

That book describes acts supposedly carried out by God's direct command. They are as shocking to humanity and to every idea of moral justice as any act by Robespierre, Carrier, or Joseph le Bon in France. They are as shocking as anything done by the English government in the East Indies or by any other assassin in modern times. In the books attributed to Moses, Joshua, and others, we read that the Israelites attacked entire nations by stealth. The history itself shows that these nations had done them no harm. Yet the Israelites killed everyone in those nations by the sword. They spared neither the old nor the very young. They utterly destroyed men, women, and children, leaving not a soul alive. Expressions like these appear again and again in those books, in a tone of savage triumph. Are we sure these events actually happened? Are we sure that the Creator of man ordered them? Are we sure that the books that tell us so were written by his authority?

It is not the antiquity of a tale that is an evidence of its truth; on the contrary, it is a symptom of its being fabulous; for the more ancient any history pretends to be, the more it has the resemblance of a fable. The origin of every nation is buried in fabulous tradition, and that of the Jews is as much to be suspected as any other.

The age of a story is not evidence that it is true. On the contrary, it suggests that the story is made up. The further back a history claims to go, the more it resembles a fable. The origins of every nation are buried in legendary traditions, and those of the Jews are as suspect as any other.

To charge the commission of things upon the Almighty, which in their own nature, and by every rule of moral justice, are crimes, as all assassination is, and more especially the assassination of infants, is matter of serious concern. The Bible tells us, that those assassinations were done by the express command of God. To believe therefore the Bible to be true, we must unbelieve all our belief in the moral justice of God; for wherein could crying or smiling infants offend? And to read the Bible without horror, we must undo every thing that is tender, sympathising, and benevolent in the heart of man. Speaking for myself, if I had no other evidence that the Bible is fabulous, than the sacrifice I must make to believe it to be true, that alone would be sufficient to determine my choice.

It is a serious matter to accuse the Almighty of committing acts that are crimes by their very nature and by every rule of moral justice. All assassination is a crime, and the assassination of infants especially so. The Bible tells us that these assassinations were carried out at God's express command. To believe the Bible is true, then, we must give up all our belief in God's moral justice. For how could crying or smiling infants have done wrong? And to read the Bible without horror, we must undo everything tender, compassionate, and kind in the human heart. Speaking for myself, I might have no other evidence that the Bible is a fable than what I must sacrifice to believe it is true. That alone would be enough to determine my choice.

But in addition to all the moral evidence against the Bible, I will, in the progress of this work, produce such other evidence as even a priest cannot deny; and show, from that evidence, that the Bible is not entitled to credit, as being the word of God.

But beyond all the moral evidence against the Bible, I will present other evidence in this work that even a priest cannot deny. And I will use that evidence to show that the Bible cannot be trusted as the word of God.

But, before I proceed to this examination, I will show wherein the Bible differs from all other ancient writings with respect to the nature of the evidence necessary to establish its authenticity; and this is the more proper to be done, because the advocates of the Bible, in their answers to the former part of ‘The Age of Reason,’ undertake to say, and they put some stress thereon, that the authenticity of the Bible is as well established as that of any other ancient book: as if our belief of the one could become any rule for our belief of the other.

But before I begin this examination, I will show how the Bible differs from all other ancient writings. The difference concerns the kind of evidence needed to establish its authenticity. This is especially appropriate because defenders of the Bible make a claim in their responses to the first part of ‘The Age of Reason.’ They place some emphasis on the claim that the Bible's authenticity is as well established as that of any other ancient book. They argue as if our belief in the authenticity of one could be a rule for believing in the authenticity of the other.

I know, however, but of one ancient book that authoritatively challenges universal consent and belief, and that is Euclid’s Elements of Geometry; [Euclid, according to chronological history, lived three hundred years before Christ, and about one hundred before Archimedes; he was of the city of Alexandria, in Egypt.—Author.] and the reason is, because it is a book of self-evident demonstration, entirely independent of its author, and of every thing relating to time, place, and circumstance. The matters contained in that book would have the same authority they now have, had they been written by any other person, or had the work been anonymous, or had the author never been known; for the identical certainty of who was the author makes no part of our belief of the matters contained in the book. But it is quite otherwise with respect to the books ascribed to Moses, to Joshua, to Samuel, etc.: those are books of testimony, and they testify of things naturally incredible; and therefore the whole of our belief, as to the authenticity of those books, rests, in the first place, upon the certainty that they were written by Moses, Joshua, and Samuel; secondly, upon the credit we give to their testimony. We may believe the first, that is, may believe the certainty of the authorship, and yet not the testimony; in the same manner that we may believe that a certain person gave evidence upon a case, and yet not believe the evidence that he gave. But if it should be found that the books ascribed to Moses, Joshua, and Samuel, were not written by Moses, Joshua, and Samuel, every part of the authority and authenticity of those books is gone at once; for there can be no such thing as forged or invented testimony; neither can there be anonymous testimony, more especially as to things naturally incredible; such as that of talking with God face to face, or that of the sun and moon standing still at the command of a man.

I know, however, of only one ancient book that rightfully demands universal agreement and belief: Euclid’s Elements of Geometry. [According to historical chronology, Euclid lived three hundred years before Christ and about one hundred years before Archimedes. He was from the city of Alexandria, in Egypt. Author.] It deserves universal belief because it demonstrates truths that are self-evident. These truths are entirely independent of its author and of any time, place, or circumstance. The contents would have the same authority if anyone else had written them, or if the work were anonymous. They would have the same authority even if the author had never been known. Certainty about who wrote the book plays no part in our belief in its contents. But the books attributed to Moses, Joshua, Samuel, and others are quite different. They are books of testimony, and they testify to things that are naturally incredible. Therefore, our belief in their authenticity rests first on certainty that Moses, Joshua, and Samuel wrote them. It rests second on how much credit we give their testimony. We may believe the first claim, that is, we may be certain of the authorship, yet not believe the testimony. In the same way, we may believe that someone gave evidence in a case without believing the evidence. But suppose the books attributed to Moses, Joshua, and Samuel were not written by them. Then all their authority and authenticity disappear at once. There can be no such thing as forged or invented testimony. Neither can there be anonymous testimony, especially about things that are naturally incredible. These include talking with God face to face, or the sun and moon standing still at a man’s command.

The greatest part of the other ancient books are works of genius; of which kind are those ascribed to Homer, to Plato, to Aristotle, to Demosthenes, to Cicero, etc. Here again the author is not an essential in the credit we give to any of those works; for as works of genius they would have the same merit they have now, were they anonymous. Nobody believes the Trojan story, as related by Homer, to be true; for it is the poet only that is admired, and the merit of the poet will remain, though the story be fabulous. But if we disbelieve the matters related by the Bible authors (Moses for instance) as we disbelieve the things related by Homer, there remains nothing of Moses in our estimation, but an imposter. As to the ancient historians, from Herodotus to Tacitus, we credit them as far as they relate things probable and credible, and no further: for if we do, we must believe the two miracles which Tacitus relates were performed by Vespasian, that of curing a lame man, and a blind man, in just the same manner as the same things are told of Jesus Christ by his historians. We must also believe the miracles cited by Josephus, that of the sea of Pamphilia opening to let Alexander and his army pass, as is related of the Red Sea in Exodus. These miracles are quite as well authenticated as the Bible miracles, and yet we do not believe them; consequently the degree of evidence necessary to establish our belief of things naturally incredible, whether in the Bible or elsewhere, is far greater than that which obtains our belief to natural and probable things; and therefore the advocates for the Bible have no claim to our belief of the Bible because that we believe things stated in other ancient writings; since that we believe the things stated in those writings no further than they are probable and credible, or because they are self-evident, like Euclid; or admire them because they are elegant, like Homer; or approve them because they are sedate, like Plato; or judicious, like Aristotle.

Most other ancient books are works of genius. These include works attributed to Homer, Plato, Aristotle, Demosthenes, Cicero, and others. Here again, the author is not essential to the credit we give these works. As works of genius, they would have the same merit even if they were anonymous. Nobody believes the Trojan story as Homer tells it. We admire the poet alone, and his merit remains even if the story is fiction. But suppose we disbelieve what the Bible authors, Moses for example, tell us, just as we disbelieve Homer. Then Moses is nothing in our eyes but an impostor. As for the ancient historians, from Herodotus to Tacitus, we believe them only when their accounts are probable and credible. If we believed more than that, we would have to believe the two miracles Tacitus says Vespasian performed. Tacitus says Vespasian cured a lame man and a blind man. The historians of Jesus Christ tell of the same cures in just the same way. We would also have to believe the miracles Josephus cites. One is that the sea of Pamphilia opened to let Alexander and his army pass. Exodus tells a similar story about the Red Sea. These miracles are just as well supported by evidence as the Bible miracles, yet we do not believe them. So naturally unbelievable things require far more evidence to make us believe them than natural and probable things do. This is true whether the stories appear in the Bible or elsewhere. Therefore, advocates for the Bible cannot demand that we believe it because we believe things stated in other ancient writings. We believe the statements in those writings only when they are probable and credible, or because they are self-evident, like Euclid. We admire them because they are elegant, like Homer. Or we approve of them because they are thoughtful, like Plato, or wise, like Aristotle.

Having premised these things, I proceed to examine the authenticity of the Bible; and I begin with what are called the five books of Moses, Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy. My intention is to shew that those books are spurious, and that Moses is not the author of them; and still further, that they were not written in the time of Moses nor till several hundred years afterwards; that they are no other than an attempted history of the life of Moses, and of the times in which he is said to have lived, and also of the times prior thereto, written by some very ignorant and stupid pretenders to authorship, several hundred years after the death of Moses; as men now write histories of things that happened, or are supposed to have happened, several hundred or several thousand years ago.

Having stated these points, I will examine the authenticity of the Bible. I begin with what are called the five books of Moses: Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy. I intend to show that these books are not authentic and that Moses did not write them. I will also show that they were not written in Moses's time, but several hundred years later. They are nothing more than an attempted history of Moses's life and the times in which he supposedly lived. They also attempt to recount the times before him. Some very ignorant and stupid pretenders to authorship wrote these books several hundred years after Moses's death. They did so just as people now write histories of events that happened, or supposedly happened, hundreds or thousands of years ago.

The evidence that I shall produce in this case is from the books themselves; and I will confine myself to this evidence only. Were I to refer for proofs to any of the ancient authors, whom the advocates of the Bible call prophane authors, they would controvert that authority, as I controvert theirs: I will therefore meet them on their own ground, and oppose them with their own weapon, the Bible.

The evidence I will present in this case comes from the books themselves. I will rely only on this evidence. If I cited ancient authors as proof, the Bible's defenders would dispute their authority, just as I dispute theirs. They call these ancient writers secular authors. So I will meet the Bible's defenders on their own ground and fight them with their own weapon, the Bible.

In the first place, there is no affirmative evidence that Moses is the author of those books; and that he is the author, is altogether an unfounded opinion, got abroad nobody knows how. The style and manner in which those books are written give no room to believe, or even to suppose, they were written by Moses; for it is altogether the style and manner of another person speaking of Moses. In Exodus, Leviticus and Numbers, (for every thing in Genesis is prior to the times of Moses and not the least allusion is made to him therein,) the whole, I say, of these books is in the third person; it is always, the Lord said unto Moses, or Moses said unto the Lord; or Moses said unto the people, or the people said unto Moses; and this is the style and manner that historians use in speaking of the person whose lives and actions they are writing. It may be said, that a man may speak of himself in the third person, and, therefore, it may be supposed that Moses did; but supposition proves nothing; and if the advocates for the belief that Moses wrote those books himself have nothing better to advance than supposition, they may as well be silent.

First, there is no positive evidence that Moses wrote those books. The belief that he wrote them is completely unfounded, and nobody knows how it spread. The style and manner of the books give no reason to believe, or even suppose, that Moses wrote them. They are written entirely in the style and manner of someone else speaking about Moses. In Exodus, Leviticus, and Numbers, the whole account is in the third person. (Everything in Genesis takes place before Moses’ time, and it makes no mention of him.) It is always the Lord said to Moses, or Moses said to the Lord, or Moses said to the people, or the people said to Moses. This is the style and manner historians use when writing about a person’s life and actions. Someone may say that a man can speak of himself in the third person. Therefore, they may suppose that Moses did so. But supposition proves nothing. If those who believe Moses wrote the books himself have nothing better to offer than supposition, they might as well be silent.

But granting the grammatical right, that Moses might speak of himself in the third person, because any man might speak of himself in that manner, it cannot be admitted as a fact in those books, that it is Moses who speaks, without rendering Moses truly ridiculous and absurd:—for example, Numbers xii. 3: “Now the man Moses was very MEEK, above all the men which were on the face of the earth.” If Moses said this of himself, instead of being the meekest of men, he was one of the most vain and arrogant coxcombs; and the advocates for those books may now take which side they please, for both sides are against them: if Moses was not the author, the books are without authority; and if he was the author, the author is without credit, because to boast of meekness is the reverse of meekness, and is a lie in sentiment.

Granted, Moses could grammatically speak of himself in the third person, since anyone could do so. But we cannot accept that Moses speaks in those books without making him truly ridiculous and absurd. For example, Numbers 12:3 says: “Now the man Moses was very MEEK, more than any other man on earth.” If Moses said this about himself, he was not the meekest of men. He was one of the most vain and arrogant fools. The defenders of those books may choose whichever side they please, for both are against them. If Moses was not the author, the books have no authority. If he was the author, he has no credibility. To boast of meekness is the opposite of meekness, and the claim is insincere.

In Deuteronomy, the style and manner of writing marks more evidently than in the former books that Moses is not the writer. The manner here used is dramatical; the writer opens the subject by a short introductory discourse, and then introduces Moses as in the act of speaking, and when he has made Moses finish his harrangue, he (the writer) resumes his own part, and speaks till he brings Moses forward again, and at last closes the scene with an account of the death, funeral, and character of Moses.

In Deuteronomy, the writing style shows even more clearly than in the earlier books that Moses is not the author. The writer uses a dramatic style. He opens with a short introduction, then presents Moses speaking. When Moses finishes his speech, the writer resumes his own account. He continues until he brings Moses forward to speak again. Finally, he closes the scene with an account of Moses’s death, funeral, and character.

This interchange of speakers occurs four times in this book: from the first verse of the first chapter, to the end of the fifth verse, it is the writer who speaks; he then introduces Moses as in the act of making his harrangue, and this continues to the end of the 40th verse of the fourth chapter; here the writer drops Moses, and speaks historically of what was done in consequence of what Moses, when living, is supposed to have said, and which the writer has dramatically rehearsed.

The speakers change four times in this book. The writer speaks from the first verse of the first chapter through the fifth verse. He then presents Moses delivering a speech, which continues through the 40th verse of the fourth chapter. At that point, the writer leaves Moses and gives a historical account of what was done as a result of Moses’ supposed words. Moses is supposed to have said these things while he was alive, and the writer has presented them dramatically.

The writer opens the subject again in the first verse of the fifth chapter, though it is only by saying that Moses called the people of Israel together; he then introduces Moses as before, and continues him as in the act of speaking, to the end of the 26th chapter. He does the same thing at the beginning of the 27th chapter; and continues Moses as in the act of speaking, to the end of the 28th chapter. At the 29th chapter the writer speaks again through the whole of the first verse, and the first line of the second verse, where he introduces Moses for the last time, and continues him as in the act of speaking, to the end of the 33d chapter.

The writer returns to the subject in the first verse of chapter 5, though he only says that Moses gathered the people of Israel. He then introduces Moses as before and presents him as speaking through the end of chapter 26. The writer does the same at the beginning of chapter 27, presenting Moses as speaking through the end of chapter 28. In chapter 29, the writer speaks again throughout the first verse and the first line of the second verse. There he introduces Moses for the last time and presents him as speaking through the end of chapter 33.

The writer having now finished the rehearsal on the part of Moses, comes forward, and speaks through the whole of the last chapter: he begins by telling the reader, that Moses went up to the top of Pisgah, that he saw from thence the land which (the writer says) had been promised to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob; that he, Moses, died there in the land of Moab, that he buried him in a valley in the land of Moab, but that no man knoweth of his sepulchre unto this day, that is unto the time in which the writer lived who wrote the book of Deuteronomy. The writer then tells us, that Moses was one hundred and ten years of age when he died—that his eye was not dim, nor his natural force abated; and he concludes by saying, that there arose not a prophet since in Israel like unto Moses, whom, says this anonymous writer, the Lord knew face to face.

The writer has now finished recounting Moses's words. He comes forward and speaks throughout the last chapter. He begins by telling the reader that Moses went up to the top of Pisgah. From there Moses saw the land that, the writer says, had been promised to Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. Moses died there in the land of Moab. The writer says that he buried Moses in a valley in the land of Moab. But no one knows where his grave is to this day. That means the day when the writer of Deuteronomy lived. The writer then tells us that Moses was one hundred and ten years old when he died. His eyesight had not dimmed, and his natural strength had not weakened. The writer concludes by saying that no prophet like Moses has since appeared in Israel. This anonymous writer says that the Lord knew Moses face to face.

Having thus shewn, as far as grammatical evidence implies, that Moses was not the writer of those books, I will, after making a few observations on the inconsistencies of the writer of the book of Deuteronomy, proceed to shew, from the historical and chronological evidence contained in those books, that Moses was not, because he could not be, the writer of them; and consequently, that there is no authority for believing that the inhuman and horrid butcheries of men, women, and children, told of in those books, were done, as those books say they were, at the command of God. It is a duty incumbent on every true deist, that he vindicates the moral justice of God against the calumnies of the Bible.

I have now shown, as far as grammatical evidence can show, that Moses did not write those books. I will make a few observations about inconsistencies in the writing of Deuteronomy. Then I will turn to the historical and chronological evidence in those books. This evidence shows that Moses did not write them because he could not have written them. Therefore, there is no authority for believing that God commanded the inhuman and horrid slaughter of men, women, and children described in those books, as the books claim. Every true deist has a duty to defend God's moral justice against the Bible's slanders.

The writer of the book of Deuteronomy, whoever he was, for it is an anonymous work, is obscure, and also contradictory with himself in the account he has given of Moses.

The book of Deuteronomy is anonymous, so we do not know who wrote it. Its writer is unclear and contradicts himself in his account of Moses.

After telling that Moses went to the top of Pisgah (and it does not appear from any account that he ever came down again) he tells us, that Moses died there in the land of Moab, and that he buried him in a valley in the land of Moab; but as there is no antecedent to the pronoun he, there is no knowing who he was, that did bury him. If the writer meant that he (God) buried him, how should he (the writer) know it? or why should we (the readers) believe him? since we know not who the writer was that tells us so, for certainly Moses could not himself tell where he was buried.

The writer says that Moses went to the top of Pisgah. No account seems to say that he ever came down again. The writer then tells us that Moses died there in the land of Moab, and that he buried him in a valley in the land of Moab. But there is nothing to show who “he” refers to, so there is no way to know who buried Moses. If the writer meant that God buried Moses, how would the writer know? And why should we readers believe him? We do not know who the writer was, and Moses certainly could not have told us where he was buried.

The writer also tells us, that no man knoweth where the sepulchre of Moses is unto this day, meaning the time in which this writer lived; how then should he know that Moses was buried in a valley in the land of Moab? for as the writer lived long after the time of Moses, as is evident from his using the expression of unto this day, meaning a great length of time after the death of Moses, he certainly was not at his funeral; and on the other hand, it is impossible that Moses himself could say that no man knoweth where the sepulchre is unto this day. To make Moses the speaker, would be an improvement on the play of a child that hides himself and cries nobody can find me; nobody can find Moses.

The writer also tells us that no one knows where Moses's tomb is to this day. By “this day,” he means the time when he lived. How, then, could he know that Moses was buried in a valley in the land of Moab? The writer clearly lived long after Moses. His phrase “to this day” shows that a long time had passed since Moses died. So he certainly was not at Moses's funeral. On the other hand, Moses himself could not possibly say that no one knows where his tomb is to this day. To make Moses the speaker would outdo the game of a child who hides and cries, “Nobody can find me. Nobody can find Moses.”

This writer has no where told us how he came by the speeches which he has put into the mouth of Moses to speak, and therefore we have a right to conclude that he either composed them himself, or wrote them from oral tradition. One or other of these is the more probable, since he has given, in the fifth chapter, a table of commandments, in which that called the fourth commandment is different from the fourth commandment in the twentieth chapter of Exodus. In that of Exodus, the reason given for keeping the seventh day is, because (says the commandment) God made the heavens and the earth in six days, and rested on the seventh; but in that of Deuteronomy, the reason given is, that it was the day on which the children of Israel came out of Egypt, and therefore, says this commandment, the Lord thy God commanded thee to keep the sabbath-day This makes no mention of the creation, nor that of the coming out of Egypt. There are also many things given as laws of Moses in this book, that are not to be found in any of the other books; among which is that inhuman and brutal law, xxi. 18, 19, 20, 21, which authorizes parents, the father and the mother, to bring their own children to have them stoned to death for what it pleased them to call stubbornness.—But priests have always been fond of preaching up Deuteronomy, for Deuteronomy preaches up tythes; and it is from this book, xxv. 4, they have taken the phrase, and applied it to tything, that “thou shalt not muzzle the ox when he treadeth Out the corn:” and that this might not escape observation, they have noted it in the table of contents at the head of the chapter, though it is only a single verse of less than two lines. O priests! priests! ye are willing to be compared to an ox, for the sake of tythes. [An elegant pocket edition of Paine’s Theological Works (London. R. Carlile, 1822) has in its title a picture of Paine, as a Moses in evening dress, unfolding the two tables of his “Age of Reason” to a farmer from whom the Bishop of Llandaff (who replied to this work) has taken a sheaf and a lamb which he is carrying to a church at the summit of a well stocked hill.—Editor.]—Though it is impossible for us to know identically who the writer of Deuteronomy was, it is not difficult to discover him professionally, that he was some Jewish priest, who lived, as I shall shew in the course of this work, at least three hundred and fifty years after the time of Moses.

This writer has nowhere told us how he obtained the speeches he has Moses deliver. We therefore have a right to conclude that he either composed them himself or wrote them down from oral tradition. One or the other is more likely because, in the fifth chapter, he gives a list of commandments. The one called the fourth commandment differs from the fourth commandment in the twentieth chapter of Exodus. In Exodus, the commandment gives this reason for keeping the seventh day: God made the heavens and the earth in six days and rested on the seventh. But in Deuteronomy, the reason given is that it was the day the children of Israel came out of Egypt. Therefore, says this commandment, the Lord your God commanded you to keep the Sabbath day. The commandment in Deuteronomy makes no mention of the creation, and the one in Exodus makes no mention of leaving Egypt. This book also gives many laws as laws of Moses that cannot be found in any of the other books. Among them is that inhuman and brutal law in chapter 21, verses 18 to 21. It allows parents, both father and mother, to bring their own children to be stoned to death for whatever they choose to call stubbornness. But priests have always been fond of preaching about Deuteronomy, because Deuteronomy preaches about tithes. They have taken a phrase from this book, chapter 25, verse 4, and applied it to tithing: “You shall not muzzle the ox when it treads out the grain.” So that this would not escape notice, they have included it in the table of contents at the head of the chapter. Yet it is only a single verse of less than two lines. Oh, priests! Priests! You are willing to be compared to an ox for the sake of tithes. [An elegant pocket edition of Paine’s Theological Works (London, R. Carlile, 1822) has a picture on its title page. It shows Paine as a Moses in evening dress, unfolding the two tablets of his “Age of Reason” to a farmer. The Bishop of Llandaff, who replied to this work, has taken a sheaf and a lamb from the farmer. He is carrying them to a church at the top of a well-stocked hill. Editor.] Though we cannot know exactly who wrote Deuteronomy, it is not difficult to discover his profession. He was some Jewish priest who lived at least three hundred and fifty years after Moses, as I shall show in the course of this work.

I come now to speak of the historical and chronological evidence. The chronology that I shall use is the Bible chronology; for I mean not to go out of the Bible for evidence of any thing, but to make the Bible itself prove historically and chronologically that Moses is not the author of the books ascribed to him. It is therefore proper that I inform the readers (such an one at least as may not have the opportunity of knowing it) that in the larger Bibles, and also in some smaller ones, there is a series of chronology printed in the margin of every page for the purpose of showing how long the historical matters stated in each page happened, or are supposed to have happened, before Christ, and consequently the distance of time between one historical circumstance and another.

I now turn to the historical and chronological evidence. I will use the Bible’s chronology, because I do not intend to look outside the Bible for evidence of anything. Instead, I will use the Bible itself to prove historically and chronologically that Moses did not write the books attributed to him. Some readers may not have had a chance to learn how this chronology is presented, so I should explain it. Larger Bibles, and some smaller ones, have a chronology printed in the margin of every page. It shows how long before Christ the events described on each page happened, or are supposed to have happened. It also shows the time between one historical event and another.

