Aphorisms: Book 2 on Understanding Nature, or Human Rule

3h 28m

I

1

To generate and superinduce a new nature or new natures, upon a given body, is the labor and aim of human power: while to discover the form or true difference of a given nature, or the nature to which such nature is owing, or source from which it emanates (for these terms approach nearest to an explanation of our meaning), is the labor and discovery of human knowledge; and subordinate to these primary labors are two others of a secondary nature and inferior stamp. Under the first must be ranked the transformation of concrete bodies from one to another, which is possible within certain limits; under the second, the discovery, in every species of generation and motion, of the latent and uninterrupted process from the manifest efficient and manifest subject matter up to the given form: and a like discovery of the latent conformation of bodies which are at rest instead of being in motion.

The work and aim of human power is to produce and add a new nature or new natures to a given body. The work and discovery of human knowledge is to find the form or true distinguishing feature of a given nature. It is also to discover the nature on which that nature depends, or the source from which it comes. These terms come closest to explaining what we mean. Two lesser, secondary tasks are subordinate to these primary ones. Under the first comes the transformation of concrete bodies from one kind into another. This is possible within certain limits. Under the second comes the discovery of the hidden, continuous process in every kind of generation and motion. This process runs from the visible cause and visible subject matter to the given form. The second task also includes discovering the hidden structure of bodies at rest rather than in motion.

Aristotle’s Τὸ τὶ ἦν εἶναι, or ἦν οὐσία. See lib. iii. Metap.

II

2

The unhappy state of man’s actual knowledge is manifested even by the common assertions of the vulgar. It is rightly laid down that true knowledge is that which is deduced from causes. The division of four causes also is not amiss: matter, form, the efficient, and end or final cause. Of these, however, the latter is so far from being beneficial, that it even corrupts the sciences, except in the intercourse of man with man. The discovery of form is considered desperate. As for the efficient cause and matter (according to the present system of inquiry and the received opinions concerning them, by which they are placed remote from, and without any latent process toward form), they are but desultory and superficial, and of scarcely any avail to real and active knowledge. Nor are we unmindful of our having pointed out and corrected above the error of the human mind, in assigning the first qualities of essence to forms. For although nothing exists in nature except individual bodies, exhibiting clear individual effects according to particular laws, yet in each branch of learning, that very law, its investigation, discovery, and development, are the foundation both of theory and practice. This law, therefore, and its parallel in each science, is what we understand by the term form, adopting that word because it has grown into common use, and is of familiar occurrence.

The unfortunate state of human knowledge is evident even in what ordinary people commonly say. It is rightly held that true knowledge comes from understanding causes. The division into four causes is also reasonable: matter, form, the efficient cause, and the end or final cause. Of these, the final cause is so far from being useful that it even corrupts the sciences, except in human affairs. The discovery of form is considered hopeless. As for the efficient cause and matter, current methods of inquiry and accepted opinions place them far from form. They also treat them as having no hidden process leading to form. Understood in this way, they are disconnected and superficial, and of little use for real and practical knowledge. We have not forgotten that we pointed out and corrected an error of the human mind above. That error was to assign the primary qualities of essence to forms. Nothing exists in nature except individual bodies, which produce distinct individual effects according to particular laws. Even so, in every branch of learning, the law itself is the foundation of both theory and practice. So too are its investigation, discovery, and development. This law, and its equivalent in each science, is what we mean by form. We use that word because it has become common and familiar.

These divisions come from Aristotle’s Metaphysics, where they are called: 1. ὓλη ἢ τὸ ὑποκείμενον. 2. τὸ τὶ ἦν εἶναι. 3. ὅθεν ἡ ἀρχὴ τῆς κινήσεως. 4. τὸ οὗ ἕνεκεν καὶ τὸ ἀγαθόν.

See and in the first book.

Bacon means that although only individual things exist in nature, some may share properties and be governed by the same laws. These shared qualities distinguish them from other individual things. They lead us to group them under one expression, sometimes a single term. Yet Bacon believes these classes are only concepts, not distinct substances. He is clearly attacking the Realists. They concluded that the essence uniting individuals in a class was the only real and unchanging thing in nature. They reasoned that this essence entered their ideas of individual substances as a distinct and essential property. It remained in the mind as the mold, type, or pattern of the class, while its individual forms were constantly being renewed and decaying. Ed.

Bacon’s definition is obscure. Our entire idea of a law of nature consists in an unvarying sequence between certain classes of phenomena. But this cannot be the full meaning Bacon gives to the term form. He uses it as interchangeable with the nature of any object. He also uses it as the natura naturans, or the general law or condition in any substance or quality. The substance or quality is the natura naturata. It is whatever its form is, or that particular combination of forces that gives a certain nature to the matter it affects. Thus, in the Newtonian sense, the form of whiteness would be the combination of the seven primitive rays of light that produces that color.

Two phrases associated with form give us further insight into its meaning: latens processus ad formam, et latens schematismus corporum. The latens schematismus means the internal texture, structure, or configuration of bodies. It is the result of the relative positions of all the parts of a body. The latens processus ad formam means the gradual sequence of movements among the molecules of bodies as they keep or change their shape.

We may therefore regard the form of any quality in a body as interchangeable with that quality. i.e., when the form exists, the quality is present, and vice versâ. In this sense, a thing’s form differs from its efficient cause only in being permanent. We apply the word cause to something that exists in a sequence of time.

The latens processus and latens schematismus are subordinate to form, as concrete examples of its essence. The former is the secret, invisible process by which change occurs. It involves the principle later called the law of continuity. For example, the sequence of events between applying the match and expelling the bullet is a latent process. We can now trace that process with some accuracy. The term also refers more directly to the process by which one form or condition of being is brought about in another. For example, when the surface of iron rusts, or water turns to steam, a change has occurred. This is a latent process from one form to another. Mechanics provides many examples of the first kind of latent process, and chemistry of the second.

The latens schematismus is the visible structure of bodies on which so many of their properties depend. When we investigate the constitution of crystals and the internal structure of plants, we are examining their latent schematism. Ed.

III

3

He who has learned the cause of a particular nature (such as whiteness or heat), in particular subjects only, has acquired but an imperfect knowledge: as he who can induce a certain effect upon particular substances only, among those which are susceptible of it, has acquired but an imperfect power. But he who has only learned the efficient and material cause (which causes are variable and mere vehicles conveying form to particular substances) may perhaps arrive at some new discoveries in matters of a similar nature, and prepared for the purpose, but does not stir the limits of things which are much more deeply rooted; while he who is acquainted with forms, comprehends the unity of nature in substances apparently most distinct from each other. He can disclose and bring forward, therefore (though it has never yet been done), things which neither the vicissitudes of nature, nor the industry of experiment, nor chance itself, would ever have brought about, and which would forever have escaped man’s thoughts; from the discovery of forms, therefore, results genuine theory and free practice.

Anyone who knows what causes a particular quality, such as whiteness or heat, only in particular things has imperfect knowledge. Likewise, anyone who can produce an effect only in particular substances capable of receiving it has imperfect power. But suppose someone knows only the efficient and material causes. These causes vary and are merely the means by which form is conveyed to particular substances. Such a person may perhaps make new discoveries in similar things prepared for that purpose. But they do not push back the limits of things that are much more deeply rooted. By contrast, someone who knows forms understands the unity of nature in substances that seem most different from one another. Such a person can therefore reveal and produce things that have never yet been produced. Neither changes in nature, nor diligent experiments, nor chance itself would ever have brought them about. They would have escaped human thought forever. The discovery of forms therefore leads to genuine theory and freedom in practice.

IV

4

Although there is a most intimate connection, and almost an identity between the ways of human power and human knowledge, yet, on account of the pernicious and inveterate habit of dwelling upon abstractions, it is by far the safest method to commence and build up the sciences from those foundations which bear a relation to the practical division, and to let them mark out and limit the theoretical. We must consider, therefore, what precepts, or what direction or guide, a person would most desire, in order to generate and superinduce any nature upon a given body: and this not in abstruse, but in the plainest language.

The paths to human power and human knowledge are intimately connected, and almost identical. Yet we have a harmful, deeply rooted habit of dwelling on abstractions. So the safest way to build the sciences is to begin with foundations related to their practical divisions. These should define and limit the divisions of theory. We must therefore ask what rules or guidance a person would most need to create and impose a particular nature on a given body. We must do this in the plainest language, not in obscure terms.

For instance, if a person should wish to superinduce the yellow color of gold upon silver, or an additional weight (observing always the laws of matter) or transparency on an opaque stone, or tenacity in glass, or vegetation on a substance which is not vegetable, we must (I say) consider what species of precept or guide this person would prefer. And, first, he will doubtless be anxious to be shown some method that will neither fail in effect, nor deceive him in the trial of it; secondly, he will be anxious that the prescribed method should not restrict him and tie him down to peculiar means, and certain particular methods of acting; for he will, perhaps, be at loss, and without the power or opportunity of collecting and procuring such means. Now if there be other means and methods (besides those prescribed) of creating such a nature, they will perhaps be of such a kind as are in his power, yet by the confined limits of the precept he will be deprived of reaping any advantage from them; thirdly, he will be anxious to be shown something not so difficult as the required effect itself, but approaching more nearly to practice.

For example, suppose someone wants to give silver the yellow color of gold, or add weight to it, always observing the laws of matter. Or suppose someone wants to make an opaque stone transparent, make glass tough, or make a nonliving substance grow. We must consider what kind of instruction or guidance that person would prefer. First, the person will no doubt want a method that will work and will not give misleading results when tested. Second, the person will not want the prescribed method to limit them to particular materials and ways of working. They might be unable to find or obtain those materials. There may be other means and methods for producing the desired quality, and perhaps these would be available to them. Yet the narrow limits of the instructions would prevent them from taking advantage of those alternatives. Third, the person will want guidance that is less difficult than producing the desired effect itself and closer to practical application.

We will lay this down, therefore, as the genuine and perfect rule of practice, that it should be certain, free and preparatory, or having relation to practice. And this is the same thing as the discovery of a true form; for the form of any nature is such, that when it is assigned the particular nature infallibly follows. It is, therefore, always present when that nature is present, and universally attests such presence, and is inherent in the whole of it. The same form is of such a character, that if it be removed the particular nature infallibly vanishes. It is, therefore, absent, whenever that nature is absent, and perpetually testifies such absence, and exists in no other nature. Lastly, the true form is such, that it deduces the particular nature from some source of essence existing in many subjects, and more known (as they term it) to nature, than the form itself. Such, then, is our determination and rule with regard to a genuine and perfect theoretical axiom, that a nature be found convertible with a given nature, and yet such as to limit the more known nature, in the manner of a real genus. But these two rules, the practical and theoretical, are in fact the same, and that which is most useful in practice is most correct in theory.

We therefore propose this as the true and perfect rule for practice: it should be certain, unrestricted, and preparatory, or directed toward practice. This amounts to discovering a true form. The form of any nature is such that, when the form is established, that nature follows without fail. The form is therefore always present when that nature is present. It always confirms the nature’s presence and is inherent throughout it. The form is also such that, if it is removed, that nature disappears without fail. The form is therefore absent whenever that nature is absent. It always confirms the nature’s absence and exists in no other nature. Finally, the true form derives the particular nature from a source of essence present in many subjects. This source is also, as they say, better known to nature than the form itself. Our rule for a true and perfect theoretical axiom is therefore this: find a nature that is interchangeable with the given nature. It must also limit the more known nature, as a true genus does. But the practical and theoretical rules are in fact the same. What is most useful in practice is also most correct in theory.

V

5

But the rule or axiom for the transformation of bodies is of two kinds. The first regards the body as an aggregate or combination of simple natures. Thus, in gold are united the following circumstances: it is yellow, heavy, of a certain weight, malleable and ductile to a certain extent; it is not volatile, loses part of its substance by fire, melts in a particular manner, is separated and dissolved by particular methods, and so of the other natures observable in gold. An axiom, therefore, of this kind deduces the subject from the forms of simple natures; for he who has acquired the forms and methods of superinducing yellowness, weight, ductility, stability, deliquescence, solution, and the like, and their degrees and modes, will consider and contrive how to unite them in any body, so as to transform it into gold. And this method of operating belongs to primary action; for it is the same thing to produce one or many simple natures, except that man is more confined and restricted in his operations, if many be required, on account of the difficulty of uniting many natures together. It must, however, be observed, that this method of operating (which considers natures as simple though in a concrete body) sets out from what is constant, eternal, and universal in nature, and opens such broad paths to human power, as the thoughts of man can in the present state of things scarcely comprehend or figure to itself.

The rule or axiom for transforming bodies is of two kinds. The first treats a body as a combination of simple natures. Gold, for example, combines the following qualities: it is yellow and heavy, with a particular weight. It is malleable and ductile to a certain extent. It is not volatile, loses some of its substance in fire, and melts in a particular way. It can be separated and dissolved by particular methods. The same applies to the other natures observable in gold. An axiom of this kind derives its subject from the forms of simple natures. Suppose someone has learned the forms and methods for adding yellowness, weight, ductility, stability, deliquescence, and solubility to a body. Suppose, too, that this person knows how to produce their various degrees and modes. Such a person can then consider and devise ways to unite these natures in any body, so as to transform it into gold. This method belongs to primary action. Producing many simple natures is the same kind of operation as producing one. But when many are required, human operations are more limited and restricted because it is difficult to unite them. This method treats natures as simple, even within a concrete body. It begins with what is constant, eternal, and universal in nature. It opens such broad paths to human power that people can scarcely understand or imagine them in the present state of things.

Recent discoveries in electromagnetism allow copper wires, or wires of any metal, to be turned into magnets. The magnetic law, or form, has been discovered to that extent.

The second kind of axiom (which depends on the discovery of the latent process) does not proceed by simple natures, but by concrete bodies, as they are found in nature and in its usual course. For instance, suppose the inquiry to be, from what beginnings, in what manner, and by what process gold or any metal or stone is generated from the original menstruum, or its elements, up to the perfect mineral: or, in like manner, by what process plants are generated, from the first concretion of juices in the earth, or from seeds, up to the perfect plant, with the whole successive motion, and varied and uninterrupted efforts of nature; and the same inquiry be made as to a regularly deduced system of the generation of animals from coition to birth, and so on of other bodies.

The second kind of axiom depends on discovering the hidden process. It deals not with simple natures, but with concrete bodies as they are found in nature and its usual course. For example, we might ask how gold, another metal, or a stone is formed. We would trace its beginnings and the process by which it develops from the original menstruum, or its elements, into a complete mineral. Similarly, we might ask how plants develop, from seeds or from the first gathering of juices in the earth, into complete plants. We would trace the whole sequence of movement and nature’s varied and uninterrupted efforts. In the same way, we might trace the development of animals step by step, from mating to birth. We could do the same for other bodies.

Nor is this species of inquiry confined to the mere generation of bodies, but it is applicable to other changes and labors of nature. For instance, where an inquiry is made into the whole series and continued operation of the nutritive process, from the first reception of the food to its complete assimilation to the recipient; or into the voluntary motion of animals, from the first impression of the imagination, and the continuous effects of the spirits, up to the bending and motion of the joints; or into the free motion of the tongue and lips, and other accessories which give utterance to articulate sounds. For all these investigations relate to concrete or associated natures artificially brought together, and take into consideration certain particular and special habits of nature, and not those fundamental and general laws which constitute forms. It must, however, be plainly owned, that this method appears more prompt and easy, and of greater promise than the primary one.

This kind of inquiry is not limited to how bodies are formed. It also applies to other changes and processes in nature. For example, we may investigate the entire continuous process of nutrition, from the first intake of food to its complete assimilation by the body. Or we may investigate voluntary movement in animals, from the first impression on the imagination through the continuing effects of the spirits, to the bending and movement of the joints. We may also investigate the free movement of the tongue and lips, along with the other parts involved in producing articulate sounds. All these investigations concern concrete or associated natures brought together artificially. They examine particular, special habits of nature, not the fundamental, general laws that constitute forms. However, we must plainly admit that this method seems quicker and easier than the primary method, and more promising.

Haller investigated this in his “Physiology,” leaving his successors little to do but repeat his discoveries. Ed.

In like manner the operative branch, which answers to this contemplative branch, extends and advances its operation from that which is usually observed in nature, to other subjects immediately connected with it, or not very remote from such immediate connection. But the higher and radical operations upon nature depend entirely on the primary axioms. Besides, even where man has not the means of acting, but only of acquiring knowledge, as in astronomy (for man cannot act upon, change, or transform the heavenly bodies), the investigation of facts or truth, as well as the knowledge of causes and coincidences, must be referred to those primary and universal axioms that regard simple natures; such as the nature of spontaneous rotation, attraction, or the magnetic force, and many others which are more common than the heavenly bodies themselves. For let no one hope to determine the question whether the earth or heaven revolve in the diurnal motion, unless he have first comprehended the nature of spontaneous rotation.

Similarly, the practical branch corresponds to the contemplative branch. It extends its work beyond what is usually observed in nature to subjects closely connected with it, or not far removed from that connection. But the higher and more fundamental operations upon nature depend entirely on the primary axioms. Even where people can only gain knowledge, not act, the investigation of facts and truth must be based on those axioms. So must knowledge of causes and coincidences. Astronomy is one such field, because people cannot affect, change, or transform the heavenly bodies. These primary and universal axioms concern simple natures, such as spontaneous rotation, attraction, or magnetic force. They also concern many other natures that are more widespread than the heavenly bodies themselves. No one should hope to decide whether the earth or the heavens revolve in the daily motion without first understanding spontaneous rotation.

VI

6

But the latent process of which we speak, is far from being obvious to men’s minds, beset as they now are. For we mean not the measures, symptoms, or degrees of any process which can be exhibited in the bodies themselves, but simply a continued process, which, for the most part, escapes the observation of the senses.

But the hidden process we speak of is far from obvious to minds burdened as they now are. By this, we do not mean the measures, signs, or stages of a process visible in the bodies themselves. We mean a continuous process that, for the most part, escapes observation by the senses.

For instance, in all generations and transformations of bodies, we must inquire, what is in the act of being lost and escaping, what remains, what is being added, what is being diluted, what is being contracted, what is being united, what is being separated, what is continuous, what is broken off, what is urging forward, what impedes, what predominates, what is subservient, and many other circumstances.

For example, we must examine all processes in which bodies are formed or transformed. We must ask what is being lost and escaping, what remains, and what is being added. We must ask what is being diluted, contracted, joined, or separated. We must also ask what continues, what breaks off, what pushes forward, and what gets in the way. We must ask what dominates, what is subordinate, and about many other circumstances.

Nor are these inquiries again to be made in the mere generation and transformation of bodies only, but in all other alterations and fluctuations we must in like manner inquire; what precedes, what succeeds, what is quick, what is slow, what produces and what governs motion, and the like. All which matters are unknown and unattempted by the sciences, in their present heavy and inactive state. For, since every natural act is brought about by the smallest efforts, or at least such as are too small to strike our senses, let no one hope that he will be able to direct or change nature unless he have properly comprehended and observed these efforts.

These inquiries should not be limited to the formation and transformation of bodies. We must also investigate all other changes and fluctuations in the same way. We must ask what comes before and what follows, what is quick and what is slow. We must ask what produces motion, what governs it, and similar questions. In their present sluggish and inactive state, the sciences have neither explored nor understood any of these matters. For every natural act is brought about by the smallest efforts, or at least by efforts too small for our senses to detect. No one should hope to direct or change nature without properly understanding and observing these efforts.

Here Bacon first seems to anticipate the important development of higher calculus. In the hands of Newton and Descartes, higher calculus would revolutionize philosophy as much as Bacon's method did. Ed.

VII

7

In like manner, the investigation and discovery of the latent conformation in bodies is no less new, than the discovery of the latent process and form. For we as yet are doubtless only admitted to the antechamber of nature, and do not prepare an entrance into her presence-room. But nobody can endue a given body with a new nature, or transform it successfully and appropriately into a new body, without possessing a complete knowledge of the body so to be changed or transformed. For he will run into vain, or, at least, into difficult and perverse methods, ill adapted to the nature of the body upon which he operates. A clear path, therefore, toward this object also must be thrown open, and well supported.

Likewise, investigating and discovering the hidden structure of bodies is just as new as discovering their hidden processes and forms. For we have undoubtedly only entered nature’s antechamber, and have not yet prepared to enter her inner room. But no one can give a body a new nature or transform it successfully and appropriately into another body without complete knowledge of the body being transformed. Without that knowledge, a person will use futile methods, or at least difficult and misguided ones. These methods will be poorly suited to the nature of the body being worked on. We must therefore open and support a clear path toward this goal as well.

Labor is well and usefully bestowed upon the anatomy of organized bodies, such as those of men and animals, which appears to be a subtile matter, and a useful examination of nature. The species of anatomy, however, is that of first sight, open to the senses, and takes place only in organized bodies. It is obvious, and of ready access, when compared with the real anatomy of latent conformation in bodies which are considered similar, particularly in specific objects and their parts; as those of iron, stone, and the similar parts of plants and animals, as the root, the leaf, the flower, the flesh, the blood, and bones, etc. Yet human industry has not completely neglected this species of anatomy; for we have an instance of it in the separation of similar bodies by distillation, and other solutions, which shows the dissimilarity of the compound by the union of the homogeneous parts. These methods are useful, and of importance to our inquiry, although attended generally with fallacy: for many natures are assigned and attributed to the separate bodies, as if they had previously existed in the compound, which, in reality, are recently bestowed and superinduced by fire and heat, and the other modes of separation. Besides, it is, after all, but a small part of the labor of discovering the real conformation in the compound, which is so subtile and nice, that it is rather confused and lost by the operation of the fire, than discovered and brought to light.

The study of the anatomy of organized bodies, such as those of humans and animals, is well worth the effort. It appears to be a subtle and useful examination of nature. However, this kind of anatomy deals with what is immediately visible to the senses. It is also limited to organized bodies. It is obvious and easy to approach compared with the true anatomy of hidden structures in bodies regarded as uniform. These include particular objects and their parts, such as iron, stone, and the uniform parts of plants and animals. Examples of these parts are roots, leaves, flowers, flesh, blood, and bones. Yet human effort has not completely neglected this other kind of anatomy. We see it in the separation of uniform bodies by distillation and other methods of breaking them down. These methods bring together parts of the same kind, revealing the different components of the compound. They are useful and important to our inquiry, although they are generally prone to error. Many properties are assigned to the separated substances as if they had already existed in the compound. In reality, fire, heat, and other methods of separation have newly added and imposed these properties. Besides, these methods do only a small part of the work needed to discover the compound’s true structure. That structure is so subtle and delicate that fire tends to confuse and obscure it rather than reveal it.

A separation and solution of bodies, therefore, is to be effected, not by fire indeed, but rather by reasoning and true induction, with the assistance of experiment, and by a comparison with other bodies, and a reduction to those simple natures and their forms which meet, and are combined in the compound; and we must assuredly pass from Vulcan to Minerva, if we wish to bring to light the real texture and conformation of bodies, upon which every occult and (as it is sometimes called) specific property and virtue of things depends, and whence also every rule of powerful change and transformation is deduced.

Therefore, we must separate and break down bodies, not by fire, but by reasoning and true induction, aided by experiment. We must compare bodies with others and reduce them to the simple natures and their forms that combine in them. We must surely pass from Vulcan to Minerva if we wish to reveal the real structure and makeup of bodies. Every hidden property and power of things depends on this structure. These properties and powers are sometimes called specific. Every rule for bringing about powerful changes and transformations also derives from this structure.

For instance, we must examine what spirit is in every body, what tangible essence; whether that spirit is copious and exuberant, or meagre and scarce, fine or coarse, aëriform or igniform, active or sluggish, weak or robust, progressive or retrograde, abrupt or continuous, agreeing with external and surrounding objects, or differing from them, etc. In like manner must we treat tangible essence (which admits of as many distinctions as the spirit), and its hairs, fibres, and varied texture. Again, the situation of the spirit in the corporeal mass, its pores, passages, veins, and cells, and the rudiments or first essays of the organic body, are subject to the same examination. In these, however, as in our former inquiries, and therefore in the whole investigation of latent conformation, the only genuine and clear light which completely dispels all darkness and subtile difficulties, is admitted by means of the primary axioms.

For example, we must examine the spirit in every body, and its tangible substance. We must ask whether the spirit is abundant and overflowing or thin and scarce. Is it fine or coarse, like air or like fire, active or sluggish, weak or strong? Does it move forward or backward, abruptly or continuously? Does it agree with external and surrounding things, or differ from them, and so on? We must examine tangible substance in the same way. It allows for as many distinctions as the spirit does. We must also examine its hairs, fibers, and varied texture. We must examine the spirit’s position in the mass of the body in the same way. So too must we examine its pores, passages, veins, and cells, and the beginnings or first attempts at an organic body. Yet here, as in our earlier inquiries, only the primary axioms provide genuine, clear light. In the whole investigation of hidden structure, only this light completely dispels all darkness and subtle difficulties.

By spirit, Bacon clearly means a material fluid too fine to be detected by the unaided senses. It acts rather than reasons. We sometimes use the same expression, as in spirits of nitre and spirits of wine. Nearly all modern physicists have assumed some such agent. A few of them, like Bacon, use language that suggests they believe such bodies have the power of perception. For another example of his view, see the passage on the decomposition of compounds in his essay on death. It begins: “The spirit which exists in all living bodies, keeps all the parts in due subjection; when it escapes, the body decomposes, or the similar parts unite.” Ed.

VIII

8

This method will not bring us to atoms, which takes for granted the vacuum, and immutability of matter (neither of which hypotheses is correct), but to the real particles such as we discover them to be. Nor is there any ground for alarm at this refinement as if it were inexplicable, for, on the contrary, the more inquiry is directed to simple natures, the more will everything be placed in a plain and perspicuous light, since we transfer our attention from the complicated to the simple, from the incommensurable to the commensurable, from surds to rational quantities, from the indefinite and vague to the definite and certain; as when we arrive at the elements of letters, and the simple tones of concords. The investigation of nature is best conducted when mathematics are applied to physics. Again, let none be alarmed at vast numbers and fractions, for in calculation it is as easy to set down or to reflect upon a thousand as a unit, or the thousandth part of an integer as an integer itself.

This method will not lead us to atoms, for atoms presuppose a vacuum and the immutability of matter. Neither assumption is correct. Instead, it will lead us to real particles as we discover them. Nor should anyone fear that this fine level of detail will make things impossible to explain. On the contrary, the more we investigate simple natures, the clearer everything will become. We will shift our attention from the complex to the simple, from the incommensurable to the commensurable, from irrational to rational quantities, and from the indefinite and vague to the definite and certain. This is like reaching the basic elements of letters and the simple tones of musical harmonies. We investigate nature best when we apply mathematics to physics. Again, no one should be alarmed by vast numbers and fractions. In calculation, writing down or thinking about a thousand is as easy as doing the same with one. The same is true of a thousandth of a whole number and a whole number itself.

The theory of the Epicureans and others. Atoms are supposed to be invisible, unchanging particles with all the properties of a given body. They form that body by joining together. Of course, the atoms must be separated. This either assumes a vacuum or introduces a tertium quid into the body's composition.

IX

9

From the two kinds of axioms above specified, arise the two divisions of philosophy and the sciences, and we will use the commonly adopted terms which approach the nearest to our meaning, in our own sense. Let the investigation of forms, which (in reasoning at least, and after their own laws), are eternal and immutable, constitute metaphysics, and let the investigation of the efficient cause of matter, latent process, and latent conformation (which all relate merely to the ordinary course of nature, and not to her fundamental and eternal laws), constitute physics. Parallel to these, let there be two practical divisions; to physics that of mechanics, and to metaphysics that of magic, in the purest sense of the term, as applied to its ample means, and its command over nature.

The two kinds of axioms described above give rise to two divisions of philosophy and the sciences. We will use the familiar terms closest to our meaning, but in our own sense. Let metaphysics be the study of forms, which are eternal and unchanging, at least in reasoning and according to their own laws. Let physics be the study of the efficient cause of matter, latent process, and latent conformation. These all concern only the ordinary course of nature, not its fundamental and eternal laws. Let there also be two corresponding practical divisions. Mechanics corresponds to physics, and magic to metaphysics. We mean magic in the purest sense of the term, referring to its extensive means and its command over nature.

Compare the next three aphorisms with the last three chapters of the third book of “De Augmentis Scientiarum.”

Bacon gives this unfortunate term its proper meaning. In Greek compounds, μετα signifies change or mutation. Most readers no doubt know that the word was introduced into technical philosophy purely on a whim. It dates no earlier than the publication of Aristotle’s works by Andronicus of Rhodes. He was one of the scholars who received Aristotle’s manuscripts after Sylla brought them from Athens to Rome. Fourteen books in these manuscripts had no distinctive title. Andronicus is said to have given them the title τα μετα τα φυσικα. This indicated their proper place either in Aristotle’s arrangement or in the order of study.

These books deal first with subjects common to matter and mind. Second, they deal with things separate from matter, i.e. God and the subordinate spirits. The Peripatetics believed these spirits watched over particular parts of the universe. Aristotle’s followers accepted the whimsical title of Andronicus. In their usual way, they let a word unite plainly different things into one science. The Peripatetics of the Christian Church adopted this error.

The schoolmen added the science of the mind, or pneumatology, to the idea of ontology. That kind of being has since disappeared along with the schools. So, in modern usage, metaphysics has come to mean the same as psychology. It is a pity that Bacon’s definition was not accepted. It would have freed the science of the mind from one of the greatest monstrosities in its terminology. Yet Bacon himself, oddly enough, includes mathematics in metaphysics in his De Augmentis. Ed.

X

10

The object of our philosophy being thus laid down, we proceed to precepts, in the most clear and regular order. The signs for the interpretation of nature comprehend two divisions; the first regards the eliciting or creating of axioms from experiment, the second the deducing or deriving of new experiments from axioms. The first admits of three subdivisions into ministrations. 1. To the senses. 2. To the memory. 3. To the mind or reason.

Having stated the aim of our philosophy, we now turn to its rules in the clearest and most orderly way. The guidance for interpreting nature has two parts. The first concerns drawing or creating axioms from experiments. The second concerns deriving new experiments from axioms. The first part has three subdivisions, providing aid: 1. To the senses. 2. To the memory. 3. To the mind or reason.

For we must first prepare as a foundation for the whole, a complete and accurate natural and experimental history. We must not imagine or invent, but discover the acts and properties of nature.

First, we must prepare a complete and accurate record of nature and experiments as the foundation for the whole work. We must not imagine or invent nature's actions and properties, but discover them.

But natural and experimental history is so varied and diffuse, that it confounds and distracts the understanding unless it be fixed and exhibited in due order. We must, therefore, form tables and co-ordinations of instances, upon such a plan, and in such order that the understanding may be enabled to act upon them.

But the records of nature and experiments are so varied and wide-ranging that they confuse and distract the mind unless they are organized and presented in proper order. We must therefore arrange examples in tables and groups, according to a plan and in an order that allows the mind to work with them.

Even when this is done, the understanding, left to itself and to its own operation, is incompetent and unfit to construct its axioms without direction and support. Our third ministration, therefore, must be true and legitimate induction, the very key of interpretation. We must begin, however, at the end, and go back again to the others.

Even after this is done, the understanding cannot construct its axioms on its own, without guidance and support. Our third aid, therefore, must be true and sound induction, the very key to interpretation. We must begin with this last aid, however, and then return to the others.

XI

11

The investigation of forms proceeds thus: a nature being given, we must first present to the understanding all the known instances which agree in the same nature, although the subject matter be considerably diversified. And this collection must be made as a mere history, and without any premature reflection, or too great degree of refinement. For instance; take the investigation of the form of heat.

The investigation of forms proceeds as follows. Given a particular nature, we must first bring together all known instances that share it, even when their subject matter varies considerably. We must collect these instances as a simple record, without premature reflection or excessive refinement. For example, consider the investigation of the form of heat.

Instances agreeing in the Form of Heat

Instances That Share the Form of Heat

1. The rays of the sun, particularly in summer, and at noon. 2. The same reflected and condensed, as between mountains, or along walls, and particularly in burning mirrors. 3. Ignited meteors. 4. Burning lightning. 5. Eruptions of flames from the cavities of mountains, etc. 6. Flame of every kind. 7. Ignited solids. 8. Natural warm baths. 9. Warm or heated liquids. 10. Warm vapors and smoke; and the air itself, which admits a most powerful and violent heat if confined, as in reverberating furnaces. 11. Damp hot weather, arising from the constitution of the air, without any reference to the time of the year. 12. Confined and subterraneous air in some caverns, particularly in winter. 13. All shaggy substances, as wool, the skins of animals, and the plumage of birds, contain some heat. 14. All bodies, both solid and liquid, dense and rare (as the air itself), placed near fire for any time. 15. Sparks arising from the violent percussion of flint and steel. 16. All bodies rubbed violently, as stone, wood, cloth, etc., so that rudders, and axles of wheels, sometimes catch fire, and the West Indians obtain fire by attrition. 17. Green and moist vegetable matter confined and rubbed together, as roses, peas in baskets; so hay, if it be damp when stacked, often catches fire. 18. Quicklime sprinkled with water. 19. Iron, when first dissolved by acids in a glass, and without any application to fire; the same of tin, but not so intensely. 20. Animals, particularly internally; although the heat is not perceivable by the touch in insects, on account of their small size. 21. Horse dung, and the like excrement from other animals, when fresh. 22. Strong oil of sulphur and of vitriol exhibit the operation of heat in burning linen. 23. As does the oil of marjoram, and like substances, in burning the bony substance of the teeth. 24. Strong and well rectified spirits of wine exhibit the same effects; so that white of eggs when thrown into it grows hard and white, almost in the same manner as when boiled, and bread becomes burned and brown as if toasted. 25. Aromatic substances and warm plants, as the dracunculus [arum], old nasturtium, etc., which, though they be not warm to the touch (whether whole or pulverized), yet are discovered by the tongue and palate to be warm and almost burning when slightly masticated. 26. Strong vinegar and all acids, on any part of the body not clothed with the epidermis, as the eye, tongue, or any wounded part, or where the skin is removed, excite a pain differing but little from that produced by heat. 27. Even a severe and intense cold produces a sensation of burning. “Nec Boreæ penetrabile frigus adurit.” 28. Other instances.

1. The sun’s rays, especially in summer and at noon. 2. The same rays reflected and concentrated, as between mountains or along walls, and especially in burning mirrors. 3. Burning meteors. 4. Lightning that burns. 5. Flames erupting from cavities in mountains, etc. 6. Flame of every kind. 7. Burning solids. 8. Natural warm baths. 9. Warm or heated liquids. 10. Warm vapors and smoke. Air itself can also become intensely and violently hot when confined, as in reverberating furnaces. 11. Damp, hot weather caused by the state of the air, regardless of the season. 12. Confined underground air in some caves, especially in winter. 13. All shaggy substances, such as wool, animal skins, and birds’ feathers, contain some heat. 14. All bodies placed near a fire for any length of time. This includes solids and liquids, dense and thin substances, such as air itself. 15. Sparks produced when flint and steel are struck together violently. 16. All bodies rubbed violently, such as stone, wood, and cloth. Rudders and wheel axles sometimes catch fire this way, and West Indians make fire by friction. 17. Green, moist plant matter packed together and rubbed, such as roses or peas in baskets. Likewise, hay often catches fire if it is damp when stacked. 18. Quicklime sprinkled with water. 19. Iron when first dissolved by acids in a glass, without being exposed to fire. The same is true of tin, but less intensely. 20. Animals, especially inside their bodies. In insects, however, the heat cannot be felt by touch because they are so small. 21. Fresh horse dung and similar excrement from other animals. 22. Strong oil of sulphur and oil of vitriol show the effects of heat by burning linen. 23. Oil of marjoram and similar substances do the same by burning the bony substance of teeth. 24. Strong, thoroughly purified spirits of wine produce the same effects. Egg white placed in it hardens and turns white, much as it does when boiled. Bread becomes burned and brown, as if toasted. 25. Aromatic substances and warm plants, such as dracunculus [arum], old nasturtium, etc. They are not warm to the touch, whether whole or powdered. Yet when chewed lightly, they feel warm and almost burning on the tongue and palate. 26. Strong vinegar and all acids cause pain much like that caused by heat when applied to exposed tissue. Examples include the eye, tongue, a wound, or a place where the skin has been removed. 27. Even severe, intense cold produces a burning sensation. “Nec Boreæ penetrabile frigus adurit.” 28. Other examples.

> “Ne tenues pluviæ, rapidive potentia solis > Acrior, aut Boreæ penetrabile frigus adurat.” > Virg. Georg. i. 92, 93.

We are wont to call this a table of existence and presence.

We usually call this a table of existence and presence.

XII

12

We must next present to the understanding instances which do not admit of the given nature, for form (as we have observed) ought no less to be absent where the given nature is absent, than to be present where it is present. If, however, we were to examine every instance, our labor would be infinite.

We must next consider instances where the given nature is absent. As we have observed, the form must be absent wherever the given nature is absent. It must also be present wherever the given nature is present. But if we examined every instance, our work would never end.

Negatives, therefore, must be classed under the affirmatives, and the want of the given nature must be inquired into more particularly in objects which have a very close connection with those others in which it is present and manifest. And this we are wont to term a table of deviation or of absence in proximity.

Therefore, cases where the given quality is absent must be grouped with cases where it is present. We must examine its absence especially in objects closely related to others where it is clearly present. We call this a table of deviation or of absence in proximity.

Proximate Instances wanting the Nature of Heat

Similar Examples Without Heat

The rays of the moon, stars, and comets, are not found to be warm to the touch, nay, the severest cold has been observed to take place at the full of the moon. Yet the larger fixed stars are supposed to increase and render more intense the heat of the sun, as he approaches them, when the sun is in the sign of the Lion, for instance, and in the dog-days.

The rays of the moon, stars, and comets do not feel warm to the touch. In fact, the most severe cold has been observed during a full moon. Yet the larger fixed stars are thought to increase and intensify the sun's heat as it approaches them. This is thought to happen, for instance, when the sun is in the sign of the Lion and during the dog days.

He repeats this idea and explains it in more detail in this book. He borrowed it from the ancients, and we need hardly say it is as wise as their other astronomical guesses. The sun also approaches equally large stars in other parts of the zodiac, when it looks down on earth through winter’s murky clouds. When the sun is in Leo, the earth is certainly hotter than at any other time. But this is because heat builds up after the solstice. For the same reason, the day is hottest at two o’clock rather than noon. Ed.

The rays of the sun in what is called the middle region of the air give no heat, to account for which the commonly assigned reason is satisfactory; namely, that that region is neither sufficiently near to the body of the sun whence the rays emanate, nor to the earth whence they are reflected. And the fact is manifested by snow being perpetual on the tops of mountains, unless extremely lofty. But it is observed, on the other hand, by some, that at the Peak of Teneriffe, and also among the Andes of Peru, the tops of the mountains are free from snow, which only lies in the lower part as you ascend. Besides, the air on the summit of these mountains is found to be by no means cold, but only thin and sharp; so much so, that in the Andes it pricks and hurts the eyes from its extreme sharpness, and even excites the orifice of the stomach and produces vomiting. The ancients also observed, that the rarity of the air on the summit of Olympus was such, that those who ascended it were obliged to carry sponges moistened with vinegar and water, and to apply them now and then to their nostrils, as the air was not dense enough for their respiration; on the summit of which mountain it is also related, there reigned so great a serenity and calm, free from rain, snow, or wind, that the letters traced upon the ashes of the sacrifices on the altar of Jupiter, by the fingers of those who had offered them, would remain undisturbed till the next year. Those even, who at this day go to the top of the Peak of Teneriffe, walk by night and not in the daytime, and are advised and pressed by their guides, as soon as the sun rises, to make haste in their descent, on account of the danger (apparently arising from the rarity of the atmosphere), lest their breathing should be relaxed and suffocated.

The sun’s rays give no heat in what is called the middle region of the air. The usual explanation is satisfactory: this region is not close enough to the sun, from which the rays come. Nor is it close enough to the earth, from which they are reflected. This is shown by the permanent snow on mountaintops, unless the mountains are extremely high. But some observers report that the summits of the Peak of Teneriffe and the Andes of Peru are free of snow. Snow lies only on the lower slopes as one ascends. Moreover, the air at these summits is not at all cold, but only thin and sharp. In the Andes, it is so sharp that it stings and hurts the eyes. It even irritates the opening of the stomach and causes vomiting. The ancients also observed that the air on the summit of Olympus was extremely thin. Those who climbed it had to carry sponges moistened with vinegar and water. From time to time, they held them to their nostrils because the air was not dense enough to breathe. It is also said that the summit was perfectly serene and calm, free from rain, snow, and wind. Those who offered sacrifices on Jupiter’s altar traced letters with their fingers in the ashes. These letters would remain undisturbed until the following year. Even today, those who climb the Peak of Teneriffe do so at night rather than during the day. Their guides advise and urge them to descend quickly as soon as the sun rises. Otherwise, they risk having their breathing weakened and suffocating, apparently because of the thinness of the air.

Bouguer was employed by Louis XIV. to conduct scientific research. He climbed the Andes to investigate the earth's spherical shape. He published an account of his journey that confirms Bacon's statement.

The reflection of the solar rays in the polar regions is found to be weak and inefficient in producing heat, so that the Dutch, who wintered in Nova Zembla, and expected that their vessel would be freed about the beginning of July from the obstruction of the mass of ice which had blocked it up, were disappointed and obliged to embark in their boat. Hence the direct rays of the sun appear to have but little power even on the plain, and when reflected, unless they are multiplied and condensed, which takes place when the sun tends more to the perpendicular; for, then, the incidence of the rays occurs at more acute angles, so that the reflected rays are nearer to each other, while, on the contrary, when the sun is in a very oblique position, the angles of incidence are very obtuse, and the reflected rays at a greater distance. In the meantime it must be observed, that there may be many operations of the solar rays, relating, too, to the nature of heat, which are not proportioned to our touch, so that, with regard to us, they do not tend to produce warmth, but, with regard to some other bodies, have their due effect in producing it.

In the polar regions, reflected sunlight is weak and produces little heat. The Dutch who spent the winter in Nova Zembla expected their vessel to be freed from the surrounding ice around the beginning of July. They were disappointed and had to leave in their boat. This suggests that the sun's direct rays have little power, even on level ground. Reflected rays also have little power unless they are multiplied and concentrated. This happens when the sun is closer to directly overhead. Then the rays strike at sharper angles, so the reflected rays are closer together. But when the sun is very low in the sky, the angles of incidence are very wide. The reflected rays are then farther apart. Still, the sun's rays may have many effects related to the nature of heat that we cannot feel. Thus, although the rays do not produce warmth for us, they may nevertheless produce warmth in other bodies.

Let the following experiment be made. Take a lens the reverse of a burning-glass, and place it between the hand and the solar rays, and observe whether it diminish the heat of the sun as a burning-glass increases it. For it is clear, with regard to the visual rays, that in proportion as the lens is made of unequal thickness in the middle and at its sides, the images appear either more diffused or contracted. It should be seen, therefore, if the same be true with regard to heat.

Try the following experiment. Take a lens shaped opposite to a burning glass and place it between your hand and the sun’s rays. See whether it reduces the sun’s heat, just as a burning glass increases it. For it is clear that a lens affects images according to the difference between its thickness at the center and at the edges. Images appear either more spread out or more concentrated. See, therefore, whether the same is true of heat.

Let the experiment be well tried, whether the lunar rays can be received and collected by the strongest and best burning-glasses, so as to produce even the least degree of heat. But if that degree be, perhaps, so subtile and weak, as not to be perceived or ascertained by the touch, we must have recourse to those glasses which indicate the warm or cold state of the atmosphere, and let the lunar rays fall through the burning-glass on the top of this thermometer, and then notice if the water be depressed by the heat.

Carefully test whether the strongest and best burning glasses can collect and concentrate moonlight enough to produce even the slightest heat. But perhaps the heat is too subtle and weak to be detected by touch. If so, we must use the instruments that indicate whether the air is warm or cold. Let the moonlight pass through the burning glass onto the top of this thermometer. Then observe whether the heat pushes the water down.

In his book against the astrologers, Montanari says he conducted numerous, repeated experiments. These convinced him that moonlight focused at a point produced noticeable heat. Muschenbröck, however, disagrees. He says that he, De la Hire, Villet, and Tschirnhausen tried the strongest burning-glasses for this purpose without success. (Opera de Igne.) De la Lande makes a similar admission in his Astronomy (vol. ii. vii. § 1413). Bouguer, whom we have just quoted, demonstrated that moonlight was 300,000 degrees less intense than sunlight. To try the experiment Bacon describes, it would therefore be necessary to invent a glass with 300,000 times the absorbing power of those ordinarily used. Ed.

Unlike modern thermometers, this one did not use mercury that expanded with heat and contracted with cold. Instead, it used air that filled the bulb. It was positioned upside down compared with modern thermometers, with the bulb at the top. When heated, the air expanded and pushed the liquid down, whereas a modern thermometer pushes it up. As the heat decreased, the liquid rose to fill the space left by the air. In a modern thermometer, the liquid falls instead. This thermometer was therefore affected by changes in both temperature and air pressure. It could provide only a rough standard of accuracy for scientific investigations. Contrary to common belief, Bacon did not invent this thermometer. It was invented by Drebbel. Ed.

Let the burning-glass be tried on warm objects which emit no luminous rays, as heated but not ignited iron or stone, or hot water, or the like; and observe whether the heat become increased and condensed, as happens with the solar rays.

Test the burning glass on warm objects that give off no light. These might include heated but not glowing iron or stone, hot water, or similar things. Observe whether the heat increases and concentrates, as it does with the sun's rays.

Let it be tried on common flame.

Let it be tested on an ordinary flame.

The effect of comets (if we can reckon them among meteors) in augmenting the heat of the season is not found to be constant or clear, although droughts have generally been observed to follow them. However, luminous lines, and pillars, and openings, and the like, appear more often in winter than in summer, and especially with the most intense cold but joined with drought. Lightning, and coruscations, and thunder, however, rarely happen in winter; and generally at the time of the greatest heats. The appearances we term falling stars are generally supposed to consist of some shining and inflamed viscous substance, rather than of violently hot matter; but let this be further investigated.

The effect of comets (if we can count them among meteors) on the season’s heat is not consistent or clear. However, droughts have generally been observed to follow them. Luminous lines, pillars, openings, and similar appearances occur more often in winter than in summer. They appear especially during the most intense cold, when it is also dry. Lightning, flashes of light, and thunder, however, rarely occur in winter. They generally occur during the hottest weather. What we call falling stars are generally thought to consist of a shining, burning, sticky substance, rather than intensely hot matter. But this needs further investigation.

La Lande is indignant that the Chaldeans understood the nature of comets better than modern physicists. He accuses Bacon of believing that comets were merely the effects of vapor and heat. This passage and two more explicit ones, in the “De Aug.” (cap. xl.) and the “Descript. Globi Intellect.” (cap. vi.), certainly support the accusation. But if Bacon was wrong, so were Galileo and the leading thinkers of the time. Pythagoras and Seneca had indeed stated their belief that comets were solid bodies. But Aristotle later became so influential that their views were overshadowed, and the opposite belief prevailed everywhere. Ed.

Some coruscations emit light without burning, but are never accompanied by thunder.

Some flashes of lightning give off light without burning, but they are never accompanied by thunder.

Eructations and eruptions of flame are to be found in cold climates as well as in hot, as in Iceland and Greenland; just as the trees of cold countries are sometimes inflammable and more pitchy and resinous than in warm, as the fir, pine, and the like. But the position and nature of the soil, where such eruptions are wont to happen, is not yet sufficiently investigated to enable us to subjoin a negative instance to the affirmative.

Flames burst and erupt from the ground in cold climates as well as hot ones, as in Iceland and Greenland. Similarly, trees in cold countries, such as firs and pines, are sometimes flammable and contain more pitch and resin than those in warm countries. But we have not yet studied the location and nature of the soil where such eruptions occur closely enough. So we cannot add a negative example to the positive one.

All flame is constantly more or less warm, and this instance is not altogether negative; yet it is said that the ignis fatuus (as it is called), and which sometimes is driven against walls, has but little heat; perhaps it resembles that of spirits of wine, which is mild and gentle. That flame, however, appears yet milder, which in some well authenticated and serious histories is said to have appeared round the head and hair of boys and virgins, and instead of burning their hair, merely to have played about it. And it is most certain that a sort of flash, without any evident heat, has sometimes been seen about a horse when sweating at night, or in damp weather. It is also a well known fact, and it was almost considered as a miracle, that a few years since a girl’s apron sparkled when a little shaken or rubbed, which was, perhaps, occasioned by the alum or salts with which the apron was imbued, and which, after having been stuck together and incrusted rather strongly, were broken by the friction. It is well known that all sugar, whether candied or plain, if it be hard, will sparkle when broken or scraped in the dark. In like manner sea and salt water is sometimes found to shine at night when struck violently by the oar. The foam of the sea when agitated by tempests also sparkles at night, and the Spaniards call this appearance the sea’s lungs. It has not been sufficiently ascertained what degree of heat attends the flame which the ancient sailors called Castor and Pollux, and the moderns call St. Ermus’ fire.

All flame is always warm to some degree, so this example is not entirely negative. Yet the flame called ignis fatuus, which is sometimes driven against walls, is said to have little heat. Perhaps its heat is mild and gentle, like that of burning spirits of wine. Another flame seems even milder. Some reliable and serious histories say it appeared around the heads and hair of boys and virgins. Instead of burning their hair, it merely played around it. It is also quite certain that flashes with no noticeable heat have sometimes appeared around a sweating horse at night or in damp weather. It is also well known that, a few years ago, a girl’s apron sparkled when lightly shaken or rubbed. This was almost considered a miracle. Perhaps the alum or salts used to treat the apron caused it. They had stuck together and formed a fairly hard crust, which broke when rubbed. It is well known that all sugar, whether candied or plain, sparkles when broken or scraped in the dark, if it is hard. Similarly, seawater and salt water sometimes shine at night when struck forcefully by an oar. Sea foam also sparkles at night when storms stir it up. The Spaniards call this appearance the sea’s lungs. It has not been sufficiently established how much heat accompanies the flame ancient sailors called Castor and Pollux. Modern sailors call it St. Ermus’ fire.

Was it a silk apron that produced electric sparks? Silk was scarce at the time.

Every ignited body that is red-hot is always warm, although without flame, nor is any negative instance subjoined to this affirmative. Rotten wood, however, approaches nearly to it, for it shines at night, and yet is not found to be warm; and the putrefying scales of fish which shine in the same manner are not warm to the touch, nor the body of the glowworm, or of the fly called Lucciola.

Every red-hot body is always warm, even without a flame. There is no known exception to this. Rotten wood, however, comes close. It shines at night, yet it is not warm. The decaying scales of fish also shine, but they are not warm to the touch. Neither are the bodies of glowworms or the flies called Lucciola.

The Italian firefly.

The situation and nature of the soil of natural warm baths has not been sufficiently investigated, and therefore a negative instance is not subjoined.

The location and soil of natural warm baths have not been sufficiently studied. Therefore, no negative example is included.

To the instances of warm liquids we may subjoin the negative one of the peculiar nature of liquids in general; for no tangible liquid is known that is at once warm in its nature and constantly continues warm; but their heat is only superinduced as an adventitious nature for a limited time, so that those which are extremely warm in their power and effect, as spirits of wine, chemical aromatic oils, the oils of vitriol and sulphur, and the like, and which speedily burn, are yet cold at first to the touch, and the water of natural baths, poured into any vessel and separated from its source, cools down like water heated by the fire. It is, however, true that oily substances are rather less cold to the touch than those that are aqueous, oil for instance than water, silk than linen; but this belongs to the table of degrees of cold.

To the examples of warm liquids, we may add a negative example: the distinctive nature of liquids in general. No tangible liquid is known to be naturally warm and to remain warm constantly. Instead, heat is imposed on liquids as an added property for a limited time. Thus, some liquids are extremely hot in their power and effect and quickly burn, yet feel cold at first. These include spirits of wine, chemical aromatic oils, oils of vitriol and sulphur, and the like. Water from natural baths also cools like water heated by fire when poured into a vessel and separated from its source. It is true, however, that oily substances feel somewhat less cold than watery ones. For example, oil feels less cold than water, and silk less cold than linen. But this belongs in the table of degrees of cold.

In like manner we may subjoin a negative instance to that of warm vapor, derived from the nature of vapor itself, as far as we are acquainted with it. For exhalations from oily substances, though easily inflammable, are yet never warm unless recently exhaled from some warm substance.

Similarly, we may add a negative example to that of warm vapor. It comes from the nature of vapor itself, as far as we know it. Vapors from oily substances are easily ignited. Yet they are never warm unless they have recently risen from a warm substance.

The same may be said of the instance of air; for we never perceive that air is warm unless confined or pressed, or manifestly heated by the sun, by fire, or some other warm body.

The same may be said of air. We never perceive air as warm unless it is confined, compressed, or clearly heated by the sun, fire, or another warm body.

A negative instance is exhibited in weather by its coldness with an east or north wind, beyond what the season would lead us to expect, just as the contrary takes place with the south or west winds. An inclination to rain (especially in winter) attends warm weather, and to frost cold weather.

A negative instance appears in weather that is colder than expected for the season when the wind blows from the east or north. The opposite happens when the wind blows from the south or west. Warm weather tends to bring rain, especially in winter, while cold weather tends to bring frost.

A negative instance as to air confined in caverns may be observed in summer. Indeed, we should make a more diligent inquiry into the nature of confined air. For in the first place the qualities of air in its own nature with regard to heat and cold may reasonably be the subject of doubt; for air evidently derives its heat from the effects of celestial bodies, and possibly its cold from the exhalation of the earth, and in the mid region of air (as it is termed) from cold vapors and snow, so that no judgment can be formed of the nature of air by that which is out of doors and exposed, but a more correct one might be derived from confined air. It is necessary, however, that the air should be inclosed in a vessel of such materials as would not imbue it with heat or cold of themselves, nor easily admit the influence of the external atmosphere. The experiment should be made, therefore, with an earthen jar, covered with folds of leather to protect it from the external air, and the air should be kept three or four days in this vessel well closed. On opening the jar, the degree of heat may be ascertained either by the hand or a graduated glass tube.

A negative instance involving air confined in caverns can be observed in summer. Indeed, we should investigate the nature of confined air more carefully. First, there is good reason to question whether air is naturally hot or cold. Air evidently gets its heat from the effects of celestial bodies. It may get its cold from vapors rising from the earth. In the region known as the middle atmosphere, it may get its cold from cold vapors and snow. We cannot therefore judge the nature of air from air that is outdoors and exposed. But we might judge it more accurately from confined air. The air must, however, be enclosed in a vessel made of materials that would not themselves heat or cool it. The vessel must also resist the influence of the outside air. The experiment should therefore use an earthenware jar covered with layers of leather to protect it from the outside air. The air should be kept in the tightly closed jar for three or four days. When the jar is opened, its degree of heat can be measured by hand or with a graduated glass tube.

There is a similar doubt as to whether the warmth of wool, skins, feathers, and the like, is derived from a slight inherent heat, since they are animal excretions, or from their being of a certain fat and oily nature that accords with heat, or merely from the confinement and separation of air which we spoke of in the preceding paragraph; for all air appears to possess a certain degree of warmth when separated from the external atmosphere. Let an experiment be made, therefore, with fibrous substances of linen, and not of wool, feathers, or silk, which are animal excretions. For it is to be observed that all powders (where air is manifestly inclosed) are less cold than the substances when whole, just as we imagine froth (which contains air) to be less cold than the liquid itself.

