Part 1, Chapter 8
The New Testament
Thus much for the Bible; I now go on to the book called the New Testament. The new Testament! that is, the ‘new’ Will, as if there could be two wills of the Creator.
That is enough about the Bible. I now turn to the book called the New Testament. The New Testament! That means the ‘new’ Will, as if the Creator could have two wills.
Had it been the object or the intention of Jesus Christ to establish a new religion, he would undoubtedly have written the system himself, or procured it to be written in his life time. But there is no publication extant authenticated with his name. All the books called the New Testament were written after his death. He was a Jew by birth and by profession; and he was the son of God in like manner that every other person is; for the Creator is the Father of All.
If Jesus Christ had intended to establish a new religion, he would undoubtedly have written its principles himself. Or he would have had them written during his lifetime. But no surviving publication bears his name as proof that he wrote or authorized it. All the books called the New Testament were written after his death. He was a Jew by birth and by faith. He was the son of God in the same way that every other person is, for the Creator is the father of all.
The first four books, called Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, do not give a history of the life of Jesus Christ, but only detached anecdotes of him. It appears from these books, that the whole time of his being a preacher was not more than eighteen months; and it was only during this short time that those men became acquainted with him. They make mention of him at the age of twelve years, sitting, they say, among the Jewish doctors, asking and answering them questions. As this was several years before their acquaintance with him began, it is most probable they had this anecdote from his parents. From this time there is no account of him for about sixteen years. Where he lived, or how he employed himself during this interval, is not known. Most probably he was working at his father’s trade, which was that of a carpenter. It does not appear that he had any school education, and the probability is, that he could not write, for his parents were extremely poor, as appears from their not being able to pay for a bed when he was born. [NOTE: One of the few errors traceable to Paine’s not having a Bible at hand while writing Part I. There is no indication that the family was poor, but the reverse may in fact be inferred.—Editor.]
The first four books, called Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, do not tell the history of Jesus Christ’s life. They give only separate stories about him. According to these books, he preached for no more than eighteen months. These men knew him only during that short time. They mention him at the age of twelve, sitting among Jewish religious teachers and asking and answering questions. This was several years before they came to know him. So they most likely heard the story from his parents. There is no account of him for about sixteen years after that. We do not know where he lived or how he spent that time. Most likely, he was working at his father’s trade as a carpenter. There is no indication that he attended school, and he probably could not write. His parents were extremely poor, as shown by their inability to pay for a bed when he was born. [NOTE: This is one of the few errors Paine made because he did not have a Bible at hand while writing Part I. There is no indication that the family was poor. In fact, the opposite may be inferred. Editor.]
It is somewhat curious that the three persons whose names are the most universally recorded were of very obscure parentage. Moses was a foundling; Jesus Christ was born in a stable; and Mahomet was a mule driver. The first and the last of these men were founders of different systems of religion; but Jesus Christ founded no new system. He called men to the practice of moral virtues, and the belief of one God. The great trait in his character is philanthropy.
It is somewhat curious that the three people whose names are recorded most widely came from such obscure backgrounds. Moses was a foundling. Jesus Christ was born in a stable. Mahomet was a mule driver. Moses and Mahomet founded different religious systems, but Jesus Christ founded no new system. He called on people to practice moral virtues and believe in one God. The defining quality of his character was his love of humanity.
The manner in which he was apprehended shows that he was not much known, at that time; and it shows also that the meetings he then held with his followers were in secret; and that he had given over or suspended preaching publicly. Judas could no otherways betray him than by giving information where he was, and pointing him out to the officers that went to arrest him; and the reason for employing and paying Judas to do this could arise only from the causes already mentioned, that of his not being much known, and living concealed.
The way he was arrested shows that he was not well known at the time. It also shows that he met with his followers in secret and had stopped or suspended his public preaching. Judas could betray him only by revealing where he was and pointing him out to the officers sent to arrest him. The only reason to hire and pay Judas for this was that, as already mentioned, he was not well known and was living in hiding.
The idea of his concealment, not only agrees very ill with his reputed divinity, but associates with it something of pusillanimity; and his being betrayed, or in other words, his being apprehended, on the information of one of his followers, shows that he did not intend to be apprehended, and consequently that he did not intend to be crucified.
The idea that he hid is hard to reconcile with his supposed divinity. It also suggests a certain cowardice. He was betrayed, or, in other words, arrested because one of his followers informed on him. This shows that he did not intend to be arrested, and therefore did not intend to be crucified.
