Part 1, Chapter 12

Christianity's Effects on Education: Proposed Reforms

10 min

As the Christian system of faith has made a revolution in theology, so also has it made a revolution in the state of learning. That which is now called learning, was not learning originally. Learning does not consist, as the schools now make it consist, in the knowledge of languages, but in the knowledge of things to which language gives names.

Just as the Christian system of faith revolutionized theology, it also revolutionized learning. What we now call learning was not originally considered learning. Schools now treat learning as knowledge of languages. But learning is knowledge of the things that language gives names to.

The Greeks were a learned people, but learning with them did not consist in speaking Greek, any more than in a Roman’s speaking Latin, or a Frenchman’s speaking French, or an Englishman’s speaking English. From what we know of the Greeks, it does not appear that they knew or studied any language but their own, and this was one cause of their becoming so learned; it afforded them more time to apply themselves to better studies. The schools of the Greeks were schools of science and philosophy, and not of languages; and it is in the knowledge of the things that science and philosophy teach that learning consists.

The Greeks were a learned people. But being learned did not mean speaking Greek. It meant that no more than speaking Latin made a Roman learned, or speaking French made a Frenchman learned, or speaking English made an Englishman learned. From what we know, the Greeks do not appear to have known or studied any language but their own. This was one reason they became so learned. It gave them more time to devote to better studies. Greek schools taught science and philosophy, not languages. And being learned means knowing what science and philosophy teach.

Almost all the scientific learning that now exists, came to us from the Greeks, or the people who spoke the Greek language. It therefore became necessary to the people of other nations, who spoke a different language, that some among them should learn the Greek language, in order that the learning the Greeks had might be made known in those nations, by translating the Greek books of science and philosophy into the mother tongue of each nation.

Almost all the scientific knowledge that exists today came from the Greeks or people who spoke Greek. Other nations spoke different languages, so some of their people had to learn Greek. They could then translate Greek books on science and philosophy into their own languages, making Greek learning known in their nations.

The study, therefore, of the Greek language (and in the same manner for the Latin) was no other than the drudgery business of a linguist; and the language thus obtained, was no other than the means, or as it were the tools, employed to obtain the learning the Greeks had. It made no part of the learning itself; and was so distinct from it as to make it exceedingly probable that the persons who had studied Greek sufficiently to translate those works, such for instance as Euclid’s Elements, did not understand any of the learning the works contained.

Studying Greek, therefore, was nothing more than the tedious work of a linguist. The same was true of Latin. The language learned was merely a means, or a set of tools, for gaining access to Greek learning. It was no part of that learning itself. In fact, language was so separate from learning that translators very likely did not understand the knowledge in the works they translated. This was probably true even of those who knew enough Greek to translate works such as Euclid’s Elements.

As there is now nothing new to be learned from the dead languages, all the useful books being already translated, the languages are become useless, and the time expended in teaching and in learning them is wasted. So far as the study of languages may contribute to the progress and communication of knowledge (for it has nothing to do with the creation of knowledge) it is only in the living languages that new knowledge is to be found; and certain it is, that, in general, a youth will learn more of a living language in one year, than of a dead language in seven; and it is but seldom that the teacher knows much of it himself. The difficulty of learning the dead languages does not arise from any superior abstruseness in the languages themselves, but in their being dead, and the pronunciation entirely lost. It would be the same thing with any other language when it becomes dead. The best Greek linguist that now exists does not understand Greek so well as a Grecian plowman did, or a Grecian milkmaid; and the same for the Latin, compared with a plowman or a milkmaid of the Romans; and with respect to pronunciation and idiom, not so well as the cows that she milked. It would therefore be advantageous to the state of learning to abolish the study of the dead languages, and to make learning consist, as it originally did, in scientific knowledge.

