Part 2, Chapter 2

The New Testament

47 min

The New Testament, they tell us, is founded upon the prophecies of the Old; if so, it must follow the fate of its foundation.

They tell us that the New Testament is based on the prophecies of the Old Testament. If so, it must share the fate of its foundation.

As it is nothing extraordinary that a woman should be with child before she was married, and that the son she might bring forth should be executed, even unjustly, I see no reason for not believing that such a woman as Mary, and such a man as Joseph, and Jesus, existed; their mere existence is a matter of indifference, about which there is no ground either to believe or to disbelieve, and which comes under the common head of, It may be so, and what then? The probability however is that there were such persons, or at least such as resembled them in part of the circumstances, because almost all romantic stories have been suggested by some actual circumstance; as the adventures of Robinson Crusoe, not a word of which is true, were suggested by the case of Alexander Selkirk.

There is nothing unusual about a woman becoming pregnant before marriage, or her son being executed, even unjustly. So I see no reason to doubt that people like Mary, Joseph, and Jesus existed. Their mere existence is a matter of indifference. There is no reason either to believe or disbelieve it. It falls under the common heading: It may be so, and what then? Still, such people probably did exist, or at least people whose circumstances partly resembled theirs. That is because almost all romantic stories have been inspired by some actual event. For example, the adventures of Robinson Crusoe were inspired by the case of Alexander Selkirk, though not a word of those adventures is true.

It is not then the existence or the non-existence, of the persons that I trouble myself about; it is the fable of Jesus Christ, as told in the New Testament, and the wild and visionary doctrine raised thereon, against which I contend. The story, taking it as it is told, is blasphemously obscene. It gives an account of a young woman engaged to be married, and while under this engagement, she is, to speak plain language, debauched by a ghost, under the impious pretence, (Luke i. 35,) that “the Holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the power of the Highest shall overshadow thee.” Notwithstanding which, Joseph afterwards marries her, cohabits with her as his wife, and in his turn rivals the ghost. This is putting the story into intelligible language, and when told in this manner, there is not a priest but must be ashamed to own it. [Mary, the supposed virgin, mother of Jesus, had several other children, sons and daughters. See Matt. xiii. 55, 56.—Author.]

So it is not the existence or nonexistence of these people that concerns me. I argue against the fable of Jesus Christ as told in the New Testament, and the wild, visionary doctrine built on it. As told, the story is blasphemously obscene. It describes a young woman engaged to be married. While engaged, she is, to put it plainly, sexually violated by a ghost. This happens under the impious pretense (Luke i. 35) that “the Holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the power of the Highest shall overshadow thee.” Despite this, Joseph later marries her and lives with her as his wife. In his turn, he rivals the ghost. This puts the story in plain language. When told this way, every priest must be ashamed to admit it. [Mary, the supposed virgin and mother of Jesus, had several other children, sons and daughters. See Matt. xiii. 55, 56. Author.]

Obscenity in matters of faith, however wrapped up, is always a token of fable and imposture; for it is necessary to our serious belief in God, that we do not connect it with stories that run, as this does, into ludicrous interpretations. This story is, upon the face of it, the same kind of story as that of Jupiter and Leda, or Jupiter and Europa, or any of the amorous adventures of Jupiter; and shews, as is already stated in the former part of ‘The Age of Reason,’ that the Christian faith is built upon the heathen Mythology.

Obscenity in matters of faith, however disguised, is always a sign of fiction and deception. To believe seriously in God, we must not connect that belief with stories like this one, which invite ridiculous interpretations. On its face, this story is like those of Jupiter and Leda, Jupiter and Europa, or any of Jupiter’s love affairs. As I have already said in the earlier part of ‘The Age of Reason,’ this shows that the Christian faith is built on pagan mythology.

As the historical parts of the New Testament, so far as concerns Jesus Christ, are confined to a very short space of time, less than two years, and all within the same country, and nearly to the same spot, the discordance of time, place, and circumstance, which detects the fallacy of the books of the Old Testament, and proves them to be impositions, cannot be expected to be found here in the same abundance. The New Testament compared with the Old, is like a farce of one act, in which there is not room for very numerous violations of the unities. There are, however, some glaring contradictions, which, exclusive of the fallacy of the pretended prophecies, are sufficient to show the story of Jesus Christ to be false.

The historical parts of the New Testament concerning Jesus Christ cover a very short time, less than two years. They also take place within the same country, and nearly in the same spot. So we cannot expect to find as many contradictions of time, place, and circumstance here. Those contradictions expose the falsehood of the books of the Old Testament and prove them to be frauds. Compared with the Old Testament, the New Testament is like a one-act farce. It has little room for very many violations of the dramatic unities. There are, however, some glaring contradictions. Even apart from the falsehood of the supposed prophecies, these contradictions are enough to show that the story of Jesus Christ is false.

I lay it down as a position which cannot be controverted, first, that the agreement of all the parts of a story does not prove that story to be true, because the parts may agree, and the whole may be false; secondly, that the disagreement of the parts of a story proves the whole cannot be true. The agreement does not prove truth, but the disagreement proves falsehood positively.

I state these points as beyond dispute. First, even if all the parts of a story agree, that does not prove the story is true. The parts may agree while the whole story is false. Second, if the parts of a story disagree, that proves the whole story cannot be true. Agreement does not prove truth, but disagreement proves falsehood beyond doubt.

The history of Jesus Christ is contained in the four books ascribed to Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John.—The first chapter of Matthew begins with giving a genealogy of Jesus Christ; and in the third chapter of Luke there is also given a genealogy of Jesus Christ. Did these two agree, it would not prove the genealogy to be true, because it might nevertheless be a fabrication; but as they contradict each other in every particular, it proves falsehood absolutely. If Matthew speaks truth, Luke speaks falsehood; and if Luke speaks truth, Matthew speaks falsehood: and as there is no authority for believing one more than the other, there is no authority for believing either; and if they cannot be believed even in the very first thing they say, and set out to prove, they are not entitled to be believed in any thing they say afterwards. Truth is an uniform thing; and as to inspiration and revelation, were we to admit it, it is impossible to suppose it can be contradictory. Either then the men called apostles were imposters, or the books ascribed to them have been written by other persons, and fathered upon them, as is the case in the Old Testament.

The history of Jesus Christ is contained in the four books attributed to Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. The first chapter of Matthew begins with a genealogy of Jesus Christ. The third chapter of Luke also gives a genealogy of Jesus Christ. If the two agreed, that would not prove the genealogy true, because it could still be fabricated. But they contradict each other in every detail, which proves that one is false. If Matthew tells the truth, Luke tells a falsehood. If Luke tells the truth, Matthew tells a falsehood. There is no reason to believe one more than the other, so there is no reason to believe either. They cannot be believed even in the first thing they say and set out to prove. So they do not deserve to be believed in anything they say afterward. Truth is consistent. And even if we were to accept inspiration and revelation, they could not possibly contradict themselves. Either the men called apostles were imposters, or other people wrote the books attributed to them and passed them off as theirs. The same thing happened in the Old Testament.

The book of Matthew gives (i. 6), a genealogy by name from David, up, through Joseph, the husband of Mary, to Christ; and makes there to be twent eight generations. The book of Luke gives also a genealogy by name from Christ, through Joseph the husband of Mary, down to David, and makes there to be forty-three generations; besides which, there is only the two names of David and Joseph that are alike in the two lists.—I here insert both genealogical lists, and for the sake of perspicuity and comparison, have placed them both in the same direction, that is, from Joseph down to David.

The book of Matthew (1:6) lists Christ's ancestors by name, tracing them from David through Joseph, Mary's husband, to Christ. It gives twenty-eight generations. The book of Luke also lists ancestors by name, tracing them from Christ through Joseph, Mary's husband, down to David. But Luke gives forty-three generations. Besides that, only the names David and Joseph appear in both lists. I include both genealogies here. To make them clear and easy to compare, I have put them in the same order, from Joseph down to David.

   Genealogy, according to            Genealogy, according to
        Matthew.                                Luke.

        Christ                                  Christ
      2 Joseph                                2 Joseph
      3 Jacob                                 3 Heli
      4 Matthan                               4 Matthat
      5 Eleazer                               5 Levi
      6 Eliud                                 6 Melchl
      7 Achim                                 7 Janna
      8 Sadoc                                 8 Joseph
      9 Azor                                  9 Mattathias
     10 Eliakim                              10 Amos
     11 Abiud                                11 Naum
     12 Zorobabel                            12 Esli
     13 Salathiel                            13 Nagge
     14 Jechonias                            14 Maath
     15 Josias                               15 Mattathias
     16 Amon                                 16 Semei
     17 Manasses                             17 Joseph
     18 Ezekias                              18 Juda
     19 Achaz                                19 Joanna
     20 Joatham                              20 Rhesa
     21 Ozias                                21 Zorobabel
     22 Joram                                22 Salathiel
     23 Josaphat                             23 Neri
     24 Asa                                  24 Melchi
     25 Abia                                 25 Addi
     26 Roboam                               26 Cosam
     27 Solomon                              27 Elmodam
     28 David *                              28 Er
                                             29 Jose
                                             30 Eliezer
                                             31 Jorim
                                             32 Matthat
                                             33 Levi
                                             34 Simeon
                                             35 Juda
                                             36 Joseph
                                             37 Jonan
                                             38 Eliakim
                                             39 Melea
                                             40 Menan
                                             41 Mattatha
                                             42 Nathan
                                             43 David

[NOTE: * From the birth of David to the birth of Christ is upwards of 1080 years; and as the life-time of Christ is not included, there are but 27 full generations. To find therefore the average age of each person mentioned in the list, at the time his first son was born, it is only necessary to divide 1080 by 27, which gives 40 years for each person. As the life-time of man was then but of the same extent it is now, it is an absurdity to suppose, that 27 following generations should all be old bachelors, before they married; and the more so, when we are told that Solomon, the next in succession to David, had a house full of wives and mistresses before he was twenty-one years of age. So far from this genealogy being a solemn truth, it is not even a reasonable lie. The list of Luke gives about twenty-six years for the average age, and this is too much.—Author.]

[NOTE: * More than 1,080 years passed between the births of David and Christ. Since Christ’s lifetime is not included, there are only 27 full generations. To find the average age of each person on the list when his first son was born, divide 1,080 by 27. This gives an average of 40 years for each person. People’s lifespans were then the same as they are now. So it is absurd to suppose that all 27 successive generations remained bachelors until they were old before marrying. This is even more absurd when we are told that Solomon, David’s successor, had a house full of wives and mistresses before he was 21. Far from being a solemn truth, this genealogy is not even a reasonable lie. Luke’s list gives an average age of about 26 years, and that is too high. Author.]

Now, if these men, Matthew and Luke, set out with a falsehood between them (as these two accounts show they do) in the very commencement of their history of Jesus Christ, and of who, and of what he was, what authority (as I have before asked) is there left for believing the strange things they tell us afterwards? If they cannot be believed in their account of his natural genealogy, how are we to believe them when they tell us he was the son of God, begotten by a ghost; and that an angel announced this in secret to his mother? If they lied in one genealogy, why are we to believe them in the other? If his natural genealogy be manufactured, which it certainly is, why are we not to suppose that his celestial genealogy is manufactured also, and that the whole is fabulous? Can any man of serious reflection hazard his future happiness upon the belief of a story naturally impossible, repugnant to every idea of decency, and related by persons already detected of falsehood? Is it not more safe that we stop ourselves at the plain, pure, and unmixed belief of one God, which is deism, than that we commit ourselves on an ocean of improbable, irrational, indecent, and contradictory tales?

