Tolerance as a Companion
The Companionship of Tolerance
The Companionship of Tolerance
Intolerance is part of the unnecessary friction of life. It is prejudice on the war-path. Intolerance acknowledges only one side of any question,—its own. It is the assumption of a monopoly in thinking, the attitude of the man who believes he has a corner on wisdom and truth, in some phase of life.
Intolerance is part of life's unnecessary friction. It is prejudice on the attack. Intolerance recognizes only one side of any question: its own. It assumes a monopoly on thinking. It is the attitude of someone who believes they alone possess wisdom and truth in some area of life.
Tolerance is a calm, generous respect for the opinions of others, even of one's enemies. It recognizes the right of every man to think his own thoughts, to live his own life, to be himself in all things, so long as he does not run counter to the rights of others. It means giving to others the same freedom that we ourselves crave. Tolerance is silent justice, blended with sympathy. If he who is tolerant desires to show to others the truth as he sees it, he seeks with gentleness and deference to point out the way in which he has found peace, and certainty, and rest; he tries to raise them to the recognition of higher ideals, as he has found them inspiring; he endeavors in a spirit of love and comradeship with humanity to lead others rather than to drive them, to persuade and convince rather than to overawe and eclipse.
Tolerance is a calm, generous respect for the opinions of others, even our enemies. It recognizes everyone’s right to think their own thoughts, live their own life, and be themselves in all things. This right holds as long as they do not violate the rights of others. Tolerance means giving others the same freedom we want for ourselves. It is quiet justice, blended with sympathy. A tolerant person may want to show others the truth as they see it. If so, they gently and respectfully point out the way they have found peace, certainty, and rest. They try to help others recognize the higher ideals they have found inspiring. In a spirit of love and fellowship with humanity, they try to lead others rather than drive them. They seek to persuade and convince rather than intimidate and overshadow.
Tolerance does not use the battering-ram of argument or the club of sarcasm, or the rapier of ridicule, in discussing the weakness or wrongs of individuals. It may lash or scourge the evil of an age, but it is kind and tender with the individual; it may flay the sin, but not the sinner. Tolerance makes the individual regard truth as higher than personal opinion; it teaches him to live with the windows of his life open towards the east to catch the first rays of the sunlight of truth no matter from whom it comes, and to realize that the faith that he so harshly condemns may have the truth he desires if he would only look into it and test it before he repudiates it so cavalierly.
Tolerance does not use the battering ram of argument, the club of sarcasm, or the sword of ridicule when discussing a person’s weaknesses or wrongs. It may lash out against the evil of an age, but it is kind and gentle with the individual. It may attack the sin, but not the sinner. Tolerance leads people to value truth above personal opinion. It teaches them to live with the windows of their lives open to the east, ready to catch the first rays of truth, no matter who brings them. It also teaches them that a faith they harshly condemn may contain the truth they seek. They need only examine and test that faith before rejecting it so casually.
This world of ours is growing better, more tolerant and liberal. The days when difference in political opinions was solved and cured by the axe and the block; when a man's courage to stand by his religion meant facing the horrors of the Inquisition or the cruelty of the stake, when daring to think their own thoughts on questions of science brought noble men to a pallet of straw and a dungeon cell,—these days have, happily, passed away. Intolerance and its twin brother, Ignorance, weaken and die when the pure white light of wisdom is thrown upon them. Knowledge is the death-knell of intolerance—not mere book-learning, nor education in schools or colleges, nor accumulation of mere statistics, nor shreds of information, but the large sympathetic study of the lives, manners, customs, aims, thoughts, struggles, progress, motives and ideals of other ages, other nations, other individuals.