There is now nothing new to learn from dead languages, since all the useful books have already been translated. These languages have become useless, and the time spent teaching and learning them is wasted. Studying languages may help spread knowledge and advance it, though it has nothing to do with creating knowledge. But new knowledge is found only in living languages. And certainly, a young person will generally learn more of a living language in one year than of a dead language in seven. Even the teacher seldom knows much of the dead language. Dead languages are hard to learn not because they are more complicated, but because they are dead and their pronunciation is entirely lost. The same would be true of any other language once it dies. The best Greek scholar alive today does not understand Greek as well as a Greek plowman or milkmaid did. The same is true of Latin, compared with a Roman plowman or milkmaid. As for pronunciation and idiom, the scholar does not understand the language as well as the cows the milkmaid milked did. Learning would therefore benefit if we abolished the study of dead languages and made learning consist of scientific knowledge, as it originally did.

The apology that is sometimes made for continuing to teach the dead languages is, that they are taught at a time when a child is not capable of exerting any other mental faculty than that of memory. But this is altogether erroneous. The human mind has a natural disposition to scientific knowledge, and to the things connected with it. The first and favourite amusement of a child, even before it begins to play, is that of imitating the works of man. It builds houses with cards or sticks; it navigates the little ocean of a bowl of water with a paper boat; or dams the stream of a gutter, and contrives something which it calls a mill; and it interests itself in the fate of its works with a care that resembles affection. It afterwards goes to school, where its genius is killed by the barren study of a dead language, and the philosopher is lost in the linguist.

One excuse for continuing to teach dead languages concerns when children learn them. They are taught when a child is supposedly capable of using only memory. But this is completely wrong. The human mind has a natural inclination toward scientific knowledge and related subjects. Even before a child begins to play, its first and favorite amusement is imitating things people make. It builds houses with cards or sticks. It sails a paper boat across the little ocean of a bowl of water. Or it dams the stream in a gutter and makes something it calls a mill. It cares about what happens to its creations with a concern that resembles affection. Later, it goes to school, where its genius is killed by the barren study of a dead language. The philosopher is lost in the linguist.

But the apology that is now made for continuing to teach the dead languages, could not be the cause at first of cutting down learning to the narrow and humble sphere of linguistry; the cause therefore must be sought for elsewhere. In all researches of this kind, the best evidence that can be produced, is the internal evidence the thing carries with itself, and the evidence of circumstances that unites with it; both of which, in this case, are not difficult to be discovered.

But the justification now offered for continuing to teach dead languages cannot explain why learning was first reduced to the narrow, humble study of language. The cause must therefore be found elsewhere. In all inquiries of this kind, the best evidence comes from the subject itself and from the circumstances surrounding it. In this case, neither kind of evidence is hard to find.

Putting then aside, as matter of distinct consideration, the outrage offered to the moral justice of God, by supposing him to make the innocent suffer for the guilty, and also the loose morality and low contrivance of supposing him to change himself into the shape of a man, in order to make an excuse to himself for not executing his supposed sentence upon Adam; putting, I say, those things aside as matter of distinct consideration, it is certain that what is called the christian system of faith, including in it the whimsical account of the creation—the strange story of Eve, the snake, and the apple—the amphibious idea of a man-god—the corporeal idea of the death of a god—the mythological idea of a family of gods, and the christian system of arithmetic, that three are one, and one is three, are all irreconcilable, not only to the divine gift of reason, that God has given to man, but to the knowledge that man gains of the power and wisdom of God by the aid of the sciences, and by studying the structure of the universe that God has made.

First, set aside the affront to God's moral justice in assuming that he makes the innocent suffer for the guilty. Also set aside the loose morality and cheap trick of supposing that God changed himself into a man. Supposedly, he did this to give himself an excuse not to carry out his supposed sentence on Adam. I set these matters aside for separate consideration. Even so, the Christian system of faith includes the fanciful account of creation and the strange story of Eve, the snake, and the apple. It includes the mixed nature of a man-god, the physical death of a god, and the mythological idea of a family of gods. It also includes Christian arithmetic, in which three are one and one is three. All these things are certainly irreconcilable with the divine gift of reason that God has given humanity. They are also irreconcilable with the knowledge people gain of God's power and wisdom through science and by studying the structure of the universe he made.

The setters up, therefore, and the advocates of the Christian system of faith, could not but foresee that the continually progressive knowledge that man would gain by the aid of science, of the power and wisdom of God, manifested in the structure of the universe, and in all the works of creation, would militate against, and call into question, the truth of their system of faith; and therefore it became necessary to their purpose to cut learning down to a size less dangerous to their project, and this they effected by restricting the idea of learning to the dead study of dead languages.