The Christian mythologists tell us that Christ died for the sins of the world, and that he came on Purpose to die. Would it not then have been the same if he had died of a fever or of the small pox, of old age, or of anything else?
The Christian mythologists tell us that Christ died for the sins of the world. They say he came for the purpose of dying. If so, wouldn't it have been the same if he had died of a fever, smallpox, old age, or anything else?
The declaratory sentence which, they say, was passed upon Adam, in case he ate of the apple, was not, that thou shalt surely be crucified, but, thou shale surely die. The sentence was death, and not the manner of dying. Crucifixion, therefore, or any other particular manner of dying, made no part of the sentence that Adam was to suffer, and consequently, even upon their own tactic, it could make no part of the sentence that Christ was to suffer in the room of Adam. A fever would have done as well as a cross, if there was any occasion for either.
They say that Adam was told what his sentence would be if he ate the apple. He was not told that he would surely be crucified, but that he would surely die. The sentence was death, not a particular way of dying. Crucifixion, therefore, or any other particular way of dying, was no part of Adam's sentence. So even by their own reasoning, it could not be part of the sentence Christ suffered in Adam's place. A fever would have done as well as a cross, if either was necessary.
This sentence of death, which, they tell us, was thus passed upon Adam, must either have meant dying naturally, that is, ceasing to live, or have meant what these mythologists call damnation; and consequently, the act of dying on the part of Jesus Christ, must, according to their system, apply as a prevention to one or other of these two things happening to Adam and to us.
We are told that Adam was given a death sentence. This must have meant either natural death, the end of life, or what these mythologists call damnation. So, according to their system, the death of Jesus Christ must prevent one of these two things from happening to Adam and to us.
That it does not prevent our dying is evident, because we all die; and if their accounts of longevity be true, men die faster since the crucifixion than before: and with respect to the second explanation, (including with it the natural death of Jesus Christ as a substitute for the eternal death or damnation of all mankind,) it is impertinently representing the Creator as coming off, or revoking the sentence, by a pun or a quibble upon the word death. That manufacturer of, quibbles, St. Paul, if he wrote the books that bear his name, has helped this quibble on by making another quibble upon the word Adam. He makes there to be two Adams; the one who sins in fact, and suffers by proxy; the other who sins by proxy, and suffers in fact. A religion thus interlarded with quibble, subterfuge, and pun, has a tendency to instruct its professors in the practice of these arts. They acquire the habit without being aware of the cause.
It is clear that it does not prevent us from dying, because we all die. And if their accounts of longevity are true, men die sooner since the crucifixion than before it. The second explanation includes the natural death of Jesus Christ as a substitute for the eternal death or damnation of all mankind. This explanation impudently portrays the Creator as backing down or revoking the sentence through a pun or quibble on the word death. St. Paul, that manufacturer of quibbles, helped this quibble along by making another one about the word Adam, if he wrote the books that bear his name. He presents two Adams. One actually sins and suffers through a substitute. The other sins through a substitute and actually suffers. A religion so filled with quibbles, evasions, and puns tends to teach its followers to practice these arts. They acquire the habit without realizing what caused it.
If Jesus Christ was the being which those mythologists tell us he was, and that he came into this world to suffer, which is a word they sometimes use instead of ‘to die,’ the only real suffering he could have endured would have been ‘to live.’ His existence here was a state of exilement or transportation from heaven, and the way back to his original country was to die.—In fine, everything in this strange system is the reverse of what it pretends to be. It is the reverse of truth, and I become so tired of examining into its inconsistencies and absurdities, that I hasten to the conclusion of it, in order to proceed to something better.
If Jesus Christ was the being those mythologists tell us he was, then his only real suffering would have been ‘to live.’ That is true if he came into this world to suffer, a word they sometimes use instead of ‘to die.’ His existence here was a state of exile from heaven, and dying was his way back to his original home. In short, everything in this strange system is the opposite of what it claims to be. It is the opposite of truth. I am so tired of examining its inconsistencies and absurdities that I hurry to conclude my examination and move on to something better.
How much, or what parts of the books called the New Testament, were written by the persons whose names they bear, is what we can know nothing of, neither are we certain in what language they were originally written. The matters they now contain may be classed under two heads: anecdote, and epistolary correspondence.
We cannot know how much of the New Testament was written by the people whose names its books bear. Nor can we be certain what language the books were originally written in. Their contents can be divided into two categories: anecdotes and letters.