I begin with the book of Genesis.—In Genesis xiv., the writer gives an account of Lot being taken prisoner in a battle between the four kings against five, and carried off; and that when the account of Lot being taken came to Abraham, that he armed all his household and marched to rescue Lot from the captors; and that he pursued them unto Dan. (ver. 14.)

I begin with the book of Genesis. In Genesis 14, the writer describes how Lot was captured and carried off in a battle between four kings and five others. When Abraham heard that Lot had been captured, he armed his entire household and marched to rescue him. He pursued Lot’s captors as far as Dan. (verse 14.)

To shew in what manner this expression of Pursuing them unto Dan applies to the case in question, I will refer to two circumstances, the one in America, the other in France. The city now called New York, in America, was originally New Amsterdam; and the town in France, lately called Havre Marat, was before called Havre-de-Grace. New Amsterdam was changed to New York in the year 1664; Havre-de-Grace to Havre Marat in the year 1793. Should, therefore, any writing be found, though without date, in which the name of New-York should be mentioned, it would be certain evidence that such a writing could not have been written before, and must have been written after New Amsterdam was changed to New York, and consequently not till after the year 1664, or at least during the course of that year. And in like manner, any dateless writing, with the name of Havre Marat, would be certain evidence that such a writing must have been written after Havre-de-Grace became Havre Marat, and consequently not till after the year 1793, or at least during the course of that year.

To show how the expression Pursuing them unto Dan applies to the case in question, I will give two examples. One is from America, the other from France. The American city now called New York was originally called New Amsterdam. The French town recently called Havre Marat was previously called Havre-de-Grace. New Amsterdam became New York in 1664. Havre-de-Grace became Havre Marat in 1793. Suppose an undated document were found that mentioned New York. That name would be certain evidence that the document was written after New Amsterdam became New York. It could not have been written before that change. It must therefore have been written after 1664, or at least during that year. Likewise, the name Havre Marat in an undated document would be certain evidence that it was written after Havre-de-Grace became Havre Marat. It must therefore have been written after 1793, or at least during that year.

I now come to the application of those cases, and to show that there was no such place as Dan till many years after the death of Moses; and consequently, that Moses could not be the writer of the book of Genesis, where this account of pursuing them unto Dan is given.

I now turn to how these cases apply. I will show that there was no place called Dan until many years after Moses died. So Moses could not have written the book of Genesis, which tells of the pursuit of them to Dan.

The place that is called Dan in the Bible was originally a town of the Gentiles, called Laish; and when the tribe of Dan seized upon this town, they changed its name to Dan, in commemoration of Dan, who was the father of that tribe, and the great grandson of Abraham.

The place called Dan in the Bible was originally a Gentile town called Laish. When the tribe of Dan seized the town, they renamed it Dan. They named it in honor of Dan, the father of their tribe and Abraham's great-grandson.

To establish this in proof, it is necessary to refer from Genesis to chapter xviii. of the book called the Book of judges. It is there said (ver. 27) that “they (the Danites) came unto Laish to a people that were quiet and secure, and they smote them with the edge of the sword [the Bible is filled with murder] and burned the city with fire; and they built a city, (ver. 28,) and dwelt therein, and [ver. 29,] they called the name of the city Dan, after the name of Dan, their father; howbeit the name of the city was Laish at the first.”

To prove this, we must turn from Genesis to chapter 18 of the book called Judges. Verse 27 says: “They (the Danites) came to Laish, to a people who lived quietly and felt secure. They killed them with the sword [the Bible is filled with murder] and burned the city. They built a city (verse 28) and lived there. And (verse 29) they named the city Dan, after their father Dan. But the city was originally called Laish.”

This account of the Danites taking possession of Laish and changing it to Dan, is placed in the book of Judges immediately after the death of Samson. The death of Samson is said to have happened B.C. 1120 and that of Moses B.C. 1451; and, therefore, according to the historical arrangement, the place was not called Dan till 331 years after the death of Moses.

The account of the Danites taking Laish and renaming it Dan comes immediately after Samson's death in the book of Judges. Samson is said to have died in 1120 B.C. and Moses in 1451 B.C. So, according to this historical timeline, Laish was not called Dan until 331 years after Moses died.

There is a striking confusion between the historical and the chronological arrangement in the book of judges. The last five chapters, as they stand in the book, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, are put chronologically before all the preceding chapters; they are made to be 28 years before the 16th chapter, 266 before the 15th, 245 before the 13th, 195 before the 9th, 90 before the 4th, and 15 years before the 1st chapter. This shews the uncertain and fabulous state of the Bible. According to the chronological arrangement, the taking of Laish, and giving it the name of Dan, is made to be twenty years after the death of Joshua, who was the successor of Moses; and by the historical order, as it stands in the book, it is made to be 306 years after the death of Joshua, and 331 after that of Moses; but they both exclude Moses from being the writer of Genesis, because, according to either of the statements, no such a place as Dan existed in the time of Moses; and therefore the writer of Genesis must have been some person who lived after the town of Laish had the name of Dan; and who that person was nobody knows, and consequently the book of Genesis is anonymous, and without authority.

There is a striking confusion between the historical and chronological order in the book of Judges. The last five chapters, 17, 18, 19, 20, and 21, are placed chronologically before all the preceding chapters. They are dated 28 years before chapter 16, 266 years before chapter 15, and 245 years before chapter 13. They are also dated 195 years before chapter 9, 90 years before chapter 4, and 15 years before chapter 1. This shows how unreliable and full of fables the Bible is. According to the chronological order, Laish was taken and renamed Dan twenty years after the death of Joshua, Moses’s successor. But according to the historical order in the book, this happened 306 years after Joshua’s death and 331 years after Moses’s death. Both accounts rule out Moses as the writer of Genesis. According to either account, no place called Dan existed in Moses’s time. The writer of Genesis must therefore have lived after the town of Laish was named Dan. Nobody knows who that person was. Consequently, the book of Genesis is anonymous and has no authority.

I come now to state another point of historical and chronological evidence, and to show therefrom, as in the preceding case, that Moses is not the author of the book of Genesis.

I now turn to another piece of historical and chronological evidence. As in the previous case, this evidence shows that Moses did not write the book of Genesis.

In Genesis xxxvi. there is given a genealogy of the sons and descendants of Esau, who are called Edomites, and also a list by name of the kings of Edom; in enumerating of which, it is said, verse 31, “And these are the kings that reigned in Edom, before there reigned any king over the children of Israel.”

Genesis 36 gives a family history of the sons and descendants of Esau, who are called Edomites. It also lists the kings of Edom by name. Verse 31 introduces the list: “These are the kings who reigned in Edom before any king reigned over the children of Israel.”

Now, were any dateless writing to be found, in which, speaking of any past events, the writer should say, these things happened before there was any Congress in America, or before there was any Convention in France, it would be evidence that such writing could not have been written before, and could only be written after there was a Congress in America or a Convention in France, as the case might be; and, consequently, that it could not be written by any person who died before there was a Congress in the one country, or a Convention in the other.

Now suppose an undated piece of writing were found. In it, the writer says that past events happened before there was a Congress in America or a Convention in France. That would be evidence that the writing could not have been written before the Congress or Convention existed. It could only have been written afterward, whichever body the writer referred to. Consequently, it could not have been written by anyone who died before the Congress or Convention existed.

Nothing is more frequent, as well in history as in conversation, than to refer to a fact in the room of a date: it is most natural so to do, because a fact fixes itself in the memory better than a date; secondly, because the fact includes the date, and serves to give two ideas at once; and this manner of speaking by circumstances implies as positively that the fact alluded to is past, as if it was so expressed. When a person in speaking upon any matter, says, it was before I was married, or before my son was born, or before I went to America, or before I went to France, it is absolutely understood, and intended to be understood, that he has been married, that he has had a son, that he has been in America, or been in France. Language does not admit of using this mode of expression in any other sense; and whenever such an expression is found anywhere, it can only be understood in the sense in which only it could have been used.

Nothing is more common, in history or conversation, than referring to an event instead of giving a date. This is natural because an event sticks in the memory better than a date. Also, the event includes the date, so it conveys two ideas at once. Referring to circumstances in this way implies just as clearly that the event is past as stating it outright. Suppose someone says that something happened before he married, before his son was born, before he went to America, or before he went to France. It is absolutely understood, and meant to be understood, that he has married, had a son, been to America, or been to France. Language does not allow this way of speaking to mean anything else. Wherever such an expression appears, it can only be understood in the one sense in which it could have been used.

The passage, therefore, that I have quoted—that “these are the kings that reigned in Edom, before there reigned any king over the children of Israel,” could only have been written after the first king began to reign over them; and consequently that the book of Genesis, so far from having been written by Moses, could not have been written till the time of Saul at least. This is the positive sense of the passage; but the expression, any king, implies more kings than one, at least it implies two, and this will carry it to the time of David; and, if taken in a general sense, it carries itself through all times of the Jewish monarchy.

The passage I quoted says, “These are the kings who reigned in Edom before any king reigned over the children of Israel.” Therefore, it could only have been written after the first king began to reign over them. Consequently, Genesis was not written by Moses. It could not have been written until at least the time of Saul. That is what the passage plainly says. But the phrase “any king” implies more than one king, at least two. This would bring it to the time of David. And if taken in a general sense, the phrase extends through the whole period of the Jewish monarchy.

Had we met with this verse in any part of the Bible that professed to have been written after kings began to reign in Israel, it would have been impossible not to have seen the application of it. It happens then that this is the case; the two books of Chronicles, which give a history of all the kings of Israel, are professedly, as well as in fact, written after the Jewish monarchy began; and this verse that I have quoted, and all the remaining verses of Genesis xxxvi. are, word for word, In 1 Chronicles i., beginning at the 43d verse.

If we had found this verse elsewhere in the Bible, in a book claiming to have been written after kings began to reign in Israel, its relevance would have been impossible to miss. And that is precisely the case. The two books of Chronicles give a history of all the kings of Israel. They claim to have been written after the Jewish monarchy began, and they indeed were. The verse I quoted and all the remaining verses of Genesis 36 appear word for word in 1 Chronicles 1, beginning at verse 43.

It was with consistency that the writer of the Chronicles could say as he has said, 1 Chron. i. 43, “These are the kings that reigned in Edom, before there reigned any king over the children of Israel,” because he was going to give, and has given, a list of the kings that had reigned in Israel; but as it is impossible that the same expression could have been used before that period, it is as certain as any thing can be proved from historical language, that this part of Genesis is taken from Chronicles, and that Genesis is not so old as Chronicles, and probably not so old as the book of Homer, or as Æsop’s Fables; admitting Homer to have been, as the tables of chronology state, contemporary with David or Solomon, and Æsop to have lived about the end of the Jewish monarchy.

The writer of Chronicles was consistent when he said in 1 Chron. i. 43, “These are the kings that reigned in Edom, before there reigned any king over the children of Israel.” He was about to give a list of the kings who had reigned in Israel, and he did so. But that same expression could not have been used before Israel had kings. Therefore, it is as certain as historical language can prove anything that this part of Genesis was taken from Chronicles. Genesis is not as old as Chronicles, and probably not as old as the book of Homer or Æsop’s Fables. This assumes that Homer lived at the same time as David or Solomon, as chronological tables state, and that Æsop lived around the end of the Jewish monarchy.

Take away from Genesis the belief that Moses was the author, on which only the strange belief that it is the word of God has stood, and there remains nothing of Genesis but an anonymous book of stories, fables, and traditionary or invented absurdities, or of downright lies. The story of Eve and the serpent, and of Noah and his ark, drops to a level with the Arabian Tales, without the merit of being entertaining, and the account of men living to eight and nine hundred years becomes as fabulous as the immortality of the giants of the Mythology.

Take away the belief that Moses wrote Genesis, and nothing remains but an anonymous book of stories, fables, traditional or invented absurdities, and outright lies. Only that belief has supported the strange idea that Genesis is the word of God. The stories of Eve and the serpent and Noah and his ark fall to the level of the Arabian Tales, without even being entertaining. And the claim that men lived for eight or nine hundred years becomes as fantastic as the immortality of the giants of mythology.

Besides, the character of Moses, as stated in the Bible, is the most horrid that can be imagined. If those accounts be true, he was the wretch that first began and carried on wars on the score or on the pretence of religion; and under that mask, or that infatuation, committed the most unexampled atrocities that are to be found in the history of any nation. Of which I will state only one instance:

Besides, Moses, as described in the Bible, has the most horrible character imaginable. If those accounts are true, he was the wretch who first started and waged wars in the name of religion. Under that cover, or in that state of blind devotion, he committed atrocities unmatched in the history of any nation. I will give just one example:

When the Jewish army returned from one of their plundering and murdering excursions, the account goes on as follows (Numbers xxxi. 13): “And Moses, and Eleazar the priest, and all the princes of the congregation, went forth to meet them without the camp; and Moses was wroth with the officers of the host, with the captains over thousands, and captains over hundreds, which came from the battle; and Moses said unto them, ‘Have ye saved all the women alive?’ behold, these caused the children of Israel, through the counsel of Balaam, to commit trespass against the Lord in the matter of Peor, and there was a plague among the congregation of the Lord. Now therefore, ‘kill every male among the little ones, and kill every woman that hath known a man by lying with him; but all the women-children that have not known a man by lying with him, keep alive for Yourselves.’”

When the Jewish army returned from one of its plundering and murderous raids, the account continues (Numbers 31:13): “Moses, Eleazar the priest, and all the leaders of the congregation went outside the camp to meet them. Moses was angry with the army officers who had returned from battle, the commanders of thousands and of hundreds. Moses said to them, ‘Have you let all the women live?’ These women, on Balaam’s advice, led the children of Israel to sin against the Lord at Peor. As a result, a plague struck the Lord’s congregation. Now, therefore, ‘kill every boy, and kill every woman who has had sexual relations with a man. But keep alive for yourselves all the girls who have not had sexual relations with a man.’”

Among the detestable villains that in any period of the world have disgraced the name of man, it is impossible to find a greater than Moses, if this account be true. Here is an order to butcher the boys, to massacre the mothers, and debauch the daughters.

If this account is true, Moses was the worst of all the hateful villains who have ever disgraced humanity. He orders the boys butchered, the mothers massacred, and the daughters sexually abused.

Let any mother put herself in the situation of those mothers, one child murdered, another destined to violation, and herself in the hands of an executioner: let any daughter put herself in the situation of those daughters, destined as a prey to the murderers of a mother and a brother, and what will be their feelings? It is in vain that we attempt to impose upon nature, for nature will have her course, and the religion that tortures all her social ties is a false religion.

Let any mother imagine herself in the place of those mothers. One child has been murdered, another is destined to be raped, and she herself is in an executioner’s hands. Let any daughter imagine herself in the place of those daughters, destined to become prey to their mother’s and brother’s murderers. What would they feel? It is useless to try to defy nature, for nature will take its course. Any religion that tortures all of nature’s social bonds is a false religion.

After this detestable order, follows an account of the plunder taken, and the manner of dividing it; and here it is that the profaneings of priestly hypocrisy increases the catalogue of crimes. Verse 37, “And the Lord’s tribute of the sheep was six hundred and threescore and fifteen; and the beeves were thirty and six thousand, of which the Lord’s tribute was threescore and twelve; and the asses were thirty thousand, of which the Lord’s tribute was threescore and one; and the persons were sixteen thousand, of which the Lord’s tribute was thirty and two.” In short, the matters contained in this chapter, as well as in many other parts of the Bible, are too horrid for humanity to read, or for decency to hear; for it appears, from the 35th verse of this chapter, that the number of women-children consigned to debauchery by the order of Moses was thirty-two thousand.

After this detestable order comes an account of the plunder and how it was divided. Here, the profane acts of priestly hypocrisy add to the list of crimes. Verse 37: “And the Lord’s share of the sheep was 675. There were 36,000 cattle, of which the Lord’s share was 72. There were 30,000 donkeys, of which the Lord’s share was 61. And there were 16,000 people, of whom the Lord’s share was 32.” In short, the contents of this chapter, like many other parts of the Bible, are too horrific for humanity to read or for decency to hear. For verse 35 shows that Moses ordered 32,000 young girls to be given over to debauchery.

People in general know not what wickedness there is in this pretended word of God. Brought up in habits of superstition, they take it for granted that the Bible is true, and that it is good; they permit themselves not to doubt of it, and they carry the ideas they form of the benevolence of the Almighty to the book which they have been taught to believe was written by his authority. Good heavens! it is quite another thing, it is a book of lies, wickedness, and blasphemy; for what can be greater blasphemy, than to ascribe the wickedness of man to the orders of the Almighty!

Most people do not know how much wickedness there is in this supposed word of God. Raised in superstitious habits, they take it for granted that the Bible is true and good. They do not allow themselves to doubt it. They believe that the Almighty is benevolent, and they extend that belief to the book they were taught he authorized. Good heavens! It is quite another thing. It is a book of lies, wickedness, and blasphemy. What greater blasphemy could there be than to claim that the Almighty ordered people to commit wicked acts?

But to return to my subject, that of showing that Moses is not the author of the books ascribed to him, and that the Bible is spurious. The two instances I have already given would be sufficient, without any additional evidence, to invalidate the authenticity of any book that pretended to be four or five hundred years more ancient than the matters it speaks of, refers to, them as facts; for in the case of pursuing them unto Dan, and of the kings that reigned over the children of Israel; not even the flimsy pretence of prophecy can be pleaded. The expressions are in the preter tense, and it would be downright idiotism to say that a man could prophecy in the preter tense.

But to return to my subject: I am showing that Moses did not write the books attributed to him and that the Bible is not authentic. The two examples I have already given would be enough, without further evidence, to discredit any book claiming to be four or five hundred years older than events it refers to as facts. In the cases of the pursuit to Dan and the kings who ruled the children of Israel, not even the flimsy excuse of prophecy can be offered. The passages are written in the past tense. It would be downright idiotic to say that a man could prophesy in the past tense.

But there are many other passages scattered throughout those books that unite in the same point of evidence. It is said in Exodus, (another of the books ascribed to Moses,) xvi. 35: “And the children of Israel did eat manna until they came to a land inhabited; they did eat manna until they came unto the borders of the land of Canaan.”

But many other passages scattered throughout those books provide evidence for the same point. Exodus is another book attributed to Moses. Exodus 16:35 says: “The children of Israel ate manna until they came to a land where people lived. They ate manna until they reached the borders of the land of Canaan.”

Whether the children of Israel ate manna or not, or what manna was, or whether it was anything more than a kind of fungus or small mushroom, or other vegetable substance common to that part of the country, makes no part of my argument; all that I mean to show is, that it is not Moses that could write this account, because the account extends itself beyond the life time of Moses. Moses, according to the Bible, (but it is such a book of lies and contradictions there is no knowing which part to believe, or whether any) died in the wilderness, and never came upon the borders of ‘the land of Canaan; and consequently, it could not be he that said what the children of Israel did, or what they ate when they came there. This account of eating manna, which they tell us was written by Moses, extends itself to the time of Joshua, the successor of Moses, as appears by the account given in the book of Joshua, after the children of Israel had passed the river Jordan, and came into the borders of the land of Canaan. Joshua, v. 12: “And the manna ceased on the morrow, after they had eaten of the old corn of the land; neither had the children of Israel manna any more, but they did eat of the fruit of the land of Canaan that year.”

Whether the children of Israel ate manna is no part of my argument. Nor does it matter what manna was. It may have been nothing more than a fungus, a small mushroom, or another vegetable substance common to that region. I only mean to show that Moses could not have written this account, because it extends beyond his lifetime. According to the Bible, Moses died in the wilderness and never reached the borders of the land of Canaan. But the Bible is such a book of lies and contradictions that there is no knowing which part to believe, or whether to believe any of it. Since Moses never reached Canaan, he could not have said what the children of Israel did or ate there. We are told that Moses wrote this account of eating manna. Yet the account extends to the time of Joshua, Moses’ successor. This is clear from the book of Joshua, after the children of Israel had crossed the river Jordan and reached the borders of the land of Canaan. Joshua 5:12: “The manna stopped the next day, after they had eaten the old grain of the land. The children of Israel had no more manna, but ate the produce of the land of Canaan that year.”

But a more remarkable instance than this occurs in Deuteronomy; which, while it shows that Moses could not be the writer of that book, shows also the fabulous notions that prevailed at that time about giants’ In Deuteronomy iii. 11, among the conquests said to be made by Moses, is an account of the taking of Og, king of Bashan: “For only Og, king of Bashan, remained of the race of giants; behold, his bedstead was a bedstead of iron; is it not in Rabbath of the children of Ammon? nine cubits was the length thereof, and four cubits the breadth of it, after the cubit of a man.” A cubit is 1 foot 9 888/1000 inches; the length therefore of the bed was 16 feet 4 inches, and the breadth 7 feet 4 inches: thus much for this giant’s bed. Now for the historical part, which, though the evidence is not so direct and positive as in the former cases, is nevertheless very presumable and corroborating evidence, and is better than the best evidence on the contrary side.

But a more remarkable example appears in Deuteronomy. It shows that Moses could not have written the book. It also shows the fabulous ideas about giants that prevailed at the time. Deuteronomy iii. 11 describes the capture of Og, king of Bashan, among the conquests attributed to Moses: “For only Og, king of Bashan, remained of the race of giants. Look, his bedstead was made of iron. Is it not in Rabbath of the children of Ammon? It was nine cubits long and four cubits wide, measured by the cubit of a man.” A cubit is 1 foot 9 888/1000 inches. The bed was therefore 16 feet 4 inches long and 7 feet 4 inches wide. So much for this giant’s bed. Now for the historical part. The evidence is not as direct and definite as in the earlier cases. Even so, it is highly plausible and supports the argument. It is better than the best evidence on the other side.

The writer, by way of proving the existence of this giant, refers to his bed, as an ancient relick, and says, is it not in Rabbath (or Rabbah) of the children of Ammon? meaning that it is; for such is frequently the bible method of affirming a thing. But it could not be Moses that said this, because Moses could know nothing about Rabbah, nor of what was in it. Rabbah was not a city belonging to this giant king, nor was it one of the cities that Moses took. The knowledge therefore that this bed was at Rabbah, and of the particulars of its dimensions, must be referred to the time when Rabbah was taken, and this was not till four hundred years after the death of Moses; for which, see 2 Sam. xii. 26: “And Joab [David’s general] fought against Rabbah of the children of Ammon, and took the royal city,” etc.

To prove that this giant existed, the writer points to his bed as an ancient relic. He asks, is it not in Rabbath (or Rabbah) of the children of Ammon? He means that it is there. The Bible often uses this method to affirm something. But Moses could not have said this, because he could have known nothing about Rabbah or what was in it. Rabbah was not a city belonging to this giant king, nor was it one of the cities Moses took. So the knowledge that the bed was at Rabbah, and the details of its dimensions, must date from Rabbah’s capture. That did not happen until four hundred years after Moses died. See 2 Sam. xii. 26: “And Joab [David’s general] fought against Rabbah of the children of Ammon, and took the royal city,” etc.

As I am not undertaking to point out all the contradictions in time, place, and circumstance that abound in the books ascribed to Moses, and which prove to demonstration that those books could not be written by Moses, nor in the time of Moses, I proceed to the book of Joshua, and to shew that Joshua is not the author of that book, and that it is anonymous and without authority. The evidence I shall produce is contained in the book itself: I will not go out of the Bible for proof against the supposed authenticity of the Bible. False testimony is always good against itself.

I do not intend to point out every contradiction of time, place, and circumstance in the books attributed to Moses. These books are full of contradictions. They prove beyond doubt that Moses could not have written them, nor could they have been written in his time. So I move on to the book of Joshua. I will show that Joshua did not write it, and that it is anonymous and has no authority. The evidence I will present is in the book itself. I will not look outside the Bible for proof against its supposed authenticity. False testimony always serves as evidence against itself.

Joshua, according to Joshua i., was the immediate successor of Moses; he was, moreover, a military man, which Moses was not; and he continued as chief of the people of Israel twenty-five years; that is, from the time that Moses died, which, according to the Bible chronology, was B.C. 1451, until B.C. 1426, when, according to the same chronology, Joshua died. If, therefore, we find in this book, said to have been written by Joshua, references to facts done after the death of Joshua, it is evidence that Joshua could not be the author; and also that the book could not have been written till after the time of the latest fact which it records. As to the character of the book, it is horrid; it is a military history of rapine and murder, as savage and brutal as those recorded of his predecessor in villainy and hypocrisy, Moses; and the blasphemy consists, as in the former books, in ascribing those deeds to the orders of the Almighty.