The founders and defenders of the Christian system of faith could not help but foresee a problem. Science would continually increase human knowledge of God's power and wisdom, revealed in the structure of the universe and all the works of creation. That knowledge would work against their system of faith and call its truth into question. So, to serve their purpose, they had to reduce learning to something less dangerous to their project. They did this by limiting the idea of learning to the dead study of dead languages.

They not only rejected the study of science out of the christian schools, but they persecuted it; and it is only within about the last two centuries that the study has been revived. So late as 1610, Galileo, a Florentine, discovered and introduced the use of telescopes, and by applying them to observe the motions and appearances of the heavenly bodies, afforded additional means for ascertaining the true structure of the universe. Instead of being esteemed for these discoveries, he was sentenced to renounce them, or the opinions resulting from them, as a damnable heresy. And prior to that time Virgilius was condemned to be burned for asserting the antipodes, or in other words, that the earth was a globe, and habitable in every part where there was land; yet the truth of this is now too well known even to be told. [NOTE: I cannot discover the source of this statement concerning the ancient author whose Irish name Feirghill was Latinized into Virgilius. The British Museum possesses a copy of the work (Decalogiunt) which was the pretext of the charge of heresy made by Boniface, Archbishop of Mayence, against Virgilius, Abbot—bishop of Salzburg, These were leaders of the rival “British” and “Roman parties, and the British champion made a countercharge against Boniface of irreligious practices.” Boniface had to express a “regret,” but none the less pursued his rival. The Pope, Zachary II., decided that if his alleged “doctrine, against God and his soul, that beneath the earth there is another world, other men, or sun and moon,” should be acknowledged by Virgilius, he should be excommunicated by a Council and condemned with canonical sanctions. Whatever may have been the fate involved by condemnation with “canonicis sanctionibus,” in the middle of the eighth century, it did not fall on Virgilius. His accuser, Boniface, was martyred, 755, and it is probable that Virgilius harmonied his Antipodes with orthodoxy. The gravamen of the heresy seems to have been the suggestion that there were men not of the progeny of Adam. Virgilius was made Bishop of Salzburg in 768. He bore until his death, 789, the curious title, “Geometer and Solitary,” or “lone wayfarer” (Solivagus). A suspicion of heresy clung to his memory until 1233, when he was raised by Gregory IX, to sainthood beside his accuser, St. Boniface.—Editor. (Conway)]

They not only excluded the study of science from Christian schools, but persecuted it. The study of science has been revived only within about the last two centuries. As recently as 1610, Galileo, a Florentine, discovered telescopes and introduced their use. He used them to observe the movements and appearances of the heavenly bodies. This provided another way to establish the true structure of the universe. Instead of being honored for these discoveries, he was sentenced to renounce them, or the opinions that followed from them, as a damnable heresy. Before that, Virgilius was condemned to be burned for asserting the existence of the antipodes. In other words, he said that the earth was a globe and that every part with land was habitable. Yet this truth is now too well known even to be worth stating. [NOTE: I cannot find the source of this statement about the ancient author whose Irish name, Feirghill, was Latinized as Virgilius. The British Museum has a copy of the work (Decalogiunt) used as the pretext for the charge of heresy against him. Boniface, Archbishop of Mayence, made the charge against Virgilius, Abbot and Bishop of Salzburg. They were leaders of the rival “British” and “Roman” parties. The British champion made a countercharge against Boniface for irreligious practices. Boniface had to express “regret,” but he continued to pursue his rival. Pope Zachary II. made a decision about the alleged “doctrine, against God and his soul, that beneath the earth there is another world, other men, or sun and moon.” If Virgilius admitted to this doctrine, he was to be excommunicated by a Council and condemned with canonical sanctions. Whatever fate condemnation with “canonicis sanctionibus” may have involved in the middle of the eighth century, it did not fall on Virgilius. His accuser, Boniface, was martyred in 755. Virgilius probably reconciled his Antipodes with orthodox belief. The main point of the alleged heresy seems to have been the suggestion that some people were not descended from Adam. Virgilius was made Bishop of Salzburg in 768. Until his death in 789, he bore the curious title “Geometer and Solitary,” or “lone wayfarer” (Solivagus). A suspicion of heresy clung to his memory until 1233. Then Gregory IX raised him to sainthood alongside his accuser, St. Boniface. Editor. (Conway)]

