Part 1, Chapter 16
Applying the Above to Christianity
But, in the midst of those reflections, what are we to think of the christian system of faith that forms itself upon the idea of only one world, and that of no greater extent, as is before shown, than twenty-five thousand miles. An extent which a man, walking at the rate of three miles an hour for twelve hours in the day, could he keep on in a circular direction, would walk entirely round in less than two years. Alas! what is this to the mighty ocean of space, and the almighty power of the Creator!
But amid these reflections, what are we to think of the Christian system of faith? It is based on the idea of only one world. As shown earlier, that world is no more than twenty-five thousand miles around. A person walking three miles an hour for twelve hours a day could walk all the way around it in less than two years, if they could keep walking in a circle. Alas! What is this compared with the mighty ocean of space and the almighty power of the Creator!
From whence then could arise the solitary and strange conceit that the Almighty, who had millions of worlds equally dependent on his protection, should quit the care of all the rest, and come to die in our world, because, they say, one man and one woman had eaten an apple! And, on the other hand, are we to suppose that every world in the boundless creation had an Eve, an apple, a serpent, and a redeemer? In this case, the person who is irreverently called the Son of God, and sometimes God himself, would have nothing else to do than to travel from world to world, in an endless succession of death, with scarcely a momentary interval of life.
Where could this strange and peculiar idea have come from? The Almighty had millions of worlds equally dependent on his protection. Yet he supposedly abandoned all the others and came to die in our world. And why? Because, they say, one man and one woman ate an apple! On the other hand, are we to suppose that every world in the boundless creation had an Eve, an apple, a serpent, and a redeemer? If so, the person irreverently called the Son of God, and sometimes God himself, would have nothing else to do. He would travel from world to world, dying endlessly, with scarcely a moment of life between deaths.
It has been by rejecting the evidence, that the word, or works of God in the creation, affords to our senses, and the action of our reason upon that evidence, that so many wild and whimsical systems of faith, and of religion, have been fabricated and set up. There may be many systems of religion that so far from being morally bad are in many respects morally good: but there can be but ONE that is true; and that one necessarily must, as it ever will, be in all things consistent with the ever existing word of God that we behold in his works. But such is the strange construction of the christian system of faith, that every evidence the heavens affords to man, either directly contradicts it or renders it absurd.
So many wild and fanciful systems of faith and religion have been invented and established by rejecting evidence. This is the evidence that God's word, or works in creation, offers to our senses. They also reject the use of reason to judge that evidence. Many systems of religion may be far from morally bad and, in many respects, morally good. But there can be only ONE true religion. That religion must, and always will, be consistent in every way with God's everlasting word, which we see in his works. But the Christian system of faith is so strangely constructed that every piece of evidence the heavens offer either directly contradicts it or makes it absurd.
It is possible to believe, and I always feel pleasure in encouraging myself to believe it, that there have been men in the world who persuaded themselves that what is called a pious fraud, might, at least under particular circumstances, be productive of some good. But the fraud being once established, could not afterwards be explained; for it is with a pious fraud as with a bad action, it begets a calamitous necessity of going on.
It is possible to believe that some men have convinced themselves that a pious fraud might do some good, at least in certain circumstances. I always take pleasure in encouraging myself to believe this. But once the fraud was established, it could not be explained afterward. A pious fraud is like a bad action: it creates a disastrous need to keep going.
The persons who first preached the christian system of faith, and in some measure combined with it the morality preached by Jesus Christ, might persuade themselves that it was better than the heathen mythology that then prevailed. From the first preachers the fraud went on to the second, and to the third, till the idea of its being a pious fraud became lost in the belief of its being true; and that belief became again encouraged by the interest of those who made a livelihood by preaching it.
The first people to preach the Christian faith also combined it, to some extent, with the morality Jesus Christ preached. They may have persuaded themselves that it was better than the pagan mythology common at the time. The fraud passed from the first preachers to the second, and then to the third. Eventually, people no longer saw it as a pious fraud but believed it was true. That belief was then encouraged by the interests of those who made a living by preaching it.
But though such a belief might, by such means, be rendered almost general among the laity, it is next to impossible to account for the continual persecution carried on by the church, for several hundred years, against the sciences, and against the professors of science, if the church had not some record or tradition that it was originally no other than a pious fraud, or did not foresee that it could not be maintained against the evidence that the structure of the universe afforded.
But even if such methods could make this belief almost universal among ordinary believers, the church’s actions are hard to explain. For several hundred years, the church continually persecuted science and those who taught it. This is almost impossible to explain unless the church had some record or tradition that the belief was originally nothing more than a pious fraud, or foresaw that the belief could not stand against the evidence provided by the structure of the universe.