According to Joshua i., Joshua was Moses’s immediate successor. Unlike Moses, he was also a military man. He led the people of Israel for twenty-five years, from Moses’s death until his own. According to the Bible’s chronology, Moses died in 1451 B.C. and Joshua died in 1426 B.C. So if this book, said to have been written by Joshua, refers to events after his death, that is evidence that Joshua could not have written it. It is also evidence that the book could not have been written until after the latest event it records. As for the character of the book, it is horrific. It is a military history of plunder and murder, as savage and brutal as the deeds recorded of Moses, Joshua’s predecessor in villainy and hypocrisy. As in the earlier books, the blasphemy lies in claiming that the Almighty ordered these deeds.

In the first place, the book of Joshua, as is the case in the preceding books, is written in the third person; it is the historian of Joshua that speaks, for it would have been absurd and vainglorious that Joshua should say of himself, as is said of him in the last verse of the sixth chapter, that “his fame was noised throughout all the country.”—I now come more immediately to the proof.

First, the book of Joshua, like the preceding books, is written in the third person. Joshua's historian is the one speaking. It would have been absurd and boastful for Joshua to say what the last verse of the sixth chapter says about him: “his fame spread throughout the whole country.” I now come more directly to the proof.

In Joshua xxiv. 31, it is said “And Israel served the Lord all the days of Joshua, and all the days of the elders that over-lived Joshua.” Now, in the name of common sense, can it be Joshua that relates what people had done after he was dead? This account must not only have been written by some historian that lived after Joshua, but that lived also after the elders that out-lived Joshua.

In Joshua 24:31, it says, “And Israel served the Lord all the days of Joshua, and all the days of the elders who outlived Joshua.” Now, in the name of common sense, could Joshua have described what people did after he was dead? This account must have been written by a historian who lived after Joshua. The historian must also have lived after the elders who outlived Joshua.

There are several passages of a general meaning with respect to time, scattered throughout the book of Joshua, that carries the time in which the book was written to a distance from the time of Joshua, but without marking by exclusion any particular time, as in the passage above quoted. In that passage, the time that intervened between the death of Joshua and the death of the elders is excluded descriptively and absolutely, and the evidence substantiates that the book could not have been written till after the death of the last.

Several passages scattered throughout the book of Joshua give a general indication of when it was written. They show that it was written long after Joshua’s time. But unlike the passage quoted above, they do not rule out any particular period. The passage quoted above clearly and completely rules out the period between Joshua’s death and the death of the elders. The evidence shows that the book could not have been written until after the last elder died.

But though the passages to which I allude, and which I am going to quote, do not designate any particular time by exclusion, they imply a time far more distant from the days of Joshua than is contained between the death of Joshua and the death of the elders. Such is the passage, x. 14, where, after giving an account that the sun stood still upon Gibeon, and the moon in the valley of Ajalon, at the command of Joshua, (a tale only fit to amuse children) [NOTE: This tale of the sun standing still upon Motint Gibeon, and the moon in the valley of Ajalon, is one of those fables that detects itself. Such a circumstance could not have happened without being known all over the world. One half would have wondered why the sun did not rise, and the other why it did not set; and the tradition of it would be universal; whereas there is not a nation in the world that knows anything about it. But why must the moon stand still? What occasion could there be for moonlight in the daytime, and that too whilst the sun shined? As a poetical figure, the whole is well enough; it is akin to that in the song of Deborah and Barak, The stars in their courses fought against Sisera; but it is inferior to the figurative declaration of Mahomet to the persons who came to expostulate with him on his goings on, Wert thou, said he, to come to me with the sun in thy right hand and the moon in thy left, it should not alter my career. For Joshua to have exceeded Mahomet, he should have put the sun and moon, one in each pocket, and carried them as Guy Faux carried his dark lanthorn, and taken them out to shine as he might happen to want them. The sublime and the ridiculous are often so nearly related that it is difficult to class them separately. One step above the sublime makes the ridiculous, and one step above the ridiculous makes the sublime again; the account, however, abstracted from the poetical fancy, shews the ignorance of Joshua, for he should have commanded the earth to have stood still.—Author.] the passage says: “And there was no day like that, before it, nor after it, that the Lord hearkened to the voice of a man.”

The passages I mean to quote do not rule out any particular date. But they imply a time much further removed from Joshua’s days than the period between his death and the elders’ deaths. One such passage is Joshua 10:14. It follows the account of how the sun stood still over Gibeon and the moon over the valley of Ajalon at Joshua’s command. That is a story fit only to amuse children. [NOTE: This story of the sun standing still over Mount Gibeon and the moon over the valley of Ajalon is a fable that gives itself away. Such an event could not have happened without being known all over the world. One half of the world would have wondered why the sun did not rise, and the other why it did not set. The story would have been passed down everywhere. Yet not a nation in the world knows anything about it. But why did the moon have to stand still? Why would anyone need moonlight in the daytime, especially while the sun was shining? As a poetic figure, the whole thing is good enough. It is like the line in the song of Deborah and Barak: The stars in their courses fought against Sisera. But it falls short of Mahomet’s figurative declaration to the people who came to protest against his actions. “If you came to me with the sun in your right hand and the moon in your left,” he said, “it would not change my course.” To surpass Mahomet, Joshua should have put the sun and moon in his pockets, one in each. He could have carried them as Guy Faux carried his dark lantern, taking them out to shine whenever he needed them. The sublime and the ridiculous are often so closely related that it is difficult to put them in separate categories. One step above the sublime makes the ridiculous, and one step above the ridiculous makes the sublime again. But if we set aside the poetic fancy, the account shows Joshua’s ignorance. He should have commanded the earth to stand still. Author.] The passage says: “And there was no day like that, before or after it, when the Lord listened to the voice of a man.”

The time implied by the expression after it, that is, after that day, being put in comparison with all the time that passed before it, must, in order to give any expressive signification to the passage, mean a great length of time:—for example, it would have been ridiculous to have said so the next day, or the next week, or the next month, or the next year; to give therefore meaning to the passage, comparative with the wonder it relates, and the prior time it alludes to, it must mean centuries of years; less however than one would be trifling, and less than two would be barely admissible.

The expression after it means after that day. Compared with all the time that passed before that day, it must mean a very long time. Otherwise, the passage would have no real meaning. For example, it would have been ridiculous to say this the next day, week, month, or year. To give the passage meaning, its time span must match the wonder it describes and the earlier time it refers to. It must therefore mean centuries. Anything less than one century would be trivial, and less than two would barely be acceptable.

A distant, but general time is also expressed in chapter viii.; where, after giving an account of the taking the city of Ai, it is said, ver. 28th, “And Joshua burned Ai, and made it an heap for ever, a desolation unto this day;” and again, ver. 29, where speaking of the king of Ai, whom Joshua had hanged, and buried at the entering of the gate, it is said, “And he raised thereon a great heap of stones, which remaineth unto this day,” that is, unto the day or time in which the writer of the book of Joshua lived. And again, in chapter x. where, after speaking of the five kings whom Joshua had hanged on five trees, and then thrown in a cave, it is said, “And he laid great stones on the cave’s mouth, which remain unto this very day.”

Chapter 8 also refers generally to a distant time. After describing the capture of Ai, verse 28 says: “And Joshua burned Ai and made it a heap of ruins forever, a desolation to this day.” Again, verse 29 speaks of the king of Ai, whom Joshua had hanged and buried at the city gate. It says: “And he raised a great heap of stones over him, which remains to this day.” That means the day or time when the writer of the book of Joshua lived. Again, chapter 10 speaks of the five kings Joshua had hanged on five trees and then thrown into a cave. It says: “And he laid great stones at the mouth of the cave, which remain to this very day.”

In enumerating the several exploits of Joshua, and of the tribes, and of the places which they conquered or attempted, it is said, xv. 63, “As for the Jebusites, the inhabitants of Jerusalem, the children of Judah could not drive them out; but the Jebusites dwell with the children of Judah AT JERUSALEM unto this day.” The question upon this passage is, At what time did the Jebusites and the children of Judah dwell together at Jerusalem? As this matter occurs again in judges i. I shall reserve my observations till I come to that part.

The book lists the exploits of Joshua and the tribes, and the places they conquered or attempted to conquer. It says in xv. 63, “The children of Judah could not drive out the Jebusites, who lived in Jerusalem. But the Jebusites live with the children of Judah AT JERUSALEM to this day.” The question is: When did the Jebusites and the children of Judah live together in Jerusalem? This matter comes up again in Judges i, so I will save my observations until I reach that part.

Having thus shewn from the book of Joshua itself, without any auxiliary evidence whatever, that Joshua is not the author of that book, and that it is anonymous, and consequently without authority, I proceed, as before-mentioned, to the book of Judges.

I have shown from the book of Joshua itself, without any other evidence, that Joshua did not write it. The book is anonymous and therefore has no authority. I now turn, as I said I would, to the book of Judges.

The book of Judges is anonymous on the face of it; and, therefore, even the pretence is wanting to call it the word of God; it has not so much as a nominal voucher; it is altogether fatherless.

The book of Judges is plainly anonymous. So there is not even a pretense for calling it the word of God. It does not have even a named person to vouch for it. It is entirely fatherless.

This book begins with the same expression as the book of Joshua. That of Joshua begins, chap i. 1, Now after the death of Moses, etc., and this of the Judges begins, Now after the death of Joshua, etc. This, and the similarity of stile between the two books, indicate that they are the work of the same author; but who he was, is altogether unknown; the only point that the book proves is that the author lived long after the time of Joshua; for though it begins as if it followed immediately after his death, the second chapter is an epitome or abstract of the whole book, which, according to the Bible chronology, extends its history through a space of 306 years; that is, from the death of Joshua, B.C. 1426 to the death of Samson, B.C. 1120, and only 25 years before Saul went to seek his father’s asses, and was made king. But there is good reason to believe, that it was not written till the time of David, at least, and that the book of Joshua was not written before the same time.

This book begins with the same words as the book of Joshua. Joshua begins in chapter 1, verse 1: Now after the death of Moses, etc. Judges begins: Now after the death of Joshua, etc. This similarity, along with their similar styles, suggests that the two books were written by the same author. But who that author was is completely unknown. The only thing the book proves is that its author lived long after Joshua. It begins as if it follows immediately after his death. But the second chapter summarizes the whole book, which, according to biblical chronology, covers 306 years. That is, it runs from Joshua’s death in 1426 B.C. to Samson’s death in 1120 B.C. Samson’s death was only 25 years before Saul went looking for his father’s donkeys and was made king. But there is good reason to believe that Judges was not written until at least the time of David. There is also good reason to believe that Joshua was not written before then.

In Judges i., the writer, after announcing the death of Joshua, proceeds to tell what happened between the children of Judah and the native inhabitants of the land of Canaan. In this statement the writer, having abruptly mentioned Jerusalem in the 7th verse, says immediately after, in the 8th verse, by way of explanation, “Now the children of Judah had fought against Jerusalem, and taken it;” consequently this book could not have been written before Jerusalem had been taken. The reader will recollect the quotation I have just before made from Joshua xv. 63, where it said that the Jebusites dwell with the children of Judah at Jerusalem at this day; meaning the time when the book of Joshua was written.

In Judges 1, the writer announces the death of Joshua. He then describes what happened between the children of Judah and the native inhabitants of Canaan. After suddenly mentioning Jerusalem in verse 7, the writer immediately explains in verse 8: “Now the children of Judah had fought against Jerusalem and taken it.” So this book could not have been written before Jerusalem was taken. The reader will recall the passage I just quoted from Joshua 15:63. It says that the Jebusites live with the children of Judah in Jerusalem “at this day.” This means at the time when the book of Joshua was written.

The evidence I have already produced to prove that the books I have hitherto treated of were not written by the persons to whom they are ascribed, nor till many years after their death, if such persons ever lived, is already so abundant, that I can afford to admit this passage with less weight than I am entitled to draw from it. For the case is, that so far as the Bible can be credited as an history, the city of Jerusalem was not taken till the time of David; and consequently, that the book of Joshua, and of Judges, were not written till after the commencement of the reign of David, which was 370 years after the death of Joshua.

I have already presented abundant evidence that the books I have discussed were not written by their supposed authors. They were not written until many years after those authors died, if they ever lived at all. So I can afford to give this passage less weight than it deserves. For as far as the Bible can be trusted as history, Jerusalem was not captured until David’s time. The books of Joshua and Judges were therefore not written until after David began to reign. That was 370 years after Joshua’s death.

The name of the city that was afterward called Jerusalem was originally Jebus, or Jebusi, and was the capital of the Jebusites. The account of David’s taking this city is given in 2 Samuel, v. 4, etc.; also in 1 Chron. xiv. 4, etc. There is no mention in any part of the Bible that it was ever taken before, nor any account that favours such an opinion. It is not said, either in Samuel or in Chronicles, that they “utterly destroyed men, women and children, that they left not a soul to breathe,” as is said of their other conquests; and the silence here observed implies that it was taken by capitulation; and that the Jebusites, the native inhabitants, continued to live in the place after it was taken. The account therefore, given in Joshua, that “the Jebusites dwell with the children of Judah” at Jerusalem at this day, corresponds to no other time than after taking the city by David.

The city later called Jerusalem was originally named Jebus, or Jebusi. It was the capital of the Jebusites. The account of David’s capture of the city appears in 2 Samuel, v. 4, and following verses. It also appears in 1 Chron. xiv. 4, and following verses. Nowhere does the Bible say the city had ever been taken before. Nor does it give any account that supports that idea. Neither Samuel nor Chronicles says that they “utterly destroyed men, women and children, that they left not a soul to breathe,” as is said of their other conquests. This silence suggests that the city surrendered. It also suggests that the Jebusites, its native inhabitants, continued to live there after its capture. Joshua says that “the Jebusites dwell with the children of Judah” in Jerusalem at this day. This account therefore fits no other time than the period after David took the city.

Having now shown that every book in the Bible, from Genesis to Judges, is without authenticity, I come to the book of Ruth, an idle, bungling story, foolishly told, nobody knows by whom, about a strolling country-girl creeping slily to bed to her cousin Boaz. [The text of Ruth does not imply the unpleasant sense Paine’s words are likely to convey.—Editor.] Pretty stuff indeed to be called the word of God. It is, however, one of the best books in the Bible, for it is free from murder and rapine.

I have now shown that every book in the Bible, from Genesis to Judges, lacks authenticity. I come now to the book of Ruth. It is a pointless, badly written story, foolishly told by nobody knows who. It tells of a wandering country girl who sneaks into bed with her cousin Boaz. [The text of Ruth does not suggest the unpleasant meaning Paine’s words are likely to convey. Editor.] Fine stuff indeed to call the word of God. It is, however, one of the best books in the Bible, because it contains no murder or plunder.

I come next to the two books of Samuel, and to shew that those books were not written by Samuel, nor till a great length of time after the death of Samuel; and that they are, like all the former books, anonymous, and without authority.

I turn next to the two books of Samuel. I will show that Samuel did not write them. They were written a long time after his death. Like all the earlier books, they are anonymous and have no authority.

To be convinced that these books have been written much later than the time of Samuel, and consequently not by him, it is only necessary to read the account which the writer gives of Saul going to seek his father’s asses, and of his interview with Samuel, of whom Saul went to enquire about those lost asses, as foolish people now-a-days go to a conjuror to enquire after lost things.

To see that these books were written long after Samuel’s time, and therefore not by him, one need only read one account. It tells how Saul went looking for his father’s donkeys and met Samuel. Saul went to ask Samuel about the lost donkeys, just as foolish people now go to a fortune teller to ask about lost things.

The writer, in relating this story of Saul, Samuel, and the asses, does not tell it as a thing that had just then happened, but as an ancient story in the time this writer lived; for he tells it in the language or terms used at the time that Samuel lived, which obliges the writer to explain the story in the terms or language used in the time the writer lived.

The writer tells the story of Saul, Samuel, and the donkeys as an ancient story, not as something that had just happened. He uses the language of Samuel’s time, so he must explain the story in the language of his own time.

Samuel, in the account given of him in the first of those books, chap. ix. 13 called the seer; and it is by this term that Saul enquires after him, ver. 11, “And as they [Saul and his servant] went up the hill to the city, they found young maidens going out to draw water; and they said unto them, Is the seer here?” Saul then went according to the direction of these maidens, and met Samuel without knowing him, and said unto him, ver. 18, “Tell me, I pray thee, where the seer’s house is? and Samuel answered Saul, and said, I am the seer.”

In the account of Samuel in the first of those books, chapter 9, verse 13, he is called the seer. Saul uses this term when he asks for Samuel in verse 11: “As they [Saul and his servant] went up the hill to the city, they met young women going out to draw water. They asked them, Is the seer here?” Saul followed the young women’s directions and met Samuel, but did not recognize him. In verse 18, he said to Samuel, “Please tell me where the seer’s house is. Samuel answered Saul, I am the seer.”

As the writer of the book of Samuel relates these questions and answers, in the language or manner of speaking used in the time they are said to have been spoken, and as that manner of speaking was out of use when this author wrote, he found it necessary, in order to make the story understood, to explain the terms in which these questions and answers are spoken; and he does this in the 9th verse, where he says, “Before-time in Israel, when a man went to enquire of God, thus he spake, Come let us go to the seer; for he that is now called a prophet, was before-time called a seer.” This proves, as I have before said, that this story of Saul, Samuel, and the asses, was an ancient story at the time the book of Samuel was written, and consequently that Samuel did not write it, and that the book is without authenticity.

The writer of the book of Samuel tells these questions and answers in the language supposedly used at the time. That way of speaking had fallen out of use by the time the author wrote. So he found it necessary to explain the terms to make the story understandable. He does this in verse 9, where he says, “In earlier times in Israel, when a man went to consult God, he would say, Come, let us go to the seer. For someone now called a prophet was formerly called a seer.” As I have said before, this proves that the story of Saul, Samuel, and the donkeys was already ancient when the book of Samuel was written. Consequently, Samuel did not write the book, and the book lacks authenticity.

But if we go further into those books the evidence is still more positive that Samuel is not the writer of them; for they relate things that did not happen till several years after the death of Samuel. Samuel died before Saul; for i Samuel, xxviii. tells, that Saul and the witch of Endor conjured Samuel up after he was dead; yet the history of matters contained in those books is extended through the remaining part of Saul’s life, and to the latter end of the life of David, who succeeded Saul. The account of the death and burial of Samuel (a thing which he could not write himself) is related in i Samuel xxv.; and the chronology affixed to this chapter makes this to be B.C. 1060; yet the history of this first book is brought down to B.C. 1056, that is, to the death of Saul, which was not till four years after the death of Samuel.

But if we look further into those books, the evidence is even clearer that Samuel did not write them. They describe events that did not happen until several years after Samuel’s death. Samuel died before Saul. In 1 Samuel 28, Saul and the witch of Endor summon Samuel after his death. Yet the books continue the history through the rest of Saul’s life. They also cover nearly all the life of David, who succeeded Saul. The account of Samuel’s death and burial appears in 1 Samuel 25. Samuel could not have written that account himself. The chronology attached to the chapter dates his death to 1060 B.C. Yet the first book continues the history to 1056 B.C., when Saul died. That was four years after Samuel’s death.

The second book of Samuel begins with an account of things that did not happen till four years after Samuel was dead; for it begins with the reign of David, who succeeded Saul, and it goes on to the end of David’s reign, which was forty-three years after the death of Samuel; and, therefore, the books are in themselves positive evidence that they were not written by Samuel.

The second book of Samuel begins with events that happened only four years after Samuel died. It begins with the reign of David, who succeeded Saul, and continues to the end of David’s reign. That was forty-three years after Samuel’s death. The books themselves are therefore positive evidence that Samuel did not write them.

I have now gone through all the books in the first part of the Bible, to which the names of persons are affixed, as being the authors of those books, and which the church, styling itself the Christian church, have imposed upon the world as the writings of Moses, Joshua and Samuel; and I have detected and proved the falsehood of this imposition.—And now ye priests, of every description, who have preached and written against the former part of the ‘Age of Reason,’ what have ye to say? Will ye with all this mass of evidence against you, and staring you in the face, still have the assurance to march into your pulpits, and continue to impose these books on your congregations, as the works of inspired penmen and the word of God? when it is as evident as demonstration can make truth appear, that the persons who ye say are the authors, are not the authors, and that ye know not who the authors are. What shadow of pretence have ye now to produce for continuing the blasphemous fraud? What have ye still to offer against the pure and moral religion of deism, in support of your system of falsehood, idolatry, and pretended revelation? Had the cruel and murdering orders, with which the Bible is filled, and the numberless torturing executions of men, women, and children, in consequence of those orders, been ascribed to some friend, whose memory you revered, you would have glowed with satisfaction at detecting the falsehood of the charge, and gloried in defending his injured fame. It is because ye are sunk in the cruelty of superstition, or feel no interest in the honour of your Creator, that ye listen to the horrid tales of the Bible, or hear them with callous indifference. The evidence I have produced, and shall still produce in the course of this work, to prove that the Bible is without authority, will, whilst it wounds the stubbornness of a priest, relieve and tranquillize the minds of millions: it will free them from all those hard thoughts of the Almighty which priestcraft and the Bible had infused into their minds, and which stood in everlasting opposition to all their ideas of his moral justice and benevolence.

I have now examined all the books in the first part of the Bible that bear the names of supposed authors. The church, calling itself the Christian church, has imposed these books on the world as the writings of Moses, Joshua, and Samuel. I have exposed and proved this claim false. And now, priests of every kind, who have preached and written against the first part of ‘The Age of Reason,’ what do you have to say? With all this evidence staring you in the face, will you still dare to enter your pulpits? Will you continue to present these books to your congregations as the works of inspired writers and the word of God? It is as clear as proof can make it that the people you name as authors did not write them. And you do not know who the authors are. What shred of an excuse can you now offer for continuing this blasphemous fraud? What more can you say against the pure and moral religion of deism to defend your system of lies, idolatry, and pretended revelation? Suppose the cruel and murderous orders that fill the Bible had been attributed to a friend whose memory you revered. Suppose, too, that your friend had been blamed for the countless executions of men, women, and children tortured under those orders. You would have been delighted to expose the accusation as false. You would have been proud to defend your friend’s damaged reputation. You listen to the Bible’s horrible stories, or hear them with callous indifference, because you are sunk in the cruelty of superstition or care nothing for your Creator’s honor. The evidence I have presented, and will continue to present in this work, proves that the Bible has no authority. While this evidence wounds the stubbornness of a priest, it will bring relief and peace to the minds of millions. It will free them from all the harsh thoughts about the Almighty that priestcraft and the Bible had planted in their minds. Those thoughts were forever at odds with all their ideas of his moral justice and goodness.

I come now to the two books of Kings, and the two books of Chronicles.—Those books are altogether historical, and are chiefly confined to the lives and actions of the Jewish kings, who in general were a parcel of rascals: but these are matters with which we have no more concern than we have with the Roman emperors, or Homer’s account of the Trojan war. Besides which, as those books are anonymous, and as we know nothing of the writer, or of his character, it is impossible for us to know what degree of credit to give to the matters related therein. Like all other ancient histories, they appear to be a jumble of fable and of fact, and of probable and of improbable things, but which distance of time and place, and change of circumstances in the world, have rendered obsolete and uninteresting.

I now come to the two books of Kings and the two books of Chronicles. These books are entirely historical. They deal mainly with the lives and actions of the Jewish kings, who were generally a bunch of rascals. But these matters concern us no more than the Roman emperors or Homer’s account of the Trojan war. Besides, these books are anonymous. We know nothing about their writer or his character, so we cannot know how much to trust their accounts. Like all other ancient histories, they appear to be a jumble of fable and fact, of likely and unlikely events. But time, distance, and changes in the world have made them outdated and uninteresting.

The chief use I shall make of those books will be that of comparing them with each other, and with other parts of the Bible, to show the confusion, contradiction, and cruelty in this pretended word of God.

I will mainly compare these books with each other and with other parts of the Bible. This will show the confusion, contradictions, and cruelty in this supposed word of God.

The first book of Kings begins with the reign of Solomon, which, according to the Bible chronology, was B.C. 1015; and the second book ends B.C. 588, being a little after the reign of Zedekiah, whom Nebuchadnezzar, after taking Jerusalem and conquering the Jews, carried captive to Babylon. The two books include a space of 427 years.

The first book of Kings begins with Solomon's reign. According to the Bible's chronology, his reign began in 1015 BC. The second book ends in 588 BC, shortly after Zedekiah's reign. After taking Jerusalem and conquering the Jews, Nebuchadnezzar took Zedekiah captive to Babylon. The two books cover 427 years.

The two books of Chronicles are an history of the same times, and in general of the same persons, by another author; for it would be absurd to suppose that the same author wrote the history twice over. The first book of Chronicles (after giving the genealogy from Adam to Saul, which takes up the first nine chapters) begins with the reign of David; and the last book ends, as in the last book of Kings, soon, after the reign of Zedekiah, about B.C. 588. The last two verses of the last chapter bring the history 52 years more forward, that is, to 536. But these verses do not belong to the book, as I shall show when I come to speak of the book of Ezra.

