Part 1, Chapter 13
Christianity Compared with Nature-Inspired Religious Ideas
Having thus shewn, from the internal evidence of things, the cause that produced a change in the state of learning, and the motive for substituting the study of the dead languages, in the place of the Sciences, I proceed, in addition to the several observations already made in the former part of this work, to compare, or rather to confront, the evidence that the structure of the universe affords, with the christian system of religion. But as I cannot begin this part better than by referring to the ideas that occurred to me at an early part of life, and which I doubt not have occurred in some degree to almost every other person at one time or other, I shall state what those ideas were, and add thereto such other matter as shall arise out of the subject, giving to the whole, by way of preface, a short introduction.
I have shown, from the evidence within the subject itself, what caused learning to change. I have also shown the motive for replacing the study of science with the study of dead languages. Now, adding to my earlier observations in this work, I will compare the evidence offered by the structure of the universe with the Christian system of religion. I will, in fact, set them against each other. But I can best begin with ideas that occurred to me early in life. I have no doubt that similar ideas have occurred to almost everyone at one time or another. I will state those ideas and add whatever else arises from the subject. First, I will offer a short introduction as a preface to the whole.
My father being of the quaker profession, it was my good fortune to have an exceedingly good moral education, and a tolerable stock of useful learning. Though I went to the grammar school, I did not learn Latin, not only because I had no inclination to learn languages, but because of the objection the quakers have against the books in which the language is taught. But this did not prevent me from being acquainted with the subjects of all the Latin books used in the school.
My father was a Quaker, and I was fortunate to receive an excellent moral education and a fair amount of useful learning. Although I attended grammar school, I did not learn Latin. I had no interest in learning languages, and Quakers objected to the books used to teach Latin. But this did not prevent me from knowing the subjects of all the Latin books used at school.
The natural bent of my mind was to science. I had some turn, and I believe some talent for poetry; but this I rather repressed than encouraged, as leading too much into the field of imagination. As soon as I was able, I purchased a pair of globes, and attended the philosophical lectures of Martin and Ferguson, and became afterwards acquainted with Dr. Bevis, of the society called the Royal Society, then living in the Temple, and an excellent astronomer.
My mind was naturally drawn to science. I had some inclination toward poetry and, I believe, some talent for it. But I held back rather than encouraging it, because it drew me too far into imagination. As soon as I could, I bought a pair of globes and attended Martin and Ferguson’s lectures on natural philosophy. Later, I met Dr. Bevis, an excellent astronomer and a member of the Royal Society. He was then living in the Temple.
I had no disposition for what was called politics. It presented to my mind no other idea than is contained in the word jockeyship. When, therefore, I turned my thoughts towards matters of government, I had to form a system for myself, that accorded with the moral and philosophic principles in which I had been educated. I saw, or at least I thought I saw, a vast scene opening itself to the world in the affairs of America; and it appeared to me, that unless the Americans changed the plan they were then pursuing, with respect to the government of England, and declared themselves independent, they would not only involve themselves in a multiplicity of new difficulties, but shut out the prospect that was then offering itself to mankind through their means. It was from these motives that I published the work known by the name of Common Sense, which is the first work I ever did publish, and so far as I can judge of myself, I believe I should never have been known in the world as an author on any subject whatever, had it not been for the affairs of America. I wrote Common Sense the latter end of the year 1775, and published it the first of January, 1776. Independence was declared the fourth of July following. [NOTE: The pamphlet Common Sense was first advertised, as “just published,” on January 10, 1776. His plea for the Officers of Excise, written before leaving England, was printed, but not published until 1793. Despite his reiterated assertion that Common Sense was the first work he ever published the notion that he was “junius” still finds some believers. An indirect comment on our Paine-Junians may be found in Part 2 of this work where Paine says a man capable of writing Homer “would not have thrown away his own fame by giving it to another.” It is probable that Paine ascribed the Letters of Junius to Thomas Hollis. His friend F. Lanthenas, in his translation of the Age of Reason (1794) advertises his translation of the Letters of Junius from the English “(Thomas Hollis).” This he could hardly have done without consultation with Paine. Unfortunately this translation of Junius cannot be found either in the Bibliotheque Nationale or the British Museum, and it cannot be said whether it contains any attempt at an identification of Junius—Editor.]