Now, Matthew and Luke begin their accounts of Jesus Christ with a contradiction, as their two accounts show. They disagree about who and what he was. So, as I asked before, what reason is left to believe the strange things they tell us afterward? If we cannot believe their accounts of his earthly ancestry, how can we believe their other claims? They tell us he was the son of God, conceived by a ghost, and that an angel told his mother this in secret. If they lied about one ancestry, why should we believe them about the other? His earthly ancestry is certainly made up. So why should we not suppose that his heavenly ancestry is also made up, and that the whole story is a fable? Can any thoughtful person risk their future happiness on belief in such a story? It is naturally impossible, offensive to every idea of decency, and told by people already caught lying. Is it not safer to hold to the plain, pure, and unmixed belief in one God, which is deism? Is that not safer than setting ourselves adrift on an ocean of improbable, irrational, indecent, and contradictory tales?

The first question, however, upon the books of the New Testament, as upon those of the Old, is, Are they genuine? were they written by the persons to whom they are ascribed? For it is upon this ground only that the strange things related therein have been credited. Upon this point, there is no direct proof for or against; and all that this state of a case proves is doubtfulness; and doubtfulness is the opposite of belief. The state, therefore, that the books are in, proves against themselves as far as this kind of proof can go.

The first question about the books of the New Testament, as with those of the Old, is whether they are genuine. Were they written by the people they are attributed to? Only on that basis have the strange things they describe been believed. There is no direct proof for or against their authorship. This lack of proof establishes only doubt, and doubt is the opposite of belief. So, as far as this kind of proof can go, the state of the books counts against them.

But, exclusive of this, the presumption is that the books called the Evangelists, and ascribed to Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, were not written by Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John; and that they are impositions. The disordered state of the history in these four books, the silence of one book upon matters related in the other, and the disagreement that is to be found among them, implies that they are the productions of some unconnected individuals, many years after the things they pretend to relate, each of whom made his own legend; and not the writings of men living intimately together, as the men called apostles are supposed to have done: in fine, that they have been manufactured, as the books of the Old Testament have been, by other persons than those whose names they bear.

But apart from this, the evidence suggests that Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John did not write the books attributed to them, known as the Gospels. It suggests that the books are frauds. Their accounts are disordered, each book leaves out matters described in another, and they disagree with one another. This suggests that they were written by unrelated individuals, many years after the events they claim to describe. Each writer made up his own story. The books do not appear to be the work of men who lived closely together, as the apostles are supposed to have done. In short, like the books of the Old Testament, they were fabricated by people other than those whose names they bear.

The story of the angel announcing what the church calls the immaculate conception, is not so much as mentioned in the books ascribed to Mark, and John; and is differently related in Matthew and Luke. The former says the angel, appeared to Joseph; the latter says, it was to Mary; but either Joseph or Mary was the worst evidence that could have been thought of; for it was others that should have testified for them, and not they for themselves. Were any girl that is now with child to say, and even to swear it, that she was gotten with child by a ghost, and that an angel told her so, would she be believed? Certainly she would not. Why then are we to believe the same thing of another girl whom we never saw, told by nobody knows who, nor when, nor where? How strange and inconsistent is it, that the same circumstance that would weaken the belief even of a probable story, should be given as a motive for believing this one, that has upon the face of it every token of absolute impossibility and imposture.

The story of the angel announcing what the church calls the immaculate conception is not even mentioned in the books attributed to Mark and John. Matthew and Luke tell the story differently. Matthew says the angel appeared to Joseph. Luke says the angel appeared to Mary. But either Joseph or Mary was the worst possible witness. Other people should have testified for them, rather than their testifying for themselves. Suppose a girl who is pregnant today said she had been made pregnant by a ghost. Suppose she even swore that an angel had told her so. Would she be believed? Certainly not. Why, then, should we believe the same thing about another girl we have never seen? Nobody knows who told her story, or when, or where. How strange and inconsistent! The same circumstance that would make even a plausible story less believable is offered as a reason to believe this one. Yet this story bears every sign of sheer impossibility and fraud.

The story of Herod destroying all the children under two years old, belongs altogether to the book of Matthew; not one of the rest mentions anything about it. Had such a circumstance been true, the universality of it must have made it known to all the writers, and the thing would have been too striking to have been omitted by any. This writer tell us, that Jesus escaped this slaughter, because Joseph and Mary were warned by an angel to flee with him into Egypt; but he forgot to make provision for John [the Baptist], who was then under two years of age. John, however, who staid behind, fared as well as Jesus, who fled; and therefore the story circumstantially belies itself.

The story of Herod killing all children under two years old appears only in the book of Matthew. None of the other writers mentions it. If it were true, such a widespread event must have been known to all the writers. It would have been too striking for any of them to leave out. Matthew tells us that Jesus escaped the slaughter because an angel warned Joseph and Mary to flee with him to Egypt. But Matthew forgot to account for John [the Baptist], who was then under two years old. John stayed behind, however, and fared just as well as Jesus, who fled. The details of the story therefore contradict it.

Not any two of these writers agree in reciting, exactly in the same words, the written inscription, short as it is, which they tell us was put over Christ when he was crucified; and besides this, Mark says, He was crucified at the third hour, (nine in the morning;) and John says it was the sixth hour, (twelve at noon.) [According to John, (xix. 14) the sentence was not passed till about the sixth hour (noon,) and consequently the execution could not be till the afternoon; but Mark (xv. 25) Says expressly that he was crucified at the third hour, (nine in the morning,)—Author.]

No two of these writers give exactly the same wording for the inscription they say was placed above Christ during his crucifixion. And the inscription is short. Besides this, Mark says Christ was crucified at the third hour (nine in the morning). John says it was the sixth hour (noon). [According to John (xix. 14), the sentence was not passed until about the sixth hour (noon). So the execution could not have taken place until the afternoon. But Mark (xv. 25) says explicitly that Christ was crucified at the third hour (nine in the morning). Author.]

The inscription is thus stated in those books:

The inscription appears in those books as follows:

Matthew—This is Jesus the king of the Jews. Mark—The king of the Jews. Luke—This is the king of the Jews. John—Jesus of Nazareth the king of the Jews.

Matthew: This is Jesus, the king of the Jews. Mark: The king of the Jews. Luke: This is the king of the Jews. John: Jesus of Nazareth, the king of the Jews.

We may infer from these circumstances, trivial as they are, that those writers, whoever they were, and in whatever time they lived, were not present at the scene. The only one of the men called apostles who appears to have been near to the spot was Peter, and when he was accused of being one of Jesus’s followers, it is said, (Matthew xxvi. 74,) “Then Peter began to curse and to swear, saying, I know not the man:” yet we are now called to believe the same Peter, convicted, by their own account, of perjury. For what reason, or on what authority, should we do this?

These details may seem trivial, but they suggest that the writers were not present at the scene. This applies whoever they were and whenever they lived. Of the men called apostles, only Peter appears to have been near the spot. When he was accused of being one of Jesus’s followers, we are told (Matthew 26:74): “Then Peter began to curse and swear, saying, I do not know the man.” Yet we are now asked to believe Peter, who, by their own account, was guilty of perjury. Why should we believe him, and on whose authority?

The accounts that are given of the circumstances, that they tell us attended the crucifixion, are differently related in those four books.

The four books give different accounts of the circumstances they say accompanied the crucifixion.

The book ascribed to Matthew says ‘there was darkness over all the land from the sixth hour unto the ninth hour—that the veil of the temple was rent in twain from the top to the bottom—that there was an earthquake—that the rocks rent—that the graves opened, that the bodies of many of the saints that slept arose and came out of their graves after the resurrection, and went into the holy city and appeared unto many.’ Such is the account which this dashing writer of the book of Matthew gives, but in which he is not supported by the writers of the other books.

The book attributed to Matthew says, ‘There was darkness over all the land from the sixth hour until the ninth hour. The temple curtain was torn in two from top to bottom. There was an earthquake, and the rocks split. The graves opened, and the bodies of many saints who had died rose. After the resurrection, they came out of their graves, went into the holy city, and appeared to many people.’ This is the account given by the flamboyant writer of the book of Matthew. But the writers of the other books do not support him.

The writer of the book ascribed to Mark, in detailing the circumstances of the crucifixion, makes no mention of any earthquake, nor of the rocks rending, nor of the graves opening, nor of the dead men walking out. The writer of the book of Luke is silent also upon the same points. And as to the writer of the book of John, though he details all the circumstances of the crucifixion down to the burial of Christ, he says nothing about either the darkness—the veil of the temple—the earthquake—the rocks—the graves—nor the dead men.

The writer of the book attributed to Mark describes the crucifixion but says nothing about an earthquake or rocks splitting. He also says nothing about graves opening or dead men walking out. The writer of the book of Luke is also silent on these points. The writer of the book of John describes every detail of the crucifixion, right up to Christ’s burial. Yet he says nothing about the darkness, the temple curtain, the earthquake, the rocks, the graves, or the dead men.

Now if it had been true that these things had happened, and if the writers of these books had lived at the time they did happen, and had been the persons they are said to be—namely, the four men called apostles, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John,—it was not possible for them, as true historians, even without the aid of inspiration, not to have recorded them. The things, supposing them to have been facts, were of too much notoriety not to have been known, and of too much importance not to have been told. All these supposed apostles must have been witnesses of the earthquake, if there had been any, for it was not possible for them to have been absent from it: the opening of the graves and resurrection of the dead men, and their walking about the city, is of still greater importance than the earthquake. An earthquake is always possible, and natural, and proves nothing; but this opening of the graves is supernatural, and directly in point to their doctrine, their cause, and their apostleship. Had it been true, it would have filled up whole chapters of those books, and been the chosen theme and general chorus of all the writers; but instead of this, little and trivial things, and mere prattling conversation of ‘he said this and she said that’ are often tediously detailed, while this most important of all, had it been true, is passed off in a slovenly manner by a single dash of the pen, and that by one writer only, and not so much as hinted at by the rest.

Now, suppose these things had really happened. Suppose also that the writers of these books had lived at the time and were who they are said to be: the four men called apostles, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. Even without inspiration, they could not have been truthful historians and failed to record these events. If the events were facts, they were too widely known to have escaped notice and too important to leave untold. All these supposed apostles must have witnessed the earthquake, if there was one. They could not have been absent from it. The opening of the graves, the resurrection of the dead men, and their walking about the city are even more important than the earthquake. An earthquake is always possible and natural, and it proves nothing. But the opening of the graves is supernatural and directly relevant to their doctrine, their cause, and their apostleship. Had it been true, it would have filled whole chapters of those books. It would have been the favorite subject and common refrain of all the writers. Instead, small and trivial matters and mere chatter about ‘he said this and she said that’ are often described in tedious detail. Yet the most important event of all, had it been true, is dealt with carelessly in a single stroke of the pen. Only one writer mentions it, and the rest do not even hint at it.

It is an easy thing to tell a lie, but it is difficult to support the lie after it is told. The writer of the book of Matthew should have told us who the saints were that came to life again, and went into the city, and what became of them afterwards, and who it was that saw them; for he is not hardy enough to say that he saw them himself;—whether they came out naked, and all in natural buff, he-saints and she-saints, or whether they came full dressed, and where they got their dresses; whether they went to their former habitations, and reclaimed their wives, their husbands, and their property, and how they were received; whether they entered ejectments for the recovery of their possessions, or brought actions of crim. con. against the rival interlopers; whether they remained on earth, and followed their former occupation of preaching or working; or whether they died again, or went back to their graves alive, and buried themselves.