The two books of Chronicles cover the same period and generally the same people, but they are by another author. It would be absurd to suppose that the same author wrote the history twice. The first nine chapters of the first book of Chronicles trace the genealogy from Adam to Saul. The history then begins with the reign of David. Like the last book of Kings, the last book of Chronicles ends soon after the reign of Zedekiah, around 588 B.C. The last two verses of the final chapter bring the history forward another 52 years, to 536 B.C. But these verses do not belong to the book, as I will show when I discuss the book of Ezra.

The two books of Kings, besides the history of Saul, David, and Solomon, who reigned over all Israel, contain an abstract of the lives of seventeen kings, and one queen, who are stiled kings of Judah; and of nineteen, who are stiled kings of Israel; for the Jewish nation, immediately on the death of Solomon, split into two parties, who chose separate kings, and who carried on most rancorous wars against each other.

The two books of Kings tell the history of Saul, David, and Solomon, who ruled over all Israel. They also summarize the lives of seventeen kings and one queen, all called rulers of Judah. They summarize the lives of nineteen rulers called kings of Israel. This was because the Jewish nation split into two parties immediately after Solomon’s death. Each party chose its own kings, and they fought bitter wars against each other.

These two books are little more than a history of assassinations, treachery, and wars. The cruelties that the Jews had accustomed themselves to practise on the Canaanites, whose country they had savagely invaded, under a pretended gift from God, they afterwards practised as furiously on each other. Scarcely half their kings died a natural death, and in some instances whole families were destroyed to secure possession to the successor, who, after a few years, and sometimes only a few months, or less, shared the same fate. In 2 Kings x., an account is given of two baskets full of children’s heads, seventy in number, being exposed at the entrance of the city; they were the children of Ahab, and were murdered by the orders of Jehu, whom Elisha, the pretended man of God, had anointed to be king over Israel, on purpose to commit this bloody deed, and assassinate his predecessor. And in the account of the reign of Menahem, one of the kings of Israel who had murdered Shallum, who had reigned but one month, it is said, 2 Kings xv. 16, that Menahem smote the city of Tiphsah, because they opened not the city to him, and all the women therein that were with child he ripped up.

These two books are little more than a history of assassinations, treachery, and wars. The Jews had become accustomed to practicing cruelty on the Canaanites. They had savagely invaded the Canaanites’ country, claiming that God had given it to them. Later, they practiced the same cruelty just as furiously on one another. Hardly half their kings died a natural death. In some cases, whole families were destroyed to secure the throne for a successor. After a few years, and sometimes only a few months or less, the successor met the same fate. In 2 Kings 10, there is an account of two baskets filled with children’s heads, seventy in all. They were displayed at the entrance to the city. The children were Ahab’s, and they were murdered on Jehu’s orders. Elisha, the supposed man of God, had anointed Jehu king over Israel. He did so specifically to have Jehu commit this bloody deed and assassinate his predecessor. The account of Menahem’s reign is in 2 Kings 15:16. Menahem was one of the kings of Israel. He had murdered Shallum, who had reigned for only one month. The account says that Menahem attacked the city of Tiphsah because its people would not open it to him. He ripped open all the pregnant women in the city.

Could we permit ourselves to suppose that the Almighty would distinguish any nation of people by the name of his chosen people, we must suppose that people to have been an example to all the rest of the world of the purest piety and humanity, and not such a nation of ruffians and cut-throats as the ancient Jews were,—a people who, corrupted by and copying after such monsters and imposters as Moses and Aaron, Joshua, Samuel, and David, had distinguished themselves above all others on the face of the known earth for barbarity and wickedness. If we will not stubbornly shut our eyes and steel our hearts it is impossible not to see, in spite of all that long-established superstition imposes upon the mind, that the flattering appellation of his chosen people is no other than a LIE which the priests and leaders of the Jews had invented to cover the baseness of their own characters; and which Christian priests sometimes as corrupt, and often as cruel, have professed to believe.

If we allowed ourselves to suppose that the Almighty would call any nation his chosen people, we would expect them to be an example to the rest of the world of the purest piety and humanity. We would not expect them to be a nation of thugs and murderers, as the ancient Jews were. They were corrupted by and copied monsters and impostors like Moses and Aaron, Joshua, Samuel, and David. They distinguished themselves above all others in the known world for their barbarity and wickedness. If we do not stubbornly shut our eyes and harden our hearts, we cannot help seeing the truth. Despite everything that long-established superstition imposes on the mind, the flattering name “his chosen people” is nothing but a LIE. Jewish priests and leaders invented it to cover up their own dishonorable characters. Christian priests, sometimes just as corrupt and often just as cruel, have professed to believe it.

The two books of Chronicles are a repetition of the same crimes; but the history is broken in several places, by the author leaving out the reign of some of their kings; and in this, as well as in that of Kings, there is such a frequent transition from kings of Judah to kings of Israel, and from kings of Israel to kings of Judah, that the narrative is obscure in the reading. In the same book the history sometimes contradicts itself: for example, in 2 Kings, i. 17, we are told, but in rather ambiguous terms, that after the death of Ahaziah, king of Israel, Jehoram, or Joram, (who was of the house of Ahab), reigned in his stead in the second Year of Jehoram, or Joram, son of Jehoshaphat, king of Judah; and in viii. 16, of the same book, it is said, “And in the fifth year of Joram, the son of Ahab, king of Israel, Jehoshaphat being then king of Judah, Jehoram, the son of Jehoshaphat king of judah, began to reign.” That is, one chapter says Joram of Judah began to reign in the second year of Joram of Israel; and the other chapter says, that Joram of Israel began to reign in the fifth year of Joram of Judah.

The two books of Chronicles repeat the same crimes. But the history has gaps where the author leaves out the reigns of some kings. Both Chronicles and Kings switch so often between the kings of Judah and Israel that the narrative is hard to follow. The history in Kings sometimes contradicts itself. For example, 2 Kings 1:17 tells us, though somewhat ambiguously, what happened after Ahaziah, king of Israel, died. Jehoram, or Joram, who belonged to the house of Ahab, took his place. He began to reign in the second year of Jehoram, or Joram, son of Jehoshaphat, king of Judah. But 2 Kings 8:16 says, “In the fifth year of Joram, son of Ahab, king of Israel, Jehoshaphat was king of Judah. Then Jehoram, son of Jehoshaphat, king of Judah, began to reign.” In other words, one chapter says Joram of Judah began to reign in the second year of Joram of Israel. The other says Joram of Israel began to reign in the fifth year of Joram of Judah.

Several of the most extraordinary matters related in one history, as having happened during the reign of such or such of their kings, are not to be found in the other, in relating the reign of the same king: for example, the two first rival kings, after the death of Solomon, were Rehoboam and Jeroboam; and in i Kings xii. and xiii. an account is given of Jeroboam making an offering of burnt incense, and that a man, who is there called a man of God, cried out against the altar (xiii. 2): “O altar, altar! thus saith the Lord: Behold, a child shall be born unto the house of David, Josiah by name, and upon thee shall he offer the priests of the high places that burn incense upon thee, and men’s bones shall be burned upon thee.” Verse 4: “And it came to pass, when king Jeroboam heard the saying of the man of God, which had cried against the altar in Bethel, that he put forth his hand from the altar, saying, Lay hold on him; and his hand which he put out against him dried up so that he could not pull it again to him.”

Several of the most extraordinary events described in one history are missing from the other history’s account of the same king’s reign. For example, the first two rival kings after Solomon’s death were Rehoboam and Jeroboam. In 1 Kings 12 and 13, Jeroboam is described as burning incense as an offering. A man called a man of God cried out against the altar (13:2): “O altar, altar! This is what the Lord says: A child named Josiah will be born to the house of David. On you he will sacrifice the priests of the high places who burn incense on you, and human bones will be burned on you.” Verse 4: “When King Jeroboam heard what the man of God had cried out against the altar at Bethel, he stretched out his hand from the altar and said, Seize him! But the hand he stretched out toward the man dried up, so that he could not pull it back.”

One would think that such an extraordinary case as this, (which is spoken of as a judgement,) happening to the chief of one of the parties, and that at the first moment of the separation of the Israelites into two nations, would, if it,. had been true, have been recorded in both histories. But though men, in later times, have believed all that the prophets have said unto them, it does appear that those prophets, or historians, disbelieved each other: they knew each other too well.

One would think that such an extraordinary event would have been recorded in both histories, if it had been true. It is described as a judgment, and it happened to the leader of one of the parties. It also happened just as the Israelites split into two nations. But although people in later times have believed all that the prophets told them, the prophets or historians seem to have disbelieved each other. They knew each other too well.

A long account also is given in Kings about Elijah. It runs through several chapters, and concludes with telling, 2 Kings ii. 11, “And it came to pass, as they (Elijah and Elisha) still went on, and talked, that, behold, there appeared a chariot of fire and horses of fire, and parted them both asunder, and Elijah went up by a whirlwind into heaven.” Hum! this the author of Chronicles, miraculous as the story is, makes no mention of, though he mentions Elijah by name; neither does he say anything of the story related in the second chapter of the same book of Kings, of a parcel of children calling Elisha bald head; and that this man of God (ver. 24) “turned back, and looked upon them, and cursed them in the name of the Lord; and there came forth two she-bears out of the wood, and tare forty and two children of them.” He also passes over in silence the story told, 2 Kings xiii., that when they were burying a man in the sepulchre where Elisha had been buried, it happened that the dead man, as they were letting him down, (ver. 21) “touched the bones of Elisha, and he (the dead man) revived, and stood up on his feet.” The story does not tell us whether they buried the man, notwithstanding he revived and stood upon his feet, or drew him up again. Upon all these stories the writer of the Chronicles is as silent as any writer of the present day, who did not chose to be accused of lying, or at least of romancing, would be about stories of the same kind.

Kings also gives a long account of Elijah. It runs through several chapters and ends by telling us in 2 Kings 2:11: “As they (Elijah and Elisha) continued walking and talking, a chariot of fire and horses of fire appeared. They separated the two men, and Elijah went up to heaven in a whirlwind.” Hum! Despite how miraculous this story is, the author of Chronicles does not mention it, though he mentions Elijah by name. Nor does he say anything about another story from the second chapter of the same book of Kings. In it, a group of children call Elisha bald. Then this man of God (verse 24) “turned around, looked at them, and cursed them in the name of the Lord. Two female bears came out of the woods and tore apart forty-two of the children.” He also passes over in silence the story told in 2 Kings 13. Some people were burying a man in the tomb where Elisha had been buried. As they lowered the dead man, he (verse 21) “touched Elisha’s bones, and he (the dead man) came back to life and stood up.” The story does not tell us whether they buried the man despite his coming back to life and standing up, or pulled him out again. The writer of Chronicles is silent about all these stories. Any writer today would be just as silent about stories of the same kind if he did not want to be accused of lying, or at least of making things up.

But, however these two historians may differ from each other with respect to the tales related by either, they are silent alike with respect to those men styled prophets whose writings fill up the latter part of the Bible. Isaiah, who lived in the time of Hezekiab, is mentioned in Kings, and again in Chronicles, when these histories are speaking of that reign; but except in one or two instances at most, and those very slightly, none of the rest are so much as spoken of, or even their existence hinted at; though, according to the Bible chronology, they lived within the time those histories were written; and some of them long before. If those prophets, as they are called, were men of such importance in their day, as the compilers of the Bible, and priests and commentators have since represented them to be, how can it be accounted for that not one of those histories should say anything about them?

However much these two historians differ in the stories they tell, both are silent about the men called prophets whose writings fill the later part of the Bible. Isaiah lived in the time of Hezekiab. He is mentioned in Kings and again in Chronicles when these histories discuss that reign. But none of the other prophets are even mentioned, or their existence hinted at, except perhaps one or two, and those only briefly. Yet, according to the Bible’s chronology, they lived during the period these histories cover, and some lived long before. If these so-called prophets were as important in their day as the compilers of the Bible, priests, and commentators have since claimed, how can we explain why neither history says anything about them?

The history in the books of Kings and of Chronicles is brought forward, as I have already said, to the year B.C. 588; it will, therefore, be proper to examine which of these prophets lived before that period.

As I have already said, the history in Kings and Chronicles continues up to 588 B.C. So it makes sense to examine which of these prophets lived before that date.

Here follows a table of all the prophets, with the times in which they lived before Christ, according to the chronology affixed to the first chapter of each of the books of the prophets; and also of the number of years they lived before the books of Kings and Chronicles were written:

The following table lists all the prophets and when they lived before Christ. The dates follow the chronology at the beginning of the first chapter of each book of the prophets. The table also shows how many years before the books of Kings and Chronicles were written each prophet lived:

TABLE of the Prophets, with the time in which they lived before Christ,
and also before the books of Kings and Chronicles were written:

                      Years     Years before
       NAMES.         before     Kings and     Observations.
                      Christ.   Chronicles.

  Isaiah............... 760      172            mentioned.


                                                (mentioned only in
  Jeremiah............. 629       41            the last [two] chapters
                                                of Chronicles.

  Ezekiel.............. 595        7            not mentioned.

  Daniel............... 607       19            not mentioned.

  Hosea................ 785       97            not mentioned.

  Joel................. 800      212            not mentioned.

  Amos................. 789      199            not mentioned.

  Obadiah.............. 789      199            not mentioned.

  Jonah................ 862      274            see the note.

  Micah................ 750      162            not mentioned.

  Nahum................ 713      125            not mentioned.

  Habakkuk............. 620       38            not mentioned.

  Zepbaniah............ 630       42            not mentioned.

Haggai Zechariah all three after the year 588 Medachi [NOTE In 2 Kings xiv. 25, the name of Jonah is mentioned on account of the restoration of a tract of land by Jeroboam; but nothing further is said of him, nor is any allusion made to the book of Jonah, nor to his expedition to Nineveh, nor to his encounter with the whale.—Author.]

Haggai Zechariah all three after the year 588 Medachi [NOTE In 2 Kings xiv. 25, Jonah is mentioned because Jeroboam restored an area of land. But nothing more is said about Jonah. There is no reference to the book of Jonah, his journey to Nineveh, or his encounter with the whale. Author.]

This table is either not very honourable for the Bible historians, or not very honourable for the Bible prophets; and I leave to priests and commentators, who are very learned in little things, to settle the point of etiquette between the two; and to assign a reason, why the authors of Kings and of Chronicles have treated those prophets, whom, in the former part of the ‘Age of Reason,’ I have considered as poets, with as much degrading silence as any historian of the present day would treat Peter Pindar.

This table reflects poorly on either the Bible historians or the Bible prophets. I leave it to priests and commentators, who are very learned in little things, to settle this question of etiquette between them. They can also explain why the authors of Kings and Chronicles treated those prophets with such degrading silence. I have called these prophets poets in the earlier part of the ‘Age of Reason.’ The authors treated them as dismissively as any historian today would treat Peter Pindar, by saying nothing about them.

I have one more observation to make on the book of Chronicles; after which I shall pass on to review the remaining books of the Bible.

I have one more observation about the book of Chronicles. After that, I will review the remaining books of the Bible.

In my observations on the book of Genesis, I have quoted a passage from xxxvi. 31, which evidently refers to a time, after that kings began to reign over the children of Israel; and I have shown that as this verse is verbatim the same as in 1 Chronicles i. 43, where it stands consistently with the order of history, which in Genesis it does not, that the verse in Genesis, and a great part of the 36th chapter, have been taken from Chronicles; and that the book of Genesis, though it is placed first in the Bible, and ascribed to Moses, has been manufactured by some unknown person, after the book of Chronicles was written, which was not until at least eight hundred and sixty years after the time of Moses.

In my observations on Genesis, I quoted a passage from chapter 36, verse 31. It clearly refers to a time after kings began to reign over the children of Israel. I have shown that this verse is word for word the same as 1 Chronicles 1:43. In Chronicles, the verse fits the order of history, but in Genesis it does not. I have therefore shown that the verse in Genesis, and much of chapter 36, were taken from Chronicles. I have also shown that Genesis was written by some unknown person after Chronicles was written. This is so, though Genesis is placed first in the Bible and attributed to Moses. Chronicles was not written until at least 860 years after the time of Moses.

The evidence I proceed by to substantiate this, is regular, and has in it but two stages. First, as I have already stated, that the passage in Genesis refers itself for time to Chronicles; secondly, that the book of Chronicles, to which this passage refers itself, was not begun to be written until at least eight hundred and sixty years after the time of Moses. To prove this, we have only to look into 1 Chronicles iii. 15, where the writer, in giving the genealogy of the descendants of David, mentions Zedekiah; and it was in the time of Zedekiah that Nebuchadnezzar conquered Jerusalem, B.C. 588, and consequently more than 860 years after Moses. Those who have superstitiously boasted of the antiquity of the Bible, and particularly of the books ascribed to Moses, have done it without examination, and without any other authority than that of one credulous man telling it to another: for, so far as historical and chronological evidence applies, the very first book in the Bible is not so ancient as the book of Homer, by more than three hundred years, and is about the same age with Æsop’s Fables.

The evidence I use to support this argument follows two clear steps. First, as I have already stated, the passage in Genesis refers to Chronicles for its dating. Second, the book of Chronicles was not begun until at least 860 years after the time of Moses. To prove this, we need only look at 1 Chronicles iii. 15. There, the writer lists David’s descendants and mentions Zedekiah. During Zedekiah’s reign, Nebuchadnezzar conquered Jerusalem in 588 B.C., more than 860 years after Moses. Some have superstitiously boasted about the age of the Bible, especially the books attributed to Moses. They have done so without examining the evidence. Their only authority is one gullible person telling another. But the historical and chronological evidence shows that the first book of the Bible is more than 300 years younger than the book of Homer. It is about the same age as Æsop’s Fables.

I am not contending for the morality of Homer; on the contrary, I think it a book of false glory, and tending to inspire immoral and mischievous notions of honour; and with respect to Æsop, though the moral is in general just, the fable is often cruel; and the cruelty of the fable does more injury to the heart, especially in a child, than the moral does good to the judgment.

I am not defending the morality of Homer. On the contrary, I think it is a book of false glory. It tends to inspire immoral and harmful ideas about honor. As for Æsop, the moral is generally sound, but the fable is often cruel. The cruelty of the fable does more harm to the heart, especially a child’s, than the moral does good to the judgment.

Having now dismissed Kings and Chronicles, I come to the next in course, the book of Ezra.

Having finished with Kings and Chronicles, I now turn to the next book, Ezra.

As one proof, among others I shall produce to shew the disorder in which this pretended word of God, the Bible, has been put together, and the uncertainty of who the authors were, we have only to look at the first three verses in Ezra, and the last two in 2 Chronicles; for by what kind of cutting and shuffling has it been that the first three verses in Ezra should be the last two verses in 2 Chronicles, or that the last two in 2 Chronicles should be the first three in Ezra? Either the authors did not know their own works or the compilers did not know the authors.

Among other proofs, I will show how disorderly this supposed word of God, the Bible, is and how uncertain its authorship is. We need only look at the first three verses of Ezra and the last two of 2 Chronicles. What kind of cutting and shuffling made the first three verses of Ezra the last two of 2 Chronicles? Or the last two verses of 2 Chronicles the first three of Ezra? Either the authors did not know their own works, or the compilers did not know the authors.

Last Two Verses of 2 Chronicles.

The last two verses of 2 Chronicles.

Ver. 22. Now in the first year of Cyrus, King of Persia, that the word of the Lord, spoken by the mouth of Jeremiah, might be accomplished, the Lord stirred up the spirit of Cyrus, king of Persia, that he made a proclamation throughout all his kingdom, and put it also in writing, saying.

Verse 22. In the first year of Cyrus, King of Persia, the Lord moved him to make a proclamation. This fulfilled the Lord's word spoken through Jeremiah. Cyrus proclaimed it throughout his kingdom and put it in writing, saying:

earth hath the Lord God of heaven given me; and he hath charged me to build him an house in Jerusalem which is in Judah. Who is there among you of all his people? the Lord his God be with him, and let him go up. ***

The Lord God of heaven has given me the earth. He has commanded me to build him a house in Jerusalem, which is in Judah. Who among you belongs to his people? May the Lord his God be with him, and let him go up. ***

First Three Verses of Ezra.

The First Three Verses of Ezra.

Ver. 1. Now in the first year of Cyrus, king of Persia, that the word of the Lord, by the mouth of Jeremiah, might be fulfilled, the Lord stirred up the spirit of Cyrus, king of Persia, that he made a proclamation throughout all his kingdom, and put it also in writing, saying.

Ver. 1. In the first year of Cyrus, king of Persia, the Lord moved him to make a proclamation throughout his kingdom. The Lord did this to fulfill the word he had spoken through Jeremiah. Cyrus also put the proclamation in writing. It said:

2. Thus saith Cyrus, king of Persia, The Lord God of heaven hath given me all the kingdoms of the earth; and he hath charged me to build him an house at Jerusalem, which is in Judah.

2. This is what Cyrus, king of Persia, says: The Lord God of heaven has given me all the kingdoms of the earth. He has commanded me to build him a house in Jerusalem, in Judah.

3. Who is there among you of all his people? his God be with him, and let him go up to Jerusalem, which is in Judah, and build the house of the Lord God of Israel (he is the God) which is in Jerusalem.

3. Who among you belongs to his people? May his God be with you. Go to Jerusalem in Judah and build the house of the Lord God of Israel. He is the God in Jerusalem.

*** The last verse in Chronicles is broken abruptly, and ends in the middle of the phrase with the word ‘up’ without signifying to what place. This abrupt break, and the appearance of the same verses in different books, show as I have already said, the disorder and ignorance in which the Bible has been put together, and that the compilers of it had no authority for what they were doing, nor we any authority for believing what they have done. [NOTE I observed, as I passed along, several broken and senseless passages in the Bible, without thinking them of consequence enough to be introduced in the body of the work; such as that, 1 Samuel xiii. 1, where it is said, “Saul reigned one year; and when he had reigned two years over Israel, Saul chose him three thousand men,” &c. The first part of the verse, that Saul reigned one year has no sense, since it does not tell us what Saul did, nor say any thing of what happened at the end of that one year; and it is, besides, mere absurdity to say he reigned one year, when the very next phrase says he had reigned two for if he had reigned two, it was impossible not to have reigned one.

*** The last verse in Chronicles breaks off abruptly. It ends in the middle of a phrase with the word ‘up’, without saying where. This abrupt break and the appearance of the same verses in different books show, as I have already said, the disorder and ignorance involved in putting the Bible together. They also show that its compilers had no authority for what they were doing. Nor do we have any authority for believing what they have written. [NOTE As I went along, I noticed several broken and senseless passages in the Bible. I did not think them important enough to include in the main part of this work. One example is 1 Samuel xiii. 1, which says, “Saul reigned one year; and when he had reigned two years over Israel, Saul chose him three thousand men,” and so on. The first part of the verse, saying that Saul reigned one year, makes no sense. It does not tell us what Saul did or what happened at the end of that year. Besides, saying he reigned one year is simply absurd when the very next phrase says he had reigned two. For if he had reigned two years, he could not possibly have failed to reign one.

Another instance occurs in Joshua v. where the writer tells us a story of an angel (for such the table of contents at the head of the chapter calls him) appearing unto Joshua; and the story ends abruptly, and without any conclusion. The story is as follows:—Ver. 13. “And it came to pass, when Joshua was by Jericho, that he lifted up his eyes and looked, and behold there stood a man over against him with his sword drawn in his hand; and Joshua went unto him and said unto him, Art thou for us, or for our adversaries?” Verse 14, “And he said, Nay; but as captain of the host of the Lord am I now come. And Joshua fell on his face to the earth, and did worship and said unto him, What saith my Lord unto his servant?” Verse 15, “And the captain of the Lord’s host said unto Joshua, Loose thy shoe from off thy foot; for the place whereon thou standeth is holy. And Joshua did so.”—And what then? nothing: for here the story ends, and the chapter too.

Another example appears in Joshua chapter 5. The writer tells a story about an angel appearing to Joshua. The table of contents at the start of the chapter calls him an angel. The story ends abruptly, without any conclusion. It goes as follows: Verse 13: “When Joshua was near Jericho, he looked up and saw a man standing before him with a drawn sword. Joshua went up to him and asked, Are you for us or for our enemies?” Verse 14: “He replied, No, but I have now come as commander of the Lord’s army. Joshua fell face down on the ground and worshiped him. He asked, What does my lord say to his servant?” Verse 15: “The commander of the Lord’s army said to Joshua, Take off your shoe, because the place where you stand is holy. And Joshua did so.” And what then? Nothing. The story ends here, and so does the chapter.