There is a similar question about the warmth of wool, skins, feathers, and the like. Does it come from a slight natural heat, since these materials are animal excretions? Or does it come from their somewhat fatty and oily nature, which is compatible with heat? Or does it come simply from trapping and separating air, as discussed in the preceding paragraph? For all air seems to have some warmth when separated from the outside air. Let us therefore experiment with linen fibers, rather than wool, feathers, or silk, which are animal excretions. For all powders, which clearly contain trapped air, are less cold than the same substances in whole form. Similarly, we imagine froth, which contains air, to be less cold than the liquid itself.

This last explanation is the real reason. Air is a poor conductor, so it does not let heat escape. The trapped air is released when these substances are placed under a vacuum receiver.

We have here no exactly negative instance, for we are not acquainted with any body tangible or spirituous which does not admit of heat when exposed to the fire. There is, however, this difference, that some admit it more rapidly, as air, oil, and water, others more slowly, as stone and metals. This, however, belongs to the table of degrees.

We have no exact negative instance here. We know of no tangible body or spirit that cannot absorb heat when exposed to fire. There is, however, a difference in how quickly they absorb heat. Some, such as air, oil, and water, absorb it more rapidly. Others, such as stone and metals, absorb it more slowly. This difference, however, belongs in the table of degrees.

This is incorrect. In fact, air is one of the worst conductors of heat, and metals are the best.

No negative is here subjoined, except the remark that sparks are not kindled by flint and steel, or any other hard substance, unless some small particles of the stone or metal are struck off, and that the air never forms them by friction, as is commonly supposed; besides, the sparks from the weight of the ignited substance have a tendency to descend rather than to rise, and when extinguished become a sort of dark ash.

No negative instance is added here, except for this observation. Flint and steel, or any other hard substance, produce sparks only when small particles of stone or metal are struck off. Air never produces sparks through friction, as people commonly suppose. Also, because of the weight of the burning material, sparks tend to fall rather than rise. When they go out, they become a kind of dark ash.

We are of opinion that here again there is no negative; for we are not acquainted with any tangible body which does not become decidedly warm by friction, so that the ancients feigned that the gods had no other means or power of creating heat than the friction of air, by rapid and violent rotation. On this point, however, further inquiry must be made, whether bodies projected by machines (as balls from cannon) do not derive some degree of heat from meeting the air, which renders them somewhat warm when they fall. The air in motion rather cools than heats, as in the winds, the bellows, or breath when the mouth is contracted. The motion, however, in such instances is not sufficiently rapid to excite heat, and is applied to a body of air, and not to its component parts, so that it is not surprising that heat should not be generated.

We believe there is no negative instance here either. We know of no tangible body that does not become noticeably warm through friction. Indeed, the ancients imagined that the gods could create heat only by spinning air rapidly and violently, producing friction. However, this point needs further investigation. Do objects launched by machines, such as cannonballs, gain some heat from passing through the air? Does this make them somewhat warm when they fall? Moving air cools rather than heats, as with winds, bellows, or breath blown through pursed lips. In these cases, however, the motion is not fast enough to produce heat. It also moves the air as a body, rather than moving its component parts. So it is not surprising that no heat is generated.

We must make a more diligent inquiry into this instance; for herbs and green and moist vegetables appear to possess a latent heat, so small, however, as not to be perceived by the touch in single specimens, but when they are united and confined, so that their spirit cannot exhale into the air, and they rather warm each other, their heat is at once manifested, and even flame occasionally in suitable substances.

We must examine this instance more carefully. Herbs and green, moist vegetables seem to contain hidden heat. In individual plants, however, the heat is too slight to feel. But when they are gathered and confined, their spirit cannot escape into the air, and they warm each other instead. Their heat then becomes apparent at once, and suitable substances sometimes even burst into flame.

Here, too, we must make a more diligent inquiry; for quicklime, when sprinkled with water, appears to conceive heat, either from its being collected into one point (as we observed of herbs when confined), or from the irritation and exasperation of the fiery spirit by water, which occasions a conflict and struggle. The true reason will more readily be shown if oil be used instead of water, for oil will equally tend to collect the confined spirit, but not to irritate. The experiment may be made more general, both by using the ashes and calcined products of different bodies and by pouring different liquids upon them.

Here, too, we must investigate more carefully. When sprinkled with water, quicklime seems to generate heat. This may happen because its heat gathers in one place, as we observed with herbs when confined. Or the water may irritate and excite the fiery spirit, causing a conflict and struggle. The true reason will be easier to determine if oil is used instead of water. Oil will be just as likely to gather the confined spirit, but it will not irritate it. The experiment can be broadened by using ashes and calcined products from different materials and pouring different liquids on them.

A negative instance may be subjoined of other metals which are more soft and soluble; for leaf gold dissolved by aqua regia, or lead by aqua fortis, are not warm to the touch while dissolving, no more is quicksilver (as far as I remember), but silver excites a slight heat, and so does copper, and tin yet more plainly, and most of all iron and steel, which excite not only a powerful heat, but a violent bubbling. The heat, therefore, appears to be occasioned by the struggle which takes place when these strong dissolvents penetrate, dig into, and tear asunder the parts of those substances, while the substances themselves resist. When, however, the substances yield more easily, scarcely any heat is excited.

A negative example can be found in other metals that are softer and more soluble. Gold leaf dissolved in aqua regia, or lead dissolved in aqua fortis, does not feel warm while dissolving. As far as I remember, neither does mercury. But silver produces a little heat, as does copper. Tin produces more noticeable heat. Iron and steel produce the most heat, as well as violent bubbling. The heat, therefore, seems to come from a struggle. The strong solvents penetrate, dig into, and tear apart the substances, while the substances themselves resist. When the substances yield more easily, however, hardly any heat is produced.

There is no negative instance with regard to the heat of animals, except in insects (as has been observed), owing to their small size; for in fishes, as compared with land animals, a lower degree rather than a deprivation of heat is observable. In plants and vegetables, both as to their exudations and pith when freshly exposed, there is no sensible degree of heat. But in animals there is a great difference in the degree, both in particular parts (for the heat varies near the heart, the brain, and the extremities) and in the circumstances in which they are placed, such as violent exercise and fevers.

As noted, insects are the only exception to the presence of heat in animals, because they are so small. Fish have less heat than land animals, but they do not lack it entirely. In plants and vegetables, neither their secretions nor their freshly exposed pith show any perceptible heat. But in animals, the degree of heat varies greatly. It varies between body parts, such as the heart, brain, and extremities. It also varies with conditions such as strenuous exercise and fever.

Here, again, there is scarcely a negative instance. I might add that the excrements of animals, even when they are no longer fresh, possess evidently some effective heat, as is shown by their enriching the soil.

Here again, there is hardly any example to the contrary. I might add that animal waste, even when no longer fresh, evidently has some active heat. Its ability to enrich the soil shows this.

Such liquids (whether oily or watery) as are intensely acrid exhibit the effects of heat, by the separation and burning of bodies after some little action upon them, yet they are not at first warm to the touch, but they act according to their affinity and the pores of the substances to which they are applied; for aqua regia dissolves gold but not silver—on the contrary, aqua fortis dissolves silver but not gold; neither of them dissolves glass, and so of the rest.

Highly acrid liquids, whether oily or watery, produce effects like heat. After acting on substances for a short time, they separate and burn them. Yet these liquids are not warm to the touch at first. Instead, they act according to their affinity with the substances and the pores of those substances. For example, aqua regia dissolves gold but not silver. Aqua fortis, by contrast, dissolves silver but not gold. Neither dissolves glass, and the same holds for other substances.

Let spirits of wine be tried on wood, or butter, wax, or pitch, to see if this will melt them at all by their heat; for the twenty-fourth instance shows that they possess properties resembling those of heat in causing incrustation. Let an experiment also be made with a graduated glass or calendar, concave at the top, by pouring well-rectified spirits of wine into the cavity, and covering it up in order that they may the better retain their heat, then observe whether their heat make the water descend.

Test spirits of wine on wood, butter, wax, or pitch to see if their heat melts any of them. For the twenty-fourth instance shows that spirits of wine have properties resembling those of heat in causing a crust to form. Also experiment with a graduated glass or calendar, with a hollow at the top. Pour well-refined spirits of wine into the hollow and cover it so that the spirits retain their heat better. Then observe whether their heat makes the water go down.

See .

Spices and acrid herbs are sensibly warm to the palate, and still more so when taken internally; one should see, therefore, on what other substances they exhibit the effects of heat. Now, sailors tell us that when large quantities of spices are suddenly opened, after having been shut up for some time, there is some danger of fever and inflammation to those who stir them or take them out. An experiment might, therefore, be made whether such spices and herbs, when produced, will, like smoke, dry fish and meat hung up over them.

Spices and pungent herbs feel warm on the tongue, and even warmer when swallowed. We should therefore see what other substances they affect as heat would. Sailors tell us of large quantities of spices being suddenly uncovered after being shut up for some time. Those who stir or remove the spices then run some risk of fever and inflammation. We might therefore test whether such spices and herbs, when brought out, can dry fish and meat hung above them, as smoke does.

There is an acrid effect and a degree of penetration in cold liquids, such as vinegar and oil of vitriol, as well as in warm, such as oil of marjoram and the like; they have, therefore, an equal effect in causing animated substances to smart, and separating and consuming inanimate parts. There is not any negative instance as to this, nor does there exist any animal pain unaccompanied by the sensation of heat.

Cold liquids, such as vinegar and oil of vitriol, can be sharp and penetrating. So can warm liquids, such as oil of marjoram and the like. Both therefore have the same effect: they cause living tissue to sting and separate and consume nonliving matter. There are no exceptions to this, and no animal pain occurs without a sensation of heat.

There are many effects common to cold and heat, however different in their process; for snowballs appear to burn boys’ hands after a little time, and cold no less than fire preserves bodies from putrefaction—besides both heat and cold contract bodies. But it is better to refer these instances and the like to the investigation of cold.

Cold and heat have many effects in common, though they work differently. For example, snowballs seem to burn boys’ hands after a short time. Cold also preserves bodies from decay just as fire does. Both heat and cold cause bodies to contract. But it is better to consider these and similar examples when investigating cold.

XIII

13

In the third place we must exhibit to the understanding the instances in which that nature, which is the object of our inquiries, is present in a greater or less degree, either by comparing its increase and decrease in the same object, or its degree in different objects; for since the form of a thing is its very essence, and the thing only differs from its form as the apparent from the actual object, or the exterior from the interior, or that which is considered with relation to man from that which is considered with relation to the universe; it necessarily follows that no nature can be considered a real form which does not uniformly diminish and increase with the given nature. We are wont to call this our Table of Degrees, or Comparative Instances.

Third, we must present to the understanding instances in which the nature we are investigating is present to a greater or lesser degree. We do this by comparing its increase and decrease in the same object, or its degree in different objects. The form of a thing is its very essence. The thing differs from its form only as appearance differs from reality, or as the exterior differs from the interior. It also differs as something considered in relation to humans differs from something considered in relation to the universe. It necessarily follows that no nature can be considered a real form unless it consistently diminishes and increases with the given nature. We call this our Table of Degrees, or Comparative Instances.

Table of the Degrees or Comparative Instances of Heat

Table of Degrees or Comparative Examples of Heat

We will first speak of those bodies which exhibit no degree of heat sensible to the touch, but appear rather to possess a potential heat, or disposition and preparation for it. We will then go on to others, which are actually warm to the touch, and observe the strength and degree of it.

We will first discuss bodies that do not feel warm to the touch. Instead, they seem to have potential heat, or a readiness to become warm. We will then turn to bodies that do feel warm and observe how strong their heat is.

1. There is no known solid or tangible body which is by its own nature originally warm; for neither stone, metal, sulphur, fossils, wood, water, nor dead animal carcasses are found warm. The warm springs in baths appear to be heated accidentally, by flame, subterraneous fire (such as is thrown up by Etna and many other mountains), or by the contact of certain bodies, as heat is exhibited in the dissolution of iron and tin. The degree of heat, therefore, in inanimate objects is not sensible to our touch; but they differ in their degrees of cold, for wood and metal are not equally cold. This, however, belongs to the Table of Degrees of Cold. 2. But with regard to potential heat and predisposition to flame, we find many inanimate substances wonderfully adapted to it, as sulphur, naphtha, and saltpetre. 3. Bodies which have previously acquired heat, as horse dung from the animal, or lime, and perhaps ashes and soot from fire, retain some latent portion of it. Hence distillations and separations of substances are effected by burying them in horse dung, and heat is excited in lime by sprinkling it with water (as has been before observed). 4. In the vegetable world we know of no plant, nor part of any plant (as the exudations or pith) that is warm to man’s touch. Yet (as we have before observed) green weeds grow warm when confined, and some vegetables are warm and others cold to our internal touch, i.e., the palate and stomach, or even after a while to our external skin (as is shown in plasters and ointments). 5. We know of nothing in the various parts of animals, when dead or detached from the rest, that is warm to the touch; for horse dung itself does not retain its heat, unless it be confined and buried. All dung, however, appears to possess a potential heat, as in manuring fields; so also dead bodies are endued with this latent and potential heat to such a degree, that in cemeteries where people are interred daily the earth acquires a secret heat, which consumes any recently deposited body much sooner than pure earth; and they tell you that the people of the East are acquainted with a fine soft cloth, made of the down of birds, which can melt butter wrapped gently up in it by its own warmth. 6. Manures, such as every kind of dung, chalk, sea-sand, salt and the like, have some disposition toward heat. 7. All putrefaction exhibits some slight degree of heat, though not enough to be perceptible by the touch; for neither the substances which by putrefaction are converted into animalculæ, as flesh and cheese, nor rotten wood which shines in the dark, are warm to the touch. The heat, however, of putrid substances displays itself occasionally in a disgusting and strong scent. 8. The first degree of heat, therefore, in substances which are warm to the human touch appears to be that of animals, and this admits of a great variety of degrees, for the lowest (as in insects) is scarcely perceptible, the highest scarcely equals that of the sun’s rays in warm climates and weather, and is not so acute as to be insufferable to the hand. It is said, however, of Constantius, and some others of a very dry constitution and habit of body, that when attacked with violent fevers, they became so warm as to appear almost to burn the hand applied to them. 9. Animals become more warm by motion and exercise, wine and feasting, venery, burning fevers, and grief. 10. In the paroxysm of intermittent fevers the patients are at first seized with cold and shivering, but soon afterward become more heated than at first—in burning and pestilential fevers they are hot from the beginning. 11. Let further inquiry be made into the comparative heat of different animals, as fishes, quadrupeds, serpents, birds, and also of the different species, as the lion, the kite, or man; for, according to the vulgar opinion, fishes are the least warm internally, and birds the most, particularly doves, hawks, and ostriches. 12. Let further inquiry be made as to the comparative heat in different parts and limbs of the same animal; for milk, blood, seed, and eggs are moderately warm, and less hot than the outward flesh of the animal when in motion or agitated. The degree of heat of the brain, stomach, heart, and the rest, has not yet been equally well investigated. 13. All animals are externally cold in winter and cold weather, but are thought to be internally warmer. 14. The heat of the heavenly bodies, even in the warmest climates and seasons, never reaches such a pitch as to light or burn the driest wood or straw, or even tinder without the aid of burning-glasses. It can, however, raise vapor from moist substances. 15. Astronomers tell us that some stars are hotter than others. Mars is considered the warmest after the Sun, then Jupiter, then Venus. The Moon and, above all, Saturn, are considered to be cold. Among the fixed stars Sirius is thought the warmest, then Cor Leonis or Regulus, then the lesser Dog-star. 16. The sun gives out more heat as it approaches toward the perpendicular or zenith, which may be supposed to be the case with the other planets, according to their degree of heat; for instance, that Jupiter gives out more heat when situated beneath Cancer or Leo than when he is beneath Capricorn and Aquarius. 17. It is to be supposed that the sun and other planets give more heat in perigee, from their approximation to the earth, than when in apogee. But if in any country the sun should be both in its perigee and nearer to the perpendicular at the same time, it must necessarily give out more heat than in a country where it is also in perigee, but situated more obliquely; so that the comparative altitude of the planets should be observed, and their approach to or declination from the perpendicular in different countries. 18. The sun and other planets are thought also to give out more heat in proportion as they are nearer to the larger fixed stars, as when the sun is in Leo he is nearer Cor Leonis, Cauda Leonis, Spica Virginis, Sirius, and the lesser Dog-star, than when he is in Cancer, where, however, he approaches nearer to the perpendicular. It is probable, also, that the quarters of the heavens produce a greater heat (though not perceptibly), in proportion as they are adorned with a greater number of stars, particularly those of the first magnitude. 19. On the whole, the heat of the heavenly bodies is augmented in three ways: 1. The approach to the perpendicular; 2. Proximity or their perigee; 3. The conjunction or union of stars. 20. There is a very considerable difference between the degree of heat in animals, and even in the rays of the heavenly bodies (as they reach us), and the heat of the most gentle flame, and even of all ignited substances, nay, liquids, or the air itself when unusually heated by fire. For the flame of spirit of wine, though diffused and uncollected, is yet able to set straw, linen, or paper on fire, which animal heat, or that of the sun, will never accomplish without a burning-glass. 21. There are, however, many degrees of strength and weakness in flame and ignited bodies: but no diligent inquiry has been made in this respect, and we must, therefore, pass it hastily over. Of all flames, that of spirits of wine appears to be the most gentle, except perhaps the ignis fatuus, or the flashes from the perspiration of animals. After this we should be inclined to place the flame of light and porous vegetables, such as straw, reeds, and dried leaves; from which the flame of hair or feathers differs but little. Then, perhaps, comes the flame of wood, particularly that which contains but little rosin or pitch; that of small wood, however (such as is usually tied up in fagots), is milder than that of the trunks or roots of trees. This can be easily tried in iron furnaces, where a fire of fagots or branches of trees is of little service. Next follows the flame of oil, tallow, wax, and the like oily and fat substances, which are not very violent. But a most powerful heat is found in pitch and rosin, and a still greater in sulphur, camphor, naphtha, saltpetre, and salts (after they have discharged their crude matter), and in their compounds; as in gunpowder, Greek fire (vulgarly called wild fire), and its varieties, which possess such a stubborn heat as scarcely to be extinguished by water. 22. We consider that the flame which results from some imperfect metals is very strong and active; but on all these points further inquiry should be made. 23. The flame of vivid lightning appears to exceed all the above, so as sometimes to have melted even wrought iron into drops, which the other flames cannot accomplish. 24. In ignited bodies there are different degrees of heat, concerning which, also, a diligent inquiry has not been made. We consider the faintest heat to be that of tinder, touchwood, and dry rope match, such as is used for discharging cannon. Next follows that of ignited charcoal or cinders, and even bricks, and the like; but the most violent is that of ignited metals, as iron, copper, and the like. Further inquiry, however, must be made into this also. 25. Some ignited bodies are found to be much warmer than some flames; for instance, red hot iron is much warmer, and burns more than the flame of spirits of wine. 26. Some bodies even not ignited, but only heated by the fire, as boiling water, and the air confined in reverberatories, surpass in heat many flames and ignited substances. 27. Motion increases heat, as is shown in the bellows and the blowpipe; for the harder metals are not dissolved or melted by steady quiet fire, without the aid of the blowpipe. 28. Let an experiment be made with burning-glasses; in which respect I have observed, that if a glass be placed at the distance of ten inches, for instance, from the combustible object, it does not kindle or burn it so readily, as if the glass be placed at the distance of five inches (for instance), and be then gradually and slowly withdrawn to the distance of ten inches. The cone and focus of the rays, however, are the same, but the mere motion increases the effect of the heat. 29. Conflagrations, which take place with a high wind, are thought to make greater way against than with the wind, because when the wind slackens, the flame recoils more rapidly than it advances when the wind is favorable. 30. Flame does not burst out or arise unless it have some hollow space to move and exert itself in, except in the exploding flame of gunpowder, and the like, where the compression and confinement of the flame increase its fury. 31. The anvil becomes so hot by the hammer, that if it were a thin plate it might probably grow red, like ignited iron by repeated strokes. Let the experiment be tried. 32. But in ignited bodies that are porous, so as to leave room for the fire to move itself, if its motion be prevented by strong compression, the fire is immediately extinguished; thus it is with tinder, or the burning snuff of a candle or lamp, or even hot charcoal or cinders; for when they are squeezed by snuffers, or the foot, and the like, the effect of the fire instantly ceases. 33. The approach toward a hot body increases heat in proportion to the approximation; a similar effect to that of light, for the nearer any object is placed toward the light, the more visible it becomes. 34. The union of different heats increases heat, unless the substances be mixed; for a large and small fire in the same spot tend mutually to increase each other’s heat, but lukewarm water poured into boiling water cools it. 35. The continued neighborhood of a warm body increases heat. For the heat, which perpetually passes and emanates from it, being mixed with that which preceded it, multiplies the whole. A fire, for instance, does not warm a room in half an hour as much as the same fire would in an hour. This does not apply to light, for a lamp or candle placed in a spot gives no more light by remaining there, than it did at first. 36. The irritation of surrounding cold increases heat, as may be seen in fires during a sharp frost. We think that this is owing not merely to the confinement and compression of the heat (which forms a sort of union), but also by the exasperation of it, as when the air or a stick are violently compressed or bent, they recoil, not only to the point they first occupied, but still further back. Let an accurate experiment, therefore, be made with a stick, or something of the kind, put into the flame, in order to see whether it be not sooner burned at the sides than in the middle of it. 37. There are many degrees in the susceptibility of heat. And, first, it must be observed how much a low gentle heat changes and partially warms even the bodies least susceptible of it. For even the heat of the hand imparts a little warmth to a ball of lead or other metal held a short time in it; so easily is heat transmitted and excited, without any apparent change in the body. 38. Of all bodies that we are acquainted with, air admits and loses heat the most readily, which is admirably seen in weather-glasses, whose construction is as follows: Take a glass with a hollow belly, and a thin and long neck; turn it upside down, and place it with its mouth downward into another glass vessel containing water; the end of the tube touching the bottom of the vessel, and the tube itself leaning a little on the edge, so as to be fixed upright. In order to do this more readily, let a little wax be applied to the edge, not, however, so as to block up the orifice, lest, by preventing the air from escaping, the motion, which we shall presently speak of, and which is very gentle and delicate, should be impeded. Before the first glass be inserted in the other, its upper part (the belly) should be warmed at the fire. Then upon placing it as we have described, the air (which was dilated by the heat), after a sufficient time has been allowed for it to lose the additional temperature, will restore and contract itself to the same dimensions as that of the external or common atmosphere at the moment of immersion, and the water will be attracted upward in the tube to a proportionate extent. A long narrow slip of paper should be attached to the tube, divided into as many degrees as you please. You will then perceive, as the weather grows warmer or colder, that the air contracts itself into a narrower space in cold weather and dilates in the warm, which will be exhibited by the rising of the water as the air contracts itself, and its depression as the air dilates. The sensibility of the air with regard to heat or cold is so delicate and exquisite, that it far exceeds the human touch, so that a ray of sunshine, the heat of the breath, and much more, that of the hand placed on the top of the tube, immediately causes an evident depression of the water. We think, however, that the spirit of animals possesses a much more delicate susceptibility of heat and cold, only that it is impeded and blunted by the grossness of their bodies. 39. After air, we consider those bodies to be most sensible of heat, which have been recently changed and contracted by cold, as snow and ice; for they begin to be dissolved and melt with the first mild weather. Next, perhaps, follows quicksilver; then greasy substances, as oil, butter, and the like; then wood; then water; lastly, stones and metals, which do not easily grow hot, particularly toward their centre. When heated, however, they retain their temperature for a very long time; so that a brick or stone, or hot iron, plunged in a basin of cold water, and kept there for a quarter of an hour or thereabout, retains such a heat as not to admit of being touched. 40. The less massive the body is, the more readily it grows warm at the approach of a heated body, which shows that heat with us is somewhat averse to a tangible mass. 41. Heat with regard to the human senses and touch is various and relative, so that lukewarm water appears hot if the hand be cold, and cold if the hand be hot.

1. No known solid or tangible body is naturally warm on its own. Stone, metal, sulphur, fossils, wood, water, and dead animal carcasses are not found warm. The warm springs used for baths seem to be heated by external causes. These may include flames, underground fire, such as Etna and many other mountains throw up, or contact with certain substances. Such contact produces heat when iron and tin are dissolved. The heat of inanimate objects, then, cannot be felt by touch. But these objects differ in their degrees of cold, for wood and metal are not equally cold. This, however, belongs in the Table of Degrees of Cold. 2. But many inanimate substances are remarkably suited to potential heat and to catching fire. These include sulphur, naphtha, and saltpetre. 3. Bodies that have previously acquired heat retain some hidden part of it. Examples include horse dung, which gets heat from the animal, and lime, and perhaps ashes and soot, which get it from fire. Thus substances are distilled and separated by burying them in horse dung. Heat is also stirred up in lime by sprinkling it with water, as noted earlier. 4. We know of no plant, or part of a plant, that feels warm to the human touch. This includes its secretions and pith. Yet, as noted earlier, green weeds grow warm when confined. Some plants feel warm and others cold to our internal sense of touch, that is, to the palate and stomach. After a while, they may even feel warm or cold on our skin, as plasters and ointments show. 5. We know of no animal part that feels warm when dead or detached from the rest. Even horse dung does not retain its heat unless it is confined and buried. All dung, however, seems to possess potential heat, as it does when used to manure fields. Dead bodies also possess this hidden, potential heat to a considerable degree. In cemeteries where people are buried daily, the earth acquires a hidden heat. This consumes a newly buried body much sooner than pure earth would. People also say that in the East there is a fine, soft cloth made from bird down. They say its own warmth can melt butter gently wrapped in it. 6. Manures such as all kinds of dung, chalk, sea sand, salt, and similar substances have some tendency toward heat. 7. All decay shows some slight degree of heat, though not enough to be felt by touch. Flesh and cheese, which decay into animalculæ, do not feel warm. Neither does rotten wood that glows in the dark. Sometimes, however, the heat of decaying substances reveals itself in a strong and disgusting smell. 8. The first degree of heat felt by the human touch therefore seems to be animal heat. This varies greatly in degree. At its lowest, as in insects, it is barely noticeable. At its highest, it barely equals the sun’s rays in warm climates and weather. It is not so intense that the hand cannot bear it. It is said, however, that Constantius and some others had a very dry constitution and bodily habit. When struck by violent fevers, they became so hot that they seemed almost to burn a hand laid on them. 9. Animals become warmer through movement and exercise, wine and feasting, sexual activity, burning fevers, and grief. 10. During an attack of intermittent fever, patients are first seized by cold and shivering. Soon afterward, however, they become hotter than before. In burning and pestilential fevers, they are hot from the beginning. 11. Further inquiry should compare the heat of different kinds of animals, such as fish, quadrupeds, snakes, and birds. It should also compare different species, such as the lion, the kite, and man. According to common opinion, fish are the least warm internally, and birds the warmest, especially doves, hawks, and ostriches. 12. Further inquiry should also compare the heat of different parts and limbs of the same animal. Milk, blood, semen, and eggs are moderately warm. They are less hot than the animal’s outer flesh when it is moving or agitated. The heat of the brain, stomach, heart, and other parts has not yet been investigated as thoroughly. 13. All animals are cold on the outside in winter and cold weather, but they are thought to be warmer inside. 14. Even in the warmest climates and seasons, the heat of the heavenly bodies never reaches the point of igniting or burning the driest wood, straw, or even tinder without the help of burning glasses. It can, however, raise vapor from moist substances. 15. Astronomers tell us that some stars are hotter than others. Mars is considered the warmest after the Sun, followed by Jupiter and then Venus. The Moon and, above all, Saturn are considered cold. Among the fixed stars, Sirius is thought to be the warmest, followed by Cor Leonis or Regulus, and then the lesser Dog-star. 16. The sun gives out more heat as it approaches a position directly overhead, or the zenith. The same may be supposed of the other planets, according to their degree of heat. For example, Jupiter may give out more heat beneath Cancer or Leo than beneath Capricorn and Aquarius. 17. The sun and other planets may be supposed to give more heat in perigee, when they are closer to the earth, than in apogee. But suppose the sun is both in perigee and nearer to directly overhead in one country. It must then give out more heat there than in a country where it is also in perigee but stands at a more slanting angle. We should therefore observe the planets’ comparative height and how close they come to, or how far they move from, a position directly overhead in different countries. 18. The sun and other planets are also thought to give out more heat when they are closer to the larger fixed stars. For example, when the sun is in Leo, it is nearer Cor Leonis, Cauda Leonis, Spica Virginis, Sirius, and the lesser Dog-star than when it is in Cancer. In Cancer, however, the sun comes closer to a position directly overhead. It is also probable that parts of the heavens produce more heat, though not noticeably so, when they are adorned with more stars, especially stars of the first magnitude. 19. Overall, the heat of the heavenly bodies increases in three ways: 1. Their approach toward a position directly overhead. 2. Their nearness, or perigee. 3. The conjunction or joining of stars. 20. There is a considerable difference between the heat of animals, or even of the rays of heavenly bodies as they reach us, and the heat of the gentlest flame. The same difference holds for all glowing substances, and even for liquids or air unusually heated by fire. For the flame of spirits of wine can set straw, linen, or paper on fire, even when the flame is spread out rather than concentrated. Animal heat and the sun’s heat will never do this without a burning glass. 21. Flames and glowing bodies, however, vary greatly in strength and weakness. No careful inquiry has been made into these differences, so we must pass over them quickly. Of all flames, that of spirits of wine seems the gentlest, except perhaps the ignis fatuus or the flashes from animal perspiration. Next we would be inclined to place the flame of light, porous plants, such as straw, reeds, and dried leaves. The flame of hair or feathers differs little from these. Then perhaps comes the flame of wood, especially wood with little resin or pitch. Small pieces of wood, such as those usually tied in bundles, produce a milder flame than tree trunks or roots. This can easily be tested in iron furnaces, where a fire of bundles or branches is of little use. Next comes the flame of oil, tallow, wax, and similar oily and fatty substances. These flames are not very fierce. But pitch and resin produce a very powerful heat. An even greater heat is found in sulphur, camphor, naphtha, saltpetre, and salts after they have discharged their crude matter. The same is true of their compounds, such as gunpowder, Greek fire (commonly called wild fire), and its varieties. These have such a stubborn heat that water can scarcely put them out. 22. We believe that the flame produced by some imperfect metals is very strong and active. But all these points need further inquiry. 23. The flame of vivid lightning seems to exceed all these. It has sometimes even melted wrought iron into drops, which the other flames cannot do. 24. Glowing bodies also have different degrees of heat, and these too have not been carefully investigated. We believe the faintest heat is that of tinder, touchwood, and dry rope match, such as is used to fire cannon. Next comes the heat of glowing charcoal or cinders, and even of bricks and similar materials. But the most intense heat is that of glowing metals, such as iron and copper. This too, however, needs further inquiry. 25. Some glowing bodies are found to be much hotter than some flames. Red-hot iron, for example, is much hotter than the flame of spirits of wine and burns more. 26. Some bodies are not even glowing but are merely heated by fire. These include boiling water and air confined in reverberatory furnaces. They surpass many flames and glowing substances in heat. 27. Motion increases heat, as bellows and the blowpipe show. The harder metals cannot be dissolved or melted by a steady, quiet fire without the help of the blowpipe. 28. Let an experiment be made with burning glasses. I have observed that a glass placed, for example, ten inches from a combustible object does not ignite or burn it as readily as one placed five inches away and then gradually withdrawn to ten inches. Yet the cone and focus of the rays are the same. The motion alone increases the effect of the heat. 29. Fires that occur in a high wind are thought to make more progress against the wind than with it. This is because, when the wind slackens, the flame springs back more quickly than it advances when the wind favors it. 30. Flame does not burst out or arise unless it has some hollow space in which to move and act. The exception is the exploding flame of gunpowder and similar substances, where compression and confinement increase the flame’s fury. 31. Hammering makes an anvil so hot that, if it were a thin plate, it might probably turn red like glowing iron under repeated blows. Let the experiment be tried. 32. But some glowing bodies are porous, leaving room for the fire to move. If strong compression prevents that movement, the fire goes out immediately. This happens with tinder, the burning wick of a candle or lamp, and even hot charcoal or cinders. When these are squeezed with snuffers, a foot, or something similar, the fire’s effect stops at once. 33. Moving closer to a hot body increases heat in proportion to the closeness. Light has a similar effect, for the nearer an object is placed to a light, the more visible it becomes. 34. The joining of different sources of heat increases heat, unless the substances are mixed. A large fire and a small fire in the same place increase each other’s heat. But lukewarm water poured into boiling water cools it. 35. Remaining near a warm body increases heat. The heat continually passes out from the warm body and joins the heat that came before, increasing the total. For example, a fire does not warm a room as much in half an hour as the same fire does in an hour. This does not apply to light. A lamp or candle left in one place gives no more light by remaining there than it did at first. 36. The irritation caused by surrounding cold increases heat, as fires during a sharp frost show. We think this happens not merely because the heat is confined and compressed, which forms a kind of union. We think the heat is also provoked, as when air or a stick is violently compressed or bent. It springs back not only to its original position, but even farther. Let a careful experiment therefore be made by putting a stick or something similar into a flame. The aim is to see whether it burns sooner at the sides than in the middle. 37. Bodies vary greatly in how readily they take in heat. First, we should notice how much a low, gentle heat changes and partly warms even the bodies least receptive to it. Even the heat of a hand gives a little warmth to a lead ball or other metal held in it briefly. Heat is transmitted and stirred up so easily, without any visible change in the body. 38. Of all the bodies we know, air takes in and loses heat most readily. Weather glasses show this remarkably well. They are made as follows: Take a glass vessel with a hollow bulb and a long, thin neck. Turn it upside down and place its open end in another glass vessel containing water. The end of the tube should touch the bottom of the vessel, and the tube should lean slightly against the rim so that it stays upright. To make this easier, apply a little wax to the rim. Do not block the opening, however. That would prevent air from escaping and hinder the very gentle, delicate movement we will describe shortly. Before placing the first glass in the other, warm its upper part, the bulb, at the fire. Then place it as described. The air, which the heat expanded, will gradually lose its added warmth. It will return to the same volume it had at the temperature of the surrounding air when the glass was immersed. The water will then be drawn a corresponding distance up the tube. Attach a long, narrow strip of paper to the tube and divide it into as many degrees as you please. You will then see that, as the weather changes, the air contracts into a smaller space in cold weather and expands in warm weather. The water rises as the air contracts and falls as it expands. Air is so delicately sensitive to heat and cold that it far surpasses human touch. A ray of sunshine or the warmth of a breath immediately makes the water fall visibly. The heat of a hand placed on top of the tube has an even greater effect. We think, however, that the spirit of animals is much more sensitive to heat and cold. Its sensitivity is only hindered and dulled by the coarseness of their bodies. 39. After air, we believe the bodies most sensitive to heat are those recently changed and contracted by cold, such as snow and ice. They begin to dissolve and melt at the first mild weather. Next, perhaps, comes quicksilver. Then come greasy substances such as oil and butter, followed by wood, water, and finally stones and metals. Stones and metals do not heat up easily, especially toward their centers. Once heated, however, they retain their temperature for a very long time. A brick, stone, or piece of hot iron can be plunged into a basin of cold water and kept there for about a quarter of an hour. Even then, it remains too hot to touch. 40. The less massive a body is, the more readily it grows warm when a heated body approaches. This shows that heat, as we experience it, is somewhat averse to a tangible mass. 41. Heat as perceived by the human senses and touch varies and is relative. Lukewarm water feels hot if the hand is cold, and cold if the hand is hot.

Bacon mistakes a sensation within ourselves for an inherent property of different substances. Metals are denser than wood. When we touch metals, our bodies therefore come into contact with more particles of matter. As a result, our bodies lose more heat than when we touch lighter substances. Ed.

This was the ancient view. But modern writers tend to believe that these insects reproduce from seeds deposited by their kind in bodies about to decay. Ed.

The activity of a flame is measured by multiplying its natural force by the square of its velocity. This is why the vivid lightning mentioned in has so much force. Its velocity is greater than that produced by other heat. Ed.

The fires supply fresh heat, but the water contains only a certain amount of heat. As this heat spreads through a fresh supply of cooler water, the overall temperature must fall.

Bacon concludes that if condensation caused greater heat, the center of the flame would be hotter, and vice versa. In fact, neither cause Bacon gives is correct. The fire burns faster only because the airflow is faster. Cold, dense air rushes into the heated room and toward the chimney. Ed.

Bacon appears to have confused the ability to burn or melt with the ability to absorb heat. Metals certainly do not melt as quickly as ice or butter, or burn as quickly as wood. But this only shows that different materials need different degrees of heat to produce similar effects. Metals absorb and transmit the same degree of heat much more readily than any of those materials. This rapid transmission generally makes metals feel cold to the touch. The usefulness of wooden handles on vessels containing hot water illustrates these points.

Another striking error. In fact, solid bodies are the best conductors. But of course, when heat spreads through a large mass, each part receives less than if it alone absorbed the whole amount. Ed.

XIV

14

Any one may readily see how poor we are in history, since in the above tables, besides occasionally inserting traditions and report instead of approved history and authentic instances (always, however, adding some note if their credit or authority be doubtful), we are often forced to subjoin, “Let the experiment be tried—Let further inquiry be made.”

Anyone can see how little reliable historical evidence we have. In the tables above, we sometimes include traditions and reports instead of verified history and authentic examples. We always note when their reliability or authority is doubtful. We are also often forced to add, “Let the experiment be tried. Let further inquiry be made.”

XV

15

We are wont to term the office and use of these three tables the presenting a review of instances to the understanding; and when this has been done, induction itself is to be brought into action. For on an individual review of all the instances a nature is to be found, such as always to be present and absent with the given nature, to increase and decrease with it, and, as we have said, to form a more common limit of the nature. If the mind attempt this affirmatively from the first (which it always will when left to itself), there will spring up phantoms, mere theories and ill-defined notions, with axioms requiring daily correction. These will, doubtless, be better or worse, according to the power and strength of the understanding which creates them. But it is only for God (the bestower and creator of forms), and perhaps for angels and intelligences, at once to recognize forms affirmatively at the first glance of contemplation: man, at lest, is unable to do so, and is only allowed to proceed first by negatives, and then to conclude with affirmatives, after every species of exclusion.

We usually say that these three tables present instances for the mind to review. Once this has been done, induction itself must begin. Each instance must be examined to find a nature that is always present or absent with the given nature. It must also increase and decrease with it and, as we have said, form a more general limit of the nature. If the mind tries to do this by affirmation from the start, it will produce phantoms, mere theories, and vague notions. The mind will always do this if left to itself. It will also produce axioms that need correcting every day. These results will no doubt be better or worse, depending on the power and strength of the mind that creates them. But only God, the giver and creator of forms, and perhaps angels and intelligences, can recognize forms affirmatively at first glance. Human beings, at least, cannot do so. They can only begin with negatives and then reach affirmations after every kind of exclusion.

XVI

16

We must, therefore, effect a complete solution and separation of nature; not by fire, but by the mind, that divine fire. The first work of legitimate induction, in the discovery of forms, is rejection, or the exclusive instances of individual natures, which are not found in some one instance where the given nature is present, or are found in any one instance where it is absent, or are found to increase in any one instance where the given nature decreases, or the reverse. After an exclusion correctly effected, an affirmative form will remain as the residuum, solid, true, and well defined, while all volatile opinions go off in smoke. This is readily said; but we must arrive at it by a circuitous route. We shall perhaps, however, omit nothing that can facilitate our progress.

We must, therefore, completely break down and separate nature. We must do this not by fire, but by the mind, that divine fire. In discovering forms, the first task of sound induction is to reject certain individual natures. We must reject any nature that is missing from even one instance where the given nature is present. We must also reject any nature found in even one instance where the given nature is absent. Finally, we must reject any nature that increases in even one instance where the given nature decreases, or vice versa. Once we have made these exclusions correctly, an affirmative form will remain. It will be solid, true, and well defined, while all fleeting opinions go off in smoke. This is easy to say, but we must take a roundabout path to reach it. Perhaps, however, we shall leave out nothing that can make our progress easier.

XVII

17

The first and almost perpetual precaution and warning which we consider necessary is this; that none should suppose from the great part assigned by us to forms, that we mean such forms as the meditations and thoughts of men have hitherto been accustomed to. In the first place, we do not at present mean the concrete forms, which (as we have observed) are in the common course of things compounded of simple natures, as those of a lion, an eagle, a rose, gold, or the like. The moment for discussing these will arrive when we come to treat of the latent process and latent conformation, and the discovery of them as they exist in what are called substances, or concrete natures.

The first warning we consider necessary applies almost constantly. No one should assume that the forms we give such importance to are the forms people have traditionally imagined and thought about. First, we do not mean concrete forms for now. As we have noted, these are ordinarily composed of simple natures. Examples include the forms of a lion, an eagle, a rose, or gold. We will discuss these forms when we turn to the latent process and latent conformation. We will then consider how to discover them in what are called substances, or concrete natures.

Nor again, would we be thought to mean (even when treating of simple natures) any abstract forms or ideas, either undefined or badly defined in matter. For when we speak of forms, we mean nothing else than those laws and regulations of simple action which arrange and constitute any simple nature, such as heat, light, weight, in every species of matter, and in a susceptible subject. The form of heat or form of light, therefore, means no more than the law of heat or the law of light. Nor do we ever abstract or withdraw ourselves from things, and the operative branch of philosophy. When, therefore, we say (for instance) in our investigation of the form of heat, Reject rarity, or, Rarity is not of the form of heat, it is the same as if we were to say, Man can superinduce heat on a dense body, or the reverse, Man can abstract or ward off heat from a rare body.

We also do not mean abstract forms or ideas, even when discussing simple natures. Nor do we mean forms or ideas that are undefined or badly defined in matter. By forms, we mean only the laws and rules of simple action. These arrange and constitute any simple nature, such as heat, light, or weight. They do so in every kind of matter and in any subject capable of receiving that nature. The form of heat or light, therefore, means nothing more than the law of heat or light. Nor do we ever turn away from things or from the practical branch of philosophy. Suppose, for example, that we are investigating the form of heat. If we say, “Reject rarity,” or “Rarity is not part of the form of heat,” we mean the same as this: a person can introduce heat into a dense body. Or, conversely, a person can remove or keep heat from a rare body.

But if our forms appear to any one to be somewhat abstracted, from their mingling and uniting heterogeneous objects (the heat, for instance, of the heavenly bodies appears to be very different from that of fire; the fixed red of the rose and the like, from that which is apparent in the rainbow, or the radiation of opal or the diamond; death by drowning, from that by burning, the sword, apoplexy, or consumption; and yet they all agree in the common natures of heat, redness, and death), let him be assured that his understanding is inthralled by habit, by general appearances and hypotheses. For it is most certain that, however heterogeneous and distinct, they agree in the form or law which regulates heat, redness, or death; and that human power cannot be emancipated and freed from the common course of nature, and expanded and exalted to new efficients and new modes of operation, except by the revelation and invention of forms of this nature. But after this union of nature, which is the principal point, we will afterward, in its proper place, treat of the divisions and ramifications of nature, whether ordinary or internal and more real.

But our forms may seem somewhat abstract to anyone because they bring together different kinds of things. For example, the heat of heavenly bodies seems very different from the heat of fire. The permanent red of a rose and similar things seems different from the red visible in a rainbow or in light from an opal or a diamond. Death by drowning seems different from death by burning, the sword, apoplexy, or consumption. Yet all these examples share the common natures of heat, redness, and death. Anyone who finds our forms too abstract should be assured that habit, general appearances, and hypotheses have trapped their understanding. For it is certain that, however different and distinct these things are, they share the form or law governing heat, redness, or death. Human power cannot be freed from nature’s usual course and extended to new causes and new ways of operating without discovering and revealing forms of this kind. But this unity of nature is the main point. Afterward, in the proper place, we will discuss nature’s divisions and branches, whether ordinary or internal and more real.

Newton’s discovery of how colors break down clearly illustrates this general law or form.

I.e., the common link or form connecting different kinds of natures, such as the hot or red natures listed above. See .

XVIII

18

We must now offer an example of the exclusion or rejection of natures found by the tables of review, not to be of the form of heat; first premising that not only each table is sufficient for the rejection of any nature, but even each single instance contained in them. For it is clear from what has been said that every contradictory instance destroys a hypothesis as to the form. Still, however, for the sake of clearness, and in order to show more plainly the use of the tables, we redouble or repeat the exclusive.

We must now give an example of excluding or rejecting properties that the tables of review show are not the form of heat. First, we must note that each table alone is enough to reject any property. Indeed, each single instance in the tables is enough. As we have said, every contradictory instance disproves a hypothesis about the form. Still, for clarity and to show how the tables are used, we repeat the exclusions.

An Example of the Exclusive Table, or of the Rejection of Natures from the Form of Heat

An Example of the Table of Exclusions, or the Rejection of Natures from the Form of Heat

1. On account of the sun’s rays, reject elementary (or terrestrial) nature. 2. On account of common fire, and particularly subterranean fires (which are the most remote and secluded from the rays of the heavenly bodies), reject celestial nature. 3. On account of the heat acquired by every description of substances (as minerals, vegetables, the external parts of animals, water, oil, air, etc.) by mere approximation to the fire or any warm body, reject all variety and delicate texture of bodies. 4. On account of iron and ignited metals, which warm other bodies, and yet neither lose their weight nor substance, reject the imparting or mixing of the substance of the heating body. 5. On account of boiling water and air, and also those metals and other solid bodies which are heated, but not to ignition, or red heat, reject flame or light. 6. On account of the rays of the moon and other heavenly bodies (except the sun), again reject flame or light. 7. On account of the comparison between red-hot iron and the flame of spirits of wine (for the iron is more hot and less bright, while the flame of spirits of wine is more bright and less hot), again reject flame and light. 8. On account of gold and other ignited metals, which are of the greatest specific density, reject rarity. 9. On account of air, which is generally found to be cold and yet continues rare, reject rarity. 10. On account of ignited iron, which does not swell in bulk, but retains the same apparent dimension, reject the absolute expansive motion of the whole. 11. On account of the expansion of the air in thermometers and the like, which is absolutely moved and expanded to the eye, and yet acquires no manifest increase of heat, again reject absolute or expansive motion of the whole. 12. On account of the ready application of heat to all substances without any destruction or remarkable alteration of them, reject destructive nature or the violent communication of any new nature. 13. On account of the agreement and conformity of the effects produced by cold and heat, reject both expansive and contracting motion as regards the whole. 14. On account of the heat excited by friction, reject principal nature, by which we mean that which exists positively, and is not caused by a preceding nature.

1. Because of the sun’s rays, reject elemental (or earthly) nature. 2. Because of ordinary fire, especially underground fires, reject celestial nature. Underground fires are the most distant and sheltered from the rays of heavenly bodies. 3. Heat reaches all kinds of substances simply by bringing them near a fire or any warm body. These substances include minerals, plants, the outer parts of animals, water, oil, and air. For this reason, reject all differences in the fine structure of bodies. 4. Iron and heated metals warm other bodies without losing weight or substance. For this reason, reject the transfer or mixing of substance from the heating body. 5. Boiling water and air are hot without flames or light. So are metals and other solids heated below the point of ignition or red heat. For this reason, reject flame or light. 6. Because of the rays of the moon and other heavenly bodies, except the sun, again reject flame or light. 7. Compare red-hot iron with the flame of alcohol. The iron is hotter and less bright, while the alcohol flame is brighter and less hot. For this reason, again reject flame and light. 8. Gold and other heated metals have the greatest specific density. For this reason, reject low density. 9. Air is generally cold, yet it remains low in density. For this reason, reject low density. 10. Heated iron does not swell but appears to remain the same size. For this reason, reject actual expansion of the whole body. 11. The air in thermometers and similar devices visibly moves and expands, yet shows no noticeable increase in heat. For this reason, again reject actual movement or expansion of the whole body. 12. Heat can readily be applied to all substances without destroying or significantly changing them. For this reason, reject a destructive nature or the violent introduction of any new nature. 13. Because cold and heat produce matching and similar effects, reject both expansion and contraction of the whole body. 14. Because friction produces heat, reject primary nature. By primary nature, we mean a nature that exists in its own right and is not caused by a preceding nature.

This is wrong. All metals expand considerably when heated.

There are other natures to be rejected; but we are merely offering examples, and not perfect tables.

There are other natures to reject. But we are only offering examples, not complete tables.

None of the above natures are of the form of heat; and man is freed from them all in his operation upon heat.

None of the natures listed above belong to the form of heat. People can work with heat without relying on any of them.

XIX

19

In the exclusive table are laid the foundations of true induction, which is not, however, completed until the affirmative be attained. Nor is the exclusive table perfect, nor can it be so at first. For it is clearly a rejection of simple natures; but if we have not as yet good and just notions of simple natures, how can the exclusive table be made correct? Some of the above, as the notion of elementary and celestial nature, and rarity, are vague and ill defined. We, therefore, who are neither ignorant nor forgetful of the great work which we attempt, in rendering the human understanding adequate to things and nature, by no means rest satisfied with what we have hitherto enforced, but push the matter further, and contrive and prepare more powerful aid for the use of the understanding, which we will next subjoin. And, indeed, in the interpretation of nature the mind is to be so prepared and formed, as to rest itself on proper degrees of certainty, and yet to remember (especially at first) that what is present depends much upon what remains behind.

The exclusive table lays the foundations of true induction, but induction is not complete until an affirmative result is reached. Nor is the exclusive table perfect, and it cannot be perfect at first. It is, clearly, a rejection of simple natures. But if we do not yet have sound and accurate notions of simple natures, how can the table be correct? Some of the notions mentioned above, such as elementary and celestial nature and rarity, are vague and poorly defined. We are aware of the great work we are undertaking, and we have not forgotten it. We seek to make human understanding equal to things and nature. So we are by no means satisfied with what we have set out so far. We push further, devising and preparing more powerful aids for the understanding. We will present these next. Indeed, in interpreting nature, the mind must be prepared and trained to rely on appropriate degrees of certainty. Yet it must remember, especially at first, that what is before it depends greatly on what remains to come.

XX

20

Since, however, truth emerges more readily from error than confusion, we consider it useful to leave the understanding at liberty to exert itself and attempt the interpretation of nature in the affirmative, after having constructed and weighed the three tables of preparation, such as we have laid them down, both from the instances there collected, and others occurring elsewhere. Which attempt we are wont to call the liberty of the understanding, or the commencement of interpretation, or the first vintage.

Truth emerges more readily from error than from confusion. So, after constructing and weighing the three tables of preparation as we have set them out, we think it useful to let the mind make its own attempt to interpret nature. This attempt draws on the instances collected in those tables and on others found elsewhere. We call this attempt the liberty of the understanding, the beginning of interpretation, or the first vintage.

The First Vintage of the Form of Heat

The First Findings on the Form of Heat

It must be observed that the form of anything is inherent (as appears clearly from our premises) in each individual instance in which the thing itself is inherent, or it would not be a form. No contradictory instance, therefore, can be alleged. The form, however, is found to be much more conspicuous and evident in some instances than in others; in those (for example) where its nature is less restrained and embarrassed, and reduced to rule by other natures. Such instances we are wont to term coruscations, or conspicuous instances. We must proceed, then, to the first vintage of the form of heat.

We should note that the form of anything is present in every instance of the thing itself. This is clear from our premises. Otherwise, it would not be a form. Therefore, no contradictory instance can be found. The form, however, is much more noticeable and clear in some instances than in others. For example, it is clearer where other natures less restrained, hinder, or regulate its nature. We call such instances coruscations, or conspicuous instances. We must now proceed to the first harvest of the form of heat.

From the instances taken collectively, as well as singly, the nature whose limit is heat appears to be motion. This is chiefly exhibited in flame, which is in constant motion, and in warm or boiling liquids, which are likewise in constant motion. It is also shown in the excitement or increase of heat by motion, as by bellows and draughts: for which see , and by other species of motion, as in and . It is also shown by the extinction of fire and heat upon any strong pressure, which restrains and puts a stop to motion; for which see and . It is further shown by this circumstance, namely, that every substance is destroyed, or at least materially changed, by strong and powerful fire and heat: whence it is clear that tumult and confusion are occasioned by heat, together with a violent motion in the internal parts of bodies; and this gradually tends to their dissolution.

The examples, taken together and individually, suggest that the nature whose limit is heat is motion. This is especially clear in flame, which is constantly moving. Warm or boiling liquids are also in constant motion. It is also shown when motion produces or increases heat, as with bellows and drafts. See for this, and and for other kinds of motion. Strong pressure also puts out fire and heat by restraining and stopping motion. See and . Finally, strong, intense fire and heat destroy every substance, or at least change it substantially. This shows that heat causes turmoil and disorder, along with violent motion in the internal parts of bodies. This gradually tends to break them apart.

In mechanics and the general sciences, causes combine their effects. In other words, we can generally predict the result of introducing complex forces into an experiment. We can do this by accounting for the effect of each simple cause that makes up those forces. In chemistry and physiology, the opposite rule holds. The causes involved generally unite to form distinct substances and produce unforeseen laws and combinations. The deductive method therefore does not apply, and we must rely on experiment.

Bacon is hardly consistent with himself here. In the second book, he accepts the doctrine that elements can be transformed into one another, as modern discoveries suggest. This seemed like poetic fiction in the theories of Pythagoras and Seneca. In the hands of Baron Caynard, it takes on the appearance of scientific fact. Ed.

In Scripture, everything concerning the body's temporary interests is called dead. Only knowledge concerning the soul's eternal interest is alive. Ed.

Until we reach potential and formless matter. Nearly all ancient philosophers accepted the existence of a primitive, shapeless matter underlying all things. Creative power had given this matter fixed proportions and transformed it into distinct substances. Potential matter is the substance at the basis of the Peripatetic system. It contained in potential all the forms that an efficient cause could draw out of it. Ed.

Galileo had recently accepted the idea that nature abhors a vacuum as a fundamental principle. His disciple Torricelli discovered the barometer (1643), providing practical proof of the value of Bacon’s method. Only then was this error disproved, along with the error described below concerning the homeopathic tendencies of bodies, which Bacon also believed. Ed.

An allusion to the humanity of the Sultans. Early histories describe them as marking their accession to the throne by killing their families, to prevent rivalry and the horrors of civil war. Ed.

What we have said with regard to motion must be thus understood, when taken as the genus of heat: it must not be thought that heat generates motion, or motion heat (though in some respects this be true), but that the very essence of heat, or the substantial self of heat, is motion and nothing else, limited, however, by certain differences which we will presently add, after giving some cautions for avoiding ambiguity.

What we have said about motion as the genus of heat must be understood as follows. We should not think that heat produces motion, or motion produces heat, though this is true in some respects. Rather, the very essence of heat, or its substantial self, is motion and nothing else. However, this motion is limited by certain distinguishing features. We will add these shortly, after some cautions to avoid ambiguity.

“Quid ipsum,” Aristotle’s τὸ τὶ ἦν εἶναι.

Sensible heat is relative, and regards man, not universe; and is rightly held to be merely the effect of heat on animal spirit. It is even variable in itself, since the same body (in different states of sensation) excites the feeling of heat and of cold; this is shown by .

The sensation of heat is relative. It concerns humans, not the universe, and is rightly understood as merely heat's effect on animal spirit. The sensation itself varies. The same body can feel hot or cold, depending on the state of the senses. This is shown by .

Remember that when Bacon wrote, algebra was still in its infancy. The doctrine of units and infinitesimals had not yet been discovered.

Nor should we confound the communication of heat or its transitive nature, by which a body grows warm at the approach of a heated body, with the form of heat; for heat is one thing and heating another. Heat can be excited by friction without any previous heating body, and, therefore, heating is excluded from the form of heat. Even when heat is excited by the approach of a hot body, this depends not on the form of heat, but on another more profound and common nature; namely, that of assimilation and multiplication, about which a separate inquiry must be made.