It is easy to tell a lie, but hard to back it up afterward. The writer of the book of Matthew should have told us who the saints were who came back to life and went into the city. He should have told us what happened to them afterward and who saw them. For he is not bold enough to say that he saw them himself. Did the saints come out naked, with both male and female saints completely bare? Or did they come out fully dressed, and where did they get their clothes? Did they go back to their old homes and claim their wives, husbands, and property? How were they received? Did they file lawsuits to recover their property or sue their rivals for having affairs with their spouses? Did they stay on earth and go back to preaching or working, as they had before? Or did they die again, or go back to their graves alive and bury themselves?

Strange indeed, that an army of saints should retum to life, and nobody know who they were, nor who it was that saw them, and that not a word more should be said upon the subject, nor these saints have any thing to tell us! Had it been the prophets who (as we are told) had formerly prophesied of these things, they must have had a great deal to say. They could have told us everything, and we should have had posthumous prophecies, with notes and commentaries upon the first, a little better at least than we have now. Had it been Moses, and Aaron, and Joshua, and Samuel, and David, not an unconverted Jew had remained in all Jerusalem. Had it been John the Baptist, and the saints of the times then present, everybody would have known them, and they would have out-preached and out-famed all the other apostles. But, instead of this, these saints are made to pop up, like Jonah’s gourd in the night, for no purpose at all but to wither in the morning.—Thus much for this part of the story.

How strange that an army of saints should return to life, yet nobody knew who they were or who saw them! Not another word was said about them, and the saints themselves had nothing to tell us! What if they had been the prophets who, as we are told, had predicted these things? They would have had a great deal to say. They could have told us everything. We would have had prophecies made after their deaths, with notes and commentary on their earlier ones. These would have been at least a little better than what we have now. What if they had been Moses, Aaron, Joshua, Samuel, and David? Not a single unconverted Jew would have remained in all Jerusalem. What if they had been John the Baptist and the saints of that time? Everyone would have known them, and they would have surpassed all the other apostles in preaching and fame. But instead, these saints are made to pop up like Jonah’s gourd in the night. They serve no purpose at all except to wither in the morning. So much for this part of the story.

The tale of the resurrection follows that of the crucifixion; and in this as well as in that, the writers, whoever they were, disagree so much as to make it evident that none of them were there.

The story of the resurrection follows the story of the crucifixion. In both, the writers, whoever they were, disagree so much that clearly none of them were there.

The book of Matthew states, that when Christ was put in the sepulchre the Jews applied to Pilate for a watch or a guard to be placed over the septilchre, to prevent the body being stolen by the disciples; and that in consequence of this request the sepulchre was made sure, sealing the stone that covered the mouth, and setting a watch. But the other books say nothing about this application, nor about the sealing, nor the guard, nor the watch; and according to their accounts, there were none. Matthew, however, follows up this part of the story of the guard or the watch with a second part, that I shall notice in the conclusion, as it serves to detect the fallacy of those books.

The book of Matthew says that after Christ was placed in the tomb, the Jews asked Pilate to post a guard. They wanted to prevent the disciples from stealing the body. As a result, the tomb was secured by sealing the stone over its entrance and posting a guard. But the other books say nothing about this request, the sealing, or the guard. According to their accounts, there was no guard. Matthew, however, adds a second part to the story of the guard. I will discuss it in the conclusion, as it helps expose the falsehood of those books.

The book of Matthew continues its account, and says, (xxviii. 1,) that at the end of the Sabbath, as it began to dawn, towards the first day of the week, came Mary Magdalene and the other Mary, to see the sepulchre. Mark says it was sun-rising, and John says it was dark. Luke says it was Mary Magdalene and Joanna, and Mary the mother of James, and other women, that came to the sepulchre; and John states that Mary Magdalene came alone. So well do they agree about their first evidence! They all, however, appear to have known most about Mary Magdalene; she was a woman of large acquaintance, and it was not an ill conjecture that she might be upon the stroll. [The Bishop of Llandaff, in his famous “Apology,” censured Paine severely for this insinuation against Mary Magdalene, but the censure really falls on our English version, which, by a chapter-heading (Luke vii.), has unwarrantably identified her as the sinful woman who anointed Jesus, and irrevocably branded her.—Editor.]

The book of Matthew continues its account (xxviii. 1). It says Mary Magdalene and the other Mary came to see the tomb at the end of the Sabbath. It was beginning to dawn, toward the first day of the week. Mark says it was sunrise, and John says it was dark. Luke says Mary Magdalene, Joanna, Mary the mother of James, and other women came to the tomb. John says Mary Magdalene came alone. How well they agree about their first evidence! All of them, however, appear to have known the most about Mary Magdalene. She was a woman with many acquaintances, and it was not a bad guess that she might be out looking for customers. [The Bishop of Llandaff, in his famous “Apology,” severely criticized Paine for this insinuation about Mary Magdalene. But the criticism really falls on our English version. Its chapter heading for Luke vii. has identified her, without justification, as the sinful woman who anointed Jesus. It has branded her forever. Editor.]

The book of Matthew goes on to say (ver. 2): “And behold there was a great earthquake, for the angel of the Lord descended from heaven, and came and rolled back the stone from the door, and sat upon it” But the other books say nothing about any earthquake, nor about the angel rolling back the stone, and sitting upon it and, according to their account, there was no angel sitting there. Mark says the angel [Mark says “a young man,” and Luke “two men.”—Editor.] was within the sepulchre, sitting on the right side. Luke says there were two, and they were both standing up; and John says they were both sitting down, one at the head and the other at the feet.

The book of Matthew goes on to say (verse 2): “And suddenly there was a great earthquake. The angel of the Lord came down from heaven, rolled back the stone from the entrance, and sat on it.” But the other books say nothing about an earthquake or about the angel rolling back the stone and sitting on it. According to their accounts, no angel was sitting there. Mark says the angel was inside the tomb, sitting on the right side. [Mark says “a young man,” and Luke says “two men.” Editor.] Luke says there were two, and both were standing. John says both were sitting, one at the head and the other at the feet.

Matthew says, that the angel that was sitting upon the stone on the outside of the sepulchre told the two Marys that Christ was risen, and that the women went away quickly. Mark says, that the women, upon seeing the stone rolled away, and wondering at it, went into the sepulchre, and that it was the angel that was sitting within on the right side, that told them so. Luke says, it was the two angels that were Standing up; and John says, it was Jesus Christ himself that told it to Mary Magdalene; and that she did not go into the sepulchre, but only stooped down and looked in.

Matthew says an angel was sitting on the stone outside the tomb. The angel told the two Marys that Christ had risen, and the women quickly left. Mark says the women saw that the stone had been rolled away and wondered at it. They went into the tomb, where an angel sitting on the right told them Christ had risen. Luke says it was two angels standing up who told them. John says Jesus Christ himself told Mary Magdalene, and that she did not enter the tomb. She only bent down and looked inside.

Now, if the writers of these four books had gone into a court of justice to prove an alibi, (for it is of the nature of an alibi that is here attempted to be proved, namely, the absence of a dead body by supernatural means,) and had they given their evidence in the same contradictory manner as it is here given, they would have been in danger of having their ears cropt for perjury, and would have justly deserved it. Yet this is the evidence, and these are the books, that have been imposed upon the world as being given by divine inspiration, and as the unchangeable word of God.

Suppose the writers of these four books had gone to court to prove an alibi. What they are trying to prove here is like an alibi: that a dead body was absent by supernatural means. Suppose they had given the same contradictory evidence in court as they give here. They would have risked having their ears cut off for perjury, and they would have deserved it. Yet this is the evidence and these are the books that have been imposed on the world as divinely inspired and as the unchanging word of God.

The writer of the book of Matthew, after giving this account, relates a story that is not to be found in any of the other books, and which is the same I have just before alluded to. “Now,” says he, [that is, after the conversation the women had had with the angel sitting upon the stone,] “behold some of the watch [meaning the watch that he had said had been placed over the sepulchre] came into the city, and shewed unto the chief priests all the things that were done; and when they were assembled with the elders and had taken counsel, they gave large money unto the soldiers, saying, Say ye, that his disciples came by night, and stole him away while we slept; and if this come to the governor’s ears, we will persuade him, and secure you. So they took the money, and did as they were taught; and this saying [that his disciples stole him away] is commonly reported among the Jews until this day.”

After giving this account, the writer of Matthew tells a story found in none of the other books. It is the story I mentioned just before. He says that after the women spoke with the angel sitting on the stone: “Some of the guards came into the city and told the chief priests everything that had happened. The priests met with the elders and discussed what to do. Then they gave the soldiers a large sum of money and said, ‘Say that his disciples came at night and stole him while we slept. If the governor hears about this, we will persuade him and protect you.’ So the soldiers took the money and did as they were told. And the story that his disciples stole him is still commonly reported among the Jews to this day.” The guards were the ones Matthew said had been posted at the tomb.

The expression, until this day, is an evidence that the book ascribed to Matthew was not written by Matthew, and that it has been manufactured long after the times and things of which it pretends to treat; for the expression implies a great length of intervening time. It would be inconsistent in us to speak in this manner of any thing happening in our own time. To give, therefore, intelligible meaning to the expression, we must suppose a lapse of some generations at least, for this manner of speaking carries the mind back to ancient time.

The expression “until this day” is evidence that Matthew did not write the book attributed to him. It shows that the book was manufactured long after the times and events it claims to describe. The expression implies that a great deal of time has passed. It would be inconsistent to speak this way about anything happening in our own time. Therefore, for the expression to make sense, we must assume that at least a few generations have passed. This way of speaking takes the mind back to ancient times.

The absurdity also of the story is worth noticing; for it shows the writer of the book of Matthew to have been an exceeding weak and foolish man. He tells a story that contradicts itself in point of possibility; for though the guard, if there were any, might be made to say that the body was taken away while they were asleep, and to give that as a reason for their not having prevented it, that same sleep must also have prevented their knowing how, and by whom, it was done; and yet they are made to say that it was the disciples who did it. Were a man to tender his evidence of something that he should say was done, and of the manner of doing it, and of the person who did it, while he was asleep, and could know nothing of the matter, such evidence could not be received: it will do well enough for Testament evidence, but not for any thing where truth is concerned.

The absurdity of the story is also worth noticing. It shows that the writer of the book of Matthew was an extremely weak and foolish man. His story contradicts itself in a way that makes it impossible. The guards, if there were any, might have been made to say the body was taken while they slept. They might have given that as their reason for not preventing it. But their sleep would also have kept them from knowing how the body was taken or who took it. Yet they are made to say that the disciples did it. Suppose a man offered evidence about something done while he was asleep and could know nothing about it. Suppose he said how it was done and who did it. His evidence could not be accepted. It would do well enough as Testament evidence, but not for anything where truth is concerned.

I come now to that part of the evidence in those books, that respects the pretended appearance of Christ after this pretended resurrection.

I now turn to the evidence in those books about Christ's supposed appearance after his supposed resurrection.

The writer of the book of Matthew relates, that the angel that was sitting on the stone at the mouth of the sepulchre, said to the two Marys (xxviii. 7), “Behold Christ is gone before you into Galilee, there ye shall see him; lo, I have told you.” And the same writer at the next two verses (8, 9,) makes Christ himself to speak to the same purpose to these women immediately after the angel had told it to them, and that they ran quickly to tell it to the disciples; and it is said (ver. 16), “Then the eleven disciples went away into Galilee, into a mountain where Jesus had appointed them; and, when they saw him, they worshipped him.”