Our world is growing better, more tolerant, and more open-minded. In the past, differences of political opinion were settled with the axe and the executioner’s block. A man who dared to stand by his religion faced the horrors of the Inquisition or the cruelty of burning at the stake. Noble men who dared to think for themselves about science were sent to dungeon cells to sleep on beds of straw. Happily, those days are gone. Intolerance and its twin brother, Ignorance, weaken and die when the pure white light of wisdom shines on them. Knowledge is the death of intolerance. This knowledge is not just book-learning, schooling, or the collection of statistics and scraps of information. It is a broad, sympathetic study of the lives, manners, customs, aims, thoughts, struggles, progress, motives, and ideals of other ages, other nations, and other individuals.
Tolerance unites men in the closer bonds of human brotherhood, brings them together in unity and sympathy in essentials and gives them greater liberality and freedom in non-essentials. Napoleon when First Consul said, "Let there be no more Jacobins, nor Moderates, nor Royalists: let all be Frenchmen." Sectionalism and sectarianism always mean concentration on the body of a part at the expense of the soul of the whole. The religious world to-day needs more Christ and less sects in its gospel. When Christ lived on earth Christianity was a unit; when he died sects began.
Tolerance brings people closer together in human brotherhood. It unites them in agreement and sympathy on essential matters. It also gives them greater openness and freedom in matters that are not essential. When Napoleon was First Consul, he said, "Let there be no more Jacobins, Moderates, or Royalists. Let all be Frenchmen." Sectionalism and sectarianism always focus on the body of one part at the expense of the soul of the whole. The religious world today needs more Christ and fewer sects in its gospel. When Christ lived on earth, Christianity was united. When he died, sects began.
There are in America to-day, hundreds of small towns, scattered over the face of the land, that are over-supplied with churches. In many of these towns, just emerging from the short dresses of village-hood, there are a dozen or more weak churches, struggling to keep their organization alive. Between these churches there is often only a slight difference in creed, the tissue-paper wall of some technicality of belief. Half-starved, dragging out a mere existence, trying to fight a large mortgage with a small congregation and a small contribution box, there is little spiritual fervor. By combination, by coöperation, by tolerance, by the mutual surrender of non-essentials and a strong, vital concentration and unity on the great fundamental realities of Christianity, their spiritual health and possibilities could be marvellously increased. Three or four sturdy, live, growing churches would then take the place of a dozen strugglers. Why have a dozen weak bridges across a stream, if greater good can come from three or four stronger ones, or even a single strongest bridge? The world needs a great religious trust which will unite the churches into a single body of faith, to precede and prepare the way for the greater religious trust, predicted in Holy Writ,—the millennium.
Today, hundreds of small towns across America have too many churches. Many of these towns are just beginning to outgrow their village days. Yet they have a dozen or more weak churches, struggling to keep their organizations alive. Often, their beliefs differ only slightly. A thin wall of some technical point of belief separates them. These churches are barely surviving. They try to pay off large mortgages with small congregations and small collections. There is little spiritual fervor. But they could greatly improve their spiritual health and possibilities by joining forces, cooperating, and showing tolerance. They could give up their differences on minor points and unite around the great fundamental realities of Christianity. Three or four strong, lively, growing churches would then replace a dozen struggling ones. Why have a dozen weak bridges across a stream if three or four stronger ones would do more good? Or even a single, strongest bridge? The world needs a great religious trust to unite the churches into a single body of faith. This would prepare the way for the greater religious trust predicted in Holy Writ, the millennium.
We can ever be loyal to our own belief, faithful to our own cause, without condemning those who give their fidelity in accord with their own conscience or desires. The great reformers of the world, men who are honestly and earnestly seeking to solve the great social problems and to provide means for meeting human sin and wrong, agreeing perfectly in their estimate of the gravity and awfulness of the situation, often propose diametrically opposite methods. They are regarding the subject from different points of view, and it would be intolerance for us, who are looking on, to condemn the men on either side merely because we cannot accept their verdict as our own.
We can always remain loyal to our beliefs and faithful to our cause without condemning others. They, too, give their loyalty according to their own conscience or desires. The world’s great reformers honestly and earnestly seek to solve major social problems and find ways to address human sin and wrongdoing. They agree completely about how serious and terrible the situation is, yet they often propose completely opposite methods. They see the subject from different points of view. As observers, we would be intolerant to condemn either side merely because we cannot accept its conclusions as our own.
