Part 1, Chapter 5

Detailed Examination of the Previous Foundations

2 min

Putting aside everything that might excite laughter by its absurdity, or detestation by its profaneness, and confining ourselves merely to an examination of the parts, it is impossible to conceive a story more derogatory to the Almighty, more inconsistent with his wisdom, more contradictory to his power, than this story is.

Let us set aside everything so absurd it might make us laugh, or so profane it might make us recoil. Looking only at the parts of the story, it is impossible to imagine one that demeans the Almighty more, is more inconsistent with his wisdom, or more at odds with his power.

In order to make for it a foundation to rise upon, the inventors were under the necessity of giving to the being whom they call Satan a power equally as great, if not greater, than they attribute to the Almighty. They have not only given him the power of liberating himself from the pit, after what they call his fall, but they have made that power increase afterwards to infinity. Before this fall they represent him only as an angel of limited existence, as they represent the rest. After his fall, he becomes, by their account, omnipresent. He exists everywhere, and at the same time. He occupies the whole immensity of space.

To give it a foundation to build on, its inventors had to give Satan enormous power. They gave him power equal to, if not greater than, the power they give the Almighty. They gave Satan the power to free himself from the pit after what they call his fall. But they also made his power grow without limit afterward. Before his fall, they describe him as an angel with a limited existence, like the other angels. After his fall, by their account, he becomes omnipresent. He exists everywhere at the same time. He fills the whole vastness of space.

Not content with this deification of Satan, they represent him as defeating by stratagem, in the shape of an animal of the creation, all the power and wisdom of the Almighty. They represent him as having compelled the Almighty to the direct necessity either of surrendering the whole of the creation to the government and sovereignty of this Satan, or of capitulating for its redemption by coming down upon earth, and exhibiting himself upon a cross in the shape of a man.

Not content with turning Satan into a god, they depict him as taking the form of an animal. In that form, he uses trickery to defeat all the power and wisdom of the Almighty. They say Satan forced the Almighty to choose between two things. He could surrender all creation to Satan’s rule and sovereignty. Or he could make a bargain to redeem it, coming down to earth and appearing on a cross as a man.

Had the inventors of this story told it the contrary way, that is, had they represented the Almighty as compelling Satan to exhibit himself on a cross in the shape of a snake, as a punishment for his new transgression, the story would have been less absurd, less contradictory. But, instead of this they make the transgressor triumph, and the Almighty fall.

If the inventors of this story had told it the other way around, it would have been less absurd and contradictory. They could have depicted the Almighty forcing Satan to appear on a cross in the form of a snake, as punishment for his new sin. But instead, they make the sinner triumph and the Almighty fall.

That many good men have believed this strange fable, and lived very good lives under that belief (for credulity is not a crime) is what I have no doubt of. In the first place, they were educated to believe it, and they would have believed anything else in the same manner. There are also many who have been so enthusiastically enraptured by what they conceived to be the infinite love of God to man, in making a sacrifice of himself, that the vehemence of the idea has forbidden and deterred them from examining into the absurdity and profaneness of the story. The more unnatural anything is, the more is it capable of becoming the object of dismal admiration. [NOTE: The French work has “blind and” preceding dismal.—Editor.]

I have no doubt that many good men have believed this strange fable and lived very good lives under that belief. Being gullible is not a crime. For one thing, they were taught to believe it, and they would have believed anything else in the same way. Many others have been filled with passionate delight at what they saw as God’s infinite love for humanity. They believed he showed this love by sacrificing himself. The intensity of this idea kept them from examining how absurd and irreverent the story is. The more unnatural something is, the more capable it is of inspiring gloomy admiration. [NOTE: The French work has “blind and” before gloomy. Editor.]