If the belief of errors not morally bad did no mischief, it would make no part of the moral duty of man to oppose and remove them. There was no moral ill in believing the earth was flat like a trencher, any more than there was moral virtue in believing it was round like a globe; neither was there any moral ill in believing that the Creator made no other world than this, any more than there was moral virtue in believing that he made millions, and that the infinity of space is filled with worlds. But when a system of religion is made to grow out of a supposed system of creation that is not true, and to unite itself therewith in a manner almost inseparable therefrom, the case assumes an entirely different ground. It is then that errors, not morally bad, become fraught with the same mischiefs as if they were. It is then that the truth, though otherwise indifferent itself, becomes an essential, by becoming the criterion that either confirms by corresponding evidence, or denies by contradictory evidence, the reality of the religion itself. In this view of the case it is the moral duty of man to obtain every possible evidence that the structure of the heavens, or any other part of creation affords, with respect to systems of religion. But this, the supporters or partizans of the christian system, as if dreading the result, incessantly opposed, and not only rejected the sciences, but persecuted the professors. Had Newton or Descartes lived three or four hundred years ago, and pursued their studies as they did, it is most probable they would not have lived to finish them; and had Franklin drawn lightning from the clouds at the same time, it would have been at the hazard of expiring for it in flames.

If believing harmless errors did no harm, people would have no moral duty to oppose and correct them. There was nothing morally wrong in believing that the earth was flat like a platter. Nor was there any moral virtue in believing that it was round like a globe. Likewise, there was nothing morally wrong in believing that the Creator made no world but this one. Nor was there any moral virtue in believing that he made millions of worlds filling infinite space. But the matter is entirely different when a religion grows out of a false account of creation. The religion may become so closely linked to that account that the two are almost inseparable. Then errors that are not morally wrong can do as much harm as if they were. The truth, though otherwise of no moral importance in itself, then becomes essential. It becomes the test of the religion’s reality. Supporting evidence confirms the religion, while contradictory evidence denies it. Seen in this way, people have a moral duty to gather every possible piece of evidence about religious systems. They must seek it from the structure of the heavens and every other part of creation. But the supporters or partisans of the Christian system constantly opposed this search, as if they feared the result. They not only rejected the sciences but persecuted those who practiced them. If Newton or Descartes had lived three or four hundred years ago and pursued their studies as they did, they most likely would not have lived to finish them. And if Franklin had drawn lightning from the clouds at that time, he would have risked being burned to death for it.

Later times have laid all the blame upon the Goths and Vandals, but, however unwilling the partizans of the Christian system may be to believe or to acknowledge it, it is nevertheless true, that the age of ignorance commenced with the Christian system. There was more knowledge in the world before that period, than for many centuries afterwards; and as to religious knowledge, the Christian system, as already said, was only another species of mythology; and the mythology to which it succeeded, was a corruption of an ancient system of theism. [NOTE by Paine: It is impossible for us now to know at what time the heathen mythology began; but it is certain, from the internal evidence that it carries, that it did not begin in the same state or condition in which it ended. All the gods of that mythology, except Saturn, were of modern invention. The supposed reign of Saturn was prior to that which is called the heathen mythology, and was so far a species of theism that it admitted the belief of only one God. Saturn is supposed to have abdicated the govemment in favour of his three sons and one daughter, Jupiter, Pluto, Neptune, and Juno; after this, thousands of other gods and demigods were imaginarily created, and the calendar of gods increased as fast as the calendar of saints and the calendar of courts have increased since.