Either this story is broken off in the middle, or it is a story told by some Jewish humourist in ridicule of Joshua’s pretended mission from God, and the compilers of the Bible, not perceiving the design of the story, have told it as a serious matter. As a story of humour and ridicule it has a great deal of point; for it pompously introduces an angel in the figure of a man, with a drawn sword in his hand, before whom Joshua falls on his face to the earth, and worships (which is contrary to their second commandment;) and then, this most important embassy from heaven ends in telling Joshua to pull off his shoe. It might as well have told him to pull up his breeches.

Either this story breaks off in the middle, or a Jewish humorist told it to mock Joshua’s supposed mission from God. The compilers of the Bible failed to see the joke and presented the story as a serious account. As a humorous and mocking story, it makes a sharp point. It makes a grand show of introducing an angel in the form of a man, holding a drawn sword. Joshua falls face down on the ground before him and worships him (which goes against their second commandment). Then this all-important message from heaven ends with the angel telling Joshua to take off his shoe. He might as well have told him to pull up his pants.

It is certain, however, that the Jews did not credit every thing their leaders told them, as appears from the cavalier manner in which they speak of Moses, when he was gone into the mount. As for this Moses, say they, we wot not what is become of him. Exod. xxxii. 1.—Author.

It is certain, however, that the Jews did not believe everything their leaders told them. This is clear from the casual way they spoke of Moses when he had gone up the mountain. As for this Moses, they said, we do not know what has become of him. Exodus 32:1. Author.

The only thing that has any appearance of certainty in the book of Ezra is the time in which it was written, which was immediately after the return of the Jews from the Babylonian captivity, about B.C. 536. Ezra (who, according to the Jewish commentators, is the same person as is called Esdras in the Apocrypha) was one of the persons who returned, and who, it is probable, wrote the account of that affair. Nebemiah, whose book follows next to Ezra, was another of the returned persons; and who, it is also probable, wrote the account of the same affair, in the book that bears his name. But those accounts are nothing to us, nor to any other person, unless it be to the Jews, as a part of the history of their nation; and there is just as much of the word of God in those books as there is in any of the histories of France, or Rapin’s history of England, or the history of any other country.

The only thing in the book of Ezra that seems certain is when it was written. It was written immediately after the Jews returned from captivity in Babylon, around 536 B.C. Ezra was one of those who returned. Jewish commentators say he is the same person called Esdras in the Apocrypha. He probably wrote the account of the return. Nebemiah was another of those who returned, and his book follows Ezra’s. He probably also wrote the account of the same event in the book that bears his name. But those accounts mean nothing to us or anyone else, except perhaps to the Jews as part of their national history. And those books contain just as much of the word of God as any history of France, Rapin’s history of England, or the history of any other country.

But even in matters of historical record, neither of those writers are to be depended upon. In Ezra ii., the writer gives a list of the tribes and families, and of the precise number of souls of each, that returned from Babylon to Jerusalem; and this enrolment of the persons so returned appears to have been one of the principal objects for writing the book; but in this there is an error that destroys the intention of the undertaking.

But even in matters of historical record, neither writer can be relied on. In Ezra 2, the writer lists the tribes and families who returned from Babylon to Jerusalem. He gives the exact number of people in each group. Recording these people appears to have been one of the main reasons for writing the book. But there is an error in the list that defeats its purpose.

The writer begins his enrolment in the following manner (ii. 3): “The children of Parosh, two thousand one hundred seventy and four.” Ver. 4, “The children of Shephatiah, three hundred seventy and two.” And in this manner he proceeds through all the families; and in the 64th verse, he makes a total, and says, the whole congregation together was forty and two thousand three hundred and threescore.

The writer begins his list as follows (ii. 3): “The children of Parosh, 2,174.” Verse 4 says, “The children of Shephatiah, 372.” He continues in this way through all the families. In verse 64, he gives a total and says the whole congregation together numbered 42,360.

But whoever will take the trouble of casting up the several particulars, will find that the total is but 29,818; so that the error is 12,542. What certainty then can there be in the Bible for any thing?

But anyone who takes the trouble to add up the individual figures will find that the total is only 29,818. So the error is 12,542. How, then, can we be certain of anything in the Bible?

[Here Mr. Paine includes the long list of numbers from the Bible of all the children listed and the total thereof. This can be had directly from the Bible.]

[Here Mr. Paine includes the long list of numbers from the Bible for all the children listed, along with their total. The list can be found in the Bible.]

Nehemiah, in like manner, gives a list of the returned families, and of the number of each family. He begins as in Ezra, by saying (vii. 8): “The children of Parosh, two thousand three hundred and seventy-two;” and so on through all the families. (The list differs in several of the particulars from that of Ezra.) In ver. 66, Nehemiah makes a total, and says, as Ezra had said, “The whole congregation together was forty and two thousand three hundred and threescore.” But the particulars of this list make a total but of 31,089, so that the error here is 11,271. These writers may do well enough for Bible-makers, but not for any thing where truth and exactness is necessary.

Nehemiah likewise lists the families who returned and the number of people in each family. He begins as Ezra does, saying (vii. 8): “The children of Parosh, two thousand three hundred and seventy-two.” He continues in the same way through all the families. (The list differs from Ezra's in several details.) In verse 66, Nehemiah gives a total, as Ezra had done: “The whole congregation together was forty-two thousand three hundred and sixty.” But the individual numbers in Nehemiah's list add up to only 31,089, so the error here is 11,271. These writers may be good enough for making Bibles, but not for anything that requires truth and accuracy.

The next book in course is the book of Esther. If Madam Esther thought it any honour to offer herself as a kept mistress to Ahasuerus, or as a rival to Queen Vashti, who had refused to come to a drunken king in the midst of a drunken company, to be made a show of, (for the account says, they had been drinking seven days, and were merry,) let Esther and Mordecai look to that, it is no business of ours, at least it is none of mine; besides which, the story has a great deal the appearance of being fabulous, and is also anonymous. I pass on to the book of Job.

The next book is Esther. Perhaps Madam Esther thought it an honor to offer herself as Ahasuerus's mistress, or as a rival to Queen Vashti. Vashti had refused to appear before a drunken king and his drunken guests, just to be put on display. (The account says they had been drinking for seven days and were merry.) If Esther thought it an honor, let her and Mordecai answer for it. It is none of our business, at least none of mine. Besides, the story looks very much like a fable, and its author is unknown. I move on to the book of Job.

The book of Job differs in character from all the books we have hitherto passed over. Treachery and murder make no part of this book; it is the meditations of a mind strongly impressed with the vicissitudes of human life, and by turns sinking under, and struggling against the pressure. It is a highly wrought composition, between willing submission and involuntary discontent; and shows man, as he sometimes is, more disposed to be resigned than he is capable of being. Patience has but a small share in the character of the person of whom the book treats; on the contrary, his grief is often impetuous; but he still endeavours to keep a guard upon it, and seems determined, in the midst of accumulating ills, to impose upon himself the hard duty of contentment.

The book of Job is different from all the books we have discussed so far. It contains no treachery or murder. Instead, it reflects the thoughts of a mind deeply affected by the ups and downs of human life. It alternately sinks under their pressure and struggles against it. The book is a carefully crafted work about the tension between willing submission and involuntary discontent. It shows how people sometimes want to accept their fate more than they are able to. The man the book describes has little patience. On the contrary, his grief is often intense and uncontrolled. But he still tries to keep it in check. As his troubles mount, he seems determined to impose on himself the difficult duty of contentment.

I have spoken in a respectful manner of the book of Job in the former part of the ‘Age of Reason,’ but without knowing at that time what I have learned since; which is, that from all the evidence that can be collected, the book of Job does not belong to the Bible.

I spoke respectfully of the book of Job in the earlier part of ‘The Age of Reason.’ But I did not know then what I have since learned. All the available evidence shows that the book of Job does not belong to the Bible.

I have seen the opinion of two Hebrew commentators, Abenezra and Spinoza, upon this subject; they both say that the book of Job carries no internal evidence of being an Hebrew book; that the genius of the composition, and the drama of the piece, are not Hebrew; that it has been translated from another language into Hebrew, and that the author of the book was a Gentile; that the character represented under the name of Satan (which is the first and only time this name is mentioned in the Bible) [In a later work Paine notes that in “the Bible” (by which he always means the Old Testament alone) the word Satan occurs also in 1 Chron. xxi. 1, and remarks that the action there ascribed to Satan is in 2 Sam. xxiv. 1, attributed to Jehovah (“Essay on Dreams”). In these places, however, and in Ps. cix. 6, Satan means “adversary,” and is so translated (A.S. version) in 2 Sam. xix. 22, and 1 Kings v. 4, xi. 25. As a proper name, with the article, Satan appears in the Old Testament only in Job and in Zech. iii. 1, 2. But the authenticity of the passage in Zechariah has been questioned, and it may be that in finding the proper name of Satan in Job alone, Paine was following some opinion met with in one of the authorities whose comments are condensed in his paragraph.—Editor.] does not correspond to any Hebrew idea; and that the two convocations which the Deity is supposed to have made of those whom the poem calls sons of God, and the familiarity which this supposed Satan is stated to have with the Deity, are in the same case.

I have read what two Hebrew commentators, Abenezra and Spinoza, say on this subject. Both say that the book of Job contains no internal evidence that it is a Hebrew book. Its style and dramatic form are not Hebrew. They say it was translated into Hebrew from another language and that its author was a Gentile. They also say that the character named Satan does not correspond to any Hebrew idea. This is the first and only time the name is mentioned in the Bible. [In a later work, Paine notes that the word Satan also occurs in 1 Chron. xxi. 1. By “the Bible,” he always means the Old Testament alone. He remarks that the action attributed there to Satan is attributed to Jehovah in 2 Sam. xxiv. 1 (“Essay on Dreams”). In these passages, however, and in Ps. cix. 6, Satan means “adversary.” It is translated that way in the A.S. version of 2 Sam. xix. 22, and 1 Kings v. 4, xi. 25. As a proper name, preceded by the article, Satan appears in the Old Testament only in Job and in Zech. iii. 1, 2. But the authenticity of the passage in Zechariah has been questioned. Paine may have been following an opinion found in one of the sources whose comments he summarizes in this paragraph. That opinion would explain why he found the proper name Satan only in Job. Editor.] Abenezra and Spinoza say the same is true of the two gatherings the Deity is supposed to have called. The poem calls those gathered the sons of God. The same is true of the familiarity this supposed Satan is said to have with the Deity.

It may also be observed, that the book shows itself to be the production of a mind cultivated in science, which the Jews, so far from being famous for, were very ignorant of. The allusions to objects of natural philosophy are frequent and strong, and are of a different cast to any thing in the books known to be Hebrew. The astronomical names, Pleiades, Orion, and Arcturus, are Greek and not Hebrew names, and it does not appear from any thing that is to be found in the Bible that the Jews knew any thing of astronomy, or that they studied it, they had no translation of those names into their own language, but adopted the names as they found them in the poem. [Paine’s Jewish critic, David Levi, fastened on this slip (“Defence of the Old Testament,” 1797, p. 152). In the original the names are Ash (Arcturus), Kesil’ (Orion), Kimah’ (Pleiades), though the identifications of the constellations in the A.S.V. have been questioned.—Editor.]

It may also be noted that the book shows it was written by a mind educated in science. The Jews, far from being famous for science, knew very little about it. The book often makes striking references to the natural world. These references differ in character from anything in the books known to be Hebrew. The astronomical names Pleiades, Orion, and Arcturus are Greek, not Hebrew. Nothing in the Bible seems to show that the Jews knew anything about astronomy or studied it. They had no translations of those names in their own language. Instead, they adopted the names as they found them in the poem. [Paine’s Jewish critic, David Levi, seized on this mistake (“Defence of the Old Testament,” 1797, p. 152). In the original, the names are Ash (Arcturus), Kesil’ (Orion), and Kimah’ (Pleiades). The identification of the constellations in the A.S.V. has been questioned, however. Editor.]

That the Jews did translate the literary productions of the Gentile nations into the Hebrew language, and mix them with their own, is not a matter of doubt; Proverbs xxxi. i, is an evidence of this: it is there said, The word of king Lemuel, the prophecy which his mother taught him. This verse stands as a preface to the proverbs that follow, and which are not the proverbs of Solomon, but of Lemuel; and this Lemuel was not one of the kings of Israel, nor of Judah, but of some other country, and consequently a Gentile. The Jews however have adopted his proverbs; and as they cannot give any account who the author of the book of Job was, nor how they came by the book, and as it differs in character from the Hebrew writings, and stands totally unconnected with every other book and chapter in the Bible before it and after it, it has all the circumstantial evidence of being originally a book of the Gentiles. [The prayer known by the name of Agur’s Prayer, in Proverbs xxx.,—immediately preceding the proverbs of Lemuel,—and which is the only sensible, well-conceived, and well-expressed prayer in the Bible, has much the appearance of being a prayer taken from the Gentiles. The name of Agur occurs on no other occasion than this; and he is introduced, together with the prayer ascribed to him, in the same manner, and nearly in the same words, that Lemuel and his proverbs are introduced in the chapter that follows. The first verse says, “The words of Agur, the son of Jakeh, even the prophecy:” here the word prophecy is used with the same application it has in the following chapter of Lemuel, unconnected with anything of prediction. The prayer of Agur is in the 8th and 9th verses, “Remove far from me vanity and lies; give me neither riches nor poverty, but feed me with food convenient for me; lest I be full and deny thee and say, Who is the Lord? or lest I be poor and steal, and take the name of my God in vain.” This has not any of the marks of being a Jewish prayer, for the Jews never prayed but when they were in trouble, and never for anything but victory, vengeance, or riches.—Author. (Prov. xxx. 1, and xxxi. 1) the word “prophecy” in these verses is translated “oracle” or “burden” (marg.) in the revised version.—The prayer of Agur was quoted by Paine in his plea for the officers of Excise, 1772.—Editor.]

There is no doubt that the Jews translated the writings of Gentile nations into Hebrew and mixed them with their own. Proverbs 31:1 is evidence of this. It says: The words of King Lemuel, the prophecy his mother taught him. This verse introduces the proverbs that follow. They are Lemuel’s proverbs, not Solomon’s. Lemuel was not a king of Israel or Judah, but of some other country. He was therefore a Gentile. Yet the Jews adopted his proverbs. The Jews cannot say who wrote the book of Job or how they obtained it. It also differs in character from Hebrew writings. It is entirely unconnected with every other book and chapter in the Bible, whether before or after it. All the circumstantial evidence therefore points to its being originally a Gentile book. [The prayer known as Agur’s Prayer appears in Proverbs 30, immediately before Lemuel’s proverbs. It is the only sensible, well-conceived, and well-expressed prayer in the Bible. It looks very much like a prayer taken from the Gentiles. Agur’s name appears nowhere else. He and the prayer attributed to him are introduced much as Lemuel and his proverbs are in the following chapter. The wording is also nearly the same. The first verse says, “The words of Agur, the son of Jakeh, even the prophecy:” Here, as in the following chapter about Lemuel, “prophecy” has nothing to do with prediction. Agur’s prayer appears in verses 8 and 9: “Keep vanity and lies far from me. Give me neither riches nor poverty, but provide me with the food I need. Otherwise, I might have plenty and deny you, saying, Who is the Lord? Or I might be poor and steal, and take the name of my God in vain.” This prayer has none of the marks of a Jewish prayer. The Jews prayed only when they were in trouble, and only for victory, vengeance, or riches. Author. In Proverbs 30:1 and 31:1, “prophecy” is translated as “oracle” or “burden” in the margin of the revised version. Paine quoted Agur’s prayer in his 1772 plea for the officers of Excise. Editor.]

The Bible-makers, and those regulators of time, the Bible chronologists, appear to have been at a loss where to place and how to dispose of the book of Job; for it contains no one historical circumstance, nor allusion to any, that might serve to determine its place in the Bible. But it would not have answered the purpose of these men to have informed the world of their ignorance; and, therefore, they have affixed it to the aera of B.C. 1520, which is during the time the Israelites were in Egypt, and for which they have just as much authority and no more than I should have for saying it was a thousand years before that period. The probability however is, that it is older than any book in the Bible; and it is the only one that can be read without indignation or disgust.

The Bible-makers and the Bible chronologists, those regulators of time, seem unsure where to put the book of Job. It contains no historical event or reference that could establish its place in the Bible. But admitting their ignorance to the world would not have served their purpose. So they dated it to 1520 B.C., when the Israelites were in Egypt. They have just as much authority for that date, and no more, than I would have for dating it a thousand years earlier. The book is probably older than any other book in the Bible, however. It is also the only one that can be read without indignation or disgust.

We know nothing of what the ancient Gentile world (as it is called) was before the time of the Jews, whose practice has been to calumniate and blacken the character of all other nations; and it is from the Jewish accounts that we have learned to call them heathens. But, as far as we know to the contrary, they were a just and moral people, and not addicted, like the Jews, to cruelty and revenge, but of whose profession of faith we are unacquainted. It appears to have been their custom to personify both virtue and vice by statues and images, as is done now-a-days both by statuary and by painting; but it does not follow from this that they worshipped them any more than we do.—I pass on to the book of,

We know nothing about the ancient Gentile world, as it is called, before the time of the Jews. The Jews have made a practice of slandering and blackening the character of all other nations. It is from Jewish accounts that we have learned to call those nations heathens. But as far as we know, they were a just and moral people. Unlike the Jews, they were not given to cruelty and revenge. We do not know what their beliefs were. They seem to have represented both virtue and vice in statues and images, just as sculptors and painters do today. But it does not follow that they worshipped those images any more than we do. I pass on to the book of,

Psalms, of which it is not necessary to make much observation. Some of them are moral, and others are very revengeful; and the greater part relates to certain local circumstances of the Jewish nation at the time they were written, with which we have nothing to do. It is, however, an error or an imposition to call them the Psalms of David; they are a collection, as song-books are now-a-days, from different song-writers, who lived at different times. The 137th Psalm could not have been written till more than 400 years after the time of David, because it is written in commemoration of an event, the captivity of the Jews in Babylon, which did not happen till that distance of time. “By the rivers of Babylon we sat down; yea, we wept when we remembered Zion. We hanged our harps upon the willows, in the midst thereof; for there they that carried us away captive required of us a song, saying, sing us one of the songs of Zion.” As a man would say to an American, or to a Frenchman, or to an Englishman, sing us one of your American songs, or your French songs, or your English songs. This remark, with respect to the time this psalm was written, is of no other use than to show (among others already mentioned) the general imposition the world has been under with respect to the authors of the Bible. No regard has been paid to time, place, and circumstance; and the names of persons have been affixed to the several books which it was as impossible they should write, as that a man should walk in procession at his own funeral.

There is little need to comment on Psalms. Some are moral, while others are very revengeful. Most concern particular circumstances of the Jewish nation when they were written, which have nothing to do with us. But calling them the Psalms of David is either a mistake or a deception. They are a collection, like modern songbooks, by different songwriters who lived at different times. The 137th Psalm could not have been written until more than 400 years after David's time. It commemorates the captivity of the Jews in Babylon, which did not happen until more than 400 years after David. “By the rivers of Babylon we sat down. Yes, we wept when we remembered Zion. We hung our harps on the willow trees there. For our captors demanded a song from us, saying, sing us one of the songs of Zion.” It is like saying to an American, a Frenchman, or an Englishman, sing us one of your American songs, your French songs, or your English songs. This observation about when the psalm was written has only one purpose. Along with others already mentioned, it shows how thoroughly the world has been deceived about the authors of the Bible. No attention has been paid to time, place, or circumstance. People's names have been attached to books they could no more have written than a man could walk in his own funeral procession.

The Book of Proverbs. These, like the Psalms, are a collection, and that from authors belonging to other nations than those of the Jewish nation, as I have shewn in the observations upon the book of Job; besides which, some of the Proverbs ascribed to Solomon did not appear till two hundred and fifty years after the death of Solomon; for it is said in xxv. i, “These are also proverbs of Solomon which the men of Hezekiah, king of Judah, copied out.” It was two hundred and fifty years from the time of Solomon to the time of Hezekiah. When a man is famous and his name is abroad he is made the putative father of things he never said or did; and this, most probably, has been the case with Solomon. It appears to have been the fashion of that day to make proverbs, as it is now to make jest-books, and father them upon those who never saw them. [A “Tom Paine’s Jest Book” had appeared in London with little or nothing of Paine in it.—Editor.]

The Book of Proverbs. Like the Psalms, Proverbs is a collection. Its authors include people from nations other than the Jewish nation, as I showed in my observations on the book of Job. Besides this, some proverbs attributed to Solomon did not appear until 250 years after his death. For it says in 25:1, “These are also proverbs of Solomon which the men of Hezekiah, king of Judah, copied out.” There were 250 years between the time of Solomon and the time of Hezekiah. When a man becomes famous and widely known, things he never said or did are attributed to him. This is most probably what happened with Solomon. Making proverbs seems to have been the fashion in those days, just as making joke books is now. And, as with joke books, people attributed them to those who had never seen them. [A “Tom Paine’s Jest Book” had appeared in London with little or nothing by Paine in it. Editor.]

The book of Ecclesiastes, or the Preacher, is also ascribed to Solomon, and that with much reason, if not with truth. It is written as the solitary reflections of a worn-out debauchee, such as Solomon was, who looking back on scenes he can no longer enjoy, cries out All is Vanity! A great deal of the metaphor and of the sentiment is obscure, most probably by translation; but enough is left to show they were strongly pointed in the original. [Those that look out of the window shall be darkened, is an obscure figure in translation for loss of sight.—Author.] From what is transmitted to us of the character of Solomon, he was witty, ostentatious, dissolute, and at last melancholy. He lived fast, and died, tired of the world, at the age of fifty-eight years.

The book of Ecclesiastes, or the Preacher, is also attributed to Solomon, and with good reason, even if not truthfully. It reads like the private reflections of a worn-out pleasure seeker, which Solomon was. Looking back on pleasures he can no longer enjoy, he cries out, All is Vanity! Much of the imagery and feeling is obscure, most likely because of the translation. But enough remains to show that both were sharply expressed in the original. [Those who look out of the window shall be darkened is an obscure figure of speech for loss of sight in translation. Author.] From what we know of Solomon's character, he was witty, showy, dissolute, and finally melancholy. He lived fast and died at fifty-eight, tired of the world.

Seven hundred wives, and three hundred concubines, are worse than none; and, however it may carry with it the appearance of heightened enjoyment, it defeats all the felicity of affection, by leaving it no point to fix upon; divided love is never happy. This was the case with Solomon; and if he could not, with all his pretensions to wisdom, discover it beforehand, he merited, unpitied, the mortification he afterwards endured. In this point of view, his preaching is unnecessary, because, to know the consequences, it is only necessary to know the cause. Seven hundred wives, and three hundred concubines would have stood in place of the whole book. It was needless after this to say that all was vanity and vexation of spirit; for it is impossible to derive happiness from the company of those whom we deprive of happiness.

Seven hundred wives and three hundred concubines are worse than none. However much enjoyment they may seem to promise, they destroy all the happiness of affection. They leave affection with no single object to settle on. Divided love is never happy. This was Solomon's case. If he could not foresee this, despite all his claims to wisdom, he deserved the humiliation he later suffered. He deserves no pity for it. From this point of view, his preaching is unnecessary. To know the consequences, one need only know the cause. Seven hundred wives and three hundred concubines could have taken the place of the whole book. After that, there was no need to say that all was meaningless and a torment to the spirit. It is impossible to find happiness in the company of those we deprive of happiness.

To be happy in old age it is necessary that we accustom ourselves to objects that can accompany the mind all the way through life, and that we take the rest as good in their day. The mere man of pleasure is miserable in old age; and the mere drudge in business is but little better: whereas, natural philosophy, mathematical and mechanical science, are a continual source of tranquil pleasure, and in spite of the gloomy dogmas of priests, and of superstition, the study of those things is the study of the true theology; it teaches man to know and to admire the Creator, for the principles of science are in the creation, and are unchangeable, and of divine origin.

To be happy in old age, we must grow used to interests that can stay with us throughout life. We should enjoy everything else while it lasts. A person who lives only for pleasure is miserable in old age. A person who only toils at business is little better off. By contrast, the study of nature, mathematics, and mechanics provides a constant source of peaceful pleasure. Despite the gloomy doctrines of priests and the darkness of superstition, studying these subjects is the study of true theology. It teaches us to know and admire the Creator. For the principles of science are found in creation. They are unchanging and of divine origin.

Those who knew Benjamin Franklin will recollect, that his mind was ever young; his temper ever serene; science, that never grows grey, was always his mistress. He was never without an object; for when we cease to have an object we become like an invalid in an hospital waiting for death.

Those who knew Benjamin Franklin will remember that his mind was always young and his mood always calm. Science, which never grows old, was always his mistress. He always had a purpose. For when we stop having a purpose, we become like a patient in a hospital waiting to die.