We should not confuse the transfer of heat with the form of heat. Heat is transferred when a body grows warm as a heated body approaches it. But heat is one thing, and heating another. Friction can produce heat without any previously heated body. Therefore, heating is excluded from the form of heat. Even when heat is produced by the approach of a hot body, this does not depend on the form of heat. It depends instead on a deeper and more general nature, namely assimilation and multiplication. This nature requires a separate inquiry.

The notion of fire is vulgar, and of no assistance; it is merely compounded of the conjunction of heat and light in any body, as in ordinary flame and red-hot substances.

The common idea of fire is of no use. It simply combines heat and light in any material, as in ordinary flames and red-hot substances.

Laying aside all ambiguity, therefore, we must lastly consider the true differences which limit motion and render it the form of heat.

Putting all ambiguity aside, we must finally consider the specific differences that limit motion and make it the form of heat.

I. The first difference is, that heat is an expansive motion, by which the body strives to dilate itself, and to occupy a greater space than before. This difference is principally seen in flame, where the smoke or thick vapor is clearly dilated and bursts into flame.

I. The first difference is that heat is an expanding motion. It causes a body to strive to expand and occupy more space than before. This difference is most clearly seen in a flame, where smoke or thick vapor visibly expands and bursts into flame.

It is also shown in all boiling liquids, which swell, rise, and boil up to the sight, and the process of expansion is urged forward till they are converted into a much more extended and dilated body than the liquid itself, such as steam, smoke, or air.

It is also shown in all boiling liquids, which visibly swell, rise, and bubble. They continue to expand until they become a much more expanded substance than the liquid itself, such as steam, smoke, or air.

It is also shown in wood and combustibles where exudation sometimes takes place, and evaporation always.

It can also be seen in wood and other combustible materials, which sometimes ooze liquid and always undergo evaporation.

It is also shown in the melting of metals, which, being very compact, do not easily swell and dilate, but yet their spirit, when dilated and desirous of further expansion, forces and urges its thicker parts into dissolution, and if the heat be pushed still further, reduces a considerable part of them into a volatile state.

This is also shown when metals melt. Because metals are very compact, they do not easily swell and expand. But when their spirit expands and seeks to expand further, it forces their denser parts to melt. If the heat is increased further, it turns a considerable part of the metals into vapor.

It is also shown in iron or stones, which though not melted or dissolved, are however softened. The same circumstance takes place in sticks of wood, which become flexible when a little heated in warm ashes.

It is also seen in iron and stones, which soften even though they do not melt or dissolve. The same thing happens to sticks of wood, which become flexible when warmed slightly in warm ashes.

It is most readily observed in air, which instantly and manifestly expands with a small degree of heat, as in .

It is easiest to observe in air, which expands instantly and visibly with a little heat, as in .

Bacon is equally striking for his use and misuse of analogies. As Stuart Mill rightly observes, the levity that makes substances float on a stream has only its name in common with the levity that means worthlessness. The analogy has little value. We need only replace “levity” with “buoyancy” to turn the apparent argument against Bacon himself. Ed.

It is also shown in the contrary nature of cold; for cold contracts and narrows every substance; so that in intense frosts nails fall out of the wall and brass cracks, and heated glass exposed suddenly to the cold cracks and breaks. So the air, by a slight degree of cold, contracts itself, as in . More will be said of this in the inquiry into cold.

This is also shown by the opposite nature of cold. Cold contracts and narrows every substance. In severe frosts, nails fall out of walls and brass cracks. Heated glass also cracks and breaks when suddenly exposed to cold. Similarly, air contracts in mild cold, as in . More will be said about this in the inquiry into cold.

To show the error in the text, we need only consider water sealed in corked vessels and exposed to freezing air. The water will expand and break any vessel too small to hold it. Megalotti recounts a hundred other similar examples. Ed.

Bacon is equally notable for his use and misuse of analogies. As Stuart Mill rightly observes, the levity that makes substances float on a stream has nothing but a name in common with levity meaning worthlessness. To show how little the comparison is worth, we need only replace “levity” with “buoyancy.” This turns the appearance of an argument against Bacon himself. Ed.

Nor is it to be wondered at if cold and heat exhibit many common effects (for which see ), since two differences, of which we shall presently speak, belong to each nature: although in the present difference the effects be diametrically opposed to each other. For heat occasions an expansive and dilating motion, but cold a contracting and condensing motion.

It is not surprising that cold and heat have many effects in common (see ). Both have two differences, which we will discuss shortly. But in the present difference, their effects are directly opposed. Heat causes expansion and dilation, while cold causes contraction and condensation.

An allusion to the humanity of the Sultans. Early histories portray them as marking their accession to the throne by killing their families, to remove the danger of rivalry and the horrors of civil war. Ed.

II. The second difference is a modification of the preceding, namely, that heat is an expansive motion, tending toward the exterior, but at the same time bearing the body upward. For there is no doubt that there be many compound motions, as an arrow or dart, for instance, has both a rotatory and progressive motion. In the same way the motion of heat is both expansive and tending upward.

II. The second difference modifies the first. Heat is a motion that expands outward, but it also carries the body upward. There is no doubt that many motions are combined. An arrow or dart, for example, both spins and moves forward. In the same way, heat moves both outward and upward.

This difference is shown by putting the tongs or poker into the fire. If placed perpendicularly with the hand above, they soon burn it, but much less speedily if the hand hold them sloping or from below.

This difference can be seen by putting tongs or a poker into a fire. If you hold them vertically with your hand above the fire, they soon burn your hand. But they burn it much less quickly if you hold them at an angle or from below.

It is also conspicuous in distillations per descensum, which men are wont to employ with delicate flowers, whose scent easily evaporates. Their industry has devised placing the fire above instead of below, that it may scorch less; for not only flame but all heat has an upward tendency.

It is also clear in distillation per descensum, which people often use for delicate flowers whose scent easily evaporates. They have devised a way to place the fire above rather than below, so that it scorches less. For not only flame but all heat tends to rise.

Let an experiment be made on the contrary nature of cold, whether its contraction be downward, as the expansion of heat is upward. Take, therefore, two iron rods or two glass tubes, alike in other respects, and warm them a little, and place a sponge, dipped in cold water, or some snow, below the one and above the other. We are of opinion that the extremities will grow cold in that rod first where it is placed beneath, as the contrary takes place with regard to heat.

Let us test whether cold, the opposite of heat, contracts downward, just as heat expands upward. Take two iron rods or two glass tubes that are alike in all other respects. Warm them slightly. Place a sponge dipped in cold water, or some snow, below one and above the other. We believe the ends will grow cold first in the rod with the cold material beneath it. With heat, the opposite happens.

III. The third difference is this; that heat is not a uniform expansive motion of the whole, but of the small particles of the body; and this motion being at the same time restrained, repulsed, and reflected, becomes alternating, perpetually hurrying, striving, struggling, and irritated by the repercussion, which is the source of the violence of flame and heat.

III. The third difference is that heat is not a uniform expansion of the whole body. Instead, it is an expansion of the body's small particles. At the same time, this motion is restrained, pushed back, and reflected, so it moves back and forth. It constantly rushes, strains, and struggles, driven on by being pushed back. This is the source of the violence of flame and heat.

But this difference is chiefly shown in flame and boiling liquids, which always hurry, swell, and subside again in detached parts.

But this difference is most visible in flames and boiling liquids, which always surge, swell, and subside in separate parts.

It is also shown in bodies of such hard texture as not to swell or dilate in bulk, such as red-hot iron, in which the heat is most violent.

It is also shown in materials too hard to swell or expand, such as red-hot iron, where the heat is most intense.

It is also shown by the fires burning most briskly in the coldest weather.

This is also shown by fires burning most fiercely in the coldest weather.

It is also shown by this, that when the air is dilated in the thermometer uniformly and equably, without any impediment or repulsion, the heat is not perceptible. In confined draughts also, although they break out very violently, no remarkable heat is perceived, because the motion affects the whole, without any alternating motion in the particles; for which reason try whether flame do not burn more at the sides than in its centre.

This is also shown when air expands evenly in a thermometer, without any obstruction or resistance. The heat is not noticeable. Likewise, confined currents of air produce no noticeable heat, even when they burst out violently. This is because the motion affects the whole current, without any back-and-forth motion in its particles. For this reason, test whether a flame burns more at its sides than at its center.

It is also shown in this, that all burning proceeds by the minute pores of bodies—undermining, penetrating, piercing, and pricking them as if with an infinite number of needle-points. Hence all strong acids (if adapted to the body on which they act) exhibit the effects of fire, from their corroding and pungent nature.

This also shows that all burning works through the tiny pores of bodies. It undermines, penetrates, pierces, and pricks them, as if with countless needle points. So all strong acids have the effects of fire because they are corrosive and pungent, if suited to the body they act on.

The difference of which we now speak is common also to the nature of cold, in which the contracting motion is restrained by the resistance of expansion, as in heat the expansive motion is restrained by the resistance of contraction.

The difference we are discussing also applies to cold. In cold, the motion of contraction is restrained by resistance from expansion. Similarly, in heat, the motion of expansion is restrained by resistance from contraction.

Whether, therefore, the particles of matter penetrate inward or outward, the reasoning is the same, though the power be very different, because we have nothing on earth which is intensely cold.

So, whether particles of matter penetrate inward or outward, the reasoning is the same. But the power is very different because nothing on earth is intensely cold.

IV. The fourth difference is a modification of the preceding, namely, that this stimulating or penetrating motion should be rapid and never sluggish, and should take place not in the very minutest particles, but rather in those of some tolerable dimensions.

IV. The fourth difference modifies the previous one. The stimulating or penetrating motion should be rapid, never sluggish. It should occur not in the very smallest particles, but in particles of a reasonably large size.

It is shown by comparing the effects of fire with those of time. Time dries, consumes, undermines, and reduces to ashes as well as fire, and perhaps to a much finer degree; but as its motion is very slow, and attacks very minute particles, no heat is perceived.

This is shown by comparing the effects of fire with those of time. Like fire, time dries, consumes, undermines, and reduces things to ashes. Perhaps it does so to a much finer degree. But time works very slowly and affects very small particles, so no heat is felt.

It is also shown in a comparison of the dissolution of iron and gold; for gold is dissolved without the excitement of any heat, but iron with a vehement excitement of it, although most in the same time, because in the former the penetration of the separating acid is mild, and gently insinuates itself, and the particles of gold yield easily, but the penetration of iron is violent, and attended with some struggle, and its particles are more obstinate.

This is also shown by comparing how iron and gold dissolve. Gold dissolves without producing heat, but iron produces intense heat, although most dissolves in the same time. This is because the acid that separates gold penetrates it gently, and the particles of gold yield easily. But the acid penetrates iron violently, with some struggle, and its particles are more resistant.

It is partially shown, also, in some gangrenes and mortifications of flesh, which do not excite great heat or pain, from the gentle nature of the putrefaction.

It is also partly shown in some cases of gangrene and tissue death. These cause little heat or pain because the decay is mild.

Let this suffice for a first vintage, or the commencement of the interpretation of the form of heat by the liberty of the understanding.

Let this be enough for a first harvest, a beginning in interpreting the form of heat through free thought.

From this first vintage the form or true definition of heat (considered relatively to the universe and not to the sense) is briefly thus—Heat is an expansive motion restrained, and striving to exert itself in the smaller particles. The expansion is modified by its tendency to rise, though expanding toward the exterior; and the effort is modified by its not being sluggish, but active and somewhat violent.

From this first survey, the true nature or definition of heat is briefly as follows. This definition considers heat in relation to the universe, not to our senses. Heat is an expanding motion that is restrained and strives to act within smaller particles. Though heat expands outward, its expansion is also directed upward. Its effort is not sluggish, but active and somewhat violent.

Bacon’s investigation into the nature of heat is meant to show how to interpret nature. It can only be regarded as a complete failure. The exact nature of heat is still obscure and disputed. Yet the science of thermotics now contains many important truths, and Bacon’s method comes nowhere near any of them. The science actually advanced through the discovery of a measure of heat or temperature. It also advanced through the establishment of the laws of conduction and radiation, specific heat, latent heat, and the like.

These advances have led to Ampère’s hypothesis that heat consists in the vibrations of an imponderable fluid. They have also led to Laplace’s theory that temperature consists in the internal radiation of a similar medium. Neither hypothesis can yet be said to be even probable. But both are at least framed to include some of the firmly established laws just mentioned. By contrast, Bacon’s “form,” or true definition of heat, as stated in the text, includes no laws of phenomena. It explains no process and is itself an example of an unjustified generalization.

Bacon fares badly in every detail of his example of heat. His collection of instances includes the hot tastes of aromatic plants and the caustic effects of acids. It also includes many other facts that can be attributed to heat only by using the word deliberately loosely. Ed.

With regard to the operative definition, the matter is the same. If you are able to excite a dilating or expansive motion in any natural body, and so to repress that motion and force it on itself as not to allow the expansion to proceed equally, but only to be partially exerted and partially repressed, you will beyond all doubt produce heat, without any consideration as to whether the body be of earth (or elementary, as they term it), or imbued with celestial influence, luminous or opaque, rare or dense, locally expanded or contained within the bounds of its first dimensions, verging to dissolution or remaining fixed, animal, vegetable, or mineral, water, or oil, or air, or any other substance whatever susceptible of such motion. Sensible heat is the same, but considered relatively to the senses. Let us now proceed to further helps.

The same is true of the operative definition. Suppose you can cause an expanding motion in any natural body. If you can restrain that motion and force it back on itself, you will undoubtedly produce heat. The expansion must not proceed evenly, but must be partly exerted and partly restrained. It does not matter whether the body is earthly (or elementary, as it is called) or imbued with celestial influence. Nor does it matter whether the body is luminous or opaque, rare or dense. It may expand in space or remain within its original dimensions. It may be approaching dissolution or remain fixed. It may be animal, vegetable, or mineral, water, oil, air, or any other substance capable of such motion. Sensible heat is the same thing, but considered in relation to the senses. Let us now turn to further aids.

XXI

21

After our tables of first review, our rejection or exclusive table, and the first vintage derived from them, we must advance to the remaining helps of the understanding with regard to the interpretation of nature, and a true and perfect induction, in offering which we will take the examples of cold and heat where tables are necessary, but where fewer instances are required we will go through a variety of others, so as neither to confound investigation nor to narrow our doctrine.

After our preliminary tables, our table of exclusions, and the first results drawn from them, we must move on. We must consider the remaining aids to understanding that help us interpret nature and achieve true and complete induction. In presenting these aids, we will use cold and heat as examples where tables are necessary. But where fewer instances are needed, we will use a variety of other examples. This will prevent us from confusing the investigation or narrowing our doctrine.

In the first place, therefore, we will treat of prerogative instances; 2. Of the supports of induction; 3. Of the correction of induction; 4. Of varying the investigation according to the nature of the subject; 5. Of the prerogative natures with respect to investigation, or of what should be the first or last objects of our research; 6. Of the limits of investigation, or a synopsis of all natures that exist in the universe; 7. Of the application to practical purposes, or of what relates to man; 8. Of the preparations for investigation; 9. And lastly, of the ascending and descending scale of axioms.

First, then, we will discuss prerogative instances. 2. The supports of induction. 3. The correction of induction. 4. How to vary an investigation according to the nature of its subject. 5. The prerogative natures in investigation, or what we should investigate first and last. 6. The limits of investigation, or an overview of all natures that exist in the universe. 7. The application of investigation to practical purposes, or what relates to human beings. 8. Preparations for investigation. 9. Finally, the ascending and descending scale of axioms.

By this term Bacon means general phenomena selected in order from a mass of undifferentiated facts. As these facts occur in nature, their number, obscurity, and complexity tend to cause confusion. Such classes of phenomena are especially suggestive of causation. Bacon gives them the curious title of prerogative inquiries. He may have been drawn to a fanciful analogy between these instances and the prerogativa centuria in the Roman Comitia. Or, as Herschel supposes, he may have rightly regarded them as having a special dignity because they are especially suggestive of causation.

Two leading authorities in physical science (v. Herschel, Nat. Phil., art. 192; Whewell’s Philosophy of the Inductive Sciences, vol. ii. p. 243) judge these instances of little use in induction. For the most part, Bacon classifies them according to their influence on the inquiry in which they are used. He does not classify them according to the ideas they involve or any obvious feature of their facts.

Thus we have solitary, migrating, ostensive, and clandestine instances. These are named according to how clearly they show, or seem to show, the property whose nature we wish to examine. We also have guide-post instances, crucial instances, instances of the parted road, of the doorway, and of the lamp. These are named according to the guidance they give us as we proceed.

Whewell compares this classification to a way of teaching the art of building. We might describe tools by the amount and place of the work they must do, rather than explaining their construction and use. We might tell the pupil that we need tools for lifting a stone, moving it sideways, laying it square, and cementing it firmly. The means are thus lost in the end, and this disorderly arrangement produces confusion through overlapping categories.

In addition, all the instances are affected by the error of confusing the laws of phenomena with their causes. We are urged to adopt the fundamental error of seeking universal agents, or general causes of phenomena, in these instances. We are urged to do this without first ascending through the gradual steps of intermediate laws. Ed.

Of these nine general topics, the author develops only the first.

XXII

22

Among the prerogative instances we will first mention solitary instances. Solitary instances are those which exhibit the required nature in subjects that have nothing in common with any other subject than the nature in question, or which do not exhibit the required nature in subjects resembling others in every respect except that of the nature in question; for these instances manifestly remove prolixity, and accelerate and confirm exclusion, so that a few of them are of as much avail as many.

Among the prerogative instances, we will first consider solitary instances. These are cases that show the quality being studied in subjects that share nothing else with one another. They also include cases where that quality is absent from subjects otherwise identical to those that have it. These instances clearly cut short lengthy investigations and make exclusion faster and more certain. So a few of them are as useful as many other instances.

For instance, let the inquiry be the nature of color. Prisms, crystalline gems, which yield colors not only internally but on the wall, dews, etc., are solitary instances; for they have nothing in common with the fixed colors in flowers and colored gems, metals, woods, etc., except the color itself. Hence we easily deduce that color is nothing but a modification of the image of the incident and absorbed light, occasioned in the former case by the different degrees of incidence, in the latter by the various textures and forms of bodies. These are solitary instances as regards similitude.

For example, suppose we are investigating the nature of color. Prisms, crystal gems that produce colors both inside themselves and on walls, dew, and similar things are solitary instances. They have nothing in common with the fixed colors of flowers, colored gems, metals, woods, and other such things except color itself. From this, we can easily conclude that color is nothing more than a change in the image of the light striking or absorbed by a body. In the first case, this change is caused by the different angles at which light strikes. In the second, it is caused by the various textures and forms of bodies. These are solitary instances in respect of similarity.

This comes very close to Sir I. Newton’s discovery of how a prism decomposes light.

Again, in the same inquiry the distinct veins of white and black in marble, and the variegated colors of flowers of the same species, are solitary instances; for the black and white of marble, and the spots of white and purple in the flowers of the stock, agree in every respect but that of color. Thence we easily deduce that color has not much to do with the intrinsic natures of any body, but depends only on the coarser and as it were mechanical arrangement of the parts. These are solitary instances as regards difference. We call them both solitary or wild, to borrow a word from the astronomers.

Again, in the same inquiry, the distinct white and black veins in marble are solitary instances. So are the different colors of flowers of the same species. The black and white parts of marble agree in every respect except color. The same is true of the white and purple spots on stock flowers. From this we can easily conclude that color has little to do with a body's inherent nature. Instead, it depends only on the coarser, almost mechanical arrangement of its parts. These are solitary instances with respect to difference. Borrowing a term from astronomers, we call both kinds solitary or wild.

XXIII

23

In the second rank of prerogative instances we will consider migrating instances. In these the required nature passes toward generation, having no previous existence, or toward corruption, having first existed. In each of these divisions, therefore, the instances are always twofold, or rather it is one instance, first in motion or on its passage, and then brought to the opposite conclusion. These instances not only hasten and confirm exclusion, but also reduce affirmation, or the form itself, to a narrow compass; for the form must be something conferred by this migration, or, on the contrary, removed and destroyed by it; and although all exclusion advances affirmation, yet this takes place more directly in the same than in different subjects; but if the form (as it is quite clear from what has been advanced) exhibit itself in one subject, it leads to all. The more simple the migration is, the more valuable is the instance. These migrating instances are, moreover, very useful in practice, for since they manifest the form, coupled with that which causes or destroys it, they point out the right practice in some subjects, and thence there is an easy transition to those with which they are most allied. There is, however, a degree of danger which demands caution, namely, lest they should refer the form too much to its efficient cause, and imbue, or at least tinge, the understanding with a false notion of the form from the appearance of such cause, which is never more than a vehicle or conveyance of the form. This may easily be remedied by a proper application of exclusion.

In the second rank of prerogative instances, we will consider migrating instances. In these, the nature being investigated either comes into existence where it did not exist before or passes out of existence where it did. In each case, then, there are always two instances. Or rather, there is one instance, first undergoing a change and then reaching the opposite state. These instances not only speed up and confirm exclusion, but also narrow the search for affirmation, or the form itself. For the form must be something either introduced by this change or removed and destroyed by it. All exclusion advances affirmation. Yet it does so more directly when it takes place in the same subject than in different subjects. But if the form appears in one subject, it leads us to all subjects, as what has been said makes clear. The simpler the change, the more valuable the instance. Migrating instances are also very useful in practice. They show the form together with what causes or destroys it. Thus, they point out the right practice in some subjects. From there, it is easy to move to closely related subjects. There is, however, a danger that calls for caution. Migrating instances may lead us to connect the form too closely with its efficient cause. The appearance of that cause may fill or at least color the understanding with a false notion of the form. Yet the cause is never more than a vehicle or means of conveying the form. Proper use of exclusion can easily remedy this danger.

Let us then give an example of a migrating instance. Let whiteness be the required nature. An instance which passes toward generation is glass in its entire and in its powdered state, or water in its natural state, and when agitated to froth; for glass when entire, and water in its natural state, are transparent and not white, but powdered glass and the froth of water are white and not transparent. We must inquire, therefore, what has happened to the glass or water in the course of this migration; for it is manifest that the form of whiteness is conveyed and introduced by the bruising of the glass and the agitation of the water; but nothing is found to have been introduced but a diminishing of the parts of the glass and water and the insertion of air. Yet this is no slight progress toward discovering the form of whiteness, namely, that two bodies, in themselves more or less transparent (as air and water, or air and glass), when brought into contact in minute portions, exhibit whiteness from the unequal refraction of the rays of light.

Let us give an example of a migrating instance. Let whiteness be the nature we want to investigate. One instance in which whiteness comes into being is glass, first whole and then powdered. Another is water, first in its natural state and then stirred into froth. Whole glass and water in its natural state are transparent, not white. But powdered glass and water froth are white, not transparent. We must therefore ask what happened to the glass or water during this change. Clearly, crushing the glass and stirring the water bring about the form of whiteness. Yet they appear to do nothing more than reduce the glass and water to smaller parts and introduce air. This is no small step toward discovering the form of whiteness. It shows that two bodies, each more or less transparent on its own, can produce whiteness. Examples are air and water, or air and glass. When they are brought into contact in tiny portions, they appear white because they refract light rays unequally.

But here we must also give an example of the danger and caution of which we spoke; for instance, it will readily occur to an understanding perverted by efficients, that air is always necessary for producing the form of whiteness, or that whiteness is only generated by transparent bodies, which suppositions are both false, and proved to be so by many exclusions; nay, it will rather appear (without any particular regard to air or the like), that all bodies which are even in such of their parts as affect the sight exhibit transparency, those which are uneven and of simple texture whiteness, those which are uneven and of compound but regular texture all the other colors except black, but those which are uneven and of a compound irregular and confused texture exhibit blackness. An example has been given, therefore, of an instance migrating toward generation in the required nature of whiteness. An instance migrating toward corruption in the same nature is that of dissolving froth or snow, for they lose their whiteness and assume the transparency of water in its pure state without air.

But here we must also give an example of the danger we warned against. A mind led astray by efficient causes might readily assume that air is always necessary to produce the form of whiteness. Or it might assume that whiteness is produced only by transparent bodies. Both assumptions are false, as many instances of exclusion prove. Rather, without special regard to air or anything like it, the following seems to be true. All bodies that are even in the parts affecting sight appear transparent. Those that are uneven and have a simple texture appear white. Those that are uneven and have a compound but regular texture display all the other colors except black. But those that are uneven and have a compound, irregular, and confused texture appear black. We have therefore given an example of an instance moving toward the generation of the nature under investigation, whiteness. An instance moving toward the loss of that same nature is dissolving froth or snow. These lose their whiteness and take on the transparency of water in its pure state, without air.

Nor should we by any means omit to state, that under migrating instances we must comprehend not only those which pass toward generation and destruction, but also those which pass toward increase or decrease, for they, too, assist in the discovery of the form, as is clear from our definition of a form and the Table of Degrees. Hence paper, which is white when dry, is less white when moistened (from the exclusion of air and admission of water), and tends more to transparency. The reason is the same as in the above instances.

We must not forget that migrating instances include more than those that move toward generation or destruction. They also include those that move toward increase or decrease. These, too, help us discover the form, as our definition of a form and the Table of Degrees make clear. For example, paper is white when dry, but less white when wet. This is because water enters and air is excluded. The paper also becomes more transparent. The reason is the same as in the examples above.

The mineral kingdom is the great arena for examples of migration. It shows the same nature in all its gradations, from the perfectly structured shells in limestone to the finer marbles, where their nature gradually disappears. Ed.

XXIV

24

In the third rank of prerogative instances we will class conspicuous instances, of which we spoke in our first vintage of the form of heat, and which we are also wont to call coruscations, or free and predominant instances. They are such as show the required nature in its bare substantial shape, and at its height or greatest degree of power, emancipated and free from all impediments, or at least overcoming, suppressing, and restraining them by the strength of its qualities; for since every body is susceptible of many united forms of natures in the concrete, the consequence is that they mutually deaden, depress, break, and confine each other, and the individual forms are obscured. But there are some subjects in which the required nature exists in its full vigor rather than in others, either from the absence of any impediment, or the predominance of its quality. Such instances are eminently conspicuous. But even in these care must be taken, and the hastiness of the understanding checked, for whatever makes a show of the form, and forces it forward, is to be suspected, and recourse must be had to severe and diligent exclusion.

The third rank of prerogative instances consists of conspicuous instances. We discussed them in our first investigation of the form of heat. We also call them coruscations, or free and predominant instances. They show the nature under investigation in its bare, essential form, at its height or greatest power. It is free from all obstacles, or at least overcomes, suppresses, and restrains them through its own strength. Every body can contain many forms of nature together in concrete form. As a result, these forms weaken, suppress, break, and limit one another, and the individual forms are obscured. But in some subjects, the nature under investigation exists in greater vigor than in others. This is either because there is no obstacle or because the nature’s quality predominates. Such instances are especially conspicuous. But even with these, we must be careful and restrain the understanding’s haste. For anything that displays the form and brings it to the foreground is suspect. We must therefore apply a rigorous and careful process of exclusion.

For example, let heat be the required nature. The thermometer is a conspicuous instance of the expansive motion, which (as has been observed) constitutes the chief part of the form of heat; for although flame clearly exhibits expansion, yet from its being extinguished every moment, it does not exhibit the progress of expansion. Boiling water again, from its rapid conversion into vapor, does not so well exhibit the expansion of water in its own shape, while red-hot iron and the like are so far from showing this progress, that, on the contrary, the expansion itself is scarcely evident to the senses, on account of its spirit being repressed and weakened by the compact and coarse particles which subdue and restrain it. But the thermometer strikingly exhibits the expansion of the air as being evident and progressive, durable and not transitory.

For example, suppose heat is the nature we want to study. A thermometer clearly shows expansive motion, which, as noted, makes up the chief part of the form of heat. Flame clearly shows expansion, but it is extinguished every moment. So it does not show how the expansion progresses. Boiling water, too, turns so quickly into vapor that it does not show expansion as well while still in liquid form. Red-hot iron and similar materials are even less able to show this progress. In fact, their expansion is barely noticeable to the senses. This is because their spirit is suppressed and weakened by the dense, coarse particles that subdue and restrain it. But a thermometer strikingly shows the expansion of air. The expansion is visible and gradual, lasting rather than passing quickly.

Bacon did not know a fact later discovered by Römer. Down to fourteen fathoms below the earth’s mean level, the thermometer remains fixed at the tenth degree. But below that depth, the heat increases in proportion to the depth. This happens with little variation in all climates. Buffon considers this proof of a central fire in our planet. Ed.

Take another example. Let the required nature be weight. Quicksilver is a conspicuous instance of weight; for it is far heavier than any other substance except gold, which is not much heavier, and it is a better instance than gold for the purpose of indicating the form of weight; for gold is solid and consistent, which qualities must be referred to density, but quicksilver is liquid and teeming with spirit, yet much heavier than the diamond and other substances considered to be most solid; whence it is shown that the form of gravity or weight predominates only in the quantity of matter, and not in the close fitting of it.

Take another example. Let weight be the quality we want to investigate. Quicksilver is a striking example of weight. It is far heavier than any other substance except gold, which is only slightly heavier. Quicksilver is a better example than gold for revealing the form of weight. Gold is solid and firm, and these qualities must be attributed to its density. But quicksilver is liquid and full of spirit. Yet it is much heavier than diamond and other substances considered the most solid. This shows that the form of gravity or weight depends only on the quantity of matter, not on how closely it is packed.

All differences among bodies depend on two principles: the quantity and position of the elements that make them up. The most important difference depends not on the quantity of material elements, but on their position. Leibnitz quickly grasped this truth. He said that completing mathematics required adding the analysis of position to the analysis of quantity. Ed.

XXV

25

In the fourth rank of prerogative instances we will class clandestine instances, which we are also wont to call twilight instances; they are as it were opposed to the conspicuous instances, for they show the required nature in its lowest state of efficacy, and as it were its cradle and first rudiments, making an effort and a sort of first attempt, but concealed and subdued by a contrary nature. Such instances are, however, of great importance in discovering forms, for as the conspicuous tend easily to differences, so do the clandestine best lead to genera, that is, to those common natures of which the required natures are only the limits.

We place clandestine instances in the fourth rank of prerogative instances. We also call them twilight instances. They are, as it were, the opposite of conspicuous instances. They show the nature under investigation at its weakest, as if in its cradle and first beginnings. It makes an effort, a kind of first attempt, but is hidden and held back by an opposing nature. Yet these instances are very important for discovering forms. Just as conspicuous instances readily lead to differences, clandestine instances best lead to genera. These are the common natures of which the natures under investigation are only the limits.

As an example, let consistency, or that which confines itself, be the required nature, the opposite of which is a liquid or flowing state. The clandestine instances are such as exhibit some weak and low degree of consistency in fluids, as a water bubble, which is a sort of consistent and bounded pellicle formed out of the substance of the water. So eaves’ droppings, if there be enough water to follow them, draw themselves out into a thin thread, not to break the continuity of the water, but if there be not enough to follow, the water forms itself into a round drop, which is the best form to prevent a breach of continuity; and at the moment the thread ceases, and the water begins to fall in drops, the thread of water recoils upward to avoid such a breach. Nay, in metals, which when melted are liquid but more tenacious, the melted drops often recoil and are suspended. There is something similar in the instance of the child’s looking-glass, which little boys will sometimes form of spittle between rushes, and where the same pellicle of water is observable; and still more in that other amusement of children, when they take some water rendered a little more tenacious by soap, and inflate it with a pipe, forming the water into a sort of castle of bubbles, which assumes such consistency, by the interposition of the air, as to admit of being thrown some little distance without bursting. The best example is that of froth and snow, which assume such consistency as almost to admit of being cut, although composed of air and water, both liquids. All these circumstances clearly show that the terms liquid and consistent are merely vulgar notions adapted to the sense, and that in reality all bodies have a tendency to avoid a breach of continuity, faint and weak in bodies composed of homogeneous parts (as is the case with liquids), but more vivid and powerful in those composed of heterogeneous parts, because the approach of heterogeneous matter binds bodies together, while the insinuation of homogeneous matter loosens and relaxes them.

As an example, suppose the property we are investigating is consistency, or the ability to hold together. Its opposite is a liquid or flowing state. The hidden instances show a slight, weak degree of consistency in fluids. One is a water bubble, a kind of solid, bounded film made from the water itself. Similarly, drops falling from the eaves stretch into a thin thread if enough water follows them. This prevents a break in the continuity of the water. But if not enough water follows, the water forms a round drop. This is the best shape for preventing a break in its continuity. When the thread ends and the water begins to fall in drops, the thread recoils upward to avoid a break. Even in metals, which are liquid when melted but hold together more strongly, melted drops often recoil and remain suspended. Something similar appears in a child's looking-glass, which boys sometimes make from spit between rushes. The same film of water can be seen there. It is even clearer in another children's amusement. They take water made slightly more cohesive with soap and blow into it through a pipe. This forms a kind of castle of bubbles. With air between them, the bubbles hold together well enough to be thrown a short distance without bursting. The best examples are froth and snow. They hold together well enough to be almost cut, although they are made of air and water, both fluids. All these things clearly show that the terms liquid and consistent are merely common notions based on what we sense. In reality, all bodies tend to avoid a break in their continuity. This tendency is faint and weak in bodies made of similar parts, as liquids are. But it is stronger and more powerful in bodies made of different parts. This is because the joining of different kinds of matter binds bodies together, while the entry of similar matter loosens them.

Again, to take another example, let the required nature be attraction or the cohesion of bodies. The most remarkable conspicuous instance with regard to its form is the magnet. The contrary nature to attraction is non-attraction, though in a similar substance. Thus iron does not attract iron, lead lead, wood wood, nor water water. But the clandestine instance is that of the magnet armed with iron, or rather that of iron in the magnet so armed. For its nature is such that the magnet when armed does not attract iron more powerfully at any given distance than when unarmed; but if the iron be brought in contact with the armed magnet, the latter will sustain a much greater weight than the simple magnet, from the resemblance of substance in the two portions of iron, a quality altogether clandestine and hidden in the iron until the magnet was introduced. It is manifest, therefore, that the form of cohesion is something which is vivid and robust in the magnet, and hidden and weak in the iron. It is to be observed, also, that small wooden arrows without an iron point, when discharged from large mortars, penetrate further into wooden substances (such as the ribs of ships or the like), than the same arrows pointed with iron, owing to the similarity of substance, though this quality was previously latent in the wood. Again, although in the mass air does not appear to attract air, nor water water, yet when one bubble is brought near another, they are both more readily dissolved, from the tendency to contact of the water with the water, and the air with the air. These clandestine instances (which are, as has been observed, of the most important service) are principally to be observed in small portions of bodies, for the larger masses observe more universal and general forms, as will be mentioned in its proper place.

Again, consider another example. Let the nature we are investigating be attraction, or the cohesion of bodies. The magnet is the most striking and obvious example of its form. The opposite of attraction is the absence of attraction, even between substances of the same kind. Thus iron does not attract iron, lead does not attract lead, wood does not attract wood, and water does not attract water. But the hidden instance is a magnet fitted with iron, or rather the iron in a magnet fitted this way. A magnet fitted with iron does not attract iron more powerfully at any given distance than a magnet without it. But if iron is brought into contact with the fitted magnet, the magnet will support much more weight than the magnet alone. This is because the two pieces of iron are made of the same substance. This quality was completely hidden in the iron until the magnet was introduced. It is clear, then, that the form of cohesion is strong and vigorous in the magnet, but hidden and weak in the iron. Notice also what happens when small wooden arrows without iron points are fired from large mortars. They penetrate wooden objects, such as ships' ribs, more deeply than the same arrows fitted with iron points. This is because the arrow and the object are made of the same substance. Yet this quality was previously hidden in the wood. Again, air in a mass does not appear to attract air, nor water to attract water. Yet when one bubble is brought near another, both burst more readily. This is because the water tends to come into contact with the water, and the air with the air. As noted, these hidden instances are extremely useful. They should be observed chiefly in small portions of bodies. Larger masses follow more universal and general forms, as will be explained in its proper place.

Question?

The real cause is that the sides of the bubbles attract water at the surface of the vessel. As the bubbles approach each other, their nearest sides both tend to raise the water between them. As a result, each of these sides raises less water than the outer side of the bubble. The greater weight of the water raised on the outer sides pushes the bubbles together. In the same way, a bubble near the side of a vessel is pushed toward it. Both the vessel and the bubble draw up the water between them. Bacon’s hypothesis cannot explain this second phenomenon.

Modern discoveries seem to confirm the wisdom of Bacon’s remark. Baron Cagnard’s experiments may be a first step toward fully proving it. The new facts discovered by that philosopher leave little doubt about the states of matter. Solids, liquids, and gases are merely stages in a gradual transition from one extreme to the other. However sharp the distinctions may seem, no sudden or abrupt boundary ultimately separates them. Instead, they pass into one another by imperceptible degrees.

Bacon’s suggestion, however, is as old as Pythagoras, and perhaps as old as the first stirrings of philosophical thought. The idea that the elements can change into one another underlies all ancient physical theories. Epicureans and Stoics alike adopted it. Ovid opens the last book of the Metamorphoses with a poetic account of the subject. There he expressly points to the idea Bacon suggested:

> ——“Tenuatus in auras > Aëraque humor abit, etc., etc. > Inde retro redeunt, idemque retexitur ordo.”—xv. 246–249.

In the third book of his Natural Philosophy, quest. iv., Seneca states the idea more precisely than either the ancient poet or the modern philosopher. Ed.

XXVI

26

In the fifth rank of prerogative instances we will class constitutive instances, which we are wont also to call collective instances. They constitute a species or lesser form, as it were, of the required nature. For since the real forms (which are always convertible with the given nature) lie at some depth, and are not easily discovered, the necessity of the case and the infirmity of the human understanding require that the particular forms, which collect certain groups of instances (but by no means all) into some common notion, should not be neglected, but most diligently observed. For whatever unites nature, even imperfectly, opens the way to the discovery of the form. The instances, therefore, which are serviceable in this respect are of no mean power, but endowed with some degree of prerogative.

In the fifth rank of prerogative instances, we place constitutive instances, which we also call collective instances. They constitute a kind, or lesser form, of the nature being investigated. True forms always correspond exactly to the given nature. But they lie deep and are not easily discovered. We must therefore account for the limits of human understanding and the difficulty of the task. We must not neglect particular forms, but observe them very carefully. These forms bring certain groups of instances, though by no means all, under a common idea. Anything that unifies nature, even imperfectly, opens the way to discovering the form. Instances that help in this way are therefore quite powerful and have some degree of prerogative.

Here, nevertheless, great care must be taken that, after the discovery of several of these particular forms, and the establishing of certain partitions or divisions of the required nature derived from them, the human understanding do not at once rest satisfied, without preparing for the investigation of the great or leading form, and taking it for granted that nature is compound and divided from its very root, despise and reject any further union as a point of superfluous refinement, and tending to mere abstraction.

Here, however, great care is needed. After discovering several particular forms, we may establish certain divisions of the nature under investigation based on them. But we must not let the human mind rest satisfied at once, without preparing to investigate the great or leading form. Nor must we assume that nature is composite and divided at its very root. Such an assumption would lead us to dismiss and reject any further unifying principle as needless refinement and mere abstraction.

For instance, let the required nature be memory, or that which excites and assists memory. The constitutive instances are order or distribution, which manifestly assists memory: topics or commonplaces in artificial memory, which may be either places in their literal sense, as a gate, a corner, a window, and the like, or familiar persons and marks, or anything else (provided it be arranged in a determinate order), as animals, plants, and words, letters, characters, historical persons, and the like, of which, however, some are more convenient than others. All these commonplaces materially assist memory, and raise it far above its natural strength. Verse, too, is recollected and learned more easily than prose. From this group of three instances—order, the commonplaces of artificial memory, and verses—is constituted one species of aid for the memory, which may be well termed a separation from infinity. For when a man strives to recollect or recall anything to memory, without a preconceived notion or perception of the object of his search, he inquires about, and labors, and turns from point to point, as if involved in infinity. But if he have any preconceived notion, this infinity is separated off, and the range of his memory is brought within closer limits. In the three instances given above, the preconceived notion is clear and determined. In the first, it must be something that agrees with order; in the second, an image which has some relation or agreement with the fixed commonplaces; in the third, words which fall into a verse: and thus infinity is divided off. Other instances will offer another species, namely, that whatever brings the intellect into contact with something that strikes the sense (the principal point of artificial memory), assists the memory. Others again offer another species, namely, whatever excites an impression by any powerful passion, as fear, shame, wonder, delight, assists the memory. Other instances will afford another species: thus those impressions remain most fixed in the memory which are taken from the mind when clear and least occupied by preceding or succeeding notions, such as the things we learn in childhood, or imagine before sleep, and the first time of any circumstance happening. Other instances afford the following species: namely, that a multitude of circumstances or handles assist the memory, such as writing in paragraphs, reading aloud, or recitation. Lastly, other instances afford still another species: thus the things we anticipate, and which rouse our attention, are more easily remembered than transient events; as if you read any work twenty times over, you will not learn it by heart so readily as if you were to read it but ten times, trying each time to repeat it, and when your memory fails you looking into the book. There are, therefore, six lesser forms, as it were, of things which assist the memory: namely—1, the separation of infinity; 2, the connection of the mind with the senses; 3, the impression in strong passion; 4, the impression on the mind when pure; 5, the multitude of handles; 6, anticipation.

For example, suppose the quality we are investigating is memory, or what stimulates and helps it. The instances that make up this inquiry include order or arrangement, which clearly helps memory. They also include the locations used in artificial memory. These may be literal places, such as a gate, a corner, or a window. They may also be familiar people, signs, or anything else, provided they are arranged in a fixed order. Examples include animals, plants, words, letters, characters, and historical figures. Some are more convenient than others. All these locations greatly help memory, raising it far above its natural strength. Verse, too, is easier to remember and learn than prose. These three instances, order, the locations of artificial memory, and verse, make up one kind of aid to memory. It may well be called a separation from infinity. When someone tries to recall something without any prior idea or perception of what they are searching for, they search and struggle. They turn from one point to another, as if lost in infinity. But a prior idea cuts off this infinity and narrows the range of the search. In the three instances above, the prior idea is clear and definite. In the first, what is sought must fit into an order. In the second, it must be an image related to or matching the fixed locations. In the third, it must be words that fit into a verse. In this way, infinity is cut off. Other instances suggest another kind of aid. Whatever brings the mind into contact with something that strikes the senses helps memory. This is the main principle of artificial memory. Still other instances suggest that whatever makes an impression through a strong emotion helps memory. Such emotions include fear, shame, wonder, and delight. Other instances suggest another kind of aid. Impressions remain most firmly in memory when the mind receives them while clear and least occupied by earlier or later ideas. These include things we learn in childhood, imagine before sleep, or experience for the first time. Other instances suggest that many circumstances or points of access help memory. Examples include writing in paragraphs, reading aloud, and reciting. Finally, other instances suggest yet another kind of aid. Things we anticipate and that arouse our attention are easier to remember than passing events. For example, suppose you read a work twenty times. You will not learn it by heart as easily as if you read it only ten times, trying to repeat it each time. Whenever your memory fails, you look at the book. There are, then, six lesser forms, as it were, of things that help memory: 1, the separation from infinity; 2, the connection of the mind with the senses; 3, impressions made by strong emotion; 4, impressions made on a clear mind; 5, many points of access; 6, anticipation.

The author’s own system of Memoria Technica can be found in the De Augmentis, chap. xv. Bacon said he intended his method to apply to religion, politics, and morals. Yet this is the only lengthy example he gave of a subject outside physical science. Ed.

Again, for example’s sake, let the required nature be taste or the power of tasting. The following instances are constitutive: 1. Those who do not smell, but are deprived by nature of that sense, do not perceive or distinguish rancid or putrid food by their taste, nor garlic from roses, and the like. 2. Again, those whose nostrils are obstructed by accident (such as a cold) do not distinguish any putrid or rancid matter from anything sprinkled with rose-water. 3. If those who suffer from a cold blow their noses violently at the very moment in which they have anything fetid or perfumed in their mouth, or on their palate, they instantly have a clear perception of the fetor or perfume. These instances afford and constitute this species or division of taste, namely, that it is in part nothing else than an internal smelling, passing and descending through the upper passages of the nostrils to the mouth and palate. But, on the other hand, those whose power of smelling is deficient or obstructed, perceive what is salt, sweet, pungent, acid, rough, and bitter, and the like, as well as any one else: so that the taste is clearly something compounded of the internal smelling, and an exquisite species of touch which we will not here discuss.

Again, as an example, let the nature we are investigating be taste, or the power of tasting. The following instances help define it: 1. People born without a sense of smell cannot use taste to detect or distinguish rancid or rotten food. Nor can they distinguish garlic from roses, and so on. 2. Similarly, people whose nostrils are blocked, as by a cold, cannot distinguish rotten or rancid matter from anything sprinkled with rose water. 3. Suppose people with a cold have something foul-smelling or fragrant in their mouth or on their palate. If they blow their noses hard at that very moment, they instantly perceive the foul smell or fragrance clearly. These instances establish one kind or part of taste. It is, in part, nothing more than an internal sense of smell. This passes down through the upper passages of the nostrils to the mouth and palate. But people whose sense of smell is impaired or blocked can perceive salt, sweet, pungent, sour, rough, and bitter tastes, and the like, as well as anyone else. Taste is therefore clearly a combination of internal smelling and a highly refined kind of touch. We will not discuss this kind of touch here.

Again, as another example, let the required nature be the communication of quality, without intermixture of substance. The instance of light will afford or constitute one species of communication, heat and the magnet another. For the communication of light is momentary and immediately arrested upon the removal of the original light. But heat, and the magnetic force, when once transmitted to or excited in another body, remain fixed for a considerable time after the removal of the source.

As another example, suppose the nature we are investigating is the transmission of a quality without any mixing of substance. Light provides one kind of transmission. Heat and magnetism provide another. Light is transmitted instantly, and its transmission stops immediately when the original light is removed. But heat and magnetic force remain in another body for a considerable time once transmitted to or induced in it. They remain even after the source is removed.

In fine, the prerogative of constitutive instances is considerable, for they materially assist the definitions (especially in detail) and the divisions or partitions of natures, concerning which Plato has well said, “He who can properly define and divide is to be considered a god.”

In short, constitutive instances are especially valuable. They greatly help us define natures, especially in detail, and divide them into parts. As Plato rightly said, “Anyone who can properly define and divide should be considered a god.”

The collective instances meant here are simply general facts or laws of varying degrees of generality. They are themselves the result of induction. For example, Jupiter or Saturn and its satellites form a collective instance. This instance greatly helped secure acceptance of the Copernican system. Here we see, in miniature and at a glance, a system like that of the planets around the sun. Because we are part of the solar system, we are poorly placed to see it except in detail. We can form a general idea of it only through slow, gradual reasoning.

But there is a kind of collective instance that Bacon does not seem to have considered. In these instances, so many individual phenomena appear at once that we can discover their law simply by looking. For example, a jet of water from a hole takes a parabolic shape. This shape is a collective instance of the speeds and directions of all the particles that make up the jet. Seeing them together lets us recognize the law of a projectile's motion without difficulty.

Similarly, sand scattered on vibrating glass or metal plates forms beautiful patterns. These are collective instances of countless points that remain still while the rest of the plate vibrates. As a result, the patterns reveal the law governing the arrangement and sequence of those points across the whole surface. The richly colored lemniscates seen around the optic axis of crystals exposed to polarized light are another striking example. They point directly to the general mathematical expression of the law governing their production.

Such collective instances lead us to a general law through an induction that arises spontaneously. They thus provide advanced positions for philosophical exploration. Kepler's laws may be cited as a collective instance. Bacon ignored them because he lacked a taste for mathematics. The first law states that the planets move in elliptical orbits, with the sun as their common focus. The second states that each planet's radius vector sweeps out equal areas around this focus in equal times. The third states that the squares of the planets' orbital periods are proportional to the cubes of their mean distances from the sun. This collective instance “opened the way” to the discovery of the Newtonian law of gravitation. Ed.

XXVII

27

In the sixth rank of prerogative instances we will place similar or proportionate instances, which we are also wont to call physical parallels, or resemblances. They are such as exhibit the resemblances and connection of things, not in minor forms (as the constitutive do), but at once in the concrete. They are, therefore, as it were, the first and lowest steps toward the union of nature; nor do they immediately establish any axiom, but merely indicate and observe a certain relation of bodies to each other. But although they be not of much assistance in discovering forms, yet they are of great advantage in disclosing the frame of parts of the universe, upon whose members they practice a species of anatomy, and thence occasionally lead us gently on to sublime and noble axioms, especially such as relate to the construction of the world, rather than to simple natures and forms.

In the sixth rank of prerogative instances, we place similar or proportionate instances. We also call these physical parallels or resemblances. They show the similarities and connections between things, not in their lesser forms, as constitutive instances do, but in concrete things themselves. They are, so to speak, the first and lowest steps toward the unity of nature. They do not establish any axiom directly. They merely reveal and draw attention to certain relationships between bodies. Although these instances are not very helpful in discovering forms, they are highly useful in revealing how the parts of the universe fit together. They do this by performing a kind of anatomy on those parts. From there, they sometimes lead us gently toward lofty and noble axioms. These concern the construction of the world rather than simple natures and forms.

As an example, take the following similar instances: a mirror and the eye; the formation of the ear, and places which return an echo. From such similarity, besides observing the resemblance (which is useful for many purposes), it is easy to collect and form this axiom. That the organs of the senses, and bodies which produce reflections to the senses, are of a similar nature. Again, the understanding once informed of this, rises easily to a higher and nobler axiom; namely, that the only distinction between sensitive and inanimate bodies, in those points in which they agree and sympathize, is this: in the former, animal spirit is added to the arrangement of the body, in the latter it is wanting. So that there might be as many senses in animals as there are points of agreement with inanimate bodies, if the animated body were perforated, so as to allow the spirit to have access to the limb properly disposed for action, as a fit organ. And, on the other hand, there are, without doubt, as many motions in an inanimate as there are senses in the animated body, though the animal spirit be absent. There must, however, be many more motions in inanimate bodies than senses in the animated, from the small number of organs of sense. A very plain example of this is afforded by pains. For, as animals are liable to many kinds and various descriptions of pains (such as those of burning, of intense cold, of pricking, squeezing, stretching, and the like), so is it most certain, that the same circumstances, as far as motion is concerned, happen to inanimate bodies, such as wood or stone when burned, frozen, pricked, cut, bent, bruised, and the like; although there be no sensation, owing to the absence of animal spirit.

Take these examples of similar things: a mirror and the eye, and the structure of the ear and places that produce an echo. Besides noting the resemblance, which is useful for many purposes, we can easily draw a principle from it. Sense organs and bodies that reflect things back to the senses are similar in nature. Once the mind understands this, it can easily rise to a higher and nobler principle. In the ways that sensitive and inanimate bodies agree and respond alike, they differ in only one respect. In sensitive bodies, animal spirit is added to the body's structure. In inanimate bodies, it is absent. Animals could therefore have as many senses as they have points of agreement with inanimate bodies. This would be possible if the living body had openings allowing the spirit to reach a body part suitably arranged to act as an organ. Conversely, inanimate bodies undoubtedly have as many motions as living bodies have senses, although animal spirit is absent. But inanimate bodies must have many more motions than living bodies have senses, because sense organs are few. Pain provides a very clear example. Animals are subject to many kinds and degrees of pain. These include the pain of burning, intense cold, pricking, squeezing, stretching, and the like. It is equally certain that, as far as motion is concerned, the same things happen to inanimate bodies. For example, wood or stone can be burned, frozen, pricked, cut, bent, bruised, and so on. Yet there is no sensation, because animal spirit is absent.

Again, wonderful as it may appear, the roots and branches of trees are similar instances. For every vegetable swells and throws out its constituent parts toward the circumference, both upward and downward. And there is no difference between the roots and branches, except that the root is buried in the earth, and the branches are exposed to the air and sun. For if one take a young and vigorous shoot, and bend it down to a small portion of loose earth, although it be not fixed to the ground, yet will it immediately produce a root, and not a branch. And, vice versâ, if earth be placed above, and so forced down with a stone or any hard substance, as to confine the plant and prevent its branching upward, it will throw out branches into the air downward.

Again, surprising as it may seem, the roots and branches of trees are similar examples. Every plant swells and sends its parts outward, both upward and downward. The only difference is that roots are buried in the earth, while branches are exposed to air and sun. Take a young, vigorous shoot and bend it down to a small patch of loose earth. Even if it is not fixed to the ground, it will immediately produce a root, not a branch. And vice versa, if earth is placed above the plant, it can be pressed down with a stone or another hard object. If this confines the plant and prevents it from branching upward, it will send branches downward into the air.

The gums of trees, and most rock gems, are similar instances; for both of them are exudations and filtered juices, derived in the former instance from trees, in the latter from stones; the brightness and clearness of both arising from a delicate and accurate filtering. For nearly the same reason, the hair of animals is less beautiful and vivid in its color than the plumage of most birds, because the juices are less delicately filtered through the skin than through the quills.

Tree gums and most rock gems are similar examples. Both are substances that seep out and are filtered, tree gums from trees and gems from stones. Both are bright and clear because they have been filtered finely and thoroughly. For much the same reason, animal hair is less beautiful and vivid in color than the feathers of most birds. The juices are filtered less finely through skin than through quills.

The scrotum of males and matrix of females are also similar instances; so that the noble formation which constitutes the difference of the sexes appears to differ only as to the one being internal and the other external; a greater degree of heat causing the genitals to protrude in the male, while the heat of the female being too weak to effect this, they are retained internally.

The male scrotum and the female womb are also similar examples. The remarkable structure that distinguishes the sexes appears to differ only in being internal in females and external in males. Greater heat causes the male genitals to protrude. The female’s heat is too weak to do this, so her genitals remain inside.

The fins of fishes and the feet of quadrupeds, or the feet and wings of birds, are similar instances; to which Aristotle adds the four folds in the motion of serpents; so that in the formation of the universe, the motion of animals appears to be chiefly effected by four joints or bendings.

The fins of fish and the feet of four-legged animals are similar examples, as are the feet and wings of birds. Aristotle adds the four bends in the movement of snakes. So, in the formation of the universe, animals seem to move mainly by means of four joints or bends.

Isn't this a very hasty generalization? Do snakes move with only four bends? Also, observe how centipedes and other insects move.

The teeth of land animals, and the beaks of birds, are similar instances, whence it is clear, that in all perfect animals there is a determination of some hard substance toward the mouth.

The teeth of land animals and the beaks of birds are similar examples. They show that in all fully developed animals, some hard substance forms toward the mouth.

Again, the resemblance and conformity of man to an inverted plant is not absurd. For the head is the root of the nerves and animal faculties, and the seminal parts are the lowest, not including the extremities of the legs and arms. But in the plant, the root (which resembles the head) is regularly placed in the lowest, and the seeds in the highest part.

Again, it is not absurd to compare a man to an upside-down plant. The head is the root of the nerves and the faculties of animal life. The reproductive organs are the lowest part, apart from the ends of the legs and arms. But in a plant, the root, which resembles the head, is normally at the bottom. The seeds are at the top.

Shaw notes another difference between the things cited in the text: animals have their roots inside, while plants have theirs outside. Animal lacteals correspond closely to the root fibers of plants. Thus animals seem to be nourished from within, just as plants are nourished from without. Ed.