The writer of Matthew says that an angel was sitting on the stone at the entrance to the tomb. The angel said to the two Marys (xxviii. 7), “Look, Christ has gone ahead of you into Galilee. You will see him there. Now I have told you.” In the next two verses (8, 9), the same writer says that Christ himself told the women the same thing, immediately after the angel had told them. The women then ran quickly to tell the disciples. And it is said (verse 16), “Then the eleven disciples went to Galilee, to a mountain where Jesus had arranged to meet them. When they saw him, they worshipped him.”

But the writer of the book of John tells us a story very different to this; for he says (xx. 19) “Then the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, [that is, the same day that Christ is said to have risen,] when the doors were shut, where the disciples were assembled, for fear of the Jews, came Jesus and stood in the midst of them.”

But the writer of the book of John tells a very different story. He says (xx. 19): “That same day, the first day of the week, the disciples had gathered behind closed doors for fear of the Jews. That evening, Jesus came and stood among them.” [This was the same day that Christ is said to have risen.]

According to Matthew the eleven were marching to Galilee, to meet Jesus in a mountain, by his own appointment, at the very time when, according to John, they were assembled in another place, and that not by appointment, but in secret, for fear of the Jews.

According to Matthew, the eleven were traveling to Galilee to meet Jesus on a mountain, as he had arranged. But according to John, they were gathered elsewhere at that very time. They had not arranged to meet there, but had gathered in secret for fear of the Jews.

The writer of the book of Luke xxiv. 13, 33-36, contradicts that of Matthew more pointedly than John does; for he says expressly, that the meeting was in Jerusalem the evening of the same day that he (Christ) rose, and that the eleven were there.

The writer of Luke xxiv. 13, 33-36 contradicts Matthew more directly than John does. He states plainly that the meeting took place in Jerusalem on the evening of the day Christ rose. He also says that the eleven were there.

Now, it is not possible, unless we admit these supposed disciples the right of wilful lying, that the writers of these books could be any of the eleven persons called disciples; for if, according to Matthew, the eleven went into Galilee to meet Jesus in a mountain by his own appointment, on the same day that he is said to have risen, Luke and John must have been two of that eleven; yet the writer of Luke says expressly, and John implies as much, that the meeting was that same day, in a house in Jerusalem; and, on the other hand, if, according to Luke and John, the eleven were assembled in a house in Jerusalem, Matthew must have been one of that eleven; yet Matthew says the meeting was in a mountain in Galilee, and consequently the evidence given in those books destroy each other.

Now, unless we grant these supposed disciples the right to lie deliberately, the writers cannot have been among the eleven disciples. According to Matthew, the eleven went to a mountain in Galilee to meet Jesus at his request. This happened on the same day he is said to have risen. If that is true, Luke and John must have been among the eleven. Yet the writer of Luke says plainly that the meeting was in a house in Jerusalem that same day. John implies the same thing. On the other hand, if Luke and John are right, the eleven gathered in a house in Jerusalem. In that case, Matthew must have been among them. Yet Matthew says the meeting was on a mountain in Galilee. So the accounts in these books contradict each other.

The writer of the book of Mark says nothing about any meeting in Galilee; but he says (xvi. 12) that Christ, after his resurrection, appeared in another form to two of them, as they walked into the country, and that these two told it to the residue, who would not believe them. [This belongs to the late addition to Mark, which originally ended with xvi. 8.—Editor.] Luke also tells a story, in which he keeps Christ employed the whole of the day of this pretended resurrection, until the evening, and which totally invalidates the account of going to the mountain in Galilee. He says, that two of them, without saying which two, went that same day to a village called Emmaus, three score furlongs (seven miles and a half) from Jerusalem, and that Christ in disguise went with them, and stayed with them unto the evening, and supped with them, and then vanished out of their sight, and reappeared that same evening, at the meeting of the eleven in Jerusalem.

The writer of Mark says nothing about a meeting in Galilee. But he says (xvi. 12) that Christ appeared in another form to two of them after his resurrection. They were walking into the country. The two told the others, who would not believe them. [This passage belongs to the later addition to Mark, which originally ended at xvi. 8. Editor.] Luke also tells a story that keeps Christ occupied all day, until the evening, on the day of this supposed resurrection. The story completely invalidates the account of the journey to the mountain in Galilee. Luke says that two of them went that same day to a village called Emmaus. He does not say which two. Emmaus was 60 furlongs (seven and a half miles) from Jerusalem. Christ went with them in disguise and stayed with them until evening. He ate supper with them, then vanished from their sight. That same evening, he appeared again at the meeting of the eleven in Jerusalem.

This is the contradictory manner in which the evidence of this pretended reappearance of Christ is stated: the only point in which the writers agree, is the skulking privacy of that reappearance; for whether it was in the recess of a mountain in Galilee, or in a shut-up house in Jerusalem, it was still skulking. To what cause then are we to assign this skulking? On the one hand, it is directly repugnant to the supposed or pretended end, that of convincing the world that Christ was risen; and, on the other hand, to have asserted the publicity of it would have exposed the writers of those books to public detection; and, therefore, they have been under the necessity of making it a private affair.

The accounts of Christ’s supposed reappearance contradict one another. The writers agree only that he reappeared in secret, as if hiding. Whether in a remote part of a mountain in Galilee or a closed house in Jerusalem, he was still hiding. Why, then, was he hiding? On the one hand, it directly contradicts the supposed purpose of the reappearance, to convince the world that Christ had risen. On the other hand, claiming that he appeared publicly would have exposed the writers of those books to public detection. So they had to make it a private affair.

As to the account of Christ being seen by more than five hundred at once, it is Paul only who says it, and not the five hundred who say it for themselves. It is, therefore, the testimony of but one man, and that too of a man, who did not, according to the same account, believe a word of the matter himself at the time it is said to have happened. His evidence, supposing him to have been the writer of Corinthians xv., where this account is given, is like that of a man who comes into a court of justice to swear that what he had sworn before was false. A man may often see reason, and he has too always the right of changing his opinion; but this liberty does not extend to matters of fact.

As for the claim that more than five hundred people saw Christ at once, only Paul says it. The five hundred do not say it themselves. It is therefore the testimony of only one man. And according to the same account, that man did not believe a word of it when it supposedly happened. Suppose Paul wrote Corinthians xv., where this account appears. His evidence is like that of a man who comes into court to swear that his earlier testimony was false. A man may often see reason to change his opinion, and he always has the right to do so. But this freedom does not extend to matters of fact.

I now come to the last scene, that of the ascension into heaven.—Here all fear of the Jews, and of every thing else, must necessarily have been out of the question: it was that which, if true, was to seal the whole; and upon which the reality of the future mission of the disciples was to rest for proof. Words, whether declarations or promises, that passed in private, either in the recess of a mountain in Galilee, or in a shut-up house in Jerusalem, even supposing them to have been spoken, could not be evidence in public; it was therefore necessary that this last scene should preclude the possibility of denial and dispute; and that it should be, as I have stated in the former part of ‘The Age of Reason,’ as public and as visible as the sun at noon-day; at least it ought to have been as public as the crucifixion is reported to have been.—But to come to the point.

I now come to the last scene, the ascension into heaven. At this point, fear of the Jews or anything else must have been entirely out of the question. If true, the ascension was to confirm the whole account. It was also to serve as proof that the disciples’ future mission was real. Words spoken in private could not serve as public evidence, even supposing they were spoken. This applies to declarations and promises made in a secluded place on a mountain in Galilee or in a closed house in Jerusalem. This last scene therefore had to rule out any possibility of denial or dispute. As I stated in the earlier part of ‘The Age of Reason,’ it had to be as public and visible as the sun at noon. At least, it ought to have been as public as the crucifixion is reported to have been. But to come to the point.

In the first place, the writer of the book of Matthew does not say a syllable about it; neither does the writer of the book of John. This being the case, is it possible to suppose that those writers, who affect to be even minute in other matters, would have been silent upon this, had it been true? The writer of the book of Mark passes it off in a careless, slovenly manner, with a single dash of the pen, as if he was tired of romancing, or ashamed of the story. So also does the writer of Luke. And even between these two, there is not an apparent agreement, as to the place where this final parting is said to have been. [The last nine verses of Mark being ungenuine, the story of the ascension rests exclusively on the words in Luke xxiv. 51, “was carried up into heaven,”—words omitted by several ancient authorities.—Editor.]

First, the writers of Matthew and John do not say a word about it. They claim to be detailed about other matters. If this were true, could they really have remained silent about it? The writer of Mark deals with it carelessly and sloppily, in a single stroke of the pen. He writes as if he were tired of making up stories or ashamed of this one. The writer of Luke does the same. Even these two do not seem to agree about where this final parting took place. [The last nine verses of Mark are not genuine. So the story of the ascension rests entirely on the words in Luke xxiv. 51, “was carried up into heaven.” Several ancient authorities omit these words. Editor.]

The book of Mark says that Christ appeared to the eleven as they sat at meat, alluding to the meeting of the eleven at Jerusalem: he then states the conversation that he says passed at that meeting; and immediately after says (as a school-boy would finish a dull story,) “So then, after the Lord had spoken unto them, he was received up into heaven, and sat on the right hand of God.” But the writer of Luke says, that the ascension was from Bethany; that he (Christ) led them out as far as Bethany, and was parted from them there, and was carried up into heaven. So also was Mahomet: and, as to Moses, the apostle Jude says, ver. 9. That ‘Michael and the devil disputed about his body.’ While we believe such fables as these, or either of them, we believe unworthily of the Almighty.

The book of Mark says that Christ appeared to the eleven as they sat eating. This refers to the meeting of the eleven in Jerusalem. Mark then describes the conversation he says took place there. Immediately afterward, he writes, like a schoolboy finishing a dull story, “So then, after the Lord had spoken to them, he was taken up into heaven and sat at the right hand of God.” But the writer of Luke says that the ascension took place from Bethany. He says Christ led them out as far as Bethany, parted from them there, and was carried up into heaven. So too was Mahomet. As for Moses, the apostle Jude says in verse 9 that ‘Michael and the devil disputed over his body.’ As long as we believe such fables, or any one of them, we believe in a way unworthy of the Almighty.

I have now gone through the examination of the four books ascribed to Matthew, Mark, Luke and John; and when it is considered that the whole space of time, from the crucifixion to what is called the ascension, is but a few days, apparently not more than three or four, and that all the circumstances are reported to have happened nearly about the same spot, Jerusalem, it is, I believe, impossible to find in any story upon record so many and such glaring absurdities, contradictions, and falsehoods, as are in those books. They are more numerous and striking than I had any expectation of finding, when I began this examination, and far more so than I had any idea of when I wrote the former part of ‘The Age of Reason.’ I had then neither Bible nor Testament to refer to, nor could I procure any. My own situation, even as to existence, was becoming every day more precarious; and as I was willing to leave something behind me upon the subject, I was obliged to be quick and concise. The quotations I then made were from memory only, but they are correct; and the opinions I have advanced in that work are the effect of the most clear and long-established conviction,—that the Bible and the Testament are impositions upon the world;—that the fall of man, the account of Jesus Christ being the Son of God, and of his dying to appease the wrath of God, and of salvation by that strange means, are all fabulous inventions, dishonourable to the wisdom and power of the Almighty;—that the only true religion is deism, by which I then meant and now mean the belief of one God, and an imitation of his moral character, or the practice of what are called moral virtues;—and that it was upon this only (so far as religion is concerned) that I rested all my hopes of happiness hereafter. So say I now—and so help me God.