I had no interest in what was called politics. To me, the word suggested nothing but maneuvering for advantage. So when I began thinking about government, I had to develop a system of my own. It had to accord with the moral and philosophical principles I had been taught. I saw, or at least thought I saw, a vast opportunity opening up to the world through America’s affairs. But the Americans were pursuing a course with the English government that they needed to change. Unless they declared independence, they would not only bring many new difficulties on themselves. They would also shut out the opportunity they were offering to humanity. These were my reasons for publishing the work known as Common Sense, the first work I ever published. As far as I can judge, I believe I would never have become known as an author on any subject had it not been for America’s affairs. I wrote Common Sense toward the end of 1775 and published it on January 1, 1776. Independence was declared on July 4 of that year. [NOTE: The pamphlet Common Sense was first advertised as “just published” on January 10, 1776. His plea for the Officers of Excise was written before he left England. It was printed, but not published until 1793. Paine repeatedly said that Common Sense was the first work he ever published. Despite this, some still believe that he was “junius.” An indirect comment on our Paine-Junians may be found in Part 2 of this work. There, Paine says that a man capable of writing Homer “would not have thrown away his own fame by giving it to another.” Paine probably attributed the Letters of Junius to Thomas Hollis. His friend F. Lanthenas advertised his translation of the Letters of Junius from the English “(Thomas Hollis).” He did so in his 1794 translation of the Age of Reason. He could hardly have done this without consulting Paine. Unfortunately, this translation of Junius cannot be found in either the Bibliotheque Nationale or the British Museum. So we cannot say whether it contains any attempt to identify Junius. Editor.]
Any person, who has made observations on the state and progress of the human mind, by observing his own, can not but have observed, that there are two distinct classes of what are called Thoughts; those that we produce in ourselves by reflection and the act of thinking, and those that bolt into the mind of their own accord. I have always made it a rule to treat those voluntary visitors with civility, taking care to examine, as well as I was able, if they were worth entertaining; and it is from them I have acquired almost all the knowledge that I have. As to the learning that any person gains from school education, it serves only, like a small capital, to put him in the way of beginning learning for himself afterwards. Every person of learning is finally his own teacher; the reason of which is, that principles, being of a distinct quality to circumstances, cannot be impressed upon the memory; their place of mental residence is the understanding, and they are never so lasting as when they begin by conception. Thus much for the introductory part.
Anyone who has studied the state and progress of the human mind by observing their own must have noticed two distinct kinds of thoughts. We produce some through reflection and the act of thinking. Others come into the mind on their own. I have always made it a rule to treat these uninvited visitors politely. I take care to examine them as well as I can, to see whether they are worth considering. It is from them that I have gained almost all the knowledge I have. As for what a person learns at school, it serves only as a small sum of money might. It helps them begin learning for themselves afterward. Every educated person is ultimately their own teacher. That is because principles are different in nature from circumstances and cannot be fixed in the memory. They reside in the understanding, and they are never so lasting as when they begin as ideas we form for ourselves. That is all for the introduction.
From the time I was capable of conceiving an idea, and acting upon it by reflection, I either doubted the truth of the christian system, or thought it to be a strange affair; I scarcely knew which it was: but I well remember, when about seven or eight years of age, hearing a sermon read by a relation of mine, who was a great devotee of the church, upon the subject of what is called Redemption by the death of the Son of God. After the sermon was ended, I went into the garden, and as I was going down the garden steps (for I perfectly recollect the spot) I revolted at the recollection of what I had heard, and thought to myself that it was making God Almighty act like a passionate man, that killed his son, when he could not revenge himself any other way; and as I was sure a man would be hanged that did such a thing, I could not see for what purpose they preached such sermons. This was not one of those kind of thoughts that had any thing in it of childish levity; it was to me a serious reflection, arising from the idea I had that God was too good to do such an action, and also too almighty to be under any necessity of doing it. I believe in the same manner to this moment; and I moreover believe, that any system of religion that has anything in it that shocks the mind of a child, cannot be a true system.