Lastly, we must particularly recommend and suggest, that man’s present industry in the investigation and compilation of natural history be entirely changed, and directed to the reverse of the present system. For it has hitherto been active and curious in noting the variety of things, and explaining the accurate differences of animals, vegetables, and minerals, most of which are the mere sport of nature, rather than of any real utility as concerns the sciences. Pursuits of this nature are certainly agreeable, and sometimes of practical advantage, but contribute little or nothing to the thorough investigation of nature. Our labor must therefore be directed toward inquiring into and observing resemblances and analogies, both in the whole and its parts, for they unite nature, and lay the foundation of the sciences.

Lastly, we must strongly recommend a complete change in how people investigate and compile natural history. Their efforts should be directed in the opposite way from the present system. Until now, they have been busy and curious about recording the variety of things. They have carefully described the differences among animals, plants, and minerals. Most of these differences are merely nature’s play and have no real use for the sciences. Such pursuits are certainly enjoyable and sometimes practically useful, but they contribute little or nothing to a thorough investigation of nature. We must therefore direct our efforts toward investigating and observing similarities and analogies, both in whole things and their parts. These unite nature and lay the foundation of the sciences.

Here, however, a severe and rigorous caution must be observed, that we only consider as similar and proportionate instances, those which (as we first observed) point out physical resemblances; that is, real and substantial resemblances, deeply founded in nature, and not casual and superficial, much less superstitious or curious; such as those which are constantly put forward by the writers on natural magic (the most idle of men, and who are scarcely fit to be named in connection with such serious matters as we now treat of), who, with much vanity and folly, describe, and sometimes too, invent, unmeaning resemblances and sympathies.

Here, however, we must exercise great care. As we first noted, we should count instances as similar and proportionate only when they show physical resemblances. These resemblances must be real and substantial, deeply rooted in nature, not accidental or superficial. Still less should they be superstitious or fanciful, like those constantly offered by writers on natural magic. These writers are the most idle of men and are scarcely fit to be mentioned in connection with such serious matters as we are discussing. With great vanity and folly, they describe meaningless resemblances and sympathies, and sometimes even invent them.

But leaving such to themselves, similar instances are not to be neglected, in the greater portions of the world’s conformation; such as Africa and the Peruvian continent, which reaches to the Straits of Magellan; both of which possess a similar isthmus and similar capes, a circumstance not to be attributed to mere accident.

But leaving such things aside, we should not overlook similarities in the shapes of the world's major landmasses. Africa and the Peruvian continent, which reaches to the Straits of Magellan, have similar isthmuses and capes. This similarity cannot be attributed to mere chance.

Again, the New and Old World are both of them broad and expanded toward the north, and narrow and pointed toward the south.

Also, both the New and Old World are broad in the north and narrow to a point in the south.

Again, we have very remarkable similar instances in the intense cold, toward the middle regions (as it is termed) of the air, and the violent fires which are often found to burst from subterraneous spots, the similarity consisting in both being ends and extremes; the extreme of the nature of cold, for instance, is toward the boundary of heaven, and that of the nature of heat toward the centre of the earth, by a similar species of opposition or rejection of the contrary nature.

Again, we find remarkably similar examples in the intense cold of what is called the middle region of the air and the fierce fires that often burst from underground. They are similar because both occur at outer limits and extremes. The extreme of cold, for example, is toward the boundary of heaven. The extreme of heat is toward the center of the earth. Both arise through a similar kind of opposition to, or rejection of, the opposite nature.

Lastly, in the axioms of the sciences, there is a similarity of instances worthy of observation. Thus the rhetorical trope which is called surprise, is similar to that of music termed the declining of a cadence. Again—the mathematical postulate, that things which are equal to the same are equal to one another, is similar to the form of the syllogism in logic, which unites things agreeing in the middle term. Lastly, a certain degree of sagacity in collecting and searching for physical points of similarity, is very useful in many respects.

Lastly, the principles of the sciences contain similarities worth noting. For example, the rhetorical figure called surprise resembles the musical device called the declining of a cadence. Similarly, a mathematical postulate states that things equal to the same thing are equal to one another. This resembles the logical syllogism, which connects things that agree with a middle term. Finally, some skill in finding and gathering similarities in nature is useful in many ways.

Bacon makes an error here by treating the syllogism as distinct from the faculty of reasoning and as only one of its forms. It is not generally true that the syllogism is merely a form of reasoning that connects ideas that agree with the middle term. Such agreement is not even essential to a valid syllogism. If two things are equal or similar to a third, they can of course be said to be equal or similar to each other. But if their relation to the third term takes a different form, then the two extremes do not necessarily have the same relation to each other as they have to the middle term. For example, if A is double B, and B is double C, then A is four times C. But A’s relation to C differs from A’s relation to B and B’s relation to C. Ed.

Comparative anatomy is full of such similarities. Similarities between natural and artificial products deserve attention and sometimes lead to important discoveries. Harvey noticed one such similarity between hydraulic engines and blood vessels. Hydraulic engines use a mechanism to prevent fluid from flowing backward, and blood vessels have a similar feature. This observation led Harvey to discover the circulation of the blood. Ed.

XXVIII

28

In the seventh rank of prerogative instances, we will place singular instances, which we are also wont to call irregular or heteroclite (to borrow a term from the grammarians). They are such as exhibit bodies in the concrete, of an apparently extravagant and separate nature, agreeing but little with other things of the same species. For, while the similar instances resemble each other, those we now speak of are only like themselves. Their use is much the same with that of clandestine instances: they bring out and unite nature, and discover genera or common natures, which must afterward be limited by real differences. Nor should we desist from inquiry, until the properties and qualities of those things, which may be deemed miracles, as it were, of nature, be reduced to, and comprehended in, some form or certain law; so that all irregularity or singularity may be found to depend on some common form; and the miracle only consists in accurate differences, degree, and rare coincidence, not in the species itself. Man’s meditation proceeds no further at present, than just to consider things of this kind as the secrets and vast efforts of nature, without an assignable cause, and, as it were, exceptions to general rules.

In the seventh rank of prerogative instances, we place singular instances. We also call them irregular or heteroclite instances, borrowing a term from grammarians. These are instances of particular bodies that seem unusual and distinct, with little in common with others of their species. Similar instances resemble one another, but singular instances resemble only themselves. Their use is much the same as that of clandestine instances. They bring together things in nature and reveal genera, or common natures. These must afterward be defined by their real differences. We should not stop investigating until we understand the properties and qualities of these apparent miracles of nature. We must bring them under some form or definite law. In this way, all irregularity or singularity may be found to depend on some common form. The miracle lies only in precise differences, degree, and rare coincidence, not in the species itself. At present, human thought goes no further than treating such things as nature’s secrets and extraordinary efforts. It sees them as having no identifiable cause and as exceptions, as it were, to general rules.

As examples of singular instances, we have the sun and moon among the heavenly bodies; the magnet among minerals; quicksilver among metals; the elephant among quadrupeds; the venereal sensation among the different kinds of touch; the scent of sporting dogs among those of smell. The letter S, too, is considered by the grammarians as sui generis, from its easily uniting with double or triple consonants, which no other letter will. These instances are of great value, because they excite and keep alive inquiry, and correct an understanding depraved by habit and the common course of things.

Examples of singular instances include the sun and moon among heavenly bodies, the magnet among minerals, and mercury among metals. Other examples are the elephant among four-legged animals, sexual sensation among kinds of touch, and the scenting ability of hunting dogs among kinds of smell. Grammarians also consider the letter S unique. It easily combines with two or three consonants, which no other letter can do. These instances are very valuable because they inspire and sustain inquiry. They also correct an understanding corrupted by habit and the usual course of things.

XXIX

29

In the eighth rank of prerogative instances, we will place deviating instances, such as the errors of nature, or strange and monstrous objects, in which nature deviates and turns from her ordinary course. For the errors of nature differ from singular instances, inasmuch as the latter are the miracles of species, the former of individuals. Their use is much the same, for they rectify the understanding in opposition to habit, and reveal common forms. For with regard to these, also, we must not desist from inquiry, till we discern the cause of the deviation. The cause does not, however, in such cases rise to a regular form, but only to the latent process toward such a form. For he who is acquainted with the paths of nature, will more readily observe her deviations; and, vice versâ, he who has learned her deviations will be able more accurately to describe her paths.

In the eighth rank of prerogative instances, we place deviating instances. These include errors of nature and strange or monstrous objects, in which nature departs from its usual course. Errors of nature differ from singular instances. Singular instances are miracles of species, while errors of nature are miracles of individuals. Their uses are much the same. Both correct our understanding against the influence of habit and reveal common forms. Here too, we must keep investigating until we find the cause of the deviation. In such cases, however, the cause does not lead to a regular form. It leads only to the hidden process toward such a form. Someone who knows nature's paths will more readily notice its deviations. And, vice versa, someone who has learned its deviations will be able to describe its paths more accurately.

They differ again from singular instances, by being much more apt for practice and the operative branch. For it would be very difficult to generate new species, but less so to vary known species, and thus produce many rare and unusual results. The passage from the miracles of nature to those of art is easy; for if nature be once seized in her variations, and the cause be manifest, it will be easy to lead her by art to such deviation as she was at first led to by chance; and not only to that but others, since deviations on the one side lead and open the way to others in every direction. Of this we do not require any examples, since they are so abundant. For a compilation, or particular natural history, must be made of all monsters and prodigious births of nature; of everything, in short, which is new, rare and unusual in nature. This should be done with a rigorous selection, so as to be worthy of credit. Those are most to be suspected which depend upon superstition, as the prodigies of Livy, and those perhaps, but little less, which are found in the works of writers on natural magic, or even alchemy, and the like; for such men, as it were, are the very suitors and lovers of fables; but our instances should be derived from some grave and credible history, and faithful narration.

They also differ from singular instances because they are much more useful in practice and in producing results. It would be very difficult to create new species, but less difficult to alter known species. In this way, we can produce many rare and unusual results. It is easy to move from the wonders of nature to those produced by human skill. Once we have observed nature’s variations and understood their cause, we can use skill to guide nature toward the same variation that first occurred by chance. We can also produce other variations. For variations in one direction lead and open the way to others in every direction. We need no examples of this, since they are so abundant. We must compile a detailed natural history of all monsters and extraordinary births of nature. In short, it must include everything in nature that is new, rare, and unusual. The selection must be rigorous, so that the account is credible. We should be most suspicious of accounts based on superstition, such as Livy’s accounts of prodigies. Perhaps we should be only a little less suspicious of accounts in works on natural magic, alchemy, and similar subjects. For such writers are, as it were, the very suitors and lovers of fables. Our instances, however, should come from serious, credible histories and faithful accounts.

Plants illustrate this well. A gardener can produce endless varieties of any known species, but can never produce a new species.

XXX

30

In the ninth rank of prerogative instances, we will place bordering instances, which we are also wont to term participants. They are such as exhibit those species of bodies which appear to be composed of two species, or to be the rudiments between the one and the other. They may well be classed with the singular or heteroclite instances; for in the whole system of things, they are rare and extraordinary. Yet from their dignity, they must be treated of and classed separately, for they point out admirably the order and constitution of things, and suggest the causes of the number and quality of the more common species in the universe, leading the understanding from that which is, to that which is possible.

In the ninth rank of prerogative instances, we place bordering instances, which we also call participants. These show species of bodies that appear to be composed of two species, or to be early forms between them. They could be classed with singular or irregular instances, since they are rare and extraordinary in the whole system of things. Yet their importance means they must be treated and classed separately. They reveal the order and structure of things remarkably well. They also suggest why the more common species in the universe are as numerous and as varied as they are. In doing so, they lead the understanding from what exists to what is possible.

We have examples of them in moss, which is something between putrescence and a plant; in some comets, which hold a place between stars and ignited meteors; in flying fishes, between fishes and birds; and in bats, between birds and quadrupeds. Again,

We have examples of them in moss, which is something between decay and a plant. Some comets lie between stars and burning meteors. Flying fish lie between fish and birds, and bats between birds and four-legged animals. Again,

Tournefort's discoveries established that moss is a plant. The fish mentioned below are found only in the tropics. Ed.

However, neither flying fish nor bats are truly like birds, just as a man is not like a fish because he can swim. The wings of flying fish and bats are merely extensions of skin. They bear no resemblance to birds' wings. Ed.

Simia quam similis turpissima bestia nobis.

How like us the ape is, that ugliest of beasts.

We have also biformed fœtus, mingled species and the like.

We also have fetuses with two forms, mixed species, and the like.

XXXI

31

In the tenth rank of prerogative instances, we will place the instances of power, or the fasces (to borrow a term from the insignia of empire), which we are also wont to call the wit or hands of man. These are such works as are most noble and perfect, and, as it were, the masterpieces in every art. For since our principal object is to make nature subservient to the state and wants of man, it becomes us well to note and enumerate the works, which have long since been in the power of man, especially those which are most polished and perfect: because the passage from these to new and hitherto undiscovered works, is more easy and feasible. For if any one, after an attentive contemplation of such works as are extant, be willing to push forward in his design with alacrity and vigor, he will undoubtedly either advance them, or turn them to something within their immediate reach, or even apply and transfer them to some more noble purpose.

In the tenth rank of prerogative instances, we place instances of power, or the fasces. We borrow this term from the symbols of imperial authority. We also call these instances the wit or hands of man. They are the noblest and most perfect works, the masterpieces of every art. Our main aim is to make nature serve human life and needs. So we should note and list the works that people have long been able to produce, especially the most polished and perfect. For it is easier to move from these works to new ones that have not yet been discovered. Suppose someone studies existing works carefully and then pursues a design eagerly and vigorously. That person will undoubtedly improve the works, turn them to some closely related use, or even adapt them to a nobler purpose.

Nor is this all: for as the understanding is elevated and raised by rare and unusual works of nature, to investigate and discover the forms which include them also, so is the same effect frequently produced by the excellent and wonderful works of art; and even to a greater degree, because the mode of effecting and constructing the miracles of art is generally plain, while that of effecting the miracles of nature is more obscure. Great care, however, must be taken, that they do not depress the understanding, and fix it, as it were, to earth.

Nor is this all. Rare and unusual works of nature lift the understanding, prompting it to investigate and discover the forms that include them. Excellent and wonderful works of art often have the same effect, and to an even greater degree. This is because how the miracles of art are made is generally clear, while how nature produces its miracles is more obscure. Great care must be taken, however, that these works do not lower the understanding and fix it, as it were, to the earth.

For there is some danger, lest the understanding should be astonished and chained down, and as it were bewitched, by such works of art, as appear to be the very summit and pinnacle of human industry, so as not to become familiar with them, but rather to suppose that nothing of the kind can be accomplished, unless the same means be employed, with perhaps a little more diligence, and more accurate preparation.

For there is some danger that the mind may be awed, held captive, and almost bewitched by works of art. These works seem to be the highest achievements of human effort. As a result, the mind may fail to become familiar with them. Instead, it may suppose that nothing of the kind can be accomplished without using the same methods, perhaps with a little more care and more precise preparation.

Now, on the contrary, it may be stated as a fact, that the ways and means hitherto discovered and observed, of effecting any matter or work, are for the most part of little value, and that all really efficient power depends, and is really to be deduced from the sources of forms, none of which have yet been discovered.

On the contrary, it is a fact that most methods discovered and used so far to accomplish anything are of little value. All truly effective power depends on and must be derived from the sources of forms. None of these sources has yet been discovered.

Thus (as we have before observed), had any one meditated on ballistic machines, and battering rams, as they were used by the ancients, whatever application he might have exerted, and though he might have consumed a whole life in the pursuit, yet would he never have hit upon the invention of flaming engines, acting by means of gunpowder; nor would any person, who had made woollen manufactories and cotton the subject of his observation and reflection, have ever discovered thereby the nature of the silkworm or of silk.

As we have observed before, someone might have studied the ballistic machines and battering rams used by the ancients. However hard they worked, even if they spent a lifetime on the task, they would never have invented weapons powered by gunpowder. Nor would anyone who studied and reflected on wool manufacturing and cotton ever have discovered the nature of the silkworm or of silk.

Hence all the most noble discoveries have (if you observe) come to light, not by any gradual improvement and extension of the arts, but merely by chance; while nothing imitates or anticipates chance (which is wont to act at intervals of ages) but the invention of forms.

So, if you look closely, all the greatest discoveries have come about by chance, not through gradual improvements and advances in the arts. But chance tends to produce discoveries only once in many ages. Nothing can imitate or anticipate it except the discovery of forms.

There is no necessity for adducing any particular examples of these instances, since they are abundant. The plan to be pursued is this: all the mechanical, and even the liberal arts (as far as they are practical), should be visited and thoroughly examined, and thence there should be formed a compilation or particular history of the great masterpieces, or most finished works in each, as well as of the mode of carrying them into effect.

There is no need to give specific examples of these instances, since they are plentiful. The plan is this: all the mechanical arts, and even the liberal arts insofar as they are practical, should be visited and thoroughly examined. From this examination, a compilation or detailed history should be made of the masterpieces or most finished works in each art. It should also describe how those works are made.

Nor do we confine the diligence to be used in such a compilation to the leading works and secrets only of every art, and such as excite wonder; for wonder is engendered by rarity, since that which is rare, although it be compounded of ordinary natures, always begets wonder.

Nor should we limit our careful work on such a compilation to the major works and secrets of each art, or to things that inspire wonder. For rarity creates wonder. A rare thing always inspires wonder, even if it is made up of ordinary elements.

On the contrary, that which is really wonderful, from some specific difference distinguishing it from other species, is carelessly observed, if it be but familiar. Yet the singular instances of art should be observed no less than those of nature, which we have before spoken of: and as in the latter we have classed the sun, the moon, the magnet, and the like, all of them most familiar to us, but yet in their nature singular, so should we proceed with the singular instances of art.

On the contrary, we observe something carelessly if it is familiar, even when it is truly remarkable in what distinguishes it from other kinds. Yet we should observe unique examples of art as carefully as the unique examples of nature discussed earlier. Among those examples of nature, we included the sun, the moon, the magnet, and the like. All are very familiar to us, but unique in their nature. We should proceed in the same way with unique examples of art.

For example: paper, a very common substance, is a singular instance of art; for if you consider the subject attentively, you will find that artificial substances are either woven by straight and transverse lines, as silk, woollen, or linen cloth, and the like; or coagulated from concrete juices, such as brick, earthenware, glass, enamel, porcelain and the like, which admit of a polish if they be compact, but if not, become hard without being polished; all which latter substances are brittle, and not adherent or tenacious. On the contrary, paper is a tenacious substance, which can be cut and torn, so as to resemble and almost rival the skin of any animal, or the leaf of vegetables, and the like works of nature; being neither brittle like glass, nor woven like cloth, but having fibres and not distinct threads, just as natural substances, so that scarcely anything similar can be found among artificial substances, and it is absolutely singular. And in artificial works we should certainly prefer those which approach the nearest to an imitation of nature, or, on the other hand, powerfully govern and change her course.

For example, paper is a very common substance, but it is a unique example of human craftsmanship. If you look closely, you will find that manufactured substances are of two kinds. Some are woven from lengthwise and crosswise threads, like silk, woolen, or linen cloth. Others are formed from materials that have hardened together, such as brick, earthenware, glass, enamel, and porcelain. These substances can be polished if they are compact. If they are not compact, they harden without taking a polish. All substances of this second kind are brittle, and they do not hold together firmly. Paper, by contrast, is a tough substance that can be cut and torn. It resembles and almost rivals animal skin, plant leaves, and similar works of nature. It is not brittle like glass or woven like cloth. Like natural substances, it has fibers rather than separate threads. Hardly anything like it can be found among manufactured substances, and it is absolutely unique. Among human creations, we should certainly favor those that come closest to imitating nature or, on the other hand, powerfully control and change its course.

Again, in these instances which we term the wit and hands of man, charms and conjuring should not be altogether despised, for although mere amusements, and of little use, yet they may afford considerable information.

Again, among the examples we call the wit and hands of man, charms and conjuring should not be entirely dismissed. Although they are merely amusements and of little use, they may provide considerable information.

Lastly, superstition and magic (in its common acceptation) are not to be entirely omitted; for although they be overwhelmed by a mass of lies and fables, yet some investigation should be made, to see if there be really any latent natural operation in them; as in fascination, and the fortifying of the imagination, the sympathy of distant objects, the transmission of impressions from spirit to spirit no less than from body to body, and the like.

Lastly, superstition and magic, as commonly understood, should not be entirely overlooked. Although they are buried under a mass of lies and fables, they deserve some investigation. We should see whether any hidden natural processes are really at work in them. Examples include fascination, the strengthening of the imagination, and the sympathy between distant objects. They also include the transmission of impressions from spirit to spirit, just as from body to body, and similar phenomena.

XXXII

32

From the foregoing remarks, it is clear that the last five species of instances (the similar, singular, deviating and bordering instances, and those of power) should not be reserved for the investigation of any given nature, as the preceding and many of the succeeding instances must, but a collection of them should be made at once, in the style of a particular history, so that they may arrange the matter which enters the understanding, and correct its depraved habit, for it is necessarily imbued, corrupted, perverted and distorted by daily and habitual impressions.

From these remarks, it is clear that the last five types of instances should not be reserved for investigating a particular nature. These are similar, singular, deviating, and bordering instances, and instances of power. The preceding instances and many of those that follow must be reserved for such investigations. But these five types should be collected at once, in the form of a particular history. This will help organize the material that enters the mind and correct its corrupted habits. For daily, habitual impressions necessarily fill, corrupt, pervert, and distort the mind.

They are to be used, therefore, as a preparative, for the purpose of rectifying and purifying the understanding; for whatever withdraws it from habit, levels and planes down its surface for the reception of the dry and pure light of true notions.

They should therefore be used to prepare, correct, and purify the understanding. For whatever draws the understanding away from habit smooths its surface, making it ready to receive the dry, pure light of true ideas.

These instances, moreover, level and prepare the way for the operative branch, as we will mention in its proper place when speaking of the practical deductions.

These examples also prepare the way for practical work. We will discuss this in the proper place, when we consider practical conclusions.

XXXIII

33

In the eleventh rank of prerogative instances we will place accompanying and hostile instances. These are such as exhibit any body or concrete, where the required nature is constantly found, as an inseparable companion, or, on the contrary, where the required nature is constantly avoided, and excluded from attendance, as an enemy. From these instances may be formed certain and universal propositions, either affirmative or negative; the subject of which will be the concrete body, and the predicate the required nature. For particular propositions are by no means fixed, when the required nature is found to fluctuate and change in the concrete, either approaching and acquired, or receding and laid aside. Hence particular propositions have no great prerogative, except in the case of migration, of which we have spoken above. Yet such particular propositions are of great use, when compared with the universal, as will be mentioned in its proper place. Nor do we require absolute affirmation or negation, even in universal propositions, for if the exceptions be singular or rare, it is sufficient for our purpose.

In the eleventh rank of prerogative instances, we place accompanying and hostile instances. These show a body or concrete thing in which the nature under investigation is always found, as an inseparable companion. Or, on the contrary, they show one from which that nature is always absent and excluded, as an enemy. From these instances, we can form certain and universal propositions, either affirmative or negative. The concrete body will be the subject of these propositions, and the nature under investigation will be the predicate. Particular propositions, however, are by no means fixed. They concern cases where the nature under investigation varies within the concrete body, appearing and being acquired or disappearing and being lost. Particular propositions therefore have no great privilege, except in the case of migration, which we discussed above. Yet they are very useful when compared with universal propositions, as we will explain in its proper place. Even universal propositions need not affirm or deny absolutely. If the exceptions are isolated or rare, that is enough for our purpose.

The use of accompanying instances is to narrow the affirmative of form; for as it is narrowed by the migrating instances, where the form must necessarily be something communicated or destroyed by the act of migration, so it is narrowed by accompanying instances, where the form must necessarily be something which enters into the concretion of the body, or, on the contrary, is repugnant to it; and one who is well acquainted with the constitution or formation of the body, will not be far from bringing to light the form of the required nature.

Accompanying instances help narrow down what can be affirmed about the form. Migrating instances narrow it down in one way: the form must be something imparted or destroyed by the act of migration. Accompanying instances narrow it down in another: the form must be something that enters into the composition of the body, or else is incompatible with it. So anyone who understands the body’s constitution or formation will be close to discovering the form of the nature being sought.

For example: let the required nature be heat. Flame is an accompanying instance; for in water, air, stone, metal, and many other substances, heat is variable, and can approach or retire; but all flame is hot, so that heat always accompanies the concretion of flame. We have no hostile instance of heat; for the senses are unacquainted with the interior of the earth, and there is no concretion of any known body which is not susceptible of heat.

For example, suppose heat is the property we are investigating. Flame is an accompanying instance. In water, air, stone, metal, and many other substances, heat varies. It can come and go. But all flame is hot, so heat always accompanies flame as a physical substance. We have no hostile instance of heat. For our senses cannot reach the interior of the earth, and every known physical substance is capable of being heated.

Again, let solidity be the required nature. Air is a hostile instance; for metals may be liquid or solid, so may glass; even water may become solid by congelation, but air cannot become solid or lose its fluidity.

Again, suppose solidity is the quality we are investigating. Air is a hostile instance. Metals and glass can be liquid or solid. Even water can become solid by freezing. But air cannot become solid or lose its fluidity.

With regard to these instances of fixed propositions, there are two points to be observed, which are of importance. First, that if there be no universal affirmative or negative, it be carefully noted as not existing. Thus, in heat, we have observed that there exists no universal negative, in such substances, at least, as have come to our knowledge. Again, if the required nature be eternity or incorruptibility, we have no universal affirmative within our sphere, for these qualities cannot be predicated of any bodies below the heavens, or above the interior of the earth. Secondly, to our general propositions as to any concrete, whether affirmative or negative, we should subjoin the concretes which appear to approach nearest to the non-existing substances; such as the most gentle or least-burning flames in heat, or gold in incorruptibility, since it approaches nearest to it. For they all serve to show the limit of existence and non-existence, and circumscribe forms, so that they cannot wander beyond the conditions of matter.

There are two important points to note about these instances of fixed propositions. First, if there is no universal affirmative or negative proposition, we must carefully note its absence. For example, we have observed that there is no universal negative proposition about heat, at least among substances known to us. Again, suppose the nature we are investigating is eternity or incorruptibility. Within our sphere, we have no universal affirmative proposition about either. For neither quality can be attributed to any bodies below the heavens or above the earth’s interior. Second, we should add examples to our general propositions about any concrete thing, whether those propositions are affirmative or negative. These examples should be the concrete things that come closest to the substances that do not exist. For heat, they include the gentlest or least burning flames. For incorruptibility, they include gold, since it comes closest to being incorruptible. All these examples help show the boundary between existence and nonexistence. They also set limits on forms, so that forms cannot wander beyond the conditions of matter.

XXXIV

34

In the twelfth rank of prerogative instances, we will class those subjunctive instances, of which we spoke in the last aphorism, and which we are also wont to call instances of extremity or limits; for they are not only serviceable when subjoined to fixed propositions, but also of themselves and from their own nature. They indicate with sufficient precision the real divisions of nature, and measures of things, and the “how far” nature effects or allows of anything, and her passage thence to something else. Such are gold in weight, iron in hardness, the whale in the size of animals, the dog in smell, the flame of gunpowder in rapid expansion, and others of a like nature. Nor are we to pass over the extremes in defect, as well as in abundance, as spirits of wine in weight, the touchstone in softness, the worms upon the skin in the size of animals, and the like.

In the twelfth rank of prerogative instances, we place the subjunctive instances discussed in the last aphorism. We also call them instances of extremity or limits. They are useful not only when added to established propositions, but also in themselves and by their own nature. They show with sufficient precision the real divisions of nature and the measures of things. They show “how far” nature produces or permits anything, and where it passes from one thing to another. Examples include gold in weight, iron in hardness, the whale in animal size, and the dog in its sense of smell. Another is the flame of gunpowder in the speed of its expansion. We must also consider extremes of deficiency, as well as extremes of abundance. Examples include spirits of wine in weight, the touchstone in softness, and skin worms in animal size.

XXXV

35

In the thirteenth rank of prerogative instances we will place those of alliance or union. They are such as mingle and unite natures held to be heterogeneous, and observed and marked as such in received classifications.

In the thirteenth rank of prerogative instances, we place instances of alliance or union. These bring together and unite natures that established classifications identify as different in kind.

These instances show that the operation and effect, which is considered peculiar to some one of such heterogeneous natures, may also be attributed to another nature styled heterogeneous, so as to prove that the difference of the natures is not real nor essential, but a mere modification of a common nature. They are very serviceable, therefore, in elevating and carrying on the mind, from differences to genera, and in removing those phantoms and images of things, which meet it in disguise in concrete substances.

These examples show that an action or effect thought unique to one of several different natures may also belong to another. This shows that the difference between those natures is not real or essential. Instead, it is merely a variation of a common nature. These examples are therefore very useful in lifting and guiding the mind from differences to broader categories. They also help clear away the false appearances and images of things that confront the mind disguised in concrete substances.

For example: let the required nature be heat. The classification of heat into three kinds, that of the celestial bodies, that of animals, and that of fire, appears to be settled and admitted; and these kinds of heat, especially one of them compared with the other two, are supposed to be different, and clearly heterogeneous in their essence and species, or specific nature, since the heat of the heavenly bodies and of animals generates and cherishes, while that of fire corrupts and destroys. We have an instance of alliance, then, in a very common experiment, that of a vine branch admitted into a building where there is a constant fire, by which the grapes ripen a whole month sooner than in the air; so that fruit upon the tree can be ripened by fire, although this appear the peculiar effect of the sun. From this beginning, therefore, the understanding rejects all essential difference, and easily ascends to the investigation of the real differences between the heat of the sun and that of fire, by which their operation is rendered dissimilar, although they partake of a common nature.

For example, suppose heat is the nature we wish to study. It seems settled and accepted that there are three kinds of heat: heat from heavenly bodies, animals, and fire. These kinds are thought to differ in their essence and specific nature. The heat of fire, especially, is thought to be clearly different from the other two. For the heat of heavenly bodies and animals generates and nourishes, while fire corrupts and destroys. A very common experiment provides an instance of alliance. A vine branch is brought into a building where a fire burns constantly. Its grapes ripen a whole month sooner than they would outdoors. So fire can ripen fruit on the vine, although this seems to be a special effect of the sun. From this starting point, the mind rejects any essential difference between the two kinds of heat. It can then easily investigate the real differences between them. These differences make the heat of the sun and that of fire act differently, although they share a common nature.

These differences will be found to be four in number. 1. The heat of the sun is much milder and gentler in degree than that of fire. 2. It is much more moist in quality, especially as it is transmitted to us through the air. 3. Which is the chief point, it is very unequal, advancing and increased at one time, retiring and diminished at another, which mainly contributes to the generation of bodies. For Aristotle rightly asserted, that the principal cause of generation and corruption on the surface of the earth was the oblique path of the sun in the zodiac, whence its heat becomes very unequal, partly from the alternation of night and day, partly from the succession of summer and winter. Yet must he immediately corrupt and pervert his discovery, by dictating to nature according to his habit, and dogmatically assigning the cause of generation to the approach of the sun, and that of corruption to its retreat; while, in fact, each circumstance indifferently and not respectively contributes both to generation and corruption; for unequal heat tends to generate and corrupt, as equable heat does to preserve. 4. The fourth difference between the heat of the sun and fire is of great consequence; namely, that the sun, gradually, and for a length of time, insinuates its effects, while those of fire (urged by the impatience of man) are brought to a termination in a shorter space of time. But if any one were to pay attention to the tempering of fire, and reducing it to a more moderate and gentle degree (which may be done in various ways), and then were to sprinkle and mix a degree of humidity with it; and, above all, were to imitate the sun in its inequality; and, lastly, were patiently to suffer some delay (not such, however, as is proportioned to the effects of the sun, but more than men usually admit of in those of fire), he would soon banish the notion of any difference, and would attempt, or equal, or perhaps sometimes surpass the effect of the sun, by the heat of fire. A like instance of alliance is that of reviving butterflies, benumbed and nearly dead from cold, by the gentle warmth of fire; so that fire is no less able to revive animals than to ripen vegetables. We may also mention the celebrated invention of Fracastorius, of applying a pan considerably heated to the head in desperate cases of apoplexy, which clearly expands the animal spirits, when compressed and almost extinguished by the humors and obstructions of the brain, and excites them to action, as the fire would operate on water or air, and in the result produces life. Eggs are sometimes hatched by the heat of fire, an exact imitation of animal heat; and there are many instances of the like nature, so that no one can doubt that the heat of fire, in many cases, can be modified till it resemble that of the heavenly bodies and of animals.

There are four differences. 1. The sun’s heat is much milder and gentler than the heat of fire. 2. It is much moister, especially as it reaches us through the air. 3. Most importantly, the sun’s heat varies greatly. At one time it advances and grows stronger, and at another it retreats and grows weaker. This variation contributes greatly to the formation of bodies. Aristotle rightly said that the sun’s slanting path through the zodiac was the main cause of generation and decay on Earth’s surface. This path makes the sun’s heat vary greatly, partly through the alternation of night and day, and partly through the succession of summer and winter. Yet he immediately corrupted and distorted his discovery. As usual, he dictated to nature, dogmatically assigning generation to the sun’s approach and decay to its retreat. In fact, each contributes to both generation and decay, not to one or the other alone. Uneven heat tends to generate and destroy, just as even heat tends to preserve. 4. The fourth difference between the heat of the sun and that of fire is very important. The sun produces its effects gradually and over a long time. Fire, driven by human impatience, completes its effects in less time. But someone might take care to temper fire and reduce it to a more moderate, gentle heat. This can be done in various ways. He might then add and mix in some moisture and, above all, imitate the variations in the sun’s heat. Finally, he might patiently allow some delay, though not as much as the sun’s effects require. He would have to allow more time than people usually give to the effects of fire. If he did all this, he would soon dismiss the idea that there was any difference. With the heat of fire, he would attempt to match the sun’s effects, succeed, or perhaps sometimes surpass them. A similar example of this connection is the revival of butterflies numbed and nearly killed by cold, using the gentle warmth of fire. Thus fire can revive animals just as it can ripen plants. We may also mention Fracastorius’s celebrated invention. He applied a well-heated pan to the head in desperate cases of apoplexy. The heat clearly expands the animal spirits when the brain’s humors and obstructions have compressed and nearly extinguished them. It stirs them into action, just as fire would act on water or air, and the result is life. Eggs are sometimes hatched by the heat of fire, in an exact imitation of animal heat. There are many similar examples. So no one can doubt that, in many cases, the heat of fire can be adjusted to resemble that of heavenly bodies and animals.

Again, let the required natures be motion and rest. There appears to be a settled classification, grounded on the deepest philosophy, that natural bodies either revolve, move in a straight line, or stand still and rest. For there is either motion without limit, or continuance within a certain limit, or a translation toward a certain limit. The eternal motion of revolution appears peculiar to the heavenly bodies, rest to this our globe, and the other bodies (heavy and light, as they are termed, that is to say, placed out of their natural position) are borne in a straight line to masses or aggregates which resemble them, the light toward the heaven, the heavy toward the earth; and all this is very fine language.

Again, let the natures we are investigating be motion and rest. There seems to be an established classification, based on the deepest philosophy. Natural bodies either revolve, move in a straight line, or remain still. For there is either motion without a limit, rest within a certain limit, or movement toward a certain limit. Eternal circular motion seems to belong to the heavenly bodies, and rest to our globe. Other bodies, called heavy and light, are out of their natural positions. They move in a straight line toward masses or groups of bodies like themselves. Light bodies move toward the heavens, and heavy ones toward the earth. All this is very fine language.

But we have an instance of alliance in low comets, which revolve, though far below the heavens; and the fiction of Aristotle, of the comet being fixed to, or necessarily following some star, has been long since exploded; not only because it is improbable in itself, but from the evident fact of the discursive and irregular motion of comets through various parts of the heavens.

But low comets offer an instance of alliance. They revolve, though they are far below the heavens. Aristotle claimed that a comet is fixed to a star or must follow one. This idea was disproved long ago. It is not only improbable in itself, but also contradicted by the evident fact that comets move irregularly through various parts of the heavens.

Seneca was a more reliable astronomer than Bacon. He mocked the idea that any heavenly bodies moved irregularly. He predicted that one day their orbits would be shown to follow the same laws as the planets. Newton fulfilled this prediction. Ed.

Another instance of alliance is that of the motion of air, which appears to revolve from east to west within the tropics, where the circles of revolution are the greatest.

Another example of alliance is the movement of air. Within the tropics, where the circles of revolution are largest, air seems to move around the earth from east to west.

The flow and ebb of the sea would perhaps be another instance, if the water were once found to have a motion of revolution, though slow and hardly perceptible, from east to west, subject, however, to a reaction twice a day. If this be so, it is clear that the motion of revolution is not confined to the celestial bodies, but is shared, also, by air and water.

The rise and fall of the sea might be another example. This would be so if water were found to move in a circular motion from east to west, though slowly and almost imperceptibly. This motion would, however, be reversed twice a day. If so, circular motion is clearly not limited to heavenly bodies. Air and water share it too.

Again—the supposed peculiar disposition of light bodies to rise is rather shaken; and here we may find an instance of alliance in a water bubble. For if air be placed under water, it rises rapidly toward the surface by that striking motion (as Democritus terms it) with which the descending water strikes the air and raises it, not by any struggle or effort of the air itself; and when it has reached the surface of the water, it is prevented from ascending any further, by the slight resistance it meets with in the water, which does not allow an immediate separation of its parts, so that the tendency of the air to rise must be very slight.

Again, the supposed tendency of light bodies to rise is called into question. Here we may find an instance of alliance in a water bubble. If air is placed under water, it rises rapidly toward the surface. Democritus calls this a striking motion. The descending water strikes the air and raises it. The air does not rise through any struggle or effort of its own. Once it reaches the surface, the air is prevented from rising further by the slight resistance of the water. The water does not allow its parts to separate immediately. The tendency of air to rise must therefore be very slight.

Again, let the required nature be weight. It is certainly a received classification, that dense and solid bodies are borne toward the centre of the earth, and rare and light bodies to the circumference of the heavens, as their appropriate places. As far as relates to places (though these things have much weight in the schools), the notion of there being any determinate place is absurd and puerile. Philosophers trifle, therefore, when they tell you, that if the earth were perforated, heavy bodies would stop on their arrival at the centre. This centre would indeed be an efficacious nothing, or mathematical point, could it affect bodies or be sought by them, for a body is not acted upon except by a body. In fact, this tendency to ascend and descend is either in the conformation of the moving body, or in its harmony and sympathy with another body. But if any dense and solid body be found, which does not, however, tend toward the earth, the classification is at an end. Now, if we allow of Gilbert’s opinion, that the magnetic power of the earth, in attracting heavy bodies, is not extended beyond the limit of its peculiar virtue (which operates always at a fixed distance and no further), and this be proved by some instance, such an instance will be one of alliance in our present subject. The nearest approach to it is that of waterspouts, frequently seen by persons navigating the Atlantic toward either of the Indies. For the force and mass of the water suddenly effused by waterspouts, appears to be so considerable, that the water must have been collected previously, and have remained fixed where it was formed, until it was afterward forced down by some violent cause, rather than made to fall by the natural motion of gravity: so that it may be conjectured that a dense and compact mass, at a great distance from the earth, may be suspended as the earth itself is, and would not fall, unless forced down. We do not, however, affirm this as certain. In the meanwhile, both in this respect and many others, it will readily be seen how deficient we are in natural history, since we are forced to have recourse to suppositions for examples, instead of ascertained instances.

Again, let the nature we are investigating be weight. A commonly accepted classification holds that dense, solid bodies move toward the center of the earth. Rare, light bodies move toward the outermost reaches of the heavens. Each is said to move toward its proper place. Such places carry much weight in the schools. But the idea that anything has a fixed place is absurd and childish. Philosophers therefore talk nonsense when they say that heavy bodies would stop at the center of a perforated earth. The center would indeed be a powerful nothing, a mere mathematical point, if it could affect bodies or attract them. For a body can be acted on only by another body. In fact, this tendency to rise or fall lies either in the structure of the moving body or in its harmony and sympathy with another body. But if a dense, solid body is found that does not move toward the earth, the classification fails. Now consider Gilbert’s view that the earth’s magnetic power attracts heavy bodies only within the range of its particular force. This force always acts over a fixed distance and no farther. If we accept this view and an example proves it, that example will be an instance of alliance in our present inquiry. The closest example is that of waterspouts. People sailing across the Atlantic toward either of the Indies often see them. The water suddenly poured down by waterspouts seems so great in force and volume that it must have collected beforehand. It seems to have remained fixed where it formed until some violent cause forced it down. This seems more likely than that it fell through the natural motion of gravity. So we may conjecture that a dense, compact mass, far from the earth, can remain suspended as the earth itself does. It would not fall unless forced down. We do not, however, claim this as certain. Meanwhile, this and many other matters readily show how deficient our natural history is. For we are forced to rely on suppositions for examples, instead of established instances.

But see Bacon’s own corollary at the end of the Instances of Divorce, . If Bacon’s remark is accepted, the criticism applies to Newton and the system generally accepted today. However, the criticism is unfair. The centre Newton often speaks of is not a point with an active force of its own. It is only the result of the individual, mutual attractions of the planet’s different parts acting on one spot. Clearly, if all these forces were united at this centre, their sum would equal all their individual effects. Ed.

Since Newton discovered the law of gravitation, we know that the earth’s attractive force must extend infinitely. Bacon himself refers to this force acting at great distances in the Instances of the Rod, .

Again, let the required nature be the discursive power of the mind. The classification of human reason and animal instinct appears to be perfectly correct. Yet there are some instances of the actions of brutes which seem to show that they, too, can syllogize. Thus it is related, that a crow, which had nearly perished from thirst in a great drought, saw some water in the hollow trunk of a tree, but as it was too narrow for him to get into it, he continued to throw in pebbles, which made the water rise till he could drink; and it afterward became a proverb.

Again, suppose the quality we are investigating is the mind’s ability to reason. The distinction between human reason and animal instinct seems perfectly sound. Yet some animal actions seem to show that animals, too, can reason logically. One story tells of a crow that nearly died of thirst during a severe drought. It saw water in the hollow trunk of a tree, but the opening was too narrow for it to enter. So it kept dropping pebbles into the trunk. The water rose until the crow could drink, and the story later became a proverb.

Again, let the required nature be vision. The classification appears real and certain, which considers light as that which is originally visible, and confers the power of seeing; and color, as being secondarily visible, and not capable of being seen without light, so as to appear a mere image or modification of light. Yet there are instances of alliance in each respect; as in snow when in great quantities, and in the flame of sulphur; the one being a color originally and in itself light, the other a light verging toward color.

Again, let the nature we are investigating be vision. One classification seems sound and certain. It treats light as visible in itself and as giving us the power to see. It treats color as visible only secondarily, since it cannot be seen without light. Color thus appears to be merely an image or modification of light. Yet there are examples that link the two in each respect. These are snow in great quantities and the flame of sulfur. Snow has a color that is originally and in itself light. The flame is a light that approaches color.

Snow reflects light but does not produce it.

XXXVI

36

In the fourteenth rank of prerogative instances, we will place the instances of the cross, borrowing our metaphor from the crosses erected where two roads meet, to point out the different directions. We are wont also to call them decisive and judicial instances, and in some cases instances of the oracle and of command. Their nature is as follows: When in investigating any nature the understanding is, as it were, balanced, and uncertain to which of two or more natures the cause of the required nature should be assigned, on account of the frequent and usual concurrence of several natures, the instances of the cross show that the union of one nature with the required nature is firm and indissoluble, while that of the other is unsteady and separable; by which means the question is decided, and the first is received as the cause, while the other is dismissed and rejected. Such instances, therefore, afford great light, and are of great weight, so that the course of interpretation sometimes terminates, and is completed in them. Sometimes, however, they are found among the instances already observed, but they are generally new, being expressly and purposely sought for and applied, and brought to light only by attentive and active diligence.

In the fourteenth rank of prerogative instances, we place instances of the cross. The metaphor comes from the crosses erected where two roads meet, pointing in different directions. We also call them decisive and judicial instances, and sometimes instances of the oracle and of command. Their nature is as follows. When investigating a nature, the understanding may be balanced between two or more possible causes. This uncertainty arises because several natures frequently and usually occur together. Instances of the cross show that one nature is firmly and inseparably connected with the nature under investigation. They also show that another nature is connected with it unsteadily and can be separated from it. In this way, the question is decided. The first nature is accepted as the cause, while the other is dismissed and rejected. These instances therefore shed great light and carry great weight. Sometimes the process of interpretation ends and is completed with them. Sometimes they are found among instances already observed. Generally, however, they are new. They are expressly and deliberately sought out and applied, and brought to light only through attentive and active diligence.

For example: let the required nature be the flow and ebb of the sea, which is repeated twice a day, at intervals of six hours between each advance and retreat, with some little difference, agreeing with the motion of the moon. We have here the following crossways:

For example, let the nature we are investigating be the rise and fall of the sea. This happens twice a day, with about six hours between each rise and fall, in keeping with the moon's movement. We have the following crossroads:

This motion must be occasioned either by the advancing and the retiring of the sea, like water shaken in a basin, which leaves one side while it washes the other; or by the rising of the sea from the bottom, and its again subsiding, like boiling water. But a doubt arises, to which of these causes we should assign the flow and ebb. If the first assertion be admitted, it follows, that when there is a flood on one side, there must at the same time be an ebb on another, and the question therefore is reduced to this. Now Acosta, and some others, after a diligent inquiry, have observed that the flood tide takes place on the coast of Florida, and the opposite coasts of Spain and Africa, at the same time, as does also the ebb; and that there is not, on the contrary, a flood tide at Florida when there is an ebb on the coasts of Spain and Africa. Yet if one consider the subject attentively, this does not prove the necessity of a rising motion, nor refute the notion of a progressive motion. For the motion may be progressive, and yet inundate the opposite shores of a channel at the same time; as if the waters be forced and driven together from some other quarter, for instance, which takes place in rivers, for they flow and ebb toward each bank at the same time, yet their motion is clearly progressive, being that of the waters from the sea entering their mouths. So it may happen, that the waters coming in a vast body from the eastern Indian Ocean are driven together, and forced into the channel of the Atlantic, and therefore inundate both coasts at once. We must inquire, therefore, if there be any other channel by which the waters can at the same time sink and ebb; and the Southern Ocean at once suggests itself, which is not less than the Atlantic, but rather broader and more extensive than is requisite for this effect.

This motion must be caused by one of two things. The sea may move forward and backward, like water shaken in a basin. The water leaves one side while washing against the other. Or the sea may rise from the bottom and then sink again, like boiling water. But which of these causes produces the flow and ebb of the tides? If the first explanation is correct, a flood tide on one side must coincide with an ebb tide on another. The question is therefore whether this happens. After careful investigation, Acosta and some others observed that the flood tide occurs at the same time on the coast of Florida and on the opposite coasts of Spain and Africa. The ebb tide also occurs at the same time on both sides. They found that the tide does not flood at Florida while it ebbs on the coasts of Spain and Africa. Yet, on closer examination, this does not prove that the water must rise from below. Nor does it disprove the idea that the water moves forward. The water may move forward and still flood the opposite shores of a channel at the same time. For example, water might be forced and driven together from some other direction. This happens in rivers, where the tide floods and ebbs toward both banks at once. Yet the water clearly moves forward, entering the river mouths from the sea. In the same way, a vast body of water may come from the eastern Indian Ocean and be driven together into the Atlantic channel. It would then flood both coasts at once. We must therefore ask whether another channel allows the water to sink and ebb at the same time. The Southern Ocean immediately suggests itself. It is no smaller than the Atlantic, but rather wider and more extensive than this effect requires.

We at length arrive, then, at an instance of the cross, which is this. If it be positively discovered, that when the flood sets in toward the opposite coasts of Florida and Spain in the Atlantic, there is at the same time a flood tide on the coasts of Peru and the back part of China, in the Southern Ocean, then assuredly, from this decisive instance, we must reject the assertion, that the flood and ebb of the sea, about which we inquire, takes place by progressive motion; for no other sea or place is left where there can be an ebb. But this may most easily be learned, by inquiring of the inhabitants of Panama and Lima (where the two oceans are separated by a narrow isthmus), whether the flood and ebb takes place on the opposite sides of the isthmus at the same time, or the reverse. This decision or rejection appears certain, if it be granted that the earth is fixed; but if the earth revolves, it may perhaps happen, that from the unequal revolution (as regards velocity) of the earth and the waters of the sea, there may be a violent forcing of the waters into a mass, forming the flood, and a subsequent relaxation of them (when they can no longer bear the accumulation), forming the ebb. A separate inquiry must be made into this. Even with this hypothesis, however, it remains equally true, that there must be an ebb somewhere, at the same time that there is a flood in another quarter.

We now come to a decisive test, or instance of the cross. Suppose we establish that the tide is rising along the opposite Atlantic coasts of Florida and Spain. Suppose it is also rising at the same time along the coasts of Peru and the far side of China, on the Southern Ocean. This decisive instance would certainly require us to reject the claim that the tides we are investigating result from the progressive movement of water. For no other sea or place would be left where the tide could be falling. We can most easily find this out by asking the inhabitants of Panama and Lima. There, a narrow isthmus separates the two oceans. We can ask whether the tides rise and fall at the same time on opposite sides of the isthmus, or whether they do the reverse. This rejection seems certain if we assume that the earth is stationary. But if the earth revolves, another explanation may be possible. The earth and the sea may revolve at different speeds, perhaps forcing the water violently into a mass and producing the rising tide. The water may then spread out again, when it can no longer remain piled up, producing the falling tide. This requires a separate inquiry. Even under this hypothesis, however, one point remains equally true: the tide must be falling somewhere while it is rising elsewhere.

Again, let the required nature be the latter of the two motions we have supposed; namely, that of a rising and subsiding motion, if it should happen that upon diligent examination the progressive motion be rejected. We have, then, three ways before us, with regard to this nature. The motion, by which the waters raise themselves, and again fall back, in the floods and ebbs, without the addition of any other water rolled toward them, must take place in one of the three following ways: Either the supply of water emanates from the interior of the earth, and returns back again; or there is really no greater quantity of water, but the same water (without any augmentation of its quantity) is extended or rarefied, so as to occupy a greater space and dimension, and again contracts itself; or there is neither an additional supply nor any extension, but the same waters (with regard to quantity, density, or rarity) raise themselves and fall from sympathy, by some magnetic power attracting and calling them up, as it were, from above. Let us then (passing over the first two motions) reduce the investigation to the last, and inquire if there be any such elevation of the water by sympathy or a magnetic force; and it is evident, in the first place, that the whole mass of water being placed in the trench or cavity of the sea, cannot be raised at once, because there would not be enough to cover the bottom, so that if there be any tendency of this kind in the water to raise itself, yet it would be interrupted and checked by the cohesion of things, or (as the common expression is) that there may be no vacuum. The water, therefore, must rise on one side, and for that reason be diminished and ebb on another. But it will again necessarily follow that the magnetic power not being able to operate on the whole, operates most intensely on the centre, so as to raise the waters there, which, when thus raised successively, desert and abandon the sides.

Again, let the nature we are investigating be the second of the two motions we have proposed. This is a rising and falling motion, if careful examination should rule out progressive motion. We then have three possibilities for this motion. In floods and ebbs, the waters rise and fall again without any additional water flowing toward them. This must happen in one of three ways: Either water flows from inside the earth and returns there again. Or there is no increase in the amount of water. Instead, the same water expands or becomes less dense, occupying more space, and then contracts again. Or there is neither an additional supply nor any expansion. Instead, the same waters, unchanged in quantity or density, rise and fall through sympathy. Some magnetic power attracts and draws them up, as it were, from above. Let us pass over the first two motions and investigate the last. We can ask whether water rises through sympathy or a magnetic force. First, it is clear that the whole mass of water in the sea's basin cannot rise at once. There would not be enough water to cover the bottom. So even if the water has some tendency to rise, the cohesion of things would interrupt and check it. As the common expression has it, there can be no vacuum. The water must therefore rise on one side and, for that reason, fall and ebb on another. But it also necessarily follows that the magnetic power cannot act on the whole mass. Instead, it acts most strongly at the center, raising the waters there. As the waters are successively raised, they leave the sides bare.

Bacon’s insight here anticipates Newton’s theory of the tides.

We at length arrive, then, at an instance of the cross, which is this: if it be found that during the ebb the surface of the waters at sea is more curved and round, from the waters rising in the middle, and sinking at the sides or coast, and if, during a flood, it be more even and level, from the waters returning to their former position, then assuredly, by this decisive instance, the raising of them by a magnetic force can be admitted; if otherwise, it must be entirely rejected. It is not difficult to make the experiment (by sounding in straits), whether the sea be deeper toward the middle in ebbs, than in floods. But it must be observed, if this be the case, that (contrary to common opinion) the waters rise in ebbs, and only return to their former position in floods, so as to bathe and inundate the coast.

We finally come to a decisive test, known as an instance of the cross. Suppose that, at low tide, the sea’s surface is more curved and rounded. The water rises in the middle and sinks at the sides, near the coast. Suppose also that, at high tide, the surface is more even and level as the water returns to its former position. Then this decisive test would certainly allow us to accept that a magnetic force raises the water. If not, we must reject that explanation entirely. It is not difficult to test this by measuring the depth of water in straits. We can see whether the sea is deeper toward the middle at low tide than at high tide. But if it is, we must note what follows. Contrary to common opinion, the water rises at low tide. At high tide, it only returns to its former position, washing over and flooding the coast.

Again, let the required nature be the spontaneous motion of revolution, and particularly, whether the diurnal motion, by which the sun and stars appear to us to rise and set, be a real motion of revolution in the heavenly bodies, or only apparent in them, and real in the earth. There may be an instance of the cross of the following nature. If there be discovered any motion in the ocean from east to west, though very languid and weak, and if the same motion be discovered rather more swift in the air (particularly within the tropics, where it is more perceptible from the circles being greater). If it be discovered also in the low comets, and be already quick and powerful in them; if it be found also in the planets, but so tempered and regulated as to be slower in those nearest the earth, and quicker in those at the greatest distance, being quickest of all in the heavens, then the diurnal motion should certainly be considered as real in the heavens, and that of the earth must be rejected; for it will be evident that the motion from east to west is part of the system of the world and universal; since it is most rapid in the height of the heavens, and gradually grows weaker, till it stops and is extinguished in rest at the earth.

Again, let the subject of inquiry be spontaneous circular motion. In particular, let us ask whether the daily motion that makes the sun and stars appear to rise and set is real. Do the heavenly bodies actually revolve, or do they only appear to revolve while the earth moves? There may be a decisive instance of the following kind. Suppose a very slow and weak motion from east to west is found in the ocean. Suppose the same motion is found to be somewhat faster in the air. It is more noticeable within the tropics, where the circles are larger. Suppose the same motion is also found in low comets, where it is already swift and powerful. Suppose it is also found in the planets, but regulated so that it is slower in those nearest the earth. It would be faster in those farther away and fastest of all in the heavens. Then the daily motion should certainly be taken as real in the heavens, and the earth's motion must be rejected. For it would be evident that motion from east to west is universal and part of the system of the world. It is fastest at the greatest heights of the heavens and gradually weakens until it stops and dies out at the resting earth.

Again, let the required nature be that other motion of revolution, so celebrated among astronomers, which is contrary to the diurnal, namely, from west to east—and which the ancient astronomers assign to the planets, and even to the starry sphere, but Copernicus and his followers to the earth also—and let it be examined whether any such motion be found in nature, or it be rather a fiction and hypothesis for abridging and facilitating calculation, and for promoting that fine notion of effecting the heavenly motions by perfect circles; for there is nothing which proves such a motion in heavenly objects to be true and real, either in a planet’s not returning in its diurnal motion to the same point of the starry sphere, or in the pole of the zodiac being different from that of the world, which two circumstances have occasioned this notion. For the first phenomenon is well accounted for by the spheres overtaking or falling behind each other, and the second by spiral lines; so that the inaccuracy of the return and declination to the tropics may be rather modifications of the one diurnal motion than contrary motions, or about different poles. And it is most certain, if we consider ourselves for a moment as part of the vulgar (setting aside the fictions of astronomers and the school, who are wont undeservedly to attack the senses in many respects, and to affect obscurity), that the apparent motion is such as we have said, a model of which we have sometimes caused to be represented by wires in a sort of a machine.