Solomon’s Songs, amorous and foolish enough, but which wrinkled fanaticism has called divine.—The compilers of the Bible have placed these songs after the book of Ecclesiastes; and the chronologists have affixed to them the aera of B.C. 1014, at which time Solomon, according to the same chronology, was nineteen years of age, and was then forming his seraglio of wives and concubines. The Bible-makers and the chronologists should have managed this matter a little better, and either have said nothing about the time, or chosen a time less inconsistent with the supposed divinity of those songs; for Solomon was then in the honey-moon of one thousand debaucheries.

Solomon’s Songs are full of love and foolishness, but wrinkled fanaticism has called them divine. The Bible’s compilers placed these songs after the book of Ecclesiastes. Chronologists have dated them to 1014 B.C. According to the same chronology, Solomon was nineteen then and was building his harem of wives and concubines. The Bible-makers and chronologists should have handled this matter better. They should either have said nothing about the date or chosen one less inconsistent with the songs’ supposed divinity. For Solomon was then in the honeymoon of a thousand debaucheries.

It should also have occurred to them, that as he wrote, if he did write, the book of Ecclesiastes, long after these songs, and in which he exclaims that all is vanity and vexation of spirit, that he included those songs in that description. This is the more probable, because he says, or somebody for him, Ecclesiastes ii. 8, I got me men-singers, and women-singers [most probably to sing those songs], and musical instruments of all sorts; and behold (Ver. ii), “all was vanity and vexation of spirit.” The compilers however have done their work but by halves; for as they have given us the songs they should have given us the tunes, that we might sing them.

It should also have occurred to them that he wrote Ecclesiastes, if he wrote it at all, long after these songs. In that book, he declares that all is vanity and vexation of spirit. So he must have included those songs in that description. This is more likely because he, or someone writing for him, says in Ecclesiastes ii. 8, “I got male and female singers [most likely to sing those songs], and musical instruments of all kinds.” Then he says (verse 11), “all was vanity and vexation of spirit.” The compilers, however, have done only half the job. Since they gave us the songs, they should also have given us the tunes, so we could sing them.

The books called the books of the Prophets fill up all the remaining part of the Bible; they are sixteen in number, beginning with Isaiah and ending with Malachi, of which I have given a list in the observations upon Chronicles. Of these sixteen prophets, all of whom except the last three lived within the time the books of Kings and Chronicles were written, two only, Isaiah and Jeremiah, are mentioned in the history of those books. I shall begin with those two, reserving, what I have to say on the general character of the men called prophets to another part of the work.

The books called the books of the Prophets make up the rest of the Bible. There are sixteen, beginning with Isaiah and ending with Malachi. I listed them in my observations on Chronicles. All but the last three prophets lived during the period covered by Kings and Chronicles. Yet only two, Isaiah and Jeremiah, are mentioned in the history told in those books. I will begin with those two. I will discuss the general character of the men called prophets in another part of this work.

Whoever will take the trouble of reading the book ascribed to Isaiah, will find it one of the most wild and disorderly compositions ever put together; it has neither beginning, middle, nor end; and, except a short historical part, and a few sketches of history in the first two or three chapters, is one continued incoherent, bombastical rant, full of extravagant metaphor, without application, and destitute of meaning; a school-boy would scarcely have been excusable for writing such stuff; it is (at least in translation) that kind of composition and false taste that is properly called prose run mad.

Anyone who takes the trouble to read the book attributed to Isaiah will find it one of the wildest, most disorderly works ever put together. It has no beginning, middle, or end. Apart from a short historical section and a few sketches of history in the first two or three chapters, it is one long, incoherent, bombastic rant. It is full of extravagant metaphors that apply to nothing and mean nothing. A schoolboy could hardly be excused for writing such stuff. At least in translation, it is the kind of writing and bad taste rightly called prose gone mad.

The historical part begins at chapter xxxvi., and is continued to the end of chapter xxxix. It relates some matters that are said to have passed during the reign of Hezekiah, king of Judah, at which time Isaiah lived. This fragment of history begins and ends abruptly; it has not the least connection with the chapter that precedes it, nor with that which follows it, nor with any other in the book. It is probable that Isaiah wrote this fragment himself, because he was an actor in the circumstances it treats of; but except this part there are scarcely two chapters that have any connection with each other. One is entitled, at the beginning of the first verse, the burden of Babylon; another, the burden of Moab; another, the burden of Damascus; another, the burden of Egypt; another, the burden of the Desert of the Sea; another, the burden of the Valley of Vision: as you would say the story of the Knight of the Burning Mountain, the story of Cinderella, or the glassen slipper, the story of the Sleeping Beauty in the Wood, etc., etc.

The historical section begins in chapter 36 and continues through the end of chapter 39. It relates events said to have taken place during the reign of Hezekiah, king of Judah, when Isaiah lived. This fragment of history begins and ends abruptly. It has no connection at all with the chapters before or after it, or with any other chapter in the book. Isaiah probably wrote this fragment himself because he took part in the events it describes. But apart from this section, hardly any two chapters have any connection with each other. At the beginning of the first verse, one chapter is titled the burden of Babylon. Another is titled the burden of Moab. Others are titled the burden of Damascus, the burden of Egypt, the burden of the Desert of the Sea, and the burden of the Valley of Vision. These titles are like the story of the Knight of the Burning Mountain, the story of Cinderella, or the glass slipper, the story of the Sleeping Beauty in the Wood, and so on.

I have already shown, in the instance of the last two verses of 2 Chronicles, and the first three in Ezra, that the compilers of the Bible mixed and confounded the writings of different authors with each other; which alone, were there no other cause, is sufficient to destroy the authenticity of an compilation, because it is more than presumptive evidence that the compilers are ignorant who the authors were. A very glaring instance of this occurs in the book ascribed to Isaiah: the latter part of the 44th chapter, and the beginning of the 45th, so far from having been written by Isaiah, could only have been written by some person who lived at least an hundred and fifty years after Isaiah was dead.

I have already shown how the compilers of the Bible mixed up the writings of different authors. The last two verses of 2 Chronicles and the first three of Ezra provide an example. This alone, even without any other reason, is enough to destroy the authenticity of a compilation. It is more than presumptive evidence that the compilers did not know who the authors were. A glaring example appears in the book attributed to Isaiah. The later part of chapter 44 and the beginning of chapter 45 could not have been written by Isaiah. They could only have been written by someone who lived at least 150 years after Isaiah died.

These chapters are a compliment to Cyrus, who permitted the Jews to return to Jerusalem from the Babylonian captivity, to rebuild Jerusalem and the temple, as is stated in Ezra. The last verse of the 44th chapter, and the beginning of the 45th [Isaiah] are in the following words: “That saith of Cyrus, he is my shepherd, and shall perform all my pleasure; even saying to Jerusalem, thou shalt be built; and to the temple thy foundations shall be laid: thus saith the Lord to his enointed, to Cyrus, whose right hand I have holden to subdue nations before him, and I will loose the loins of kings to open before him the two-leaved gates, and the gates shall not be shut; I will go before thee,” etc.

These chapters pay tribute to Cyrus, who allowed the Jews to return to Jerusalem from captivity in Babylon. As stated in Ezra, he allowed them to rebuild Jerusalem and the temple. The last verse of chapter 44 and the beginning of chapter 45 of Isaiah say: “He says of Cyrus, he is my shepherd and will do all that I wish. He will say of Jerusalem, let it be rebuilt, and of the temple, let its foundations be laid. This is what the Lord says to his anointed, to Cyrus, whose right hand I have held. I will subdue nations before him and strip kings of their strength. I will open the double gates before him, and they will not be shut. I will go before you,” etc.

What audacity of church and priestly ignorance it is to impose this book upon the world as the writing of Isaiah, when Isaiah, according to their own chronology, died soon after the death of Hezekiah, which was B.C. 698; and the decree of Cyrus, in favour of the Jews returning to Jerusalem, was, according to the same chronology, B.C. 536; which is a distance of time between the two of 162 years. I do not suppose that the compilers of the Bible made these books, but rather that they picked up some loose, anonymous essays, and put them together under the names of such authors as best suited their purpose. They have encouraged the imposition, which is next to inventing it; for it was impossible but they must have observed it.

What audacity and ignorance the church and its priests show by presenting this book to the world as Isaiah’s writing! According to their own chronology, Isaiah died soon after Hezekiah’s death in 698 BC. According to that same chronology, Cyrus issued his decree allowing the Jews to return to Jerusalem in 536 BC. That is a gap of 162 years. I do not suppose the compilers of the Bible wrote these books. Rather, I think they gathered some separate, anonymous essays and put them together under the names of authors who best suited their purpose. They encouraged the deception, which is nearly as bad as inventing it. They could not possibly have failed to notice it.

When we see the studied craft of the scripture-makers, in making every part of this romantic book of school-boy’s eloquence bend to the monstrous idea of a Son of God, begotten by a ghost on the body of a virgin, there is no imposition we are not justified in suspecting them of. Every phrase and circumstance are marked with the barbarous hand of superstitious torture, and forced into meanings it was impossible they could have. The head of every chapter, and the top of every page, are blazoned with the names of Christ and the Church, that the unwary reader might suck in the error before he began to read.

The scripture-makers showed calculated skill in bending every part of this fanciful book, with its schoolboy eloquence, to one monstrous idea. That idea is that a ghost fathered a Son of God in a virgin's body. When we see this, we are justified in suspecting them of any deception. Every phrase and detail bears the brutal marks of superstitious torture. Each has been forced to mean something it could not possibly have meant. The names of Christ and the Church are displayed at the head of every chapter and every page. They are placed there so that unwary readers will absorb the error before they begin to read.

Behold a virgin shall conceive, and bear a son (Isa. vii. I4), has been interpreted to mean the person called Jesus Christ, and his mother Mary, and has been echoed through christendom for more than a thousand years; and such has been the rage of this opinion, that scarcely a spot in it but has been stained with blood and marked with desolation in consequence of it. Though it is not my intention to enter into controversy on subjects of this kind, but to confine myself to show that the Bible is spurious,—and thus, by taking away the foundation, to overthrow at once the whole structure of superstition raised thereon,—I will however stop a moment to expose the fallacious application of this passage.

“Behold, a virgin shall conceive and bear a son” (Isa. vii. 14) has been interpreted as referring to Jesus Christ and his mother Mary. This interpretation has been echoed throughout Christendom for more than a thousand years. The passion for this belief has been so fierce that scarcely a place in Christendom has escaped bloodshed and devastation because of it. I do not intend to enter into controversy over subjects of this kind. Instead, I intend to show that the Bible is spurious. By removing its foundation, I mean to overthrow the whole structure of superstition built upon it at once. But I will pause for a moment to expose the false application of this passage.

Whether Isaiah was playing a trick with Ahaz, king of Judah, to whom this passage is spoken, is no business of mine; I mean only to show the misapplication of the passage, and that it has no more reference to Christ and his mother, than it has to me and my mother. The story is simply this:

Whether Isaiah was playing a trick on Ahaz, king of Judah, is none of my concern. Isaiah addressed this passage to Ahaz. I only mean to show that the passage is being misapplied. It has no more to do with Christ and his mother than it does with me and my mother. The story is simple:

The king of Syria and the king of Israel (I have already mentioned that the Jews were split into two nations, one of which was called Judah, the capital of which was Jerusalem, and the other Israel) made war jointly against Ahaz, king of Judah, and marched their armies towards Jerusalem. Ahaz and his people became alarmed, and the account says (Is. vii. 2), Their hearts were moved as the trees of the wood are moved with the wind.

The king of Syria and the king of Israel joined forces to make war on Ahaz, king of Judah. As I have already mentioned, the Jews were split into two nations. One was called Judah, and its capital was Jerusalem. The other was called Israel. The two kings marched their armies toward Jerusalem. Ahaz and his people were alarmed. The account says (Is. vii. 2) that their hearts shook as the trees of the forest shake in the wind.

In this situation of things, Isaiah addresses himself to Ahaz, and assures him in the name of the Lord (the cant phrase of all the prophets) that these two kings should not succeed against him; and to satisfy Ahaz that this should be the case, tells him to ask a sign. This, the account says, Ahaz declined doing; giving as a reason that he would not tempt the Lord; upon which Isaiah, who is the speaker, says, ver. 14, “Therefore the Lord himself shall give you a sign; behold a virgin shall conceive and bear a son;” and the 16th verse says, “And before this child shall know to refuse the evil, and choose the good, the land which thou abhorrest or dreadest [meaning Syria and the kingdom of Israel] shall be forsaken of both her kings.” Here then was the sign, and the time limited for the completion of the assurance or promise; namely, before this child shall know to refuse the evil and choose the good.

In this situation, Isaiah speaks to Ahaz. He assures him, in the name of the Lord (the stock phrase of all the prophets), that the two kings will not succeed against him. To convince Ahaz of this, Isaiah tells him to ask for a sign. According to the account, Ahaz refuses, saying that he will not tempt the Lord. Isaiah then says in verse 14, “Therefore the Lord himself will give you a sign. Look, a virgin will conceive and bear a son.” Verse 16 says, “Before this child knows how to refuse evil and choose good, the land you hate or dread [meaning Syria and the kingdom of Israel] will be abandoned by both its kings.” Here, then, was the sign and the time set for fulfilling the assurance or promise: before the child knew how to refuse evil and choose good.

Isaiah having committed himself thus far, it became necessary to him, in order to avoid the imputation of being a false prophet, and the consequences thereof, to take measures to make this sign appear. It certainly was not a difficult thing, in any time of the world, to find a girl with child, or to make her so; and perhaps Isaiah knew of one beforehand; for I do not suppose that the prophets of that day were any more to be trusted than the priests of this: be that, however, as it may, he says in the next chapter, ver. 2, “And I took unto me faithful witnesses to record, Uriah the priest, and Zechariah the son of Jeberechiah, and I went unto the prophetess, and she conceived and bare a son.”

Isaiah had committed himself this far. To avoid being accused of being a false prophet and suffering the consequences, he had to make the sign appear. Surely, at any time in history, it was not difficult to find a pregnant girl or make her pregnant. Perhaps Isaiah knew of one beforehand. I do not suppose the prophets of that day were any more trustworthy than the priests of today. Be that as it may, Isaiah says in the next chapter, verse 2, “And I took faithful witnesses to record what happened, Uriah the priest and Zechariah the son of Jeberechiah. I went to the prophetess, and she conceived and gave birth to a son.”

Here then is the whole story, foolish as it is, of this child and this virgin; and it is upon the barefaced perversion of this story that the book of Matthew, and the impudence and sordid interest of priests in later times, have founded a theory, which they call the gospel; and have applied this story to signify the person they call Jesus Christ; begotten, they say, by a ghost, whom they call holy, on the body of a woman engaged in marriage, and afterwards married, whom they call a virgin, seven hundred years after this foolish story was told; a theory which, speaking for myself, I hesitate not to believe, and to say, is as fabulous and as false as God is true. [In Is. vii. 14, it is said that the child should be called Immanuel; but this name was not given to either of the children, otherwise than as a character, which the word signifies. That of the prophetess was called Maher-shalalhash-baz, and that of Mary was called Jesus.—Author.]

Here, then, is the whole foolish story of this child and this virgin. The book of Matthew and the shamelessness and selfish interests of priests in later times have built a theory on a blatant distortion of this story. They call their theory the gospel and apply the story to the person they call Jesus Christ. They say he was fathered by a ghost they call holy. His mother was a woman who was engaged to be married and later married, yet they call her a virgin. All this happened seven hundred years after the foolish story was told. Speaking for myself, I have no hesitation in believing and saying that this theory is as fictional and false as God is true. [In Is. vii. 14, it says that the child should be called Immanuel. But neither child was given this name, except as a description, which is what the word means. The prophetess's child was called Maher-shalalhash-baz, and Mary's child was called Jesus. Author.]

But to show the imposition and falsehood of Isaiah we have only to attend to the sequel of this story; which, though it is passed over in silence in the book of Isaiah, is related in 2 Chronicles, xxviii; and which is, that instead of these two kings failing in their attempt against Ahaz, king of Judah, as Isaiah had pretended to foretel in the name of the Lord, they succeeded: Ahaz was defeated and destroyed; an hundred and twenty thousand of his people were slaughtered; Jerusalem was plundered, and two hundred thousand women and sons and daughters carried into captivity. Thus much for this lying prophet and imposter Isaiah, and the book of falsehoods that bears his name. I pass on to the book of Jeremiah. This prophet, as he is called, lived in the time that Nebuchadnezzar besieged Jerusalem, in the reign of Zedekiah, the last king of Judah; and the suspicion was strong against him that he was a traitor in the interest of Nebuchadnezzar. Every thing relating to Jeremiah shows him to have been a man of an equivocal character: in his metaphor of the potter and the clay, (ch. xviii.) he guards his prognostications in such a crafty manner as always to leave himself a door to escape by, in case the event should be contrary to what he had predicted. In the 7th and 8th verses he makes the Almighty to say, “At what instant I shall speak concerning a nation, and concerning a kingdom, to pluck up, and to pull down, and destroy it, if that nation, against whom I have pronounced, turn from their evil, I will repent me of the evil that I thought to do unto them.” Here was a proviso against one side of the case: now for the other side. Verses 9 and 10, “At what instant I shall speak concerning a nation, and concerning a kingdom, to build and to plant it, if it do evil in my sight, that it obey not my voice, then I will repent me of the good wherewith I said I would benefit them.” Here is a proviso against the other side; and, according to this plan of prophesying, a prophet could never be wrong, however mistaken the Almighty might be. This sort of absurd subterfuge, and this manner of speaking of the Almighty, as one would speak of a man, is consistent with nothing but the stupidity of the Bible.

To expose Isaiah’s deception and lies, we need only look at what happened next. The book of Isaiah says nothing about it, but 2 Chronicles, chapter 28, tells the story. Isaiah had claimed to predict, in the name of the Lord, that the two kings would fail against Ahaz, king of Judah. Instead, they succeeded. Ahaz was defeated and destroyed. One hundred and twenty thousand of his people were slaughtered, Jerusalem was plundered, and two hundred thousand women, sons, and daughters were carried into captivity. So much for Isaiah, that lying prophet and impostor, and the book of lies that bears his name. I turn now to the book of Jeremiah. This prophet, as he is called, lived when Nebuchadnezzar besieged Jerusalem, during the reign of Zedekiah, the last king of Judah. He was strongly suspected of being a traitor working for Nebuchadnezzar. Everything about Jeremiah shows him to have been a man of questionable character. In his metaphor of the potter and the clay, in chapter 18, he phrases his predictions with cunning. He always leaves himself a way out in case events turn out differently from what he predicted. In verses 7 and 8, he has the Almighty say, “If I announce that I will uproot, pull down, and destroy a nation or kingdom, and that nation turns from its evil, I will change my mind about the harm I planned to do to it.” That provides an escape on one side. Now for the other. Verses 9 and 10 say, “If I announce that I will build up and plant a nation or kingdom, and it does evil in my sight and does not obey me, I will change my mind about the good I said I would do for it.” That provides an escape on the other side. Under this system of prophecy, a prophet could never be wrong, however mistaken the Almighty might be. This kind of absurd evasion, and this way of speaking about the Almighty as if he were a man, fit with nothing but the stupidity of the Bible.

As to the authenticity of the book, it is only necessary to read it in order to decide positively that, though some passages recorded therein may have been spoken by Jeremiah, he is not the author of the book. The historical parts, if they can be called by that name, are in the most confused condition; the same events are several times repeated, and that in a manner different, and sometimes in contradiction to each other; and this disorder runs even to the last chapter, where the history, upon which the greater part of the book has been employed, begins anew, and ends abruptly. The book has all the appearance of being a medley of unconnected anecdotes respecting persons and things of that time, collected together in the same rude manner as if the various and contradictory accounts that are to be found in a bundle of newspapers, respecting persons and things of the present day, were put together without date, order, or explanation. I will give two or three examples of this kind.

As for the book’s authenticity, one need only read it to reach a definite conclusion. Though Jeremiah may have spoken some passages in it, he is not the book’s author. The historical sections, if they can be called that, are hopelessly confused. The same events are repeated several times, with accounts that differ and sometimes contradict one another. The disorder continues even into the last chapter. There, the history that has occupied most of the book begins again and ends abruptly. The book looks like a jumble of disconnected anecdotes about people and events of that time. It is put together as crudely as a bundle of newspapers might be. Imagine their various and contradictory accounts of people and events today thrown together without dates, order, or explanation. I will give two or three examples of this.

It appears, from the account of chapter xxxvii. that the army of Nebuchadnezzer, which is called the army of the Chaldeans, had besieged Jerusalem some time; and on their hearing that the army of Pharaoh of Egypt was marching against them, they raised the siege and retreated for a time. It may here be proper to mention, in order to understand this confused history, that Nebuchadnezzar had besieged and taken Jerusalem during the reign of Jehoakim, the redecessor of Zedekiah; and that it was Nebuchadnezzar who had make Zedekiah king, or rather viceroy; and that this second siege, of which the book of Jeremiah treats, was in consequence of the revolt of Zedekiah against Nebuchadnezzar. This will in some measure account for the suspicion that affixes itself to Jeremiah of being a traitor, and in the interest of Nebuchadnezzar,—whom Jeremiah calls, xliii. 10, the servant of God.

Chapter 37 suggests that Nebuchadnezzar’s army, called the Chaldean army, had besieged Jerusalem for some time. When the Chaldeans heard that Pharaoh’s Egyptian army was marching against them, they lifted the siege and temporarily retreated. To understand this confused history, it helps to know that Nebuchadnezzar had besieged and captured Jerusalem during Jehoakim’s reign. Jehoakim was Zedekiah’s predecessor. Nebuchadnezzar had made Zedekiah king, or rather viceroy. The second siege, described in the book of Jeremiah, followed Zedekiah’s revolt against Nebuchadnezzar. This helps explain, to some extent, the suspicion that Jeremiah was a traitor acting in Nebuchadnezzar’s interest. In chapter 43, verse 10, Jeremiah calls Nebuchadnezzar the servant of God.

Chapter xxxvii. 11-13, says, “And it came to pass, that, when the army of the Chaldeans was broken up from Jerusalem, for fear of Pharaoh’s army, that Jeremiah went forth out of Jerusalem, to go (as this account states) into the land of Benjamin, to separate himself thence in the midst of the people; and when he was in the gate of Benjamin a captain of the ward was there, whose name was Irijah... and he took Jeremiah the prophet, saying, Thou fallest away to the Chaldeans; then Jeremiah said, It is false; I fall not away to the Chaldeans.” Jeremiah being thus stopt and accused, was, after being examined, committed to prison, on suspicion of being a traitor, where he remained, as is stated in the last verse of this chapter.

Chapter 37, verses 11 to 13, says, “The Chaldean army withdrew from Jerusalem because it feared Pharaoh’s army. Jeremiah then left Jerusalem. According to this account, he was going into the land of Benjamin to separate himself there among the people. At the Gate of Benjamin, a captain of the guard named Irijah was on duty... He seized Jeremiah the prophet and said, ‘You are deserting to the Chaldeans.’ Jeremiah replied, ‘That is false. I am not deserting to the Chaldeans.’” After Jeremiah was stopped and accused, he was questioned and sent to prison on suspicion of being a traitor. As the last verse of this chapter says, he remained there.

But the next chapter gives an account of the imprisonment of Jeremiah, which has no connection with this account, but ascribes his imprisonment to another circumstance, and for which we must go back to chapter xxi. It is there stated, ver. 1, that Zedekiah sent Pashur the son of Malchiah, and Zephaniah the son of Maaseiah the priest, to Jeremiah, to enquire of him concerning Nebuchadnezzar, whose army was then before Jerusalem; and Jeremiah said to them, ver. 8, “Thus saith the Lord, Behold I set before you the way of life, and the way of death; he that abideth in this city shall die by the sword and by the famine, and by the pestilence; but he that goeth out and falleth to the Chaldeans that besiege you, he shall live, and his life shall be unto him for a prey.”

But the next chapter gives an account of Jeremiah’s imprisonment that has no connection to this account. It attributes his imprisonment to another circumstance, which takes us back to chapter 21. Verse 1 says that Zedekiah sent Pashur, the son of Malchiah, and Zephaniah, the son of Maaseiah the priest, to Jeremiah. They were to ask him about Nebuchadnezzar, whose army was then outside Jerusalem. In verse 8, Jeremiah said to them: “This is what the Lord says: I set before you the way of life and the way of death. Anyone who stays in this city will die by the sword, famine, or plague. But anyone who goes out and surrenders to the Chaldeans besieging you will live. His life will be his prize.”