From the time I could form an idea and think it through, I either doubted the truth of Christianity or thought it strange. I hardly knew which. But I clearly remember hearing a sermon when I was about seven or eight. A relative who was deeply devoted to the church read it aloud. The sermon was about what is called redemption through the death of the Son of God. After the sermon, I went into the garden. As I walked down the garden steps, I recoiled at the memory of what I had heard. I remember the spot perfectly. I thought the sermon made God Almighty act like an angry man. Such a man would kill his son because he could find no other way to take revenge. I was sure a man who did such a thing would be hanged. So I could not see why they preached such sermons. This was not a frivolous childhood thought. It was a serious reflection, arising from my belief that God was too good to do such a thing. I also believed he was too almighty to have any need to do it. I still believe the same thing today. I also believe that a religion cannot be true if anything in it shocks the mind of a child.
It seems as if parents of the christian profession were ashamed to tell their children any thing about the principles of their religion. They sometimes instruct them in morals, and talk to them of the goodness of what they call Providence; for the Christian mythology has five deities: there is God the Father, God the Son, God the Holy Ghost, the God Providence, and the Goddess Nature. But the christian story of God the Father putting his son to death, or employing people to do it, (for that is the plain language of the story,) cannot be told by a parent to a child; and to tell him that it was done to make mankind happier and better, is making the story still worse; as if mankind could be improved by the example of murder; and to tell him that all this is a mystery, is only making an excuse for the incredibility of it.
It seems that Christian parents are ashamed to tell their children anything about the principles of their religion. They sometimes teach them morals and talk about the goodness of what they call Providence. For Christian mythology has five deities: God the Father, God the Son, God the Holy Ghost, the God Providence, and the Goddess Nature. But a parent cannot tell a child the Christian story of God the Father putting his son to death, or hiring people to do it. That is the plain meaning of the story. To tell the child that this was done to make mankind happier and better makes the story even worse. It is as if mankind could be improved by the example of murder. And to tell the child that all this is a mystery merely excuses the story’s unbelievability.
How different is this to the pure and simple profession of Deism! The true deist has but one Deity; and his religion consists in contemplating the power, wisdom, and benignity of the Deity in his works, and in endeavouring to imitate him in every thing moral, scientifical, and mechanical.
How different this is from the pure and simple faith of Deism! The true deist believes in only one God. His religion consists of contemplating God's power, wisdom, and kindness in his works. It also consists of trying to imitate God in everything moral, scientific, and mechanical.
The religion that approaches the nearest of all others to true Deism, in the moral and benign part thereof, is that professed by the quakers: but they have contracted themselves too much by leaving the works of God out of their system. Though I reverence their philanthropy, I can not help smiling at the conceit, that if the taste of a quaker could have been consulted at the creation, what a silent and drab-colored creation it would have been! Not a flower would have blossomed its gaieties, nor a bird been permitted to sing.
Of all religions, the Quakers’ faith comes closest to true Deism in its moral and kindly aspects. But they have made their faith too narrow by leaving God’s works out of it. Though I respect their love of humanity, I cannot help smiling at the thought of consulting a Quaker’s taste at creation. If that had happened, what a silent, drab-colored creation it would have been! Not a flower would have bloomed in bright colors, nor a bird been allowed to sing.