Again, let the subject of inquiry be that other revolving motion, so celebrated among astronomers. It runs from west to east, contrary to the daily motion. Ancient astronomers attribute it to the planets and even to the sphere of the stars. Copernicus and his followers attribute it to the earth as well. Let us examine whether any such motion exists in nature. Or is it rather a fiction, a hypothesis for shortening and simplifying calculations? Does it also serve the elegant idea that heavenly motions follow perfect circles? Two observations have given rise to this notion. A planet does not return to the same point in the sphere of the stars during its daily motion. And the pole of the zodiac differs from the pole of the world. But neither observation proves that this motion in heavenly bodies is true and real. The first phenomenon is well explained by the spheres overtaking or falling behind one another. The second is well explained by spiral paths. Thus, the imperfect return and the movement toward the tropics may be variations of the single daily motion. They need not be contrary motions or motions around different poles. Let us imagine ourselves for a moment as ordinary people. Let us set aside the fictions of astronomers and scholars. They often unjustly attack the senses in many respects and make a show of obscurity. If we do this, it is most certain that the apparent motion is as we have described it. We have sometimes had a model of it made with wires in a kind of machine.

We may take the following instances of the cross upon this subject. If it be found in any history worthy of credit, that there has existed any comet, high or low, which has not revolved in manifest harmony (however irregularly) with the diurnal motion, then we may decide so far as to allow such a motion to be possible in nature. But if nothing of the sort be found, it must be suspected, and recourse must be had to other instances of the cross.

We may consider the following decisive tests on this subject. Suppose a reliable historical account describes a comet, high or low, that did not move in clear harmony with the daily motion, however irregularly. We may then conclude, at least, that such a motion is possible in nature. But if no such account is found, we must doubt that such a motion is possible. We must then turn to other decisive tests.

Again, let the required nature be weight or gravity. Heavy and ponderous bodies must, either of their own nature, tend toward the centre of the earth by their peculiar formation, or must be attracted and hurried by the corporeal mass of the earth itself, as being an assemblage of similar bodies, and be drawn to it by sympathy. But if the latter be the cause, it follows that the nearer bodies approach to the earth, the more powerfully and rapidly they must be borne toward it, and the further they are distant, the more faintly and slowly (as is the case in magnetic attractions), and that this must happen within a given distance; so that if they be separated at such a distance from the earth that the power of the earth cannot act upon them, they will remain suspended like the earth, and not fall at all.

Again, let the nature we are investigating be weight or gravity. Heavy bodies must, by their own nature and particular structure, tend toward the center of the earth. Or the earth’s physical mass must attract and pull them toward it. On this second view, the earth draws them through sympathy, because it is a collection of similar bodies. But if this is the cause, it follows that bodies must be drawn toward the earth more powerfully and quickly as they approach it. The farther away they are, the more weakly and slowly they must be drawn, as with magnetic attraction. This attraction must also have a limited range. So if bodies are far enough from the earth that its power cannot act on them, they will remain suspended like the earth and not fall at all.

The error in the text arose from Bacon’s belief that the earth did not move. Since gravity acts at an infinite distance, clearly no such point could be found. Even if the impossible point of equilibrium were discovered, the body could not stay there for an instant. At the first movement of the heavenly bodies, it would be swept toward the strongest gravitational pull. Ed.

The following instance of the cross may be adopted. Take a clock moved by leaden weights, and another by a spring, and let them be set well together, so that one be neither quicker nor slower than the other; then let the clock moved by weights be placed on the top of a very high church, and the other be kept below, and let it be well observed, if the former move slower than it did, from the diminished power of the weights. Let the same experiment be made at the bottom of mines worked to a considerable depth, in order to see whether the clock move more quickly from the increased power of the weights. But if this power be found to diminish at a height, and to increase in subterraneous places, the attraction of the corporeal mass of the earth may be taken as the cause of weight.

The following crucial test may be used. Take one clock driven by lead weights, and another driven by a spring. Set them so that neither runs faster or slower than the other. Then place the weight-driven clock at the top of a very tall church, and keep the other below. Observe carefully whether the first clock runs slower than before because the weights have less power. Make the same experiment at the bottom of a deep mine. See whether the clock runs faster because the weights have more power. But if the power of the weights decreases at a height and increases underground, the attraction of the earth's physical mass may be taken as the cause of weight.

The text refers to fly clocks, not pendulum clocks, which were not known in England until 1662. Fly clocks were clumsy and crude in construction, but they embodied sound mechanical principles. Professors Airy and Whewell recently compared the effects of a spring and a weight in producing timed motions at high altitudes and in mines. They conducted the experiment in Dalcoath mine using a pendulum, a weight moved by gravity, and a chronometer balance moved and regulated by a spring. In his , Bacon also describes gravity as an incorporeal power that acts at a distance and takes time to travel. Laplace later considered this idea in one of his most delicate investigations.

As Herschel notes, crucial instances provide the quickest and surest means of eliminating outside causes and deciding between rival hypotheses. This is especially true when hypotheses explain whole classes of phenomena equally well but finally differ over a single fact. M. Fresnel gives a curious example that, in his view, decides between the two great theories of light. These theories have divided philosophers since the time of Newton and Huyghens. When two very clean pieces of glass are placed together, beautiful, vivid colors appear between them if they are not perfectly flat, but one or both are convex, even to an almost imperceptible degree. Viewed through red glass, the colors appear as alternating dark and bright stripes. These stripes form between the two surfaces that appear to be in contact. Both theories can explain them, so supporters of each cite them as strong confirming evidence. But the theories differ in one detail of their explanations. According to the Huyghenian theory, when a prism is used for the upper glass, the spaces between the bright stripes should appear completely black. According to the other theory, they should appear half bright. M. Fresnel tested this curious difference as soon as he noticed the opposing predictions. He states that the result decisively favors the theory that light consists of vibrations in an elastic medium. Ed.

Again, let the required nature be the polarity of the steel needle when touched with the magnet. We have these two ways with regard to this nature—Either the touch of the magnet must communicate polarity to the steel toward the north and south, or else it may only excite and prepare it, while the actual motion is occasioned by the presence of the earth, which Gilbert considers to be the case, and endeavors to prove with so much labor. The particulars he has inquired into with such ingenious zeal amount to this—1. An iron bolt placed for a long time toward the north and south acquires polarity from this habit, without the touch of the magnet, as if the earth itself operating but weakly from its distance (for the surface or outer crust of the earth does not, in his opinion, possess the magnetic power), yet, by long continued motion, could supply the place of the magnet, excite the iron, and convert and change it when excited. 2. Iron, at a red or white heat, when quenched in a direction parallel to the north and south, also acquires polarity without the touch of the magnet, as if the parts of iron being put in motion by ignition, and afterward recovering themselves, were, at the moment of being quenched, more susceptible and sensitive of the power emanating from the earth, than at other times, and therefore as it were excited. But these points, though well observed, do not completely prove his assertion.

Again, suppose the property we are investigating is the polarity of a steel needle touched by a magnet. There are two possibilities. The magnet may give the steel its north-south polarity. Or the magnet may only stimulate and prepare the steel, while the presence of the earth causes its actual movement. Gilbert believes the second explanation and works hard to prove it. The evidence he has investigated with such ingenious zeal amounts to this: 1. An iron bolt left pointing north and south for a long time acquires polarity without being touched by a magnet. It is as if the earth itself could take the place of the magnet through long-continued action. The earth could stimulate the iron and, once it was stimulated, turn and change it. This would happen even though the earth acts only weakly at that distance. Gilbert believes that the earth’s surface, or outer crust, has no magnetic power. 2. Iron heated until red or white and then quenched while pointing north and south also acquires polarity without a magnet’s touch. It is as if heating sets the iron’s particles in motion and they then settle back into place. At the moment of quenching, they seem more susceptible and sensitive to the force coming from the earth. They are therefore, as it were, stimulated. But although these points are well observed, they do not completely prove Gilbert’s claim.

An instance of the cross on this point might be as follows: Let a small magnetic globe be taken, and its poles marked, and placed toward the east and west, not toward the north and south, and let it continue thus. Then let an untouched needle be placed over it, and suffered to remain so for six or seven days. Now, the needle (for this is not disputed), while it remains over the magnet, will leave the poles of the world and turn to those of the magnet, and therefore, as long as it remains in the above position, will turn to the east and west. But if the needle, when removed from the magnet and placed upon a pivot, be found immediately to turn to the north and south, or even by degrees to return thither, then the presence of the earth must be considered as the cause, but if it remains turned as at first, toward the east and west, or lose its polarity, then that cause must be suspected, and further inquiry made.

A decisive test on this point might be as follows. Take a small magnetic globe and mark its poles. Place it with its poles pointing east and west, not north and south, and leave it there. Then place a needle that has not been touched by a magnet above the globe. Leave it there for six or seven days. While the needle remains above the magnet, it will turn away from the earth’s poles toward the magnet’s poles. This is not disputed. So, as long as the magnet remains in this position, the needle will point east and west. Then remove the needle from the magnet and place it on a pivot. If it turns north and south immediately, or even returns to that direction gradually, the earth’s presence must be considered the cause. But if it remains pointing east and west, as it did before, or loses its polarity, that cause must be questioned and investigated further.

Again, let the required nature be the corporeal substance of the moon, whether it be rare, fiery, and aërial (as most of the ancient philosophers have thought), or solid and dense (as Gilbert and many of the moderns, with some of the ancients, hold). The reasons for this latter opinion are grounded chiefly upon this, that the moon reflects the sun’s rays, and that light does not appear capable of being reflected except by solids. The instances of the cross will therefore (if any) be such as to exhibit reflection by a rare body, such as flame, if it be but sufficiently dense. Now, certainly, one of the reasons of twilight is the reflection of the rays of the sun by the upper part of the atmosphere. We see the sun’s rays also reflected on fine evenings by streaks of moist clouds, with a splendor not less, but perhaps more bright and glorious than that reflected from the body of the moon, and yet it is not clear that those clouds have formed into a dense body of water. We see, also, that the dark air behind the windows at night reflects the light of a candle in the same manner as a dense body would do. The experiment should also be made of causing the sun’s rays to fall through a hole upon some dark and bluish flame. The unconfined rays of the sun, when falling on faint flames, do certainly appear to deaden them, and render them more like white smoke than flames. These are the only instances which occur at present of the nature of those of the cross, and better perhaps can be found. But it must always be observed that reflection is not to be expected from flame, unless it be of some depth, for otherwise it becomes nearly transparent. This at least may be considered certain, that light is always either received and transmitted or reflected by an even surface.

Again, let the subject of inquiry be the physical substance of the moon. Is it thin, fiery, and airy, as most ancient philosophers thought? Or is it solid and dense, as Gilbert and many modern thinkers, along with some ancients, hold? The latter view rests mainly on the fact that the moon reflects the sun’s rays. Light seems capable of being reflected only by solids. Crucial instances, if any can be found, would therefore show reflection by a thin body, such as a sufficiently dense flame. Certainly, one cause of twilight is the reflection of the sun’s rays by the upper atmosphere. On fine evenings, we also see the sun’s rays reflected by streaks of moist clouds. Their splendor is no less bright and glorious than the light reflected from the moon, and perhaps even greater. Yet it is not clear that those clouds have formed into a dense body of water. We also see the dark air behind windows at night reflect a candle’s light, just as a dense body would. An experiment should also be made by directing the sun’s rays through a hole onto a dark, bluish flame. The sun’s rays, when not confined and falling on faint flames, certainly seem to dim them. They make the flames look more like white smoke than fire. These are the only examples resembling crucial instances that occur to me now. Perhaps better ones can be found. But we must always remember that a flame cannot be expected to reflect light unless it has some depth. Otherwise, it becomes nearly transparent. At least this may be regarded as certain: light is always either received and transmitted or reflected by an even surface.

This passage clearly suggests that Bacon believed the moon, like comets, was nothing more than illuminated vapor. Newton’s law, however, has established not only that the moon is solid, but also its density and weight. The moon’s attraction of the sea and its motion around the earth sufficiently prove its solidity. Ed.

Rather, the refraction. The sky or air, however, reflects the blue rays of light.

In this case, the glass's polished surface causes the reflection, not the air. In daylight, a hat or another black surface placed behind the window lets the glass reflect clearly for the same reason. The reflected rays are not mixed with rays passing through from the other side of the window.

Again, let the required nature be the motion of projectiles (such as darts, arrows, and balls) through the air. The school, in its usual manner, treats this very carelessly, considering it enough to distinguish it by the name of violent motion, from that which they term natural, and as far as regards the first percussion or impulse, satisfies itself by its axiom, that two bodies cannot exist in one place, or there would be a penetration of dimensions. With regard to this nature we have these two crossways—The motion must arise either from the air carrying the projected body, and collecting behind it, like a stream behind boats, or the wind behind straws; or from the parts of the body itself not supporting the impression, but pushing themselves forward in succession to ease it. Fracastorius, and nearly all those who have entered into any refined inquiry upon the subject, adopt the first. Nor can it be doubted that the air has some effect, yet the other motion is without doubt real, as is clear from a vast number of experiments. Among others we may take this instance of the cross, namely, that a thin plate or wire of iron rather stiff, or even a reed or pen split in two, when drawn up and bent between the finger and thumb, will leap forward; for it is clear that this cannot be attributed to the air’s being collected behind the body, because the source of motion is in the centre of the plate or pen, and not in its extremities.

Again, let the subject under investigation be the motion of projectiles, such as darts, arrows, and balls, through the air. The schools, as usual, treat the matter very carelessly. They think it enough to call it violent motion, distinguishing it from what they call natural motion. As for the initial blow or impulse, they are satisfied with their axiom that two bodies cannot occupy the same place. Otherwise, they say, their dimensions would have to penetrate each other. On this question, we have two alternative paths. The motion must arise either from the air carrying the projectile and gathering behind it, like a current behind boats or wind behind straws. Or it must arise from the parts of the body itself, which cannot bear the force and push forward in succession to relieve it. Fracastorius, and nearly all who have made a subtle inquiry into the subject, accept the first explanation. The air undoubtedly has some effect. Yet the other motion is undoubtedly real, as a great many experiments show. One decisive example is a thin plate or wire of fairly stiff iron, or even a reed or pen split in two. When held and bent between finger and thumb, it will leap forward. Clearly, this cannot be attributed to air gathering behind it. The source of motion is in the middle of the plate or pen, not at its ends.

Again, let the required nature be the rapid and powerful motion of the explosion of gunpowder, by which such vast masses are upheaved, and such weights discharged as we observe in large mines and mortars, there are two crossways before us with regard to this nature. This motion is excited either by the mere effort of the body expanding itself when inflamed, or by the assisting effort of the crude spirit, which escapes rapidly from fire, and bursts violently from the surrounding flame as from a prison. The school, however, and common opinion only consider the first effort; for men think that they are great philosophers when they assert that flame, from the form of the element, is endowed with a kind of necessity of occupying a greater space than the same body had occupied when in the form of powder, and that thence proceeds the motion in question. In the meantime they do not observe, that although this may be true, on the supposition of flame being generated, yet the generation may be impeded by a weight of sufficient force to compress and suffocate it, so that no such necessity exists as they assert. They are right, indeed, in imagining that the expansion and the consequent emission or removal of the opposing body, is necessary if flame be once generated, but such a necessity is avoided if the solid opposing mass suppress the flame before it be generated; and we in fact see that flame, especially at the moment of its generation, is mild and gentle, and requires a hollow space where it can play and try its force. The great violence of the effect, therefore, cannot be attributed to this cause; but the truth is, that the generation of these exploding flames and fiery blasts arises from the conflict of two bodies of a decidedly opposite nature—the one very inflammable, as is the sulphur, the other having an antipathy to flame, namely, the crude spirit of the nitre; so that an extraordinary conflict takes place while the sulphur is becoming inflamed as far as it can (for the third body, the willow charcoal, merely incorporates and conveniently unites the two others), and the spirit of nitre is escaping, as far also as it can, and at the same time expanding itself (for air, and all crude substances, and water are expanded by heat), fanning thus, in every direction, the flame of the sulphur by its escape and violence, just as if by invisible bellows.

Again, suppose the nature we want to investigate is the rapid, powerful motion of a gunpowder explosion. This motion lifts enormous masses and sends great weights flying, as we see in large mines and mortars. We face two possible explanations. The motion comes either from the body expanding as it catches fire, or from the additional force of the crude spirit. This spirit escapes rapidly from the fire and bursts violently out of the surrounding flame, as if from a prison. The schools and common opinion, however, consider only the first force. People think they are great philosophers when they say that flame must occupy more space than the same body occupied as powder. They attribute this necessity to the form of the element and say that it causes the motion. Meanwhile, they overlook a point. Even if this is true once flame has formed, a sufficiently heavy weight may compress and suffocate it before it forms. So no such necessity exists as they claim. They are right that, once flame has formed, it must expand and push aside or move the body opposing it. But this necessity is avoided if the solid mass opposing the flame suppresses it before it forms. In fact, we see that flame is mild and gentle, especially when it first forms. It needs a hollow space where it can play and test its force. The great violence of the effect, therefore, cannot be attributed to expansion alone. The truth is that these exploding flames and fiery blasts arise from a conflict between two bodies of distinctly opposite natures. One is highly flammable, namely the sulphur. The other is opposed to flame, namely the crude spirit of the nitre. An extraordinary conflict takes place as the sulphur catches fire as far as it can. The third body, willow charcoal, merely combines the other two and conveniently holds them together. At the same time, the spirit of the nitre escapes as far as it can and expands. For air, all crude substances, and water expand when heated. As the spirit escapes, its violence fans the sulphur flame in every direction, just as invisible bellows would.

Two kinds of instances of the cross might here be used—the one of very inflammable substances, such as sulphur and camphor, naphtha and the like, and their compounds, which take fire more readily and easily than gunpowder if left to themselves (and this shows that the effort to catch fire does not of itself produce such a prodigious effect); the other of substances which avoid and repel flame, such as all salts; for we see that when they are cast into the fire, the aqueous spirit escapes with a crackling noise before flame is produced, which also happens in a less degree in stiff leaves, from the escape of the aqueous part before the oily part has caught fire. This is more particularly observed in quicksilver, which is not improperly called mineral water, and which, without any inflammation, nearly equals the force of gunpowder by simple explosion and expansion, and is said, when mixed with gunpowder, to increase its force.

Two kinds of instances of the cross might be used here. The first involves highly flammable substances, such as sulphur, camphor, naphtha, and their compounds. Left to themselves, they catch fire more readily and easily than gunpowder. This shows that the tendency to catch fire does not by itself produce such a tremendous effect. The second involves substances that avoid and repel flame, such as all salts. When salts are thrown into a fire, the water vapor escapes with a crackling noise before flame appears. The same thing happens to a lesser degree in stiff leaves. Their water escapes before their oily part catches fire. This is seen especially in quicksilver, which is not improperly called mineral water. Without catching fire, quicksilver nearly matches the force of gunpowder through simple explosion and expansion. It is also said to increase the force of gunpowder when mixed with it.

Again, let the required nature be the transitory nature of flame and its momentaneous extinction; for to us the nature of flame does not appear to be fixed or settled, but to be generated from moment to moment, and to be every instant extinguished; it being clear that those flames which continue and last, do not owe their continuance to the same mass of flame, but to a continued succession of new flame regularly generated, and that the same identical flame does not continue. This is easily shown by removing the food or source of the flame, when it at once goes out. We have the two following crossways with regard to this nature:

Again, let the nature we wish to study be the brief existence of flame and its immediate extinction. For flame does not seem to us to be stable or lasting. Instead, it seems to arise moment by moment and to go out at every instant. Clearly, flames that last do not continue as the same mass of flame. They persist through a steady succession of newly generated flames. The same individual flame does not last. This is easily shown by removing the flame’s fuel or source. The flame goes out at once. We have the following two paths of inquiry into this nature:

This momentary nature either arises from the cessation of the cause which first produced it, as in light, sounds, and violent motions, as they are termed, or flame may be capable, by its own nature, of duration, but is subjected to some violence from the contrary natures which surround it, and is destroyed.

This brief existence may result from the loss of the cause that first produced it. This happens with light, sounds, and what are called violent motions. Or flame may be capable of lasting by its own nature, but may be destroyed by the opposing forces around it.

We may therefore adopt the following instance of the cross. We see to what a height the flames rise in great conflagrations; for as the base of the flame becomes more extensive, its vertex is more lofty. It appears, then, that the commencement of the extinction takes place at the sides, where the flame is compressed by the air, and is ill at ease; but the centre of the flame, which is untouched by the air and surrounded by flame, continues the same, and is not extinguished until compressed by degrees by the air attacking it from the sides. All flame, therefore, is pyramidal, having its base near the source, and its vertex pointed from its being resisted by the air, and not supplied from the source. On the contrary, the smoke, which is narrow at the base, expands in its ascent, and resembles an inverted pyramid, because the air admits the smoke, but compresses the flame; for let no one dream that the lighted flame is air, since they are clearly heterogeneous.

We may therefore use the following instance of the cross. We see how high flames rise in great fires. As the base of a flame grows wider, its tip rises higher. It appears, then, that the flame begins to go out at the sides. There the air presses against it, and it is ill at ease. But the center of the flame remains unchanged because the air does not touch it and flames surround it. It goes out only when the air gradually presses on it from the sides. All flames are therefore pyramidal, with their bases near their sources. Their tips are pointed because the air resists them and their sources do not feed them there. Smoke, by contrast, is narrow at the base and spreads as it rises, like an inverted pyramid. This is because the air admits smoke but presses against flame. Let no one imagine that a burning flame is air, for they are clearly different substances.

The instance of the cross will be more accurate, if the experiment can be made by flames of different colors. Take, therefore, a small metal sconce, and place a lighted taper in it, then put it in a basin, and pour a small quantity of spirits of wine round the sconce, so as not to reach its edge, and light the spirit. Now the flame of the spirit will be blue, and that of the taper yellow; observe, therefore, whether the latter (which can easily be distinguished from the former by its color, for flames do not mix immediately, as liquids do) continue pyramidal, or tend more to a globular figure, since there is nothing to destroy or compress it. If the latter result be observed, it must be considered as settled, that flame continues positively the same, while inclosed within another flame, and not exposed to the resisting force of the air.

This decisive test will be more accurate if it can be performed using flames of different colors. Take a small metal candleholder and place a lighted candle in it. Put the holder in a basin and pour a little alcohol around it, keeping the liquid below its rim. Then light the alcohol. Its flame will be blue, while the candle flame will be yellow. The colors make the two flames easy to distinguish, since flames do not mix immediately as liquids do. Observe whether the candle flame remains pyramid-shaped or becomes more spherical. Nothing is there to destroy or compress it. If the flame becomes more spherical, it must be considered settled that flame definitely remains unchanged when enclosed within another flame and not exposed to the resistance of the air.

Let this suffice for the instances of the cross. We have dwelt the longer upon them in order gradually to teach and accustom mankind to judge of nature by these instances, and enlightening experiments, and not by probable reasons.

That is enough about instances of the cross. We have spent more time on them to gradually teach people to judge nature by these instances and illuminating experiments, rather than by plausible arguments.

These instances, which Bacon seems to regard as a great discovery, are simply disjunctive propositions combined with dilemmas. To explain an effect, we begin by listing the different causes that seem connected with producing it. Then, using one or more dilemmas, we eliminate each phenomenon incidental to its composition. Finally, we attribute the effect to what remains. For example, a certain phenomenon (a) is produced either by phenomenon (B) or phenomenon (C). But C cannot cause a, because it is found in D, E, and F, none of which are connected with a. So the true cause of phenomenon (a) must be phenomenon (B).

This kind of reasoning is vulnerable to several errors, against which Bacon has not warned his readers. He himself fell into them without realizing it. The two main errors are false exclusions and incomplete lists. Bacon surveys the causes that can combine to produce the tides. But he does not account for the periodic melting of the Polar ice or the expansion of water by solar heat. Nor does he do better in his exclusions. The attraction of the planets and the forward and backward motion caused by the earth’s daily rotation can plainly affect the sea together. Both can influence its surface at the same time.

Bacon is hardly fair or consistent in his criticism of Ramus. The purpose of Ramus’s dichotomy was only to make reasoning by dilemma and crucial instances more reliable. He did this by reducing the divisions that made up their parts to two sets of contradictory propositions. Affirming or denying one would then necessarily lead to accepting or rejecting the other. Ed.

XXXVII

37

We will treat of the instances of divorce as the fifteenth of our prerogative instances. They indicate the separation of natures of the most common occurrence. They differ, however, from those subjoined to the accompanying instances; for the instances of divorce point out the separation of a particular nature from some concrete substance with which it is usually found in conjunction, while the hostile instances point out the total separation of one nature from another. They differ, also, from the instances of the cross, because they decide nothing, but only inform us that the one nature is capable of being separated from the other. They are of use in exposing false forms, and dissipating hasty theories derived from obvious facts; so that they add ballast and weight, as it were, to the understanding.

We will consider instances of divorce as the fifteenth kind of prerogative instance. They show the separation of natures most commonly found together. But they differ from the hostile instances listed under the accompanying instances. Instances of divorce show a particular nature separated from a concrete substance with which it is usually found. Hostile instances, by contrast, show the complete separation of one nature from another. Instances of divorce also differ from instances of the cross because they settle nothing. They tell us only that one nature can be separated from another. They help expose false forms and dispel hasty theories drawn from obvious facts. In this way, they add ballast and weight, as it were, to the understanding.

For instance, let the acquired natures be those four which Telesius terms associates, and of the same family, namely, heat, light, rarity, and mobility, or promptitude to motion; yet many instances of divorce can be discovered between them. Air is rare and easily moved, but neither hot nor light; the moon is light but not hot; boiling water is warm but not light; the motion of the needle in the compass is swift and active, and yet its substance is cold, dense, and opaque; and there are many similar examples.

For example, take the four acquired properties that Telesius calls related and part of the same family: heat, light, rarity, and mobility, or readiness to move. Yet many examples show that these properties can exist separately. Air is rare and easily moved, but it is neither hot nor light. The moon gives light but is not hot. Boiling water is warm but gives no light. A compass needle moves swiftly and actively, yet its substance is cold, dense, and opaque. There are many similar examples.

Again, let the required natures be corporeal nature and natural action. The latter appears incapable of subsisting without some body, yet may we, perhaps, even here find an instance of divorce, as in the magnetic motion, which draws the iron to the magnet, and heavy bodies to the globe of the earth; to which we may add other actions which operate at a distance. For such action takes place in time, by distinct moments, not in an instant; and in space, by regular degrees and distances. There is, therefore, some one moment of time and some interval of space, in which the power or action is suspended between the two bodies creating the motion. Our consideration, then, is reduced to this, whether the bodies which are the extremes of motion prepare or alter the intermediate bodies, so that the power advances from one extreme to the other by succession and actual contact, and in the meantime exists in some intermediate body; or whether there exists in reality nothing but the bodies, the power, and the space? In the case of the rays of light, sounds, and heat, and some other objects which operate at a distance, it is indeed probable that the intermediate bodies are prepared and altered, the more so because a qualified medium is required for their operation. But the magnetic or attractive power admits of an indifferent medium, and it is not impeded in any. But if that power or action is independent of the intermediate body, it follows that it is a natural power or action existing in a certain time and space without any body, since it exists neither in the extreme nor in the intermediate bodies. Hence the magnetic action may be taken as an instance of divorce of corporeal nature and natural action; to which we may add, as a corollary and an advantage not to be neglected, that it may be taken as a proof of essence and substance being separate and incorporeal, even by those who philosophize according to the senses. For if natural power and action emanating from a body can exist at any time and place entirely without any body, it is nearly a proof that it can also emanate originally from an incorporeal substance; for a corporeal nature appears to be no less necessary for supporting and conveying, than for exciting or generating natural action.

Again, let the natures we are investigating be bodily existence and natural action. Natural action seems unable to exist without some body. Yet perhaps we can find an instance where the two are separate, even here. One example is magnetic motion, which draws iron to a magnet and heavy bodies to the earth. We may add other actions that operate at a distance. Such action takes place over time, moment by moment, not instantly. It also takes place through space, by regular degrees and distances. Therefore, at some moment and across some interval, the power or action is suspended between the two bodies producing the motion. The question, then, is this: Do the bodies at either end of the motion prepare or alter the bodies between them? If so, the power advances from one end to the other through successive contact. Meanwhile, it exists in some intermediate body. Or do only the bodies, the power, and the space really exist? In the case of rays of light, sounds, heat, and some other things that act at a distance, the intermediate bodies are probably prepared and altered. This is all the more likely because these actions require a medium with suitable properties. But magnetic or attractive power works through any medium and is blocked by none. If this power or action is independent of the intermediate body, then it is a natural power or action existing at a particular time and place without any body. For it exists neither in the bodies at either end nor in the bodies between them. Magnetic action may therefore be taken as an instance of the separation of bodily existence from natural action. We may add a further conclusion, and one whose value should not be overlooked. Even those who base their philosophy on the senses may take it as proof that essence and substance can be separate from bodies and incorporeal. For if natural power and action can come from a body and exist at some time and place entirely without any body, this nearly proves that they can also come originally from an incorporeal substance. A bodily nature seems no less necessary to support and convey natural action than to set it in motion or produce it.

XXXVIII

38

Next follow five classes of instances which we are wont to call by the general term of instances of the lamp, or of immediate information. They are such as assist the senses; for since every interpretation of nature sets out from the senses, and leads, by a regular fixed and well-established road, from the perceptions of the senses to those of the understanding (which are true notions and axioms), it necessarily follows, that in proportion as the representatives or ministerings of the senses are more abundant and accurate, everything else must be more easy and successful.

Next come five classes of instances that we generally call instances of the lamp, or of immediate information. They help the senses. Every interpretation of nature begins with the senses. It follows a regular, fixed, and well-established path from sensory perceptions to those of the understanding, which are true notions and axioms. It follows, then, that the more abundant and accurate the information supplied by the senses, the easier and more successful everything else will be.

The first of these five sets of instances of the lamp, strengthen, enlarge, and correct the immediate operations of the senses; the second reduce to the sphere of the senses such matters as are beyond it; the third indicate the continued process or series of such things and motions, as for the most part are only observed in their termination, or in periods; the fourth supply the absolute wants of the senses; the fifth excite their attention and observation, and at the same time limit the subtilty of things. We will now proceed to speak of them singly.

The first of these five sets of instances of the lamp strengthen, extend, and correct the direct workings of the senses. The second bring within reach of the senses things that lie beyond them. The third reveal the continuous processes or sequences of things and movements. These are mostly observed only at their end or at intervals. The fourth make up for what the senses entirely lack. The fifth sharpen attention and observation while also limiting the subtlety of things. We will now discuss each set in turn.

XXXIX

39

In the sixteenth rank, then, of prerogative instances, we will place the instances of the door or gate, by which name we designate such as assist the immediate action of the senses. It is obvious, that sight holds the first rank among the senses, with regard to information, for which reason we must seek principally helps for that sense. These helps appear to be threefold, either to enable it to perceive objects not naturally seen, or to see them from a greater distance, or to see them more accurately and distinctly.

In the sixteenth rank of prerogative instances, then, we place instances of the door or gate. These are instances that help the senses perceive directly. Sight is clearly the most important sense for gathering information, so we must look mainly for ways to help it. These aids seem to be of three kinds. They enable us to see objects we cannot naturally see, to see them from farther away, or to see them more accurately and clearly.

We have an example of the first (not to speak of spectacles and the like, which only correct and remove the infirmity of a deficient sight, and therefore give no further information) in the lately invented microscopes, which exhibit the latent and invisible minutiæ of substances, and their hidden formation and motion, by wonderfully increasing their apparent magnitude. By their assistance we behold with astonishment the accurate form and outline of a flea, moss, and animalculæ, as well as their previously invisible color and motion. It is said, also, that an apparently straight line, drawn with a pen or pencil, is discovered by such a microscope to be very uneven and curved, because neither the motion of the hand, when assisted by a ruler, nor the impression of ink or color, are really regular, although the irregularities are so minute as not to be perceptible without the assistance of the microscope. Men have (as is usual in new and wonderful discoveries) added a superstitious remark, that the microscope sheds a lustre on the works of nature, and dishonor on those of art, which only means that the tissue of nature is much more delicate than that of art. For the microscope is only of use for minute objects, and Democritus, perhaps, if he had seen it, would have exulted in the thought of a means being discovered for seeing his atom, which he affirmed to be entirely invisible. But the inadequacy of these microscopes, for the observation of any but the most minute bodies, and even of those if parts of a larger body, destroys their utility; for if the invention could be extended to greater bodies, or the minute parts of greater bodies, so that a piece of cloth would appear like a net, and the latent minutiæ and irregularities of gems, liquids, urine, blood, wounds, and many other things could be rendered visible, the greatest advantage would, without doubt, be derived.

We have an example of the first in the recently invented microscopes. I do not mean spectacles and similar devices, which only correct poor eyesight and therefore provide no additional information. Microscopes greatly increase the apparent size of substances. In this way, they reveal tiny details that are hidden and invisible, along with their formation and movement. With their help, we can see with astonishment the precise shapes and outlines of fleas, moss, and tiny living creatures. We can also see their previously invisible colors and movements. It is also said that a microscope reveals that an apparently straight line drawn with a pen or pencil is very uneven and curved. This is because neither the movement of the hand, even with a ruler, nor the application of ink or color is truly regular. The irregularities are so small, however, that they cannot be seen without a microscope. As usual with new and wonderful discoveries, people have added a superstitious remark. They say that the microscope brings glory to the works of nature and dishonor to those of art. This only means that the fabric of nature is much more delicate than that of art. For the microscope is useful only for tiny objects. If Democritus had seen it, perhaps he would have rejoiced at the discovery of a way to see his atom. He had maintained that the atom was entirely invisible. But microscopes are inadequate for observing anything except the smallest bodies. They are inadequate even for those when they are parts of a larger body. This destroys their usefulness. The invention might, however, be extended to larger bodies or to their tiny parts. A piece of cloth might then appear like a net. The hidden details and irregularities of gems, liquids, urine, blood, wounds, and many other things might also be made visible. If this were possible, the greatest benefit would, without doubt, follow.

We have an instance of the second kind in the telescope, discovered by the wonderful exertions of Galileo; by the assistance of which a nearer intercourse may be opened (as by boats or vessels) between ourselves and the heavenly objects. For by its aid we are assured that the Milky Way is but a knot or constellation of small stars, clearly defined and separate, which the ancients only conjectured to be the case; whence it appears to be capable of demonstration, that the spaces of the planetary orbits (as they are termed) are not quite destitute of other stars, but that the heaven begins to glitter with stars before we arrive at the starry sphere, although they may be too small to be visible without the telescope. By the telescope, also, we can behold the revolutions of smaller stars round Jupiter, whence it may be conjectured that there are several centres of motion among the stars. By its assistance, also, the irregularity of light and shade on the moon’s surface is more clearly observed and determined, so as to allow of a sort of selenography. By the telescope we see the spots in the sun, and other similar phenomena; all of which are most noble discoveries, as far as credit can be safely given to demonstrations of this nature, which are on this account very suspicious, namely, that experiment stops at these few, and nothing further has yet been discovered by the same method, among objects equally worthy of consideration.

The telescope is an example of the second kind, discovered through Galileo’s remarkable efforts. With its help, we can come into closer contact with heavenly objects, as if traveling to them by boat. The telescope assures us that the Milky Way is simply a cluster or constellation of small, distinct, separate stars. The ancients only guessed that this was so. From this, it appears possible to demonstrate that the spaces within the planetary orbits, as they are called, are not entirely empty of other stars. The heavens begin to glitter with stars before we reach the starry sphere, although these stars may be too small to see without a telescope. Through the telescope, we can also see smaller stars revolving around Jupiter. From this, we may guess that there are several centers of motion among the stars. The telescope also lets us observe and identify the uneven light and shade on the moon’s surface more clearly. This makes a kind of selenography possible. Through the telescope, we see spots on the sun and other similar phenomena. All these are most noble discoveries, as far as we can safely trust demonstrations of this kind. Yet they are highly suspect for this reason: experiment has stopped with these few discoveries. Nothing further has yet been discovered by the same method among objects equally worthy of study.

Père Shenier first observed the spots on the sun’s disk. He used them to calculate that the sun rotates in twenty-five days and some hours. Ed.

We have instances of the third kind in measuring-rods, astrolabes, and the like, which do not enlarge, but correct and guide the sight. If there be other instances which assist the other senses in their immediate and individual action, yet if they add nothing further to their information they are not apposite to our present purpose, and we have therefore said nothing of them.

Examples of the third kind include measuring rods, astrolabes, and similar instruments. These do not magnify what we see, but correct and guide our sight. Other devices may assist the other senses in their immediate, individual actions. But if they add no further information, they are not relevant to our present purpose. We have therefore said nothing about them.

XL

40

In the seventeenth rank of prerogative instances we will place citing instances (to borrow a term from the tribunals), because they cite those things to appear, which have not yet appeared. We are wont also to call them invoking instances, and their property is that of reducing to the sphere of the senses objects which do not immediately fall within it.

In the seventeenth rank of prerogative instances, we place citing instances. We borrow this term from the courts because these instances summon things to appear that have not yet appeared. We also call them invoking instances. They bring within reach of our senses things that do not immediately fall within it.

Objects escape the senses either from their distance, or the intervention of other bodies, or because they are not calculated to make an impression upon the senses, or because they are not in sufficient quantity to strike the senses, or because there is not sufficient time for their acting upon the senses, or because the impression is too violent, or because the senses are previously filled and possessed by the object, so as to leave no room for any new motion. These remarks apply principally to sight, and next to touch, which two senses act extensively in giving information, and that too upon general objects, while the remaining three inform us only, as it were, by their immediate action, and as to specific objects.

Objects escape our senses for several reasons. They may be too far away, or other objects may be in the way. They may not be capable of affecting our senses, or there may not be enough of them to register. They may not have enough time to act on our senses, or their impact may be too strong. Or the senses may already be so occupied by an object that no new movement can register. These remarks apply mainly to sight, and then to touch. Both senses give us information over a wide range and about objects in general. The other three senses inform us only, as it were, through their immediate action and about specific objects.

There can be no reduction to the sphere of the senses in the first case, unless in the place of the object, which cannot be perceived on account of the distance, there be added or substituted some other object, which can excite and strike the sense from a greater distance, as in the communication of intelligence by fires, bells, and the like.

In the first case, something can reach the senses only if another object is added or substituted for it. The original object cannot be perceived because it is too far away. The other object must be able to stimulate the senses from a greater distance. This is how information is communicated by fires, bells, and similar signals.

In the second case we effect this reduction by rendering those things which are concealed by the interposition of other bodies, and which cannot easily be laid open, evident to the senses by means of that which lies at the surface, or proceeds from the interior; thus the state of the body is judged of by the pulse, urine, etc.

In the second case, we make things perceptible to the senses through what appears on the surface or comes from within. These things are hidden by other bodies and cannot easily be exposed. For example, we judge the condition of the body by its pulse, urine, and so on.

The third and fourth cases apply to many subjects, and the reduction to the sphere of the senses must be obtained from every quarter in the investigation of things. There are many examples. It is obvious that air, and spirit, and the like, whose whole substance is extremely rare and delicate, can neither be seen nor touched—a reduction, therefore, to the senses becomes necessary in every investigation relating to such bodies.

The third and fourth cases apply to many subjects. In investigating things, we must use every available means to make them perceptible to the senses. There are many examples. Air, spirit, and similar substances are obviously too fine and delicate to be seen or touched. So, in every investigation of such substances, we must find a way to make them perceptible to the senses.

Let the required nature, therefore, be the action and motion of the spirit inclosed in tangible bodies; for every tangible body with which we are acquainted contains an invisible and intangible spirit, over which it is drawn, and which it seems to clothe. This spirit being emitted from a tangible substance, leaves the body contracted and dry; when retained, it softens and melts it; when neither wholly emitted nor retained, it models it, endows it with limbs, assimilates, manifests, organizes it, and the like. All these points are reduced to the sphere of the senses by manifest effects.

Let the nature we are investigating, then, be the action and movement of the spirit enclosed in tangible bodies. Every tangible body we know contains an invisible, intangible spirit. The body is drawn over this spirit and seems to clothe it. When the spirit escapes from a tangible substance, it leaves the body contracted and dry. When the spirit is retained, it softens and melts the body. When it is neither entirely released nor retained, it shapes the body, gives it limbs, assimilates, reveals, and organizes it, and so on. All these things are made perceptible to the senses through their visible effects.

For in every tangible and inanimate body the inclosed spirit at first increases, and as it were feeds on the tangible parts which are most open and prepared for it; and when it has digested and modified them, and turned them into spirit, it escapes with them. This formation and increase of spirit is rendered sensible by the diminution of weight; for in every desiccation something is lost in quantity, not only of the spirit previously existing in the body, but of the body itself, which was previously tangible, and has been recently changed, for the spirit itself has no weight. The departure or emission of spirit is rendered sensible in the rust of metals, and other putrefactions of a like nature, which stop before they arrive at the rudiments of life, which belong to the third species of process. In compact bodies the spirit does not find pores and passages for its escape, and is therefore obliged to force out, and drive before it, the tangible parts also, which consequently protrude, whence arises rust and the like. The contraction of the tangible parts, occasioned by the emission of part of the spirit (whence arises desiccation), is rendered sensible by the increased hardness of the substance, and still more by the fissures, contractions, shrivelling, and folds of the bodies thus produced. For the parts of wood split and contract, skins become shrivelled, and not only that, but, if the spirit be emitted suddenly by the heat of the fire, become so hastily contracted as to twist and roll themselves up.

In every tangible, inanimate body, the spirit enclosed within it first increases. It feeds, as it were, on the tangible parts most open and ready for it. Once it has digested and altered those parts, turning them into spirit, it escapes along with them. We can detect the formation and increase of spirit by the loss of weight. Whenever a body dries out, it loses some of the spirit already present in it. It also loses some of the body itself, which was tangible but has recently been changed into spirit. For spirit itself has no weight. We can detect the departure or release of spirit in the rusting of metals and in other similar forms of decay. These processes stop before they reach the beginnings of life, which belong to the third kind of process. In dense bodies, the spirit finds no pores or passages through which to escape. It must therefore force out the tangible parts too, driving them ahead of it. These parts consequently stick out, producing rust and similar formations. The release of some of the spirit causes the tangible parts to contract, producing dryness. We can detect this contraction by the increased hardness of the substance. It is even more apparent in the cracks, contractions, shrivelling, and folds it produces in bodies. For the parts of wood split and contract, and skins become shrivelled. Moreover, if the spirit is released suddenly by the heat of a fire, skins contract so quickly that they twist and roll up.

Rust is now known to form when oxygen chemically combines with metal. The metal gains weight as it rusts. His theory of how animals originate is based on the mistaken idea that spontaneous generation is possible. See the paragraph after next.

On the contrary, when the spirit is retained, and yet expanded and excited by heat or the like (which happens in solid and tenacious bodies), then the bodies are softened, as in hot iron; or flow, as in metals; or melt, as in gums, wax, and the like. The contrary effects of heat, therefore (hardening some substances and melting others), are easily reconciled, because the spirit is emitted in the former, and agitated and retained in the latter; the latter action is that of heat and the spirit, the former that of the tangible parts themselves, after the spirit’s emission.

By contrast, heat or something similar can expand and excite the spirit while it remains inside. This happens in solid, cohesive bodies. The bodies then soften, as with hot iron, flow, as with metals, or melt, as with gums, wax, and similar substances. Heat therefore has opposite effects, hardening some substances and melting others. These effects are easily reconciled, because the spirit escapes in the former case and is stirred up and retained in the latter. Melting is the action of heat and the spirit. Hardening is the action of the tangible parts themselves, after the spirit has escaped.

> “Limus ut hic durescit, et hæc ut cera liquescit > Uno eodemque igni.” Virg. Ecl. viii.

But when the spirit is neither entirely retained nor emitted, but only strives and exercises itself, within its limits, and meets with tangible parts, which obey and readily follow it wherever it leads them, then follows the formation of an organic body, and of limbs, and the other vital actions of vegetables and animals. These are rendered sensible chiefly by diligent observation of the first beginnings, and rudiments or effects of life in animalculæ sprung from putrefaction, as in the eggs of ants, worms, mosses, frogs after rain, etc. Both a mild heat and a pliant substance, however, are necessary for the production of life, in order that the spirit may neither hastily escape, nor be restrained by the obstinacy of the parts, so as not to be able to bend and model them like wax.

But when the spirit is neither completely contained nor released, it strives and acts within its limits. If it encounters tangible parts that readily obey and follow its lead, an organic body and limbs then form. The other vital activities of plants and animals follow. These processes can be observed chiefly by carefully examining the first beginnings, traces, or effects of life in tiny creatures arising from decay. Examples include ant eggs, worms, mosses, and frogs after rain. Both gentle heat and a pliable substance are necessary to produce life. This keeps the spirit from escaping too quickly or being constrained by unyielding parts that it cannot bend and shape like wax.

Again, the difference of spirit which is important and of effect in many points (as unconnected spirit, branching spirit, branching and cellular spirit, the first of which is that of all inanimate substances, the second of vegetables, and the third of animals), is placed, as it were, before the eyes by many reducing instances.

Again, differences in spirit are important and have effects in many respects. There are three kinds: unconnected spirit, branching spirit, and branching and cellular spirit. The first belongs to all inanimate substances, the second to plants, and the third to animals. Many reducing instances bring these differences, as it were, before our eyes.

Again, it is clear that the more refined tissue and conformation of things (though forming the whole body of visible or tangible objects) are neither visible nor tangible. Our information, therefore, must here also be derived from reduction to the sphere of the senses. But the most radical and primary difference of formation depends on the abundance or scarcity of matter within the same space or dimensions. For the other formations which regard the dissimilarity of the parts contained in the same body, and their collocation and position, are secondary in comparison with the former.

Again, the finer structure and arrangement of things are clearly neither visible nor tangible, though they make up the whole body of visible or tangible objects. Therefore, here too, we must gain information by bringing these finer features within the reach of our senses. But the most fundamental difference in structure depends on how much matter occupies the same amount of space. Other differences in structure concern the differences among the parts of a body and how those parts are arranged and positioned. These differences are secondary by comparison.

Let the required nature then be the expansion or coherence of matter in different bodies, or the quantity of matter relative to the dimensions of each. For there is nothing in nature more true than the twofold proposition—that nothing proceeds from nothing and that nothing is reduced to nothing, but that the quantum, or sum total of matter, is constant, and is neither increased nor diminished. Nor is it less true, that out of this given quantity of matter, there is a greater or less quantity, contained within the same space or dimensions according to the difference of bodies; as, for instance, water contains more than air. So that if any one were to assert that a given content of water can be changed into an equal content of air, it is the same as if he were to assert that something can be reduced into nothing. On the contrary, if any one were to assert that a given content of air can be changed into an equal content of water, it is the same as if he were to assert that something can proceed from nothing. From this abundance or scarcity of matter are properly derived the notions of density and rarity, which are taken in various and promiscuous senses.

Let the nature we seek to understand be the expansion or compactness of matter in different bodies. In other words, let it be the quantity of matter in each body relative to its size. Nothing in nature is more certain than this twofold proposition: nothing comes from nothing, and nothing is reduced to nothing. The total quantity of matter is constant. It neither increases nor decreases. It is equally true that different bodies contain more or less of this matter within the same space. Water, for example, contains more matter than air. Suppose someone claimed that a given volume of water could be changed into an equal volume of air. That would be the same as claiming that something could be reduced to nothing. Conversely, suppose someone claimed that a given volume of air could be changed into an equal volume of water. That would be the same as claiming that something could come from nothing. The concepts of density and rarity properly derive from this abundance or scarcity of matter. Yet these terms are used in various, indiscriminate ways.

This third assertion may be considered as being also sufficiently certain; namely, that the greater or less quantity of matter in this or that body, may, by comparison, be reduced to calculation, and exact, or nearly exact, proportion. Thus, if one should say that there is such an accumulation of matter in a given quantity of gold, that it would require twenty-one times the quantity in dimension of spirits of wine, to make up the same quantity of matter, it would not be far from the truth.

This third claim may also be regarded as sufficiently certain. By comparing bodies, we can calculate the ratio of matter in them exactly or nearly exactly. For example, suppose someone said that a given volume of gold contains as much matter as twenty-one times that volume of spirits of wine. That would not be far from the truth.

The accumulation of matter, however, and its relative quantity, are rendered sensible by weight; for weight is proportionate to the quantity of matter, as regards the parts of a tangible substance, but spirit and its quantity of matter are not to be computed by weight, which spirit rather diminishes than augments.

However, weight makes the accumulation of matter and its relative quantity perceptible. For the parts of a tangible substance, weight is proportional to the quantity of matter. But spirit and the quantity of matter in it cannot be measured by weight. Spirit decreases weight rather than increasing it.

We have made a tolerably accurate table of weight, in which we have selected the weights and size of all the metals, the principal minerals, stones, liquids, oils, and many other natural and artificial bodies: a very useful proceeding both as regards theory and practice, and which is capable of revealing many unexpected results. Nor is this of little consequence, that it serves to demonstrate that the whole range of the variety of tangible bodies with which we are acquainted (we mean tolerably close, and not spongy, hollow bodies, which are for a considerable part filled with air), does not exceed the ratio of one to twenty-one. So limited is nature, or at least that part of it to which we are most habituated.

We have made a reasonably accurate table comparing weights and sizes. It includes all metals, the main minerals, stones, liquids, oils, and many other natural and artificial materials. This is useful for both theory and practice, and it can reveal many unexpected results. The table also shows something important. Across all the tangible materials we know, the ratio of weights does not exceed one to twenty-one. By this we mean reasonably solid materials, not spongy or hollow ones, which are largely filled with air. Nature is limited to this extent, or at least the part of it we know best.

We have also thought it deserving our industry, to try if we could arrive at the ratio of intangible or pneumatic bodies to tangible bodies, which we attempted by the following contrivance. We took a vial capable of containing about an ounce, using a small vessel in order to effect the subsequent evaporation with less heat. We filled this vial, almost to the neck, with spirits of wine, selecting it as the tangible body which, by our table, was the rarest, and contained a less quantity of matter in a given space than all other tangible bodies which are compact and not hollow. Then we noted exactly the weight of the liquid and vial. We next took a bladder, containing about two pints, and squeezed all the air out of it, as completely as possible, and until the sides of the bladder met. We first, however, rubbed the bladder gently with oil, so as to make it air-tight, by closing its pores with the oil. We tied the bladder tightly round the mouth of the vial, which we had inserted in it, and with a piece of waxed thread to make it fit better and more tightly, and then placed the vial on some hot coals in a brazier. The vapor or steam of the spirit, dilated and become aëriform by the heat, gradually swelled out the bladder, and stretched it in every direction like a sail. As soon as that was accomplished, we removed the vial from the fire and placed it on a carpet, that it might not be cracked by the cold; we also pricked the bladder immediately, that the steam might not return to a liquid state by the cessation of heat, and confound the proportions. We then removed the bladder, and again took the weight of the spirit which remained; and so calculated the quantity which had been converted into vapor, or an aëriform shape, and then examined how much space had been occupied by the body in its form of spirits of wine in the vial, and how much, on the other hand, had been occupied by it in its aëriform shape in the bladder, and subtracted the results; from which it was clear that the body, thus converted and changed, acquired an expansion of one hundred times beyond its former bulk.

We also thought it worth trying to find the ratio of intangible, or gaseous, bodies to tangible bodies. We attempted this with the following experiment. We took a vial that could hold about an ounce. We used a small vessel so that the liquid could later be evaporated with less heat. We filled the vial almost to the neck with spirits of wine. We chose this liquid because, according to our table, it was the least dense tangible body. It contained less matter in a given space than any other compact, non-hollow tangible body. We then noted the exact weight of the liquid and vial. Next, we took a bladder that could hold about two pints. We first rubbed it gently with oil, sealing its pores to make it airtight. Then we squeezed out as much air as possible, until its sides met. We inserted the mouth of the vial into the bladder and tied the bladder tightly around it. We used waxed thread to make the fit better and tighter. Then we placed the vial on hot coals in a brazier. The heat expanded the spirit into vapor, turning it into a gas. The vapor gradually filled the bladder, stretching it in every direction like a sail. As soon as this happened, we removed the vial from the fire and placed it on a carpet. This kept it from cracking in the cold. We also pricked the bladder immediately, so that the vapor would not cool and return to liquid, confusing the proportions. We then removed the bladder and weighed the spirit that remained. From this, we calculated how much had been converted into vapor, or gas. We then examined how much space that quantity had occupied as spirits of wine in the vial. We compared this with the space it had occupied as gas in the bladder and subtracted the results. From this, it was clear that the body, once converted, had expanded to one hundred times its former volume.

Again, let the required nature be heat or cold, of such a degree as not to be sensible from its weakness. They are rendered sensible by the thermometer, as we described it above; for the cold and heat are not actually perceived by the touch, but heat expands and cold contracts the air. Nor, again, is that expansion or contraction of the air in itself visible, but the air when expanded depresses the water, and when contracted raises it, which is the first reduction to sight.

Again, suppose the nature under investigation is heat or cold too weak to be felt. A thermometer makes it perceptible, as we described above. The heat or cold cannot be felt by touch, but heat expands the air and cold contracts it. The expansion or contraction of the air is not visible in itself. But when the air expands, it pushes the water down, and when it contracts, it draws the water up. This makes the effect visible for the first time.

See .

Again, let the required nature be the mixture of bodies; namely, how much aqueous, oleaginous or spirituous, ashy or salt parts they contain; or, as a particular example, how much butter, cheese, and whey there is in milk, and the like. These things are rendered sensible by artificial and skilful separations in tangible substances; and the nature of the spirit in them, though not immediately perceptible, is nevertheless discovered by the various motions and efforts of bodies. And, indeed, in this branch men have labored hard in distillations and artificial separations, but with little more success than in their other experiments now in use; their methods being mere guesses and blind attempts, and more industrious than intelligent; and what is worst of all, without any imitation or rivalry of nature, but rather by violent heats and too energetic agents, to the destruction of any delicate conformation, in which principally consist the hidden virtues and sympathies. Nor do men in these separations ever attend to or observe what we have before pointed out; namely, that in attacking bodies by fire, or other methods, many qualities are superinduced by the fire itself, and the other bodies used to effect the separation, which were not originally in the compound. Hence arise most extraordinary fallacies; for the mass of vapor which is emitted from water by fire, for instance, did not exist as vapor or air in the water, but is chiefly created by the expansion of the water by the heat of the fire.

Again, suppose the quality we are investigating is the composition of bodies. We want to know how much water, oil or spirit, ash or salt they contain. Or, to take a particular example, we may ask how much butter, cheese, and whey milk contains. Skillful artificial separation makes these components perceptible in tangible substances. The nature of the spirit in them is not immediately perceptible. Nevertheless, it can be discovered through the various movements and actions of bodies. Indeed, people have worked hard at distillation and artificial separation. But they have had little more success than with their other current experiments. Their methods are mere guesses and blind attempts, showing more effort than intelligence. Worst of all, they neither imitate nor seek to rival nature. Instead, they use violent heat and overly powerful agents. These destroy any delicate structure, in which hidden powers and affinities chiefly reside. In these separations, people also fail to notice what we have pointed out before. When they attack bodies with fire or other means, the process introduces many qualities not originally present in the compound. These qualities come from the fire itself and from the other substances used to separate the compound. This gives rise to extraordinary errors. For example, the mass of vapor released from water by fire did not exist as vapor or air in the water. It is chiefly created when the heat of the fire causes the water to expand.