This interview and conference breaks off abruptly at the end of the 10th verse of chapter xxi.; and such is the disorder of this book that we have to pass over sixteen chapters upon various subjects, in order to come at the continuation and event of this conference; and this brings us to the first verse of chapter xxxviii., as I have just mentioned. The chapter opens with saying, “Then Shaphatiah, the son of Mattan, Gedaliah the son of Pashur, and Jucal the son of Shelemiah, and Pashur the son of Malchiah, (here are more persons mentioned than in chapter xxi.) heard the words that Jeremiah spoke unto all the people, saying, Thus saith the Lord, He that remaineth in this city, shall die by the sword, by famine, and by the pestilence; but he that goeth forth to the Chaldeans shall live; for he shall have his life for a prey, and shall live”; [which are the words of the conference;] therefore, (say they to Zedekiah,) “We beseech thee, let this man be put to death, for thus he weakeneth the hands of the men of war that remain in this city, and the hands of all the people, in speaking such words unto them; for this man seeketh not the welfare of the people, but the hurt:” and at the 6th verse it is said, “Then they took Jeremiah, and put him into the dungeon of Malchiah.”

This meeting and discussion breaks off abruptly at the end of verse 10 of chapter 21. The book is so disorganized that we must skip sixteen chapters on various subjects to find the discussion’s continuation and outcome. This brings us to the first verse of chapter 38, as I have just mentioned. The chapter opens by saying, “Then Shaphatiah son of Mattan, Gedaliah son of Pashur, Jucal son of Shelemiah, and Pashur son of Malchiah heard the words Jeremiah spoke to all the people.” More people are mentioned here than in chapter 21. Jeremiah said, “This is what the Lord says: Anyone who stays in this city will die by the sword, famine, or disease. But anyone who goes out to the Chaldeans will live. He will escape with his life.” These are the words from the discussion. So they say to Zedekiah, “Please put this man to death. By saying these things, he is weakening the resolve of the soldiers who remain in the city and of all the people. This man is not seeking the people’s welfare, but their harm.” And verse 6 says, “Then they took Jeremiah and put him in Malchiah’s dungeon.”

These two accounts are different and contradictory. The one ascribes his imprisonment to his attempt to escape out of the city; the other to his preaching and prophesying in the city; the one to his being seized by the guard at the gate; the other to his being accused before Zedekiah by the conferees. [I observed two chapters in I Samuel (xvi. and xvii.) that contradict each other with respect to David, and the manner he became acquainted with Saul; as Jeremiah xxxvii. and xxxviii. contradict each other with respect to the cause of Jeremiah’s imprisonment.

These two accounts are different and contradictory. One says he was imprisoned because he tried to escape from the city. The other says he was imprisoned because he preached and prophesied in the city. One says the guard seized him at the gate. The other says the officials accused him before Zedekiah. [I noted that two chapters in I Samuel (xvi. and xvii.) contradict each other about David and how he met Saul. Similarly, Jeremiah xxxvii. and xxxviii. contradict each other about the cause of Jeremiah’s imprisonment.

In 1 Samuel, xvi., it is said, that an evil spirit of God troubled Saul, and that his servants advised him (as a remedy) “to seek out a man who was a cunning player upon the harp.” And Saul said, ver. 17, “Provide me now a man that can play well, and bring him to me. Then answered one of his servants, and said, Behold, I have seen a son of Jesse, the Bethlehemite, that is cunning in playing, and a mighty man, and a man of war, and prudent in matters, and a comely person, and the Lord is with him; wherefore Saul sent messengers unto Jesse, and said, Send me David, thy son. And (verse 21) David came to Saul, and stood before him, and he loved him greatly, and he became his armour-bearer; and when the evil spirit from God was upon Saul, (verse 23) David took his harp, and played with his hand, and Saul was refreshed, and was well.”

In 1 Samuel, chapter 16, we are told that an evil spirit from God troubled Saul. His servants advised him to “find a man who could play the harp skillfully” as a remedy. In verse 17, Saul said, “Find me a man who can play well, and bring him to me. One of his servants answered, I have seen a son of Jesse, the Bethlehemite, who plays skillfully. He is a mighty man, a warrior, wise in his affairs, and handsome. The Lord is with him. So Saul sent messengers to Jesse and said, Send me your son David. And (verse 21) David came to Saul and entered his service. Saul loved him greatly, and David became his armor-bearer. When the evil spirit from God came upon Saul (verse 23), David took his harp and played it. Saul was refreshed and felt well.”

But the next chapter (xvii.) gives an account, all different to this, of the manner that Saul and David became acquainted. Here it is ascribed to David’s encounter with Goliah, when David was sent by his father to carry provision to his brethren in the camp. In the 55th verse of this chapter it is said, “And when Saul saw David go forth against the Philistine (Goliah) he said to Abner, the captain of the host, Abner, whose son is this youth? And Abner said, As thy soul liveth, 0 king, I cannot tell. And the king said, Enquire thou whose son the stripling is. And as David returned from the slaughter of the Philistine, Abner took him and brought him before Saul, with the head of the Philistine in his hand; and Saul said unto him, Whose son art thou, thou young man? And David answered, I am the son of thy servant, Jesse, the Betblehemite,” These two accounts belie each other, because each of them supposes Saul and David not to have known each other before. This book, the Bible, is too ridiculous for criticism.—Author.]

But the next chapter (xvii.) gives a completely different account of how Saul and David met. It says they met after David’s encounter with Goliah. David’s father had sent him to take food to his brothers in the camp. Verse 55 of this chapter says: “When Saul saw David go out against the Philistine (Goliah), he spoke to Abner, the army commander. He asked, Abner, whose son is this young man? Abner said, As surely as you live, O king, I do not know. The king said, Find out whose son the young man is. When David returned from killing the Philistine, Abner brought him before Saul. David was holding the Philistine’s head. Saul asked him, Whose son are you, young man? David answered, I am the son of your servant Jesse, the Bethlehemite.” These two accounts contradict each other. Each assumes that Saul and David had not met before. This book, the Bible, is too ridiculous for criticism. Author.]

In the next chapter (Jer. xxxix.) we have another instance of the disordered state of this book; for notwithstanding the siege of the city by Nebuchadnezzar has been the subject of several of the preceding chapters, particularly xxxvii. and xxxviii., chapter xxxix. begins as if not a word had been said upon the subject, and as if the reader was still to be informed of every particular respecting it; for it begins with saying, ver. 1, “In the ninth year of Zedekiah king of Judah, in the tenth month, came Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon, and all his army, against Jerusalem, and besieged it,” etc.

In the next chapter (Jer. 39), we find another example of how disorganized this book is. Nebuchadnezzar’s siege of the city has been the subject of several preceding chapters, especially chapters 37 and 38. Yet chapter 39 begins as if nothing had been said about it, and as if the reader still needed every detail. For it begins in verse 1: “In the ninth year of Zedekiah king of Judah, in the tenth month, Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon came with all his army against Jerusalem and besieged it,” etc.

But the instance in the last chapter (lii.) is still more glaring; for though the story has been told over and over again, this chapter still supposes the reader not to know anything of it, for it begins by saying, ver. i, “Zedekiah was one and twenty years old when he began to reign, and he reigned eleven years in Jerusalem, and his mother’s name was Hamutal, the daughter of Jeremiah of Libnah.” (Ver. 4,) “And it came to pass in the ninth year of his reign, in the tenth month, that Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon came, he and all his army, against Jerusalem, and pitched against it, and built forts against it,” etc.

But the example in the last chapter (52) is even more glaring. Though the story has been told over and over again, this chapter still assumes the reader knows nothing about it. It begins in verse 1: “Zedekiah was twenty-one years old when he began to reign. He reigned for eleven years in Jerusalem. His mother’s name was Hamutal, the daughter of Jeremiah of Libnah.” (Verse 4) “In the ninth year of his reign, in the tenth month, Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon came against Jerusalem with all his army. He camped outside the city and built forts against it,” etc.

It is not possible that any one man, and more particularly Jeremiah, could have been the writer of this book. The errors are such as could not have been committed by any person sitting down to compose a work. Were I, or any other man, to write in such a disordered manner, no body would read what was written, and every body would suppose that the writer was in a state of insanity. The only way, therefore, to account for the disorder is, that the book is a medley of detached unauthenticated anecdotes, put together by some stupid book-maker, under the name of Jeremiah; because many of them refer to him, and to the circumstances of the times he lived in.

No single person could have written this book, especially not Jeremiah. Its errors could not have been made by anyone sitting down to compose a work. If I or anyone else wrote in such a disordered way, nobody would read it. Everyone would assume the writer was insane. The only explanation for the disorder, then, is that the book is a jumble of separate, unauthenticated anecdotes. Some stupid book-maker put them together under Jeremiah's name because many refer to him and the circumstances of his time.

Of the duplicity, and of the false predictions of Jeremiah, I shall mention two instances, and then proceed to review the remainder of the Bible.

I will give two examples of Jeremiah’s deceit and false predictions. Then I will review the rest of the Bible.

It appears from chapter xxxviii. that when Jeremiah was in prison, Zedekiah sent for him, and at this interview, which was private, Jeremiah pressed it strongly on Zedekiah to surrender himself to the enemy. “If,” says he, (ver. 17,) “thou wilt assuredly go forth unto the king of Babylon’s princes, then thy soul shall live,” etc. Zedekiah was apprehensive that what passed at this conference should be known; and he said to Jeremiah, (ver. 25,) “If the princes [meaning those of Judah] hear that I have talked with thee, and they come unto thee, and say unto thee, Declare unto us now what thou hast said unto the king; hide it not from us, and we will not put thee to death; and also what the king said unto thee; then thou shalt say unto them, I presented my supplication before the king that he would not cause me to return to Jonathan’s house, to die there. Then came all the princes unto Jeremiah, and asked him, and “he told them according to all the words the king had commanded.” Thus, this man of God, as he is called, could tell a lie, or very strongly prevaricate, when he supposed it would answer his purpose; for certainly he did not go to Zedekiah to make this supplication, neither did he make it; he went because he was sent for, and he employed that opportunity to advise Zedekiah to surrender himself to Nebuchadnezzar.

Chapter 38 shows that Zedekiah sent for Jeremiah while Jeremiah was in prison. At this private meeting, Jeremiah strongly urged Zedekiah to surrender to the enemy. “If,” he said (verse 17), “you surely go out to the king of Babylon’s princes, then your life will be spared,” etc. Zedekiah was afraid that others would learn what was said at the meeting. He said to Jeremiah (verse 25), “If the princes [meaning those of Judah] hear that I have talked with you, they may come and question you. They may say, ‘Tell us now what you said to the king. Do not hide it from us, and we will not put you to death. Tell us also what the king said to you.’ Then you must tell them, ‘I begged the king not to send me back to Jonathan’s house to die there.’” Then all the princes came to Jeremiah and questioned him. He “told them everything the king had commanded him to say.” Thus this man of God, as he is called, could lie or be highly evasive when he thought it would serve his purpose. For he certainly did not go to Zedekiah to make this request, nor did he make it. He went because he was sent for. He used the opportunity to advise Zedekiah to surrender to Nebuchadnezzar.

In chapter xxxiv. 2-5, is a prophecy of Jeremiah to Zedekiah in these words: “Thus saith the Lord, Behold I will give this city into the hand of the king of Babylon, and he will burn it with fire; and thou shalt not escape out of his hand, but thou shalt surely be taken, and delivered into his hand; and thine eyes shall behold the eyes of the king of Babylon, and he shall speak with thee mouth to mouth, and thou shalt go to Babylon. Yet hear the word of the Lord; O Zedekiah, king, of Judah, thus saith the Lord, Thou shalt not die by the sword, but thou shalt die in Peace; and with the burnings of thy fathers, the former kings that were before thee, so shall they burn odours for thee, and they will lament thee, saying, Ah, Lord! for I have pronounced the word, saith the Lord.”

In chapter 34, verses 2 through 5, Jeremiah gives Zedekiah this prophecy: “This is what the Lord says: I will give this city to the king of Babylon, and he will burn it down. You will not escape him. You will surely be captured and handed over to him. You will see the king of Babylon face to face, and he will speak to you in person. And you will go to Babylon. Yet hear the word of the Lord, Zedekiah, king of Judah. This is what the Lord says: You will not die by the sword, but you will die in peace. People will burn fragrant spices for you, just as they did for your ancestors, the kings who ruled before you. And they will mourn you, saying, ‘Ah, Lord!’ For I have spoken, says the Lord.”

Now, instead of Zedekiah beholding the eyes of the king of Babylon, and speaking with him mouth to mouth, and dying in peace, and with the burning of odours, as at the funeral of his fathers, (as Jeremiah had declared the Lord himself had pronounced,) the reverse, according to chapter Iii., 10, 11 was the case; it is there said, that the king of Babylon slew the sons of Zedekiah before his eyes: then he put out the eyes of Zedekiah, and bound him in chains, and carried him to Babylon, and put him in prison till the day of his death.

Jeremiah declared that the Lord himself had made a promise about Zedekiah. Zedekiah would look the king of Babylon in the eyes and speak with him face to face. He would die in peace, and fragrant spices would be burned at his funeral, as at his fathers’ funerals. But according to chapter 52, verses 10 and 11, the opposite happened. The king of Babylon killed Zedekiah’s sons before his eyes. Then he put out Zedekiah’s eyes, bound him in chains, and carried him to Babylon. There he put Zedekiah in prison until the day he died.

What then can we say of these prophets, but that they are impostors and liars?

So what can we say about these prophets except that they are frauds and liars?

As for Jeremiah, he experienced none of those evils. He was taken into favour by Nebuchadnezzar, who gave him in charge to the captain of the guard (xxxix, 12), “Take him (said he) and look well to him, and do him no harm; but do unto him even as he shall say unto thee.” Jeremiah joined himself afterwards to Nebuchadnezzar, and went about prophesying for him against the Egyptians, who had marched to the relief of Jerusalem while it was besieged. Thus much for another of the lying prophets, and the book that bears his name.

As for Jeremiah, he suffered none of those evils. Nebuchadnezzar favored him and placed him in the care of the captain of the guard (xxxix, 12). He said, “Take him and look after him. Do him no harm, but do whatever he asks you.” Jeremiah later joined Nebuchadnezzar and went about prophesying for him against the Egyptians. They had marched to help Jerusalem while it was under siege. So much for another lying prophet and the book that bears his name.

I have been the more particular in treating of the books ascribed to Isaiah and Jeremiah, because those two are spoken of in the books of Kings and Chronicles, which the others are not. The remainder of the books ascribed to the men called prophets I shall not trouble myself much about; but take them collectively into the observations I shall offer on the character of the men styled prophets.

I have discussed the books attributed to Isaiah and Jeremiah in greater detail because those two are mentioned in Kings and Chronicles. The other prophets are not. I will not concern myself much with the remaining books attributed to the men called prophets. Instead, I will consider them together in my comments on the character of these men.

In the former part of the ‘Age of Reason,’ I have said that the word prophet was the Bible-word for poet, and that the flights and metaphors of Jewish poets have been foolishly erected into what are now called prophecies. I am sufficiently justified in this opinion, not only because the books called the prophecies are written in poetical language, but because there is no word in the Bible, except it be the word prophet, that describes what we mean by a poet. I have also said, that the word signified a performer upon musical instruments, of which I have given some instances; such as that of a company of prophets, prophesying with psalteries, with tabrets, with pipes, with harps, etc., and that Saul prophesied with them, 1 Sam. x., 5. It appears from this passage, and from other parts in the book of Samuel, that the word prophet was confined to signify poetry and music; for the person who was supposed to have a visionary insight into concealed things, was not a prophet but a seer, [I know not what is the Hebrew word that corresponds to the word seer in English; but I observe it is translated into French by Le Voyant, from the verb voir to see, and which means the person who sees, or the seer.—Author.]

In the earlier part of ‘The Age of Reason,’ I said that prophet was the Bible’s word for poet. I also said that the flights of imagination and metaphors of Jewish poets have been foolishly turned into what are now called prophecies. I have good reason for this view. The books called prophecies are written in poetic language. Also, apart from prophet, the Bible has no word for what we mean by a poet. I have also said that the word meant a person who played musical instruments, and I gave some examples. One was a group of prophets prophesying with psalteries, tambourines, pipes, harps, and other instruments. Saul prophesied with them, as described in 1 Samuel 10:5. This passage and other parts of Samuel suggest that the word prophet referred only to poetry and music. A person believed to have visionary insight into hidden things was not a prophet but a seer. [I do not know the Hebrew word that corresponds to the English word seer. But I note that it is translated into French as Le Voyant, from the verb voir, meaning to see. Le Voyant means the person who sees, or the seer. Author.]

[The Hebrew word for Seer, in 1 Samuel ix., transliterated, is chozeh, the gazer, it is translated in Is. xlvii. 13, “the stargazers.”—Editor.] (i Sam, ix. 9;) and it was not till after the word seer went out of use (which most probably was when Saul banished those he called wizards) that the profession of the seer, or the art of seeing, became incorporated into the word prophet.

[The Hebrew word for Seer in 1 Samuel ix., transliterated, is chozeh, meaning “the gazer.” In Is. xlvii. 13, it is translated as “the stargazers.” (Editor.)] (1 Sam. ix. 9.) The word seer fell out of use, most likely when Saul banished those he called wizards. Only after that did the word prophet come to include the profession of the seer, or the art of seeing.

According to the modern meaning of the word prophet and prophesying, it signifies foretelling events to a great distance of time; and it became necessary to the inventors of the gospel to give it this latitude of meaning, in order to apply or to stretch what they call the prophecies of the Old Testament, to the times of the New. But according to the Old Testament, the prophesying of the seer, and afterwards of the prophet, so far as the meaning of the word “seer” was incorporated into that of prophet, had reference only to things of the time then passing, or very closely connected with it; such as the event of a battle they were going to engage in, or of a journey, or of any enterprise they were going to undertake, or of any circumstance then pending, or of any difficulty they were then in; all of which had immediate reference to themselves (as in the case already mentioned of Ahaz and Isaiah with respect to the expression, Behold a virgin shall conceive and bear a son,) and not to any distant future time. It was that kind of prophesying that corresponds to what we call fortune-telling; such as casting nativities, predicting riches, fortunate or unfortunate marriages, conjuring for lost goods, etc.; and it is the fraud of the Christian church, not that of the Jews, and the ignorance and the superstition of modern, not that of ancient times, that elevated those poetical, musical, conjuring, dreaming, strolling gentry, into the rank they have since had.

In modern usage, the words prophet and prophesying refer to foretelling events far in the future. The inventors of the gospel had to give these words such a broad meaning. That allowed them to apply, or stretch, what they call the prophecies of the Old Testament to New Testament times. But in the Old Testament, a seer’s prophesying concerned only events happening at the time or closely connected to it. The same was true of a prophet’s prophesying, insofar as the word prophet had taken on the meaning of “seer”. These events included the outcome of an approaching battle or journey, or of any enterprise they were about to undertake. They also included any pending circumstance or difficulty they faced. All of these matters concerned the people themselves, not some distant future time. That was true in the case already mentioned of Ahaz and Isaiah, and the expression, Behold a virgin shall conceive and bear a son. This kind of prophesying corresponds to what we call fortune-telling. It includes casting birth horoscopes, predicting riches and lucky or unlucky marriages, conjuring to find lost goods, and so on. It was the fraud of the Christian church, not the Jews, that raised these poetic, musical, conjuring, dreaming, wandering characters to the rank they have since held. It was also the ignorance and superstition of modern times, not ancient times, that raised them to that rank.

But, besides this general character of all the prophets, they had also a particular character. They were in parties, and they prophesied for or against, according to the party they were with; as the poetical and political writers of the present day write in defence of the party they associate with against the other.

But besides this general character shared by all the prophets, they also had a particular character. They belonged to parties, and they prophesied for or against others according to their party. In the same way, today's poets and political writers defend their own party against the other.

After the Jews were divided into two nations, that of Judah and that of Israel, each party had its prophets, who abused and accused each other of being false prophets, lying prophets, impostors, etc.

After the Jews split into two nations, Judah and Israel, each side had its own prophets. These prophets insulted one another and accused each other of being false prophets, liars, impostors, and so on.

The prophets of the party of Judah prophesied against the prophets of the party of Israel; and those of the party of Israel against those of Judah. This party prophesying showed itself immediately on the separation under the first two rival kings, Rehoboam and Jeroboam. The prophet that cursed, or prophesied against the altar that Jeroboam had built in Bethel, was of the party of Judah, where Rehoboam was king; and he was way-laid on his return home by a prophet of the party of Israel, who said unto him (i Kings xiii.) “Art thou the man of God that came from Judah? and he said, I am.” Then the prophet of the party of Israel said to him “I am a prophet also, as thou art, [signifying of Judah,] and an angel spake unto me by the word of the Lord, saying, Bring him back with thee unto thine house, that he may eat bread and drink water; but (says the 18th verse) he lied unto him.” The event, however, according to the story, is, that the prophet of Judah never got back to Judah; for he was found dead on the road by the contrivance of the prophet of Israel, who no doubt was called a true prophet by his own party, and the prophet of Judah a lying prophet.

The prophets of Judah prophesied against the prophets of Israel, and the prophets of Israel against those of Judah. This partisan prophesying began immediately after the separation under the first two rival kings, Rehoboam and Jeroboam. The prophet who cursed, or prophesied against, the altar Jeroboam had built in Bethel belonged to Judah, where Rehoboam was king. On his way home, he was intercepted by a prophet of Israel. The prophet of Israel asked him (1 Kings xiii.), “Are you the man of God who came from Judah? And he said, I am.” Then the prophet of Israel said to him, “I am a prophet too, as you are, [meaning a prophet of Judah,] and an angel spoke to me by the word of the Lord. He said, Bring him back with you to your house, so that he may eat bread and drink water. But (says verse 18) he lied to him.” According to the story, however, the prophet of Judah never got back to Judah. Because of the prophet of Israel’s scheme, he was found dead on the road. No doubt the prophet of Israel’s own party called him a true prophet and the prophet of Judah a lying prophet.

In 2 Kings, iii., a story is related of prophesying or conjuring that shews, in several particulars, the character of a prophet. Jehoshaphat king of Judah, and Joram king of Israel, had for a while ceased their party animosity, and entered into an alliance; and these two, together with the king of Edom, engaged in a war against the king of Moab. After uniting and marching their armies, the story says, they were in great distress for water, upon which Jehoshaphat said, “Is there not here a prophet of the Lord, that we may enquire of the Lord by him? and one of the servants of the king of Israel said here is Elisha. [Elisha was of the party of Judah.] And Jehoshaphat the king of Judah said, The word of the Lord is with him.” The story then says, that these three kings went down to Elisha; and when Elisha [who, as I have said, was a Judahmite prophet] saw the King of Israel, he said unto him, “What have I to do with thee, get thee to the prophets of thy father and the prophets of thy mother. Nay but, said the king of Israel, the Lord hath called these three kings together, to deliver them into the hands of the king of Moab,” (meaning because of the distress they were in for water;) upon which Elisha said, “As the Lord of hosts liveth before whom I stand, surely, were it not that I regard the presence of Jehoshaphat, king of Judah, I would not look towards thee nor see thee.” Here is all the venom and vulgarity of a party prophet. We are now to see the performance, or manner of prophesying.

In 2 Kings 3, a story of prophecy or conjuring reveals a prophet’s character in several ways. Jehoshaphat, king of Judah, and Joram, king of Israel, had temporarily set aside their party hostility and formed an alliance. Together with the king of Edom, they went to war against the king of Moab. After joining forces and marching their armies, the story says, they were desperately short of water. Jehoshaphat then asked, “Is there no prophet of the Lord here, through whom we can ask the Lord?” One of the king of Israel’s servants said that Elisha was there. [Elisha belonged to the party of Judah.] Jehoshaphat, king of Judah, said, “The word of the Lord is with him.” The story then says that the three kings went down to Elisha. As I have said, Elisha was a Judahmite prophet. When he saw the king of Israel, he said, “What do I have to do with you? Go to the prophets of your father and your mother.” The king of Israel replied, “No, the Lord has called these three kings together to deliver them into the hands of the king of Moab.” He meant this because they were desperately short of water. Elisha then said, “As surely as the Lord of hosts lives, before whom I stand, I would not look at you or even see you if I did not respect the presence of Jehoshaphat, king of Judah.” Here we have all the venom and vulgarity of a party prophet. Now we are to see the performance, or how he prophesies.

Ver. 15. “‘Bring me,’ (said Elisha), ‘a minstrel’; and it came to pass, when the minstrel played, that the hand of the Lord came upon him.” Here is the farce of the conjurer. Now for the prophecy: “And Elisha said, [singing most probably to the tune he was playing], Thus saith the Lord, Make this valley full of ditches;” which was just telling them what every countryman could have told them without either fiddle or farce, that the way to get water was to dig for it.

Verse 15. “‘Bring me a musician,’ said Elisha. And when the musician played, the hand of the Lord came upon him.” Here is the conjurer’s farce. Now for the prophecy: “And Elisha said, [probably singing to the tune the musician was playing], This is what the Lord says: Fill this valley with ditches.” This was just telling them what any countryman could have told them without a fiddle or a farce. To get water, dig for it.