Quitting these reflections, I proceed to other matters. After I had made myself master of the use of the globes, and of the orrery, [NOTE by Paine: As this book may fall into the bands of persons who do not know what an orrery is, it is for their information I add this note, as the name gives no idea of the uses of the thing. The orrery has its name from the person who invented it. It is a machinery of clock-work, representing the universe in miniature: and in which the revolution of the earth round itself and round the sun, the revolution of the moon round the earth, the revolution of the planets round the sun, their relative distances from the sun, as the center of the whole system, their relative distances from each other, and their different magnitudes, are represented as they really exist in what we call the heavens.—Author.] and conceived an idea of the infinity of space, and of the eternal divisibility of matter, and obtained, at least, a general knowledge of what was called natural philosophy, I began to compare, or, as I have before said, to confront, the internal evidence those things afford with the christian system of faith.
Leaving these reflections behind, I turn to other matters. I learned how to use globes and the orrery. [NOTE by Paine: This book may reach people who do not know what an orrery is. I add this note for them, since the name gives no idea of its uses. The orrery is named after its inventor. It is a clockwork machine that represents the universe in miniature. It shows the earth rotating on its axis and revolving around the sun, and the moon revolving around the earth. It also shows the planets revolving around the sun. It represents their relative distances from the sun, the center of the whole system, and from one another. It shows their different sizes, as they really are in what we call the heavens. Author.] I also formed an idea of the infinity of space and the endless divisibility of matter. I gained at least a general knowledge of what was called natural philosophy. Then I began to compare the evidence these things provide with the Christian system of faith. As I said before, I began to confront that system with this evidence.
Though it is not a direct article of the christian system that this world that we inhabit is the whole of the habitable creation, yet it is so worked up therewith, from what is called the Mosaic account of the creation, the story of Eve and the apple, and the counterpart of that story, the death of the Son of God, that to believe otherwise, that is, to believe that God created a plurality of worlds, at least as numerous as what we call stars, renders the christian system of faith at once little and ridiculous; and scatters it in the mind like feathers in the air. The two beliefs can not be held together in the same mind; and he who thinks that he believes both, has thought but little of either.
Christianity does not directly teach that the world we live in is the only inhabited world. Yet this belief is so woven into Christianity that believing otherwise makes the Christian system of faith seem small and ridiculous. It scatters that system in the mind like feathers in the air. This belief is woven into the Mosaic account of creation, the story of Eve and the apple, and that story’s counterpart, the death of the Son of God. To believe otherwise is to believe that God created many worlds, at least as numerous as what we call stars. The two beliefs cannot exist together in the same mind. Anyone who thinks they believe both has given little thought to either.
Though the belief of a plurality of worlds was familiar to the ancients, it is only within the last three centuries that the extent and dimensions of this globe that we inhabit have been ascertained. Several vessels, following the tract of the ocean, have sailed entirely round the world, as a man may march in a circle, and come round by the contrary side of the circle to the spot he set out from. The circular dimensions of our world, in the widest part, as a man would measure the widest round of an apple, or a ball, is only twenty-five thousand and twenty English miles, reckoning sixty-nine miles and an half to an equatorial degree, and may be sailed round in the space of about three years. [NOTE by Paine: Allowing a ship to sail, on an average, three miles in an hour, she would sail entirely round the world in less than one year, if she could sail in a direct circle, but she is obliged to follow the course of the ocean.—Author.]
Although the ancients were familiar with the belief that many worlds exist, we have learned the size and extent of our own globe only in the last three centuries. Several ships have sailed all the way around the world, following the ocean’s path. They returned to their starting point from the opposite direction, just as a person walking in a circle might. Around its widest part, our world measures only 25,020 English miles. This is like measuring around the widest part of an apple or a ball. The measurement is based on 69½ miles per degree at the equator. A ship can sail around the world in about three years. [NOTE by Paine: Suppose a ship sails at an average speed of three miles an hour. It would sail around the world in less than a year if it could follow a direct circle. But it must follow the course of the ocean. Author.]