On the great national questions brought before statesmen for their decision, men equally able, equally sincere, just and unselfish, differ in their remedies. One, as a surgeon, suggests cutting away the offending matter, the use of the knife,—this typifies the sword, or war. Another, as a doctor, urges medicine that will absorb and cure,—this is the prescription of the diplomat. The third suggests waiting for developments, leaving the case with time and nature,—this is the conservative. But all three classes agree as to the evil and the need of meeting it.
On great national questions, equally capable, sincere, fair, and unselfish statesmen disagree about how to solve them. One acts like a surgeon and suggests cutting away the problem. The surgeon's knife represents the sword, or war. Another acts like a doctor and recommends medicine that will absorb and cure the problem. This is the diplomat's prescription. A third suggests waiting to see what happens and leaving the case to time and nature. This is the conservative's approach. But all three groups agree that the problem exists and must be addressed.
The conflict of authorities on every great question to be settled by human judgment should make us tolerant of the opinion of others, though we may be as confident of the rightness of the judgment we have formed as if it were foreordained from the day of the creation. But if we receive any new light that makes us see clearer, let us change at once without that foolish consistency of some natures that continue to use last year's almanac as a guide to this year's eclipses. Tolerance is ever progressive.
Experts disagree on every great question that human judgment must settle. Their disagreements should make us tolerant of others’ opinions. This is true even if we are certain our own judgment is right, as if it were destined from creation. But if new information helps us see more clearly, let us change our minds at once. We should not cling foolishly to consistency, as some people do. That is like using last year’s almanac to predict this year’s eclipses. Tolerance is always progressive.
Intolerance believes it is born with the peculiar talent for managing the affairs of others, without any knowledge of the details, better than the men themselves, who are giving their life's thought to the vital questions. Intolerance is the voice of the Pharisee still crying through the ages and proclaiming his infallibility.
Intolerance believes it has an inborn talent for managing other people’s affairs without knowing any of the details. It believes it can manage them better than the people who devote their lives to these vital questions. Intolerance is the voice of the Pharisee, still crying out through the ages and declaring that he cannot be wrong.
Let us not seek to fit the whole world with shoes from our individual last. If we think that all music ceased to be written when Wagner laid down the pen, let us not condemn those who find enjoyment in light opera. Perhaps they may sometime rise to our heights of artistic appreciation and learn the proper parts to applaud. If their lighter music satisfies their souls, is our Wagner doing more for us? It is not fair to take from a child its rag doll in order to raise it to the appreciation of the Venus de Milo. The rag doll is its Venus; it may require a long series of increasingly better dolls to lead it to realize the beauties of the marble woman of Melos.
Let us not try to make the whole world fit shoes made on our own mold. Suppose we think no music has been written since Wagner laid down his pen. Let us not condemn those who enjoy light opera. Perhaps someday they may rise to our heights of artistic appreciation and learn the right parts to applaud. If their lighter music satisfies their souls, is our Wagner doing more for us? It is not fair to take a child’s rag doll away to teach the child to appreciate the Venus de Milo. The rag doll is the child’s Venus. It may take a long series of increasingly better dolls to lead the child to appreciate the beauty of the marble woman of Melos.
Intolerance makes its great mistakes in measuring the needs of others from its own standpoint. Intolerance ignores the personal equation in life. What would be an excellent book for a man of forty might be worse than useless for a boy of thirteen. The line of activity in life that we would choose as our highest dream of bliss, as our Paradise, might, if forced on another, be to him worse than the after-death fate of the wicked, according to the old-fashioned theologians. What would be a very acceptable breakfast for a sparrow would be a very poor meal for an elephant.
Intolerance makes serious mistakes by judging other people’s needs from its own point of view. It ignores individual differences. A book that is excellent for a forty-year-old man might be worse than useless for a thirteen-year-old boy. The life we dream of as perfect happiness, our own paradise, might be forced on someone else. For that person, it might be worse than the fate of the wicked after death, as old-fashioned theologians described it. A good breakfast for a sparrow would be a very poor meal for an elephant.