But as every conjuror is not famous alike for the same thing, so neither were those prophets; for though all of them, at least those I have spoken of, were famous for lying, some of them excelled in cursing. Elisha, whom I have just mentioned, was a chief in this branch of prophesying; it was he that cursed the forty-two children in the name of the Lord, whom the two she-bears came and devoured. We are to suppose that those children were of the party of Israel; but as those who will curse will lie, there is just as much credit to be given to this story of Elisha’s two she-bears as there is to that of the Dragon of Wantley, of whom it is said:

Just as not every conjurer is famous for the same thing, neither were the prophets. All of them, at least those I have mentioned, were famous for lying. But some of them excelled at cursing. Elisha, whom I just mentioned, was a leader in this branch of prophecy. He cursed the forty-two children in the name of the Lord, and two female bears came and devoured them. We are supposed to assume that those children belonged to the party of Israel. But people who curse also lie. So Elisha’s story of the two bears is just as credible as the story of the Dragon of Wantley, of whom it is said:

Poor children three devoured be, That could not with him grapple; And at one sup he eat them up, As a man would eat an apple.

Three poor children were devoured, They could not fight him off. He ate them up in one gulp, As a man would eat an apple.

There was another description of men called prophets, that amused themselves with dreams and visions; but whether by night or by day we know not. These, if they were not quite harmless, were but little mischievous. Of this class are,

There was another kind of men called prophets, who amused themselves with dreams and visions. But we do not know whether these came by night or by day. If these men were not entirely harmless, they did little harm. Among them are,

EZEKIEL and DANIEL; and the first question upon these books, as upon all the others, is, Are they genuine? that is, were they written by Ezekiel and Daniel?

EZEKIEL and DANIEL. The first question about these books, as with all the others, is whether they are genuine. Were they written by Ezekiel and Daniel?

Of this there is no proof; but so far as my own opinion goes, I am more inclined to believe they were, than that they were not. My reasons for this opinion are as follows: First, Because those books do not contain internal evidence to prove they were not written by Ezekiel and Daniel, as the books ascribed to Moses, Joshua, Samuel, etc., prove they were not written by Moses, Joshua, Samuel, etc.

There is no proof of this. But in my opinion, it is more likely that they were than that they were not. My reasons are as follows: First, the books contain no internal evidence that Ezekiel and Daniel did not write them. By contrast, the books attributed to Moses, Joshua, Samuel, etc., contain evidence that those men did not write them.

Secondly, Because they were not written till after the Babylonish captivity began; and there is good reason to believe that not any book in the bible was written before that period; at least it is proveable, from the books themselves, as I have already shown, that they were not written till after the commencement of the Jewish monarchy.

Second, because they were not written until after the Babylonian captivity began. There is good reason to believe that no book in the Bible was written before then. At least, as I have already shown, the books themselves prove they were written after the Jewish monarchy began.

Thirdly, Because the manner in which the books ascribed to Ezekiel and Daniel are written, agrees with the condition these men were in at the time of writing them.

Third, because the writing style of the books attributed to Ezekiel and Daniel fits their circumstances at the time they wrote them.

Had the numerous commentators and priests, who have foolishly employed or wasted their time in pretending to expound and unriddle those books, been carred into captivity, as Ezekiel and Daniel were, it would greatly have improved their intellects in comprehending the reason for this mode of writing, and have saved them the trouble of racking their invention, as they have done to no purpose; for they would have found that themselves would be obliged to write whatever they had to write, respecting their own affairs, or those of their friends, or of their country, in a concealed manner, as those men have done.

The many commentators and priests have foolishly spent or wasted their time pretending to explain and unravel those books. If they had been taken captive, as Ezekiel and Daniel were, they would have better understood why those men wrote that way. They would also have spared themselves the trouble of straining their imaginations for no purpose, as they have done. For they would have found that they, too, had to write in a concealed way, as those men did. They would have had to do so when writing about their own affairs, those of their friends, or those of their country.

These two books differ from all the rest; for it is only these that are filled with accounts of dreams and visions: and this difference arose from the situation the writers were in as prisoners of war, or prisoners of state, in a foreign country, which obliged them to convey even the most trifling information to each other, and all their political projects or opinions, in obscure and metaphorical terms. They pretend to have dreamed dreams, and seen visions, because it was unsafe for them to speak facts or plain language. We ought, however, to suppose, that the persons to whom they wrote understood what they meant, and that it was not intended anybody else should. But these busy commentators and priests have been puzzling their wits to find out what it was not intended they should know, and with which they have nothing to do.

These two books differ from all the others. Only these two are filled with accounts of dreams and visions. This difference arose because the writers were prisoners of war or political prisoners in a foreign country. They had to use obscure and metaphorical language to share even the most trivial information, as well as all their political plans and opinions. They claimed to have had dreams and seen visions because it was unsafe to state facts or speak plainly. We should assume, however, that the people they wrote to understood their meaning. No one else was meant to understand it. But these meddling commentators and priests have been racking their brains to discover what they were never meant to know and what is none of their business.

Ezekiel and Daniel were carried prisoners to Babylon, under the first captivity, in the time of Jehoiakim, nine years before the second captivity in the time of Zedekiah. The Jews were then still numerous, and had considerable force at Jerusalem; and as it is natural to suppose that men in the situation of Ezekiel and Daniel would be meditating the recovery of their country, and their own deliverance, it is reasonable to suppose that the accounts of dreams and visions with which these books are filled, are no other than a disguised mode of correspondence to facilitate those objects: it served them as a cypher, or secret alphabet. If they are not this, they are tales, reveries, and nonsense; or at least a fanciful way of wearing off the wearisomeness of captivity; but the presumption is, they are the former.

Ezekiel and Daniel were taken prisoner to Babylon during the first captivity, in the time of Jehoiakim. This was nine years before the second captivity, in the time of Zedekiah. The Jews were still numerous then and had a considerable force in Jerusalem. It is natural to suppose that men in the position of Ezekiel and Daniel would have been planning to recover their country and secure their own freedom. So it is reasonable to suppose that the dreams and visions filling these books were simply a disguised way of communicating to help achieve those goals. They served as a cipher, or secret alphabet. If they were not a cipher, they were tales, daydreams, and nonsense. Or at least, they were a fanciful way to pass the tedious days of captivity. But the more likely explanation is that they were a cipher.

Ezekiel begins his book by speaking of a vision of cherubims, and of a wheel within a wheel, which he says he saw by the river Chebar, in the land of his captivity. Is it not reasonable to suppose that by the cherubims he meant the temple at Jerusalem, where they had figures of cherubims? and by a wheel within a wheel (which as a figure has always been understood to signify political contrivance) the project or means of recovering Jerusalem? In the latter part of his book he supposes himself transported to Jerusalem, and into the temple; and he refers back to the vision on the river Chebar, and says, (xliii- 3,) that this last vision was like the vision on the river Chebar; which indicates that those pretended dreams and visions had for their object the recovery of Jerusalem, and nothing further.

Ezekiel begins his book by describing a vision of cherubim and a wheel within a wheel. He says he saw them by the river Chebar, in the land where he was held captive. Is it not reasonable to suppose that the cherubim meant the temple at Jerusalem, where there were figures of cherubim? And that the wheel within a wheel meant the plan or means of recovering Jerusalem? As a figure, a wheel within a wheel has always been understood to signify political maneuvering. Later in his book, Ezekiel imagines himself transported to Jerusalem and into the temple. He refers back to the vision by the river Chebar. He says (xliii- 3) that this last vision was like the one by the river Chebar. This suggests that those supposed dreams and visions had no purpose beyond the recovery of Jerusalem.

As to the romantic interpretations and applications, wild as the dreams and visions they undertake to explain, which commentators and priests have made of those books, that of converting them into things which they call prophecies, and making them bend to times and circumstances as far remote even as the present day, it shows the fraud or the extreme folly to which credulity or priestcraft can go.

Commentators and priests have made fanciful interpretations and applications of those books. Their interpretations are as wild as the dreams and visions they claim to explain. They turn the books into what they call prophecies. They twist them to fit times and circumstances as far removed as the present day. This shows the fraud or extreme folly that credulity or priestcraft can lead to.

Scarcely anything can be more absurd than to suppose that men situated as Ezekiel and Daniel were, whose country was over-run, and in the possession of the enemy, all their friends and relations in captivity abroad, or in slavery at home, or massacred, or in continual danger of it; scarcely any thing, I say, can be more absurd than to suppose that such men should find nothing to do but that of employing their time and their thoughts about what was to happen to other nations a thousand or two thousand years after they were dead; at the same time nothing more natural than that they should meditate the recovery of Jerusalem, and their own deliverance; and that this was the sole object of all the obscure and apparently frantic writing contained in those books.

Hardly anything could be more absurd than to suppose that men in the position of Ezekiel and Daniel had nothing else to do. Their country had been overrun and was in enemy hands. All their friends and relatives were captives abroad, slaves at home, or massacred, or were in constant danger of massacre. Yet we are supposed to believe that these men spent their time and thoughts on what would happen to other nations a thousand or two thousand years after their deaths. On the other hand, nothing is more natural than that they should think about retaking Jerusalem and gaining their own freedom. That was the sole purpose of all the obscure and seemingly frantic writing in those books.

In this sense the mode of writing used in those two books being forced by necessity, and not adopted by choice, is not irrational; but, if we are to use the books as prophecies, they are false. In Ezekiel xxix. 11., speaking of Egypt, it is said, “No foot of man shall pass through it, nor foot of beast pass through it; neither shall it be inhabited for forty years.” This is what never came to pass, and consequently it is false, as all the books I have already reviewed are.—I here close this part of the subject.

In this sense, the style of writing in those two books is not unreasonable. It was forced by necessity, not chosen freely. But if we use the books as prophecies, they are false. In Ezekiel 29:11, speaking of Egypt, it says: “No human foot or animal foot will pass through it. No one will live there for forty years.” This never happened, so the prophecy is false, as are all the books I have already reviewed. I will end this part of the discussion here.

In the former part of ‘The Age of Reason’ I have spoken of Jonah, and of the story of him and the whale.—A fit story for ridicule, if it was written to be believed; or of laughter, if it was intended to try what credulity could swallow; for, if it could swallow Jonah and the whale it could swallow anything.

In the earlier part of ‘The Age of Reason’, I discussed Jonah and the story of him and the whale. The story deserves ridicule if it was written to be believed. It deserves laughter if it was meant to test what gullible people would swallow. For if they could swallow Jonah and the whale, they could swallow anything.

But, as is already shown in the observations on the book of Job and of Proverbs, it is not always certain which of the books in the Bible are originally Hebrew, or only translations from the books of the Gentiles into Hebrew; and, as the book of Jonah, so far from treating of the affairs of the Jews, says nothing upon that subject, but treats altogether of the Gentiles, it is more probable that it is a book of the Gentiles than of the Jews, [I have read in an ancient Persian poem (Saadi, I believe, but have mislaid the reference) this phrase: “And now the whale swallowed Jonah: the sun set.”—Editor.] and that it has been written as a fable to expose the nonsense, and satyrize the vicious and malignant character, of a Bible-prophet, or a predicting priest.

But, as I have already shown in my observations on Job and Proverbs, the origins of the Bible’s books are not always certain. Some may have been written in Hebrew, while others may be translations of Gentile books into Hebrew. The book of Jonah says nothing about Jewish affairs. Instead, it deals entirely with Gentiles. It is therefore more likely a Gentile book than a Jewish one. [I have read this phrase in an ancient Persian poem, by Saadi, I believe, though I have lost the reference: “And now the whale swallowed Jonah: the sun set.” Editor.] It was probably written as a fable to expose the nonsense and mock the vicious and malicious character of a Bible prophet, or a priest who makes predictions.

Jonah is represented, first as a disobedient prophet, running away from his mission, and taking shelter aboard a vessel of the Gentiles, bound from Joppa to Tarshish; as if he ignorantly supposed, by such a paltry contrivance, he could hide himself where God could not find him. The vessel is overtaken by a storm at sea; and the mariners, all of whom are Gentiles, believing it to be a judgement on account of some one on board who had committed a crime, agreed to cast lots to discover the offender; and the lot fell upon Jonah. But before this they had cast all their wares and merchandise over-board to lighten the vessel, while Jonah, like a stupid fellow, was fast asleep in the hold.

Jonah is first portrayed as a disobedient prophet who runs away from his mission. He takes refuge aboard a ship belonging to Gentiles, bound from Joppa to Tarshish. It is as if he foolishly thought this pathetic scheme could hide him where God could not find him. A storm overtakes the ship at sea. The sailors, who are all Gentiles, believe the storm is a punishment for a crime someone aboard has committed. They agree to draw lots to find the offender, and the lot falls on Jonah. But before this, they had thrown all their goods and merchandise overboard to lighten the ship. Meanwhile, Jonah was fast asleep in the hold, like a stupid fool.

After the lot had designated Jonah to be the offender, they questioned him to know who and what he was? and he told them he was an Hebrew; and the story implies that he confessed himself to be guilty. But these Gentiles, instead of sacrificing him at once without pity or mercy, as a company of Bible-prophets or priests would have done by a Gentile in the same case, and as it is related Samuel had done by Agag, and Moses by the women and children, they endeavoured to save him, though at the risk of their own lives: for the account says, “Nevertheless [that is, though Jonah was a Jew and a foreigner, and the cause of all their misfortunes, and the loss of their cargo] the men rowed hard to bring the boat to land, but they could not, for the sea wrought and was tempestuous against them.” Still however they were unwilling to put the fate of the lot into execution; and they cried, says the account, unto the Lord, saying, “We beseech thee, O Lord, let us not perish for this man’s life, and lay not upon us innocent blood; for thou, O Lord, hast done as it pleased thee.” Meaning thereby, that they did not presume to judge Jonah guilty, since that he might be innocent; but that they considered the lot that had fallen upon him as a decree of God, or as it pleased God. The address of this prayer shows that the Gentiles worshipped one Supreme Being, and that they were not idolaters as the Jews represented them to be. But the storm still continuing, and the danger encreasing, they put the fate of the lot into execution, and cast Jonah in the sea; where, according to the story, a great fish swallowed him up whole and alive!

After the lot identified Jonah as the offender, the men questioned him about who he was and what he did. He told them he was a Hebrew, and the story implies that he admitted his guilt. But these Gentiles did not immediately sacrifice him without pity or mercy. A company of Bible prophets or priests would have done that to a Gentile in the same situation. Samuel is said to have done it to Agag, and Moses to the women and children. Instead, the men tried to save Jonah, even at the risk of their own lives. For the account says, “Nevertheless the men rowed hard to bring the boat to land. But they could not, for the sea grew stormier and raged against them.” They did this even though Jonah was a Jew and a foreigner, and had caused all their troubles and the loss of their cargo. Still, they were unwilling to carry out the fate decided by the lot. According to the account, they cried out to the Lord, saying, “We beg you, O Lord, do not let us die for taking this man's life. Do not hold us guilty of shedding innocent blood, for you, O Lord, have done as you pleased.” They meant that they did not presume to judge Jonah guilty, since he might be innocent. But they took the lot that fell on him as God's decree, or as what pleased God. The prayer's address shows that the Gentiles worshipped one Supreme Being. It also shows that they were not idolaters, as the Jews represented them to be. But the storm continued, and the danger increased. So they carried out the fate decided by the lot and threw Jonah into the sea. There, according to the story, a great fish swallowed him whole and alive!

We have now to consider Jonah securely housed from the storm in the fish’s belly. Here we are told that he prayed; but the prayer is a made-up prayer, taken from various parts of the Psalms, without connection or consistency, and adapted to the distress, but not at all to the condition that Jonah was in. It is such a prayer as a Gentile, who might know something of the Psalms, could copy out for him. This circumstance alone, were there no other, is sufficient to indicate that the whole is a made-up story. The prayer, however, is supposed to have answered the purpose, and the story goes on, (taking-off at the same time the cant language of a Bible-prophet,) saying, “The Lord spake unto the fish, and it vomited out Jonah upon dry land.”

We now come to Jonah, safely sheltered from the storm in the fish’s belly. We are told that he prayed there. But the prayer is made up from various parts of the Psalms, with no connection or consistency. It suits his distress, but not the situation he was in. It is the kind of prayer a Gentile who knew something of the Psalms could copy out for him. This fact alone, even without any other evidence, is enough to show that the whole story is made up. The prayer, however, is supposed to have achieved its purpose. The story goes on, imitating the pious language of a Bible prophet: “The Lord spoke to the fish, and it vomited Jonah onto dry land.”

Jonah then received a second mission to Nineveh, with which he sets out; and we have now to consider him as a preacher. The distress he is represented to have suffered, the remembrance of his own disobedience as the cause of it, and the miraculous escape he is supposed to have had, were sufficient, one would conceive, to have impressed him with sympathy and benevolence in the execution of his mission; but, instead of this, he enters the city with denunciation and malediction in his mouth, crying, “Yet forty days, and Nineveh shall be overthrown.”

Jonah was then sent on a second mission to Nineveh, and he set out. We must now consider him as a preacher. He is said to have suffered greatly because of his own disobedience and to have escaped miraculously. One would think these experiences would have made him sympathetic and kind in carrying out his mission. But instead, he enters the city condemning and cursing it, crying, “In forty days, Nineveh will be overthrown.”

We have now to consider this supposed missionary in the last act of his mission; and here it is that the malevolent spirit of a Bible-prophet, or of a predicting priest, appears in all that blackness of character that men ascribe to the being they call the devil.

We must now consider this supposed missionary in the final act of his mission. Here the evil spirit of a Bible prophet or predicting priest appears in all its darkness. It shows the same darkness of character that people attribute to the being they call the devil.

Having published his predictions, he withdrew, says the story, to the east side of the city.—But for what? not to contemplate in retirement the mercy of his Creator to himself or to others, but to wait, with malignant impatience, the destruction of Nineveh. It came to pass, however, as the story relates, that the Ninevites reformed, and that God, according to the Bible phrase, repented him of the evil he had said he would do unto them, and did it not. This, saith the first verse of the last chapter, displeased Jonah exceedingly and he was very angry. His obdurate heart would rather that all Nineveh should be destroyed, and every soul, young and old, perish in its ruins, than that his prediction should not be fulfilled. To expose the character of a prophet still more, a gourd is made to grow up in the night, that promises him an agreeable shelter from the heat of the sun, in the place to which he is retired; and the next morning it dies.

After publishing his predictions, Jonah withdrew to the east side of the city, according to the story. But why? Not to reflect in solitude on his Creator's mercy toward himself or others. He went there to wait, with malicious impatience, for the destruction of Nineveh. However, the story says that the Ninevites changed their ways. God, in the Bible's language, repented of the evil he had said he would bring upon them. He did not carry it out. The first verse of the last chapter says that this greatly displeased Jonah, and he was very angry. His hard heart would rather see all Nineveh destroyed and every soul, young and old, perish in its ruins. He preferred that to seeing his prediction go unfulfilled. To expose a prophet's character even more, a gourd is made to grow overnight. It promises Jonah welcome shelter from the sun's heat in the place where he has withdrawn. But the next morning it dies.

Here the rage of the prophet becomes excessive, and he is ready to destroy himself. “It is better, said he, for me to die than to live.” This brings on a supposed expostulation between the Almighty and the prophet; in which the former says, “Doest thou well to be angry for the gourd? And Jonah said, I do well to be angry even unto death. Then said the Lord, Thou hast had pity on the gourd, for which thou hast not laboured, neither madest it to grow, which came up in a night, and perished in a night; and should not I spare Nineveh, that great city, in which are more than threescore thousand persons, that cannot discern between their right hand and their left?”

Here the prophet’s rage becomes extreme, and he is ready to destroy himself. “It is better for me to die than to live,” he said. This leads to a supposed exchange between the Almighty and the prophet. The Almighty says, “Are you right to be angry about the gourd? And Jonah said, I am right to be angry enough to die. Then the Lord said, You have pitied the gourd, though you did not tend it or make it grow. It grew up in one night and died in one night. So should I not spare Nineveh, that great city? It has more than sixty thousand people who cannot tell their right hand from their left.”

Here is both the winding up of the satire, and the moral of the fable. As a satire, it strikes against the character of all the Bible-prophets, and against all the indiscriminate judgements upon men, women and children, with which this lying book, the bible, is crowded; such as Noah’s flood, the destruction of the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah, the extirpation of the Canaanites, even to suckling infants, and women with child; because the same reflection ‘that there are more than threescore thousand persons that cannot discern between their right hand and their left,’ meaning young children, applies to all their cases. It satirizes also the supposed partiality of the Creator for one nation more than for another.

Here is both the conclusion of the satire and the moral of the fable. As a satire, it attacks the character of all the Bible’s prophets. It also attacks all the indiscriminate judgments against men, women, and children that crowd this lying book, the Bible. These include Noah’s flood, the destruction of the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah, and the extermination of the Canaanites, including nursing infants and pregnant women. The same observation applies to all these cases: ‘there are more than sixty thousand people who cannot tell their right hand from their left’, meaning young children. The satire also attacks the supposed favoritism of the Creator toward one nation over another.

As a moral, it preaches against the malevolent spirit of prediction; for as certainly as a man predicts ill, he becomes inclined to wish it. The pride of having his judgment right hardens his heart, till at last he beholds with satisfaction, or sees with disappointment, the accomplishment or the failure of his predictions.—This book ends with the same kind of strong and well-directed point against prophets, prophecies and indiscriminate judgements, as the chapter that Benjamin Franklin made for the Bible, about Abraham and the stranger, ends against the intolerant spirit of religious persecutions—Thus much for the book Jonah. [The story of Abraham and the Fire-worshipper, ascribed to Franklin, is from Saadi. (See my “Sacred Anthology,” p. 61.) Paine has often been called a “mere scoffer,” but he seems to have been among the first to treat with dignity the book of Jonah, so especially liable to the ridicule of superficial readers, and discern in it the highest conception of Deity known to the Old Testament.—Editor.]

As a moral lesson, it warns against the malicious spirit of prediction. Whenever a man predicts something bad, he becomes inclined to wish for it. Pride in being proved right hardens his heart. In the end, he is pleased when his predictions come true and disappointed when they fail. This book ends with a strong, well-aimed point against prophets, prophecies, and indiscriminate judgments. In the same way, the chapter Benjamin Franklin wrote for the Bible, about Abraham and the stranger, ends by condemning the intolerance behind religious persecution. That is all for the book of Jonah. [The story of Abraham and the Fire-worshipper, attributed to Franklin, comes from Saadi. (See my “Sacred Anthology,” p. 61.) Paine has often been called a “mere scoffer.” Yet he seems to have been among the first to treat the book of Jonah with dignity. Superficial readers are especially likely to ridicule it. Paine also saw in it the highest conception of God known to the Old Testament. Editor.]

Of the poetical parts of the Bible, that are called prophecies, I have spoken in the former part of ‘The Age of Reason,’ and already in this, where I have said that the word for prophet is the Bible-word for Poet, and that the flights and metaphors of those poets, many of which have become obscure by the lapse of time and the change of circumstances, have been ridiculously erected into things called prophecies, and applied to purposes the writers never thought of. When a priest quotes any of those passages, he unriddles it agreeably to his own views, and imposes that explanation upon his congregation as the meaning of the writer. The whore of Babylon has been the common whore of all the priests, and each has accused the other of keeping the strumpet; so well do they agree in their explanations.

I have discussed the poetic parts of the Bible called prophecies in the first part of ‘The Age of Reason,’ and earlier in this part. I said that the Bible’s word for prophet means Poet. Many of those poets’ flights of imagination and metaphors have become obscure as time and circumstances have changed. Yet they have been absurdly turned into things called prophecies and applied to purposes their writers never imagined. When a priest quotes one of those passages, he solves its riddle to suit his own views. He then imposes that explanation on his congregation as the writer’s meaning. The whore of Babylon has been the common whore of all the priests, and each has accused the others of keeping her. So well do they agree in their explanations.

There now remain only a few books, which they call books of the lesser prophets; and as I have already shown that the greater are impostors, it would be cowardice to disturb the repose of the little ones. Let them sleep, then, in the arms of their nurses, the priests, and both be forgotten together.

Only a few books remain, which they call the books of the lesser prophets. I have already shown that the greater prophets are impostors. So it would be cowardly to disturb the little ones’ rest. Let them sleep in the arms of their nurses, the priests, and let both be forgotten together.

I have now gone through the Bible, as a man would go through a wood with an axe on his shoulder, and fell trees. Here they lie; and the priests, if they can, may replant them. They may, perhaps, stick them in the ground, but they will never make them grow.—I pass on to the books of the New Testament.

I have now gone through the Bible like a man walking through a forest with an axe on his shoulder, cutting down trees. Here they lie, and the priests can replant them if they can. Perhaps they can stick the trees in the ground, but they will never make them grow. I move on to the books of the New Testament.