I have now examined the four books attributed to Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. The whole period from the crucifixion to what is called the ascension was only a few days, apparently no more than three or four. All the events are reported to have happened in nearly the same place, Jerusalem. Given this, I believe no story on record contains so many glaring absurdities, contradictions, and falsehoods as these books do. They are more numerous and striking than I expected when I began this examination. They are far more numerous and striking than I imagined when I wrote the earlier part of ‘The Age of Reason.’ At that time, I had neither a Bible nor a Testament to consult, and I could obtain neither. My own situation, and even my survival, grew more uncertain every day. I wanted to leave something behind on the subject, so I had to be quick and concise. The quotations I made then were from memory alone, but they are correct. The opinions I expressed in that work came from a clear and long-held conviction: the Bible and the Testament are frauds imposed on the world. The fall of man, the claim that Jesus Christ is the Son of God, and the claim that he died to appease God’s anger are all invented stories. So is the claim that salvation comes by that strange means. All these inventions dishonor the wisdom and power of the Almighty. The only true religion is deism. By deism, I meant then, and still mean now, belief in one God and imitation of his moral character, or the practice of what are called moral virtues. As far as religion is concerned, I placed all my hopes of happiness after death in deism alone. So I say now, and so help me God.

But to retum to the subject.—Though it is impossible, at this distance of time, to ascertain as a fact who were the writers of those four books (and this alone is sufficient to hold them in doubt, and where we doubt we do not believe) it is not difficult to ascertain negatively that they were not written by the persons to whom they are ascribed. The contradictions in those books demonstrate two things:

But to return to the subject. So much time has passed that we cannot establish who wrote those four books. That alone is enough to make us doubt them, and where we doubt, we do not believe. But it is not difficult to establish that they were not written by the people credited with writing them. The contradictions in those books show two things:

First, that the writers cannot have been eye-witnesses and ear-witnesses of the matters they relate, or they would have related them without those contradictions; and, consequently that the books have not been written by the persons called apostles, who are supposed to have been witnesses of this kind.

First, the writers cannot have seen and heard the events they describe. If they had, their accounts would not contradict each other. Therefore, the books were not written by the apostles, who are supposed to have witnessed these events.

Secondly, that the writers, whoever they were, have not acted in concerted imposition, but each writer separately and individually for himself, and without the knowledge of the other.

Secondly, that the writers, whoever they were, did not work together to deceive. Each acted independently, without the others' knowledge.

The same evidence that applies to prove the one, applies equally to prove both cases; that is, that the books were not written by the men called apostles, and also that they are not a concerted imposition. As to inspiration, it is altogether out of the question; we may as well attempt to unite truth and falsehood, as inspiration and contradiction.

The same evidence proves both points. The books were not written by the men called apostles, and they are not a deliberate fraud. As for inspiration, it is entirely out of the question. We might as well try to unite truth and falsehood as unite inspiration and contradiction.

If four men are eye-witnesses and ear-witnesses to a scene, they will without any concert between them, agree as to time and place, when and where that scene happened. Their individual knowledge of the thing, each one knowing it for himself, renders concert totally unnecessary; the one will not say it was in a mountain in the country, and the other at a house in town; the one will not say it was at sunrise, and the other that it was dark. For in whatever place it was and whatever time it was, they know it equally alike.

If four men see and hear the same event, they will agree on when and where it happened without coordinating their accounts. Each knows what happened firsthand, so there is no need for them to coordinate. One will not say it happened on a mountain in the country while another says it happened in a house in town. One will not say it happened at sunrise while another says it was dark. For whatever the place and time, they all know them equally well.

And on the other hand, if four men concert a story, they will make their separate relations of that story agree and corroborate with each other to support the whole. That concert supplies the want of fact in the one case, as the knowledge of the fact supersedes, in the other case, the necessity of a concert. The same contradictions, therefore, that prove there has been no concert, prove also that the reporters had no knowledge of the fact, (or rather of that which they relate as a fact,) and detect also the falsehood of their reports. Those books, therefore, have neither been written by the men called apostles, nor by imposters in concert.—How then have they been written?

On the other hand, suppose four men agree on a story. They will make their separate accounts agree and support one another, so that the whole story seems credible. In one case, their agreement makes up for the lack of facts. In the other, knowledge of the facts makes such agreement unnecessary. So the same contradictions that prove there was no agreement also prove that the reporters knew nothing of the fact. Or rather, they knew nothing of what they report as a fact. The contradictions also expose their reports as false. These books, therefore, were written neither by the men called apostles nor by imposters acting together. How, then, were they written?

I am not one of those who are fond of believing there is much of that which is called wilful lying, or lying originally, except in the case of men setting up to be prophets, as in the Old Testament; for prophesying is lying professionally. In almost all other cases it is not difficult to discover the progress by which even simple supposition, with the aid of credulity, will in time grow into a lie, and at last be told as a fact; and whenever we can find a charitable reason for a thing of this kind, we ought not to indulge a severe one.

I am not inclined to believe that much lying is deliberate or made up from the start. The exception is men who set themselves up as prophets, as in the Old Testament. Prophecy is professional lying. In almost all other cases, it is easy to see how a simple guess can gradually become a lie. With the help of people’s willingness to believe, the guess eventually comes to be told as fact. Whenever we can find a charitable explanation for something like this, we should not favor a harsh one.

The story of Jesus Christ appearing after he was dead is the story of an apparition, such as timid imaginations can always create in vision, and credulity believe. Stories of this kind had been told of the assassination of Julius Caesar not many years before, and they generally have their origin in violent deaths, or in execution of innocent persons. In cases of this kind, compassion lends its aid, and benevolently stretches the story. It goes on a little and a little farther, till it becomes a most certain truth. Once start a ghost, and credulity fills up the history of its life, and assigns the cause of its appearance; one tells it one way, another another way, till there are as many stories about the ghost, and about the proprietor of the ghost, as there are about Jesus Christ in these four books.

The story of Jesus Christ appearing after his death is a ghost story. Fearful imaginations can always create such visions, and gullible people can believe them. Similar stories were told about the assassination of Julius Caesar not many years before. Such stories generally arise after violent deaths or the execution of innocent people. In such cases, compassion plays a part, and kindhearted people exaggerate the story. It grows little by little until it becomes an absolute truth. Once a ghost story starts, gullible people fill in the story of the ghost's life and explain why it appeared. One person tells it one way, another tells it another. Soon there are as many stories about the ghost and the person it belonged to as there are about Jesus Christ in these four books.

The story of the appearance of Jesus Christ is told with that strange mixture of the natural and impossible, that distinguishes legendary tale from fact. He is represented as suddenly coming in and going out when the doors are shut, and of vanishing out of sight, and appearing again, as one would conceive of an unsubstantial vision; then again he is hungry, sits down to meat, and eats his supper. But as those who tell stories of this kind never provide for all the cases, so it is here: they have told us, that when he arose he left his grave-clothes behind him; but they have forgotten to provide other clothes for him to appear in afterwards, or to tell us what he did with them when he ascended; whether he stripped all off, or went up clothes and all. In the case of Elijah, they have been careful enough to make him throw down his mantle; how it happened not to be burnt in the chariot of fire, they also have not told us; but as imagination supplies all deficiencies of this kind, we may suppose if we please that it was made of salamander’s wool.

The story of Jesus Christ's appearance is told with a strange mixture of the natural and the impossible. This mixture distinguishes a legend from a fact. He is shown suddenly coming and going while the doors are shut. He vanishes from sight and appears again, like a vision without substance. Then he is hungry, sits down, and eats his supper. But people who tell stories like this never account for everything, and that is true here. They tell us that when he rose, he left his grave clothes behind. But they forgot to provide him with other clothes to appear in afterward. Nor did they tell us what he did with those clothes when he ascended. Did he take them all off, or go up with them on? In Elijah's case, they were careful enough to have him throw down his cloak. They did not tell us how it escaped being burned in the chariot of fire, either. But imagination fills all gaps of this kind. If we like, we may suppose that the cloak was made of salamander's wool.

Those who are not much acquainted with ecclesiastical history, may suppose that the book called the New Testament has existed ever since the time of Jesus Christ, as they suppose that the books ascribed to Moses have existed ever since the time of Moses. But the fact is historically otherwise; there was no such book as the New Testament till more than three hundred years after the time that Christ is said to have lived.

People who know little about church history may suppose that the New Testament has existed since the time of Jesus Christ. They may also suppose that the books attributed to Moses have existed since the time of Moses. But the historical facts say otherwise. There was no book called the New Testament until more than three hundred years after Christ is said to have lived.

At what time the books ascribed to Matthew, Mark, Luke and John, began to appear, is altogether a matter of uncertainty. There is not the least shadow of evidence of who the persons were that wrote them, nor at what time they were written; and they might as well have been called by the names of any of the other supposed apostles as by the names they are now called. The originals are not in the possession of any Christian Church existing, any more than the two tables of stone written on, they pretend, by the finger of God, upon Mount Sinai, and given to Moses, are in the possession of the Jews. And even if they were, there is no possibility of proving the hand-writing in either case. At the time those four books were written there was no printing, and consequently there could be no publication otherwise than by written copies, which any man might make or alter at pleasure, and call them originals. Can we suppose it is consistent with the wisdom of the Almighty to commit himself and his will to man upon such precarious means as these; or that it is consistent we should pin our faith upon such uncertainties? We cannot make nor alter, nor even imitate, so much as one blade of grass that he has made, and yet we can make or alter words of God as easily as words of man. [The former part of the ‘Age of Reason’ has not been published two years, and there is already an expression in it that is not mine. The expression is: The book of Luke was carried by a majority of one voice only. It may be true, but it is not I that have said it. Some person who might know of that circumstance, has added it in a note at the bottom of the page of some of the editions, printed either in England or in America; and the printers, after that, have erected it into the body of the work, and made me the author of it. If this has happened within such a short space of time, notwithstanding the aid of printing, which prevents the alteration of copies individually, what may not have happened in a much greater length of time, when there was no printing, and when any man who could write could make a written copy and call it an original by Matthew, Mark, Luke, or John?—Author.]

It is entirely uncertain when the books attributed to Matthew, Mark, Luke and John first appeared. There is not the slightest evidence of who wrote them or when they were written. They could just as well have been named after any of the other supposed apostles. No Christian Church today possesses the original books. Nor do the Jews possess the two stone tablets supposedly written on by God’s finger on Mount Sinai and given to Moses. Even if the originals were in their possession, there would be no way to prove the handwriting in either case. When those four books were written, there was no printing. They could only be published as handwritten copies. Anyone could make or alter those copies as they pleased and call them originals. Can we suppose that the Almighty, in his wisdom, would entrust himself and his will to people through such unreliable means? Or that we should base our faith on such uncertainties? We cannot make, alter, or even imitate a single blade of grass that he has made. Yet we can make or alter the words of God as easily as the words of man. [The first part of the ‘Age of Reason’ has not been published for even two years. Yet an expression that is not mine has already appeared in it. The expression is: The book of Luke was accepted by a majority of only one vote. That may be true, but I did not say it. Someone who may have known about this circumstance added it in a note at the bottom of the page. The note appeared in some editions printed either in England or in America. Later, printers moved it into the body of the work and made me its author. This happened in such a short time, despite printing, which prevents individual copies from being altered. So what might have happened over a much longer time, when there was no printing? Anyone who could write could make a handwritten copy and call it an original by Matthew, Mark, Luke, or John. Author.]

[The spurious addition to Paine’s work alluded to in his footnote drew on him a severe criticism from Dr. Priestley (“Letters to a Philosophical Unbeliever,” p. 75), yet it seems to have been Priestley himself who, in his quotation, first incorporated into Paine’s text the footnote added by the editor of the American edition (1794). The American added: “Vide Moshiem’s (sic) Ecc. History,” which Priestley omits. In a modern American edition I notice four verbal alterations introduced into the above footnote.—Editor.]