So, in general, all delicate experiments on natural or artificial bodies, by which the genuine are distinguished from the adulterated, and the better from the more common, should be referred to this division; for they bring that which is not the object of the senses within their sphere. They are therefore to be everywhere diligently sought after.

In general, all precise tests of natural or artificial substances belong to this division. These tests distinguish genuine substances from adulterated ones, and better substances from more ordinary ones. They bring things beyond the reach of the senses within their reach. Therefore, we should diligently seek out such tests everywhere.

With regard to the fifth cause of objects escaping our senses, it is clear that the action of the sense takes place by motion, and this motion is time. If, therefore, the motion of any body be either so slow or so swift as not to be proportioned to the necessary momentum which operates on the senses, the object is not perceived at all; as in the motion of the hour hand, and that, again, of a musket-ball. The motion which is imperceptible by the senses from its slowness, is readily and usually rendered sensible by the accumulation of motion; that which is imperceptible from its velocity, has not as yet been well measured; it is necessary, however, that this should be done in some cases, with a view to a proper investigation of nature.

The fifth reason objects escape our senses concerns motion. Our senses work through motion, and motion takes time. A body may move too slowly or too quickly to produce the necessary motion in our senses. If it does, we do not perceive it at all. Examples include the movement of an hour hand and of a musket ball. Motion that is too slow for our senses can easily and usually be detected by allowing it to accumulate. Motion that is too fast for our senses has not yet been well measured. But in some cases, it must be measured if we are to investigate nature properly.

The sixth case, where the sense is impeded by the power of the object, admits of a reduction to the sensible sphere, either by removing the object to a greater distance, or by deadening its effects by the interposition of a medium, which may weaken and not destroy the object; or by the admission of its reflection where the direct impression is too strong, as that of the sun in a basin of water.

The sixth case occurs when an object is too powerful for the senses to perceive. It can be brought within range of the senses by moving it farther away. Another way is to place something between the object and the senses to weaken its effects without destroying it. Or, when the direct impression is too strong, one can look at its reflection. For example, one can look at the sun’s reflection in a basin of water.

The seventh case, where the senses are so overcharged with the object as to leave no further room, scarcely occurs except in the smell or taste, and is not of much consequence as regards our present subject. Let what we have said, therefore, suffice with regard to the reduction to the sensible sphere of objects not naturally within its compass.

The seventh case is when an object overwhelms the senses, leaving them no room for more. This scarcely occurs except with smell or taste, and it has little importance for our present subject. Let what we have said, then, be enough about making objects perceptible that are not naturally within the reach of the senses.

Sometimes, however, this reduction is not extended to the senses of man, but to those of some other animal, whose senses, in some points, exceed those of man; as (with regard to some scents) to that of the dog, and with regard to light existing imperceptibly in the air, when not illuminated from any extraneous source, to the sense of the cat, the owl, and other animals which see by night. For Telesius has well observed, that there appears to be an original portion of light even in the air itself, although but slight and meagre, and of no use for the most part to the eyes of men, and those of the generality of animals; because those animals to whose senses this light is proportioned can see by night, which does not, in all probability, proceed from their seeing either without light or by any internal light.

Sometimes, however, this reduction relies not on human senses but on those of other animals. Some animals have senses that surpass ours in certain respects. A dog, for example, can detect some scents better than a human can. Cats, owls, and other animals that see at night can detect light in the air that we cannot perceive. They can do so even when the air is not illuminated by any external source. For Telesius rightly observed that the air itself seems to contain a certain amount of light. This light is faint and weak, and mostly useless to the eyes of humans and most animals. But animals whose senses are suited to this light can see at night. In all probability, this is not because they see without light or by any light within themselves.

Riccati and all modern physicists find some light in every body. This seems to confirm the passage in Genesis that says light was created first. Ed.

Here, too, we would observe, that we at present discuss only the wants of the senses, and their remedies; for their deceptions must be referred to the inquiries appropriated to the senses, and sensible objects; except that important deception, which makes them define objects in their relation to man, and not in their relation to the universe, and which is only corrected by universal reasoning and philosophy.

Here, too, we should note that we are discussing only the limitations of the senses and their remedies. Their errors belong to inquiries into the senses and the objects they perceive. But there is one important exception: the senses define objects in relation to humans, not to the universe. Only universal reasoning and philosophy can correct this error.

Scientific progress since Bacon’s time provides examples of this kind. The air pump and barometer show the weight and elasticity of air. The velocity of light has been measured using the occultation of Jupiter’s satellites and the aberration of the fixed stars. Other examples include experiments in electricity and galvanism, and much of pneumatic chemistry. In all these cases, scientific facts are revealed that our senses alone could never have shown us. Ed.

XLI

41

In the eighteenth rank of prerogative instances we will class the instances of the road, which we are also wont to call itinerant and jointed instances. They are such as indicate the gradually continued motions of nature. This species of instances escapes rather our observation than our senses; for men are wonderfully indolent upon this subject, consulting nature in a desultory manner, and at periodic intervals, when bodies have been regularly finished and completed, and not during her work. But if any one were desirous of examining and contemplating the talents and industry of an artificer, he would not merely wish to see the rude materials of his art, and then his work when finished, but rather to be present while he is at labor, and proceeding with his work. Something of the same kind should be done with regard to nature. For instance, if any one investigate the vegetation of plants, he should observe from the first sowing of any seed (which can easily be done, by pulling up every day seeds which have been two, three, or four days in the ground, and examining them diligently), how and when the seed begins to swell and break, and be filled, as it were, with spirit; then how it begins to burst the bark and push out fibres, raising itself a little at the same time, unless the ground be very stiff; then how it pushes out these fibres, some downward for roots, others upward for the stem, sometimes also creeping laterally, if it find the earth open and more yielding on one side, and the like. The same should be done in observing the hatching of eggs, where we may easily see the process of animation and organization, and what parts are formed of the yolk, and what of the white of the egg, and the like. The same may be said of the inquiry into the formation of animals from putrefaction; for it would not be so humane to inquire into perfect and terrestrial animals, by cutting the fœtus from the womb; but opportunities may perhaps be offered of abortions, animals killed in hunting, and the like. Nature, therefore, must, as it were, be watched, as being more easily observed by night than by day: for contemplations of this kind may be considered as carried on by night, from the minuteness and perpetual burning of our watch-light.

In the eighteenth class of prerogative instances, we place instances of the road. We also call them itinerant and jointed instances. They reveal the gradual, continuous movements of nature. These instances escape our attention rather than our senses. For people are remarkably lazy in this matter. They observe nature only occasionally and at intervals, when bodies have been fully formed, not while nature is at work. But suppose someone wanted to examine the skill and industry of a craftsperson. They would not simply want to see the raw materials and then the finished work. They would rather be present while the craftsperson was working and watch the work progress. We should do something similar with nature. For example, someone studying plant growth should observe it from the moment a seed is sown. This is easy to do by pulling up seeds each day after they have spent two, three, or four days in the ground. The seeds should then be examined carefully. The observer should watch how and when the seed begins to swell and split, becoming filled, as it were, with life. Next comes the breaking of its outer coat and the emergence of fibers. At the same time, the seed rises a little, unless the ground is very hard. Then it sends some fibers downward as roots and others upward as the stem. Sometimes it also spreads sideways, if the earth is open and softer on one side. The observer should note these and similar details. The same method should be used to observe eggs hatching. There we can easily see the development of life and the formation of parts. We can see which parts form from the yolk and which from the white, and so on. The same applies to studying the formation of animals from decaying matter. It would not be humane to study fully formed land animals by cutting a fetus from the womb. But there may be opportunities to study miscarried fetuses, animals killed in hunting, and the like. Nature must therefore be watched, as it were, as something more easily observed by night than by day. Studies of this kind may be thought of as taking place at night, because our watch-light is so small and burns constantly.

The same must be attempted with inanimate objects, which we have ourselves done by inquiring into the opening of liquids by fire. For the mode in which water expands is different from that observed in wine, vinegar, or verjuice, and very different, again, from that observed in milk and oil, and the like; and this was easily seen by boiling them with slow heat, in a glass vessel, through which the whole may be clearly perceived. But we merely mention this, intending to treat of it more at large and more closely when we come to the discovery of the latent process; for it should always be remembered that we do not here treat of things themselves, but merely propose examples.

The same approach must be tried with inanimate objects. We have done this by studying how liquids expand when heated. Water expands differently from wine, vinegar, or verjuice. Milk, oil, and similar liquids expand in a very different way again. We easily observed this by boiling them slowly in a glass vessel, where the whole process was clearly visible. But we mention this only briefly. We intend to examine it more fully and closely when we come to the discovery of the latent process. For it should always be remembered that we are not discussing things themselves here, but merely offering examples.

Itinerant instances, like frontier instances, let us trace the general law of continuity that seems to pervade all nature. This law is aptly expressed in the phrase “natura non agit per saltum.” Exploring this law in phenomena where it is not immediately obvious has opened a rich source of physical discoveries. It has also revealed close connections between facts that at first seemed opposed. For example, gold leaf lets bluish-green light pass through it. This makes it a frontier instance between transparent and opaque bodies. It shows that a body from the class generally regarded as the most opaque in nature still has some slight transparency. Thus, opacity is not the opposite of transparency, but only its lowest extreme.

XLII

42

In the nineteenth rank of prerogative instances we will class supplementary or substitutive instances, which we are also wont to call instances of refuge. They are such as supply information, where the senses are entirely deficient, and we therefore have recourse to them when appropriate instances cannot be obtained. This substitution is twofold, either by approximation or by analogy. For instance, there is no known medium which entirely prevents the effect of the magnet in attracting iron—neither gold, nor silver, nor stone, nor glass, wood, water, oil, cloth, or fibrous bodies, air, flame, or the like. Yet by accurate experiment, a medium may perhaps be found which would deaden its effect, more than another comparatively and in degree; as, for instance, the magnet would not perhaps attract iron through the same thickness of gold as of air, or the same quantity of ignited as of cold silver, and so on; for we have not ourselves made the experiment, but it will suffice as an example. Again, there is no known body which is not susceptible of heat, when brought near the fire; yet air becomes warm much sooner than stone. These are examples of substitution by approximation.

In the nineteenth rank of prerogative instances, we place supplementary or substitutive instances. We also call them instances of refuge. They supply information where our senses fail us entirely. We therefore turn to them when we cannot obtain the appropriate instances. This substitution takes two forms: approximation and analogy. For example, no known material completely blocks a magnet from attracting iron. This is true of gold, silver, stone, glass, wood, water, oil, cloth, fibrous materials, air, flame, and the like. Yet careful experiments might find that one material weakens the effect more than another. For instance, a magnet might not attract iron through as much gold as air. Nor might it attract iron through as much heated silver as cold silver, and so on. We have not made these experiments ourselves, but they will serve as an example. Again, no known substance resists heat when brought near a fire. Yet air becomes warm much sooner than stone. These are examples of substitution by approximation.

Substitution by analogy is useful, but less sure, and therefore to be adopted with some judgment. It serves to reduce that which is not the object of the senses to their sphere, not by the perceptible operations of the imperceptible body, but by the consideration of some similar perceptible body. For instance, let the subject for inquiry be the mixture of spirits, which are invisible bodies. There appears to be some relation between bodies and their sources or support. Now, the source of flame seems to be oil and fat; that of air, water, and watery substances; for flame increases over the exhalation of oil, and air over that of water. One must therefore consider the mixture of oil and water, which is manifest to the senses, since that of air and flame in general escapes the senses. But oil and water mix very imperfectly by composition or stirring, while they are exactly and nicely mixed in herbs, blood, and the parts of animals. Something similar, therefore, may take place in the mixture of flame and air in spirituous substances, not bearing mixture very well by simple collision, while they appear, however, to be well mixed in the spirits of plants and animals.

Using an analogy as a substitute is useful, but less reliable. It should therefore be used with judgment. It helps us bring what cannot be sensed within the reach of our senses. It does this not through the perceptible effects of an imperceptible body, but by examining a similar perceptible body. For example, suppose we are investigating the mixture of spirits, which are invisible bodies. There seems to be a relationship between bodies and what produces or sustains them. Oil and fat seem to be the source of flame. Water and watery substances seem to be the source of air. For flame increases over the vapor given off by oil, and air increases over that given off by water. We should therefore examine the mixture of oil and water, which we can perceive. For the mixture of air and flame generally escapes our senses. Oil and water mix very imperfectly when combined or stirred. Yet they are thoroughly and precisely mixed in plants, blood, and the parts of animals. Something similar may therefore happen when flame and air mix in spirituous substances. They may not mix well through simple contact, yet they seem to be well mixed in the spirits of plants and animals.

Again, if the inquiry do not relate to perfect mixtures of spirits, but merely to their composition, as whether they easily incorporate with each other, or there be rather (as an example) certain winds and exhalations, or other spiritual bodies, which do not mix with common air, but only adhere to and float in it in globules and drops, and are rather broken and pounded by the air, than received into, and incorporated with it; this cannot be perceived in common air, and other aëriform substances, on account of the rarity of the bodies, but an image, as it were, of this process may be conceived in such liquids as quicksilver, oil, water, and even air, when broken and dissipated it ascends in small portions through water, and also in the thicker kinds of smoke; lastly, in dust, raised and remaining in the air, in all of which there is no incorporation: and the above representation in this respect is not a bad one, if it be first diligently investigated, whether there can be such a difference of nature between spirituous substances, as between liquids, for then these images might conveniently be substituted by analogy.

Again, the inquiry may concern not perfect mixtures of spirits, but simply how they combine. For example, do they mix easily with one another? Or are there certain winds, exhalations, or other spirit-like bodies that do not mix with ordinary air? Perhaps they only cling to it and float in it as globules and drops. In that case, the air breaks and pounds them rather than taking them in and mixing with them. This cannot be observed in ordinary air and other gaseous substances because the bodies are so rarefied. But we can form an image of the process from liquids such as mercury, oil, and water. We can also see it when air breaks up and rises through water in small portions. The same is true of thicker kinds of smoke and, finally, of dust raised and suspended in the air. In all these cases, the substances do not mix into one another. This picture is not a bad one for the purpose. But we must first investigate carefully whether spirit-like substances can differ in nature as liquids do. If they can, these images may conveniently serve as analogies.

And although we have observed of these supplementary instances, that information is to be derived from them, when appropriate instances are wanting, by way of refuge, yet we would have it understood, that they are also of great use, when the appropriate instances are at hand, in order to confirm the information afforded by them; of which we will speak more at length, when our subject leads us, in due course, to the support of induction.

We have observed that supplementary instances can provide information when appropriate instances are lacking. But they are also very useful when appropriate instances are available. They can confirm the information those instances provide. We will discuss this more fully when we come to the support of induction.

XLIII

43

In the twentieth rank of prerogative instances we will place lancing instances, which we are also wont (but for a different reason) to call twitching instances. We adopt the latter name, because they twitch the understanding, and the former because they pierce nature, whence we style them occasionally the instances of Democritus. They are such as warn the understanding of the admirable and exquisite subtilty of nature, so that it becomes roused and awakened to attention, observation, and proper inquiry; as, for instance, that a little drop of ink should be drawn out into so many letters; that silver merely gilt on its surface should be stretched to such a length of gilt wire; that a little worm, such as you may find on the skin, should possess both a spirit and a varied conformation of its parts; that a little saffron should imbue a whole tub of water with its color; that a little musk or aroma should imbue a much greater extent of air with its perfume; that a cloud of smoke should be raised by a little incense; that such accurate differences of sounds as articulate words should be conveyed in all directions through the air, and even penetrate the pores of wood and water (though they become much weakened), that they should be, moreover, reflected, and that with such distinctness and velocity; that light and color should for such an extent and so rapidly pass through solid bodies, such as glass and water, with so great and so exquisite a variety of images, and should be refracted and reflected; that the magnet should attract through every description of body, even the most compact; but (what is still more wonderful) that in all these cases the action of one should not impede that of another in a common medium, such as air; and that there should be borne through the air, at the same time, so many images of visible objects, so many impulses of articulation, so many different perfumes, as of the violet, rose, etc., besides cold and heat, and magnetic attractions; all of them, I say, at once, without any impediment from each other, as if each had its paths and peculiar passage set apart for it, without infringing against or meeting each other.

In the twentieth rank of prerogative instances, we place lancing instances. For a different reason, we also call them twitching instances. We use the latter name because they twitch the understanding, and the former because they pierce nature. For that reason, we sometimes call them the instances of Democritus. They alert the understanding to the wonderful and delicate subtlety of nature. In this way, they awaken it to attention, observation, and proper inquiry. For example, a small drop of ink can be drawn out into so many letters. Silver gilded only on its surface can be stretched into such a long gilt wire. A tiny worm, like one found on the skin, can have both a spirit and a complex arrangement of parts. A little saffron can color a whole tub of water. A little musk or other fragrance can fill a much greater volume of air with its scent. A little incense can raise a cloud of smoke. The precise differences in sound that make up spoken words can travel through the air in all directions. They can even pass through the pores of wood and water, though they become much weaker. They can also be reflected with such clarity and speed. Light and color can travel so far and so quickly through solid bodies such as glass and water. They can carry such a great and delicate variety of images, and be refracted and reflected. A magnet can attract through every kind of body, even the most dense. But what is still more wonderful is that, in all these cases, one action does not hinder another in a common medium, such as air. So many images of visible objects, so many impulses of speech, and so many different scents, such as violet and rose, can travel through the air at the same time. Cold and heat and magnetic attractions can travel through it as well. All of them travel at once, without hindering one another. It is as if each had its own paths and passages set apart, without crossing or meeting the others.

Referring to his theory of atoms.

To these lancing instances, however, we are wont, not without some advantage, to add those which we call the limits of such instances. Thus, in the cases we have pointed out, one action does not disturb or impede another of a different nature, yet those of a similar nature subdue and extinguish each other; as the light of the sun does that of the candle, the sound of a cannon that of the voice, a strong perfume a more delicate one, a powerful heat a more gentle one, a plate of iron between the magnet and other iron the effect of the magnet. But the proper place for mentioning these will be also among the supports of induction.

We usually add what we call the limits of lancing instances, and this is not without benefit. In the cases we have described, one action does not disturb or hinder another of a different kind. But actions of the same kind overcome and extinguish one another. Sunlight does this to candlelight, and the sound of a cannon does it to a voice. A strong perfume overpowers a delicate one, and intense heat overpowers gentler heat. An iron plate placed between a magnet and another piece of iron blocks the magnet’s effect. But the proper place to discuss these limits is also among the supports of induction.

XLIV

44

We have now spoken of the instances which assist the senses, and which are principally of service as regards information; for information begins from the senses. But our whole labor terminates in practice, and as the former is the beginning, so is the latter the end of our subject. The following instances, therefore, will be those which are chiefly useful in practice. They are comprehended in two classes, and are seven in number. We call them all by the general name of practical instances. Now there are two defects in practice, and as many divisions of important instances. Practice is either deceptive or too laborious. It is generally deceptive (especially after a diligent examination of natures), on account of the power and actions of bodies being ill defined and determined. Now the powers and actions of bodies are defined and determined either by space or by time, or by the quantity at a given period, or by the predominance of energy; and if these four circumstances be not well and diligently considered, the sciences may indeed be beautiful in theory, but are of no effect in practice. We call the four instances referred to this class, mathematical instances and instances of measure.

We have now discussed the instances that aid the senses and are mainly useful for gaining information. For information begins with the senses. But all our work ends in practice. Just as information is the beginning of our subject, practice is its end. The following instances, therefore, are chiefly useful in practice. There are seven of them, divided into two classes. We call them all practical instances. There are two defects in practice, and a corresponding division of these important instances. Practice is either misleading or too laborious. It is generally misleading because the powers and actions of bodies are poorly defined and determined. This is especially true after a careful examination of natures. The powers and actions of bodies are defined and determined by space, time, quantity at a given time, or predominance of energy. If these four circumstances are not carefully considered, the sciences may be beautiful in theory but ineffective in practice. We call the four instances in this class mathematical instances and instances of measure.

Practice is laborious either from the multitude of instruments, or the bulk of matter and substances requisite for any given work. Those instances, therefore, are valuable, which either direct practice to that which is of most consequence to mankind, or lessen the number of instruments or of matter to be worked upon. We assign to the three instances relating to this class, the common name of propitious or benevolent instances. We will now separately discuss these seven instances, and conclude with them that part of our work which relates to the prerogative or illustrious instances.

Practical work is laborious because it requires either many instruments or large quantities of materials and substances. Instances are therefore valuable if they direct practical work toward what matters most to humanity. They are also valuable if they reduce the number of instruments or the amount of material needed. We give the three instances in this class the common name of propitious or benevolent instances. We will now discuss these seven instances separately. With them, we will conclude the part of our work dealing with prerogative or illustrious instances.

XLV

45

In the twenty-first rank of prerogative instances we will place the instances of the rod or rule, which we are also wont to call the instances of completion or non ultrà. For the powers and motions of bodies do not act and take effect through indefinite and accidental, but through limited and certain spaces; and it is of great importance to practice that these should be understood and noted in every nature which is investigated, not only to prevent deception, but to render practice more extensive and efficient. For it is sometimes possible to extend these powers, and bring the distance, as it were, nearer, as in the example of telescopes.

In the twenty-first rank of prerogative instances, we place instances of the rod or rule. We also call them instances of completion or non ultrà. The powers and motions of bodies do not act over unlimited or accidental distances. They act over definite and limited distances. For practical purposes, it is very important to understand and note these limits for every nature we investigate. This prevents deception and makes practical work more extensive and effective. For sometimes these powers can be extended, bringing distant things nearer, as it were, as telescopes do.

Many powers act and take effect only by actual touch, as in the percussion of bodies, where the one does not remove the other, unless the impelling touch the impelled body. External applications in medicine, as ointment and plasters, do not exercise their efficacy except when in contact with the body. Lastly, the objects of touch and taste only strike those senses when in contact with their organs.

Many forces act and have an effect only through direct contact. For example, when bodies collide, one cannot move the other unless it touches it. Medicines applied externally, such as ointments and plasters, work only when in contact with the body. Finally, things can be felt or tasted only when they touch the organs of those senses.

Other powers act at a distance, though it be very small, of which but few have as yet been noted, although there be more than men suspect; this happens (to take everyday instances) when amber or jet attracts straws, bubbles dissolve bubbles, some purgative medicines draw humors from above, and the like. The magnetic power by which iron and the magnet, or two magnets, are attracted together, acts within a definite and narrow sphere, but if there be any magnetic power emanating from the earth a little below its surface, and affecting the needle in its polarity, it must act at a great distance.

Other forces act at a distance, though usually a very short one. Few have been noted so far, although there are more than people suspect. Everyday examples include amber or jet attracting straws, bubbles dissolving bubbles, and some purgative medicines drawing humors from above. The magnetic force that draws iron and a magnet, or two magnets, together acts within a limited, narrow range. But if a magnetic force comes from just below the earth’s surface and affects the direction of a compass needle, it must act over a great distance.

Again, if there be any magnetic force which acts by sympathy between the globe of the earth and heavy bodies, or between that of the moon and the waters of the sea (as seems most probable from the particular floods and ebbs which occur twice in the month), or between the starry sphere and the planets, by which they are summoned and raised to their apogees, these must all operate at very great distances.

Again, there may be a magnetic force acting through sympathy between the earth and heavy bodies. Or such a force may act between the moon and the waters of the sea. The particular floods and ebbs that occur twice a month make this seem most probable. Or such a force may act between the starry sphere and the planets, drawing and raising them to their apogees. If these forces exist, they must all act over very great distances.

Notice how closely this approaches Newton’s theory. The same idea appears even more clearly in the ninth motion. Newton believed that the planets might act together to disrupt the earth’s annual revolution. They might lengthen the line of apsides and the ellipse the earth traces each year around the sun.

Suppose all the planets met in a straight line. Venus and Mercury would be on one side of the sun. The earth, moon, Mars, Jupiter and Saturn would be on the opposite side. Saturn would then attract Jupiter, Jupiter would attract Mars, and Mars would attract the moon. The moon, in turn, would attract the earth in proportion to the force pulling it out of its orbit.

The combined effect on our planet would lengthen its orbit along the ecliptic. This would draw it so far from the source of heat that the cold would destroy animal life. But this movement would stop as soon as the planetary alignment that caused it ended. The earth would then spring back, like a compressed spring, almost as close to the sun as it had been drawn away. The resulting heat on its surface would be about as intense as the earlier cold had been severe. Until the earth regained its regular path, it would swing back and forth across its orbit. Its atmosphere would change with each swing, in proportion to the square of the change in its distance from the sun.

Nowhere is Bacon’s genius more evident than in these repeated guesses at the truth. He would have been a strong Copernican if Gilbert had not defended the system. Ed.

Again, some conflagrations and the kindling of flames take place at very considerable distances with particular substances, as they report of the naphtha of Babylon. Heat, too, insinuates itself at wide distances, as does also cold, so that the masses of ice which are broken off and float upon the Northern Ocean, and are borne through the Atlantic to the coast of Canada, become perceptible by the inhabitants, and strike them with cold from a distance. Perfumes also (though here there appears to be always some corporeal emission) act at remarkable distances, as is experienced by persons sailing by the coast of Florida, or parts of Spain, where there are whole woods of lemons, oranges, and other odoriferous plants, or rosemary and marjoram bushes, and the like. Lastly, the rays of light and the impressions of sound act at extensive distances.

Again, some fires and flames ignite at great distances in certain substances, as people report happens with the naphtha of Babylon. Heat also spreads over great distances, as does cold. Masses of ice break off and float on the Northern Ocean, then drift across the Atlantic to the coast of Canada. The inhabitants can sense the ice and feel its cold from a distance. Scents also travel remarkable distances, though there always seems to be some physical substance given off. People experience this when sailing along the coast of Florida or parts of Spain. There, whole woods are filled with lemons, oranges, and other fragrant plants, as well as bushes of rosemary, marjoram, and the like. Lastly, rays of light and sounds travel over great distances.

Yet all these powers, whether acting at a small or great distance, certainly act within definite distances, which are well ascertained by nature, so that there is a limit depending either on the mass or quantity of the bodies, the vigor or faintness of the powers, or the favorable or impeding nature of the medium, all of which should be taken into account and observed. We must also note the boundaries of violent motions, such as missiles, projectiles, wheels and the like, since they are also manifestly confined to certain limits.

Yet all these forces, whether they act over short or long distances, act within definite ranges set by nature. Their limits depend on the mass or quantity of the bodies, the strength or weakness of the forces, or whether the medium helps or hinders them. All these factors should be considered and observed. We must also note the limits of forced motions, such as those of missiles, projectiles, wheels, and the like. These motions are also clearly confined to certain limits.

Some motions and virtues are to be found of a directly contrary nature to these, which act in contact but not at a distance; namely, such as operate at a distance and not in contact, and again act with less force at a less distance, and the reverse. Sight, for instance, is not easily effective in contact, but requires a medium and distance; although I remember having heard from a person deserving of credit, that in being cured of a cataract (which was done by putting a small silver needle within the first coat of the eye, to remove the thin pellicle of the cataract, and force it into a corner of the eye), he had distinctly seen the needle moving across the pupil. Still, though this may be true, it is clear that large bodies cannot be seen well or distinctly, unless at the vertex of a cone, where the rays from the object meet at some distance from the eye. In old persons the eye sees better if the object be moved a little further, and not nearer. Again, it is certain that in projectiles the impact is not so violent at too short a distance as a little afterward. Such are the observations to be made on the measure of motions as regards distance.

Some motions and forces are directly opposite to those that act through contact but not at a distance. They act at a distance but not through contact. They also act less strongly at a shorter distance, and more strongly at a greater distance. Sight, for example, does not work easily through contact. It requires a medium and some distance. Yet I remember hearing an account from a trustworthy person who had been treated for a cataract. The treatment involved inserting a small silver needle beneath the outer layer of the eye. The needle was used to remove the thin film of the cataract and push it into a corner of the eye. He said he had clearly seen the needle moving across his pupil. Even if this account is true, large objects clearly cannot be seen well or distinctly except at the point of a cone, where the rays from the object meet some distance from the eye. Older people see better if an object is moved a little farther away, not closer. Again, projectiles certainly do not strike as violently at too short a distance as they do a little farther on. These are the observations to be made about how motions vary with distance.

This is true only when a projectile gains speed at every successive instant of its flight. This happens only with falling bodies. Bacon seems to have formed this opinion after observing that bullets penetrate many objects at a distance. The bullets bounce off those same objects when fired from close range. This apparent contradiction, however, arises from resistance within the object. Overcoming that resistance requires speed combined with force. Ed.

There is another measure of motion in space which must not be passed over, not relating to progressive but spherical motion—that is, the expansion of bodies into a greater, or their contraction into a lesser sphere. For in our measure of this motion we must inquire what degree of compression or extension bodies easily and readily admit of, according to their nature, and at what point they begin to resist it, so as at last to bear it no further—as when an inflated bladder is compressed, it allows a certain compression of the air, but if this be increased, the air does not suffer it, and the bladder is burst.

There is another measure of motion in space that we must not overlook. It concerns spherical motion rather than motion from one place to another. Spherical motion is the expansion of bodies into a larger sphere or their contraction into a smaller one. To measure this motion, we must ask how much bodies can easily be compressed or expanded, depending on their nature. We must also ask when they begin to resist compression or expansion, and when they can bear no more. For example, an inflated bladder can be squeezed enough to compress the air inside it. But if the pressure increases, the air resists further compression, and the bladder bursts.

We have proved this by a more delicate experiment. We took a metal bell, of a light and thin sort, such as is used for salt-cellars, and immersed it in a basin of water, so as to carry the air contained in its interior down with it to the bottom of the basin. We had first, however, placed a small globe at the bottom of the basin, over which we placed the bell. The result was, that if the globe were small compared with the interior of the bell, the air would contract itself, and be compressed without being forced out, but if it were too large for the air readily to yield to it, the latter became impatient of the pressure, raised the bell partly up, and ascended in bubbles.

We proved this with a more precise experiment. We took a light, thin metal bell, like those used for salt cellars. We lowered it into a basin of water, carrying the air inside it down to the bottom. First, however, we had placed a small sphere at the bottom of the basin. We placed the bell over it. If the sphere was small compared with the space inside the bell, the air compressed without being forced out. But if the sphere was too large for the air to give way easily, the air resisted the pressure. It lifted the bell partway and rose in bubbles.

To prove, also, the extension (as well as the compression) which air admits of, we adopted the following method:—We took a glass egg, with a small hole at one end; we drew out the air by violent suction at this hole, and then closed the hole with the finger, immersed the egg in water, and then removed the finger. The air being constrained by the effort made in suction, and dilated beyond its natural state, and therefore striving to recover and contract itself (so that if the egg had not been immersed in water, it would have drawn in the air with a hissing sound), now drew in a sufficient quantity of water to allow the air to recover its former dimensions.

To show that air can expand as well as compress, we used the following method. We took a glass egg with a small hole at one end. We sucked air out forcefully through the hole, then covered it with a finger. We immersed the egg in water and removed the finger. The suction had forced the air to expand beyond its natural state. The air then tried to return to its original state by contracting. If the egg had not been immersed in water, it would have drawn in air with a hissing sound. Instead, it drew in enough water to let the air return to its former volume.

This passage shows that in Bacon’s time, people did not understand how atmospheric pressure forces water into the egg. Ed.

It is well ascertained that rare bodies (such as air) admit of considerable contraction, as has been before observed; but tangible bodies (such as water) admit of it much less readily, and to a less extent. We investigated the latter point by the following experiment:

As noted earlier, it is well established that rare bodies, such as air, can be compressed considerably. But tangible bodies, such as water, are much harder to compress and cannot be compressed as much. We investigated this latter point with the following experiment:

We had a leaden globe made, capable of containing about two pints, wine measure, and of tolerable thickness, so as to support considerable pressure. We poured water into it through an aperture, which we afterward closed with melted lead, as soon as the globe was filled with water, so that the whole became perfectly solid. We next flattened the two opposite sides with a heavy hammer, which necessarily caused the water to occupy a less space, since the sphere is the solid of greatest content; and when hammering failed from the resistance of the water, we made use of a mill or press, till at last the water, refusing to submit to a greater pressure, exuded like a fine dew through the solid lead. We then computed the extent to which the original space had been reduced, and concluded that water admitted such a degree of compression when constrained by great violence.

We had a lead sphere made that could hold about two pints by wine measure. Its walls were thick enough to withstand considerable pressure. We filled it with water through an opening, then sealed the opening with melted lead. The whole sphere was then completely solid. Next, we flattened two opposite sides with a heavy hammer. This necessarily forced the water into a smaller space, since a sphere has the greatest volume of any solid. When the water resisted the hammer blows, we used a mill or press. At last, the water would submit to no greater pressure and seeped through the solid lead like a fine dew. We then calculated how much the original space had been reduced. We concluded that water could be compressed to that degree under great force.

The more solid, dry or compact bodies, such as stones, wood and metals, admit of much less, and indeed scarcely any perceptible compression or expansion, but escape by breaking, slipping forward, or other efforts; as appears in bending wood, or steel for watch-springs, in projectiles, hammering and many other motions, all of which, together with their degrees, are to be observed and examined in the investigation of nature, either to a certainty, or by estimation, or comparison, as opportunity permits.

More solid, dry, or compact bodies, such as stone, wood, and metal, allow much less compression or expansion. Indeed, they allow scarcely any that can be detected. Instead, they give way by breaking, slipping forward, or other movements. This can be seen when wood or steel for watch springs is bent, and in projectiles, hammering, and many other motions. In investigating nature, we must observe and examine all these motions and their degrees. We should measure them exactly, estimate them, or compare them, as opportunity permits.

XLVI

46

In the twenty-second rank of prerogative instances we will place the instances of the course, which we are also wont to call water instances, borrowing our expression from the water hour-glasses employed by the ancients instead of those with sand. They are such as measure nature by the moments of time, as the last instances do by the degrees of space. For all motion or natural action takes place in time, more or less rapidly, but still in determined moments well ascertained by nature. Even those actions which appear to take effect suddenly, and in the twinkling of an eye (as we express it), are found to admit of greater or less rapidity.

In the twenty-second rank of prerogative instances, we place instances of the course. We also call them water instances. We borrow this name from the water clocks the ancients used instead of sand clocks. These instances measure nature by moments of time, just as the previous instances measure it by degrees of space. For all motion or natural action takes place in time, whether more or less rapidly. But each takes place within a definite time, precisely determined by nature. Even actions that appear to happen suddenly, in the twinkling of an eye, as we say, can be faster or slower.

In the first place, then, we see that the return of the heavenly bodies to the same place takes place in regular times, as does the flood and ebb of the sea. The descent of heavy bodies toward the earth, and the ascent of light bodies toward the heavenly sphere, take place in definite times, according to the nature of the body, and of the medium through which it moves. The sailing of ships, the motions of animals, the transmission of projectiles, all take place in times the sums of which can be computed. With regard to heat, we see that boys in winter bathe their hands in the flame without being burned; and conjurers, by quick and regular movements, overturn vessels filled with wine or water, and replace them without spilling the liquid, with several similar instances. The compression, expansion and eruption of several bodies, take place more or less rapidly, according to the nature of the body and its motion, but still in definite moments.

First, we see that heavenly bodies return to the same place at regular intervals, as the sea rises and falls. Heavy bodies descend toward the earth, and light bodies rise toward the heavenly sphere, in definite times. These times depend on the nature of the body and the medium through which it moves. Ships sail, animals move, and projectiles travel over periods of time that can all be calculated. As for heat, we see boys in winter pass their hands through a flame without being burned. With quick, controlled movements, conjurers overturn vessels filled with wine or water and set them upright without spilling the liquid. There are several similar examples. Bodies compress, expand, and burst at different speeds, depending on their nature and motion. But these events still take place within definite periods of time.

We have already mentioned Newton’s error about the absolute lightness of bodies in a note preceding the same aphorism in the first book. Newton returns to the volatile or spiritual substances () that he, like the Platonists and some schoolmen, supposed were part of every body. He claims that they can reduce the weight of the material coating he supposes encloses them. These passages and the text suggest that Bacon had no idea of the relative density of bodies. Nor, apparently, did he understand that some bodies can reduce the specific gravity of heavier substances by expanding their parts. If he did understand this, then Aristotle’s fantasies about the soul must have corrupted his thinking. Aristotle imagined that bodies have an appetite to join similar substances: flame and spirit fly to the sky, while solid, opaque substances fly to the earth. Ed.

In the explosion of several cannon at once (which are sometimes heard at the distance of thirty miles), the sound of those nearest to the spot is heard before that of the most distant. Even in sight (whose action is most rapid), it is clear that a definite time is necessary for its exertion, which is proved by certain objects being invisible from the velocity of their motion, such as a musket-ball; for the flight of the ball is too swift to allow an impression of its figure to be conveyed to the sight.

When several cannons are fired at once, the sound of the nearest is heard before that of the most distant. Cannon fire can sometimes be heard thirty miles away. Even sight, which works very quickly, clearly takes a definite amount of time to act. This is shown by objects that move too fast to be seen, such as a musket ball. The ball flies too quickly for an impression of its shape to reach the eye.

This last instance, and others of a like nature, have sometimes excited in us a most marvellous doubt, no less than whether the image of the sky and stars is perceived as at the actual moment of its existence, or rather a little after, and whether there is not (with regard to the visible appearance of the heavenly bodies) a true and apparent time, as well as a true and apparent place, which is observed by astronomers in parallaxes. It appeared so incredible to us, that the images or radiations of heavenly bodies could suddenly be conveyed through such immense spaces to the sight, and it seemed that they ought rather to be transmitted in a definite time. That doubt, however (as far as regards any great difference between the true and apparent time), was subsequently completely set at rest, when we considered the infinite loss and diminution of size as regards the real and apparent magnitude of a star, occasioned by its distance, and at the same time observed at how great a distance (at least sixty miles) bodies which are merely white can be suddenly seen by us. For there is no doubt, that the light of the heavenly bodies not only far surpasses the vivid appearance of white, but even the light of any flame (with which we are acquainted) in the vigor of its radiation. The immense velocity of the bodies themselves, which is perceived in their diurnal motion, and has so astonished thinking men, that they have been more ready to believe in the motion of the earth, renders the motion of radiation from them (marvellous as it is in its rapidity) more worthy of belief. That which has weighed most with us, however, is, that if there were any considerable interval of time between the reality and the appearance, the images would often be interrupted and confused by clouds formed in the meantime, and similar disturbances of the medium. Let this suffice with regard to the simple measures of time.

This last example, and others like it, have sometimes raised a most remarkable doubt in us. Do we see the sky and stars as they are at that very moment, or a little later? Is there a true time and an apparent time for the visible appearance of heavenly bodies? Astronomers observe a similar difference between true and apparent positions when they study parallax. It seemed incredible to us that images or rays from heavenly bodies could reach our eyes instantly across such vast distances. Rather, it seemed that they must take some definite time to travel. Later, however, our doubt was completely resolved, at least as to any great difference between true and apparent time. We considered the enormous reduction in a star’s apparent size compared with its actual size, owing to its distance. At the same time, we observed that we can instantly see objects that are merely white from at least sixty miles away. For there is no doubt that the light of heavenly bodies radiates far more powerfully than the brightness of white objects. It even radiates more powerfully than the light of any flame we know. The immense speed of the heavenly bodies themselves, seen in their daily motion, also makes their rays’ motion more believable. This is so, even though the speed of the rays is astonishing. The bodies’ speed has so amazed thoughtful people that they have been more ready to believe that the earth moves. What convinced us most, however, was another point. If there were any considerable interval between the actual event and its appearance, the images would often be interrupted and confused. Clouds forming in the meantime, and similar disturbances in the intervening medium, would cause this. Let this suffice on the simple measures of time.

Römer, a Danish astronomer, was the first to demonstrate that light takes time to travel. He did this by linking irregularities in the eclipses of Jupiter’s satellites to their distances from the earth. The idea also occurred to Dominic Cassini and Bacon, but both let the discovery slip out of their hands. Ed.

It is not merely the absolute, but still more the relative measure of motions and actions which must be inquired into, for this latter is of great use and application. We perceive that the flame of firearms is seen sooner than the sound is heard, although the ball must have struck the air before the flame, which was behind it, could escape: the reason of which is, that light moves with greater velocity than sound. We perceive, also, that visible images are received by the sight with greater rapidity than they are dismissed, and for this reason, a violin string touched with the finger appears double or triple, because the new image is received before the former one is dismissed. Hence, also, rings when spinning appear globular, and a lighted torch, borne rapidly along at night, appears to have a tail. Upon the principle of the inequality of motion, also, Galileo attempted an explanation of the flood and ebb of the sea, supposing the earth to move rapidly, and the water slowly, by which means the water, after accumulating, would at intervals fall back, as is shown in a vessel of water made to move rapidly. He has, however, imagined this on data which cannot be granted (namely, the earth’s motion), and besides, does not satisfactorily account for the tide taking place every six hours.

We must investigate not only the absolute speeds of motions and actions, but even more their speeds relative to one another. The latter are very useful and have many applications. We see the flash of a firearm before we hear the sound. Yet the ball must have struck the air before the flame behind it could escape. This is because light travels faster than sound. We also see that the eye receives images faster than it lets them go. For this reason, a violin string touched with a finger appears double or triple. The eye receives the new image before it lets go of the previous one. For the same reason, spinning rings appear spherical. A lighted torch carried quickly at night also appears to have a tail. Galileo also tried to explain the rise and fall of the sea through differences in the speed of motion. He supposed that the earth moves quickly and the water slowly. As a result, the water would accumulate and then fall back at intervals. This can be seen in a vessel of water moved quickly. However, his explanation rests on a premise that cannot be accepted, namely, the earth’s motion. Besides, it does not satisfactorily explain why the tide occurs every six hours.

An example of our present point (the relative measure of motion), and, at the same time, of its remarkable use of which we have spoken, is conspicuous in mines filled with gunpowder, where immense weights of earth, buildings, and the like, are overthrown and prostrated by a small quantity of powder; the reason of which is decidedly this, that the motion of the expansion of the gunpowder is much more rapid than that of gravity, which would resist it, so that the former has terminated before the latter has commenced. Hence, also, in missiles, a strong blow will not carry them so far as a sharp and rapid one. Nor could a small portion of animal spirit in animals, especially in such vast bodies as those of the whale and elephant, have ever bent or directed such a mass of body, were it not owing to the velocity of the former, and the slowness of the latter in resisting its motion.

A clear example of our present point, the relative measure of motion, appears in mines filled with gunpowder. It also shows the remarkable use of this principle, which we have discussed. A small quantity of powder throws down immense weights of earth, buildings, and the like. The reason is certainly that gunpowder expands much faster than gravity can act against it. The expansion is therefore over before gravity has begun to resist it. For the same reason, a sharp, rapid blow sends a projectile farther than a strong one. The same principle applies to animals, especially those with bodies as large as whales and elephants. A small amount of animal spirit could never bend or direct such a massive body otherwise. It can do so because it moves quickly, while the body is slow to resist its motion.

The author confuses inertness with gravity. Inertness is simply the indifference of bodies to action. Gravity is a force that always acts in proportion to their density. He makes the same mistake later. Ed.

In short, this point is one of the principal foundations of the magic experiments (of which we shall presently speak), where a small mass of matter overcomes and regulates a much larger, if there but be an anticipation of motion, by the velocity of one before the other is prepared to act.

In short, this point is a principal foundation of magic experiments, which we will discuss shortly. In these experiments, a small mass of matter overcomes and controls a much larger one. It can do this if it moves quickly enough to act before the larger mass is ready to act.

Finally, the point of the first and last should be observed in all natural actions. Thus, in an infusion of rhubarb the purgative property is first extracted, and then the astringent; we have experienced something of the same kind in steeping violets in vinegar, which first extracts the sweet and delicate odor of the flower, and then the more earthy part, which disturbs the perfume; so that if the violets be steeped a whole day, a much fainter perfume is extracted than if they were steeped for a quarter of an hour only, and then taken out; and since the odoriferous spirit in the violet is not abundant, let other and fresh violets be steeped in the vinegar every quarter of an hour, as many as six times, when the infusion becomes so strengthened, that although the violets have not altogether remained there for more than one hour and a half, there remains a most pleasing perfume, not inferior to the flower itself, for a whole year. It must be observed, however, that the perfume does not acquire its full strength till about a month after the infusion. In the distillation of aromatic plants macerated in spirits of wine, it is well known that an aqueous and useless phlegm rises first, then water containing more of the spirit, and, lastly, water containing more of the aroma; and many observations of the like kind, well worthy of notice, are to be made in distillations. But let these suffice as examples.

Finally, we should observe what happens first and last in all natural processes. For example, when rhubarb is steeped, its purgative property is extracted first, followed by its astringent property. We have observed something similar when steeping violets in vinegar. The vinegar first extracts the flower’s sweet, delicate scent, then its earthier part, which spoils the perfume. So violets steeped for a whole day yield a much fainter perfume than those removed after only fifteen minutes. Since violets contain little of the fragrant essence, replace them with fresh violets every fifteen minutes, up to six times. This strengthens the infusion. Although the violets have spent no more than an hour and a half in the vinegar altogether, a most pleasing perfume remains for a whole year. It is not inferior to the scent of the flower itself. Note, however, that the perfume does not reach its full strength until about a month after the infusion. When aromatic plants steeped in spirits of wine are distilled, a watery and useless liquid is well known to rise first. Next comes water containing more of the spirit, and finally water containing more of the aroma. Many similar observations, well worth noting, can be made about distillation. But these examples will suffice.

The experiments in the last two classes of instances are considered only in relation to practice. Bacon does not even mention their infinitely greater importance to the theoretical part of induction. The important law of gravitation in physical astronomy could only have been demonstrated through observations and experiments that gave precise geometrical measurements of the quantities compared. It was necessary to determine the earth’s radius, the velocity of falling bodies at its surface, the moon’s distance, and its orbital speed. Only then could the relationship be discovered between the force that draws a stone to the ground and the force that keeps the moon in its orbit.

In many cases, only geometry can reveal the result of a number of particular facts, or the collective instances arising from them. Geometry is therefore necessary to complete the work of induction. Take optics, for example. When light passes from one transparent medium to another, it is refracted. The angle at which the incoming ray meets the boundary between the two media determines the angle at which the refracted ray meets that same boundary. Experiments can only determine the angle of refraction corresponding to a particular angle of incidence. They give no direct information about the general rule that relates these angles in every possible case. Nor do they directly reveal the constant, unchanging relationship between the angles.

Geometry must therefore be brought in. Suppose two angles, or two variable quantities of any kind, have a constant but unknown relationship. If an unlimited number of values for those quantities are given, geometry provides infallible means of discovering the relationship, either exactly or approximately. In this way, it has been found that the cosines of the angles mentioned above have a constant ratio when the two media remain the same.

Once the relationships among the simple elements of phenomena have been discovered, they provide a general rule applicable to any particular case. The deductive method must then be used to show how these elementary principles account for the laws governing more complex combinations. Even before Newton’s day, the reflection and refraction of light by rain falling from a cloud opposite the sun were thought to contain the form of the rainbow. Newton turned a probable conjecture into a certain fact. From the known laws of reflection and refraction, he deduced the width of the colored arc and the diameter of the circle of which it forms a part. He also deduced the circle’s position relative to the spectator and the sun. Doubt was silenced at once when his calculations combined the same laws governing the simple elements of optics and produced results matching the phenomena in nature. Ed.

XLVII

47

In the twenty-third rank of prerogative instances we will place instances of quantity, which we are also wont to call the doses of nature (borrowing a word from medicine). They are such as measure the powers by the quantity of bodies, and point out the effect of the quantity in the degree of power. And in the first place, some powers only subsist in the universal quantity, or such as bears a relation to the confirmation and fabric of the universe. Thus the earth is fixed, its parts fall. The waters in the sea flow and ebb, but not in the rivers, except by the admission of the sea. Then, again, almost all particular powers act according to the greater or less quantity of the body. Large masses of water are not easily rendered foul, small are. New wine and beer become ripe and drinkable in small skins much more readily than in large casks. If a herb be placed in a considerable quantity of liquid, infusion takes place rather than impregnation; if in less, the reverse. A bath, therefore, and a light sprinkling, produce different effects on the human body. Light dew, again, never falls, but is dissipated and incorporated with the air; thus we see that in breathing on gems, the slight quantity of moisture, like a small cloud in the air, is immediately dissolved. Again, a piece of the same magnet does not attract so much iron as the whole magnet did. There are some powers where the smallness of the quantity is of more avail; as in boring, a sharp point pierces more readily than a blunt one; the diamond, when pointed, makes an impression on glass, and the like.

In the twenty-third rank of prerogative instances, we place instances of quantity. Borrowing a term from medicine, we also call them the doses of nature. These instances measure powers by the quantity of matter and show how quantity affects their degree of power. First, some powers exist only at the scale of the whole universe, or in relation to its structure and fabric. Thus, the earth is fixed, while its parts fall. The waters of the sea ebb and flow, but rivers do not, except where the sea enters them. Almost all particular powers, moreover, act according to the greater or smaller quantity of matter. Large bodies of water do not easily become foul, but small ones do. New wine and beer mature and become drinkable much more readily in small skins than in large casks. If a herb is placed in a large quantity of liquid, infusion takes place rather than impregnation. In a smaller quantity, the reverse happens. A bath and a light sprinkling therefore have different effects on the human body. Light dew, too, never falls, but disperses and becomes part of the air. We see this when we breathe on gems. The small amount of moisture immediately dissolves, like a small cloud in the air. Again, a piece of a magnet does not attract as much iron as the whole magnet did. In some powers, a smaller quantity is more effective. In boring, for example, a sharp point pierces more readily than a blunt one. A pointed diamond makes a mark on glass, and so on.

Here, too, we must not rest contented with a vague result, but inquire into the exact proportion of quantity requisite for a particular exertion of power; for one would be apt to suppose that the power bears an exact proportion to the quantity; that if a leaden bullet of one ounce, for instance, would fall in a given time, one of two ounces ought to fall twice as rapidly, which is most erroneous. Nor does the same ratio prevail in every kind of power, their difference being considerable. The measure, therefore, must be determined by experiment, and not by probability or conjecture.

Here, too, we must not settle for a vague result. We must find the exact quantity needed to produce a particular effect. One might suppose that the power is exactly proportional to the quantity. For example, suppose a one-ounce lead bullet falls in a given time. One might expect a two-ounce bullet to fall twice as fast, but that is quite wrong. Nor does the same ratio apply to every kind of power. The differences are considerable. Therefore, we must determine the measure through experiment, not through probability or guesswork.

Lastly, we must in all our investigations of nature observe what quantity, or dose, of the body is requisite for a given effect, and must at the same time be guarded against estimating it at too much or too little.

Finally, in all our investigations of nature, we must determine how much of a substance is needed for a given effect. At the same time, we must be careful not to estimate the amount too high or too low.

XLVIII

48

In the twenty-fourth rank of prerogative instances we will place wrestling instances, which we are also wont to call instances of predominance. They are such as point out the predominance and submission of powers compared with each other, and which of them is the more energetic and superior, or more weak and inferior. For the motions and effects of bodies are compounded, decomposed, and combined, no less than the bodies themselves. We will exhibit, therefore, the principal kinds of motions or active powers, in order that their comparative strength, and thence a demonstration and definition of the instances in question, may be rendered more clear.

In the twenty-fourth rank of prerogative instances, we place wrestling instances, which we also call instances of predominance. These show how powers compare with one another, which dominate and which yield. They show which powers are stronger and superior, and which are weaker and inferior. For the motions and effects of bodies are compounded, decomposed, and combined, just as bodies themselves are. We will therefore set out the principal kinds of motion or active power. This will make their comparative strength clearer and help us demonstrate and define these instances.

Let the first motion be that of the resistance of matter, which exists in every particle, and completely prevents its annihilation; so that no conflagration, weight, pressure, violence, or length of time can reduce even the smallest portion of matter to nothing, or prevent it from being something, and occupying some space, and delivering itself (whatever straits it be put to), by changing its form or place, or, if that be impossible, remaining as it is; nor can it ever happen that it should either be nothing or nowhere. This motion is designated by the schools (which generally name and define everything by its effects and inconveniences rather than by its inherent cause) by the axiom, that two bodies cannot exist in the same place, or they call it a motion to prevent the penetration of dimensions. It is useless to give examples of this motion, since it exists in every body.

Let the first motion be the resistance of matter. It exists in every particle and completely prevents its annihilation. No fire, weight, pressure, force, or passage of time can reduce even the smallest portion of matter to nothing. Nor can any of these prevent it from being something and occupying some space. However tightly confined it is, matter frees itself by changing its form or place. If that is impossible, it remains as it is. It can never be nothing or nowhere. The schools generally name and define everything by its effects and difficulties rather than by its inherent cause. They describe this motion through the axiom that two bodies cannot exist in the same place. They also call it a motion to prevent the penetration of dimensions. It is useless to give examples of this motion, since it exists in every body.

Let the second motion be that which we term the motion of connection, by which bodies do not allow themselves to be separated at any point from the contact of another body, delighting, as it were, in the mutual connection and contact. This is called by the schools a motion to prevent a vacuum. It takes place when water is drawn up by suction or a syringe, the flesh by cupping, or when the water remains without escaping from perforated jars, unless the mouth be opened to admit the air, and innumerable instances of a like nature.

Let the second motion be what we call the motion of connection. By this motion, bodies resist being separated at any point from contact with another body. They seem to delight in their connection and contact with one another. Scholars call this a motion to prevent a vacuum. It occurs when water is drawn up by suction or with a syringe, or when flesh is drawn up by cupping. It also occurs when water stays in perforated jars without escaping, unless the mouth is opened to let air in. There are countless similar examples.

Let the third be that which we term the motion of liberty, by which bodies strive to deliver themselves from any unnatural pressure or tension, and to restore themselves to the dimensions suited to their mass; and of which, also, there are innumerable examples. Thus, we have examples of their escaping from pressure, in the water in swimming, in the air in flying, in the water again in rowing, and in the air in the undulation of the winds, and in springs of watches. An exact instance of the motion of compressed air is seen in children’s popguns, which they make by scooping out elder-branches or some such matter, and forcing in a piece of some pulpy root or the like, at each end; then they force the root or other pellet with a ramrod to the opposite end, from which the lower pellet is emitted and projected with a report, and that before it is touched by the other piece of root or pellet, or by the ramrod. We have examples of their escape from tension, in the motion of the air that remains in glass eggs after suction, in strings, leather, and cloth, which recoil after tension, unless it be long continued. The schools define this by the term of motion from the form of the element; injudiciously enough, since this motion is to be found not only in air, water, or fire, but in every species of solid, as wood, iron, lead, cloth, parchment, etc., each of which has its own proper size, and is with difficulty stretched to any other. Since, however, this motion of liberty is the most obvious of all, and to be seen in an infinite number of cases, it will be as well to distinguish it correctly and clearly; for some most carelessly confound this with the two others of resistance and connection; namely, the freedom from pressure with the former, and that from tension with the latter, as if bodies when compressed yielded or expanded to prevent a penetration of dimensions, and when stretched rebounded and contracted themselves to prevent a vacuum. But if the air, when compressed, could be brought to the density of water, or wood to that of stone, there would be no need of any penetration of dimensions, and yet the compression would be much greater than they actually admit of. So if water could be expanded till it became as rare as air, or stone as rare as wood, there would be no need of a vacuum, and yet the expansion would be much greater than they actually admit of.