A world of this extent may, at first thought, appear to us to be great; but if we compare it with the immensity of space in which it is suspended, like a bubble or a balloon in the air, it is infinitely less in proportion than the smallest grain of sand is to the size of the world, or the finest particle of dew to the whole ocean, and is therefore but small; and, as will be hereafter shown, is only one of a system of worlds, of which the universal creation is composed.
A world this size may seem large at first. But consider the immense space in which it hangs, like a bubble or a balloon in the air. Compared with that space, the world is infinitely smaller than the smallest grain of sand is compared with the world, or the finest drop of dew with the whole ocean. So the world is small. And, as I will show later, it is only one of a system of worlds that make up the universe.
It is not difficult to gain some faint idea of the immensity of space in which this and all the other worlds are suspended, if we follow a progression of ideas. When we think of the size or dimensions of, a room, our ideas limit themselves to the walls, and there they stop. But when our eye, or our imagination darts into space, that is, when it looks upward into what we call the open air, we cannot conceive any walls or boundaries it can have; and if for the sake of resting our ideas we suppose a boundary, the question immediately renews itself, and asks, what is beyond that boundary? and in the same manner, what beyond the next boundary? and so on till the fatigued imagination returns and says, there is no end. Certainly, then, the Creator was not pent for room when he made this world no larger than it is; and we have to seek the reason in something else.
It is not difficult to get a faint idea of the vastness of space, where this and all other worlds hang. We can do so by following a chain of thoughts. When we think of the size of a room, our thoughts reach the walls and stop there. But when our eyes or imagination dart into space, looking up into what we call the open air, we cannot imagine any walls or boundaries. If we suppose there is a boundary to give our thoughts a place to rest, the question immediately returns: What is beyond that boundary? And what is beyond the next one? This continues until our tired imagination returns and says there is no end. Surely, then, the Creator did not lack room when he made this world no larger than it is. We must look elsewhere for the reason.
If we take a survey of our own world, or rather of this, of which the Creator has given us the use as our portion in the immense system of creation, we find every part of it, the earth, the waters, and the air that surround it, filled, and as it were crowded with life, down from the largest animals that we know of to the smallest insects the naked eye can behold, and from thence to others still smaller, and totally invisible without the assistance of the microscope. Every tree, every plant, every leaf, serves not only as an habitation, but as a world to some numerous race, till animal existence becomes so exceedingly refined, that the effluvia of a blade of grass would be food for thousands.
If we look at our world, we find life filling every part of it. More precisely, this world is our share of the immense system of creation, which the Creator has given us to use. The earth, its waters, and the air around it are all crowded with life. It ranges from the largest animals we know to the smallest insects visible to the naked eye. There are even smaller creatures that are completely invisible without a microscope. Every tree, plant, and leaf serves not only as a home but as a world for some numerous species. Living things become so incredibly tiny that the substances given off by a blade of grass would feed thousands.
Since then no part of our earth is left unoccupied, why is it to be supposed that the immensity of space is a naked void, lying in eternal waste? There is room for millions of worlds as large or larger than ours, and each of them millions of miles apart from each other.
Since no part of our earth is unoccupied, why suppose that vast space is empty and forever wasted? There is room for millions of worlds as large as ours or larger. Each could be millions of miles apart from the others.
Having now arrived at this point, if we carry our ideas only one thought further, we shall see, perhaps, the true reason, at least a very good reason for our happiness, why the Creator, instead of making one immense world, extending over an immense quantity of space, has preferred dividing that quantity of matter into several distinct and separate worlds, which we call planets, of which our earth is one. But before I explain my ideas upon this subject, it is necessary (not for the sake of those that already know, but for those who do not) to show what the system of the universe is.
Now that we have reached this point, let us take our thinking one step further. Perhaps we will see the true reason, or at least a very good reason for our happiness. The Creator chose to divide that amount of matter into several separate worlds, rather than make one immense world spread across an immense space. We call these worlds planets, and our earth is one of them. But before I explain my ideas on this subject, I must describe the system of the universe. This is necessary not for those who already know it, but for those who do not.