The four books already mentioned, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, are altogether anecdotal. They relate events after they had taken place. They tell what Jesus Christ did and said, and what others did and said to him; and in several instances they relate the same event differently. Revelation is necessarily out of the question with respect to those books; not only because of the disagreement of the writers, but because revelation cannot be applied to the relating of facts by the persons who saw them done, nor to the relating or recording of any discourse or conversation by those who heard it. The book called the Acts of the Apostles (an anonymous work) belongs also to the anecdotal part.
The four books already mentioned, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, are entirely accounts of events. They describe events after they happened. They tell what Jesus Christ did and said, and what others did and said to him. In several cases, they give different accounts of the same event. Revelation is necessarily out of the question for these books. This is not only because the writers disagree. Revelation cannot apply to accounts of facts by people who saw them happen. Nor can it apply to accounts or records of speeches or conversations by those who heard them. The book called the Acts of the Apostles (an anonymous work) also belongs among the accounts of events.
All the other parts of the New Testament, except the book of enigmas, called the Revelations, are a collection of letters under the name of epistles; and the forgery of letters has been such a common practice in the world, that the probability is at least equal, whether they are genuine or forged. One thing, however, is much less equivocal, which is, that out of the matters contained in those books, together with the assistance of some old stories, the church has set up a system of religion very contradictory to the character of the person whose name it bears. It has set up a religion of pomp and of revenue in pretended imitation of a person whose life was humility and poverty.
All the other parts of the New Testament are collections of letters called epistles, except for the book of riddles called Revelations. Forging letters has been so common that these letters are at least as likely to be forged as genuine. One thing, however, is much clearer. From the contents of those books and some old stories, the church has created a system of religion. This system contradicts the character of the person whose name it bears. The church has created a religion of pomp and profit, supposedly in imitation of a person who lived in humility and poverty.
The invention of a purgatory, and of the releasing of souls therefrom, by prayers, bought of the church with money; the selling of pardons, dispensations, and indulgences, are revenue laws, without bearing that name or carrying that appearance. But the case nevertheless is, that those things derive their origin from the proxysm of the crucifixion, and the theory deduced therefrom, which was, that one person could stand in the place of another, and could perform meritorious services for him. The probability, therefore, is, that the whole theory or doctrine of what is called the redemption (which is said to have been accomplished by the act of one person in the room of another) was originally fabricated on purpose to bring forward and build all those secondary and pecuniary redemptions upon; and that the passages in the books upon which the idea of theory of redemption is built, have been manufactured and fabricated for that purpose. Why are we to give this church credit, when she tells us that those books are genuine in every part, any more than we give her credit for everything else she has told us; or for the miracles she says she has performed? That she could fabricate writings is certain, because she could write; and the composition of the writings in question, is of that kind that anybody might do it; and that she did fabricate them is not more inconsistent with probability, than that she should tell us, as she has done, that she could and did work miracles.
The invention of purgatory is a way for the church to raise money. So is the idea that souls can be released from it through prayers bought from the church. The same is true of selling pardons, dispensations, and indulgences. These are revenue laws, though they do not bear that name or appear to be laws. Yet these practices originated in the crisis of the crucifixion and the theory drawn from it. That theory was that one person could take another’s place and perform meritorious acts for them. It is therefore probable that the whole theory or doctrine called redemption was invented for this purpose. Redemption is said to have been accomplished by one person acting in another’s place. The doctrine was probably invented to introduce and build upon it all those lesser redemptions involving money. And the passages in the books on which the theory of redemption rests were probably fabricated for that purpose. Why should we believe the church when it tells us that those books are genuine in every part? Why believe that any more than everything else it has told us, or the miracles it claims to have performed? The church certainly could have fabricated writings, because it could write. And the writings in question are of a kind that anybody could compose. It is no less probable that the church fabricated them than that it should make another claim. It has told us that it could and did perform miracles.
Since, then, no external evidence can, at this long distance of time, be produced to prove whether the church fabricated the doctrine called redemption or not, (for such evidence, whether for or against, would be subject to the same suspicion of being fabricated,) the case can only be referred to the internal evidence which the thing carries of itself; and this affords a very strong presumption of its being a fabrication. For the internal evidence is, that the theory or doctrine of redemption has for its basis an idea of pecuniary justice, and not that of moral justice.