[The false addition to Paine’s work, mentioned in his footnote, brought him harsh criticism from Dr. Priestley (“Letters to a Philosophical Unbeliever,” p. 75). Yet Priestley himself seems to have been the first to include an editor’s footnote in a quotation from Paine. The footnote had been added by the editor of the American edition (1794). The American editor added: “Vide Moshiem’s (sic) Ecc. History,” which Priestley leaves out. In a modern American edition, I notice four changes in wording in the footnote above. Editor.]

About three hundred and fifty years after the time that Christ is said to have lived, several writings of the kind I am speaking of were scattered in the hands of divers individuals; and as the church had begun to form itself into an hierarchy, or church government, with temporal powers, it set itself about collecting them into a code, as we now see them, called ‘The New Testament.’ They decided by vote, as I have before said in the former part of the Age of Reason, which of those writings, out of the collection they had made, should be the word of God, and which should not. The Robbins of the Jews had decided, by vote, upon the books of the Bible before.

About 350 years after Christ is said to have lived, several writings of the kind I am discussing were scattered among different people. By then, the church had begun to form a hierarchy, or church government, with earthly powers. So it set about collecting these writings into a book, now called ‘The New Testament.’ As I said earlier in the first part of The Age of Reason, church leaders voted on which of the collected writings should be the word of God and which should not. The Jewish rabbis had earlier voted on the books of the Bible.

As the object of the church, as is the case in all national establishments of churches, was power and revenue, and terror the means it used, it is consistent to suppose that the most miraculous and wonderful of the writings they had collected stood the best chance of being voted. And as to the authenticity of the books, the vote stands in the place of it; for it can be traced no higher.

The church sought power and revenue, as all national churches do, and it used terror to achieve them. So it is reasonable to suppose that the most miraculous and wonderful writings they collected were most likely to be voted in. As for the authenticity of the books, the vote takes its place. Their authenticity can be traced no further back than the vote.

Disputes, however, ran high among the people then calling themselves Christians, not only as to points of doctrine, but as to the authenticity of the books. In the contest between the person called St. Augustine, and Fauste, about the year 400, the latter says, “The books called the Evangelists have been composed long after the times of the apostles, by some obscure men, who, fearing that the world would not give credit to their relation of matters of which they could not be informed, have published them under the names of the apostles; and which are so full of sottishness and discordant relations, that there is neither agreement nor connection between them.”

However, people who called themselves Christians at the time argued fiercely. They disputed not only points of doctrine but also whether the books were authentic. Around the year 400, the person called St. Augustine disputed with Fauste. Fauste said, “The books called the Gospels were written long after the apostles’ time by some obscure men. These men feared the world would not believe their accounts of matters they could not have known about. So they published the books under the apostles’ names. The books are so full of foolishness and conflicting accounts that they neither agree nor connect with one another.”

And in another place, addressing himself to the advocates of those books, as being the word of God, he says, “It is thus that your predecessors have inserted in the scriptures of our Lord many things which, though they carry his name, agree not with his doctrine.” This is not surprising, since that we have often proved that these things have not been written by himself, nor by his apostles, but that for the greatest part they are founded upon tales, upon vague reports, and put together by I know not what half-Jews, with but little agreement between them; and which they have nevertheless published under the name of the apostles of our Lord, and have thus attributed to them their own errors and their lies. [I have taken these two extracts from Boulanger’s Life of Paul, written in French; Boulanger has quoted them from the writings of Augustine against Fauste, to which he refers.—Author.]

Elsewhere, he addresses those who defend these books as the word of God. He says, “Your predecessors have inserted many things into the scriptures of our Lord. Though these things bear his name, they do not agree with his teaching.” This is not surprising. We have often proved that these things were written neither by him nor by his apostles. For the most part, they are based on tales and vague reports. They were put together by I know not what half-Jews, who agreed little with one another. Yet they published these things under the names of our Lord’s apostles. In this way, they attributed their own errors and lies to the apostles. [I have taken these two extracts from Boulanger’s Life of Paul, written in French. Boulanger quotes them from the writings of Augustine against Fauste, which he cites. Author.]

This Bishop Faustus is usually styled “The Manichaeum,” Augustine having entitled his book, Contra Frustum Manichaeum Libri xxxiii., in which nearly the whole of Faustus’ very able work is quoted.—Editor.]

This Bishop Faustus is usually called “The Manichaeum.” Augustine titled his book Contra Frustum Manichaeum Libri xxxiii. In it, Augustine quotes nearly all of Faustus’ very able work. (Editor.)]

The reader will see by those extracts that the authenticity of the books of the New Testament was denied, and the books treated as tales, forgeries, and lies, at the time they were voted to be the word of God. But the interest of the church, with the assistance of the faggot, bore down the opposition, and at last suppressed all investigation. Miracles followed upon miracles, if we will believe them, and men were taught to say they believed whether they believed or not. But (by way of throwing in a thought) the French Revolution has excommunicated the church from the power of working miracles; she has not been able, with the assistance of all her saints, to work one miracle since the revolution began; and as she never stood in greater need than now, we may, without the aid of divination, conclude that all her former miracles are tricks and lies. [Boulanger in his life of Paul, has collected from the ecclesiastical histories, and the writings of the fathers as they are called, several matters which show the opinions that prevailed among the different sects of Christians, at the time the Testament, as we now see it, was voted to be the word of God. The following extracts are from the second chapter of that work:

These extracts show that the books of the New Testament were disputed when they were voted to be the word of God. People treated them as tales, forgeries, and lies. But the church, acting in its own interest and using the threat of burning, crushed the opposition. In the end, it suppressed all investigation. Miracles followed upon miracles, if we choose to believe the stories. And men were taught to say they believed, whether they did or not. But here is a thought. The French Revolution has excommunicated the church from the power to work miracles. Since the revolution began, the church has not been able to work one miracle, even with the help of all her saints. The church has never needed miracles more than it does now. So we need no powers of prophecy to conclude that all her former miracles are tricks and lies. [Boulanger, in his life of Paul, draws several accounts from church histories and the writings of the so-called church fathers. These accounts show the opinions held by different Christian sects when the Testament, as we now see it, was voted to be the word of God. The following extracts are from the second chapter of that work:

[The Marcionists (a Christian sect) asserted that the evangelists were filled with falsities. The Manichaeans, who formed a very numerous sect at the commencement of Christianity, rejected as false all the New Testament, and showed other writings quite different that they gave for authentic. The Corinthians, like the Marcionists, admitted not the Acts of the Apostles. The Encratites and the Sevenians adopted neither the Acts, nor the Epistles of Paul. Chrysostom, in a homily which he made upon the Acts of the Apostles, says that in his time, about the year 400, many people knew nothing either of the author or of the book. St. Irene, who lived before that time, reports that the Valentinians, like several other sects of the Christians, accused the scriptures of being filled with imperfections, errors, and contradictions. The Ebionites, or Nazarenes, who were the first Christians, rejected all the Epistles of Paul, and regarded him as an impostor. They report, among other things, that he was originally a Pagan; that he came to Jerusalem, where he lived some time; and that having a mind to marry the daughter of the high priest, he had himself been circumcised; but that not being able to obtain her, he quarrelled with the Jews and wrote against circumcision, and against the observation of the Sabbath, and against all the legal ordinances.—Author.] [Much abridged from the Exam. Crit. de la Vie de St. Paul, by N.A. Boulanger, 1770.—Editor.]

[The Marcionists, a Christian sect, claimed that the Gospel writers were full of falsehoods. The Manichaeans were a very large sect at the beginning of Christianity. They rejected the entire New Testament as false and presented very different writings as authentic. Like the Marcionists, the Corinthians did not accept the Acts of the Apostles. The Encratites and the Sevenians accepted neither Acts nor the Epistles of Paul. In a sermon on the Acts of the Apostles, Chrysostom said that around the year 400, many people knew nothing about either the book or its author. St. Irene lived before that time. He reported that the Valentinians, like several other Christian sects, accused the scriptures of being full of imperfections, errors, and contradictions. The Ebionites, or Nazarenes, were the first Christians. They rejected all the Epistles of Paul and regarded him as an impostor. Among other things, they reported that he was originally a Pagan. They said he came to Jerusalem and lived there for some time. He wanted to marry the high priest's daughter, so he had himself circumcised. But when he could not obtain her hand, he quarreled with the Jews. He wrote against circumcision, the observance of the Sabbath, and all the legal ordinances. Author.] [Much abridged from the Exam. Crit. de la Vie de St. Paul, by N.A. Boulanger, 1770. Editor.]

When we consider the lapse of more than three hundred years intervening between the time that Christ is said to have lived and the time the New Testament was formed into a book, we must see, even without the assistance of historical evidence, the exceeding uncertainty there is of its authenticity. The authenticity of the book of Homer, so far as regards the authorship, is much better established than that of the New Testament, though Homer is a thousand years the most ancient. It was only an exceeding good poet that could have written the book of Homer, and, therefore, few men only could have attempted it; and a man capable of doing it would not have thrown away his own fame by giving it to another. In like manner, there were but few that could have composed Euclid’s Elements, because none but an exceeding good geometrician could have been the author of that work.

More than three hundred years passed between the time Christ is said to have lived and the formation of the New Testament as a book. Even without historical evidence, we must see how uncertain its authenticity is. The authorship of Homer’s book is much better established than that of the New Testament, though Homer lived a thousand years earlier. Only a very good poet could have written Homer’s book, so few men could have attempted it. And a man capable of writing it would not have given up his own fame by crediting someone else. Similarly, few could have composed Euclid’s Elements, because only a very good mathematician specializing in geometry could have written it.

But with respect to the books of the New Testament, particularly such parts as tell us of the resurrection and ascension of Christ, any person who could tell a story of an apparition, or of a man’s walking, could have made such books; for the story is most wretchedly told. The chance, therefore, of forgery in the Testament is millions to one greater than in the case of Homer or Euclid. Of the numerous priests or parsons of the present day, bishops and all, every one of them can make a sermon, or translate a scrap of Latin, especially if it has been translated a thousand times before; but is there any amongst them that can write poetry like Homer, or science like Euclid? The sum total of a parson’s learning, with very few exceptions, is a, b, ab, and hic, haec, hoc; and their knowledge of science is, three times one is three; and this is more than sufficient to have enabled them, had they lived at the time, to have written all the books of the New Testament.

But as for the books of the New Testament, especially the parts about Christ’s resurrection and ascension, anyone could have written them. Anyone who could tell a story about a ghost or a man walking could have done it. The story is told so terribly. The chance of forgery in the Testament is therefore millions of times greater than in the case of Homer or Euclid. Every one of today’s many priests and ministers, bishops included, can write a sermon or translate a scrap of Latin. That is especially true if the Latin has been translated a thousand times before. But can any of them write poetry like Homer or science like Euclid? With very few exceptions, a minister’s learning amounts to a, b, ab, and hic, haec, hoc. His knowledge of science is that three times one is three. And that is more than enough to have enabled them to write all the books of the New Testament, had they lived at the time.

As the opportunities of forgery were greater, so also was the inducement. A man could gain no advantage by writing under the name of Homer or Euclid; if he could write equal to them, it would be better that he wrote under his own name; if inferior, he could not succeed. Pride would prevent the former, and impossibility the latter. But with respect to such books as compose the New Testament, all the inducements were on the side of forgery. The best imagined history that could have been made, at the distance of two or three hundred years after the time, could not have passed for an original under the name of the real writer; the only chance of success lay in forgery; for the church wanted pretence for its new doctrine, and truth and talents were out of the question.