Later generations have placed all the blame on the Goths and Vandals. But the age of ignorance began with the Christian system. That is true, however unwilling supporters of the Christian system may be to believe or acknowledge it. There was more knowledge in the world before Christianity began than there was for many centuries afterward. As for religious knowledge, the Christian system was only another kind of mythology, as I have already said. The mythology it replaced was itself a corruption of an ancient system of theism. [NOTE by Paine: We cannot now know when ancient non-Christian mythology began. But its own internal evidence makes one thing certain. It did not begin in the same form in which it ended. Except for Saturn, all the gods of that mythology were invented later. Saturn’s supposed reign came before what is called ancient non-Christian mythology. It was a kind of theism in that it allowed belief in only one God. Saturn is supposed to have given up his rule to his three sons and one daughter: Jupiter, Pluto, Neptune, and Juno. After this, people imagined thousands of other gods and demigods. The calendar of gods grew as fast as the calendars of saints and courts have grown since.

All the corruptions that have taken place, in theology and in religion have been produced by admitting of what man calls ‘revealed religion.’ The mythologists pretended to more revealed religion than the christians do. They had their oracles and their priests, who were supposed to receive and deliver the word of God verbally on almost all occasions.

All corruption in theology and religion has come from accepting what people call ‘revealed religion.’ The mythologists claimed to have received more revelation than Christians do. They had their oracles and priests. These were supposed to receive and speak the word of God on almost every occasion.

Since then all corruptions down from Moloch to modern predestinarianism, and the human sacrifices of the heathens to the christian sacrifice of the Creator, have been produced by admitting of what is called revealed religion, the most effectual means to prevent all such evils and impositions is, not to admit of any other revelation than that which is manifested in the book of Creation., and to contemplate the Creation as the only true and real word of God that ever did or ever will exist; and every thing else called the word of God is fable and imposition.—Author.]

All corruptions, from Moloch to modern predestinarianism, have arisen from accepting what is called revealed religion. So have all corruptions from pagan human sacrifices to the Christian sacrifice of the Creator. The best way to prevent all such evils and deceptions is to accept no revelation except what appears in the book of Creation. We should regard Creation as the only true and real word of God that ever has existed or ever will exist. Everything else called the word of God is fable and deception. Author.]

It is owing to this long interregnum of science, and to no other cause, that we have now to look back through a vast chasm of many hundred years to the respectable characters we call the Ancients. Had the progression of knowledge gone on proportionably with the stock that before existed, that chasm would have been filled up with characters rising superior in knowledge to each other; and those Ancients we now so much admire would have appeared respectably in the background of the scene. But the christian system laid all waste; and if we take our stand about the beginning of the sixteenth century, we look back through that long chasm, to the times of the Ancients, as over a vast sandy desert, in which not a shrub appears to intercept the vision to the fertile hills beyond.

This long interruption in the progress of science is the only reason we must now look back across a gap of many hundreds of years to the respected figures we call the Ancients. Suppose knowledge had continued to advance in proportion to what was already known. Then that gap would have been filled with figures, each surpassing the last in knowledge. The Ancients we now admire so much would have appeared respectfully in the background. But the Christian system laid everything to waste. If we stand at the beginning of the sixteenth century, we look back across that long gap to the times of the Ancients. It is like looking across a vast sandy desert, where not a single shrub blocks our view of the fertile hills beyond.

It is an inconsistency scarcely possible to be credited, that any thing should exist, under the name of a religion, that held it to be irreligious to study and contemplate the structure of the universe that God had made. But the fact is too well established to be denied. The event that served more than any other to break the first link in this long chain of despotic ignorance, is that known by the name of the Reformation by Luther. From that time, though it does not appear to have made any part of the intention of Luther, or of those who are called Reformers, the Sciences began to revive, and Liberality, their natural associate, began to appear. This was the only public good the Reformation did; for, with respect to religious good, it might as well not have taken place. The mythology still continued the same; and a multiplicity of National Popes grew out of the downfall of the Pope of Christendom.

It is almost unbelievable that anything called a religion would regard studying and contemplating the universe God made as irreligious. But the fact is too well established to deny. The event that did most to break the first link in this long chain of oppressive ignorance was Luther's Reformation. From then on, the sciences began to revive, and open-mindedness, their natural companion, began to appear. Yet neither Luther nor those called Reformers seem to have intended this. It was the only public good the Reformation did. As for religious good, the Reformation might as well never have happened. The mythology remained the same, and the fall of the Pope of Christendom gave rise to many national popes.