When we sit in solemn judgment of the acts and characters of those around us and condemn them with the easy nonchalance of our ignorance, yet with the assumption of omniscience we reveal our intolerance. Tolerance ever leads us to recognize and respect the differences in the natures of those who are near to us, to make allowance for differences in training, in opportunities, in ideals, in motives, in tastes, in opinions, in temperaments and in feelings. Intolerance seeks to live other people's lives for them; sympathy helps us to live their lives with them. We must accept humanity with all its weakness, sin and folly and seek to make the best of it, just as humanity must accept us. We learn this lesson as we grow older, and, with the increase of our knowledge of the world, we see how much happier life would have been for us and for others if we had been more tolerant, more charitable, more generous.
When we judge the actions and characters of those around us, we reveal our intolerance. We casually condemn them out of ignorance, yet act as if we know everything. Tolerance always leads us to recognize and respect differences in the nature of those close to us. It makes allowances for differences in upbringing, opportunities, ideals, motives, tastes, opinions, temperaments, and feelings. Intolerance tries to live other people's lives for them. Sympathy helps us live their lives with them. We must accept humanity with all its weakness, sin, and folly and try to make the best of it, just as humanity must accept us. We learn this lesson as we grow older and learn more about the world. We see how much happier life would have been for us and others if we had been more tolerant, more charitable, and more generous.
No one in the world is absolutely perfect; if he were he would probably be translated from earth to heaven, as was Elijah of old, without waiting for the sprouting of wings or the passport of death. It is a hard lesson for youth to learn, but we must realize, as the old college professor said to his class of students, bowed with the consciousness of their wisdom: "No one of us is infallible, no, not even the youngest." Let us accept the little failings of those around us as we accept facts in nature, and make the best of them, as we accept the hard shells of nuts, the skin of fruits, the shadow that always accompanies light. These are not absolute faults, they are often but individual peculiarities. Intolerance sees the mote in its neighbor's eye as larger than the beam in its own.
No one in the world is absolutely perfect. If anyone were, they would probably be taken from earth to heaven, as Elijah was long ago. They would not have to wait to grow wings or receive the passport of death. This is a hard lesson for young people to learn. But we must realize what an old college professor told his students, who were weighed down by their own wisdom: "None of us is infallible, not even the youngest." Let us accept the small failings of those around us as we accept facts of nature, and make the best of them. We accept the hard shells of nuts, the skins of fruit, and the shadow that always accompanies light. These are not absolute faults. Often, they are simply individual peculiarities. Intolerance sees the speck in a neighbor's eye as larger than the beam in its own.
Instead of concentrating our thought on the one weak spot in a character, let us seek to find some good quality that offsets it, just as a credit may more than cancel a debt on a ledger account. Let us not constantly speak of roses having thorns, let us be thankful that the thorns have roses. In Nature there are both thorns and prickles; thorns are organic, they have their root deep in the fibre and the being of the twig; prickles are superficial, they are lightly held in the cuticle or covering of the twig. There are thorns in character that reveal an internal inharmony, that can be controlled only from within; there are also prickles, which are merely peculiarities of temperament, that the eye of tolerance may overlook and the finger of charity can gently remove.
Instead of focusing on one weakness in a person's character, let us look for a good quality that offsets it. Just as a credit on a ledger may more than cancel a debt, a good quality may outweigh a weakness. Let us not keep saying that roses have thorns. Let us be thankful that thorns have roses. In nature, there are both thorns and prickles. Thorns are part of the plant itself, rooted deep in the fibers and structure of the twig. Prickles are superficial, held loosely in the twig's outer covering. Some flaws in character are like thorns. They reveal an inner conflict that can be controlled only from within. Other flaws are like prickles, merely quirks of temperament. The eye of tolerance can overlook them, and the finger of kindness can gently remove them.