The third is what we call the motion of liberty. By this motion, bodies strive to free themselves from unnatural pressure or tension. They seek to restore themselves to the dimensions suited to their mass. There are countless examples. We see bodies escaping pressure in water during swimming and rowing, and in air during flight. We also see it in the movement of winds and in watch springs. A clear example of compressed air in motion appears in children’s popguns. Children make these by hollowing out elder branches or similar material. They force a piece of soft root or a similar pellet into each end. Then they use a ramrod to force one pellet toward the other end. The pellet at that end is shot out with a bang. This happens before the other pellet or the ramrod touches it. We see bodies escaping tension in the motion of air left in glass eggs after suction. We also see it in strings, leather, and cloth, which spring back after being stretched, unless the stretching continues too long. The schools call this motion from the form of the element. This is a poor definition, since the motion occurs not only in air, water, or fire, but in every kind of solid. It occurs in wood, iron, lead, cloth, parchment, and so on. Each has its own proper size, and each is difficult to stretch to any other size. The motion of liberty is the most obvious of all and appears in countless cases. It is therefore worth distinguishing it accurately and clearly. Some people carelessly confuse it with two other motions, resistance and connection. They confuse freedom from pressure with resistance, and freedom from tension with connection. They speak as if compressed bodies yielded or expanded to prevent their dimensions from penetrating one another. Likewise, they speak as if stretched bodies sprang back and contracted to prevent a vacuum. But suppose air could be compressed to the density of water, or wood to that of stone. There would be no need for their dimensions to penetrate one another. Yet the compression would be much greater than they can actually undergo. Likewise, suppose water could be expanded until it was as rare as air, or stone as rare as wood. There would be no need for a vacuum. Yet the expansion would be much greater than they can actually undergo.

We do not, therefore, arrive at a penetration of dimensions or a vacuum before the extremes of condensation and rarefaction, while the motion we speak of stops and exerts itself much within them, and is nothing more than a desire of bodies to preserve their specific density (or, if it be preferred, their form), and not to desert them suddenly, but only to change by degrees, and of their own accord. It is, however, much more necessary to intimate to mankind (because many other points depend upon this), that the violent motion which we call mechanical, and Democritus (who, in explaining his primary motions, is to be ranked even below the middling class of philosophers) termed the motion of a blow, is nothing else than this motion of liberty, namely, a tendency to relaxation from compression. For in all simple impulsion or flight through the air, the body is not displaced or moved in space, until its parts are placed in an unnatural state, and compressed by the impelling force. When that takes place, the different parts urging the other in succession, the whole is moved, and that with a rotatory as well as progressive motion, in order that the parts may, by this means also, set themselves at liberty, or more readily submit. Let this suffice for the motion in question.

Therefore, we do not reach the penetration of dimensions or a vacuum until the extremes of condensation and rarefaction. The motion we are discussing stops well short of those extremes and operates within them. It is nothing more than the desire of bodies to preserve their specific density (or, if preferred, their form). They do not abandon it suddenly, but change only gradually and of their own accord. It is much more important, however, to make another point clear, because many other things depend on it. Violent motion, which we call mechanical motion, is nothing more than this motion of liberty. It is a tendency to relax after compression. Democritus called it the motion of a blow. His explanation of primary motions places him even below the middle rank of philosophers. In all simple pushing or flight through the air, a body is not displaced or moved through space until the pushing force compresses its parts and puts them in an unnatural state. When that happens, the parts push one another in succession, moving the whole body. It moves both by rotating and by advancing, so that its parts can free themselves or give way more readily. Let that be enough about this motion.

Let the fourth be that which we term the motion of matter, and which is opposed to the last; for in the motion of liberty, bodies abhor, reject, and avoid, a new size or volume, or any new expansion or contraction (for these different terms have the same meaning), and strive, with all their power, to rebound and resume their former density; on the contrary, in the motion of matter, they are anxious to acquire a new volume or dimension, and attempt it willingly and rapidly, and occasionally by a most vigorous effort, as in the example of gunpowder. The most powerful, or at least most frequent, though not the only instruments of this motion, are heat and cold. For instance, the air, if expanded by tension (as by suction in the glass egg), struggles anxiously to restore itself; but if heat be applied, it strives, on the contrary, to dilate itself, and longs for a larger volume, regularly passing and migrating into it, as into a new form (as it is termed); nor after a certain degree of expansion is it anxious to return, unless it be invited to do so by the application of cold, which is not indeed a return, but a fresh change. So also water, when confined by compression, resists, and wishes to become as it was before, namely, more expanded; but if there happen an intense and continued cold, it changes itself readily, and of its own accord, into the condensed state of ice; and if the cold be long continued, without any intervening warmth (as in grottoes and deep caves), it is changed into crystal or similar matter, and never resumes its form.

The fourth is what we call the motion of matter, which is the opposite of the last motion. In the motion of liberty, bodies resist, reject, and avoid a new size or volume. They also resist any new expansion or contraction. These different terms mean the same thing. Bodies strive with all their power to spring back and regain their former density. In the motion of matter, by contrast, bodies are eager to acquire a new volume or size. They attempt it willingly and rapidly, sometimes with great force, as gunpowder does. Heat and cold are the most powerful, or at least the most common, means of producing this motion, though not the only ones. For example, air may be expanded by tension, as by suction in a glass egg. It then struggles to return to its former state. But if heat is applied, the air strives instead to expand and longs for a larger volume. It steadily moves into that larger volume, as if entering what is called a new form. Once expanded to a certain degree, it no longer seeks to return unless cold is applied. Even then, this is not a return but a fresh change. Similarly, water resists when confined by compression. It wants to return to its former, more expanded state. But if it is exposed to intense and sustained cold, it readily changes into the condensed state of ice. It does this of its own accord. If the cold continues long enough without any intervening warmth, as in grottoes and deep caves, the water changes into crystal or similar matter. It never returns to its former state.

Let the fifth be that which we term the motion of continuity. We do not understand by this simple and primary continuity with any other body (for that is the motion of connection), but the continuity of a particular body in itself; for it is most certain that all bodies abhor a solution of continuity, some more and some less, but all partially. In hard bodies (such as steel and glass) the resistance to an interruption of continuity is most powerful and efficacious, while although in liquids it appears to be faint and languid, yet it is not altogether null, but exists in the lowest degree, and shows itself in many experiments, such as bubbles, the round form of drops, the thin threads which drip from roofs, the cohesion of glutinous substances, and the like. It is most conspicuous, however, if an attempt be made to push this separation to still smaller particles. Thus, in mortars, the pestle produces no effect after a certain degree of contusion, water does not penetrate small fissures, and the air itself, notwithstanding its subtilty, does not penetrate the pores of solid vessels at once, but only by long-continued insinuation.

Let the fifth be what we call the motion of continuity. By this we do not mean simple, primary continuity with another body. That is the motion of connection. We mean the continuity of a particular body within itself. For it is certain that all bodies resist being separated, some more than others, but all to some extent. In hard bodies, such as steel and glass, this resistance is strongest and most effective. In liquids, the resistance appears weak and faint. Yet it is not entirely absent, but exists to the lowest degree. It shows itself in many experiments, such as bubbles, the round shape of drops, and the thin threads that drip from roofs. It also shows itself in the way sticky substances hold together, and in similar phenomena. This resistance is most conspicuous, however, when an attempt is made to separate a body into still smaller particles. Thus, after a substance has been crushed to a certain point in a mortar, the pestle has no further effect. Water does not penetrate small cracks. Even air, despite its subtlety, does not penetrate the pores of solid vessels at once. It does so only by gradually making its way in over a long time.

Let the sixth be that which we term the motion of acquisition, or the motion of need. It is that by which bodies placed among others of a heterogeneous and, as it were, hostile nature, if they meet with the means or opportunity of avoiding them, and uniting themselves with others of a more analogous nature, even when these latter are not closely allied to them, immediately seize and, as it were, select them, and appear to consider it as something acquired (whence we derive the name), and to have need of these latter bodies. For instance, gold, or any other metal in leaf, does not like the neighborhood of air; if, therefore, they meet with any tangible and thick substance (such as the finger, paper, or the like), they immediately adhere to it, and are not easily torn from it. Paper, too, and cloth, and the like, do not agree with the air, which is inherent and mixed in their pores. They readily, therefore, imbibe water or other liquids, and get rid of the air. Sugar, or a sponge, dipped in water or wine, and though part of it be out of the water or wine, and at some height above it, will yet gradually absorb them.

Let the sixth be what we call the motion of acquisition, or the motion of need. This occurs when bodies are surrounded by other bodies of a different and, as it were, hostile nature. If they find a way to avoid these bodies and unite with others of a more similar nature, they immediately seize them. They do this even when the more similar bodies are not closely related to them. They seem, as it were, to select these bodies and regard them as something acquired, hence the name. They also seem to need them. For example, gold or any other metal in leaf form does not like being near air. So, if it comes into contact with a solid, substantial object, such as a finger or paper, it immediately sticks to it. It is not easily pulled away. Paper, cloth, and similar materials also do not agree with the air present in their pores. They therefore readily absorb water or other liquids and get rid of the air. Sugar or a sponge dipped in water or wine will gradually absorb the liquid. This happens even if part of the sugar or sponge is out of the liquid and some height above it.

To the extent that this motion results from attraction and repulsion, it is simply a consequence of the last two. Ed.

These two cases are now explained by the properties of capillary tubes. They show another aspect of the law of attraction. Ed.

Hence an excellent rule is derived for the opening and dissolution of bodies; for (not to mention corrosive and strong waters, which force their way) if a body can be found which is more adapted, suited, and friendly to a given solid, than that with which it is by some necessity united, the given solid immediately opens and dissolves itself to receive the former, and excludes or removes the latter. Nor is the effect or power of this motion confined to contact, for the electric energy (of which Gilbert and others after him have told so many fables) is only the energy excited in a body by gentle friction, and which does not endure the air, but prefers some tangible substance if there be any at hand.

From this we can derive an excellent rule for breaking open and dissolving bodies. We may set aside corrosive substances and strong waters, which force their way in. Suppose a solid is necessarily joined to another substance, but a different substance is better adapted, suited, and friendly to it. The solid immediately opens and dissolves to receive the new substance, excluding or removing the other. The effect or power of this motion is not limited to contact. Gilbert and others after him have told many fables about electrical energy. But it is only the energy produced in a body by gentle friction. This energy does not tolerate air, but prefers some tangible substance if one is at hand.

This is one of the most useful practical methods in chemistry today.

Let the seventh be that which we term the motion of greater congregation, by which bodies are borne toward masses of a similar nature, for instance, heavy bodies toward the earth, light to the sphere of heaven. The schools termed this natural motion, by a superficial consideration of it, because produced by no external visible agent, which made them consider it innate in the substances; or perhaps because it does not cease, which is little to be wondered at, since heaven and earth are always present, while the causes and sources of many other motions are sometimes absent and sometimes present. They therefore called this perpetual and proper, because it is never interrupted, but instantly takes place when the others are interrupted, and they called the others adscititious. The former, however, is in reality weak and slow, since it yields, and is inferior to the others as long as they act, unless the mass of the body be great; and although this motion have so filled men’s minds, as almost to have obscured all others, yet they know but little about it, and commit many errors in its estimate.

Let the seventh be what we call the motion of greater congregation. By this motion, bodies move toward masses of a similar nature. For example, heavy bodies move toward the earth, and light bodies toward the sphere of heaven. The schools called this natural motion, based on a superficial understanding of it. Because no external, visible force produced it, they considered it inherent in substances. Or perhaps they called it natural because it never stops. But this is hardly surprising, since heaven and earth are always present. The causes and sources of many other motions, by contrast, are sometimes absent and sometimes present. They therefore called this motion perpetual and proper because it is never interrupted. It also takes place immediately when the other motions are interrupted. They called those other motions adscititious, or added from outside. In reality, however, the motion of greater congregation is weak and slow. It yields to the other motions and is weaker than they are as long as they act, unless the body’s mass is great. This motion has so filled people’s minds that it has almost obscured all the others. Yet they know little about it and make many errors in judging it.

Let the eighth be that which we term the motion of lesser congregation, by which the homogeneous parts in any body separate themselves from the heterogeneous and unite together, and whole bodies of a similar substance coalesce and tend toward each other, and are sometimes congregated, attracted, and meet, from some distance; thus in milk the cream rises after a certain time, and in wine the dregs and tartar sink; which effects are not to be attributed to gravity and levity only, so as to account for the rising of some parts and the sinking of others, but much more to the desire of the homogeneous bodies to meet and unite. This motion differs from that of need in two points: 1st, because the latter is the stimulus of a malignant and contrary nature, while in this of which we treat (if there be no impediment or restraint), the parts are united by their affinity, although there be no foreign nature to create a struggle; 2dly, because the union is closer and more select. For in the other motion, bodies which have no great affinity unite, if they can but avoid the hostile body, while in this, substances which are connected by a decided kindred resemblance come together and are molded into one. It is a motion existing in all compound bodies, and would be readily seen in each, if it were not confined and checked by the other affections and necessities of bodies which disturb the union.

The eighth is what we call the motion of lesser congregation. By this motion, similar parts of a body separate from dissimilar parts and unite. Whole bodies of similar substance also come together and tend toward one another. Sometimes they gather, attract one another, and meet from some distance. Thus, after a while, cream rises in milk, and dregs and tartar sink in wine. These effects should not be attributed only to heaviness and lightness, which explain why some parts rise and others sink. They are due much more to the desire of similar bodies to meet and unite. This motion differs from the motion of need in two ways. First, the motion of need is prompted by a hostile and contrary nature. In the motion we are discussing, however, the parts unite through their affinity, if nothing prevents or restrains them. They do so even when no foreign nature causes a struggle. Second, their union is closer and more selective. In the motion of need, bodies without much affinity unite if they can thereby avoid the hostile body. In this motion, substances with a distinct family resemblance come together and are molded into one. This motion exists in all compound bodies. It would be easy to see in each one if it were not confined and checked. Other properties and necessities of bodies disturb their union.

This motion is usually confined in the three following manners: by the torpor of the bodies; by the power of the predominating body; by external motion. With regard to the first, it is certain that there is more or less sluggishness in tangible bodies, and an abhorrence of locomotion; so that unless excited they prefer remaining contented with their actual state, to placing themselves in a better position. There are three means of breaking through this sluggishness—heat; the active power of a similar body; vivid and powerful motion. With regard to the first, heat is, on this account, defined as that which separates heterogeneous, and draws together homogeneous substances; a definition of the Peripatetics which is justly ridiculed by Gilbert, who says it is as if one were to define man to be that which sows wheat and plants vineyards; being only a definition deduced from effects, and those but partial. But it is still more to be blamed, because those effects, such as they are, are not a peculiar property of heat, but a mere accident (for cold, as we shall afterward show, does the same), arising from the desire of the homogeneous parts to unite; the heat then assists them in breaking through that sluggishness which before restrained their desire. With regard to the assistance derived from the power of a similar body, it is most conspicuous in the magnet when armed with steel, for it excites in the steel a power of adhering to steel, as a homogeneous substance, the power of the magnet breaking through the sluggishness of the steel. With regard to the assistance of motion, it is seen in wooden arrows or points, which penetrate more deeply into wood than if they were tipped with iron, from the similarity of the substance, the swiftness of the motion breaking through the sluggishness of the wood; of which two last experiments we have spoken above in the aphorism on clandestine instances.

This motion is usually restrained in three ways: by the sluggishness of bodies, by the power of the dominant body, and by external motion. First, tangible bodies are certainly sluggish to some degree and resist moving from place to place. Unless something sets them in motion, they prefer to remain as they are rather than move into a better position. Three things can overcome this sluggishness: heat, the active power of a similar body, and strong, vigorous motion. First, heat is defined on this basis as what separates unlike substances and draws like substances together. Gilbert rightly ridicules this definition of the Peripatetics. He says it is like defining a human being as something that sows wheat and plants vineyards. The definition is drawn only from effects, and only some of them. But it deserves even more criticism because these effects, such as they are, are not peculiar to heat. They are merely incidental, since cold does the same, as we shall show later. They arise from the desire of like parts to unite. Heat helps them overcome the sluggishness that previously restrained that desire. The help provided by the power of a similar body is most obvious in a magnet fitted with steel. The magnet gives the steel the power to adhere to other steel, a substance like itself. The power of the magnet overcomes the sluggishness of the steel. The help provided by motion can be seen in wooden arrows or points. These penetrate wood more deeply than they would if tipped with iron, because the substances are alike. The speed of the motion overcomes the sluggishness of the wood. We have discussed these last two experiments above, in the aphorism on clandestine instances.

See .

The confinement of the motion of lesser congregation, which arises from the power of the predominant body, is shown in the decomposition of blood and urine by cold. For as long as these substances are filled with the active spirit, which regulates and restrains each of their component parts, as the predominant ruler of the whole, the several different parts do not collect themselves separately on account of the check; but as soon as that spirit has evaporated, or has been choked by the cold, then the decomposed parts unite, according to their natural desire. Hence it happens, that all bodies which contain a sharp spirit (as salts and the like), last without decomposition, owing to the permanent and durable power of the predominating and imperious spirit.

The breakdown of blood and urine by cold shows how a dominant body can restrain the motion of lesser congregation. As long as these substances are filled with active spirit, it rules the whole and regulates and restrains each part. Because of this restraint, the different parts cannot gather separately. But once the spirit has evaporated or been stifled by the cold, the separated parts come together according to their natural desire. For this reason, all bodies containing a sharp spirit, such as salts and the like, last without breaking down. This is because the dominant and commanding spirit has a lasting and durable power.

The confinement of the motion of lesser congregation, which arises from external motion, is very evident in that agitation of bodies which preserves them from putrefaction. For all putrefaction depends on the congregation of the homogeneous parts, whence, by degrees, there ensues a corruption of the first form (as it is called), and the generation of another. For the decomposition of the original form, which is itself the union of the homogeneous parts, precedes the putrefaction, which prepares the way for the generation of another. This decomposition, if not interrupted, is simple; but if there be various obstacles, putrefactions ensue, which are the rudiments of a new generation. But if (to come to our present point) a frequent agitation be excited by external motion, the motion toward union (which is delicate and gentle, and requires to be free from all external influence) is disturbed, and ceases; which we perceive to be the case in innumerable instances. Thus, the daily agitation or flowing of water prevents putrefaction; winds prevent the air from being pestilent; corn turned about and shaken in granaries continues clean: in short, everything which is externally agitated will with difficulty rot internally.

External motion can restrain the motion of lesser congregation. This is clear when agitation keeps bodies from rotting. All decay depends on similar parts gathering together. Gradually, this gathering corrupts the original form, as it is called, and produces another. The original form is itself the union of similar parts. Its breakdown comes before decay, which prepares the way for a new form. If nothing interrupts this breakdown, it is simple. But if there are various obstacles, decay follows, and a new form begins to develop. To return to our point, frequent agitation caused by external motion disturbs and stops the motion toward union. That motion is delicate and gentle, and it must be free from all outside influence. We can see this in countless examples. The daily movement or flow of water prevents decay. Winds prevent the air from becoming pestilent. Grain turned and shaken in granaries stays clean. In short, anything stirred from the outside is unlikely to rot within.

We must not omit that union of the parts of bodies which is the principal cause of induration and desiccation. When the spirit or moisture, which has evaporated into spirit, has escaped from a porous body (such as wood, bone, parchment, and the like), the thicker parts are drawn together, and united with a greater effort, and induration or desiccation is the consequence; and this we attribute not so much to the motion of connection (in order to prevent a vacuum), as to this motion of friendship and union.

We must not overlook how the parts of a body come together. This is the main cause of hardening and drying. Spirit, or moisture that has evaporated into spirit, may escape from a porous body, such as wood, bone, or parchment. When it does, the thicker parts are drawn together and unite more strongly. As a result, the body hardens or dries. We attribute this less to the motion of connection, which prevents a vacuum, than to this motion of friendship and union.

Union from a distance is rare, and yet is to be met with in more instances than are generally observed. We perceive it when one bubble dissolves another, when medicines attract humors from a similarity of substance, when one string moves another in unison with it on different instruments, and the like. We are of opinion that this motion is very prevalent also in animal spirits, but are quite ignorant of the fact. It is, however, conspicuous in the magnet, and magnetized iron. While speaking of the motions of the magnet, we must plainly distinguish them, for there are four distinct powers or effects of the magnet which should not be confounded, although the wonder and astonishment of mankind has classed them together. 1. The attraction of the magnet to the magnet, or of iron to the magnet, or of magnetized iron to iron. 2. Its polarity toward the north and south, and its variation. 3. Its penetration through gold, glass, stone, and all other substances. 4. The communication of power from the mineral to iron, and from iron to iron, without any communication of the substances. Here, however, we only speak of the first. There is also a singular motion of attraction between quicksilver and gold, so that the gold attracts quicksilver even when made use of in ointment; and those who work surrounded by the vapors of quicksilver, are wont to hold a piece of gold in their mouths, to collect the exhalations, which would otherwise attack their heads and bones, and this piece soon grows white. Let this suffice for the motion of lesser congregation.

Attraction from a distance is rare, but it occurs in more cases than people generally notice. We see it when one bubble dissolves another, or when medicines attract bodily fluids because they are made of similar substances. We also see it when a string makes a matching string on another instrument vibrate, and in similar cases. We believe this motion is also very common in animal spirits, but we do not know this for certain. It is, however, clearly visible in magnets and magnetized iron. When discussing the motions of a magnet, we must clearly distinguish between them. A magnet has four distinct powers or effects that should not be confused. Yet people have grouped them together out of wonder and astonishment. 1. A magnet attracts another magnet or iron, and magnetized iron attracts iron. 2. A magnet points north and south, with some variation. 3. Its power passes through gold, glass, stone, and all other substances. 4. The mineral passes its power to iron, and iron passes it to other iron, without any transfer of substance. Here, however, we speak only of the first effect. There is also a remarkable attraction between mercury and gold. Gold attracts mercury even when the mercury is used in an ointment. People who work surrounded by mercury vapors often hold a piece of gold in their mouths to collect the fumes. Otherwise, the fumes would attack their heads and bones. The piece of gold soon turns white. This is enough about the motion of lesser congregation.

Question?

Let the ninth be the magnetic motion, which, although of the nature of that last mentioned, yet, when operating at great distances, and on great masses, deserves a separate inquiry, especially if it neither begin in contact, as most motions of congregation do, nor end by bringing the substances into contact, as all do, but only raise them, and make them swell without any further effect. For if the moon raise the waters, or cause moist substances to swell, or if the starry sphere attract the planets toward their apogees, or the sun confine the planets Mercury and Venus to within a certain distance of his mass; these motions do not appear capable of being classed under either of those of congregation, but to be, as it were, intermediately and imperfectly congregative, and thus to form a distinct species.

Let the ninth be magnetic motion. Although it is like the motion just described, it deserves separate study when it acts across great distances and on great masses. This is especially true if it neither begins nor ends in contact between substances. Most motions of congregation begin in contact, and all end by bringing substances into contact. Magnetic motion, however, may only raise substances and make them swell, without any further effect. The moon may raise the waters or cause moist substances to swell. Or the starry sphere may attract the planets toward their apogees. Or the sun may keep the planets Mercury and Venus within a certain distance of its mass. If so, these motions do not seem to fit under either kind of congregation. Rather, they seem to be, as it were, intermediate and imperfect forms of congregation, forming a distinct kind of motion.

Notice how this approaches Newton’s theory.

Let the tenth motion be that of avoidance, or that which is opposed to the motion of lesser congregation, by which bodies, with a kind of antipathy, avoid and disperse, and separate themselves from, or refuse to unite themselves with others of a hostile nature. For although this may sometimes appear to be an accidental motion, necessarily attendant upon that of the lesser congregation, because the homogeneous parts cannot unite, unless the heterogeneous be first removed and excluded, yet it is still to be classed separately, and considered as a distinct species, because, in many cases, the desire of avoidance appears to be more marked than that of union.

Let the tenth motion be avoidance. It is opposed to the motion of lesser congregation. Through a kind of antipathy, bodies avoid and disperse from others of a hostile nature. They separate from them or refuse to unite with them. Sometimes, avoidance may seem to be merely an incidental motion that necessarily accompanies lesser congregation. This is because parts of the same kind cannot unite unless parts of a different kind are first removed and excluded. Yet avoidance should still be classified separately and treated as a distinct kind of motion. In many cases, the desire to avoid appears stronger than the desire to unite.

Differences caused by the masses and relative distances of bodies are differences of quantity, not kind. So the three classes are really one. Ed.

It is very conspicuous in the excrements of animals, nor less, perhaps, in objects odious to particular senses, especially the smell and taste; for a fetid smell is rejected by the nose, so as to produce a sympathetic motion of expulsion at the mouth of the stomach; a bitter and rough taste is rejected by the palate or throat, so as to produce a sympathetic concussion and shivering of the head. This motion is visible also in other cases. Thus it is observed in some kinds of antiperistasis, as in the middle region of the air, the cold of which appears to be occasioned by the rejection of cold from the regions of the heavenly bodies; and also in the heat and combustion observed in subterranean spots, which appear to be owing to the rejection of heat from the centre of the earth. For heat and cold, when in small quantities, mutually destroy each other, while in larger quantities, like armies equally matched, they remove and eject each other in open conflict. It is said, also that cinnamon and other perfumes retain their odor longer when placed near privies and foul places, because they will not unite and mix with stinks. It is well known that quicksilver, which would otherwise reunite into a complete mass, is prevented from so doing by man’s spittle, pork lard, turpentine and the like, from the little affinity of its parts with those substances, so that when surrounded by them it draws itself back, and its avoidance of these intervening obstacles is greater than its desire of reuniting itself to its homogeneous parts; which is what they term the mortification of quicksilver. Again, the difference in weight of oil and water is not the only reason for their refusing to mix, but it is also owing to the little affinity of the two; for spirits of wine, which are lighter than oil, mix very well with water. A very remarkable instance of the motion in question is seen in nitre, and crude bodies of a like nature, which abhor flame, as may be observed in gunpowder, quicksilver and gold. The avoidance of one pole of the magnet by iron is not (as Gilbert has well observed), strictly speaking, an avoidance, but a conformity, or attraction to a more convenient situation.

This motion is very clear in animal excrement. Perhaps it is just as clear in things that offend particular senses, especially smell and taste. The nose rejects a foul smell, causing a sympathetic motion of expulsion at the mouth of the stomach. The palate or throat rejects a bitter, harsh taste, causing a sympathetic shaking and shivering of the head. This motion can also be seen in other cases. It is observed in some kinds of antiperistasis, for example, in the middle region of the air. The cold there appears to result from cold being driven out of the regions of the heavenly bodies. Similarly, the heat and burning found underground appear to result from heat being driven out of the earth’s center. Small amounts of heat and cold destroy each other. But in larger amounts, they drive each other away in open conflict, like equally matched armies. Cinnamon and other perfumes are also said to retain their scent longer when placed near privies and foul places. This is because they will not join and mix with stinks. It is well known that quicksilver, which would otherwise come together into a single mass, can be prevented from doing so. Human spit, pork lard, turpentine, and similar substances prevent it because its parts have little affinity with them. When surrounded by these substances, the quicksilver draws back. Its avoidance of the obstacles between its parts is greater than its desire to reunite with them. This is what is called the mortification of quicksilver. The difference in weight between oil and water is not the only reason they refuse to mix. They also have little affinity with each other. Spirits of wine, for example, are lighter than oil, yet mix very well with water. A very striking example of this motion is seen in nitre and similar crude substances, which abhor flame. This can be observed in gunpowder, quicksilver, and gold. Iron’s avoidance of one pole of a magnet is not, strictly speaking, avoidance, as Gilbert has rightly observed. It is a conforming to, or attraction toward, a more suitable position.

Let the eleventh motion be that of assimilation, or self-multiplication, or simple generation, by which latter term we do not mean the simple generation of integral bodies, such as plants or animals, but of homogeneous bodies. By this motion homogeneous bodies convert those which are allied to them, or at least well disposed and prepared, into their own substance and nature. Thus flame multiplies itself over vapors and oily substances and generates fresh flame; the air over water and watery substances multiplies itself and generates fresh air; the vegetable and animal spirit, over the thin particles of a watery or oleaginous spirit contained in its food, multiplies itself and generates fresh spirit; the solid parts of plants and animals, as the leaf, flower, the flesh, bone and the like, each of them assimilate some part of the juices contained in their food, and generate a successive and daily substance. For let none rave with Paracelsus, who (blinded by his distillations) would have it, that nutrition takes place by mere separation, and that the eye, nose, brain and liver lie concealed in bread and meat, the root, leaf and flower, in the juice of the earth; asserting that just as the artist brings out a leaf, flower, eye, nose, hand, foot and the like, from a rude mass of stone or wood by the separation and rejection of what is superfluous; so the great artist within us brings out our several limbs and parts by separation and rejection. But to leave such trifling, it is most certain that all the parts of vegetables and animals, as well the homogeneous as organic, first of all attract those juices contained in their food, which are nearly common, or at least not very different, and then assimilate and convert them into their own nature. Nor does this assimilation, or simple generation, take place in animated bodies only, but the inanimate also participate in the same property (as we have observed of flame and air), and that languid spirit, which is contained in every tangible animated substance, is perpetually working upon the coarser parts, and converting them into spirit, which afterward is exhaled, whence ensues a diminution of weight, and a desiccation of which we have spoken elsewhere.

Let the eleventh motion be assimilation, self-multiplication, or simple generation. By simple generation, I do not mean the generation of whole bodies, such as plants or animals. I mean the generation of uniform substances. Through this motion, uniform substances convert related materials into their own substance and nature. They also convert materials that are at least suitably disposed and prepared. Thus flame spreads through vapors and oily substances, multiplying itself and producing fresh flame. Air likewise multiplies itself over water and watery substances, producing fresh air. The vital spirit in plants and animals multiplies itself over the fine particles of watery or oily spirit in their food. In this way, it produces fresh spirit. The solid parts of plants and animals also assimilate some of the juices in their food. Each part, such as a leaf, flower, flesh, or bone, produces fresh substance day by day. Let no one indulge in the ravings of Paracelsus. Blinded by his distillations, he claimed that nourishment takes place through separation alone. He claimed that the eye, nose, brain, and liver lie hidden in bread and meat. Likewise, he claimed that the root, leaf, and flower lie hidden in the juices of the earth. An artist brings a leaf, flower, eye, nose, hand, foot, or similar form out of rough stone or wood. The artist does this by separating and discarding the excess material. Paracelsus claimed that, in the same way, the great artist within us brings out our various limbs and parts by separating and discarding material. But let us leave such nonsense. It is certain that all parts of plants and animals first attract the juices in their food. This applies to both uniform substances and organs. These juices are nearly the same, or at least not very different. The parts then assimilate the juices and convert them into their own nature. This assimilation, or simple generation, takes place not only in living bodies. Inanimate bodies also share this property, as we have seen with flame and air. The sluggish spirit contained in every tangible living substance constantly acts on its coarser parts, converting them into spirit. That spirit is then released, causing a loss of weight and a drying out, as we have discussed elsewhere.

See the cited examples.

Nor should we, in speaking of assimilation, neglect to mention the accretion which is usually distinguished from aliment, and which is observed when mud grows into a mass between stones, and is converted into a stony substance, and the scaly substance round the teeth is converted into one no less hard than the teeth themselves; for we are of opinion that there exists in all bodies a desire of assimilation, as well as of uniting with homogeneous masses. Each of these powers, however, is confined, although in different manners, and should be diligently investigated, because they are connected with the revival of old age. Lastly, it is worthy of observation, that in the nine preceding motions, bodies appear to aim at the mere preservation of their nature, while in this they attempt its propagation.

When discussing assimilation, we should also mention accretion, which is usually distinguished from nourishment. We see accretion when mud builds up between stones and turns into a stony substance. We also see it when the scaly substance around teeth becomes just as hard as the teeth themselves. For we believe that all bodies have a desire to assimilate other matter and to join with masses of the same kind. Both powers are limited, though in different ways. They should be carefully studied because they are connected with the renewal of old age. Finally, it is worth noting that in the nine preceding motions, bodies seem to aim only to preserve their nature. In this motion, they attempt to spread it.

Let the twelfth motion be that of excitement, which appears to be a species of the last, and is sometimes mentioned by us under that name. It is, like that, a diffusive, communicative, transitive and multiplying motion; and they agree remarkably in their effect, although they differ in their mode of action, and in their subject matter. The former proceeds imperiously and with authority; it orders and compels the assimilated to be converted and changed into the assimilating body. The latter proceeds by art, insinuation and stealth, inviting and disposing the excited toward the nature of the exciting body. The former both multiplies and transforms bodies and substances; thus a greater quantity of flame, air, spirit and flesh is formed; but in the latter, the powers only are multiplied and changed, and heat, the magnetic power, and putrefaction, in the above instances, are increased. Heat does not diffuse itself when heating other bodies by any communication of the original heat, but only by exciting the parts of the heated body to that motion which is the form of heat, and of which we spoke in the first vintage of the nature of heat. Heat, therefore, is excited much less rapidly and readily in stone or metal than in air, on account of the inaptitude and sluggishness of those bodies in acquiring that motion, so that it is probable, that there may be some substances, toward the centre of the earth, quite incapable of being heated, on account of their density, which may deprive them of the spirit by which the motion of excitement is usually commenced. Thus also the magnet creates in the iron a new disposition of its parts, and a conformable motion, without losing any of its virtue. So the leaven of bread, yeast, rennet and some poisons, excite and invite successive and continued motion in dough, beer, cheese or the human body; not so much from the power of the exciting, as the predisposition and yielding of the excited body.

Let the twelfth motion be excitement. It seems to be a kind of the last motion, and I sometimes call it by that name. Like the last motion, it spreads, communicates, passes from one thing to another, and multiplies. The two motions have remarkably similar effects, although they differ in how they act and what they act on. The former acts with command and authority. It orders and forces the body being assimilated to change into the assimilating body. The latter acts by skill, suggestion, and stealth. It invites and prepares the excited body to take on the nature of the exciting body. The former multiplies and transforms bodies and substances. In this way, a greater quantity of flame, air, spirit, or flesh is formed. But in excitement, only powers are multiplied and changed. In the examples above, heat, magnetic power, and putrefaction increase. Heat does not spread to other bodies by passing on any of the original heat. Instead, it excites the parts of the heated body into the motion that constitutes heat. I discussed this motion in the first vintage on the nature of heat. Heat is therefore excited much less quickly and readily in stone or metal than in air. This is because stone and metal are less able and slower to acquire that motion. So it is probable that some substances near the center of the earth cannot be heated at all. Their density may deprive them of the spirit by which the motion of excitement usually begins. Similarly, a magnet creates a new arrangement of the parts of iron and a corresponding motion, without losing any of its power. In the same way, bread leaven, yeast, rennet, and some poisons excite and invite successive, continuous motion in dough, beer, cheese, or the human body. This happens less because of the power of the exciting substance than because the excited body is inclined and ready to respond.

Let the thirteenth motion be that of impression, which is also a species of motion of assimilation, and the most subtile of diffusive motions. We have thought it right, however, to consider it as a distinct species, on account of its remarkable difference from the last two; for the simple motion of assimilation transforms the bodies themselves, so that if you remove the first agent, you diminish not the effect of those which succeed; thus, neither the first lighting of flame, nor the first conversion into air, are of any importance to the flame or air next generated. So, also, the motion of excitement still continues for a considerable time after the removal of the first agent, as in a heated body on the removal of the original heat, in the excited iron on the removal of the magnet, and in the dough on the removal of the leaven. But the motion of impression, although diffusive and transitive, appears, nevertheless, to depend on the first agent, so that upon the removal of the latter the former immediately fails and perishes; for which reason also it takes effect in a moment, or at least a very short space of time. We are wont to call the two former motions the motions of the generation of Jupiter, because when born they continue to exist; and the latter, the motion of the generation of Saturn, because it is immediately devoured and absorbed. It may be seen in three instances: 1, in the rays of light; 2, in the percussions of sounds; 3, in magnetic attractions as regards communication. For, on the removal of light, colors and all its other images disappear, as on the cessation of the first percussion and the vibration of the body, sound soon fails, and although sounds are agitated by the wind, like waves, yet it is to be observed, that the same sound does not last during the whole time of the reverberation. Thus, when a bell is struck, the sound appears to be continued for a considerable time, and one might easily be led into the mistake of supposing it to float and remain in the air during the whole time, which is most erroneous. For the reverberation is not one identical sound, but the repetition of sounds, which is made manifest by stopping and confining the sonorous body; thus, if a bell be stopped and held tightly, so as to be immovable, the sound fails, and there is no further reverberation, and if a musical string be touched after the first vibration, either with the finger (as in the harp), or a quill (as in the harpsichord), the sound immediately ceases. If the magnet be removed the iron falls. The moon, however, cannot be removed from the sea, nor the earth from a heavy falling body, and we can, therefore, make no experiment upon them; but the case is the same.

Let the thirteenth motion be the motion of impression. It is also a kind of motion of assimilation, and the subtlest of the diffusive motions. However, we think it right to treat it as a distinct kind because it differs remarkably from the last two. Simple motion of assimilation transforms the bodies themselves. So removing the first agent does not diminish the effect of those that follow. For example, the first lighting of a flame has no importance to the flame generated afterward. Nor does the first conversion into air matter to the air generated afterward. Likewise, the motion of excitement continues for a considerable time after the first agent is removed. We see this in a heated body after the original heat is removed, and in excited iron after the magnet is removed. We also see it in dough after the leaven is removed. But the motion of impression, though it spreads and passes from one thing to another, seems to depend on the first agent. Once that agent is removed, the motion immediately fails and dies. For this reason, it also takes effect in a moment, or at least in a very short time. We usually call the first two motions the motions of the generation of Jupiter, because once born they continue to exist. We call the last the motion of the generation of Saturn, because it is immediately devoured and absorbed. The motion of impression can be seen in three instances: 1, in rays of light, 2, in the impacts that produce sounds, and 3, in the transmission of magnetic attraction. When light is removed, colors and all its other images disappear. Similarly, when the first impact and the body's vibration stop, sound soon dies away. Although sounds are stirred by the wind like waves, the same sound does not last throughout the reverberation. For example, when a bell is struck, the sound seems to continue for a considerable time. One might easily mistake this for a single sound floating and remaining in the air throughout that time. But this is quite wrong. The reverberation is not one continuous sound but a repetition of sounds. This becomes clear if the sounding body is stopped and held still. If a bell is stopped and held tightly so that it cannot move, the sound dies away and the reverberation stops. Similarly, if a musical string is touched after its first vibration, the sound stops immediately. This can be done with a finger, as on a harp, or a quill, as on a harpsichord. If the magnet is removed, the iron falls. The moon, however, cannot be removed from the sea, nor the earth from a heavy falling body. So we can make no experiment on them, but the case is the same.

Aristotle held that sound occurs when bodies strike the air. Modern acoustics has completely established this. Yet Bacon rejected Aristotle’s doctrine in a treatise on the same subject: “The collision or thrusting of air,” he says, “which they will have to be the cause of sound, neither denotes the form nor the latent process of sound, but is a term of ignorance and of superficial contemplation.” To escape the difficulty, he turned to his theory of spirits. He constantly introduces this kind of phenomenon to appear to explain things he could not understand or would not accept under his opponents’ hypothesis. Ed.

Let the fourteenth motion be that configuration or position, by which bodies appear to desire a peculiar situation, collocation, and configuration with others, rather than union or separation. This is a very abstruse notion, and has not been well investigated; and, in some instances, appears to occur almost without any cause, although we be mistaken in supposing this to be really the case. For if it be asked, why the heavens revolve from east to west, rather than from west to east, or why they turn on poles situate near the Bears, rather than round Orion or any other part of the heaven, such a question appears to be unreasonable, since these phenomena should be received as determinate and the objects of our experience. There are, indeed, some ultimate and self-existing phenomena in nature, but those which we have just mentioned are not to be referred to that class: for we attribute them to a certain harmony and consent of the universe, which has not yet been properly observed. But if the motion of the earth from west to east be allowed, the same question may be put, for it must also revolve round certain poles, and why should they be placed where they are, rather than elsewhere? The polarity and variation of the needle come under our present head. There is also observed in both natural and artificial bodies, especially solids rather than fluids, a particular collocation and position of parts, resembling hairs or fibres, which should be diligently investigated, since, without a discovery of them, bodies cannot be conveniently controlled or wrought upon. The eddies observable in liquids by which, when compressed, they successively raise different parts of their mass before they can escape, so as to equalize the pressure, is more correctly assigned to the motion of liberty.

Let the fourteenth motion be that of configuration or position. By this motion, bodies seem to seek a particular position, arrangement, and configuration with other bodies, rather than union or separation. This is a very obscure idea and has not been well investigated. In some cases, it seems to occur almost without a cause, though we are mistaken in thinking this is really so. For example, why do the heavens revolve from east to west rather than from west to east? Why do they turn on poles near the Bears, rather than around Orion or any other part of the sky? Such questions seem unreasonable, since we should accept these motions as fixed facts of experience. Some phenomena in nature are indeed ultimate and exist on their own. But the motions just mentioned do not belong to that class. We attribute them to a certain harmony and agreement in the universe, which has not yet been properly observed. But if we accept that the earth moves from west to east, the same question may be asked. The earth too must revolve around certain poles. Why should they be placed where they are rather than elsewhere? The polarity and variation of the needle come under this heading. In both natural and artificial bodies, especially solids rather than fluids, we also observe a particular arrangement and position of parts, resembling hairs or fibers. These should be carefully investigated. Without discovering them, we cannot conveniently control or work on bodies. Eddies in liquids are more properly assigned to the motion of liberty. When liquids are compressed, the eddies successively raise different parts of the liquid until it can escape and equalize the pressure.

Let the fifteenth motion be that of transmission or of passage, by which the powers of bodies are more or less impeded or advanced by the medium, according to the nature of the bodies and their effective powers, and also according to that of the medium. For one medium is adapted to light, another to sound, another to heat and cold, another to magnetic action, and so on with regard to the other actions.

Let the fifteenth motion be transmission or passage. In this motion, a medium hinders or helps the powers of bodies to varying degrees. This depends on the nature of the bodies, their effective powers, and the nature of the medium. For one medium is suited to light, another to sound, another to heat and cold, another to magnetic action, and so on for other actions.

Let the sixteenth be that which we term the royal or political motion, by which the predominant and governing parts of any body check, subdue, reduce, and regulate the others, and force them to unite, separate, stand still, move, or assume a certain position, not from any inclination of their own, but according to a certain order, and as best suits the convenience of the governing part, so that there is a sort of dominion and civil government exercised by the ruling part over its subjects. The motion is very conspicuous in the spirits of animals, where, as long as it is in force, it tempers all the motions of the other parts. It is found in a less degree in other bodies, as we have observed in blood and urine, which are not decomposed until the spirit, which mixed and retained their parts, has been emitted or extinguished. Nor is this motion peculiar to spirits only, although in most bodies the spirit predominates, owing to its rapid motion and penetration; for the grosser parts predominate in denser bodies, which are not filled with a quick and active spirit (such as exists in quicksilver or vitriol), so that unless this check or yoke be thrown off by some contrivance, there is no hope of any transformation of such bodies. And let not any one suppose that we have forgotten our subject, because we speak of predominance in this classification of motions, which is made entirely with the view of assisting the investigation of wrestling instances, or instances of predominance. For we do not now treat of the general predominance of motions or powers, but of that of parts in whole bodies, which constitutes the particular species here considered.

Let the sixteenth be what we call royal or political motion. Through it, the dominant and governing parts of a body check, subdue, bring into order, and regulate the others. They force those parts to unite, separate, stand still, move, or take a certain position. The parts do so not from any inclination of their own, but according to an order that best serves the governing part. Thus the ruling part exercises a kind of dominion and civil government over its subjects. This motion is especially clear in the spirits of animals. As long as it remains in force, it moderates all the motions of the other parts. It is also found to a lesser degree in other bodies. We have observed it in blood and urine, which do not decompose until their spirit has escaped or been extinguished. This spirit mixed their parts and held them together. Nor is this motion found only in spirits, although the spirit predominates in most bodies because it moves and penetrates rapidly. In denser bodies, the coarser parts predominate. These bodies are not filled with a quick and active spirit, such as exists in quicksilver or vitriol. Unless some method removes this restraint or yoke, there is no hope of transforming such bodies. Let no one think we have forgotten our subject because we speak of predominance in this classification of motions. The whole purpose of the classification is to help investigate wrestling instances, or instances of predominance. For we are not dealing here with the general predominance of motions or powers. We are dealing with the predominance of parts within whole bodies, which makes up the particular kind of motion considered here.

Let the seventeenth motion be the spontaneous motion of revolution, by which bodies having a tendency to move, and placed in a favorable situation, enjoy their peculiar nature, pursuing themselves and nothing else, and seeking, as it were, to embrace themselves. For bodies seem either to move without any limit, or to tend toward a limit, arrived at which they either revolve according to their peculiar nature, or rest. Those which are favorably situated, and have a tendency to motion, move in a circle with an eternal and unlimited motion; those which are favorably situated and abhor motion, rest. Those which are not favorably situated move in a straight line (as their shortest path), in order to unite with others of a congenial nature. This motion of revolution admits of nine differences: 1, with regard to the centre about which the bodies move; 2, the poles round which they move; 3, the circumference or orbit relatively to its distance from the centre; 4, the velocity, or greater or less speed with which they revolve; 5, the direction of the motion as from east to west, or the reverse; 6, the deviation from a perfect circle, by spiral lines at a greater or less distance from the centre; 7, the deviation from the circle, by spiral lines at a greater or less distance from the poles; 8, the greater or less distance of these spirals from each other; 9, and lastly, the variation of the poles if they be movable; which, however, only affects revolution when circular. The motion in question is, according to common and long-received opinion, considered to be that of the heavenly bodies. There exists, however, with regard to this, a considerable dispute between some of the ancients as well as moderns, who have attributed a motion of revolution to the earth. A much more reasonable controversy, perhaps, exists (if it be not a matter beyond dispute), whether the motion in question (on the hypothesis of the earth’s being fixed) is confined to the heavens, or rather descends and is communicated to the air and water. The rotation of missiles, as in darts, musket-balls, and the like, we refer entirely to the motion of liberty.

Let the seventeenth motion be the spontaneous motion of revolution. By this motion, bodies inclined to move, when favorably placed, enjoy their own nature. They pursue themselves and nothing else, seeking, as it were, to embrace themselves. Bodies seem either to move without limit or to move toward a limit. Once they reach it, they either revolve according to their own nature or rest. Bodies that are favorably placed and inclined to move move in a circle, in an eternal and unlimited motion. Those that are favorably placed and resist motion rest. Those that are not favorably placed move in a straight line, the shortest path, to join others of a similar nature. This motion of revolution has nine differences: 1, the center around which bodies move; 2, the poles around which they move; 3, the distance of the circumference or orbit from the center; 4, the speed at which they revolve; 5, the direction of motion, whether from east to west or the reverse; 6, departure from a perfect circle along spiral lines at varying distances from the center; 7, departure from the circle along spiral lines at varying distances from the poles; 8, the distance between these spirals; 9, and finally, changes in the poles, if they are movable. These changes, however, affect revolution only when it is circular. According to a common and long-held opinion, this is the motion of the heavenly bodies. But some thinkers, both ancient and modern, have attributed a motion of revolution to the earth. This has been the subject of considerable dispute. A much more reasonable question, perhaps, is whether this motion is confined to the heavens. It may even be beyond dispute that the motion extends downward and is passed on to the air and water. This question assumes that the earth is fixed. I attribute the rotation of projectiles, such as darts and musket balls, entirely to the motion of liberty.

Let the eighteenth motion be that of trepidation, to which (in the sense assigned to it by astronomers) we do not give much credit; but in our serious and general search after the tendencies of natural bodies, this motion occurs, and appears worthy of forming a distinct species. It is the motion of an (as it were) eternal captivity; when bodies, for instance, being placed not altogether according to their nature, and yet not exactly ill, constantly tremble, and are restless, not contented with their position, and yet not daring to advance. Such is the motion of the heart and pulse of animals, and it must necessarily occur in all bodies which are situated in a mean state, between conveniences and inconveniences; so that being removed from their proper position, they strive to escape, are repulsed, and again continue to make the attempt.

Let the eighteenth motion be trepidation. We do not give much credit to trepidation in the sense astronomers give it. But in our serious and general search into the tendencies of natural bodies, this motion appears. It seems worthy of being a distinct kind. It is the motion of what might be called eternal captivity. Bodies may be placed in a position that is not altogether natural to them, yet not exactly wrong. They constantly tremble and are restless, dissatisfied with their position but not daring to move forward. Such is the motion of the heart and pulse in animals. It must occur in all bodies positioned between favorable and unfavorable conditions. Removed from their proper position, they strive to escape, are pushed back, and keep trying again.

Ancient astronomers attributed the motion of trepidation, as Bacon calls it, to the eight spheres in relation to the precession of the equinoxes. Galileo was the first to observe this kind of lunar motion. Ed.

Let the nineteenth and last motion be one which can scarcely be termed a motion, and yet is one; and which we may call the motion of repose, or of abhorrence of motion. It is by this motion that the earth stands by its own weight, while its extremes move toward the middle, not to an imaginary centre, but in order to unite. It is owing to the same tendency, that all bodies of considerable density abhor motion, and their only tendency is not to move, which nature they preserve, although excited and urged in a variety of ways to motion. But if they be compelled to move, yet do they always appear anxious to recover their former state, and to cease from motion, in which respect they certainly appear active, and attempt it with sufficient swiftness and rapidity, as if fatigued, and impatient of delay. We can only have a partial representation of this tendency, because with us every tangible substance is not only not condensed to the utmost, but even some spirit is added, owing to the action and concocting influence of the heavenly bodies.

Let the nineteenth and last motion be one that can scarcely be called a motion, yet is one. We may call it the motion of rest, or the aversion to motion. Through this motion, the earth remains in place by its own weight. Its outer parts move toward the middle, not toward an imaginary center, but in order to unite. Because of the same tendency, all bodies of considerable density resist motion. Their only tendency is to remain still. They retain this nature, although stirred and pushed toward motion in various ways. But if they are forced to move, they always seem eager to recover their former state and stop moving. In this respect, they certainly appear active. They try to return to rest with considerable speed and rapidity, as if tired and impatient of delay. We can see only a partial example of this tendency. For every tangible substance in our world is not only less than fully condensed, but also contains some spirit. This spirit is added through the action and transforming influence of the heavenly bodies.

We have now, therefore, exhibited the species, or simple elements of the motions, tendencies, and active powers, which are most universal in nature; and no small portion of natural science has been thus sketched out. We do not, however, deny that other instances can perhaps be added, and our divisions changed according to some more natural order of things, and also reduced to a less number; in which respect we do not allude to any abstract classification, as if one were to say, that bodies desire the preservation, exaltation, propagation, or fruition of their nature; or, that motion tends to the preservation and benefit either of the universe (as in the case of those of resistance and connection), or of extensive wholes, as in the case of those of the greater congregation, revolution, and abhorrence of motion, or of particular forms, as in the case of the others. For although such remarks be just, yet, unless they terminate in matter and construction, according to true definitions, they are speculative, and of little use. In the meantime, our classification will suffice, and be of much use in the consideration of the predominance of powers, and examining the wrestling instances which constitute our present subject.

We have now presented the kinds, or simple elements, of motions, tendencies, and active powers that are most universal in nature. In doing so, we have sketched out a substantial part of natural science. But we do not deny that other instances might be added. Our divisions might also be rearranged in a more natural order and reduced in number. By this, we do not mean an abstract classification. Such a classification might say that bodies seek to preserve, exalt, propagate, or enjoy their nature. Or it might say that motion tends to preserve and benefit either the universe, larger wholes, or particular forms. Motions of resistance and connection, for example, tend toward the benefit of the universe. Motions of greater congregation, revolution, and aversion to motion tend toward the benefit of larger wholes. The other motions tend toward the benefit of particular forms. Although such observations are valid, they are speculative and of little use unless they lead to matter and its construction, according to true definitions. For now, our classification will suffice. It will be very useful in considering which powers predominate and in examining the wrestling instances that are our present subject.

For of the motions here laid down, some are quite invincible, some more powerful than others, which they confine, check, and modify; others extend to a greater distance, others are more immediate and swift, others strengthen, increase, and accelerate the rest.

Of the motions described here, some are impossible to overcome. Some are more powerful than others, which they restrain, check, and modify. Others reach farther, while others are more immediate and swift. Still others strengthen, increase, and speed up the rest.

The motion of resistance is most adamantine and invincible. We are yet in doubt whether such be the nature of that of connection; for we cannot with certainty determine whether there be a vacuum, either extensive or intermixed with matter. Of one thing, however, we are satisfied, that the reason assigned by Leucippus and Democritus for the introduction of a vacuum (namely, that the same bodies could not otherwise comprehend, and fill greater and less spaces) is false. For there is clearly a folding of matter, by which it wraps and unwraps itself in space within certain limits, without the intervention of a vacuum. Nor is there two thousand times more of vacuum in air than in gold, as there should be on this hypothesis; a fact demonstrated by the very powerful energies of fluids (which would otherwise float like fine dust in vacuo), and many other proofs. The other motions direct, and are directed by each other, according to their strength, quantity, excitement, emission, or the assistance or impediments they meet with.

The motion of resistance is extremely strong and invincible. We are still unsure whether the motion of connection has the same nature. For we cannot determine with certainty whether a vacuum exists, either in a large space or mixed with matter. But we are satisfied of one thing. Leucippus and Democritus gave a false reason for introducing a vacuum. They argued that the same bodies could not otherwise occupy and fill larger and smaller spaces. But matter clearly folds, wrapping and unwrapping itself in space within certain limits, without a vacuum. Nor is there two thousand times more vacuum in air than in gold, as this theory would require. The great power of fluids demonstrates this. Otherwise, fluids would float like fine dust in vacuo. Many other proofs demonstrate it too. The other motions direct one another and are directed by one another. This depends on their strength, quantity, excitement, or emission, or on the help or obstacles they encounter.

For instance; some armed magnets hold and support iron of sixty times their own weight; so far does the motion of lesser congregation predominate over that of the greater; but if the weight be increased, it yields. A lever of a certain strength will raise a given weight, and so far the motion of liberty predominates over that of the greater congregation, but if the weight be greater, the former motion yields. A piece of leather stretched to a certain point does not break, and so far the motion of continuity predominates over that of tension, but if the tension be greater, the leather breaks, and the motion of continuity yields. A certain quantity of water flows through a chink, and so far the motion of greater congregation predominates over that of continuity, but if the chink be smaller it yields. If a musket be charged with ball and powdered sulphur alone, and fire be applied, the ball is not discharged, in which case the motion of greater congregation overcomes that of matter; but when gunpowder is used, the motion of matter in the sulphur predominates, being assisted by that motion, and the motion of avoidance in the nitre; and so of the rest. For wrestling instances (which show the predominance of powers, and in what manner and proportion they predominate and yield) must be searched for with active and industrious diligence.