So much time has passed that no external evidence can prove whether the church invented the doctrine called redemption. Evidence for or against that claim would be equally open to suspicion of being fabricated. Therefore, the case can only be judged by the evidence within the doctrine itself. This evidence strongly suggests that the doctrine was invented. The doctrine of redemption is based on an idea of financial justice, not moral justice.
If I owe a person money, and cannot pay him, and he threatens to put me in prison, another person can take the debt upon himself, and pay it for me. But if I have committed a crime, every circumstance of the case is changed. Moral justice cannot take the innocent for the guilty even if the innocent would offer itself. To suppose justice to do this, is to destroy the principle of its existence, which is the thing itself. It is then no longer justice. It is indiscriminate revenge.
If I owe someone money and cannot pay, that person may threaten to put me in prison. Someone else can take on the debt and pay it for me. But if I have committed a crime, everything changes. Moral justice cannot punish the innocent for the guilty, even if the innocent person offers to be punished. To suppose that justice could do this is to destroy the very principle on which it exists. It is no longer justice. It is indiscriminate revenge.
This single reflection will show that the doctrine of redemption is founded on a mere pecuniary idea corresponding to that of a debt which another person might pay; and as this pecuniary idea corresponds again with the system of second redemptions, obtained through the means of money given to the church for pardons, the probability is that the same persons fabricated both the one and the other of those theories; and that, in truth, there is no such thing as redemption; that it is fabulous; and that man stands in the same relative condition with his Maker he ever did stand, since man existed; and that it is his greatest consolation to think so.
This single thought shows that the doctrine of redemption is based on a simple financial idea. It is like a debt that someone else could pay. This financial idea also matches the system of second redemptions, gained by giving money to the church for pardons. So the same people probably invented both theories. In truth, there is no such thing as redemption. It is a fable. People stand in the same relation to their Maker as they always have, since humanity first existed. And it is their greatest comfort to think so.
Let him believe this, and he will live more consistently and morally, than by any other system. It is by his being taught to contemplate himself as an out-law, as an out-cast, as a beggar, as a mumper, as one thrown as it were on a dunghill, at an immense distance from his Creator, and who must make his approaches by creeping, and cringing to intermediate beings, that he conceives either a contemptuous disregard for everything under the name of religion, or becomes indifferent, or turns what he calls devout. In the latter case, he consumes his life in grief, or the affectation of it. His prayers are reproaches. His humility is ingratitude. He calls himself a worm, and the fertile earth a dunghill; and all the blessings of life by the thankless name of vanities. He despises the choicest gift of God to man, the GIFT OF REASON; and having endeavoured to force upon himself the belief of a system against which reason revolts, he ungratefully calls it human reason, as if man could give reason to himself.
Let him believe this, and he will live more consistently and morally than under any other system. Instead, he is taught to see himself as an outlaw, an outcast, a beggar, a scrounger. He is taught to see himself as if thrown onto a dung heap, at a vast distance from his Creator. He must approach his Creator by crawling and cringing before beings who stand between them. As a result, he either treats everything called religion with contempt, becomes indifferent, or turns what he calls devout. In the last case, he spends his life in grief, or pretending to grieve. His prayers are accusations. His humility is ingratitude. He calls himself a worm and the fertile earth a dung heap. He ungratefully calls all the blessings of life vanities. He despises God's finest gift to man, the GIFT OF REASON. He tries to force himself to believe in a system against which reason rebels. Then he ungratefully calls it human reason, as if man could give reason to himself.
Yet, with all this strange appearance of humility, and this contempt for human reason, he ventures into the boldest presumptions. He finds fault with everything. His selfishness is never satisfied; his ingratitude is never at an end. He takes on himself to direct the Almighty what to do, even in the govemment of the universe. He prays dictatorially. When it is sunshine, he prays for rain, and when it is rain, he prays for sunshine. He follows the same idea in everything that he prays for; for what is the amount of all his prayers, but an attempt to make the Almighty change his mind, and act otherwise than he does? It is as if he were to say—thou knowest not so well as I.
Yet, despite this strange show of humility and contempt for human reason, he makes the boldest assumptions. He finds fault with everything. His selfishness is never satisfied, and his ingratitude never ends. He takes it upon himself to tell the Almighty what to do, even in governing the universe. He prays as if giving orders. When it is sunny, he prays for rain, and when it rains, he prays for sunshine. He follows the same pattern in everything he prays for. After all, what are his prayers but an attempt to make the Almighty change his mind and act differently? It is as if he were saying, “You do not know as well as I do.”