The tenderness of tolerance will illuminate and glorify the world,—as moonlight makes all things beautiful,—if we only permit it. Measuring a man by his weakness alone is unjust. This little frailty may be but a small mortgage on a large estate, and it is narrow and petty to judge by the mortgage on a character. Let us consider the "equity," the excess of the real value over the claim against it.
The gentleness of tolerance will light up and glorify the world, just as moonlight makes everything beautiful, if we let it. It is unfair to judge a person by their weakness alone. That small weakness may be like a small mortgage on a large estate. It is narrow-minded and petty to judge a person by the mortgage on their character. Let us consider the "equity," the amount by which its true value exceeds the debt against it.
Unless we sympathetically seek to discover the motive behind the act, to see the circumstances that inspired a course of living, the target at which a man is aiming, our snap condemnations are but arrogant and egotistic expressions of our intolerance. All things must be studied relatively instead of absolutely. The hour hand on a clock does just as valuable work as the minute hand, even though it is shorter and seems to do only one-twelfth as much.
We must try to understand the motive behind an act, the circumstances that shaped a person's life, and their goals. Unless we do so with sympathy, our snap judgments are merely arrogant, self-centered expressions of intolerance. We must judge all things in relation to other things, not by absolute standards. The hour hand on a clock does work just as valuable as the minute hand. It does so even though it is shorter and seems to do only one-twelfth as much.
Intolerance in the home circle shows itself in overdiscipline, in an atmosphere of severity heavy with prohibitions. The home becomes a place strewn with "Please keep off the grass" signs. It means the suppression of individuality, the breaking of the wills of children, instead of their development and direction. It is the foolish attempt to mould them from the outside, as a potter does clay; the higher conception is the wise training that helps the child to help himself in his own growth. Parents often forget their own youth; they do not sympathize with their children in their need of pleasure, of dress, of companionship. There should be a few absolutely firm rules on essentials, the basic principles of living, with the largest possible leeway for the varying manifestations of individuality in unimportant phases. Confidence, sympathy, love and trust would generate a spirit of tolerance and sweetness that would work marvels. Intolerance converts live, natural children into prigs of counterfeit virtue and irritatingly good automatons of obedience.
Intolerance in the home shows itself in excessive discipline and a harsh atmosphere full of prohibitions. The home becomes a place littered with "Please keep off the grass" signs. Instead of developing and guiding children, it suppresses their individuality and breaks their wills. It is a foolish attempt to shape children from the outside, as a potter shapes clay. A better approach is to guide children wisely, helping them take charge of their own growth. Parents often forget their own youth. They do not understand their children’s need for fun, clothes, and companionship. There should be a few absolutely firm rules about essentials, the basic principles of living. But children should have as much freedom as possible to express their individuality in unimportant matters. Confidence, sympathy, love, and trust would create a spirit of tolerance and kindness that would work wonders. Intolerance turns lively, natural children into self-righteous little people with fake virtue and irritatingly obedient automatons.
Tolerance is a state of mutual concessions. In the family life there should be this constant reciprocity of independence, this mutual forbearance. It is the instinctive recognition of the sacredness of individuality, the right of each to live his own life as best he can. When we set ourselves up as dictators to tyrannize over the thoughts, words and acts of others, we are sacrificing the kingly power of influence with which we may help others, for the petty triumph of tyranny which repels and loses them.
Tolerance means making mutual concessions. In family life, everyone should respect each other's independence and be patient with one another. This means recognizing instinctively that each person's individuality is sacred. Each has the right to live their own life as best they can. When we act as dictators over others' thoughts, words, and actions, we sacrifice our noble power to influence them. We could use that power to help them. Instead, we choose the petty triumph of tyranny, which drives them away and loses them to us.
Perhaps one reason why the sons of great and good men so often go astray is that the earnestness, strength and virtue of the father, exacting strict obedience to the letter of the law, kills the appreciation of the spirit of it, breeding an intolerance that forces submission under which the fire of protest and rebellion is smouldering, ready to burst into flame at the first breath of freedom. Between brother and sister, husband and wife, parent and child, master and servant, the spirit of tolerance, of "making allowances," transforms a house of gloom and harshness into a home of sweetness and love.