Just as there were more opportunities for forgery, there was also more incentive. A man could gain nothing by writing under the name of Homer or Euclid. If he could write as well as they did, he would be better off using his own name. If he wrote less well, he could not succeed. Pride would prevent the first, and impossibility the second. But for books like those that make up the New Testament, all the incentives favored forgery. Even the best invented history could not have passed for an original under its real writer's name. This was true if it was written two or three hundred years after the events. The only chance of success lay in forgery. The church needed a pretext for its new doctrine, and truth and talent were out of the question.

But as it is not uncommon (as before observed) to relate stories of persons walking after they are dead, and of ghosts and apparitions of such as have fallen by some violent or extraordinary means; and as the people of that day were in the habit of believing such things, and of the appearance of angels, and also of devils, and of their getting into people’s insides, and shaking them like a fit of an ague, and of their being cast out again as if by an emetic—(Mary Magdalene, the book of Mark tells us had brought up, or been brought to bed of seven devils;) it was nothing extraordinary that some story of this kind should get abroad of the person called Jesus Christ, and become afterwards the foundation of the four books ascribed to Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. Each writer told a tale as he heard it, or thereabouts, and gave to his book the name of the saint or the apostle whom tradition had given as the eye-witness. It is only upon this ground that the contradictions in those books can be accounted for; and if this be not the case, they are downright impositions, lies, and forgeries, without even the apology of credulity.

But as noted earlier, it is not unusual to tell stories about people walking after they are dead. There are also stories of ghosts and apparitions of people who died violently or in extraordinary ways. People in those days were in the habit of believing such things. They also believed that angels and devils appeared, and that devils entered people and shook them like a fever. They believed the devils were then cast out, as if by a medicine that makes people vomit. (The book of Mark tells us that Mary Magdalene had thrown up, or given birth to, seven devils.) So it was nothing extraordinary that such a story should spread about the person called Jesus Christ. It was nothing extraordinary, either, that the story later became the foundation of the four books attributed to Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. Each writer told the story as he had heard it, or something close to it. Each gave his book the name of the saint or apostle whom tradition had named as the eyewitness. Only on this basis can the contradictions in those books be explained. If this is not what happened, the books are outright deceptions, lies, and forgeries, without even the excuse of gullibility.

That they have been written by a sort of half Jews, as the foregoing quotations mention, is discernible enough. The frequent references made to that chief assassin and impostor Moses, and to the men called prophets, establishes this point; and, on the other hand, the church has complimented the fraud, by admitting the Bible and the Testament to reply to each other. Between the Christian-Jew and the Christian-Gentile, the thing called a prophecy, and the thing prophesied of, the type and the thing typified, the sign and the thing signified, have been industriously rummaged up, and fitted together like old locks and pick-lock keys. The story foolishly enough told of Eve and the serpent, and naturally enough as to the enmity between men and serpents (for the serpent always bites about the heel, because it cannot reach higher, and the man always knocks the serpent about the head, as the most effectual way to prevent its biting;) [“It shall bruise thy head, and thou shalt bruise his heel.” Gen. iii. 15.—Author.] this foolish story, I say, has been made into a prophecy, a type, and a promise to begin with; and the lying imposition of Isaiah to Ahaz, ‘That a virgin shall conceive and bear a son,’ as a sign that Ahaz should conquer, when the event was that he was defeated (as already noticed in the observations on the book of Isaiah), has been perverted, and made to serve as a winder up.

It is clear enough that they were written by a sort of half Jews, as the earlier quotations mention. Their frequent references to that chief assassin and impostor Moses, and to the men called prophets, establish this point. The church, for its part, has played along with the fraud by allowing the Bible and the Testament to answer each other. Between the Christian-Jew and the Christian-Gentile, they have worked hard to rummage up prophecies and the things supposedly prophesied. They have done the same with types and the things they represent, and signs and the things they signify. They have fitted them together like old locks and skeleton keys. The story of Eve and the serpent is foolish enough. Yet it describes the hostility between men and serpents naturally enough. The serpent always bites at the heel because it cannot reach higher. The man always strikes the serpent on the head, the most effective way to stop it from biting. [“It shall bruise thy head, and thou shalt bruise his heel.” Gen. iii. 15.—Author.] This foolish story, I say, has been turned into a prophecy, a type, and a promise to start with. Then there is Isaiah’s deceitful lie to Ahaz: ‘That a virgin shall conceive and bear a son.’ Isaiah offered it as a sign that Ahaz would conquer, but Ahaz was defeated. I have already noted this in my observations on the book of Isaiah. This lie has been twisted to serve as a conclusion.

Jonah and the whale are also made into a sign and type. Jonah is Jesus, and the whale is the grave; for it is said, (and they have made Christ to say it of himself, Matt. xii. 40), “For as Jonah was three days and three nights in the whale’s belly, so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.” But it happens, awkwardly enough, that Christ, according to their own account, was but one day and two nights in the grave; about 36 hours instead of 72; that is, the Friday night, the Saturday, and the Saturday night; for they say he was up on the Sunday morning by sunrise, or before. But as this fits quite as well as the bite and the kick in Genesis, or the virgin and her son in Isaiah, it will pass in the lump of orthodox things.—Thus much for the historical part of the Testament and its evidences.

Jonah and the whale are also turned into a sign and symbol. Jonah represents Jesus, and the whale represents the grave. For the Bible says, and they have made Christ say it about himself (Matt. xii. 40): “For just as Jonah was three days and three nights in the whale’s belly, so the Son of man will be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.” But, awkwardly enough, their own account says Christ was in the grave for only one day and two nights. That is about 36 hours instead of 72: Friday night, Saturday, and Saturday night. For they say he rose on Sunday morning, at or before sunrise. But this fits just as well as the bite and the kick in Genesis, or the virgin and her son in Isaiah. So it will pass along with the rest of orthodox beliefs. That is enough about the historical part of the Testament and its evidence.

Epistles of Paul—The epistles ascribed to Paul, being fourteen in number, almost fill up the remaining part of the Testament. Whether those epistles were written by the person to whom they are ascribed is a matter of no great importance, since that the writer, whoever he was, attempts to prove his doctrine by argument. He does not pretend to have been witness to any of the scenes told of the resurrection and the ascension; and he declares that he had not believed them.

Paul’s Letters: The fourteen letters attributed to Paul make up almost all the rest of the Testament. It does not much matter whether Paul wrote them. Whoever the writer was, he tries to prove his doctrine through argument. He does not claim to have witnessed any of the events described in the resurrection and the ascension. And he says that he had not believed those accounts.

The story of his being struck to the ground as he was journeying to Damascus, has nothing in it miraculous or extraordinary; he escaped with life, and that is more than many others have done, who have been struck with lightning; and that he should lose his sight for three days, and be unable to eat or drink during that time, is nothing more than is common in such conditions. His companions that were with him appear not to have suffered in the same manner, for they were well enough to lead him the remainder of the journey; neither did they pretend to have seen any vision.

The story of him being struck to the ground on his way to Damascus is neither miraculous nor extraordinary. He survived, which is more than many others struck by lightning have done. It is common in such cases to lose sight for three days and be unable to eat or drink. His companions do not seem to have suffered in the same way. They were well enough to lead him the rest of the way, and they did not claim to have seen a vision.

The character of the person called Paul, according to the accounts given of him, has in it a great deal of violence and fanaticism; he had persecuted with as much heat as he preached afterwards; the stroke he had received had changed his thinking, without altering his constitution; and either as a Jew or a Christian he was the same zealot. Such men are never good moral evidences of any doctrine they preach. They are always in extremes, as well of action as of belief.

According to the accounts of Paul, his character was marked by violence and fanaticism. He had persecuted others as fiercely as he later preached. The blow he received changed his thinking, but not his nature. Whether he was a Jew or a Christian, he was the same zealot. Such men are never good moral evidence for any doctrine they preach. They are always extreme in both their actions and their beliefs.

The doctrine he sets out to prove by argument, is the resurrection of the same body: and he advances this as an evidence of immortality. But so much will men differ in their manner of thinking, and in the conclusions they draw from the same premises, that this doctrine of the resurrection of the same body, so far from being an evidence of immortality, appears to me to be an evidence against it; for if I have already died in this body, and am raised again in the same body in which I have died, it is presumptive evidence that I shall die again. That resurrection no more secures me against the repetition of dying, than an ague-fit, when past, secures me against another. To believe therefore in immortality, I must have a more elevated idea than is contained in the gloomy doctrine of the resurrection.

The doctrine he sets out to prove is that the same body rises again. He offers this as evidence of immortality. But people think differently and draw different conclusions from the same premises. To me, the resurrection of the same body is far from evidence of immortality. It seems to be evidence against it. If I have already died in this body and am raised again in it, I presumably will die again. Resurrection no more protects me from dying again than a fever attack protects me from another once it has passed. To believe in immortality, then, I need a more elevated idea than the gloomy doctrine of resurrection offers.

Besides, as a matter of choice, as well as of hope, I had rather have a better body and a more convenient form than the present. Every animal in the creation excels us in something. The winged insects, without mentioning doves or eagles, can pass over more space with greater ease in a few minutes than man can in an hour. The glide of the smallest fish, in proportion to its bulk, exceeds us in motion almost beyond comparison, and without weariness. Even the sluggish snail can ascend from the bottom of a dungeon, where man, by the want of that ability, would perish; and a spider can launch itself from the top, as a playful amusement. The personal powers of man are so limited, and his heavy frame so little constructed to extensive enjoyment, that there is nothing to induce us to wish the opinion of Paul to be true. It is too little for the magnitude of the scene, too mean for the sublimity of the subject.

Besides, I would choose and hope to have a better body and a more convenient form than I have now. Every animal in creation surpasses us in some way. Winged insects can travel farther and more easily in a few minutes than a person can in an hour. That is without even mentioning doves or eagles. The smallest fish, compared with its size, moves almost incomparably faster than we do, and without tiring. Even the slow snail can climb out of a dungeon. A person would die there for lack of that ability. And a spider can launch itself from the top for amusement. Our physical abilities are so limited, and our heavy bodies so poorly suited to a wide range of pleasures, that nothing makes us want Paul’s opinion to be true. It is too small for the grandeur of the scene, too base for the splendor of the subject.

But all other arguments apart, the consciousness of existence is the only conceivable idea we can have of another life, and the continuance of that consciousness is immortality. The consciousness of existence, or the knowing that we exist, is not necessarily confined to the same form, nor to the same matter, even in this life.

But setting all other arguments aside, awareness that we exist is the only idea we can imagine of another life. The continuation of that awareness is immortality. Even in this life, awareness that we exist is not necessarily confined to the same form or the same matter.

We have not in all cases the same form, nor in any case the same matter, that composed our bodies twenty or thirty years ago; and yet we are conscious of being the same persons. Even legs and arms, which make up almost half the human frame, are not necessary to the consciousness of existence. These may be lost or taken away and the full consciousness of existence remain; and were their place supplied by wings, or other appendages, we cannot conceive that it could alter our consciousness of existence. In short, we know not how much, or rather how little, of our composition it is, and how exquisitely fine that little is, that creates in us this consciousness of existence; and all beyond that is like the pulp of a peach, distinct and separate from the vegetative speck in the kernel.

Our bodies do not always have the same shape they did twenty or thirty years ago. Nor are they ever made of the same matter. Yet we are aware that we are the same people. Even legs and arms, which make up almost half the human body, are not necessary for awareness of existence. They can be lost or removed, and full awareness of existence remains. If wings or other limbs replaced them, we cannot imagine that this would change our awareness of existence. In short, we do not know how much of our makeup creates this awareness, or rather, how little. Nor do we know how extraordinarily fine that small part is. Everything else is like the flesh of a peach, distinct and separate from the tiny growing part inside the pit.