For example, some fitted magnets hold iron weighing sixty times as much as the magnets themselves. In these cases, the motion of lesser congregation overcomes the motion of greater congregation. But if the weight increases, it yields. A lever of a certain strength can raise a given weight. In this case, the motion of liberty overcomes the motion of greater congregation. But if the weight is greater, the motion of liberty yields. A piece of leather stretched to a certain point does not break. In this case, the motion of continuity overcomes the motion of tension. But if the tension increases, the leather breaks, and the motion of continuity yields. A certain quantity of water flows through a narrow opening. In this case, the motion of greater congregation overcomes the motion of continuity. But if the opening is smaller, the motion of greater congregation yields. Suppose a musket is loaded with a ball and powdered sulphur alone, and fire is applied. The ball is not fired. In this case, the motion of greater congregation overcomes the motion of matter. But when gunpowder is used, the motion of matter in the sulphur prevails. It is assisted by that motion and by the motion of avoidance in the nitre. The same applies to other cases. We must therefore search actively and diligently for wrestling instances. These show which powers prevail, and how and to what extent they prevail or yield.

The methods and nature of this yielding must also be diligently examined, as for instance, whether the motions completely cease, or exert themselves, but are constrained. For in the bodies with which we are acquainted, there is no real but an apparent rest, either in the whole or in parts. This apparent rest is occasioned either by equilibrium, or the absolute predominance of motions. By equilibrium, as in the scales of the balance, which rest if the weights be equal. By predominance, as in perforated jars, in which the water rests, and is prevented from falling by the predominance of the motion of connection. It is, however, to be observed (as we have said before), how far the yielding motions exert themselves. For if a man be held stretched out on the ground against his will, with arms and legs bound down, or otherwise confined, and yet strive with all his power to get up, the struggle is not the less, although ineffectual. The real state of the case (namely, whether the yielding motion be, as it were, annihilated by the predominance, or there be rather a continued, although an invisible effort) will, perhaps, appear in the concurrence of motions, although it escape our notice in their conflict. For instance: let an experiment be made with muskets; whether a musket-ball, at its utmost range in a straight line, or (as it is commonly called) point-blank, strike with less force when projected upward, where the motion of the blow is simple, than when projected downward, where the motion of gravity concurs with the blow.

We must also carefully examine how this yielding happens and what it is. For example, do the motions stop completely, or do they still act but remain constrained? In the bodies we know, there is no real rest, only apparent rest, whether of the whole or its parts. This apparent rest results either from a balance of motions or from one motion completely dominating the others. Balance occurs in a pair of scales, which remain still when the weights are equal. Dominance occurs in perforated jars, where the water remains still. It is prevented from falling by the dominance of the motion of connection. As we said before, however, we must observe how far the yielding motions continue to act. Suppose a man is held stretched out on the ground against his will. His arms and legs are tied down, or he is otherwise confined. Even if he struggles with all his strength to get up, his struggle is no less real because it fails. The true state of the case may escape our notice when motions conflict. But perhaps it will become clear when motions act together. We may then see whether the dominant motion, as it were, destroys the yielding motion, or whether an invisible effort continues. For example, let an experiment be made with muskets. Does a musket ball strike with less force when fired upward to its maximum range in a straight line, commonly called point-blank, than when fired downward? When it is fired upward, the motion of the blow acts alone. When it is fired downward, the motion of gravity acts together with the blow.

The rules of such instances of predominance as occur should be collected: such as the following; the more general the desired advantage is, the stronger will be the motion; the motion of connection, for instance, which relates to the intercourse of the parts of the universe, is more powerful than that of gravity, which relates to the intercourse of dense bodies only. Again, the desire of a private good does not in general prevail against that of a public one, except where the quantities are small. Would that such were the case in civil matters!

We should collect rules for cases where one motion prevails over another. For example, the more general the benefit sought, the stronger the motion. The motion of connection concerns the interactions among all parts of the universe. It is stronger than gravity, which concerns only the interactions of dense bodies. Again, the desire for private good generally does not prevail over the desire for public good, except when the quantities are small. If only that were true in civil affairs!

XLIX

49

In the twenty-fifth rank of prerogative instances we will place suggesting instances; such as suggest, or point out, that which is advantageous to mankind; for bare power and knowledge in themselves exalt rather than enrich human nature. We must, therefore, select from the general store such things as are most useful to mankind. We shall have a better opportunity of discussing these when we treat of the application to practice; besides, in the work of interpretation, we leave room, on every subject, for the human or optative chart; for it is a part of science to make judicious inquiries and wishes.

In the twenty-fifth rank of prerogative instances, we place suggesting instances. These point out what is useful to humanity. Power and knowledge alone elevate human nature rather than enrich it. We must therefore select what is most useful to humanity from the general store of knowledge. We will have a better opportunity to discuss these things when we consider how to put knowledge into practice. Moreover, in the work of interpretation, we leave room on every subject for the human or optative chart. For making thoughtful inquiries and wishes is part of science.

L

50

In the twenty-sixth rank of prerogative instances we will place the generally useful instances. They are such as relate to various points, and frequently occur, sparing by that means considerable labor and new trials. The proper place for treating of instruments and contrivances, will be that in which we speak of the application to practice, and the methods of experiment. All that has hitherto been ascertained, and made use of, will be described in the particular history of each art. At present, we will subjoin a few general examples of the instances in question.

In the twenty-sixth rank of prerogative instances, we place generally useful instances. These apply to various matters and occur frequently, saving considerable labor and further trials. We will discuss instruments and devices when we turn to practical applications and methods of experiment. Each art’s particular history will describe all that has been discovered and put to use in it. For now, we will add a few general examples of these instances.

Man acts, then, upon natural bodies (besides merely bringing them together or removing them) by seven principal methods: 1, by the exclusion of all that impedes and disturbs; 2, by compression, extension, agitation, and the like; 3, by heat and cold; 4, by detention in a suitable place; 5, by checking or directing motion; 6, by peculiar harmonies; 7, by a seasonable and proper alternation, series, and succession of all these, or, at least, of some of them.

Besides simply bringing natural bodies together or moving them apart, people act on them in seven main ways: 1, by removing everything that obstructs or disturbs them; 2, by compressing, stretching, shaking them, and the like; 3, by heating or cooling them; 4, by keeping them in a suitable place; 5, by stopping or directing their motion; 6, by special harmonies; 7, by using all or some of these methods in a timely and proper sequence or alternation.

1. With regard to the first—common air, which is always at hand, and forces its admission, as also the rays of the heavenly bodies, create much disturbance. Whatever, therefore, tends to exclude them may well be considered as generally useful. The substance and thickness of vessels in which bodies are placed when prepared for operations may be referred to this head. So also may the accurate methods of closing vessels by consolidation, or the lutum sapientiæ, as the chemists call it. The exclusion of air by means of liquids at the extremity is also very useful, as when they pour oil on wine, or the juices of herbs, which by spreading itself upon the top like a cover, preserves them uninjured from the air. Powders, also, are serviceable, for although they contain air mixed up in them, yet they ward off the power of the mass of circumambient air, which is seen in the preservation of grapes and other fruits in sand or flour. Wax, honey, pitch, and other resinous bodies, are well used in order to make the exclusion more perfect, and to remove the air and celestial influence. We have sometimes made an experiment by placing a vessel or other bodies in quicksilver, the most dense of all substances capable of being poured round others. Grottoes and subterraneous caves are of great use in keeping off the effects of the sun, and the predatory action of air, and in the north of Germany are used for granaries. The depositing of bodies at the bottom of water may be also mentioned here; and I remember having heard of some bottles of wine being let down into a deep well in order to cool them, but left there by chance, carelessness, and forgetfulness for several years, and then taken out; by which means the wine not only escaped becoming flat or dead, but was much more excellent in flavor, arising (as it appears) from a more complete mixture of its parts. But if the case require that bodies should be sunk to the bottom of water, as in rivers or the sea, and yet should not touch the water, nor be inclosed in sealed vessels, but surrounded only by air, it would be right to use that vessel which has been sometimes employed under water above ships that have sunk, in order to enable the divers to remain below and breathe occasionally by turns. It was of the following nature: A hollow tub of metal was formed, and sunk so as to have its bottom parallel with the surface of the water; it thus carried down with it to the bottom of the sea all the air contained in the tub. It stood upon three feet (like a tripod), being of rather less height than a man, so that, when the diver was in want of breath, he could put his head into the hollow of the tub, breathe, and then continue his work. We hear that some sort of boat or vessel has now been invented, capable of carrying men some distance under water. Any bodies, however, can easily be suspended under some such vessel as we have mentioned, which has occasioned our remarks upon the experiment.

1. As for the first, ordinary air is always present and forces its way in. It causes much disturbance, as do the rays of the heavenly bodies. Anything that helps keep them out may therefore be considered generally useful. This includes the material and thickness of vessels in which substances are placed before operations. It also includes careful methods of sealing vessels by making them solid, or with lutum sapientiæ, as chemists call it. It is also very useful to seal off air with a liquid at the surface. For example, oil is poured over wine or the juices of herbs. The oil spreads over the surface like a cover and protects them from damage by the air. Powders are also useful. Although they contain air mixed in with them, they ward off the force of the surrounding air. This can be seen when grapes and other fruits are preserved in sand or flour. Wax, honey, pitch, and other resinous substances are useful for making the seal more complete. They keep out the air and the influence of the heavens. We have sometimes experimented by placing a vessel or other objects in mercury. It is the densest of all substances that can be poured around other things. Grottoes and underground caves are very useful for keeping out the sun and the destructive effects of air. In northern Germany, they are used to store grain. Placing things at the bottom of water may also be mentioned here. I remember hearing of some bottles of wine that were lowered into a deep well to cool. By chance, carelessness, and forgetfulness, they were left there for several years before being taken out. The wine had not only escaped becoming flat or lifeless, but tasted much better. This seems to have resulted from a more complete mixing of its parts. But some cases may require objects to be sunk to the bottom of a river or the sea. They must not touch the water or be enclosed in sealed vessels, but must be surrounded only by air. In such cases, it would be right to use a vessel sometimes employed underwater above sunken ships. It allows divers to stay below and take turns breathing. The vessel was made as follows: A hollow metal tub was sunk with its bottom parallel to the water's surface. It carried all the air inside it down to the sea floor. It stood on three feet, like a tripod, and was a little shorter than a man. When a diver needed air, he could put his head inside the tub, breathe, and continue working. We hear that some kind of boat or vessel has now been invented that can carry men some distance underwater. In any case, objects can easily be suspended beneath a vessel like the tub we have described. That is why we have remarked on this experiment.

Another advantage of the careful and hermetical closing of bodies is this—not only the admission of external air is prevented (of which we have treated), but the spirit of bodies also is prevented from making its escape, which is an internal operation. For any one operating on natural bodies must be certain as to their quantity, and that nothing has evaporated or escaped, since profound alterations take place in bodies, when art prevents the loss or escape of any portion, while nature prevents their annihilation. With regard to this circumstance, a false idea has prevailed (which if true would make us despair of preserving quantity without diminution), namely, that the spirit of bodies, and air when rarefied by a great degree of heat, cannot be so kept in by being inclosed in any vessel as not to escape by the small pores. Men are led into this idea by the common experiments of a cup inverted over water, with a candle or piece of lighted paper in it, by which the water is drawn up, and of those cups which, when heated, draw up the flesh. For they think that in each experiment the rarefied air escapes, and that its quantity is therefore diminished, by which means the water or flesh rises by the motion of connection. This is, however, most incorrect. For the air is not diminished in quantity, but contracted in dimensions, nor does this motion of the rising of the water begin till the flame is extinguished, or the air cooled, so that physicians place cold sponges, moistened with water, on the cups, in order to increase their attraction. There is, therefore, no reason why men should fear much from the ready escape of air: for although it be true that the most solid bodies have their pores, yet neither air, nor spirit, readily suffers itself to be rarefied to such an extreme degree; just as water will not escape by a small chink.

Carefully sealing bodies airtight has another advantage. It not only keeps outside air out, as we have discussed. It also prevents the spirit within bodies from escaping. Anyone working with natural bodies must be certain of their quantity and know that nothing has evaporated or escaped. Profound changes occur in bodies when human skill prevents any part from being lost or escaping, while nature prevents it from being destroyed. A false idea has prevailed on this point. If it were true, we would have to give up hope of preserving quantity without loss. The idea is that the spirit of bodies and air greatly expanded by heat cannot be contained in any vessel. They will supposedly escape through its tiny pores. People are led to this idea by common experiments. In one, a cup is inverted over water with a candle or a piece of burning paper inside. The water is drawn up into the cup. In another, heated cups draw up the flesh. People think that in both experiments the expanded air escapes and its quantity is therefore reduced. They believe the water or flesh then rises through the motion of connection. But this is quite wrong. The air is not reduced in quantity. It contracts in volume, and the water does not begin to rise until the flame goes out or the air cools. Indeed, doctors place cold, wet sponges on the cups to increase their suction. There is therefore no reason to fear that air will escape so readily. Even the most solid bodies do have pores. Yet neither air nor spirit readily expands to such an extreme degree. Just as water will not escape through a small crack.

Some of the air expands and escapes, and some is consumed by the flame. When the remaining air is cooled and contracts, it cannot resist the outside air strongly enough. The outside air then forces the liquid or flesh into the glass.

2. With regard to the second of the seven above-mentioned methods, we must especially observe, that compression and similar violence have a most powerful effect either in producing locomotion, and other motions of the same nature, as may be observed in engines and projectiles, or in destroying the organic body, and those qualities, which consist entirely in motion (for all life, and every description of flame and ignition are destroyed by compression, which also injures and deranges every machine); or in destroying those qualities which consist in position and a coarse difference of parts, as in colors; for the color of a flower when whole, differs from that it presents when bruised, and the same may be observed of whole and powdered amber; or in tastes, for the taste of a pear before it is ripe, and of the same pear when bruised and softened, is different, since it becomes perceptibly more sweet. But such violence is of little avail in the more noble transformations and changes of homogeneous bodies, for they do not, by such means, acquire any constantly and permanently new state, but one that is transitory, and always struggling to return to its former habit and freedom. It would not, however, be useless to make some more diligent experiments with regard to this; whether, for instance, the condensation of a perfectly homogeneous body (such as air, water, oil, and the like) or their rarefaction, when effected by violence, can become permanent, fixed, and, as it were, so changed, as to become a nature. This might at first be tried by simple perseverance, and then by means of helps and harmonies. It might readily have been attempted (if we had but thought of it), when we condensed water (as was mentioned above), by hammering and compression, until it burst out. For we ought to have left the flattened globe untouched for some days, and then to have drawn off the water, in order to try whether it would have immediately occupied the same dimensions as it did before the condensation. If it had not done so, either immediately, or soon afterward, the condensation would have appeared to have been rendered constant; if not, it would have appeared that a restitution took place, and that the condensation had been transitory. Something of the same kind might have been tried with the glass eggs; the egg should have been sealed up suddenly and firmly, after a complete exhaustion of the air, and should have been allowed to remain so for some days, and it might then have been tried whether, on opening the aperture, the air would be drawn in with a hissing noise, or whether as much water would be drawn into it when immersed, as would have been drawn into it at first, if it had not continued sealed. For it is probable (or, at least, worth making the experiment) that this might have happened, or might happen, because perseverance has a similar effect upon bodies which are a little less homogeneous. A stick bent together for some time does not rebound, which is not owing to any loss of quantity in the wood during the time, for the same would occur (after a larger time) in a plate of steel, which does not evaporate. If the experiment of simple perseverance should fail, the matter should not be given up, but other means should be employed. For it would be no small advantage, if bodies could be endued with fixed and constant natures by violence. Air could then be converted into water by condensation, with other similar effects; for man is more the master of violent motions than of any other means.

2. Regarding the second of the seven methods mentioned above, we must note one thing in particular. Compression and similar force can have very powerful effects. They can produce movement and other motions of the same kind, as we see in machines and projectiles. They can also destroy organic bodies and qualities that consist entirely in motion. For compression destroys all life and every kind of flame and ignition. It also damages and disrupts every machine. Compression can also destroy qualities that depend on the arrangement and obvious differences of parts, such as colors. A whole flower has a different color from a bruised one. The same can be observed with whole and powdered amber. The effect can also be seen in tastes. An unripe pear tastes different after it has been bruised and softened, since it becomes noticeably sweeter. But such force does little to bring about the more noble transformations and changes in homogeneous bodies. By these means, such bodies do not acquire a lasting new state. Instead, the change is temporary, and the bodies always struggle to return to their former condition and freedom. Even so, it would be useful to experiment more carefully with this question. Can the forced condensation or rarefaction of a perfectly homogeneous body become permanent and fixed? Can it be made so lasting that it becomes, as it were, part of the body's nature? Air, water, and oil are examples of such bodies. We might first try simply maintaining the change over time, and then use aids and other means that work in harmony with it. We could easily have tried this when we condensed water by hammering and compression until it burst out, as mentioned above. If only we had thought of it. We should have left the flattened globe untouched for several days and then drawn off the water. We could then have tested whether it immediately occupied the same volume as before its condensation. If it had not regained that volume immediately or soon afterward, the condensation would have appeared permanent. If it had, the water would have appeared to return to its former state, and the condensation to have been temporary. We might have tried something similar with the glass eggs. After completely removing the air from an egg, we should have sealed it quickly and firmly. We should then have left it sealed for several days. We could have tested whether air rushed in with a hiss when the opening was unsealed. Or we could have immersed the egg and tested how much water entered it. We could then have compared that amount with what would have entered at first, without the egg's having remained sealed. Such a result is probable, or at least worth testing. For maintaining a change over time has a similar effect on bodies that are somewhat less homogeneous. A stick held bent for some time does not spring back. This is not because the wood loses material during that time. The same thing would happen, after a longer time, with a steel plate, which does not evaporate. If simply maintaining the change over time fails, we should not give up. Instead, we should use other means. For it would be a considerable advantage if force could give bodies fixed and lasting natures. Air could then be converted into water by condensation, and other similar effects could be achieved. For humans have greater control over forced motions than over any other means.

3. The third of our seven methods is referred to that great practical engine of nature, as well as of art, cold and heat. Here, man’s power limps, as it were, with one leg. For we possess the heat of fire, which is infinitely more powerful and intense than that of the sun (as it reaches us), and that of animals. But we want cold, except such as we can obtain in winter, in caverns, or by surrounding objects with snow and ice, which, perhaps, may be compared in degree with the noontide heat of the sun in tropical countries, increased by the reflection of mountains and walls. For this degree of heat and cold can be borne for a short period only by animals, yet it is nothing compared with the heat of a burning furnace, or the corresponding degree of cold. Everything with us has a tendency to become rarefied, dry and wasted, and nothing to become condensed or soft, except by mixtures, and, as it were, spurious methods. Instances of cold, therefore, should be searched for most diligently, such as may be found by exposing bodies upon buildings in a hard frost, in subterraneous caverns, by surrounding bodies with snow and ice in deep places excavated for that purpose, by letting bodies down into wells, by burying bodies in quicksilver and metals, by immersing them in streams which petrify wood, by burying them in the earth (which the Chinese are reported to do with their china, masses of which, made for that purpose, are said to remain in the ground for forty or fifty years, and to be transmitted to their heirs as a sort of artificial mine) and the like. The condensations which take place in nature, by means of cold, should also be investigated, that by learning their causes, they may be introduced into the arts; such as are observed in the exudation of marble and stones, in the dew upon the panes of glass in a room toward morning after a frosty night, in the formation and the gathering of vapors under the earth into water, whence spring fountains and the like.

3. The third of our seven methods concerns cold and heat, those great practical forces in both nature and art. Here, human power limps, as if it had only one leg. We possess the heat of fire, which is infinitely stronger and more intense than the sun’s heat as it reaches us, or the heat of animals. But we lack cold, except what we can obtain in winter, in caves, or by surrounding objects with snow and ice. This cold may perhaps be compared in degree with the midday heat of the sun in tropical countries, intensified by reflection from mountains and walls. Animals can bear such heat or cold for only a short time. Yet neither compares with the heat of a burning furnace or a corresponding degree of cold. Everything in our hands tends to become less dense, dry, and wasted away. Nothing tends to become dense or soft, except through mixtures and, so to speak, artificial methods. We should therefore search most diligently for instances of cold. We may find them by exposing objects on buildings during a hard frost, or placing them in underground caves. We may also surround objects with snow and ice in deep pits dug for that purpose, or lower them into wells. Other methods include burying objects in mercury and metals, and immersing them in streams that turn wood to stone. We may also bury objects in the earth, as the Chinese are reported to do with their porcelain. Masses of porcelain made for this purpose are said to remain buried for forty or fifty years. They are then passed on to heirs as a kind of artificial mine. Similar methods may also be used. We should also investigate the condensations that cold produces in nature. By learning their causes, we may be able to use them in the arts. Examples include the moisture that forms on marble and other stones, and the dew on a room’s windowpanes toward morning after a frosty night. Another example is the formation and gathering of vapors underground into water, giving rise to springs and the like.

Heat can now be removed by a very simple process, producing almost any desired degree of cold. Ed.

It is impossible to compare a degree of heat with a degree of cold without choosing an arbitrary standard for measuring them. In the next sentence, Bacon appears to use an animal's ability to withstand heat or cold as the standard. If so, the comparison can only be between the degree of heat and the degree of cold that will cause death.

The zero point that lies equally between a given degree of heat and a given degree of cold must be arbitrary. Ed.

Besides the substances which are cold to the touch, there are others which have also the effect of cold, and condense; they appear, however, to act only upon the bodies of animals, and scarcely any further. Of these we have many instances, in medicines and plasters. Some condense the flesh and tangible parts, such as astringent and inspissating medicines, others the spirits, such as soporifics. There are two modes of condensing the spirits, by soporifics or provocatives to sleep; the one by calming the motion, the other by expelling the spirit. The violet, dried roses, lettuces, and other benign or mild remedies, by their friendly and gently cooling vapors, invite the spirits to unite, and restrain their violent and perturbed motion. Rose-water, for instance, applied to the nostrils in fainting fits, causes the resolved and relaxed spirits to recover themselves, and, as it were, cherishes them. But opiates, and the like, banish the spirits by their malignant and hostile quality. If they be applied, therefore, externally, the spirits immediately quit the part and no longer readily flow into it; but if they be taken internally, their vapor, mounting to the head, expels, in all directions, the spirits contained in the ventricles of the brain, and since these spirits retreat, but cannot escape, they consequently meet and are condensed, and are sometimes completely extinguished and suffocated; although the same opiates, when taken in moderation, by a secondary accident (the condensation which succeeds their union), strengthen the spirits, render them more robust, and check their useless and inflammatory motion, by which means they contribute not a little to the cure of diseases, and the prolongation of life.

Besides substances that feel cold, others have the effect of cold and cause condensation. However, they seem to act only on animal bodies, and hardly anything else. We find many examples among medicines and plasters. Some condense the flesh and other tangible parts, such as astringent and thickening medicines. Others condense the spirits, such as sleep-inducing medicines. These medicines condense the spirits in two ways: by calming their motion or by driving them out. Violets, dried roses, lettuce, and other mild remedies give off friendly, gently cooling vapors. These encourage the spirits to come together and restrain their violent and disturbed motion. For example, rose water applied to the nostrils during fainting fits helps the dispersed and relaxed spirits recover. It seems to nurture them. But opiates and similar substances drive out the spirits through their harmful and hostile nature. If applied externally, they cause the spirits to leave the affected part at once. The spirits then no longer flow readily into it. If taken internally, their vapor rises to the head. There it drives the spirits in the brain’s ventricles out in all directions. These spirits retreat but cannot escape, so they come together and condense. Sometimes they are completely extinguished and suffocated. Although opiates have this effect, when taken in moderation they strengthen the spirits through a secondary result. The spirits condense after coming together, making them more robust and checking their useless and inflammatory motion. In this way, opiates contribute considerably to curing diseases and prolonging life.

The preparations of bodies, also, for the reception of cold should not be omitted, such as that water a little warmed is more easily frozen than that which is quite cold, and the like.

We should also consider how substances are prepared to receive cold. For example, slightly warmed water freezes more easily than water that is already cold. Similar cases should also be considered.

Moreover, since nature supplies cold so sparingly, we must act like the apothecaries, who, when they cannot obtain any simple ingredient, take a succedaneum, or quid pro quo, as they term it, such as aloes for xylobalsamum, cassia for cinnamon. In the same manner we should look diligently about us, to ascertain whether there may be any substitutes for cold, that is to say, in what other manner condensation can be effected, which is the peculiar operation of cold. Such condensations appear hitherto to be of four kinds only. 1. By simple compression, which is of little avail toward permanent condensation, on account of the elasticity of substances, but may still, however, be of some assistance. 2. By the contraction of the coarser, after the escape or departure of the finer parts of a given body; as is exemplified in induration by fire, and the repeated heating and extinguishing of metals, and the like. 3. By the cohesion of the most solid homogeneous parts of a given body, which were previously separated, and mixed with others less solid, as in the return of sublimated mercury to its simple state, in which it occupies much less space than it did in powder, and the same may be observed of the cleansing of all metals from their dross. 4. By harmony, or the application of substances which condense by some latent power. These harmonies are as yet but rarely observed, at which we cannot be surprised, since there is little to hope for from their investigation, unless the discovery of forms and confirmation be attained. With regard to animal bodies, it is not to be questioned that there are many internal and external medicines which condense by harmony, as we have before observed, but this action is rare in inanimate bodies. Written accounts, as well as report, have certainly spoken of a tree in one of the Tercera or Canary Islands (for I do not exactly recollect which) that drips perpetually, so as to supply the inhabitants, in some degree, with water; and Paracelsus says that the herb called ros solis is filled with dew at noon, while the sun gives out its greatest heat, and all other herbs around it are dry. We treat both these accounts as fables; they would, however, if true, be of the most important service, and most worthy of examination. As to the honey-dew, resembling manna, which is found in May on the leaves of the oak, we are of opinion that it is not condensed by any harmony or peculiarity of the oak leaf, but that while it falls equally upon other leaves it is retained and continues on those of the oak, because their texture is closer, and not so porous as that of most of the other leaves.

Moreover, since nature provides so little cold, we must act like apothecaries. When they cannot obtain an ingredient, they use a substitute, or quid pro quo, as they call it. For example, they use aloes for xylobalsamum and cassia for cinnamon. In the same way, we should look carefully for substitutes for cold. That is, we should ask how else we can produce condensation, which is the particular action of cold. So far, there appear to be only four kinds of condensation. 1. By simple compression. This does little to produce permanent condensation because substances are elastic, but it may still help. 2. By the contraction of the coarser parts of a body after its finer parts have escaped or departed. Examples include hardening by fire and the repeated heating and cooling of metals. 3. By the joining of the most solid, uniform parts of a body. These parts were previously separate and mixed with less solid parts. For example, sublimated mercury can be returned to its simple state, in which it occupies much less space than it did as powder. The same can be observed when any metal is cleansed of its dross. 4. By harmony, or by applying substances that condense through some hidden power. Such harmonies have rarely been observed so far. This is not surprising, since there is little hope of learning from investigating them unless forms are discovered and confirmed. As we have observed before, many internal and external medicines undoubtedly condense animal bodies by harmony. But this action is rare in inanimate bodies. Both written accounts and reports have spoken of a tree on one of the Tercera or Canary Islands. I do not remember exactly which. The tree supposedly drips constantly, supplying the inhabitants with some water. Paracelsus also says that the herb called ros solis is full of dew at noon. At that time, the sun is at its hottest and all the herbs around it are dry. We regard both accounts as fables. If true, however, they would be extremely useful and well worth investigating. As for the honeydew, resembling manna, found on oak leaves in May, we do not think it is condensed by any harmony or special quality of the oak leaf. Rather, we think it falls equally on other leaves but remains on oak leaves because their texture is denser and less porous than that of most other leaves.

It can often be seen on the leaves of lime and other trees.

With regard to heat, man possesses abundant means and power; but his observation and inquiry are defective in some respects, and those of the greatest importance, notwithstanding the boasting of quacks. For the effects of intense heat are examined and observed, while those of a more gentle degree of heat, being of the most frequent occurrence in the paths of nature, are, on that very account, least known. We see, therefore, the furnaces, which are most esteemed, employed in increasing the spirits of bodies to a great extent, as in the strong acids, and some chemical oils; while the tangible parts are hardened, and, when the volatile part has escaped, become sometimes fixed; the homogeneous parts are separated, and the heterogeneous incorporated and agglomerated in a coarse lump; and (what is chiefly worthy of remark) the junction of compound bodies, and the more delicate conformations are destroyed and confounded. But the operation of a less violent heat should be tried and investigated, by which more delicate mixtures and regular conformations may be produced and elicited, according to the example of nature, and in imitation of the effect of the sun, which we have alluded to in the aphorism on the instances of alliance. For the works of nature are carried on in much smaller portions, and in more delicate and varied positions than those of fire, as we now employ it. But man will then appear to have really augmented his power, when the works of nature can be imitated in species, perfected in power, and varied in quantity; to which should be added the acceleration in point of time. Rust, for instance, is the result of a long process, but crocus martis is obtained immediately; and the same may be observed of natural verdigris and ceruse. Crystal is formed slowly, while glass is blown immediately: stones increase slowly, while bricks are baked immediately, etc. In the meantime (with regard to our present subject) every different species of heat should, with its peculiar effects, be diligently collected and inquired into; that of the heavenly bodies, whether their rays be direct, reflected, or refracted, or condensed by a burning-glass; that of lightning, flame, and ignited charcoal; that of fire of different materials, either open or confined, straitened or overflowing, qualified by the different forms of the furnaces, excited by the bellows, or quiescent, removed to a greater or less distance, or passing through different media; moist heats, such as the balneum Mariæ, and the dunghill; the external and internal heat of animals; dry heats, such as the heat of ashes, lime, warm sand; in short, the nature of every kind of heat, and its degrees.

When it comes to heat, humans have abundant means and power. But despite the boasts of quacks, our observation and inquiry are lacking in some respects, and these are the most important. We examine and observe the effects of intense heat. Yet we know least about the effects of gentler heat, precisely because it occurs most often in nature. We see that the most highly prized furnaces greatly increase the spirits of bodies, as in strong acids and some chemical oils. Meanwhile, their tangible parts harden and sometimes become fixed when the volatile part escapes. The similar parts are separated, while the dissimilar parts are combined and gathered into a coarse lump. Most notably, the bonds of compound bodies and their more delicate structures are destroyed and thrown into disorder. But we should test and investigate the effects of gentler heat. It may produce and bring out more delicate mixtures and orderly structures, following nature’s example and imitating the sun’s effects. We mentioned these effects in the aphorism on instances of alliance. Nature works with much smaller portions and with arrangements more delicate and varied than those produced by fire as we now use it. Humans will appear to have truly increased their power when they can imitate nature’s works in kind, perfect them in strength, and vary them in quantity. They should also be able to produce them more quickly. Rust, for example, results from a long process, but crocus martis is obtained immediately. The same can be said of natural verdigris and ceruse. Crystal forms slowly, while glass is blown immediately. Stones grow slowly, while bricks are baked immediately, and so on. Meanwhile, for our present purpose, we should carefully gather and examine every different kind of heat and its particular effects. These include the heat of the heavenly bodies, whether their rays are direct, reflected, refracted, or concentrated by a burning glass. They also include the heat of lightning, flame, and burning charcoal. We should examine the heat of fires made from different materials, whether open or confined, restricted or allowed to spread. Such heat varies with the shapes of furnaces. It may be stirred by bellows or left undisturbed, applied from different distances, or passed through different media. We should examine moist heat, such as that of the balneum Mariæ and the dung heap, as well as the external and internal heat of animals. We should also examine dry heat, such as that of ashes, lime, and warm sand. In short, we should examine the nature and degrees of every kind of heat.

We should, however, particularly attend to the investigation and discovery of the effects and operations of heat, when made to approach and retire by degrees, regularly, periodically, and by proper intervals of space and time. For this systematical inequality is in truth the daughter of heaven and mother of generation, nor can any great result be expected from a vehement, precipitate, or desultory heat. For this is not only most evident in vegetables, but in the wombs of animals also there arises a great inequality of heat, from the motion, sleep, food, and passions of the female. The same inequality prevails in those subterraneous beds where metals and fossils are perpetually forming, which renders yet more remarkable the ignorance of some of the reformed alchemists, who imagined they could attain their object by the equable heat of lamps, or the like, burning uniformly. Let this suffice concerning the operation and effects of heat; nor is it time for us to investigate them thoroughly before the forms and conformations of bodies have been further examined and brought to light. When we have determined upon our models, we may seek, apply, and arrange our instruments.

We should pay particular attention to the effects and operations of heat as it gradually increases and decreases. These changes should be regular and periodic, with suitable intervals of space and time. For this systematic variation is truly the daughter of heaven and the mother of generation. We cannot expect any great result from heat that is intense, rushed, or irregular. This is evident not only in plants but also in the wombs of animals. There, heat varies greatly with the female’s movement, sleep, food, and passions. The same variation occurs in underground beds where metals and fossils are constantly forming. This makes the ignorance of some reformed alchemists all the more remarkable. They imagined they could achieve their goal with the steady heat of lamps or similar sources burning uniformly. Let this be enough about the operation and effects of heat. It is not yet time to investigate them thoroughly. We must first examine and reveal more about the forms and structures of bodies. Once we have settled on our models, we can seek, apply, and arrange our instruments.

4. The fourth mode of action is by continuance, the very steward and almoner, as it were, of nature. We apply the term continuance to the abandonment of a body to itself for an observable time, guarded and protected in the meanwhile from all external force. For the internal motion then commences to betray and exert itself when the external and adventitious is removed. The effects of time, however, are far more delicate than those of fire. Wine, for instance, cannot be clarified by fire as it is by continuance. Nor are the ashes produced by combustion so fine as the particles dissolved or wasted by the lapse of ages. The incorporations and mixtures, which are hurried by fire, are very inferior to those obtained by continuance; and the various conformations assumed by bodies left to themselves, such as mouldiness, etc., are put a stop to by fire or a strong heat. It is not, in the meantime, unimportant to remark that there is a certain degree of violence in the motion of bodies entirely confined; for the confinement impedes the proper motion of the body. Continuance in an open vessel, therefore, is useful for separations, and in one hermetically sealed for mixtures, that in a vessel partly closed, but admitting the air, for putrefaction. But instances of the operation and effect of continuance must be collected diligently from every quarter.

4. The fourth mode of action is through time, which is, as it were, nature's steward and dispenser of gifts. By this I mean leaving a body to itself for an observable period, while protecting it from all external forces. When outside and accidental influences are removed, the body's internal motion begins to reveal and exert itself. The effects of time are far more delicate than those of fire. For example, fire cannot clarify wine as time can. Nor are the ashes produced by burning as fine as the particles dissolved or worn away over the ages. Blends and mixtures hastened by fire are much inferior to those achieved over time. Bodies left to themselves also undergo various changes, such as becoming moldy. Fire or strong heat stops these changes. It is also important to note that the motion of bodies kept entirely confined involves a certain violence. This is because confinement hinders their natural motion. Leaving a body in an open vessel over time is therefore useful for separating its parts. A hermetically sealed vessel is useful for mixing them. A partly closed vessel that admits air is useful for putrefaction. But examples of the action and effects of time must be collected diligently from every source.

5. The direction of motion (which is the fifth method of action) is of no small use. We adopt this term, when speaking of a body which, meeting with another, either arrests, repels, allows, or directs its original motion. This is the case principally in the figure and position of vessels. An upright cone, for instance, promotes the condensation of vapor in alembics, but when reversed, as in inverted vessels, it assists the refining of sugar. Sometimes a curved form, or one alternately contracted and dilated, is required. Strainers may be ranged under this head, where the opposed body opens a way for one portion of another substance and impedes the rest. Nor is this process or any other direction of motion carried on externally only, but sometimes by one body within another. Thus, pebbles are thrown into water to collect the muddy particles, and syrups are refined by the white of an egg, which glues the grosser particles together so as to facilitate their removal. Telesius, indeed, rashly and ignorantly enough attributes the formation of animals to this cause, by means of the channels and folds of the womb. He ought to have observed a similar formation of the young in eggs which have no wrinkles or inequalities. One may observe a real result of this direction of motion in casting and modelling.

5. Directing motion, the fifth method of action, is very useful. We use this term when one body meets another and stops, repels, permits, or directs its original motion. This happens chiefly through the shape and position of vessels. For example, an upright cone helps condense vapor in alembics. But a reversed cone, as in inverted vessels, helps refine sugar. Sometimes a curved shape is needed, or one that alternately narrows and widens. Strainers also belong under this heading. A strainer lets one part of a substance pass through while holding back the rest. This process, like other ways of directing motion, does not take place only on the outside. Sometimes one body acts within another. For example, pebbles are thrown into water to collect muddy particles. Syrups are refined with egg white, which glues the coarser particles together so they can be removed more easily. Telesius, however, rashly and ignorantly attributes the formation of animals to this cause. He says they are formed by the channels and folds of the womb. He should have noticed that young animals are formed in much the same way in eggs, which have no wrinkles or uneven surfaces. A genuine result of this direction of motion can be seen in casting and modeling.

6. The effects produced by harmony and aversion (which is the sixth method) are frequently buried in obscurity; for these occult and specific properties (as they are termed), the sympathies and antipathies, are for the most part but a corruption of philosophy. Nor can we form any great expectation of the discovery of the harmony which exists between natural objects, before that of their forms and simple conformations, for it is nothing more than the symmetry between these forms and conformations.

6. The effects of harmony and aversion, the sixth method, are often hard to understand. These so-called occult and specific properties, sympathies and antipathies, are mostly a corruption of philosophy. Nor can we expect to discover much about the harmony between natural objects before discovering their forms and simple structures. This harmony is nothing more than the symmetry between those forms and structures.

The greater and more universal species of harmony are not, however, so wholly obscure, and with them, therefore, we must commence. The first and principal distinction between them is this; that some bodies differ considerably in the abundance and rarity of their substance, but correspond in their conformation; others, on the contrary, correspond in the former and differ in the latter. Thus the chemists have well observed, that in their trial of first principles sulphur and mercury, as it were, pervade the universe; their reasoning about salt, however, is absurd, and merely introduced to comprise earthy dry fixed bodies. In the other two, indeed, one of the most universal species of natural harmony manifests itself. Thus there is a correspondence between sulphur, oil, greasy exhalations, flame, and, perhaps, the substance of the stars. On the other hand, there is a like correspondence between mercury, water, aqueous vapor, air, and, perhaps, pure inter-sidereal ether. Yet do these two quaternions, or great natural tribes (each within its own limits), differ immensely in quantity and density of substance, while they generally agree in conformation, as is manifest in many instances. On the other hand, the metals agree in such quantity and density (especially when compared with vegetables, etc.), but differ in many respects in conformation. Animals and vegetables, in like manner, vary in their almost infinite modes of conformation, but range within very limited degrees of quantity and density of substance.

The broadest and most universal kinds of harmony are not entirely obscure, however. We must therefore begin with them. The first and most important distinction is this: some bodies differ greatly in how much or how little substance they contain, but have similar structures. Others are similar in the first respect but differ in the second. For example, chemists have studied the first principles and rightly observed that sulphur and mercury seem to pervade the universe. Their reasoning about salt, however, is absurd. They introduced it merely to account for earthy, dry, fixed bodies. One of the most universal kinds of harmony in nature appears in the other two principles. There is a correspondence between sulphur, oil, greasy vapors, flame, and perhaps the substance of the stars. Similarly, there is a correspondence between mercury, water, water vapor, air, and perhaps the pure ether between the stars. Yet within each of these two groups, or great natural families, the members differ immensely in quantity and density of substance. They generally have similar structures, as many examples show. Metals, on the other hand, are similar in quantity and density, especially when compared with plants and similar things. But they differ in many respects in structure. Animals and plants likewise vary in their almost infinite forms, but their quantity and density of substance vary within very limited ranges.

The next most general correspondence is that between individual bodies and those which supply them by way of menstruum or support. Inquiry, therefore, must be made as to the climate, soil, and depth at which each metal is generated, and the same of gems, whether produced in rocks or mines, also as to the soil in which particular trees, shrubs, and herbs, mostly grow and, as it were, delight; and as to the best species of manure, whether dung, chalk, sea sand, or ashes, etc., and their different propriety and advantage according to the variety of soils. So also the grafting and setting of trees and plants (as regards the readiness of grafting one particular species on another) depends very much upon harmony, and it would be amusing to try an experiment I have lately heard of, in grafting forest trees (garden trees alone having hitherto been adopted), by which means the leaves and fruit are enlarged, and the trees produce more shade. The specific food of animals again should be observed, as well as that which cannot be used. Thus the carnivorous cannot be fed on herbs, for which reason the order of feuilletans, the experiment having been made, has nearly vanished; human nature being incapable of supporting their regimen, although the human will has more power over the bodily frame than that of other animals. The different kinds of putrefaction from which animals are generated should be noted.

The next most general relationship is between individual bodies and the substances that serve as their medium or support. We must therefore investigate the climate, soil, and depth in which each metal forms. We must do the same for gems, whether they form in rocks or mines. We should also examine the soil in which particular trees, shrubs, and herbs mostly grow and seem to thrive. And we should investigate the best kinds of manure, such as dung, chalk, sea sand, and ashes. Their different uses and benefits depend on the type of soil. The grafting and planting of trees and plants also depend greatly on compatibility. This is especially true of how readily one species can be grafted onto another. It would be interesting to try an experiment I recently heard about: grafting forest trees. Until now, only garden trees have been used. This method makes the leaves and fruit larger and makes the trees provide more shade. We should also observe the particular foods animals eat and those they cannot eat. Carnivorous animals, for example, cannot be fed on plants. For this reason, the order of feuilletans nearly died out after trying such a diet. Human nature cannot sustain their diet, although the human will has more power over the body than the will of other animals has over theirs. We should note the different kinds of decay from which animals are generated.

The harmony of principal bodies with those subordinate to them (such indeed may be deemed those we have alluded to above) are sufficiently manifest, to which may be added those that exist between different bodies and their objects, and, since these latter are more apparent, they may throw great light when well observed and diligently examined upon those which are more latent.

The harmony between principal bodies and those subordinate to them is clear enough. The bodies mentioned above may indeed be regarded as subordinate. We may also add the harmony between different bodies and their objects. Because these relationships are more apparent, careful observation and examination of them may shed great light on the less obvious ones.

The more internal harmony and aversion, or friendship and enmity (for superstition and folly have rendered the terms of sympathy and antipathy almost disgusting), have been either falsely assigned, or mixed with fable, or most rarely discovered from neglect. For if one were to allege that there is an enmity between the vine and the cabbage, because they will not come up well when sown together, there is a sufficient reason for it in the succulent and absorbent nature of each plant, so that the one defrauds the other. Again, if one were to say that there is a harmony and friendship between the corn and the corn-flower, or the wild poppy, because the latter seldom grow anywhere but in cultivated soils, he ought rather to say, there is an enmity between them, for the poppy and the corn-flower are produced and created by those juices which the corn has left and rejected, so that the sowing of the corn prepares the ground for their production. And there are a vast number of similar false assertions. As for fables, they must be totally exterminated. There remains, then, but a scanty supply of such species of harmony as has borne the test of experiment, such as that between the magnet and iron, gold and quicksilver, and the like. In chemical experiments on metals, however, there are some others worthy of notice, but the greatest abundance (where the whole are so few in numbers) is discovered in certain medicines, which, from their occult and specific qualities (as they are termed), affect particular limbs, humors, diseases, or constitutions. Nor should we omit the harmony between the motion and phenomena of the moon, and their effects on lower bodies, which may be brought together by an accurate and honest selection from the experiments of agriculture, navigation, and medicine, or of other sciences. By as much as these general instances, however, of more latent harmony, are rare, with so much the more diligence are they to be inquired after, through tradition, and faithful and honest reports, but without rashness and credulity, with an anxious and, as it were, hesitating degree of reliance. There remains one species of harmony which, though simple in its mode of action, is yet most valuable in its use, and must by no means be omitted, but rather diligently investigated. It is the ready or difficult coition or union of bodies in composition, or simple juxtaposition. For some bodies readily and willingly mix, and are incorporated, others tardily and perversely; thus powders mix best with water, chalk and ashes with oils, and the like. Nor are these instances of readiness and aversion to mixture to be alone collected, but others, also, of the collocation, distribution, and digestion of the parts when mingled, and the predominance after the mixture is complete.

Deeper instances of harmony and aversion, or friendship and enmity, have often been falsely identified or mixed with fables. Others have rarely been discovered because they have been neglected. Superstition and folly have made the terms sympathy and antipathy almost disgusting. Suppose someone claimed that the vine and the cabbage are enemies because they do not grow well when sown together. There is a sufficient reason for this. Both plants are succulent and absorbent, so each deprives the other of nourishment. Again, someone might claim that corn is in harmony and friendship with the cornflower or the wild poppy. The reason would be that these flowers seldom grow anywhere except in cultivated soil. But he should say instead that they are enemies. The poppy and cornflower grow from the juices that the corn has left and rejected. So sowing corn prepares the ground for their growth. There are a vast number of similar false claims. As for fables, they must be completely eliminated. That leaves only a few instances of harmony that have been tested by experiment. These include the harmony between the magnet and iron, and between gold and mercury. Experiments on metals in chemistry reveal some other instances worth noting. But most, few as they all are, are found in certain medicines. These medicines affect particular limbs, humors, diseases, or constitutions through what are called their hidden and specific qualities. Nor should we overlook the harmony between the moon's motion and phenomena and their effects on bodies below. Evidence of this harmony can be gathered by carefully and honestly selecting experiments from agriculture, navigation, medicine, and other sciences. These general instances of deeper harmony are rare. For that very reason, we must search for them all the more diligently in tradition and in faithful, honest reports. But we must avoid haste and credulity, and place our trust in them cautiously, almost hesitantly. One kind of harmony remains. Though simple in its action, it is extremely valuable in use. We must by no means overlook it, but should investigate it diligently. It concerns how readily or reluctantly bodies join or unite, whether in a compound or simply when placed together. Some bodies readily mix and become one, while others mix slowly and resist joining. For example, powders mix best with water, and chalk and ashes with oils. We should collect not only instances of readiness and resistance to mixing. We should also observe the arrangement, distribution, and settling of the parts when mixed, and which part predominates afterward.

7. Lastly, there remains the seventh, and last of the seven, modes of action; namely, that by the alternation and interchange of the other six; but of this, it will not be the right time to offer any examples, until some deeper investigation shall have taken place of each of the others. The series, or chain of this alternation, in its mode of application to separate effects, is no less powerful in its operation than difficult to be traced. But men are possessed with the most extreme impatience, both of such inquiries, and their practical application, although it be the clew of the labyrinth in all greater works. Thus far of the generally useful instances.

7. Lastly, there is the seventh and final mode of action: the alternation and interchange of the other six. But it would be premature to give examples until each of the other modes has been investigated more deeply. The chain of these alternations, as applied to particular effects, is as powerful in operation as it is difficult to trace. But people are extremely impatient with both such investigations and their practical application. Yet this process is the thread that leads through the labyrinth in all great works. That concludes the generally useful instances.

LI

51

The twenty-seventh and last place we will assign to the magical instances, a term which we apply to those where the matter or efficient agent is scanty or small, in comparison with the grandeur of the work or effect produced; so that even when common they appear miraculous, some at first sight, others even upon more attentive observation. Nature, however, of herself, supplies these but sparingly. What she will do when her whole store is thrown open, and after the discovery of forms, processes, and conformation, will appear hereafter. As far as we can yet conjecture, these magic effects are produced in three ways, either by self-multiplication, as in fire, and the poisons termed specific, and the motions transferred and multiplied from wheel to wheel; or by the excitement, or, as it were, invitation of another substance, as in the magnet, which excites innumerable needles without losing or diminishing its power; and again in leaven, and the like; or by the excess of rapidity of one species of motion over another, as has been observed in the case of gunpowder, cannon, and mines. The two former require an investigation of harmonies, the latter of a measure of motion. Whether there be any mode of changing bodies per minima (as it is termed), and transferring the delicate conformations of matter, which is of importance in all transformations of bodies, so as to enable art to effect, in a short time, that which nature works out by divers expedients, is a point of which we have as yet no indication. But, as we aspire to the extremest and highest results in that which is solid and true, so do we ever detest, and, as far as in us lies, expel all that is empty and vain.

We assign the twenty-seventh and last place to magical instances. By this term, we mean cases where the material or active agent is small compared with the great work or effect produced. Even when common, they seem miraculous, some at first sight, others even after closer examination. Nature, however, provides few such instances on her own. What she will do when her whole store is opened, and forms, processes, and structures are discovered, will become clear later. As far as we can now guess, these magical effects are produced in three ways. The first is through self-multiplication, as in fire, poisons known as specific, and motions transferred and multiplied from wheel to wheel. The second is through the stimulation, or, as it were, invitation, of another substance. A magnet, for example, stimulates countless needles without losing or diminishing its power. Leaven and similar things also work in this way. The third is through one kind of motion being much faster than another, as observed in gunpowder, cannons, and mines. The first two require an investigation of harmonies, and the third requires a measure of motion. Is there any way to change bodies per minima, as it is called, and transfer the delicate structures of matter? This is important in all transformations of bodies. Such a method would allow art to do quickly what nature accomplishes by various means. But we have as yet no indication that such a method exists. We aspire to the utmost and highest results in what is solid and true. But we always detest all that is empty and vain, and drive it out as far as we can.

LII

52

Let this suffice as to the respective dignity of prerogatives of instances. But it must be noted, that in this our organ, we treat of logic, and not of philosophy. Seeing, however, that our logic instructs and informs the understanding, in order that it may not, with the small hooks, as it were, of the mind, catch at, and grasp mere abstractions, but rather actually penetrate nature, and discover the properties and effects of bodies, and the determinate laws of their substance (so that this science of ours springs from the nature of things, as well as from that of the mind); it is not to be wondered at, if it have been continually interspersed and illustrated with natural observations and experiments, as instances of our method. The prerogative instances are, as appears from what has preceded, twenty-seven in number, and are termed, solitary instances, migrating instances, conspicuous instances, clandestine instances, constitutive instances, similar instances, singular instances, deviating instances, bordering instances, instances of power, accompanying and hostile instances, subjunctive instances, instances of alliance, instances of the cross, instances of divorce, instances of the gate, citing instances, instances of the road, supplementary instances, lancing instances, instances of the rod, instances of the course, doses of nature, wrestling instances, suggesting instances, generally useful instances, and magical instances. The advantage, by which these instances excel the more ordinary, regards specifically either theory or practice, or both. With regard to theory, they assist either the senses or the understanding; the senses, as in the five instances of the lamp; the understanding, either by expediting the exclusive mode of arriving at the form, as in solitary instances, or by confining, and more immediately indicating the affirmative, as in the migrating, conspicuous, accompanying, and subjunctive instances; or by elevating the understanding, and leading it to general and common natures, and that either immediately, as in the clandestine and singular instances, and those of alliance; or very nearly so, as in the constitutive; or still less so, as in the similar instances; or by correcting the understanding of its habits, as in the deviating instances; or by leading to the grand form or fabric of the universe, as in the bordering instances; or by guarding it from false forms and causes, as in those of the cross and of divorce. With regard to practice, they either point it out, or measure, or elevate it. They point it out, either by showing where we must commence in order not to repeat the labors of others, as in the instances of power; or by inducing us to aspire to that which may be possible, as in the suggesting instances; the four mathematical instances measure it. The generally useful and the magical elevate it.

Let this suffice on the relative importance of the prerogative instances. But it is important to note that this work deals with logic, not philosophy. Our logic, however, trains and informs the understanding. Its purpose is to prevent the mind from catching and grasping mere abstractions with its little hooks, as it were. Instead, it should actually penetrate nature and discover the properties and effects of bodies and the definite laws of their substance. Our science therefore springs from the nature of things as well as from the nature of the mind. So it is no wonder that natural observations and experiments have appeared throughout, illustrating our method. As we have seen, there are twenty-seven prerogative instances. They are called solitary instances, migrating instances, conspicuous instances, clandestine instances, constitutive instances, similar instances, singular instances, deviating instances, bordering instances, instances of power, accompanying and hostile instances, subjunctive instances, instances of alliance, instances of the cross, instances of divorce, instances of the gate, citing instances, instances of the road, supplementary instances, lancing instances, instances of the rod, instances of the course, doses of nature, wrestling instances, suggesting instances, generally useful instances, and magical instances. These instances are more useful than ordinary ones for theory, practice, or both. For theory, they help either the senses or the understanding. They help the senses in the five instances of the lamp. They help the understanding in several ways. Solitary instances speed up the process of arriving at the form by exclusion. Migrating, conspicuous, accompanying, and subjunctive instances narrow the search and point more directly to an affirmative answer. Other instances raise the understanding and lead it toward general and common natures. Clandestine and singular instances and instances of alliance do this directly. Constitutive instances do so almost directly, and similar instances less directly. Deviating instances correct the habits of the understanding. Bordering instances lead it toward the grand form or fabric of the universe. Instances of the cross and of divorce guard it against false forms and causes. For practice, these instances point the way, measure what can be done, or raise practice to a higher level. Instances of power show where we must begin, so that we do not repeat the work of others. Suggesting instances encourage us to aim for what may be possible. The four mathematical instances measure what can be done. Generally useful and magical instances raise practice to a higher level.

Again, out of these twenty-seven instances, some must be collected immediately, without waiting for a particular investigation of properties. Such are the similar, singular, deviating, and bordering instances, those of power, and of the gate, and suggesting, generally useful, and magical instances; for these either assist and cure the understanding and senses, or furnish our general practice. The remainder are to be collected when we finish our synoptical tables for the work of the interpreter, upon any particular nature; for these instances, honored and gifted with such prerogatives, are like the soul amid the vulgar crowd of instances, and (as we from the first observed) a few of them are worth a multitude of the others. When, therefore, we are forming our tables they must be searched out with the greatest zeal, and placed in the table. And, since mention must be made of them in what follows, a treatise upon their nature has necessarily been prefixed. We must next, however, proceed to the supports and corrections of induction, and thence to concretes, the latent process, and latent conformations, and the other matters, which we have enumerated in their order in the twenty-first aphorism, in order that, like good and faithful guardians, we may yield up their fortune to mankind upon the emancipation and majority of their understanding; from which must necessarily follow an improvement of their estate, and an increase of their power over nature. For man, by the fall, lost at once his state of innocence, and his empire over creation, both of which can be partially recovered even in this life, the first by religion and faith, the second by the arts and sciences. For creation did not become entirely and utterly rebellious by the curse, but in consequence of the Divine decree, “in the sweat of thy brow shalt thou eat bread,” she is compelled by our labors (not assuredly by our disputes or magical ceremonies), at length, to afford mankind in some degree his bread, that is to say, to supply man’s daily wants.

Again, some of these twenty-seven instances must be collected immediately, without waiting to investigate any particular property. These are the similar, singular, deviating, and bordering instances, instances of power and of the gate, and suggesting, generally useful, and magical instances. These either help and correct our understanding and senses, or provide for our practice in general. The rest should be collected when we complete our synoptic tables for interpreting any particular nature. These instances, honored and endowed with such privileges, are like the soul among the ordinary crowd of instances. As we observed at the beginning, a few of them are worth a multitude of the others. Therefore, when forming our tables, we must search for them with the greatest zeal and include them. Since we must mention them in what follows, an account of their nature had to come first. Next, however, we must turn to the supports and corrections of induction. From there, we must proceed to concrete things, the hidden process, hidden structures, and the other matters listed in order in the twenty-first aphorism. In this way, like good and faithful guardians, we may hand mankind its inheritance when its understanding is freed and comes of age. This must necessarily improve mankind’s condition and increase its power over nature. For man, through the fall, lost both his innocence and his rule over creation. Both can be partly recovered even in this life, innocence through religion and faith, and rule through the arts and sciences. For the curse did not make creation entirely rebellious. Instead, by the Divine decree, “in the sweat of thy brow shalt thou eat bread,” creation is compelled to provide mankind, in some degree, with bread. It does so through our labors, certainly not through our disputes or magical ceremonies. By bread, I mean what supplies man’s daily needs.

The end