Part 1, Chapter 3
Jesus Christ's Character and History
Nothing that is here said can apply, even with the most distant disrespect, to the real character of Jesus Christ. He was a virtuous and an amiable man. The morality that he preached and practiced was of the most benevolent kind; and though similar systems of morality had been preached by Confucius, and by some of the Greek philosophers, many years before, by the Quakers since, and by many good men in all ages, it has not been exceeded by any.
Nothing said here is meant to show even the slightest disrespect for the real character of Jesus Christ. He was a virtuous and likable man. The morality he preached and practiced was deeply compassionate. Confucius and some Greek philosophers had preached similar moral principles many years before him. The Quakers later preached similar principles, as have many good people in every age. Yet none has surpassed his.
Jesus Christ wrote no account of himself, of his birth, parentage, or anything else. Not a line of what is called the New Testament is of his writing. The history of him is altogether the work of other people; and as to the account given of his resurrection and ascension, it was the necessary counterpart to the story of his birth. His historians, having brought him into the world in a supernatural manner, were obliged to take him out again in the same manner, or the first part of the story must have fallen to the ground.
Jesus Christ wrote no account of himself, his birth, his parents, or anything else. He did not write a single line of what is called the New Testament. Everything written about his life is the work of other people. And the account of his resurrection and ascension was the necessary counterpart to the story of his birth. His historians had brought him into the world in a supernatural way. They therefore had to take him out of it in the same way. Otherwise, the first part of the story would have fallen apart.
The wretched contrivance with which this latter part is told, exceeds everything that went before it. The first part, that of the miraculous conception, was not a thing that admitted of publicity; and therefore the tellers of this part of the story had this advantage, that though they might not be credited, they could not be detected. They could not be expected to prove it, because it was not one of those things that admitted of proof, and it was impossible that the person of whom it was told could prove it himself.
The clumsy way this later part of the story is told is worse than anything that came before it. The first part, about the miraculous conception, was not something that could be witnessed publicly. This gave the storytellers an advantage. People might not believe them, but they could not be caught lying. They could not be expected to prove the conception, because it was not the kind of thing that could be proved. And it was impossible for the person the story was about to prove it himself.
But the resurrection of a dead person from the grave, and his ascension through the air, is a thing very different, as to the evidence it admits of, to the invisible conception of a child in the womb. The resurrection and ascension, supposing them to have taken place, admitted of public and ocular demonstration, like that of the ascension of a balloon, or the sun at noon day, to all Jerusalem at least. A thing which everybody is required to believe, requires that the proof and evidence of it should be equal to all, and universal; and as the public visibility of this last related act was the only evidence that could give sanction to the former part, the whole of it falls to the ground, because that evidence never was given. Instead of this, a small number of persons, not more than eight or nine, are introduced as proxies for the whole world, to say they saw it, and all the rest of the world are called upon to believe it. But it appears that Thomas did not believe the resurrection; and, as they say, would not believe without having ocular and manual demonstration himself. So neither will I; and the reason is equally as good for me, and for every other person, as for Thomas.
But the resurrection of a dead person from the grave and his ascension through the air are very different from the invisible conception of a child in the womb. They allow for a different kind of evidence. If the resurrection and ascension took place, they could have been shown publicly and seen by all of Jerusalem at least. They could have been seen like a balloon rising or the sun at noon. When everyone is required to believe something, the proof and evidence must be equal for all and available to everyone. The public visibility of the ascension was the only evidence that could give support to the earlier claim. But that evidence was never given, so the whole story falls apart. Instead, a small number of people, no more than eight or nine, are presented as stand-ins for the whole world. They say they saw it, and everyone else in the world is called upon to believe it. But it appears that Thomas did not believe in the resurrection. As they say, he would not believe without seeing and touching for himself. Neither will I. And my reason is just as good as Thomas’s, as is the reason of every other person.
It is in vain to attempt to palliate or disguise this matter. The story, so far as relates to the supernatural part, has every mark of fraud and imposition stamped upon the face of it. Who were the authors of it is as impossible for us now to know, as it is for us to be assured that the books in which the account is related were written by the persons whose names they bear. The best surviving evidence we now have respecting this affair is the Jews. They are regularly descended from the people who lived in the time this resurrection and ascension is said to have happened, and they say ‘it is not true.’ It has long appeared to me a strange inconsistency to cite the Jews as a proof of the truth of the story. It is just the same as if a man were to say, I will prove the truth of what I have told you, by producing the people who say it is false.
There is no use trying to excuse or disguise this matter. The supernatural part of the story bears every mark of fraud and deception. We cannot now know who invented it. Nor can we be sure that the books telling the story were written by the people whose names they bear. The best surviving evidence we have about this affair is the Jews. They are direct descendants of the people who lived when this resurrection and ascension supposedly happened. And they say ‘it is not true.’ It has long seemed strangely inconsistent to me to cite the Jews as proof that the story is true. It is just as if a man were to say, I will prove that what I told you is true by bringing forward the people who say it is false.
That such a person as Jesus Christ existed, and that he was crucified, which was the mode of execution at that day, are historical relations strictly within the limits of probability. He preached most excellent morality, and the equality of man; but he preached also against the corruptions and avarice of the Jewish priests, and this brought upon him the hatred and vengeance of the whole order of priest-hood. The accusation which those priests brought against him was that of sedition and conspiracy against the Roman government, to which the Jews were then subject and tributary; and it is not improbable that the Roman government might have some secret apprehension of the effects of his doctrine as well as the Jewish priests; neither is it improbable that Jesus Christ had in contemplation the delivery of the Jewish nation from the bondage of the Romans. Between the two, however, this virtuous reformer and revolutionist lost his life. [NOTE: The French work has here: “However this may be, for one or the other of these suppositions this virtuous reformer, this revolutionist, too little imitated, too much forgotten, too much misunderstood, lost his life.”—Editor. (Conway)]
It is entirely plausible that a person named Jesus Christ existed and was crucified. Crucifixion was a method of execution at the time. He preached excellent morality and the equality of people. But he also preached against the corruption and greed of the Jewish priests. This brought upon him the hatred and vengeance of the entire priesthood. Those priests accused him of sedition and conspiracy against the Roman government. The Jews were then subject to Rome and paid tribute to it. It is also possible that the Roman government, like the Jewish priests, secretly feared the effects of his teachings. It is likewise possible that Jesus Christ intended to free the Jewish nation from Roman rule. Between the two, however, this virtuous reformer and revolutionary lost his life. [NOTE: The French work reads here: “Whatever the case, this virtuous reformer, this revolutionary, was too little imitated, too much forgotten, and too much misunderstood. He lost his life because of one or the other of these possibilities.” Editor. (Conway)]