Who can say by what exceeding fine action of fine matter it is that a thought is produced in what we call the mind? and yet that thought when produced, as I now produce the thought I am writing, is capable of becoming immortal, and is the only production of man that has that capacity.

Who can say how the delicate action of fine matter produces a thought in what we call the mind? Yet a thought, like the one I am writing now, can become immortal. It is the only thing human beings produce that can do so.

Statues of brass and marble will perish; and statues made in imitation of them are not the same statues, nor the same workmanship, any more than the copy of a picture is the same picture. But print and reprint a thought a thousand times over, and that with materials of any kind, carve it in wood, or engrave it on stone, the thought is eternally and identically the same thought in every case. It has a capacity of unimpaired existence, unaffected by change of matter, and is essentially distinct, and of a nature different from every thing else that we know of, or can conceive. If then the thing produced has in itself a capacity of being immortal, it is more than a token that the power that produced it, which is the self-same thing as consciousness of existence, can be immortal also; and that as independently of the matter it was first connected with, as the thought is of the printing or writing it first appeared in. The one idea is not more difficult to believe than the other; and we can see that one is true.

Statues of bronze and marble will perish. Statues made in imitation of them are not the same statues, nor are they the same workmanship. A copy of a painting is not the same painting. But print and reprint a thought a thousand times, using any kind of material, and it remains the same thought. Carve it in wood or engrave it on stone, and it is still eternally and identically the same thought. It can exist unchanged, unaffected by changes in matter. Its nature is essentially distinct from everything else we know or can imagine. If, then, the thought produced can itself be immortal, this is more than a sign that the power that produced it can also be immortal. That power is the very same thing as consciousness of existence. It can be immortal independently of the matter it was first connected with, just as the thought can exist independently of the printing or writing in which it first appeared. One idea is no harder to believe than the other, and we can see that one is true.

That the consciousness of existence is not dependent on the same form or the same matter, is demonstrated to our senses in the works of the creation, as far as our senses are capable of receiving that demonstration. A very numerous part of the animal creation preaches to us, far better than Paul, the belief of a life hereafter. Their little life resembles an earth and a heaven, a present and a future state; and comprises, if it may be so expressed, immortality in miniature.

The natural world shows our senses that awareness of existence does not depend on having the same form or matter. It shows this as far as our senses are capable of perceiving it. Many animals teach us to believe in an afterlife far better than Paul does. Their brief lives resemble an earth and a heaven, a present and a future state. They contain, if one may put it this way, immortality in miniature.

The most beautiful parts of the creation to our eye are the winged insects, and they are not so originally. They acquire that form and that inimitable brilliancy by progressive changes. The slow and creeping caterpillar worm of to day, passes in a few days to a torpid figure, and a state resembling death; and in the next change comes forth in all the miniature magnificence of life, a splendid butterfly. No resemblance of the former creature remains; every thing is changed; all his powers are new, and life is to him another thing. We cannot conceive that the consciousness of existence is not the same in this state of the animal as before; why then must I believe that the resurrection of the same body is necessary to continue to me the consciousness of existence hereafter?

To our eyes, winged insects are the most beautiful parts of creation, but they do not start out that way. They acquire their form and unmatched brilliance through gradual changes. Today's slow, crawling caterpillar becomes still within a few days, entering a state that resembles death. In its next transformation, it emerges as a splendid butterfly, displaying all the miniature magnificence of life. Nothing of the former creature's appearance remains. Everything has changed, all its abilities are new, and life is something different for it. We cannot imagine that the creature's awareness of its existence is any different from what it was before. Why, then, must I believe that the same body must rise again for me to remain aware of my existence hereafter?

In the former part of ‘The Age of Reason.’ I have called the creation the true and only real word of God; and this instance, or this text, in the book of creation, not only shows to us that this thing may be so, but that it is so; and that the belief of a future state is a rational belief, founded upon facts visible in the creation: for it is not more difficult to believe that we shall exist hereafter in a better state and form than at present, than that a worm should become a butterfly, and quit the dunghill for the atmosphere, if we did not know it as a fact.

In the earlier part of ‘The Age of Reason,’ I called creation the true and only real word of God. This example, or passage, in the book of creation shows that a future state is not merely possible, but real. It also shows that belief in a future state is rational, because it is based on facts visible in creation. For it is no harder to believe that we will exist hereafter in a better state and form than we do now. If we did not know it as a fact, it would be just as hard to believe that a worm becomes a butterfly and leaves the dung heap for the air.

As to the doubtful jargon ascribed to Paul in 1 Corinthians xv., which makes part of the burial service of some Christian sectaries, it is as destitute of meaning as the tolling of a bell at the funeral; it explains nothing to the understanding, it illustrates nothing to the imagination, but leaves the reader to find any meaning if he can. “All flesh,” says he, “is not the same flesh. There is one flesh of men, another of beasts, another of fishes, and another of birds.” And what then? nothing. A cook could have said as much. “There are also,” says he, “bodies celestial and bodies terrestrial; the glory of the celestial is one and the glory of the terrestrial is the other.” And what then? nothing. And what is the difference? nothing that he has told. “There is,” says he, “one glory of the sun, and another glory of the moon, and another glory of the stars.” And what then? nothing; except that he says that one star differeth from another star in glory, instead of distance; and he might as well have told us that the moon did not shine so bright as the sun. All this is nothing better than the jargon of a conjuror, who picks up phrases he does not understand to confound the credulous people who come to have their fortune told. Priests and conjurors are of the same trade.

As for the dubious jargon attributed to Paul in 1 Corinthians 15, some Christian sects include it in their burial service. It is as meaningless as a bell tolling at a funeral. It explains nothing to the mind and illustrates nothing for the imagination. It leaves readers to find a meaning if they can. “All flesh,” he says, “is not the same flesh. There is one flesh of humans, another of animals, another of fish, and another of birds.” And what then? Nothing. A cook could have said as much. “There are also,” he says, “heavenly bodies and earthly bodies. The glory of the heavenly is one kind, and the glory of the earthly is another.” And what then? Nothing. And what is the difference? He has told us nothing about it. “There is,” he says, “one glory of the sun, another glory of the moon, and another glory of the stars.” And what then? Nothing. He does say that one star differs from another in glory, rather than distance. He might as well have told us that the moon does not shine as brightly as the sun. All this is no better than the jargon of a conjuror. He picks up phrases he does not understand to confuse the gullible people who come to have their fortunes told. Priests and conjurors are in the same trade.

Sometimes Paul affects to be a naturalist, and to prove his system of resurrection from the principles of vegetation. “Thou fool” says he, “that which thou sowest is not quickened except it die.” To which one might reply in his own language, and say, Thou fool, Paul, that which thou sowest is not quickened except it die not; for the grain that dies in the ground never does, nor can vegetate. It is only the living grains that produce the next crop. But the metaphor, in any point of view, is no simile. It is succession, and [not] resurrection.

Sometimes Paul pretends to be a naturalist and tries to prove his theory of resurrection through the principles of plant growth. “You fool,” he says, “what you sow does not come to life unless it dies.” One might reply in his own language: You fool, Paul, what you sow does not come to life unless it stays alive. Grain that dies in the ground never sprouts and cannot sprout. Only living grains produce the next crop. But the metaphor is not a valid comparison, however you look at it. It is succession, not resurrection.

The progress of an animal from one state of being to another, as from a worm to a butterfly, applies to the case; but this of a grain does not, and shows Paul to have been what he says of others, a fool.

An animal's change from one state of being to another, such as from a worm to a butterfly, fits the case. But the example of a grain does not. It shows that Paul was what he calls others: a fool.

Whether the fourteen epistles ascribed to Paul were written by him or not, is a matter of indifference; they are either argumentative or dogmatical; and as the argument is defective, and the dogmatical part is merely presumptive, it signifies not who wrote them. And the same may be said for the remaining parts of the Testament. It is not upon the Epistles, but upon what is called the Gospel, contained in the four books ascribed to Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, and upon the pretended prophecies, that the theory of the church, calling itself the Christian Church, is founded. The Epistles are dependant upon those, and must follow their fate; for if the story of Jesus Christ be fabulous, all reasoning founded upon it, as a supposed truth, must fall with it.

It makes no difference whether Paul wrote the fourteen letters attributed to him. They either present arguments or state doctrines. The arguments are flawed, and the doctrines are merely assumed to be true. So it does not matter who wrote them. The same may be said of the remaining parts of the Testament. The theory of the church that calls itself the Christian Church is not based on the letters. It is based on what is called the Gospel, contained in the four books attributed to Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, and on the supposed prophecies. The letters depend on the Gospel and the prophecies, and must share their fate. For if the story of Jesus Christ is a fable, all reasoning based on its supposed truth must fall with it.

We know from history, that one of the principal leaders of this church, Athanasius, lived at the time the New Testament was formed; [Athanasius died, according to the Church chronology, in the year 371—Author.] and we know also, from the absurd jargon he has left us under the name of a creed, the character of the men who formed the New Testament; and we know also from the same history that the authenticity of the books of which it is composed was denied at the time. It was upon the vote of such as Athanasius that the Testament was decreed to be the word of God; and nothing can present to us a more strange idea than that of decreeing the word of God by vote. Those who rest their faith upon such authority put man in the place of God, and have no true foundation for future happiness. Credulity, however, is not a crime, but it becomes criminal by resisting conviction. It is strangling in the womb of the conscience the efforts it makes to ascertain truth. We should never force belief upon ourselves in any thing.

History tells us that Athanasius, one of the principal leaders of this church, lived when the New Testament was formed. [According to Church chronology, Athanasius died in 371. Author.] The absurd jargon he left us under the name of a creed shows us the character of the men who formed the New Testament. History also tells us that the authenticity of its books was denied at the time. It was by the votes of men like Athanasius that the New Testament was declared the word of God. Nothing could be stranger than declaring the word of God by a vote. Those who base their faith on such authority put man in the place of God. They have no true foundation for future happiness. Credulity, however, is not a crime, but it becomes criminal when it resists being convinced of the truth. It strangles the conscience’s efforts to find the truth before they can be born. We should never force ourselves to believe anything.

I here close the subject on the Old Testament and the New. The evidence I have produced to prove them forgeries, is extracted from the books themselves, and acts, like a two-edge sword, either way. If the evidence be denied, the authenticity of the Scriptures is denied with it, for it is Scripture evidence: and if the evidence be admitted, the authenticity of the books is disproved. The contradictory impossibilities, contained in the Old Testament and the New, put them in the case of a man who swears for and against. Either evidence convicts him of perjury, and equally destroys reputation.

I end my discussion of the Old Testament and the New Testament here. The evidence I have presented to prove they are forgeries comes from the books themselves. It cuts both ways, like a two-edged sword. If the evidence is rejected, the authenticity of the Scriptures is rejected with it, because the evidence comes from Scripture. If the evidence is accepted, it disproves the authenticity of the books. The contradictions and impossibilities in the Old Testament and the New Testament put them in the position of a man who swears both for and against the same thing. Either statement convicts him of perjury and destroys his reputation just as surely.

Should the Bible and the Testament hereafter fall, it is not that I have done it. I have done no more than extracted the evidence from the confused mass of matters with which it is mixed, and arranged that evidence in a point of light to be clearly seen and easily comprehended; and, having done this, I leave the reader to judge for himself, as I have judged for myself.

If the Bible and the Testament eventually fall, it will not be because of me. I have only extracted the evidence from the confused mass of material mixed in with it. I have presented the evidence clearly so that it can be easily understood. Having done this, I leave the reader to judge for himself, as I have judged for myself.