Perhaps one reason the sons of great and good men so often go astray is their fathers' strictness. A father's earnestness, strength, and virtue may lead him to demand strict obedience to the letter of the law. This can destroy his son's appreciation of the spirit of the law. It can also breed an intolerance that forces the son to submit. Beneath that submission, protest and rebellion smolder, ready to burst into flames at the first breath of freedom. Between brother and sister, husband and wife, parent and child, master and servant, tolerance and "making allowances" can transform a gloomy, harsh house into a home filled with warmth and love.
In the sacred relation of parent to child there always comes a time when the boy becomes a man, when she whom the father still regards but as a little girl faces the great problems of life as an individual. The coming of years of discretion brings a day when the parents must surrender their powers of trusteeship, when the individual enters upon his heritage of freedom and responsibility. Parents have still the right and privilege of counsel and of helpful, loving insight their children should respect. But in meeting a great question, when the son or daughter stands before a problem that means happiness or misery for a lifetime, it must be for him or for her to decide. Coercion, bribery, undue influence, threats of disinheritance, and the other familiar weapons, are cruel, selfish, arrogant and unjust. A child is a human being, free to make his own life, not a slave. There is a clearly marked dead-line that it is intolerance to cross.
In the sacred relationship between parent and child, there always comes a time when the boy becomes a man. The girl her father still sees as little faces life’s great problems as an individual. When children are old enough to make their own decisions, parents must give up their authority as guardians. The children then take up their rightful freedom and responsibility. Parents still have the right and privilege to offer advice and loving, helpful insight. Their children should respect that advice and insight. But a son or daughter may face a great question that means a lifetime of happiness or misery. The decision must be theirs to make. Coercion, bribery, undue influence, threats of disinheritance, and the other familiar weapons are cruel, selfish, arrogant, and unjust. A child is a human being, free to make a life of their own, not a slave. There is a clear boundary that it is intolerant to cross.
Let us realize that tolerance is ever broadening; it develops sympathy, weakens worry and inspires calmness. It is but charity and optimism, it is Christianity as a living eternal fact, not a mere theory. Let us be tolerant of the weakness of others, sternly intolerant of our own. Let us seek to forgive and forget the faults of others, losing sight, to a degree, of what they are in the thought of what they may become. Let us fill their souls with the inspiring revelation of their possibilities in the majestic evolution march of humanity. Let us see, for ourselves and for them, in the acorn of their present the towering oak of their future.
Let us recognize that tolerance always broadens our outlook. It develops sympathy, reduces worry, and inspires calm. It is simply charity and optimism. It is Christianity as a living, eternal fact, not just a theory. Let us be tolerant of others' weaknesses, but strictly intolerant of our own. Let us try to forgive and forget others' faults. Let us focus less on what they are and more on what they may become. Let us inspire them to see their possibilities in humanity's majestic march of evolution. For their sake and ours, let us see the towering oak of their future in the acorn of their present.
We should realize the right of every human soul to work out its own destiny, with our aid, our sympathy, our inspiration, if we are thus privileged to help him to live his life; but it is intolerance to try to live it for him. He sits alone on the throne of his individuality; he must reign alone, and at the close of his rule must give his own account to the God of the ages of the deeds of his kingship. Life is a dignified privilege, a glorious prerogative of every man, and it is arrogant intolerance that touches the sacred ark with the hand of unkind condemnation.
We should recognize every person’s right to shape their own destiny. If we are privileged to help someone live their life, we can offer our help, sympathy, and inspiration. But trying to live their life for them is intolerance. Each person sits alone on the throne of their individuality and must rule alone. At the end of that rule, each must give the God of the ages an account of their own reign. Life is a dignified privilege, a glorious right of every person. To touch that sacred ark with unkind judgment is arrogant intolerance.